Skip to content

Case 338: The Folbigg Children (Part 2/2)

Casefile True Crime

1h 41m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode details the 2003 trial of Kathleen Folbigg, charged with murdering her four children Caleb, Patrick, Sarah, and Laura. The prosecution, led by Mark Todeski, relied on expert opinions from Dr. Janice Oppoven (who claimed a one-in-a-trillion chance of four SIDS deaths in one family), ten points of coincidence evidence, and 40 diary entries read in court. The defence, led by Peter Zahra, argued each death had a natural medical explanation. The jury returned mixed verdicts: not guilty of Caleb's murder but guilty of manslaughter, and guilty of the other three murders. Kathleen was sentenced to 40 years in prison.

After the Sally Clark case in England exposed the statistical flaws in Meadows Law, and after Professor Emma Cunliffe's 2011 research and Professor Stephen Cordner's forensic review raised further doubts, a novel CARM2 gene mutation was discovered in Kathleen and two of her children in 2018. A 2019 inquiry by Judge Blanch rejected the genetic evidence, but a second inquiry by former Chief Justice Tom Bathurst in 2022–2023 found reasonable doubt. Kathleen was pardoned on June 5, 2023, and all five convictions were formally quashed on December 14, 2023. Craig Folbigg died of a heart attack in 2024, still convinced of her guilt.

  • Meadows Law (one SIDS is a tragedy, two suspicious, three murder) was debunked after Sally Clark's wrongful conviction, and the Royal Statistical Society confirmed the figures were false. 23:52
  • A novel CARM2 gene mutation found in Kathleen and two of her children could cause fatal cardiac arrhythmias, potentially explaining Sarah's and Laura's deaths. 1:22:35
  • Professor Cordner's 125-page report concluded there was no forensic pathology evidence to suggest the Folbigg children were deliberately smothered or killed. 1:10:40
  • Kathleen Folbigg was pardoned on June 5, 2023, and all five convictions were formally quashed by the Court of Criminal Appeal on December 14, 2023. 1:37:23
  • A clinical psychologist concluded the prosecution's use of Kathleen's diaries as evidence was misleading and unsupported by psychological literature on maternal adjustment. 1:12:37

Highlights

  • 8:38

    One in a Trillion Claimdata

    Dr. Janice Oppoven, a paediatric forensic pathologist specialising in mothers who kill their children, stated that the statistical likelihood of four children dying from SIDS was in excess of one in a trillion. This figure became central to the prosecution's case.

  • 23:52

    Meadows Law and Sally Clarkinsight

    Professor Roy Meadow testified at Sally Clark's trial that the odds of two SIDS deaths in a non-smoking affluent family was one in 73 million. After her conviction was overturned, the Royal Statistical Society declared his figures false, and a mathematician concluded double SIDS was actually twice as likely as double murder.

  • 45:08

    The Jury's Mixed Verdictstory

    The jury found Kathleen not guilty of Caleb's murder but guilty of manslaughter, then guilty of Patrick's, Sarah's, and Laura's murders. Kathleen burst into tears and was half-carried out of the dock by her court chaplain.

  • 1:10:40

    Cordner's Forensic Conclusioninsight

    Professor Stephen Cordner, Australia's leading forensic pathologist, spent a year reviewing the case and concluded there was no forensic pathology evidence to suggest the children were deliberately smothered. He found Laura's myocarditis significant enough to rule as cause of death.

  • 1:22:35

    CARM2 Mutation Discoverydata

    Two immunologists independently identified a novel CARM2 gene mutation in Kathleen's DNA that had never been seen before. Sequencing of the children's tissue samples revealed both Sarah and Laura carried the same mutation, which could cause fatal cardiac arrhythmias.

  • 1:27:38

    Judge Blanch Rejects Genetic Evidencedebate

    Judge Blanch concluded the CARM2 science was too new and unproven, and that only two of the four children carried the mutation. He stated the diary entries still provided the most compelling evidence for guilt and found no reasonable doubt about Kathleen's guilt.

  • 1:37:23

    Kathleen Folbigg Pardonedstory

    Judge Bathurst found a reasonable possibility that at least Patrick, Sarah, and Laura died from natural causes, and that the diary entries were words of a grieving, depressed mother. The Attorney General declared Kathleen unconditionally pardoned after 20 years in prison.

About this episode

[Part 2 of 2] *** Content warning: child victims *** As police looked into the deaths of Caleb, Patrick, Sarah and Laura Folbigg, they were introduced to Meadows Law – the theory that one infant death is a tragedy, two is suspicious, but three is murder. With suspicion mounting against Kathleen Folbigg, years of investigation eventually led to a legal outcome that no one could have ever seen coming. --- Narration – Anonymous Host https://www.instagram.com/caseys.snaps/ Research & writing – Elsha McGill Production & music – Mike Migas http://mikemigas.com/ Audio editing – Anthony Telfer Sign up for Casefile Premium: Apple Premium https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/casefile-true-crime/id998568017?ign-itscg=30200S&ign-itsct=casefile_podcastsSpotify Premium https://spotifyanchor-web.app.link/e/9gSwcv7USsbPatreon https://www.patreon.com/casefileFor all credits and sources, please visit https://casefilepodcast.com/case-338-the-folbigg-children-part-2-2 https://casefilepodcast.com/case-338-the-folbigg-children-part-2-2/ Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

0:00
1:41:55

15,415 words · 5 speakers

Topics

  • Wrongful Conviction
  • SIDS
  • Forensic Pathology
  • Genetic Testing
  • Meadows Law
  • Criminal Justice
  • Australian Legal System
  • Motherhood

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated