Pod Insights British Scandal The Post Office Scandal | The Secret File | 2 About this episode Branded a thief, Jo is losing everything. Then, a forensic investigator starts asking questions and uncovers evidence that could clear her name. But revealing it will pit Jo and hundreds of other sub-postmasters against one of Britain's most powerful institutions.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 7,798 words · 10 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Alice Levine? Matt, what on earth are you doing?
0:01 Matt Forde? Definitely not covering anything up.
0:03 Alice Levine? Okay, you are shoving documents into a toaster?
0:07 Matt Forde? Yeah, it's just a new data management system I've developed.
0:11 Alice Levine? What are you burning slash toasting? It just looks like a receipt for that sushi place down the road.
0:16 Matt Forde? Exactly. I can't be seen eating sushi. My reputation is built on pasties. You book me, you get a guy who eats pasties. If people start thinking I eat sophisticated or modern food, I'm over.
0:27 Alice Levine? I really think you're overreacting.
0:29 Matt Forde? Alice, before the World Cup in 2010, I was pictured eating a falafel and quinoa salad. I didn't get any gigs that summer. It was a World Cup summer.
0:36 Alice Levine? Are you sure that's the reason?
0:38 Matt Forde? Well, I didn't get any work any of the other World Cup summers, but that's beside the point.
0:43 Alice Levine? Then what are you waiting for? Put it on defrost.
0:49 Alice Levine? 2012, Post Office Headquarters, London. Ian Henderson rips open the package on his desk, then stops. His shoulders tense. The Post Office has sent him the wrong batch, again.
1:04 Alice Levine? He runs a hand through his grey hair. Either the whole system is a mess, or he's missing something.
1:11 Alice Levine? The Post Office hired Ian to audit the Horizon system and the prosecutions built on it. But the deeper he digs, the murkier it gets. Files don't match, go missing, or vanish entirely. And his patience is wearing thin.
1:28 Alice Levine? He snatches up the phone, is about to ring CEO Paula Venables to complain when something catches his eye. One of the files looks different to the others. It's twice as thick. He pulls it out. It's a full legal file, stamped private and confidential. They must have sent it in error. He glances up to make sure no one's looking, then turns the pages. His eyebrows shoot up as he stares at a typewritten report. For a moment, he can't breathe.
2:04 Alice Levine? He reads it again and again, looks at the name, Joe Hamilton. Scans over her details. He cannot believe what he's reading. He flinches as one of the post office's legal team passes by, holds his breath till they've gone. For months, Paula Venels has sworn the Horizon system is watertight. No bugs, no errors, no false prosecutions. He believed them, until now.
2:40 Alice Levine? He grabs the file, heads out into the corridor. His hand shakes, not just from shock, but at the thought of what this could do to his career if he's found with it. He scrolls through his phone contacts to his business partner, Ron. His pulse beats against his ears as Ron answers.
2:58 Speaker 02 You'll have to be quick, Ian, I'm just about to meet one of the sub-postmasters.
3:02 Alice Levine? He cuts in. "Ron, I've found something." His heart thuds as he waits for a woman to walk past. When she's gone, he whispers into the phone.
3:13 Alice Levine? "I've got proof that the post office has been prosecuting people without evidence." He listens to the stunned silence on the other end. Looks up now as the woman reappears. She's staring right at him. He hangs up, attempts a casual nod, feels a trickle of sweat run down his back as he walks back to his desk. When no one's watching, he slips the file under the others. One wrong move and he could be accused of breaching confidentiality. His career could be ruined. But he has to keep this file safe. He'll get it copied tonight, keep it secure.
3:58 Matt Forde? This is 2012, so it's still in the digital era. But the thought that you would ever have to photocopy something.
4:03 Alice Levine? Yeah, I was just thinking that a giant office photocopier is the most conspicuous accessory to being a whistleblower possible.
4:11 Matt Forde? It's like firing up some sort of blast furnace. And from what I remember of working in offices is, that's when people will come and chat to you. "Anne, what are you photocopying?" "Nothing, mate. You just back off."
4:21 Alice Levine? "And can I use your key code? Because I don't want this to be on my account."
4:24 Matt Forde? And some people will say, "Well, iPhones are around then. Why not just take pictures of it?" But that way lies all sorts of other jeopardy, because your iPhone will then create montages of the private and confidential documents, set to music, that will then get shared on your WhatsApps.
4:40 Alice Levine? Called Summer 2012. Summer whistleblowing 2012.
4:45 Alice Levine? Ian looks around the busy office, then at the red post office logo that's everywhere, and realises he's about to take on one of Britain's best-loved, most powerful institutions. Because if this file is right, it isn't sub-postmasters who've been breaking the law all this time. It's the post office.
5:16 Speaker 03 With the Venture X Business Card from Capital One, you earn unlimited double miles on every purchase. Plus, big purchasing power means you can spend more and earn more. The Capital One Venture X Business Card. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com for details.
5:32 Speaker 04 PrizePix packs are here. Rip digital packs and get real basketball, footfall and Pokémon cards on PrizePix packs. Available now nationwide. Once you see your pool, you have a choice to sell back instantly for real cash or ship at home. Cash from your sale will immediately be added to your PrizePix balance. It's just another way to run your game. New users, download the PrizePix app today and use code WONDERY to get $25 instantly in bonus packs when you buy your first $5 pack. PrizePix, run your game. 18 plus in eligible areas. Terms apply. Collect responsibly.
6:05 Matt Forde? From Audible Originals, I'm Matt Ford.
6:07 Alice Levine? And I'm Alice Levine.
6:09 Matt Forde? And this is British Scandal.
6:24 Alice Levine? So Matt, last time we met Jo Hamilton, lovely postmistress. She started using the brand spanking new computer system Horizon. She had very high hopes for that. It would cut down on her bookkeeping time potentially. And then she started losing money very, very quickly. And she ended up prosecuted for stealing £36,000 from the post office, even though she was a diligent and much-loved pillar of the community before that. Does that scream hardened criminal to you?
6:56 Matt Forde? Well, on the one hand, as I've said before, I just don't trust anyone with the job title Subpostmistress. It sounds kinky.
7:02 Alice Levine? It does.
7:03 Matt Forde? So I have a natural aversion to the title. But obviously, I have to accept, on the other hand, it looks like she might be the innocent victim of a massive corporate and establishment conspiracy.
7:14 Alice Levine? And is that other hand much larger than the original hand?
7:17 Matt Forde? I'm not going to spank anyone with it if that's where this is going.
7:21 Alice Levine? Would it surprise you if I told you that Jo might not be the only one implicated?
7:26 Matt Forde? Well, given the way that justice has gone in this country and the way that we've covered previous miscarriages of justice, absolutely not.
7:33 Alice Levine? And dare I say that this scandal has potentially reached your consciousness?
7:37 Matt Forde? Oh, yeah. I watch ITVX, which again, sounds kinky.
7:41 Alice Levine? Okay, let's leave that aside. This is episode two, Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance.
7:49 Alice Levine? Three years earlier, April 2009, South Wornborough. Jo grabs her mop and bucket, heads to her car. She's been cleaning houses since six this morning, taking on extra jobs to clear her debts. And now she's late for work at the shop. She catches her reflection in the rearview mirror. Her face is pale, her eyes ringed with dark circles. It's been over a year now since she finished her 12-month community order. And still no closer to getting to the bottom of the missing money. Between work and looking after her family, there's been no time to dig deeper.
8:31 Alice Levine? She's about to drive off when someone waves at her. She looks up to see Rock Garrard, a retired probation officer. He's with a small group of elderly villagers, and they're marching towards her. She watches Rock now, as he pats down his neatly trimmed hair, grinning.
8:49 Alice Levine? We spent yesterday in the library, Jo, sleuthing. She frowns. Sleuthing? He pulls out a photocopy of an article from a plastic sleeve. Jo scans the headline. Anglesey Subpostmaster Released. She looks at the photo of a stout grey-haired man outside a prison gate. His shoulders are slumped, and he looks utterly bewildered. Who's this? Rock straightens, serious now. Noel Thomas, sent to prison for nine months for theft and false accounting. Always claimed his innocence. Jo scans the article, and then smiles wearily. Rock, this is very kind, but I've never heard of this man.
9:33 Alice Levine? She looks up, and Rock stands to his full height. He was the backbone of his community before the post office took him to court, Jo, just like you. Jo looks at the picture again. It never occurred to her that there might be another subpostmaster in her situation. Rock flips the page, triumphant. We tracked him down, if you wanna ring him. She looks back at the group, feels a lump in her throat. She couldn't have got through this last year without the support of the village, and she's never felt more grateful to be part of this community.
10:10 Alice Levine? That night, Jo sits in the kitchen, stares at the number, her hands are clammy. What if this Noel won't talk to her? Or what if he's actually guilty?
10:24 Matt Forde? But she's not going to figure that out on the phone. Hello, guilty in all Thomas. I knew it.
10:29 Alice Levine? Or would he answer the phone in a sort of guilty way like,
10:33 Alice Levine? can I help you?
10:37 Alice Levine? She closes her eyes,
10:40 Alice Levine? then picks up the phone and punches in the number before she changes her mind.
10:46 Alice Levine? A scared voice answers.
10:48 Speaker 02 Who is this, please?
10:49 Alice Levine? She blurts out her name, tells him she's an ex-subpostmistress, how she was found guilty for false accounting. I don't know what happened. All I know is I couldn't get the figures to tally, but the auditor wouldn't listen. In the end, they offered me a plea bargain. If I pleaded guilty to false accounting. Jo feels a chill run through her as he finishes her sentence.
11:13 Speaker 02 They dropped the theft charge.
11:16 Alice Levine? Jo freezes. She lets out a breath.
11:20 Alice Levine? So, there are two of us.
11:22 Speaker 02 Oh, there's more than two of us, Jo.
11:25 Alice Levine? She grips the phone closer. What do you mean? Her heart thuds as she takes in the pause on the other end, then hears him say,
11:34 Speaker 02 I think you need to talk to Alan Bates.
11:42 Matt Forde? Must be quite an odd feeling because, one, you'd feel relief, in a way, that you think, okay, so that means that there might be a bigger mistake and it would reassure you about your own mentality, I guess. But then also, you wouldn't really have wanted anyone else to go through the hell that you've been put through. So you're simultaneously kind of elated, but also deeply depressed that someone else has been put through hell.
12:06 Alice Levine? May 2009, Colwyn Bay, North Wales. Alan Bates puts his head down against the rain, walks quickly along the seafront. He's got an interview with a journalist from Computer Weekly this afternoon, and he needs to clear his head. He stops at the promenade rail, watches the waves slam against the boulders beneath his feet, and runs through his story in his head. How he's been campaigning against the post office for six years now, ever since they accused him of having a £6,000 shortfall. How he'd refused to pay it, ended up walking away from his own post office in 2003.
12:51 Matt Forde? We obviously know Alan as a formidable campaigner and someone who forced this issue through years and years of stamina into the public domain and then continually trying to get justice for people. But he had been a sub-postmaster himself, so he had been through this and experienced the injustice personally.
13:08 Alice Levine? He wipes the rain from his face. He won't tell the journalist how this fight has taken over his life, how much strain it's put on his relationship. He loves his partner Suzanne, but she's right when she calls him the most stubborn man in the world. But if he gives up now, the post office wins. He's about to head home when his mobile rings. Alan Bates. He hears a nervous woman's voice on the line.
13:37 Speaker 02 My name's Jo Hamilton. Noel Thomas gave me your number. I was convicted of false accounting last year.
13:46 Alice Levine? Alan leans against the railing, rain trickling down his neck. He listens as she explains her figures wouldn't tally and that she pleaded guilty to stop it going further.
13:58 Speaker 02 I swear I didn't steal that money. I've no idea where it went.
14:03 Alice Levine? He squints up at the grey sky. He's spoken to countless sub-postmasters over the years. Most of them are bewildered, nervous, riddled with guilt, and they all want answers. He nods. It wasn't you, Jo. It was never your fault.
14:23 Alice Levine? He hears her gasp.
14:25 Speaker 02 You believe me?
14:27 Alice Levine? He narrows his eyes, wonders if he should tell her how much research he's done into the post office, collecting evidence, being ignored. He's not sure belief is enough anymore, but it's a start. I'm planning a meeting. I want to get everyone together who's been prosecuted by the post office. Why don't you come along? He hears her hesitate.
14:50 Speaker 02 I don't know, Alan. I'm working day and night. I've got family to look after.
14:56 Alice Levine? He gently cuts in.
14:59 Alice Levine? I understand, but it might give you some answers.
15:02 Matt Forde? And you did ring me?
15:03 Alice Levine? To be fair...
15:04 Matt Forde? I'm trying to give you help. Help me help you.
15:08 Alice Levine? He puts up his hood, stares out to sea, and decides. He'll gather as many sub-postmasters as he can and tell them his concerns. He's convinced that once they hear each other's stories, they'll be forced to see and accept the patterns he's seen for years. It might well be like climbing a mountain, but he's determined to climb it anyway, one stubborn step at a time.
15:47 Alice Levine? November 2009, Fennec Compton Village Hall. Jo switches off her engine, gripping the tin of cakes and scones and looks over to the village hall. Jo's stomach twists. Alan's asked her to tell her story, but now she's dreading reliving the whole thing. Worse than that, people might not believe her.
16:10 Matt Forde? We've had gatherings of criminals in previous series of British scandal: Hatton Garden with the diamond heist, Russian gangsters. But this is the first time we've had a collection of them who are not just innocent, but have brought scones.
16:25 Alice Levine? She pushes through the doors into the main hall, tin balanced under one arm. A grey-haired man with a kind face comes striding towards her. Jo, I'm Alan. Let me take those. He nods to her to take a seat in the circle of chairs. She blinks. There's forty people here at least. Who are all these people? Sub-postmasters? Like you? She sits, hands trembling. One by one, they start to talk. She recognizes Noel Thomas from his photo in the papers. His voice cracks. When I came out of prison, the post office demanded the missing forty-eight grand. Everything's gone. I'm bankrupt. My family were harassed.
17:10 Alice Levine? And people still shun me in the street.
17:14 Alice Levine? Jo takes a breath. Alan gives her an encouraging nod. She starts to tell her story. The doubling figures. How she ended up in court in massive debt.
17:25 Speaker 02 And I still can't understand how it happened.
17:28 Alice Levine? She blinks around the silent room. Watches Alan lean forward to the woman next to her. Christine, why don't you tell us what happened when you phoned the helpline? Jo listens as she describes how her figures doubled in front of her after she called.
17:44 Speaker 02 They just kept saying it was my fault. Then, when they took me to court, they made me promise not to mention the Horizon system.
17:52 Alice Levine? Jo jolts forward. Wait, Horizon? She feels a chill run down her spine as Christine nods. Jo feels almost winded as a memory floods back. How could she have forgotten? She blurts out.
18:07 Speaker 02 They made me do the same thing. I didn't think it was important. I, I was so stressed and scared I would have agreed to anything.
18:15 Alice Levine? She grips the side of her chair. Feels dozens of eyes on her. Then here's Alan, ask the group. How many of you were asked by the post office not to mention Horizon at your trial? She watches dozens of hands shoot up. Jo can barely breathe. Alan straightens. The post office are terrified we'll mention Horizon. Because Horizon, my friends, is to blame for all of this.
18:42 Matt Forde? This is incredible that the post office will prosecute you and say, oh, but in court, don't mention that thing, right? On what grounds are you getting a favour out of these people? In return for what?
18:52 Alice Levine? And also just out of fear.
18:54 Matt Forde? Yeah, don't mention that thing that would actually damage our case against you. Deal?
18:58 Alice Levine? Well, you've stolen my livelihood and ruined my reputation, so yeah?
19:03 Alice Levine? The room goes still. Jo stares, wide-eyed. Here's herself blurt out.
19:09 Speaker 02 Horizon, faulty. It can't be.
19:14 Alice Levine? The room crackles with tension in the silence. Everyone looks at Alan. There is no doubt in my mind. Horizon's to blame for every conviction. But we still need to prove it. Jo looks around the room at the startled faces. Then back at Alan as he announces. If we've got any chance of doing that, we need to be organised. We need to unite together. She feels a surge of energy run through her as Alan stands up. He unfurls a banner. "The Justice for Subpulse Masters Alliance."
19:52 Alice Levine? For the first time in years, Jo doesn't feel alone. She's going to throw everything she's got into this fight. And she knows exactly where she'll start.
20:07 Alice Levine? 2010, constituency office, Basingstoke. James Arbuthnot marches into his office, straightens the portrait on the wall of his ancestor, James V., grabs his itinerary from his desk, and scans down the surgery list.
20:23 Speaker 02 Housing, housing, rural transport, dog mess.
20:28 Alice Levine? James sighs. He's been a Member of Parliament for 13 years, and still mainly dog mess.
20:35 Matt Forde? I came into this job to get rid of dog mess. It's what drives me.
20:39 Alice Levine? Tough on dog mess? Tough on the causes of dog mess?
20:42 Matt Forde? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
20:42 Alice Levine? Which would be dogs.
20:43 Matt Forde? You could give all dogs colostomy bags.
20:45 Alice Levine? Okay.
20:46 Matt Forde? So then they're just doing it straight into the bag anyway?
20:48 Alice Levine? How expensive or involved would that be to roll out?
20:52 Matt Forde? Yeah, sure, the upfront costs are arguably prohibitive. But I think there are opportunities here, particularly with AI, Mr. Speaker, to do these procedures very quickly.
21:06 Alice Levine? With luck, he'll finish on time today. He's promised his wife dinner at a new fusion place in Mayfair, and he doesn't want to be late. Thank you for seeing me. He looks up, sees a smiling woman in a neatly buttoned cardigan.
21:21 Speaker 02 Mrs. Hamilton.
21:23 Alice Levine? She nods, takes a seat, clears her throat. I'd like you to look into the post office Horizon system. He frowns.
21:32 Speaker 02 Horizon?
21:34 Alice Levine? James has never heard of it. He listens as she explains about being convicted of stealing thirty six thousand six hundred and forty four pounds. He cuts in. I'm really not sure I'm the best. But she carries on. There are six hundred of us, all wrongly convicted. He raises his eyebrows. Six hundred? And I just sat in a room with forty five of them. We all phoned the Horizon helpline. We were all prosecuted. He leans back, tense his fingers. It sounds impossible. He was a barrister before he became an MP, and he knows the courts don't make mistakes like that. He smiles politely.
22:18 Alice Levine? Perhaps if you consult a lawyer. She folds her hands on the desk. I rang the Horizon helpline a hundred and ninety eight times in three years, and if I have to ring you that often to get you to take this seriously, I will. All I'm asking is that you look into it. He studies her carefully. Whatever the truth is, she's certainly determined. He lets out a sigh. Of course. When she's gone, he leans back. Nothing she said makes sense. Still, a promise is a promise, and he's a man of his word.
23:02 Alice Levine? He grabs his BlackBerry, taps out an email. I had a BlackBerry.
23:07 Matt Forde? You never did.
23:08 Alice Levine? When I moved to London, that was my first phone, because for some reason, I got a work phone.
23:14 Matt Forde? It was like a mini laptop?
23:16 Alice Levine? Yeah.
23:17 Matt Forde? Not like a big calculator?
23:18 Alice Levine? Yeah, you sort of typed on it, like you kind of used all of your fingers and thumbs.
23:22 Matt Forde? Was it any good?
23:23 Alice Levine? No, no, no, no.
23:24 Matt Forde? I never had one. So I was never jealous of people who did. Thank God for the smartphone. The smartphone has got to be up there with the wheel.
23:33 Alice Levine? I think we're going back. Lots of people are going back to, maybe not the BlackBerry, but a thirty three ten is happening. It's liberating, think about it.
23:41 Matt Forde? You were just saying that because you lost yours the other week.
23:43 Alice Levine? Yeah.
23:46 Alice Levine? Next day, he makes his way to his office in the House of Commons, tries to ignore his indigestion from last night's dinner. James scans his emails and feels his eyebrows shoot up. He's had 20 replies from MPs in all parts of the country, all with sub-postmasters who were prosecuted by the post office after calling the Horizon helpline. He leans back, frowns. Could it really be possible that the post office has been unfairly sending people to jail?
24:19 Alice Levine? It's one of the backbones of British society, has been since the 17th century. A slow, angry breath. He straightens his cufflinks. He hates bullies almost as much as he hates liars.
24:34 Alice Levine? He reaches for his phone. If Mrs. Hamilton was looking for someone to fight her corner, then she's just found them. And if 600 sub-postmasters are telling the truth and have been wrongly convicted, this could be one of the biggest miscarriages of justice in British history.
25:03 Speaker 05 Confidence, it's listening to your gut. It's moving forward even when the path ahead is unclear. For nearly 160 years, Pacific Life has helped people keep their promises, building confidence for generations. Whether you're confident in your financial future or just beginning to envision it, we're here to help. Ask a financial professional how. Pacific Life, the power of a promise. Pacific Life Insurance Company, Omaha, Nebraska, and in New York, Pacific Life and Annuity, Phoenix, Arizona.
25:34 Speaker 03 With the Venture X Business Card from Capital One, you earn unlimited double miles on every purchase. Plus, big purchasing power means you can spend more and earn more. The Capital One Venture X Business Card. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com for details.
25:55 Alice Levine? May 2012, Post Office Head Office, London.
26:00 Alice Levine? Fifty-three-year-old Paula Venels smooths down her neatly cropped red hair, checks her reflection in the glass door, and strides down the corridor to the boardroom.
26:11 Alice Levine? She's only been the Post Office's chief exec for a few weeks now. Five years climbing the ladder, and she's determined to make her mark.
26:22 Alice Levine? Today, she's going to update this whole organisation and finally make it profitable. She tugs down her collarless jacket, is about to march into the meeting when her mobile buzzes.
26:36 Alice Levine? Her shoulders stiffen. It's MP James Arbuthnot. He's been sending her constant emails since she started this job, questioning Horizon. She can't understand why. It's the most advanced accounting and stock-taking system there is. It's finally put an end to the ridiculous and costly system of every sub-postmaster sending their spreadsheets through the Post.
27:03 Alice Levine? She clicks 'accept'. 'Mr Arbuthnot, thank you so much for your emails.' She starts telling him how necessary Horizon is, how its state-of-the-art technology costs a billion pounds. It's finally dragging the Post Office into the 21st... He cuts in, irritated.
27:20 Speaker 02 'Yes, yes, but I have constituents who have been convicted because of possible faults.'
27:25 Alice Levine? She rolls her eyes. The Post Office is losing £2 million a week in revenue. Last year, it made a loss of £120 million. And he's complaining about the one thing that actually works. She puts on her calmest voice. 'I can assure you, Mr Arbuthnot, Horizon is robust. There's no evidence linking it with any false conviction.'
27:50 Alice Levine? She listens to the silence on the other end of the line. Then hears his irritated voice ask.
27:56 Speaker 02 I've been in touch with the Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance. They have several cases where Horizon figures doubled in front of their eyes. Can you at least meet me to discuss this?
28:08 Alice Levine? She purses her lips. I'll have to get back to you. She looks down at her mobile. Arbuthnot isn't the only Member of Parliament asking questions about Horizon. She's had at least five calls from different MPs this week. But the Post Office has 1 million Horizon terminals. Right now, Horizon is the Post Office. She can't have its reputation damaged. So she takes a deep breath and decides she's going to nip this in the bud. Show the MPs and their subpostmasters, once and for all, that the Horizon system is solid.
28:47 Matt Forde? This is the part of a parliamentary democracy that, when it works, really works. Because if you race it with your MP and then they're down in Parliament and they all talk together, cross-party, and they're on select committees together that are cross-party, they're in all-party groups that are cross-party. Once they realise this is happening everywhere, you do get alliances that go beyond just the boundaries of political parties. And then you've got a formidable group of people in your corner that can put pressure on organisations, whether it's stuff like the Post Office or whether it's businesses. And that is often what can unblock the problems with this and hold other powerful people to account.
29:20 Alice Levine? She dips into her PA's office, asks her to draw up a shortlist of forensic accountants. She won't choose an expensive one. She doesn't want to waste money. Instead, she'll pick a small firm, get them to investigate and test the system. And finally, get Arbuthnot and his fellow MPs off her back.
29:50 Alice Levine? July 2012. Old Farm Stables, South Wornborough. Jo brings a bundle of horse feed into the stable. She loves coming here. It's the only time she feels truly calm. She starts to brush a large chestnut-coloured horse, strokes the white patch on his nose, then looks over as a car pulls up.
30:14 Alice Levine? Jo frowns as a heavily-built man in a suit steps out, picks his way across the yard, dodging the puddles. Mrs Hamilton, Ian Henderson, second-site forensic accountants. We've been hired by the post office to look into Horizon-based prosecutions. I'm busy. How dare he disturb her peace? After everything the post office has put her through.
30:38 Matt Forde? Yeah, if you're Jo, there's no way you would trust him, because you'd think, "Every time I've interacted with the post office, you've screwed me over. If anything, every time I've interacted with you, it's made it worse."
30:48 Alice Levine? Yeah, this is a company that the post office have hired, so why would they be acting in her best interest?
30:54 Matt Forde? Hi, I'm here on behalf of the company that wrongfully prosecuted you, and let's talk to you, please.
30:59 Alice Levine? She turns her back on him. He hesitates, wipes mud off his shoe. I've been given thirteen cases to look at. Yours was the first file I read. She feels her shoulders tighten. She really thought James Arbuthnot would get some answers. Instead, it's led to another god-awful inquisition. Mrs Hamilton, I'm just trying to get my head around what's happened. She spins, lets out a bitter laugh. I've been trying to do that for years, so good luck. He takes a few steps towards her, then stops. Dammit. She looks down, watches him lift his foot from a pile of horse manure. Jo lets out a laugh, then throws a cloth to him.
31:45 Alice Levine? Ian clears his throat. We're just a two-man band, Mrs Hamilton. Myself and my partner Ron, Wilmington. But if the post office think we'll just rubber-stamp their decisions, they're wrong. She studies him. She wants to believe him. It's still paying your wages, though. I'd be suspicious too, but our reputation is built on telling the truth. It's all we have.
32:10 Alice Levine? He reaches into his briefcase, pulls out his phone. I've listened to your interview with the auditor, Graham Branda. Except, he didn't interview you. He interrogated you, bullied you. It's wrong.
32:25 Matt Forde? That guy, Graham Branda, obviously the piece of work from our previous episode, who turns up at her shop and just treats her in the most appalling way with the clear assumption of guilt.
32:34 Alice Levine? The worst of the worst. I think it's very easy as well to make somebody who's innocent with this kind of intimidation feel guilty. It just reminds me of going through the conveyor belt bit of customs and them questioning you. And I just start sweating, I feel really guilty. And all I've got is, you know, 40 kilos of cocaine, but I will admit to being a murderer because I feel guilty. That is obviously a joke, go back and listen to our Peru Two series. She takes a step back. Even the mention of Branda puts her on edge.
33:05 Alice Levine? She looks from the horse to Ian. She doesn't know if she can trust this man. But it's the first time anyone said out loud that Branda bullied her. She nods. Okay. Let's talk.
33:24 Alice Levine? September 2012, St Owen's Church, Bromham.
33:29 Alice Levine? Ian Henderson slips onto a pew at the back of the church. He scans the congregation as Paula Venables gives her sermon. He's spent the past eight weeks trying to arrange a meeting about Horizon. Now he's come to see her face to face.
33:45 Speaker 02 For we are what he made us, created in Christ Jesus for good works.
33:50 Matt Forde? So Paula Venables, as well as being chief exec of the post office, was also an ordained minister in the Church of England.
33:56 Alice Levine? Moonlighting as a minister, or moonlighting as the CEO of the post office.
34:01 Matt Forde? You would be an excellent vicar.
34:02 Alice Levine? Do you think?
34:03 Matt Forde? Definitely. I think you've got all the attributes. Vocal projection from the pulpit, tick. Warmth, tick. A slight air of judgment.
34:13 Alice Levine? Tick, tick.
34:13 Matt Forde? Tick, tick, tick.
34:16 Alice Levine? Ian folds his arms. In the past few weeks, he's interviewed all 13 sub-postmasters on his list. All with the same story. Horizon figures mysteriously doubling in front of their eyes. One even noticed the balance changing unexpectedly and was convinced the post office was controlling it. So now he wants to ask Paula Venels if that's really possible. When the service ends, he pushes his way forwards. "Mrs. Venels, Ian Henderson, second sight. A few questions, if you don't mind." She steps back, surprised, clutches her Bible close to her chest as her eyes dart around the church.
34:59 Alice Levine? "Make an appointment in office hours, please, my child." He falls into step as she brushes past him. "Can anyone else access the Horizon system other than the sub-postmasters?" Her jaw tightens. "I will not discuss this to the detriment of my congregation. My office, tomorrow morning, nine sharp." He lets out a sigh as she walks away. At least tomorrow, he'll finally get some answers. Next morning, Ian checks his watch outside her office. It's already gone nine. "Mr. Henderson." He looks up to see a neatly dressed woman.
35:42 Alice Levine? "I'm Allwyn Lyons, Post Office Company Secretary." He watches her tuck a strand of grey hair behind her ears. "Mrs. Venels can't make it, I'm afraid, but I'm here to answer all of your questions." He's sick of this.
35:57 Matt Forde? It's very ironic. I'd actually come to ask questions about the Bible. I asked a post office question as well as at church and all over the place. Can you tell me about transubstantiation?
36:07 Alice Levine? He gets to his feet. When we took on this investigation, we were promised full transparency, assured of full access to senior management. He follows her into her office, tries to keep his voice measured. Is it possible for anyone else to get access to the sub-postmaster's accounts? He watches her neatly fold her hands on the desk. There's no question of remote access, Mr Henderson, it's impossible, we know it can't happen. He holds her gaze. Impossible? She nods. Absolutely. He thanks her for her time, walks out, feels a wave of unease. Her answer was too quick. These people are driving him to distraction.
36:53 Alice Levine? All he and his partner Ron want are straightforward, honest answers. But nobody in this damn organisation seems willing. Weeks of disappearing documents, delays and denials. He's still not seen one shred of hard evidence that Horizon is as foolproof as the post office claims. He marches out, he'll go to Bracknell, to Fujitsu, see the Horizon system for himself. And then he'll decide exactly how foolproof it really is.
37:31 Alice Levine? Later that day, Fujitsu headquarters, Bracknell. Ian holds his breath, signs the visitors' sheet, glances around at the elegant minimalist lobby. He knows he should have made an official appointment to come here today. If they refuse access, then everything he's done so far could be wasted. A few minutes later, a man with a long beard strides towards him.
37:57 Speaker 02 Gareth Jenkins, Horizon engineer.
38:00 Alice Levine? Ian flashes his post office ID, explains he's here to see how Horizon's technical support works.
38:07 Alice Levine? A few seconds later, he steps out of the lift onto the sixth floor, listens politely as Gareth gives him the corporate spiel.
38:14 Speaker 02 Horizon is the biggest non-military computer system in Europe.
38:18 Alice Levine? Ian's heard it all before, but he nods, lets Gareth carry on.
38:23 Speaker 02 2.5 billion transactions processed a year, with a cash value of almost 100 billion. It's the backbone of the whole post office.
38:31 Matt Forde? And the best thing is, it's only meant to be 50 billion. We don't know where the other 50 billion comes from. That magic money.
38:36 Alice Levine? Every transaction doubles. Ian steps into a dark room with dozens of blinking terminals. Thirty, maybe forty people, sit in front of screens full of code or brightly coloured Horizon boxes. He knows he needs to tread carefully, so casually asks: Is maintenance... difficult? Gareth shrugs.
38:57 Speaker 02 Horizon has its fair share of bugs and glitches like any big system.
39:02 Alice Levine? Ian clears his throat. Bugs? What kind of bugs? Ian tenses as Gareth sits in front of a screen.
39:10 Speaker 02 Our team works around the clock patching things up. Watch.
39:13 Alice Levine? Ian stares, heart thumping, as Gareth's hands fly over the keyboard.
39:18 Speaker 02 I'm actually logging into a sub-postmaster's account now.
39:21 Alice Levine? Ian draws in a sharp breath. Are you saying they have no idea you're doing this? Gareth grins.
39:29 Speaker 02 No, it's all... We shut control of the terminal and then we clone the machine. We can change whatever we like. Any numbers, anytime.
39:38 Matt Forde? Right, it's just that I was told there were no problems and people couldn't access it, and it sounds like you're telling me the truth is actually the total, complete polar opposite.
39:46 Alice Levine? And their big sell to get it into people was that only sub-postmasters had access.
39:52 Matt Forde? You are the only people that can access this, apart from Gareth and his mate Stanley Breckel. I'm just thinking I said that bit.
40:00 Alice Levine? Ian's mind races as he stares at the screen. His eyes almost pop as the figures double in front of him. The post office had promised that Horizon was flawless. His mouth opens, but he can't speak. He hears Gareth announce.
40:17 Speaker 02 We're like grand tech wizards up here. We do this day in, day out. Have to, or the system would fail.
40:24 Alice Levine? Ian stares at the multicoloured boxes, the changing figures, and realises with horror. The sub-postmasters were right. This computer system is a patched up mess, fraying at the seams. Even the patches need patching. He hears Olwen Lyons' words ringing in his ears. There's no question of remote access, Mr Henderson. It's impossible. We know it can't happen. His mind races as it hits him. If Horizon doesn't actually work, every single conviction could be flawed. He shakes Gareth's hand, feels his own palms start to sweat as he decides. He won't hold back when he writes his report.
41:07 Alice Levine? He'll describe how the post office obstructed him at every turn. How they denied remote access was possible. He'll put in every detail of what he's seen today. And he'll blow the lid off the whole Horizon system.
41:32 Speaker 06 If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. It's destroying athlete, creator, and YouTube Maxer. YouTube Premium enhances how I use YouTube with awesome features like offline downloads, so I can download my favourite training videos before I hit the gym. So no wifi doesn't turn leg day into loading day. Plus, I get ad-free videos, background play, and so much more. YouTube Premium is like YouTube got some extra gains. Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com/premium.
42:01 Speaker 07 Hey what's up guys, it's Hayley Bailey. Okay, I need to tell you about something. I just got YouTube Premium. It's got tons of awesome features like offline downloads, so I can download my favorite videos before I travel and watch them whenever I don't have wifi. Because we all know airplane wifi is the worst. I get ad-free, I get background play, and there's like a ton more in there. You should try it. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. So try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com/premium. Trial eligibility varies, terms apply, cancel anytime. That's a mouthful.
42:32 Speaker 06 If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. It's destroying athlete, creator, and YouTube Maxer. YouTube Premium enhances how I use YouTube with awesome features like offline downloads, so I can download my favorite training videos before I hit the gym. So no wifi doesn't turn leg day into loading day. Plus, I get ad-free videos, background play, and so much more. YouTube Premium is like YouTube got some extra gains. Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com/premium.
43:01 Speaker 07 Hey what's up guys, it's Hayley Bailey. Okay, I need to tell you about something. I just got YouTube Premium. It's got tons of awesome features like offline downloads, so I can download my favorite videos before I travel and watch them whenever I don't have wifi. Because we all know airplane wifi is the worst. I get ad-free, I get background play, and there's like a ton more in there. You should try it. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. So try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com/premium. Trial eligibility varies, terms apply, cancel anytime. That's a mouthful.
43:38 Alice Levine? 2013, Church of St. Owen, Bromhead. Paula Venables takes the white linen surplus from the hangar, slips it over her head and smooths it over her black cassock. She's performing a baptism today, and she's grateful for the distraction. The past few months have been a nightmare. She's been hounded by the Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance, and by MPs. Second Sight's report is due tomorrow, and it can't come soon enough. Finally, the post office will be given a clean bill of health, and she'll publicize the report to show once and for all that the Horizon system is robust.
44:17 Matt Forde? She obviously doesn't fully appreciate at this stage that the Second Sight report might not be that helpful to her.
44:21 Alice Levine? There's just something so arrogant about it. It's very much of the mindset that I don't even want to know if there's a problem.
44:29 Matt Forde? Yes, and she commissioned Second Sight because they were the cheaper option, not the forensic one. So she probably thinks, I've booked some cheap local guys. They're not going to go into too much detail.
44:39 Alice Levine? That's somebody who doesn't want a thorough audit. A short while later, she picks up the silver pitcher, gently pours water on the baby's head.
44:50 Speaker 02 I baptize you in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.
44:58 Alice Levine? Next morning, Paula sits at her spotless desk when Ian Henderson marches up. He hands her a thick folder. You asked us to be thorough and honest, Mrs Venables. We've been both. She smiles politely. And prompt with it. Thank you. She waits for him to leave and then opens the report. Feels the smile freeze on her face. Her blood runs cold as she reads how Second Sight have found 19 thematic problems. Criminal charges appear to have been motivated primarily by post officers' desire to recover losses. The post office's investigators have, in many cases, failed to identify the underlying root causes
45:42 Alice Levine? of shortfalls prior to the initiation of criminal proceedings. She flicks through the remaining pages in increasing panic, starts to read Henderson's assessment of Horizon. She throws the file across the desk. She can't put this on the website.
45:59 Matt Forde? Who's going to go on that website, anyway?
46:00 Alice Levine? Is it the same website as tracking your parcel? Because if it is, they ain't going to find anything. Don't worry about it.
46:05 Matt Forde? I'm sure Royal Mail would say, we are a separate business. We understand the link. But don't pin this on us. But yes, we can't find your parcel.
46:14 Alice Levine? The sub-postmasters and their MPs will come for her with everything they've got. The whole reputation of the post office will be shredded, and her own career with it.
46:26 Alice Levine? She turns the pearls on her necklace. If Second Sight want a war, they've got one. She'll organise her own report, make an immediate rebuttal of this one. She'll go through every point they make and tear it apart. And destroy their reputation with it.
46:50 Alice Levine? A few months later, a primary school, South Wombra. Jo walks hand in hand with her granddaughter along the brightly painted corridor. A box of fabric under her arm. She steps into the classroom and smiles, but the teacher's face falls. I'm so sorry, Jo. I'm gonna have to ask you to leave. It's your criminal record. You can't be around the kids. Jo feels winded, like she's been punched. Her face burns with humiliation as she realises the whole classroom is silent. She forces a smile. Of course, I understand. She hurries along the corridor and out of the building before she can cry. Outside, her phone vibrates. It's Ian.
47:37 Alice Levine? An hour later, she sits in the pub garden as Ian hands her a glass of wine. His hands are trembling. He looks terrible.
47:45 Matt Forde? You start drinking at lunchtime?
47:47 Alice Levine? It'll do that. I feel like that after a wine at lunch. His face is drained of colour. They've sacked us. The post office are livid with our final report. Even threatened to sue us. Told us they wouldn't stop until we were bankrupt. She gasps and shakes her head. They're lying about Horizon, Jo. It's full of flaws. Bugs that generate false evidence of cash shortfalls. She leans back, feels her jaw slacken. You found proof? He looks at his hands, then back at her. That's not all. They gave us your full legal file by mistake. I saw a note by your auditor, Graham Brander. They had no proof of theft, Jo.
48:32 Alice Levine? They should never have prosecuted you. She stares at him. For a moment, she can't speak, can't breathe. All she can hear is her own blood rushing in her ears. They knew I was innocent. They put me through hell for 10 years. And the whole time, they knew.
48:52 Alice Levine? She hears her voice catch as he nods. She blinks around, tries to take in the enormity of it all, feels her body shake with rage. "They gave me a criminal record for nothing." She grips the side of the rough wooden table. Her world has been shattered by these people. The post office isn't going to get away with this. It might be a vast empire with legions of expensive lawyers, but she's going to make them admit her risen is to blame for all of this. She's not powerless anymore, because now she knows the truth. And with that truth, she will bring them down.
49:46 Alice Levine? From Audible Originals and Samus dot audio, this is the second episode in our series, The Post Office Scandal. A quick note about our dialogue: in most cases, we can't know exactly what was said, but all our dramatizations are based on historical research. British Scandal was hosted by me, Alice Levine.
50:04 Matt Forde? And me, Matt Ford.
50:05 Alice Levine? Written by Karen Laws. Additional writing by Alice Levine and Matt Ford. Our story editor was James Maniac. Sound design by Rich Evans. Our engineer was Jai Williams. For Samus Dat, our series producer was Chica Ayers. Our assistant producer was Louise Mason. Our senior producers were Joe Sykes and Dashalys Itzina. Executive producers for Audible with Theodora Leludis and Estelle Doyle.
50:37 Speaker 08 Dr. Seuss's Cat in the Hat and Fish are back for a whole lot of wonderfully whimsical fun. What happens when you switch bodies with your best friend? Discover a caveman frozen in ice? Or make an alien so angry, he threatens to destroy the planet? Find out in season two of the Cat in the Hat podcast. The cat and fish are traveling the world in the great catastrophic cacophony cruiser, meeting genies, clown professors, cave trolls, and extraordinary characters along the way. With clever wordplay, imaginative rhymes, original songs, and stories celebrating curiosity, empathy, and creative problem solving, every adventure brings something new to discover.
51:20 Speaker 08 It's a world of wonderful words, big imaginations, and plenty of heart for the whole family. Listen to the Cat in the Hat podcast wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge all 20 episodes early and ad-free right now.
51:37 Speaker 09 A trucker merges onto the I-10 in New Orleans. He checks his mirrors. The lane is clear. And then, boom, impact. A pickup truck, seemingly out of nowhere, scrapes down the side of his 18-wheeler, multiple passengers inside. One man flees the scene. And the driver of the pickup? He doesn't seem all that upset. It didn't feel like a regular accident, because it wasn't. Across the city, truckers are getting sideswiped, all on the same stretch of the same freeway. And behind many of the cases is one person, a Hollywood stunt woman turned personal injury lawyer named Vanessa Moda. This podcast is a story about fake accidents that lead to real consequences and a scheme that ends in betrayal and murder.
52:22 Speaker 09 Listen to Over My Dead Body: Operation Sideswipe wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge all episodes early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Previous The Post Office Scandal | A New Horizon | 1 Next The Post Office Scandal | The Clarke Advice | 3 Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated