Pod Insights The Brand Called You Bridging East and West: A Journey Through Comparative Religions | Come Carpentier de Gourdon, Distinguished Fellow, India Foundation, Convener, World Affairs About this episode Join Come Carpentier de Gourdon, Distinguished Fellow at India Foundation, as he delves into the deep connections between Eastern and Western religious philosophies. From the ancient wisdom of the Vedas and Upanishads to modern existential dilemmas, this conversation offers fresh perspectives on karma, reincarnation, monotheism vs. polytheism, and how Indian thought can address today’s challenges. Carpentier sheds light on the significance of Advaita, unity in diversity, and the enduring impact of Indian philosophical traditions on Western intellectualism. 00:40- About Come Carpentier de Gourdon Come is a distinguished fellow of the India Foundation. He's a convener of world affairs of the Journal of International Issues. He's the author of a book titled From India to Infinity, and also of a book titled Memories of 101 Moons. And of course, he's got many, many more publications.
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Welcome to another episode of The Brand Called You, a podcast and podcast show that brings you leadership lessons, knowledge, experience and wisdom from thousands of successful individuals from around the world. I am your host, Ashutosh Gargi. And today, I'm privileged to welcome a very accomplished individual who has chosen to make India his home from New Delhi, India, Mr. Kom Carpenter Dugordon. Kom, welcome to the show.
0:35 Speaker 01 Thank you very much for inviting me and good morning to you.
0:39 Speaker 00 Thank you. Kom is a distinguished fellow of the India Foundation. He's a convener, World Affairs of the Journal of International Issues. He's an author of a book titled From India to Infinity and also of a book titled Memories of 101 Moons. And of course, he's got many, many more publications. So Kom, before we get into religions, tell me about your journey and what got you interested in comparative religions, endology and a whole lot of other life forms.
1:12 Speaker 01 It runs in the family. On the father's side, we were settled in North Africa, Algeria, Morocco for well over 100 years. And my grandfather spoke fluent Arabic and my father was an Orientalist as well as a sociologist. And he wrote three books on North African societies, history and the influence of Islam and the West on North Africa. So very young, when I began to read all sorts of books on Oriental and Western religions and philosophies. And when I was
1:57 Speaker 01 about 14, my father and I decided jointly in Spain, when we were living at the time, that we would travel to the east to India on the road by car and we would spend
2:10 Speaker 01 In time in India studying the ancient philosophies and the civilizations. Uh my father was uh particularly interested in Taoism and Buddhism. Uh Hinduism came later in his uh field of view. But uh I was definitely an avid reader of all the books that were in the little institute. That uh had created in Barcelona.
2:33 Speaker 00 Right. Very interesting. So now let's talk about comparative religions. Uh of course, what in your view are some of the fundamental philosophical differences between eastern and western religious traditions?
2:49 Speaker 01 First, I think the separation or the distinction is somewhat artificial, because as you know. Uh the West nowadays is dominated by what we might call Semitic religions, uh which are uh eastern. And uh you might more accurately want to talk about uh the so-called modern perspective on life, which emerged. Primarily in the seventeenth century in the West, maybe beginning in the sixteenth century with the Renaissance. Uh but particularly with the advent of what is called enlightenment. As opposed to the other civilizations of the world, which have a continuity since Neolithic times. And that is perhaps the main difference you can establish.
3:33 Speaker 01 Between uh what we now call the the West, the modern West, and the rest of the world, including India. Uh which perhaps has kept more than any other civilization. Uh its original features. Uh India is like a uh series of layers of superposed. Uh culture and also scientific investigation that has not destroyed. The foundations of its uh culture. It has kept it. And that's why you see uh today in India remnants of what you might call Neolithic uh religious practices. Together with the most modern science and also the most advanced philosophy, metaphysics and psychology.
4:17 Speaker 00 Very interesting.
4:17 Speaker 01 That sense, the West has often carried out destruction of its previous
4:25 Speaker 01 stages of evolution in order to reach a sort of a relatively homogeneous, so-called Enlightenment modern secular civilization. Of course, it's by no means all-encompassing. You still have a lot of ancient traits in Western cultures, but they are far less accepted and far less common than they are in the East and particularly in India.
4:50 Speaker 00 Hmm, very interesting. And Kome, how do you interpret the convergence and divergence of monotheistic and polytheistic religion?
5:00 Speaker 01 If you look at the history of monotheism, it's a fairly late terminology. You realize that it began by what is called by scholars heterotheism, which means the idea that there is a superior god who rules over the others. And that is essentially the history of the Bible, because the Hebrew religion, which is considered the foundation of the three great monotheistic religions, is in fact originally a branch of the greater Semitic Near and Middle East tradition, which encompasses, you know, the Babylonian, the Calvian, the Sumerian and the Arabic cultures.
5:43 Speaker 01 So out of that, what you have had gradually is the formation of a sort of an exclusive creed that established the supremacy and then the sole existence of one god, called by generally Hebrew or a later Greek or Latin name. And as a result, other beliefs, other traditions, other gods were excluded or forgotten. However, we all know that this has never been entirely the case because Christianity. He's full of angels and saints. Who are in a way gods, in a different, under a different name.
6:25 Speaker 01 And so is the case to a lesser extent, but so is the case with Islam too. Of course, especially with Shia Islam, which has kept a lot of features of the previous Persian, Zoroastrian culture, tradition. And in the case of Judaism, you have the same thing if you look at the esoteric Judaism, where you realize that there is one superior god, but there are all sorts of other things happening. And therefore, I would say that monotheism is a fairly artificial construct, which has never really been in practice universally. And if I might say so, if it is taken literally, it is very limiting and it can lead also to great violence. Of course, in human affairs, many things can lead to violence.
7:04 Speaker 00 Correct.
7:05 Speaker 01 If you look at what's happening in the Near East nowadays, you realize that monotheism has some role to play in that. And unfortunately, the exclusivism, which gives God certain specific intentions, such as God gave us this land. You know, and obviously, God is not giving anybody any land.
7:23 Speaker 00 Correct.
7:23 Speaker 01 It's just a human concept. You look at nature and if you look at the universal spirit, at Brahman, or any other name, Ishvara, you realize that the divine is the source of all things, but does not impose anything. It's all sorts of other creatures or creations that are at the root of everything that we know, see or feel. And that is why, very rightly, in India, a number of different powers are worshiped. They are psychological and spiritual powers, they are also natural powers, but they all have their place.
8:00 Speaker 00 Hmm, great response. And I'd also like to get your perspective on the notion of karma in Hinduism. And does this really compare with the concept of sin and redemption in Christianity?
8:17 Speaker 01 Originally, yes, insofar as you are your deeds. You are also more than your deeds, your actions, but clearly your actions shape you and shape your destiny.
8:32 Speaker 00 Right.
8:32 Speaker 01 Karma has a more scientific explanation because it is an accumulation of capital or on the contrary, an accumulation of debt. And debt has to be repaid and capital has to be spent, but wisely so. Otherwise, it is lost and you are back in debt again.
8:51 Speaker 00 Right.
8:51 Speaker 01 Of sin and redemption, we have a much more personalistic interpretation because sin offends God according to the, I'd say, the official interpretation, the theology. And on the contrary, redemption is a gift that comes from God when he makes himself into a man. Of course, that's a Christian interpretation. In Islam, it's different. And Judaism does not really accept redemption in that sense, you know. So there you have very different and also historically determined versions of things.
9:28 Speaker 01 But I believe originally karma probably seeded the explanation given in other religions because there is no question that it's a very, very ancient acceptance that you have to pay the price for what you have done wrong and you also will collect benefits from what you did right.
9:52 Speaker 00 Correct. Well said. And Kom, how do religious philosophies address the concept of afterlife? And what are some of the implications on cultural practices?
10:06 Speaker 01 Throughout history, the mystery of death has been paramount in the human mind.
10:14 Speaker 01 And therefore, many, many interpretations have been given, but they generally amount to, they can be put into two or three categories. The first is, of course, that you somehow have to earn enough during this life in terms of merit to ascend to a much more blissful and peaceful state. Whether it's in the company of God or whether it is in some sort of netherworld. Technically, you are either punished or rewarded. And that is one of the most fundamental explanations given by religions, all than you.
10:54 Speaker 01 Then, of course, you have the equally ancient notion of reincarnation or metamorphosis under various names, which means that there is a stream of consciousness that moves from body to body. And that purifies itself, or on the contrary, demeans itself. And therefore, according to that, it reincarnates or it inhabits either ever more perfected and virtuous beings. Or on, sorry, it falls lower and lower in the scale of evolution, in the ladder of evolution, and then ends up in what we consider to be lower forms of life.
11:33 Speaker 01 Now, this, of course, is the Indian version, broadly speaking, but you find it in many other cultures with a number of varieties. And then, of course, the third version is the one that generally modern secular society subscribe to, which is agnostic, we don't know. And probably nothing happens, and once the body dies, everything disappears, and that's the end of it. Now, in terms of the laws of preservation, conservation of energy, that doesn't seem to make a lot of sense, because technically, if there is such a thing as intelligent life, then, and life obviously propagates itself and is everywhere that we can see, then there should be something that remains and that carries on.
12:17 Speaker 01 And that's why generally even many scientists today accept that there is a possibility of something that... That could be interpreted in more spiritual or philosophical terms as reincarnation. In other words, the pursuance, the accumulation and then the transmission of a certain capital of information and glances, knowledge, intelligence, wisdom, that somehow is never lost, because we all know now that the so-called zero-point field in the universe.
12:45 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:45 Speaker 01 Is an accumulation of all the experience gathered by all forms of life throughout the universe. Therefore, it's like a sort of a giant data bank, if you want to take it in the, you know, terms of modern science.
12:57 Speaker 00 Amazing. Thank you. What a great response. So now let's talk a little bit about Indology and Indian philosophical thought, which you have very deep knowledge of. Come, what are the key philosophical contributions of the Vedic and Upanishad, Upanishadic texts in modern thought?
13:14 Speaker 01 They are multiple and they are also fairly ancient, because right from the, let's say, the, again, the age of enlightenment or even earlier, you had some transmission of philosophical concepts from India and China and other similar cultures to the West, to Europe and then to America, of course. And by and large, the wisdom that was recovered in those messages of spirituality were very precious to the West, because they now enabled many Western intellectuals and spiritual seekers
13:55 Speaker 01 to break out of what I would call, perhaps a little severely, the prison of Semitic religious absolutism. Since that they were able to look at the different perspective on life, on humanity, on the nature of God, on the nature of spirit. And as a result, you saw that there was no longer this absolute reliance on the so-called.
14:22 Speaker 01 You know, sort of God's predilection for a certain kind of belief system and for certain kinds of people, by which I mean the supremacy of either the Jews or the Christians or the Muslims. Because they have the right faith, the right God, and others were still looking for him or for it. And that, of course, was not tenable in the long run. And we see today that even among Christians, there is a great deal of questioning and doubt, and even the Pope has said, you know, all religions may be seen as equivalent. I mean, that's a very difficult thing to explain, because you can't say all religions are the same. It's not true. And you can't say all religions are equal, because
15:03 Speaker 01 that's also rather meaningless, because equality means identity. And so you would just have to say that they are different paths, which is something that has been explained in many spiritual treatises, beginning with Upanishads, and then you find that among the Sufis too, with the Masnavi of Rumi and many other texts. So clearly, the Upanishads have provided an ability to connect scientific inquiry to philosophical speculation, because Upanishads do both, just like the Vedas do in their own way. And the very fact that in some of the Sukkhas of the Rigveda, in Sadia, you have questions about who really created all this, and does he even know how he created it?
15:47 Speaker 01 And perhaps he didn't even create it, you know, perhaps it was forever existed. So these have been enormously useful vistas for physics, for biology, for chemistry, and they have enabled the Western science to free itself from the dogma that, for example, God created the universe 6,000 years ago. And therefore, everything has to be encapsulated within that, which is obviously impossible from a scientific perspective.
16:13 Speaker 00 Fascinating.
16:14 Speaker 01 You can see the liberation that Indian philosophical insights have brought to the world.
16:21 Speaker 00 Very well said. Can you also, for my viewers and listeners, talk a little bit about the role of non-duality or Advait in shaping Indian metaphysical thought?
16:35 Speaker 01 Advaita is today seen as the crowning achievement of Indian philosophical investigations. And as we all know, it's not by any means the soul, or even perhaps the dominant interpretation that India has given in terms of understanding the nature of reality. However, its merit is of course clarity and absolute definiteness about the way things are and yet are not. So, the unification of being and the non-being is a very ancient aphorism that you find both in China,
17:20 Speaker 01 not only in China and India, but in many other spiritual teachings. And that is something which of course in the West has been seen as the ultimate paradox or inconsistency, because it's either something is or is not. However, we all know now in physiologic and we know in quantum computing and quantum physics itself, that there is no such thing as mutually exclusive being and non-being, or yes and no. You see, things are both and the opposite, and they are neither. So, that is something which has been the supreme achievement perhaps of Advaita. It is not unique to Advaita because Buddhism, especially Mahayana Buddhism, has spelt out the same things in a different way.
18:03 Speaker 01 But in the case of, there is also the great consolation that Advaita brings, because it essentially enables people to rise above the suffering and the disappointments of life by showing that you do not have to regard it as something that's really happening. In fact, you should not. You are the observer. And there are many scriptures that explain to you how, as the observer, you are able to play the game, to enjoy it, but without ever confusing what you are with what is being done by something that you believe to be you.
18:44 Speaker 00 Fascinating. So, time for two or three more questions for you, Cole. In what ways do you think Indian philosophy can contribute to resolving modern existential and ethical dilemmas?
19:00 Speaker 01 People generally would refer to the Bhagavad Gita, but there is also the Ashhtavak Raghita, which says similar things. In other words, the ability to follow a moral code, to have a moral compass, is fundamental in any event, simply because according to the very law of karma, it is what gives you the best chances to improve yourself, improve others around you, and therefore, collect the fruit, although we all know that we should not do it for the results, but simply for the very benefit of it. I mean, in other words, there is a sort of detachment, not only from action,
19:45 Speaker 01 but from the results of the action. So, that is something which one makes you an arbiter of what you do, and you do not have to be constantly trying to please a vengeful and jealous god, who is watching you from above. Rather, you do it for your own self, which includes everything in the universe. And that understanding and acceptance of the law of nature, and attempt to harmonize yourself with the law of nature, is probably the most optimistic and the most comforting way of achieving a well-lived life, you know, a sort of a what everybody talks about, which is the life well-lived.
20:27 Speaker 00 Correct. Two more questions for you. What lessons can contemporary societies learn from the Indian philosophical concept of unity in diversity?
20:40 Speaker 01 Nowadays, this is a very common and widespread ideal. You know, let's have unity in diversity, simply because a lot of societies tried to be far too homogeneous in the past, and found themselves to be in a uncomfortable state as a result. So, now, the focus on diversity is something that in India is part of life because of the very nature of Indian society, because of its...
21:09 Speaker 01 And of course, it's not an easy thing to achieve because within diversity, there has to be a common respect for fundamental law. And at the base of it, you have the laws of nature. And of course, in India, as in many other countries, you also hear about respect for the constitution, for example, which is only an attempt to reflect the laws of nature, or the spiritual laws, if you prefer, in a legal framework that people can understand or apply in a more rigorous way, through the interpretation of experts, of scholars. So that itself shows that there are limits to freedom, inevitably. And therefore, diversity cannot be a mix of everything and its opposite.
21:51 Speaker 01 Although in the end, it can be that way, but there is to, there has to be a continuous attempt to bring all things together around a common goal, a common focus. And that's the role of the four ashramas, the parashramas, and the role of moksha as a common goal, as a supreme objective. And in order to reach moksha, then you have to have artha. And artha itself depends on dharma. We all know that is that concatenation of the four goals of life. So in the West and in other parts of the world, there are equivalent terms to define this rule. The mistake we are making today is by trying to promote diversity without any kind of moral
22:36 Speaker 01 or ethical guidelines, is that we are creating an increasingly chaotic and also violent society in which often the worst elements impose their will. And people are supposed to accept that because it's part of diversity. And I can give several examples. We see a lot of that in the United States. We see a lot of that in Europe nowadays. And those societies in the name of freedom are in fact becoming more and more restrictive and dictatorial in many ways, which shows that they have taken the wrong path to unity and diversity.
23:08 Speaker 00 Correct. Well said. And my last question for you. Kom, how do you interpret the influence of Indian thought on Western intellectual traditions, particularly during the colonial and post-colonial periods?
23:25 Speaker 01 That's such a long
23:29 Speaker 01 quite an answer to be given. I did not attempt to do that, but if you look at the way that the first Orientalists who came to, let's say, India, they obviously were fascinated. They were sometimes repelled because of their prejudices, particularly, of course, the Christian prejudices about idolatry and such other things. But by and large, they, those who were the better prepared ones and who had the most open minds, they realized that they were reconnecting with a fundamental and primary
24:09 Speaker 01 form of civilization that had kept secrets that had been either forgotten or misinterpreted in their own homelands. So the discovery of that primary truth, you know, what came to be known as the perennial philosophy in the 20th century, late 19th century, that was something that opened many doors and also allowed for a truer and more accurate representation or interpretation of the basic teachings that evolved into Christianity. As a result of which, you had a whole school of esoteric universalist philosophy
24:54 Speaker 01 that produced a number of great philosophers. One of the earliest, of course, was Chopin our, although his sources were not particularly accurate as far as Indian philosophy was concerned, you only had access to some very poor translations. But still, he got part of it right. And then after him, you had much more, much better informed and much more.
25:18 Speaker 01 I would say expert thinkers who were able to revive and bring to light some Indian texts that had been forgotten even in India and the same can be said about China, the same can be about other parts of the East.
25:31 Speaker 00 Right.
25:32 Speaker 01 So the result of the interaction between East and West, you had the sort of universalization of some texts which had become a bit too esoteric and abstruse and which were confined perhaps to very small schools of thinkers.
25:46 Speaker 00 Hmm.
25:46 Speaker 01 And as a result, you have the full expansion worldwide of the philosophy of yoga, of Vedanta and of Buddhist Mahayana philosophy, which were barely known to anybody until about, let's say, a hundred years ago. And now you have thousands and millions of people who are actually living by those guidelines and who are practicing this teaching in as far as, as well as they can.
26:12 Speaker 00 Hmm, great response. And on that note, Cole, I mean, you know, I could just keep on listening to the amazing amount of knowledge that you have, but given my time constraints, maybe I'm going to ask you for another conversation in a few months from now. But thank you so much for talking to me about your own journey and what you and your father started off as a journey to discover so many different religions in India and you are now the guru. Thank you for speaking to me about comparative religions. I think you gave some really deep insights into the eastern, western, and I think this is where the world needs to head towards because at the end of the day, it's only
26:53 Speaker 00 the context in which we interpret different books, but there is only one superpower. Thank you also for sparking, speaking to me about Indology, Indian philosophical thought and so many different associations that different parts of the world could have with a lot of the Indian scriptures that we have in our country. Thank you again for speaking to me and good luck to you.
27:19 Speaker 01 Thank you very much. Nice talking to you.
27:21 Speaker 00 Thank you.
27:24 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to the brand called You Videocast and Podcast, a platform that brings you knowledge, experience and wisdom of hundreds of successful individuals from around the world. Do visit our website.
27:38 Speaker 02 www.tbcy.in to watch and listen to the stories of many more individuals. You can also follow us on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. Just search for the brand called you.
Previous Balancing Care and Accountability in Leadership | Joris Merks-Benjaminsen, Trainer for Managers and Leaders; Author, 'Managing Without Power' Next Empowering India's Tribal Artisans | Shweta Menon, Founder & MD, Truly Tribal Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated