Pod Insights Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder Ep. 20 | Murders Solved By Psychics… About this episode In this episode, we're deep-diving into the paranormal! We're talking about psychics that have quite literally helped in solving real-life murder cases.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Network freedom and flexibility. That's what you want in a healthcare plan. With a Humana Medicare Advantage PPO plan, you can see any doctor in the country who accepts Medicare, including specialists. No referrals, no kidding. Learn more at gethumana.com. See any doctor who accepts Medicare and is willing to bill Humana. Humana PPOs may not be available in all areas. Benefits and costs share may vary. Humana is a Medicare Advantage PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
0:30 Speaker 01 Crime, conspiracy, serial killers, cults, and murder. All things that I love to consume, and I know you do too, you sick, beautiful, intellectually-minded freak. And today, we are going to talk about... What are we talking about? We are talking about psychics and murder. And how they both come together and make... Why do I sound like... I literally sound like the pastor from The Princess Bride. Marriage, marriage brings us together today. Sorry, I'm getting sidetracked. Marriage. Today, we're gonna be talking about psychics
1:14 Speaker 01 and how they have solved multiple murders, or helped in solving multiple murders. Or is it just a hoax? Maybe, probably, probably not, I don't know. But I do have a very special guest that is going to be in the last part of this video that is gonna give their testimony of how they quite literally helped find a dead body due to psychic happenstance. And I think you guys are gonna enjoy it a lot, so stay tuned for that. But without further ado, let's unbuckle our seatbelts, go Mach 5 down the highway, slam on the brakes, and bust through this windshield into these creepy psychic cases together.
2:06 Speaker 01 So the first case we are going to talk about is the murder of Suzanne Jacobson.
2:14 Speaker 01 Suzanne Jacobson was born February 5th, 1962, in Staten Island, New York. She was the second oldest of seven children in the Jacobson family. And her parents, Bill and Ellen Jacobson, resided at 30 Anderson Avenue in Port Richmond neighborhood of Staten Island. And the Jacobs household was bustling with activity due to the enormous amount of children, and Susan often helped babysit her younger siblings. And at 14-years-old, Susan was described as a responsible and caring individual. She was known for her very warm personality and was very well-liked by all of her peers. And academically, she did very well in school, showing promise for a very bright future. And Susan was also very much looking forward to gaining independence through part-time work, which led her to seek employment at a local ice cream parlor.
2:59 Speaker 01 So in the summer of 1975, Susan would begin dating a 16-year-old named Dempsey Hawkins, who lived nearby. And the relationship was just typical teenage romance, but became very complicated over time, because in January 1976, Susan would become pregnant, and subsequently, she would have an abortion. And following this event, her parents encouraged her to take a break from the relationship to focus on her well-being and education. But despite this advice, Susan and Dempsey continued to see each other secretly. And on May 15th, 1976, Susan would leave her home at around 1:00 PM to interview for a job at Ralph's Ices, an ice cream parlor located at the intersection of Catherine Street and Port Richmond Avenue.
3:41 Speaker 01 And she would be dressed in blue denim pants, blue sneakers with yellow shoelaces, and a white tube or halter top, and a long-sleeved beige blouse. And notably, she also wore blue tinted wireframe glasses and had long, light brown hair parted right down the middle. And when Susan didn't return home for dinner, her parents started to grow very, very concerned, because this was not how she was. She was a rule follower. She was never late for dinner. And they would end up calling police to report her missing, feeling that something was... Very amiss, but the initial response from the police was very dismissive. Authorities suggested that Susan had likely just run away, possibly even with her boyfriend, and told the Jacobsons that they lacked the resources to search for runaways.
4:22 Speaker 01 And this reaction was extremely frustrating for the family, who were convinced that Susan would not have just left voluntarily without money or any of her personal belongings. So, undeterred by the lack of official assistance, the Jacobson family mobilized dozens of friends and families for the search for Susan. They distributed flyers, canvassed the neighborhood, and reached out to anyone that might have information. And their efforts, however, yielded no significant leads. But in comes Dorothy Allison, our first psychic. She was a self-proclaimed psychic from New Jersey, known for her involvement in several criminal cases. She claimed to possess clairvoyant abilities that allowed her to provide insights into unsolved crimes. While some law enforcement officials were skeptical of her abilities, others acknowledged
5:05 Speaker 01 that she had occasionally provided very useful information. And desperate for any assistance, Bill and Ellen Jacobson contacted Dorothy Allison two weeks after Susan's disappearance. And remarkably, upon answering the phone immediately, Dorothy reported saying, "I know who you are, and I know why you're calling me. Just give me your address, and I'll be there in 45 minutes." How didn't you know the address? And how'd you know it'd be 45 minutes away? I'm just being an asshole. I'm sorry. But creepy! Anyway, when Dorothy arrived, she provided several specific clues for them immediately. She mentioned the numbers 2562, and 408, and 405. And 2562 corresponded to Susan's birthdate, February 5th, 1962.
5:47 Speaker 01 Which, you know, I'm sure on the news you would see, like, how old the person is, and probably the birthdate would be available, so that one's like, merit. 405 was the time of Susan's birth. Who the f would know that? Nobody. So that's interesting. And she inquired about the letters M-A-R, written in large, red letters specifically. And she described an abandoned car, an overpowering smell of oil, dual church steeples, dual smokestacks, two bridges close together, one not for cars, swamps, and...
6:20 Speaker 01 So very specific scene and she stated that Susan had been strangled by her boyfriend and was located in a place matching these descriptions. But despite Dorothy's very detailed insights, the police were unwilling to collaborate with a psychic. So they dismissed her information, leaving the Jacobsons to pursue these clues independently. So Bill Jacobson, along with his friends, began to search the areas that matched Dorothy's descriptions, particularly focusing on the port ivory section of Staten Island, known as the Downback. And during their search, Bill Jacobson found a rock with M-A-R on it, painted in red letters. Freaky deaky man. At the abandoned Downeys Shipyard, also known as Mariners Marsh.
7:03 Speaker 01 Recognizing the significance of this find, he brought Dorothy to the location and she confirmed, "This is it. This is where your daughter is." And despite their conviction, without official support, their search efforts were limited. And on March 25th, 1978, nearly two years after Susan's disappearance, three boys hunting muskrats discovered her skeletal remains inside a 55 gallon oil drum in a 12 foot shaft leading to an underground bunker at Downeys Shipyard. And the location was approximately 100 yards from the rock with M-A-R written on it. Whoa, I got chills. And an autopsy would confirm that Susan had been strangled.
7:45 Speaker 01 The condition of her remains and the surrounding environments aligned with Dorothy's description, including the smell of oil and the proximity to the landmarks that she had mentioned, which is wild. Following the discoveries, attention turned to Susan's boyfriend, Dempsey Hawkins. Investigators learned that he had confided in a friend and a cousin, admitting that he had strangled Susan. Additionally, after her disappearance, Hawkins had misled the family by suggesting that Susan had left for Florida or Chicago. And he also had participated in the searches, potentially to deflect suspicion. Hawkins, at this point, had relocated to Joe P, Illinois, to live with his father shortly after Susan's disappearance, further raising suspicions. So on May 6th, 1978, Hawkins was arrested and charged for second degree murder.
8:29 Speaker 01 Susan and prosecutors had argued that he killed Susan because he could not accept the end of their relationship and on February 1979 Hawkins was convicted and sentenced to 22 years to life in prison and during the trial Dorothy Allison's identification of Hawkins as the perpetrator was noted but did not serve as primary evidence obviously it was just really freaky dude like what are the odds and Dorothy Allison's involvement in the case remains a subject of debate while the information she provided was remarkably accurate skepticism persists regarding the validity of psychic abilities critics argue that clues could have been derived from publicly available information and general knowledge of the area but either way I think I mean you know you have knowledge of the area but
9:13 Speaker 01 it was he was pretty darn specific she even knew the way she was murdered which is like I don't know I I truly do believe people have have these abilities and everything and I think it's extraordinary that they could actually help people in these certain cases so I think I think follow follow all leads you know but horrible absolutely horrendous what happened to Susan and I hope Dempsey is rotten in jail but that brings us to our next murder and psychic Melanie Erhabe and Eda Smith so Melanie Mayron Erhabe which I hope I'm saying that last name right was a 31 year old licensed vocational nurse living in Arleta California divorced a single mother of an
9:57 Speaker 01 eight year old son she was known for her dedication to her profession and her reliability employed at Pacoima Hospital in Burbank California Melanie was recognized for her compassionate care and commitment to her patients and her routine life revolved around work and raising her son and she was considered a very valued member of her community and Eda Smith was aged 32 at the time and working as a shipping clerk at Lockheed Aerospace Plant in Burbank California holding a top security clearance due to her position she was regarded as a very responsible and credible individual Smith was a mother also and had no prior history of psychic experiences or involvement with law enforcement investigations prior to the events involving Erhabe she lived ...very conventional life, balancing her professional responsibilities with her
10:42 Speaker 01 family duties. So on the evening of December 15th, 1980, Melanie was scheduled to work a night shift at the Pacoima Hospital. She left her home driving her pickup truck, but never arrived at her workplace. Concerned colleagues contacted her home, but received no response. And given her reputation for punctuality and responsibility, her unexplainable absence raised immediate concerns with her peers. And witnesses would later report seeing two men force their way into her truck while she stopped at a traffic light. And the following morning, the police would find her abandoned and burned-out pickup truck along with her nurse's uniform, intensifying fears that she had met with foul play. So on December 17th, 1980, while working at Lockheed, Etta Smith heard a news report
11:26 Speaker 01 on the radio about the disappearance of a local nurse named Melanie Arrab. And upon hearing this, Smith experienced what she described as a sudden and vivid vision or mental image. She later recounted this. It was as if I saw a picture. I saw a canyon area, I saw a road, I saw it curving, I saw a dirt path, I saw shrubbery, and I saw white through the shrubbery. I could not clearly see what the white was, but it was something distinctively white. And Smith would feel a very strong compulsion to act on this vision, believing that the white object she perceived might be Melanie's nurse's uniform. And believing that her vision might be crucial to finding Melanie, Smith decided to contact the Los Angeles Police Department, otherwise known as the LAPD.
12:10 Speaker 01 And she would meet with Detective Lee Ryan and conveyed the details of her vision. And despite initial skepticism, Ryan noted Smith's sincerity and the specific details that she provided. She identified the location from her vision as Lopez Canyon. But concerned the police might not act swiftly on her information, Smith felt the urgent need to search the area herself. And she enlisted the help of her daughter, Tina, and a family friend. And together, they would drive to Lopez Canyon to look for any signs of Melanie. And upon arriving, Smith reported experiencing intense feelings of dread and a sense of Melanie's presence. She described feeling in energy or trauma that compelled her to continue searching and while exploring the area smith and her companions
12:53 Speaker 01 noticed a fresh set of tire tracks leading off the main road and following these tracks they discovered a partially concealed body in the brush and smith recognized the white nurse's shoes confirming her fears that they had found melanie and she would immediately contact police and report her discovery chills like what I don't know man like this like especially not even knowing her like not being connected I don't anyway an autopsy later confirmed the body was indeed melanie and she had been robbed unfortunately sa'd and beaten to death as well and initially law enforcement officials were perplexed by smith's accurate knowledge of where the body's location was detectives even began questioning how she could have known about
13:37 Speaker 01 the specific details without being involved in the crime itself which is like a natural a natural thing to come to and their skepticism was also fueled by the absence of physical evidence linking her to the crime scene yet her information was undeniably precise so on the evening of december 17th smith was summoned to the police station for further questioning and over several hours detectives repeatedly asked her to recount her story looking for inconsistencies and despite her cooperation they remained very doubtful of her account and smith voluntarily underwent two polygraph tests believing that they would confirm her innocence however detectives falsely informed her that she had failed both tests which I don't think is allowed but what do I know and based on their suspicions
14:20 Speaker 01 they arrested her as an accessory to murder and smith would be detained in jail for several days during which she maintained her innocence and insisted that her only involvement was through her psychic vision and while smith was in custody the investigation took a very significant turn a police informant would come forward with an information about individuals bragging about involvement in melanie's murder and the lead directed detectives to three young men from the local area so on december 21st police arrested louis carnegie morgan who was 20 years old and normus willis who was 17 years old and spencer nelson who was 21 years old and under interrogation the men did confess to the abduction And murder of Melanie Erre. And they admitted to forcing their way into her truck,
15:04 Speaker 01 robbing her and her and ultimately killing her by beating her with a large rock in Lopez Canyon. And with the true perpetrators in custody, all charges against Etta Smith were dropped and she was released from jail. But Etta Smith's case raises important ethical and legal questions. Her wrongful arrest highlights the potential risks faced by individuals who come forward with unconventional information. Law enforcement must balance skepticism with openness and all possible leads, ensuring that innocent people are not unjustly accused and lied to, by the way. Additionally, the case underscores the need for proper investigative protocols and dealing with information obtained through non-traditional means.
15:44 Speaker 01 And following her release, Etta Smith pursued legal action against the LAPD for wrongful arrest, as she should. And she filed the lawsuit alleging false imprisonment and violation of her civil rights. Yeah. And reports indicate that she did win the settlement, although the details remain private. And her experience brought her some unexpected attention, naturally. And she continued to explore her psychic abilities and reportedly assisted on other missing persons cases. Her story has even been featured in television programs and interviews, contributing to the ongoing discussions about psychic phenomenon and their place in society. So badass, man, badass. I love how she went out and just like looked for it too and everything. Like she just took initiative, unlike the LAPD. They got a bad rap, they got a bad, I'm sure there's a lot of good ones, but I don't know.
16:28 Speaker 01 It's fucked up, but that's crazy. I don't know, just like having that like 30 years old, just having like this that's a Raven vision of somebody's body and stuff is just wild. But I'm excited to talk about our next psychic. And that is my best friend, Selena Spookybo. So let's go over to that interview.
17:09 Speaker 00 Humana is a Medicare Advantage HMO and PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal. At Humana, our Medicare Advantage plans are easy to understand and easy on your wallet. Like offering more benefits than you'd get from original Medicare alone. And including dental, vision, and hearing coverage in every plan. And the best part is, every plan has a $0 or low monthly plan premium, which makes it easier to save, too. So this Medicare planning season, plan well with Humana. Learn more at gethumana.com. Humana is a Medicare Advantage HMO and PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
17:46 Speaker 01 We're here with Selena Spooky Boo. My best friend and psychic. And also, I am in Caleb's grandmother's bedroom right now. That's why I look like, that's why it looks like this. And why there's a lion behind me. Can you see her?
18:02 Speaker 02 Roar!
18:03 Speaker 01 So basically, the video, uh, the video I've been doing is talking about psychics that have solved crimes. And the first person I thought of was you, because you've told me in the past that this has actually happened to you. Is it multiple times or just one, one time?
18:18 Speaker 02 Oh, no, it's, it happens so mostly like happens to me dream wise. Like, I've probably had four or five different cases. But there's also been moments where I see things or people will come to me with like messages, but like it never connects with anything that I can find. But the, the, the most intense one was the one that happened, like the recent one that you knew about.
18:37 Speaker 01 Walk them through it. What happened, man?
18:39 Speaker 02 So I'm, obviously, I'm gonna keep some names out of it because it is local and it is something that happened. But there was a person who had gone missing. Obviously, that's what we're here for. Um, I went to bed that night and I was just really thinking kind of about this person. And I was laying in bed and it always happens right as I'm like kind of falling asleep, which is just like, you know, whenever we do things. I saw this person, I saw them sitting in their backyard. I saw them, um, getting up, I saw them going to a liquor store. And I saw them going to a track and I saw them going a certain area down and, and going into the woods and walking about 40 feet into the woods. And the interesting thing was, a couple of days later, I was convinced.
19:19 Speaker 02 That I needed to to go look and Adam was like you're not going out by yourself and I'm not coming with you.
19:28 Speaker 02 I feel like I should go.
19:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, you were a snapshot of me.
19:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, Adam's best friend was going the next day to um a search party that was gonna happen in the morning and I got up. And I was starting to get ready and I was like, I feel like I shouldn't go, but I need to tell somebody. So I actually went and I pulled up a map. Of the area and I circled exactly where I thought he was um and I sent it to Adam's friend and. I literally feel crazy when I talk about it. Um, so that morning it was breakfast and we were up and I'm like, I feel like they're gonna find him really soon. And about four minutes later, I got a ding on my phone and it was um from Adam's friend and he said, we found him. And I was like, dead or alive? Cause I had thought he was dead and he said, he's gone.
20:14 Speaker 02 And I'm like, where? And he wouldn't message back. He didn't message us back and he's like, I'm coming to your house. So he came to our house and pretty much he was like, how did you know? Cause he was, he was exactly where you circled. And the strange thing that he said is that he showed the police and the police said, don't go to that area. We've already looked there. Him and a bunch of other people went back to that area and he was there. Where I had circled, which is insane. And but a lot of this started like when I was young, there was this case and I kept dreaming about this same girl. She was blonde, she was beautiful and and and she looked familiar, but I didn't know where. And she told me kind of. Who had killed her and that she was in the woods and all the clues were in the woods. And then one day my mom had on the news and it was Holly Bobo.
20:59 Speaker 02 Which is a case of a girl who got murdered like so really interesting. You should do an episode, really interesting. Really interesting case, but that's that's two of like the main times that it happened. And then a couple of years ago, there was one where this kind of like, I was in my living room and this was one that happened not during sleep, which was freaky. And it was almost like I was watching TV and out of the corner of my eye, I just saw a young man standing over here and he's like. I'm right at the edge of the water. And as I looked, he left, but I knew what he looked like. So I started searching and I started searching. And literally like a couple towns over, um, a boy had gone missing and it was like the, the craziness was the succession of it. Because about forty five minutes later, it came on cable news that they found him like right in the edge of the water and he had drowned.
21:44 Speaker 01 When did he die?
21:45 Speaker 02 Um, it, it was, it was like, it was the day before, like he had gone missing in the water and then by the next day they found him. But it was, it happened. And then bam, and it was weird because I didn't have like, I didn't have a connection to any of these people.
21:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's what's weird. And that's what's happened. I think the, one of the cases not related at all. Oh yeah, one was the mom or something. But one was, uh, or maybe it wasn't, I can't remember, but one was completely unrelated and she had never had any psychic. Uh, like things happened to her ever. And it was just, it was so freaky. Um, and then with the first guy you were talking about, how did he die? Was it drowning as well or?
22:20 Speaker 02 No, the first guy in the woods, it never came out. Like no one ever spoke, but I wasn't able to find out how like, I know personally what I saw. But
22:32 Speaker 01 So what did you see?
22:33 Speaker 02 I'm afraid to say it just because it is local and I don't want it to like.
22:38 Speaker 01 That's fair.
22:38 Speaker 02 Come back on me. Um, but I think that I know. Yeah.
22:43 Speaker 01 Yeah. I mean, if you knew where his, his whole, whole body was, I'm assuming.
22:47 Speaker 02 Yeah.
22:48 Speaker 01 Probably have a good idea. That's interesting that they wouldn't share that. Like you, I mean, it makes you. I don't know.
22:54 Speaker 02 Well, it's, it's, it's a small community and you know, I think that that family had already been through so much. Like I've never spoken on it. But the one thing that did freak me out was before I talked to Adam's friend, I had actually sent the map to someone who had organized a bunch of stuff that I didn't know was his sister. And she was like, well, how do you know him? And sent, and I was like, oh God, back off, back off. And I, and I didn't message her back. So like after this all happened, like for two days, I like was waiting because I was like, are the cops gonna? Show up. Cause that's the thing. Like if cops show up and they're like, hey, um, how did you know this horrible thing?
23:26 Speaker 01 That happens. Yeah.
23:27 Speaker 02 And how do I be like, oh, so like I dreamt about it? Then they're like, okay, where were you at three P M on a
23:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, you need an alibi. Yeah. And that also is one of the cases I talked about. She literally went to jail. Like, and then they eventually found out, like, it wasn't her. But it was like, how else would you know?
23:44 Speaker 02 No, how would you know?
23:46 Speaker 01 Have committed this crime?
23:47 Speaker 02 But the weird thing is, like, I have, I will have dreams that are, that are literally like little clippets like that, kind of like when we do our ghost investigation. It's not a lot during the day, but I think, you know, talking about the most interesting one. This one really ties because you're talking about ones where people were involved and weren't. But the most intense one for me was the Tori Stafford case, which, as we know, I testified against that murderer in court.
24:10 Speaker 01 Yes.
24:10 Speaker 02 Day that she went missing was insane. Um, I, I did Big Brothers, Big Sisters. My co-op was four periods. I worked in the schools with little girls that were about Tori Stafford's age. After school, everybody was handing out flyers. I printed flyers. I put them on posts. Um, that night I went to bed and all I could dream about was a man's legs, a girl's legs and a woman's legs walking along a tree line. That's all it was. And I said, Mom, like, I think she's like with a mom or a dad or like, she's with a man and a woman. And then, of course, months later, we found out that she was killed by Michael Rafferty and Terry Lynn McClintock, and it was in Mount Forest along this tree line where she was found.
24:49 Speaker 02 So I, I saw it like, and then that was just, that was insane because I didn't even know at this point that I was connected to that case at all whatsoever.
24:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's crazy. Like, what does that make you feel like?
25:01 Speaker 02 I, I will never not say it doesn't make me feel crazy. It always makes me feel crazy because when you see these things in your head, you feel like you're making it up and you feel like you're lying. But then when it comes and it's been validated, you feel like nothing's real and we live in a simulation.
25:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's kind of what I think. It's just like this weird, yeah, it's like a simulation almost. Like, how are you connected? Like, something glitched?
25:22 Speaker 02 Something glitched?
25:23 Speaker 01 You're not quite wired right, or you're wired more extensively.
25:29 Speaker 02 Some radar is on, I'm some goddamn RemPod. Like, I'm just attracted to things. But it's just like you, like, when we go into places, like, um, like with these certain videos, you'll be like, I've dreamt this, I've seen this.
25:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, it's really weird. Or like deja vu even, like, everybody experiences that, but like, it's like almost, uh, different levels of it, I guess.
25:49 Speaker 02 Yeah.
25:49 Speaker 01 Like, sometimes it's stronger than other times. Or like, yeah, for me, it's mostly just been when I'm, I like related people, like, I, I knew when my grandma died before anybody else knew about it, that kind of thing, or like, drugged about her. Which is like, I don't know, maybe that's just a, a, a paranormal thing, maybe, maybe she was allowed to like, do a couple errands before she went to heaven or something, I don't know. I don't know, it makes me think too much. I'm like, what?
26:14 Speaker 02 I have a cool exercise for you that you should try.
26:16 Speaker 01 Okay.
26:17 Speaker 02 You should get Caleb to look up a murder case, but just give you the person's name and age and location. Lay down, get out of your flies, lay down and try and figure out what happened to them. Write it down on paper and see how close you were.
26:32 Speaker 01 I like that, I'm gonna do that.
26:34 Speaker 02 Do it.
26:34 Speaker 01 I'm gonna try that. He'll be like, alright, that should freak him out. I don't know. I'm gonna try that, though. But thank you so much for telling us your stories. Uh, go follow Selena on everything, it's Selena Spooky Boo on everything, I think.
26:47 Speaker 02 Yep.
26:47 Speaker 01 And, yeah, I'm sure we'll do more spooky videos together. And I'm gonna do some psychic exercises.
26:53 Speaker 02 That'd be a sick episode.
26:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, actually, yeah, yeah, that would be, that would be. We'll have to do another video together like that. Okay, everybody, I hope you enjoyed the video. And if you did, please like the video, it always helps out the channel. And also, subscribe if you want to subscribe, this is obviously the best YouTube channel ever, and I will see your beautiful face in the next video. Alright? Bye.
Previous Ep. 19 | Kara Chamberlain's Story | Kidnapped by a Serial Killer Next Ep. 21 | The Green River Killer | The MOST Sickening Serial Killer in America Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated