Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
In September 2006, paramedics in East St. Louis, Illinois, responded to a 911 call at Frank Holton State Park and found a 24-year-old woman holding a stillborn baby. She identified herself as Tiffany Hall and claimed a man named Tony had raped her, causing premature labor. Days later, at the baby's funeral, Tiffany told her boyfriend Keith Horn that the child was not his and not even hers. Police found the body of 23-year-old Jamela Tunstall in Tiffany's backyard, wrapped in a shower curtain with a large gaping hole in her abdomen.
Tiffany confessed that she had faked her own pregnancy to keep Keith, a Navy sailor stationed in Virginia, and when her friend Jamela—also pregnant—started ignoring her calls after an argument, Tiffany beat Jamela with a chair leg, bound her, and cut the baby from her womb with scissors. Three days later, she picked up Jamela's three children from their father, gave them cough medicine, and drowned them in the bathtub. Their bodies were found in the washing machine and dryer at Jamela's apartment.
Tiffany was sentenced to four life sentences without parole plus 60 years for the unborn baby. The community of East St. Louis raised $35,000 for the family's funeral, and in October 2008, the baby was reburied under her real name, Harmony.
- Tiffany Hall's case was only the 12th recorded fetal abduction (Caesarian kidnapping) in US history, with all prior cases involving women who faked pregnancies to manipulate partners. 34:56
- The people of East St. Louis raised $35,000 within days to cover the Tunstall family's funeral costs, and more than 700 mourners attended the service. 38:04
- Tiffany purchased rubbing alcohol, scissors, and a nasal aspirator in preparation for cutting the baby from Jamela's womb and clearing its airway. 22:22
- The stillborn baby was exhumed from her grave under the name Taylor and reburied alongside her real mother and siblings under the name Harmony in October 2008. 39:37
- Tiffany received four life sentences without the possibility of parole for the murders of Jamela and her three children, plus a concurrent 60-year sentence for the unborn baby. 36:04
Highlights
- 5:01
Paramedics Find Woman With Dead Babystory
At Frank Holton State Park, paramedics find a 24-year-old woman holding a stillborn newborn. She tells detectives she was raped by a man named Tony, who cut the cord and dumped them in the park.
- 11:16
Confession at the Baby's Funeralstory
At the funeral for the stillborn baby named Taylor, Tiffany tells her boyfriend Keith that the child was not his and not even hers. Police are immediately dispatched to her home.
- 12:14
Jamela's Body Found in the Backyardstory
An officer searching behind Tiffany's house finds Jamela Tunstall wrapped in a shower curtain among the bushes. She was clearly pregnant but there was no baby, only a large gaping hole in her abdomen.
- 22:22
Preparation for the Fetal Abductioninsight
Tiffany bought rubbing alcohol, scissors, and a nasal aspirator to clear the baby's airway after cutting it from Jamela's womb. She had contemplated taking the baby for quite some time.
- 31:32
Children Found in Washing Machinestory
Officers re-enter Jamela's apartment and find the semi-naked body of seven-year-old Damon in the washing machine. The dryer contains the naked bodies of two-year-old Ivan Junior and one-year-old Janella.
- 34:56
Twelfth Fetal Abduction in US Historydata
Tiffany's case was only the 12th recorded fetal abduction in US history. In all previous cases, the abductors were women who needed a newborn to pass off as their own, most to manipulate partners.
- 38:04
Community Raises $35,000 for Funeralstory
Neither Ivan Collins nor Jamela's family could afford a funeral. Within days, the people of East St. Louis raised $35,000, and more than 700 mourners gathered at the church service.
- 39:37
Baby Reburied Under Name Harmonystory
In October 2008, the stillborn baby was exhumed from her grave under the name Taylor and reburied alongside her real mother and siblings. Ivan and Jamela had chosen the name Harmony for their daughter.
About this episode
*** Content warnings: Child victims*** On September 15 2006, detectives began investigating the sexual assault of 24-year-old Tiffany Hall from East St. Louis, Illinois. The assault had caused Tiffany to miscarry her 7-month old foetus. A week later, police received a tip-off that would break the case wide open, revealing unimaginable horrors that devastated a family and an entire community. Casefile Extra features bonus episodes exploring compelling cases, stories and topics beyond our regular weekly releases. --- Narration – Anonymous Host https://www.instagram.com/caseys.snaps/ Research & writing – Holly Boyd Production & music – Mike Migas http://mikemigas.com/ Music - Andrew D. B. Joslyn Audio editing – Anthony Telfer Sign up for Casefile Premium: Apple Premium https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/casefile-true-crime/id998568017?ign-itscg=30200S&ign-itsct=casefile_podcastsSpotify Premium https://spotifyanchor-web.app.link/e/9gSwcv7USsbPatreon https://www.patreon.com/casefileFor all credits and sources, please visit https://casefilepodcast.com/casefile-archives-8-the-tunstall-family The Tunstall Family case was originally released as a premium episode in May 2024. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript
5,419 words · 5 speakers
Topics
- Fetal Abduction
- Child Homicide
- Domestic Violence
- True Crime
- Community Response
- East St. Louis
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated