Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Christopher Cole Thomas, a 22-year-old from Florida, vanished in Benson, North Carolina in November 2016 after traveling with two coworkers from a Minnesota construction job to buy meth in Mount Olive. Julian Vias Jr. and Jeremy Carpenter told police Cole panicked, grabbed the keys, and ran off into the night. But surveillance footage from a Walgreens camera, spotted by then-captain Greg Percy after weeks of reviewing tape, showed Cole walking with Jeremy, not alone. Phone data placed Cole's device in Wayne County—where the drug dealers were—not in Benson where the car was left.
Private investigator David Marshburn, hired by Cole's parents, mapped the phone data and developed a theory that Julian had been double-crossing everyone: the plan may have been to sell the meth and then steal it back, with Cole as the fall guy when drugs went missing. A man called Gordo eventually told police he was instructed to find Cole, and that he and others hit Cole with a baseball bat before taking him to an undisclosed location in Wayne County. When Cole's father Chris bonded Anthony James Jr. (TJ) out of prison to separate him from the others, TJ finally said, "He's gone."
All concealment and obstruction charges against the four men were eventually dropped to preserve potential future homicide prosecutions. As of the episode's recording, no body has been found, no one has been charged with murder, and Cole's parents remain in North Carolina searching.
- Walgreens surveillance footage proved Cole did not walk off alone—Jeremy Carpenter was walking with him, contradicting the initial story given to police. 17:13
- Cole's phone reactivated hours later in Wayne County, the same area where the drug dealers were based, suggesting his disappearance did not end in Benson. 28:42
- PI David Marshburn theorized Julian was double-crossing the group, planning to sell the meth and then steal it back, making Cole the convenient fall guy for missing drugs. 32:55
- Cole's father Chris bonded TJ out of prison to isolate him from the other suspects, a strategy that eventually led TJ to say 'He's gone.' 43:14
- All concealment and obstruction charges were dropped to preserve the possibility of future homicide prosecutions, leaving the case officially unsolved. 46:38
Highlights
- 8:51
Steven's Devastating Phone Callstory
Cole's father Chris calls Steven, the crew foreman, who immediately says 'I think they killed him,' revealing the trip was a drug deal and something went wrong.
- 17:13
Percy Spots the Walgreens Footagedata
After weeks of reviewing surveillance at his kitchen table, Captain Greg Percy catches 30 seconds of footage showing Cole and Jeremy walking together at 1:10 a.m., proving the initial story was false.
- 25:02
They Had Cole's Phone All Alonginsight
When Julian and Jeremy finally return for in-person questioning, they hand over Cole's phone, which they had been holding onto the entire time without telling police.
- 28:42
Phone Reactivates in Wayne Countydata
Cole's phone comes back on hours later, but not in Benson where he supposedly ran off—it is still in Wayne County, the same area where the drug dealers were based.
- 32:55
The Double-Cross Theoryinsight
PI David Marshburn theorizes Julian was working with the dealers all along, planning to sell the meth and then steal it back, with Cole as the easiest person to blame when drugs went missing.
- 41:31
Gordo's story shifts from Cole getting in the car willingly, to being threatened with a gun, to being hit with a baseball bat before being taken to an undisclosed location in Wayne County.
- 45:21
TJ Finally Breaksstory
After being bonded out and separated from the others, TJ sits down with Cole's mother Kathy and, after a long conversation, says 'He's gone, y'all,' confirming Cole is dead but refusing to say more.
About this episode
On Black Friday 2016, 22-year-old Christopher “Cole” Thomas was driving through rural North Carolina with two coworkers. Hours later, the coworkers approached police and said Cole had suddenly panicked, pulled over, and ran into the dark, never to be seen again.
Transcript
8,500 words · 6 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Missing Person
- Drug Deal
- Surveillance Evidence
- Phone Data
- Cold Case
- Obstruction of Justice
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated