Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode of Criminology examines the 1987 murder of thirty-year-old Rhonda Marie Fisher in Douglas County, Colorado, and how modern DNA testing ultimately linked her death to serial killer Vincent Groves. Hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Morford are joined by crime analysis supervisor Michelle Kennedy and forensic serologist Shane Williams to detail how painstaking early evidence collection—specifically placing paper bags over the victim's hands secured with electrical tape—preserved crucial touch DNA for nearly four decades. Although an initial suspect named Joe walked into police stations in 1987 and remained the primary focus for years, modern forensic reviews and CODIS database matches definitively cleared him and connected Rhonda's case to three previous murders committed by Groves. Unfortunately, because Groves died in prison in 1996 before his profile entered CODIS, he escaped legal accountability, leaving investigators with a bittersweet resolution.
- Preserving unconventional physical evidence, such as paper bags used to cover a victim's hands, can allow future scientists to recover touch DNA decades later. 25:22
- Multidisciplinary cold case reviews that bring together detectives, analysts, and lab experts can identify overlooked evidence and guide successful testing strategies. 21:14
- DNA profiles developed from casework can match unsolved homicides in national databases even when a suspect died before their own DNA was cataloged. 49:06
Chapters
- 0:37Podcast Introduction and Host Banter
Mike Ferguson and Mike Morford welcome listeners, discuss personal updates, and thank Patreon supporters before launching into the episode’s case.
- 2:04Case Overview: Rhonda Fisher’s Murder
The hosts introduce Rhonda Marie Fisher, outline the investigation’s focus on her murder, and explain the significance of linking it to serial killer Vincent Groves.
- 2:50Victim Profile and Early Investigation
Details about Rhonda’s life, last known movements, and the initial police work that identified her as a high‑risk victim are presented.
- 13:26Primary Suspect: Joe’s Involvement
Joe, a self‑presented suspect, is examined through police interviews, polygraph results, and his relationship with Rhonda, leading to his initial status as suspect number one.
- 16:14Serial Killer Vincent Groves Comes Under Scrutiny
Investigators shift focus to Vincent Groves, noting his release from prison, prior convictions, and potential link to Rhonda’s murder.
- 26:14DNA Breakthrough from Brown Paper Bags
Cold‑case evidence review reveals that preserved paper bags over Rhonda’s hands yielded DNA, allowing a match to Vincent Groves after decades.
- 33:36CODIS Match and Final Identification
The DNA profile from the paper bags is entered into CODIS, producing a match to Groves and confirming him as Rhonda’s killer.
- 54:24Case Closure and Broader Implications
The episode concludes with reflections on the impact of the solved case, the limitations of post‑humous justice, and the importance of preserving evidence for future breakthroughs.
Highlights
- 3:40
Discovering Rhonda Fisher's Bodystory
In April 1987, a motorist driving along Highway 105 in Douglas County spotted the nude body of Rhonda Fisher down an embankment. Investigators noted ligature marks, signs of sexual assault, and estimated her time of death between 3:00 and 5:00 a.m.
- 13:05
A Suspect Inserts Himselfstory
A man named Joe walked into the police station the day after Rhonda's body was found, claiming he was the last person to see her alive. Despite showing controlling behavior and failing a polygraph, he was eventually cleared decades later by DNA.
- 24:54
Re-Evaluating Evidence Decades Laterstrategy
A 2025 multidisciplinary review team re-examined the brown paper bags placed over Rhonda's hands in 1987. Recognizing that these bags had been secured around her wrists with electrical tape, they identified them as prime sources for preserved touch DNA.
- 26:54
Developing a Three-Person DNA Mixturedata
Swabs from the paper bag secured around Rhonda's right wrist yielded a three-person DNA mixture. Advanced software successfully separated a major male profile, allowing experts to definitively exclude Joe and his brother.
- 37:17
CODIS Matches Link Serial Killerdata
The unknown male profile extracted from the paper bag produced CODIS matches to the 1979 homicides of Emma Jennifer, Joyce Ramey, and Peggy Cluff. These crimes had previously been linked to serial killer Vincent Groves.
- 41:26
How Transfer DNA Survivedinsight
Experts explain that cinching the paper bags tightly with electrical tape prolonged contact, preserving skin cells transferred when Vincent Groves manipulated Rhonda's wrists. The arid climate of Denver also helped prevent total DNA degradation.
- 46:31
A Bittersweet Deathbed Silencestory
Although DNA finally proved Vincent Groves murdered Rhonda Fisher and up to 12 other victims, police could never hold him accountable. Groves died of failing health in late 1996 after refusing to confess to additional suspected murders.
Quotes
“The evidence handling was crucial in allowing, you know, investigators many, many years later to, to, you know, capitalize on the presence of DNA.”
Unnamed speaker · 7:41 “The foreign male DNA profile from Rhonda's case was then entered into the Combined DNA Index System, or CODIS, in October 2025.”
Unnamed speaker · 33:36 “The only evidence we have linking Rhonda to the other cases is the one brown paper bag.”
Unnamed speaker · 35:43 “The only thing we had left was this brown paper bag that had been making contact with her body.”
Unnamed speaker · 36:16 “The good news was that police figured out who had killed Rhonda.”
Unnamed speaker · 46:16
Sponsored segments
- Patreon 1:40–2:00
- Hers 19:20–20:29
- Criminology Podcast 54:00–54:28
Transcript
8,083 words · 5 speakers
Topics
- CODIS
- Denver
- Douglas County Sheriff's Office
- Unified Forensic Laboratory
- Castle Rock
- Colorado Bureau of Investigation
- Longmont
- South Perry Park Road
- Monaco Boulevard
- Mexico Avenue
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated