Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode examines the cold case investigation of Homer Lee Jackson III, whom Portland police linked through fingerprints and DNA to the murders of four young women in the 1980s: Angela Anderson, Latangi Watts, Tanya Harry, and Essie Jackson. Host Ashley Flowers details how cold case detectives used a 2008 fingerprint match and later DNA testing to build a case against Jackson, culminating in a ten-hour interrogation where he offered ambiguous statements. Although Jackson was indicted on 12 counts of aggravated murder, the defense successfully suppressed his statements and won separate trials for each case, exposing severe investigative missteps, overlooked alternate suspects, and unidentified DNA profiles at multiple crime scenes. Ultimately, rather than risking trial, Jackson took an Alford plea to four counts of criminally negligent homicide, serving a brief sentence before dying at age 63, leaving many questions about whether all the murders were solved.
- Cold case investigators should regularly rerun old fingerprints through modern databases since technological advances can yield matches decades later. 2:27
- A conviction built primarily on a pattern across multiple cases can unravel if a judge orders those trials separated. 41:42
- A legal case is only as strong as the original police work, and poor initial investigations leave lingering doubts even after charges are filed. 55:58
Chapters
- 0:00Episode Intro and Sponsor
Hosts welcome listeners, ask for subscriptions, and introduce the episode’s sponsor, BetterHelp.
- 1:44Host Solo and Episode Hook
Ashley Flowers explains she’s solo, thanks listeners, and sets up the story’s starting point in 2008 Portland.
- 2:14First Murder and Fingerprint Lead
Detectives trace a 2008 fingerprint to a 1983 murder of 14‑year‑old Angela Anderson, sparking a cold‑case investigation.
- 3:56Homer Lee Jackson’s Early History
The episode details Jackson’s prior arrests, assault charges, and the lack of automated databases that delayed linking him to the crime.
- 6:10DNA Connections to Multiple Victims
Forensic evidence links Jackson to three murders—Angela, Latangi, and Tanya—through DNA found on cigarette butts, fingernails, and a belt.
- 11:01Interrogation and Confessions
Jackson is questioned in 2014, admits to killing Angela, but offers vague, conflicting statements about other victims.
- 16:31Broader Context and Systemic Issues
The host discusses how systemic neglect of black women’s murders and fragmented evidence complicate the case against Jackson.
- 18:00Gaps in 1987 Investigation
The episode highlights missing interviews, unexamined alibis, and the lack of pursuit of potential suspects like Steven Rossi.
- 33:27Legal Battle Over Statements
Jackson’s defense argues his admissions were coerced, leading the court to exclude them and drop charges related to Essie Jackson.
- 42:55Case‑by‑Case Analysis Plan
The host explains her intent to examine each murder separately, starting with Latangi’s 1987 case.
- 56:41Episode Introduction
Hosts set the stage for the investigation into Homer Jackson’s crimes.
- 57:37Plea Deal and Sentencing
Prosecutors drop murder charges; Jackson pleads to negligent homicide and serves time.
Highlights
- 2:27
Cold Case Fingerprint Matchstory
A single fingerprint left in an attic crawl space in 1983 matched Homer Jackson 24 years later, sparking a cold case investigation into multiple murders in Portland.
- 14:38
Grand Jury Indictment on Twelve Countsdata
Following two days of questioning, a grand jury indicted Jackson on 12 counts of aggravated murder across four separate cases from the 1980s.
- 22:49
Unidentified DNA at Crime Scenesinsight
Forensic testing across the crime scenes revealed multiple unidentified male DNA profiles and palm prints belonging to individuals other than Jackson.
- 33:18
Confessions Thrown Out by Courtstrategy
The trial judge and later the Oregon Supreme Court suppressed Jackson's interrogation statements, ruling that police made improper promises and threats.
- 41:42
Judge Orders Separate Trialsstrategy
A judge ruled that the murders could not be tried together and barred the state from introducing evidence from one case to reinforce another.
- 57:37
Facing complex trials, prosecutors accepted an Alford plea to four lesser counts of criminally negligent homicide, resulting in a sentence Jackson had already served.
Quotes
“Homer Lee Jackson III would have been 23 in September of 1983, when 14-year-old Angela Anderson was found face down on the floor of that vacant house in Portland.”
Ashley Flowers · 3:56 “The DNA they had in her case wasn't near her or around her, it was on her, recovered from under her left-hand fingernails.”
Ashley Flowers · 7:21 “I know that you've seen them before and you're trying to find either the way to say you got nothing to do with it, or they're trying to find a way to explain it.”
Unnamed speaker · 11:54 “The state has to move forward without the statements that the court threw out.”
Ashley Flowers · 33:55 “There are three murders almost back to back in 1983, March, July, September.”
Ashley Flowers · 15:50 “And they became even more sure of it in 2021.”
Ashley Flowers · 56:54 “In January 2022, the murder charges are dropped, and Homer takes an Alfred plea to four lesser counts of criminally negligent homicide.”
Ashley Flowers · 57:37 “Four women dead. And when the gavel strikes, Homer gets to go home.”
Ashley Flowers · 58:14 “I think Homer Jackson was a dangerous man.”
Ashley Flowers · 1:03:33 “I promise you, there are more cases like these in Portland and in every major city, cases that never got a fair shot the first time around.”
Ashley Flowers · 1:04:12
Sponsored segments
- BetterHelp 0:00–0:41
- OnDeck 0:42–1:15
- Royal Farms 1:20–1:41
- BetterHelp 16:31–17:51
- SimpliSafe 34:32–35:34
- Southern New Hampshire University 49:31–50:16
- Azure Standard 1:05:22–1:06:04
- Full Body Chills 1:05:51–1:06:15
About this episode
In 2008, a single fingerprint from a vacant Portland house linked Homer Lee Jackson III to the 1983 murder of 14-year-old Angela Anderson. Detectives went on to tie him to the deaths of Tonja Harry, Latanga Watts and Lawauna Triplet, and they suspected him in Essie Jackson’s too. But the evidence against him was far less clean than the headlines suggested, and some have wondered whether police actually solved these murders, or just closed them.
Transcript
10,568 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- DNA
- Portland
- Peacock
- The Good Daughter
- fingerprint
- Union Avenue
- North Portland
- Peacock Original Limited Series
- DNA testing
- Portland, Oregon
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated