Pod Insights Betwixt The Sheets: The History of Sex, Scandal & Society History's Worst F*ckboys: Raphael About this episode The Renaissance is known for its heady combination of sex, art and exciting new ideas about the world.
Was Raphael, one of the superstar painters of the period, a Renaissance top shagger? Were sex workers essential to the artistic process of painting nudes? Why did historians think he died from having too much sex?
Joining Kate today is the wonderful professor and author, Jill Burke, to help us get to know this man better.
This episode was edited by Tim Arstall and produced by Stuart Beckwith. The senior producer is Charlotte Long.
Please vote for us for Listeners' Choice at the British Podcast Awards! Follow this link https://www.britishpodcastawards.com/voting - https://www.britishpodcastawards.com/voting - and don’t forget to confirm the email. Thank you!
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK.
All music from Epidemic Sounds.
Betwixt the Sheets: History of Sex, Scandal & Society is a History Hit podcast.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards! UK & Ireland listeners please place your vote on the Spotify mobile app here: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 7,026 words · 10 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Kate Lister? Do you want even more shocking and scandalous history? Like why the ancient Greek statues had such small manhoods? Or what went on behind closed doors in the Georgian era? Well, sign up to History Hit, where you can see me discover the scandalous side of history, as well as hundreds of hours of original documentaries, plus new releases every week, covering everything from prehistoric Scotland to the Treaty of Versailles. Sign up to join me in locations around the world and explore the past. Just visit historyhit.com/subscribe.
0:37 Speaker 01 This is Steve Covino from Covino and Rich. Quick trivia, fellas. Every guy listening is a contestant. Answer honestly to yourself. You got a belly and a little chest? Gassed by the afternoon, no drive left in the tank? You lack that confidence and mental edge? Those are classic signs that your testosterone's been sliding. And nothing drags it down faster than extra weight. So why not take matters into your own hands? Strip off the weight that tanks your testosterone with Bioma GLP-1 Booster. Every serving is packed with science-backed ingredients that crank up your natural GLP-1 production. Visit bioma.health/GLP1 and use code CRSHOW for 15% off your first order.
1:17 Speaker 02 In Our Time is a world-class seminar every week. Why was Jeremy a lonely snail? What were lines doing in York in the third century? I'm Misha Glennie, and every week I'm joined by expert guests to explore the ideas that shape our world.
1:32 Speaker 03 It's one of the first times, really, that you consistently see someone painting teeth. I know that sounds bonkers.
1:36 Speaker 04 If I was going to define mathematics, I would say it's the study of structure.
1:40 Speaker 02 In Our Time, listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Tea or coffee? Love a cup of tea.
1:50 Kate Lister? Hello, my lovely Bedtwisters. It's me, Kate Lester. You are listening to Bedtwister Sheets. And thank [bleep] you are, quite frankly, because without you, this is just nothing at all. But before we can go any further together, I do have to tell you once again, and I will tell you from now until the time that we are cancelled, this is an adult podcast spoken by adults, other adults about adulty things, and an adulty way of arranging adult subjects and used to be an adult too. We call that the fair do's warning, because if you keep listening, you happen to get upset, well, fair do's, we did tell you. Right, on with the show.
2:21 Kate Lister? It's the early 16th century in Rome and I have just snuck my way into Raphael's workshop while everyone's out for lunch to see if I can find any clues about the naughty goings on that I have heard go on here. Let's see, hmm. Hmm, searching amongst the easels and boxes of paints, what do we have? A few nude sketches, well that's not too bad, I suppose. I can certainly see why Michelangelo had a bee in his bonnet about this. Raphael is talented. But still, I'm looking for something saucier and I heard a rumour about a local baker's daughter, who apparently Raphael has been having his wicked way with. If the rumours are to be believed, she was just one of many.
3:05 Kate Lister? So, we're gonna have to dig a little bit deeper if we wanna find out if Raphael really was a Renaissance fuckboy. But let's get out of here before they come back.
3:17 Speaker 05 What are you, a funny man?
3:18 Speaker 06 Oh, money, of course.
3:20 Speaker 05 You're supposed to rise when an adult speaks to you.
3:22 Speaker 06 I make perfect copies of whatever my boss needs by just turning a knob and pushing it.
3:35 Speaker 05 Yes, social courtesy does make a difference.
3:37 Speaker 07 Goodness, I feel for them. Goodness has nothing to do with it, darling.
3:46 Kate Lister? Hello and welcome back to Betwixt the Sheets: History of Sex Scandal in Society with me, Kate Lister. If you listened last week, you will know that hurrah, our mini-series on history's worst fuckboys is back. And we kicked it off by looking at top shagger Charles II. And this week, we have esteemed Renaissance artist Raphael. And we're gonna find out how he measures up. And joining me today is none other than the marvellous Professor Jill Burke, author of How to Be a Renaissance Woman. And she's gonna take us back to the 16th century to see if this man lived up to his reputation. And whilst I have you, you know that I have to ask this of you, so do forgive me, but please, please, please, would you vote for us for the Listers' Choice Award at this year's British Podcast Award?
4:29 Kate Lister? We're actually in the top 10 now. We're in the top 10. We could actually take this. I don't even want to get my hopes up. I don't think I can cope with the pressure, but my fate is in your hands, dear listener. Right, the link is in the show notes for this episode. It takes two seconds, about the amount of time that a fuckboy would have with you. So if you can do it, I will love you forever. Now that sounds like a fuckboy line. Right, let's get back to Raphael.
4:54 Kate Lister? Hello and welcome back to Betwigs the Sheets. It's only Jill Burke. How are you doing?
5:00 Speaker 08 I am so well and so happy to be here.
5:03 Kate Lister? Thank God you are.
5:04 Speaker 08 I know. I might have invited me back.
5:06 Kate Lister? I had so much fun talking to you about pubic hair and about Renaissance beauty standards, though.
5:11 Speaker 08 Yeah, I mean, we might get some pubic hair in this.
5:14 Kate Lister? We might get some pubic hair.
5:17 Speaker 08 Yeah, it's always a possibility.
5:18 Kate Lister? Let's see where we go with this because this is another installment in our little mini series on history's worst fuckboys. And today we're looking at Raphael. And before we even get on to him, it occurred to me that if I met someone today called Raphael, my first thought would be fuckboy. I wouldn't even need him to speak. I'd just be like, oh, I bet you write poetry and I bet you go to India to find yourself and I bet you pretend to read Simone de Beauvoir, don't you? That's.
5:43 Speaker 08 I think there's a lot to say. I don't know. I quite like Raphael.
5:47 Kate Lister? It's a good name, isn't it?
5:48 Speaker 08 Yeah. I mean, Raphael, to date, it feels like someone who would be a bit like, oh, you know.
5:52 Kate Lister? Hi, I'm Raphael.
5:54 Speaker 08 Hi.
5:56 Speaker 08 Reads poetry on the tube, as you say, and really likes women.
5:58 Kate Lister? Yes, I like to think of myself as a feminist. That's. But the real Raphael. Do you have a bit of a soft spot for him? Because my producer, Stu, has got a bit of a soft spot for him. We were just talking before this. He went, I think he's quite nice, Kate. So I don't know how this one's gonna go.
6:14 Speaker 08 Yeah, he was lovely.
6:16 Kate Lister? He's lovely. Oh.
6:18 Speaker 08 I mean, he was notoriously, in the Renaissance, people thought of him as someone who was a bit of a shagger. He was kind of distracted by women, but he was just really charming. People liked to be around him. You know, compared to like the other Renaissance big boys like Leonardo, Michelangelo. I mean, Leonardo was very difficult to pin down and he was kind of charming in his own way, but never finished anything. It was really frustrating. Michelangelo was just this incredibly grumpy, sarcastic, scary person.
6:50 Speaker 08 And you get the sense that Raphael was just utterly charming. He was really lovely.
6:55 Kate Lister? They always are though, Jill, that's the problem. So let me give you a definition because fuckboy is not in the Oxford English Dictionary, I checked. So they need to update their terms, quite frankly. So we're going to have to use Urban Dictionary and they have got it as a boy who plays with girls' feelings and doesn't really like them and would say anything a girl wanted to hear in order to have sex with her or to get something from her. So that's our definition.
7:18 Speaker 08 Well, I mean, he could be in that crowd of fuckboys, I suppose. He was betrothed to someone for a very long time. So he never got married to her and he was betrothed to her just because it was like politically expedient. So maybe.
7:32 Kate Lister? Maybe, maybe. Before we even get to his betrothal, I want to hear a bit of an origin story about Raphael because I honestly don't know very much about him. He just seems to have leapt fully formed onto the Renaissance stage with a paintbrush. But where did he come from?
7:45 Speaker 08 So he was from Urbino, which was a court town, very sophisticated town, court culture in northern Italy. His dad was a painter.
7:54 Kate Lister? Nepo baby.
7:55 Speaker 08 Yeah, exactly. And he was one of these annoyingly kind of prodigious youths. He was like really good from a very early age, which is unnecessary, but he was. And he worked with an artist called Perugino. He does really sweet looking Madonnas, he's really charming painter and he really painted a lot like Perugino in his youth. And then after he'd done his training and everything and done some really great paintings in Urbino, he moved to Florence in fifteen oh four. And this was a time when Florence was like the place, if you wanted to be a painter. And Michelangelo's there, Leonardo da Vinci was there, they were painting up a storm and Raphael went and he just was looking at all these
8:37 Speaker 08 sculptures and all these paintings by all these amazing Florentine artists. And he basically just absorbed everything he knew. And by the time he left Florence four years later, he was really starting to be famous all over Italy. And he could basically mimic the style of Michelangelo, took in those styles, he took in everything he thought was good. And then in fifteen oh eight, he moved to Rome to paint a series of rooms in the Vatican, known often by the Italian name, the Vatican Stanze, while Pope Julius II.
9:04 Kate Lister? How old was he then, when he's doing this?
9:06 Speaker 08 I'm gonna have to do maths now.
9:08 Kate Lister? Okay, sorry, sorry.
9:10 Speaker 08 He was in his twenties.
9:11 Kate Lister? Jesus, though, like, that's impressive.
9:14 Speaker 08 He's a massively impressive person, Raphael.
9:18 Speaker 08 He really was interested in how you communicate stories in these rooms. And so he was really good at kind of telling the narrative history of things like the School of Athens, for example, which is a story about philosophy. It's a representation of philosophy which shows Plato and Aristotle at the centre and various philosophers arranged about them. And it's a really beautiful way of expressing ideas and the way that people communicate. And he did that all the way through the Vatican, St. Anthony, with a lot of different stories. And he became incredibly popular. And because of that, he ran a big workshop, which seemed to be really happy working together. This is another reason why he's actually seems to be quite a nice guy. He works closely with his pupils, Giulio Romano and Marco Antonio Remondi. He prints a lot of his work.
10:02 Speaker 08 And so he started to become famous well beyond Italy, around Europe. And then he stays in Rome, doing all this work, very, very busy. And then he dies very young. So he dies in fifteen twenty, when he's only thirty seven years old.
10:15 Kate Lister? Whoa, I thought he got to be older than that.
10:18 Speaker 08 Nope.
10:19 Kate Lister? Oh, as a Renaissance scholar, do you not ever think that it's so bizarre that Michelangelo, Raphael and Leonardo da Vinci were all knocking around at the same time in the same city?
10:32 Speaker 08 Yeah, yeah, yeah. And Michelangelo particularly really hated Raphael.
10:36 Kate Lister? Oh, did he? Why did he? Oh, go on, give me the gossip, give me the gossip. Why did he hate him?
10:40 Speaker 08 Because he was really good at painting.
10:42 Kate Lister? That'll do it. So it's professional jealousy.
10:46 Speaker 08 What can you say? So Michelangelo was a really difficult person. And after Raphael died, he was still painting these rooms in the Vatican when he died. And there was a room called the Room of Constantine that was up for grabs, really. And Michelangelo wanted to get his friend, Sebastiano del Piombo, to paint it. And he wrote to the Pope. And he wrote a really sarky letter, saying that, basically comparing them to capons, which are like castrated chickens, the Raphael boys. And saying they're like, not like proper boys.
11:16 Kate Lister? Like a bitchy old queen, isn't he, quite frankly?
11:17 Speaker 08 Really, absolutely. The Pope at that time, one of the Medici Popes says, you know, Raphael just copied everything from you, Michelangelo. Don't worry about it. We know you're the better artist. But then, at the same time, kind of shuffled Michelangelo off to Florence, so he didn't have to deal with it anymore. He's a real tricky character.
11:33 Kate Lister? Is there any truth in that, that he copied some of Michelangelo's work? Or was that just being said to just soothe the damaged ego?
11:40 Speaker 08 He directly copied Michelangelo's work, yeah. So, um, I mean, he, he, he copied it into drawings, but then kind of assimilated it into his own style. He went into the Sistine Chapel before it was finished and drew after figures in the Sistine Chapel ceiling that Michelangelo was doing. That was 1508 as well, so.
11:56 Kate Lister? See, that would piss me off. Would that piss you off if you were doing these amazing paintings and this just young kid comes along and starts just ripping off your work? Was that the done thing?
12:05 Speaker 08 It was a done thing within workshops to copy, you know, to work in a workshop style. But Raphael was a bit of a kind of intellectual magpie. And so you'd take whatever he thought was best, which at that time was Leonardo da Vinci, was Michelangelo. And he'd kind of incorporate it into his own style. And I can totally see if he was.
12:24 Kate Lister? Like Aldi.
12:24 Speaker 08 Yeah, like Aldi, yeah. Exactly. Here's the Aldi renaissance art.
12:31 Speaker 08 But what really annoyed Michelangelo is that he managed to incorporate this, but still make it his own and still be really, really good.
12:39 Kate Lister? Yeah, it's much worse than that. He is copying him, but he's actually using his work and making it better. That's even more irritating.
12:46 Speaker 08 Yeah, it's really irritating. And he also just had the court thing down pat. He was charming, he got on well with people, he joked with people, everyone liked him being around. So he was young, charming and talented. So you can see why people didn't like him.
13:06 Kate Lister? So then why has my producer suggested Raphael for this series? Because he sounds utterly delightful so far.
13:12 Speaker 08 Well, he did do quite a lot of shagging around, probably.
13:17 Kate Lister? There we go. Okay, let's talk about that.
13:21 Speaker 08 So, Vizzari says that the reason he died when he did so young is partly because of overwork, but partly because he exhausted himself through having too many lovers. So there is.
13:35 Speaker 08 So it's an excess of sex.
13:36 Kate Lister? You can't die from too much sex, can you? Can you?
13:39 Speaker 08 Well, I used to think that. I mean, no.
13:41 Kate Lister? No, no.
13:42 Speaker 08 No.
13:43 Kate Lister? Bonnie Blue's still going, he'd be fine.
13:46 Speaker 08 But they used to think that it weakened your constitution. If you have too much sex.
13:50 Kate Lister? Oh, I see.
13:52 Speaker 08 Having sex in the Renaissance, particularly for men involved, involved evacuation.
13:56 Kate Lister? Yeah.
13:57 Speaker 08 And the more you evacuate, the more heat you lose from the body. So if you have too much sex, it can make you very weak.
14:03 Kate Lister? Yes, they did think this, didn't they?
14:05 Speaker 08 They did think this.
14:07 Kate Lister? Because sperm is so special and magical.
14:09 Speaker 08 Yes. Doctors would advise you not to have too much sex, not to indulge yourself in too much cannibal activity. Because they really did think it would make you ill. And so Raphael, I mean, Vazari was writing in fifteen fifty, he was published in fifteen fifty. So that was thirty years after Raphael's death.
14:26 Kate Lister? Well, how does he know then?
14:27 Speaker 08 Gossip. I mean, he knew people who knew Raphael.
14:31 Kate Lister? Thirty years after you've died, people are still going, yeah, Top Shagger. That's, I mean, like hundreds of years after you've died. Do we know anything about his sex life?
14:41 Speaker 08 Hmm. Sex life is really hard to say directly. We do know that it was out of his workshop. So one of the things, we might get back to pubic hair. One of the things that Raphael did do was really start having a lot of female nude models. So there were a few female naked models, like life models before Raphael, but Raphael moved to Rome. And in the Rome that Raphael moved to, there's a load of people who, basically a load of men, who are working for the church and want to get advancement, promotion within the church. And that means they cannot get married, right? Because it's a Catholic church, you can't get married. Like, you're not meant to, you can't get married and be in holy orders.
15:23 Speaker 08 That means that Rome is full of single men in the late fifteen thirty six century. And that also means that Rome is full of sex workers.
15:31 Kate Lister? Of course it does.
15:32 Speaker 08 Yeah.
15:32 Kate Lister? Supply and demand.
15:33 Speaker 08 Supply and demand. So they reckon that there's about ten percent of the population are sex workers in Rome.
15:39 Kate Lister? Wow.
15:40 Speaker 08 Yeah.
15:40 Kate Lister? That is significant.
15:41 Speaker 08 I mean, it's difficult to work out exactly, but that's the figure that's being suggested. And certainly.
15:46 Kate Lister? Even if that's not true, that that would even be suggested tells you that it was very visible and that people were prepared to believe that.
15:55 Speaker 08 Yeah. And it's in Rome where you first get the word courtesan used in Italian.
16:00 Kate Lister? Ah, okay.
16:01 Speaker 08 In the fourteen nineties, because this is a time, fourteen nineties is a time of the Borgia papacy. And Alessandro Borja.
16:10 Kate Lister? They were the naughty ones, right?
16:11 Speaker 08 Yeah, they was the naughty ones. I mean, he had children who he had with his mistress, Renata Catane, Glaecia Borja, um Cesare Borja and others. And so it became in the late fourteen nineties, going into the early sixteenth century, it became normal for cardinals to have concubines and to have courtesans who'd come around in the Roman court for them. So these women weren't sex workers who'd work on the street. These were women who would have long-term relationships. But in that period of time, would have been thought in the same way as prostitutes and he might work in brothels or something, but these were people who would be generally with rich clients. And so Raphael was associated with
16:55 Speaker 08 some of these really famous, the very earliest really famous courtesans. So there's a courtesan called Imperia, who was active in Rome in the first decade of the sixteenth century. And Raphael is meant to have painted her naked and that painting was on the front of her house.
17:12 Kate Lister? Like when you said the front of her house, what do you mean? Like her front door?
17:15 Speaker 08 Yeah, on the front wall of her house.
17:18 Kate Lister? Wow.
17:19 Speaker 08 Rome was really licentious at this point in time.
17:22 Kate Lister? That's a hell of a move, innit? Just here are my tits, behold.
17:25 Speaker 08 Yeah, and you paint, there's drawings, really early life drawings of a woman in the guise of Venus. So, you know, starting with that really typical pose with one hand kind of half covering her breasts, one hand half covering her genitals. And they're probably portraits and it might be connected to Imperia, it might be connected to this big naked portrait he did of Imperia at this time.
17:47 Kate Lister? Was it a big deal that he was painting nude women? Because one of the things that I learnt from talking to you is that there was a lot of gayness going around in, in the Renaissance courts and within the artists. It was a lot of man love, it was a lot of painting men, it was a lot of nude men, nude men painting other nude men. And there was just a lot of bros, bros, bros. And it just struck me there when you said that Raphael started painting nude women, that that seemed. Like an unusual thing from what I know about it. Had it been done before?
18:16 Speaker 08 A little bit. So you have some Florentine artists painting nude women like Botticelli. So Botticelli's Birth of Venus. Botticelli starts experimenting with female nudes, late fourteen seventies, early fourteen eighties. So you get some Florentine workshops doing that. But what Raphael does is like this big campaign of female nudes for his fresco series he does. For Agostino Cegi, he's this massively wealthy businessman who lives in Rome for a villa that's now called the Villa Farnesina. And Raphael gets a lot of naked models. It's known that he drew after real life women, not kind of workshop boys pretending to be women or or classical sculpture. And he really does it for the first time. And him and Titian, who follows up in Venice, and then they together just basically invent the female nude as an important genre in art.
19:01 Speaker 08 This all happens in the fifteen, tens and twenties. And Raphael and that sexual culture of Rome, where you have the availability of a lot of women who, if you paid them, they'll take their clothes off. It's really important that needed to exist. And the whole kind of discussion of sexuality in a different way. Because the other thing that came out of Raphael's workshop and the other thing which will make you think of him as a fuckboy is it's a first printed porn.
19:23 Kate Lister? There you go. That'll do it. Okay. Tell me about that then. How did we go from frescoes in the Vatican to the first printed porn?
19:30 Speaker 08 Well, we know that there's a lot of bawdy associations between art and sexuality.
19:37 Kate Lister? Definitely.
19:38 Speaker 08 Yeah. So people talk about your brush, using your brush. Like in Italian, it's penello. In Italian, the word for penis is penne.
19:46 Kate Lister? Oh, look at that.
19:47 Speaker 08 Which can also mean little penis.
19:49 Kate Lister? Right.
19:50 Speaker 08 So there's this connection already. And they say that artworks are like the conception of men. And so they started to kind of riff on this. They're also rediscovering all this classical stuff, including brothel tokens.
20:02 Kate Lister? Right.
20:02 Speaker 08 Like that you get from Pompeii as well, I think. You know, these spintrai. And these brothel tokens are like coins that have pictures of people having sex. On them and they have, they're in lots of different positions. And so Giulio Romano, Raphael's people, starts to draw these and to share them, like these drawings. And they're called the positions. And then after Raphael's death in fifteen twenty four, they get printed. They're really the first kind of selection of porn.
20:29 Kate Lister? I know those.
20:30 Speaker 08 I'm sure you know.
20:30 Kate Lister? I didn't know that they were connected to Raphael though.
20:33 Speaker 08 Raphael's workshop, yeah. They get quickly banned by the Pope.
20:37 Kate Lister? Of course.
20:38 Speaker 08 Of course, you know, and the prints get banned and they get destroyed, but it's too late. By the time people have seen them, they've already been copied. They get collected in various places and people set out to sell them in Venice, which is outside of the Papal State. So they have licence to sell them. Mac Antonio Ramondi gets imprisoned for a while because of his involvement. Giulio Romano, just, he did the original drawings, just goes, goes to Mantua to work in Mantua instead of Rome. But this is all to do with the kind of ethos of Raphael's workshop. While he's there, he's had all these courtesans knocking around, he has these women knocking around. He's drawing after the female nude. And there's no sense then that female nude models aren't sexually available.
21:16 Kate Lister? Ah, so I was just about to ask you about the models. I used to work as a life model and there are quite clear boundaries in place and quite clear protocols that are followed and, you know, everybody's just very careful, knows what they're doing. I'm gonna make an assumption that when Raphael was doing his thing, that that might not have been in place.
21:35 Speaker 08 Given how careful people are generally with women's lives in this period. No, absolutely. I mean, it's really interesting talking to people who have been, and you worked on this quite a lot about nude models. Because there was, for a long time, amongst some types of art historians, this absolute disbelief that women would pose nude for artists in the sixteenth century. Because there is a lot of taboos about female nakedness. But women were also often quite impoverished.
22:03 Speaker 08 And it was difficult for them to earn money. And if they're young women who are also sex workers, they would do this. And there's records from Venice, from Lorenzo Lotto's notebooks that describe, like account records that describe paying women and to take their clothes off to be drawn. And there's also a sculptor who was in Rome at the same time as Raphael called Cellini, Benvenuto Cellini, who talks about in his diaries about his getting his female servant to pose naked for him and paying her. So it's definitely.
22:36 Kate Lister? Wow, that was some small print.
22:38 Speaker 08 Yeah, I mean, he treats them awfully. He's like, he really likes them. And then he goes, oh yeah. And then she posed me and then I had sex with her. And then she was really mean to me. She went off with someone else. So I got to pose in really uncomfortable positions for hours.
22:51 Kate Lister? Oh, dick.
22:51 Speaker 08 Yeah. So it's all a bit of a mess. And Raphael has been connected particularly with one woman who people think was a model for him. And her name was Margarita Luti.
22:59 Kate Lister? Ah, okay. Tell me about Margarita Luti.
23:03 Speaker 08 So she was a baker's daughter. And it's very complicated the way this story starts. There's a painting by Raphael called La Fornarina.
23:14 Kate Lister? Yep, very beautiful.
23:16 Speaker 08 Very beautiful painting. It's of a woman.
23:18 Kate Lister? Babs are out. It's quite an erotic painting.
23:21 Speaker 08 Yeah, I mean, definitely. It's because she's half dressed, right? It's not even, there's something about her just being in the process of undressing.
23:33 Kate Lister? Yeah. And she is squeezing her boob. Do you have a bit of like a huh kind of a situation going on? That's not what he wanted to portray, obviously.
23:41 Speaker 08 Yeah, we're not over reading this painting. So she is naked, almost entirely naked from the waist up. And she's got this kind of diaphanous, kind of material statenous veil over her belly. And she's holding it up between her breasts and she's got one of her fingers on her breast.
24:02 Kate Lister? She does. I'm looking at it right now.
24:03 Speaker 08 Yeah, I'm looking at it now too. And she's kind of looking sideways towards the viewer. She's got dark hair. She's not like a boring, typical Renaissance beauty with blonde hair and curly locks. She's golden blonde hair and curly locks. She's got dark hair. She's got a pearl in her hair. She's looking very individualized, which is interesting. And round her arm, there's a blue armlet. And that says Raphael of Urbina on it. So this is kind of like a mark of. Ownership.
24:33 Kate Lister? See, I just would like to say here to any listeners, if you are with a man and he asks you to wear a bracelet with his name on it, I think that's a red flag, personally.
24:41 Speaker 08 To be painted. This is mine.
24:46 Kate Lister? I'll be back with Jill and Raphael after this short break.
25:04 Speaker 09 Land a Viking longship on island shores, scramble over the dunes of ancient Egypt, and avoid the Poisoner's Cup in Renaissance Florence. Each week on Echoes of History, we uncover the epic stories that inspire Assassin's Creed. We're stepping into feudal Japan in our special series Chasing Shadows, where samurai warlords and shinobi spies teach us the tactics and skills needed not only to survive, but to conquer. Whether you're preparing for Assassin's Creed: Shadows or fascinated by history and great stories, listen to Echoes of History, a Ubisoft podcast brought to you by History Hits. There are new episodes every week.
26:01 Kate Lister? How did they meet if he's this big fancy, fancy pants artist and she's working down Greg's? How does this come about?
26:08 Speaker 08 Well, you know, we don't know. I'm really sorry. I mean, the evidence about Margarita Luti is really patchy and it's really uncertain. One of the problems with Raphael is that people really loved him in the late 18th and early 19th century. And so they made up a lot of stuff. A lot of art historians were like, oh yeah, we can know about his life. He loved women. Let's have a look at him. And this whole story is from, there was a tradition that we can only trace back to around the 1790s, calling this painting The Baker's Daughter of La Fornarina. And there was, in the 16th century, someone annotated a copy of the Tsarev's Life of Raphael, where they've talked about another painting called
26:52 Speaker 08 The Dona Volata, which is another really beautiful portrait of a woman by Raphael. And someone wrote next to that, Margarita. So that's the two bits of primary evidence we have. Then people have put this together to find Baker's daughter called Margarita, who was around at the same time as Raphael and was the right age. And this is where Margarita Lutie's name has come up. We don't know anything else about her or about, I know, or about her relationship with Raphael. There's no written documentation about it. So it's all a bit patchy. And people like with many things in these paintings kind of believe whatever they want to believe. We've got more evidence about just loads of people being fascinated by sex in Raphael's workshop.
27:35 Kate Lister? Yes, yes.
27:36 Speaker 08 And about, you know, things like the Kijis, Agostino Kijis images. And Vazari says about Raphael that he was very amorous. He says he was fond of women and swift to serve them. But I don't think any of this really leads to fuckboy status. It's more like
27:54 Kate Lister? It doesn't really.
27:55 Speaker 08 Nice man status.
27:57 Kate Lister? Looking at this portrait, I don't know, I'm extrapolating way too much from this, but looking at her, he clearly fancied her. She's beautiful and erotic and charged and I don't know, maybe I'm being too hot. I just can't imagine him putting his pen down and just going, see you later then, love.
28:12 Speaker 08 I really think that Raphael was a decent person. There's another, yeah, I'm so sorry.
28:20 Kate Lister? You don't have to apologize for that. That's a good thing.
28:23 Speaker 08 I know. I mean, he's particularly within the, the time, right? The time period, because this is
28:29 Kate Lister? Oh, tell me about his wife then.
28:31 Speaker 08 Well, he was never married, so he was associated with this woman. He was betrothed to this other woman, one of the Bibianna family, who he never kind of seemed to have much contact with. But within the time period, you know, people are treating women really, really awfully. There's a lot of violence against women, just casual violence, casual everyday violence. People are urged to chastise their wives by beating them, you know, in marriage manuals, right? This woman, Margarita Liti, or whoever she may be, what we do know about her is she turns up in Raphael's paintings for several years.
29:05 Kate Lister? Oh, does she?
29:05 Speaker 08 Yeah, so we're talking about a relationship, at least of a model and an artist, that goes on for maybe six or seven years.
29:13 Kate Lister? No, I don't think that we can pin that one on for being a fuckboy with that weird bracelet detail aside. So he's having a relationship with his model, but from what we can see, it seems to be, I mean, it's a low bar, but he's being quite respectful.
29:28 Speaker 08 Yeah, and it was very common for women, and this time for nude models, to pose like Venus, as I said. And that little bracelet thing is something you do find on Venus statues sometimes.
29:40 Kate Lister? Oh, that's who's off there as well.
29:42 Speaker 08 Yeah.
29:42 Kate Lister? Right, okay.
29:43 Speaker 08 And it could be just that he's saying that he wants to be, this is me, me romanticising Raphael, because I think he's very handsome as well.
29:51 Kate Lister? He always are, that's the problem.
29:52 Speaker 08 It could be just him kind of binding his name to her for eternity, right?
29:57 Kate Lister? That is quite romantic. Did he meet his fiancee then, if this woman that he was engaged to?
30:03 Speaker 08 Oh, God, you know, engagements in this period, particularly these kind of political engagements, are much more about the family joining together than anything to do. Particularly when you get to like higher levels of society.
30:14 Kate Lister? Yeah.
30:14 Speaker 08 They have like in other places in Europe, they have like bundling before marriage. So, you know, you can basically sleep with the person you want to get married to before the marriage, but that tends to be for people who aren't so high up in society. For, for normal people, that would happen. But Raphael was friends with her uncle, he was a cardinal from Florence as well, and they were good friends. So this is really why it happened. He's just a bit of a social climber, Raphael, right? So he's taking advantage of anything he can get in order to secure his role.
30:45 Kate Lister? Didn't he keep delaying this marriage?
30:46 Speaker 08 He kept delaying it probably because he was in Rome, you know, you always hope he's working for the Pope. He might, like a lot of people in Rome, he might be hoping, maybe I can get a job in the Vatican, then get in the job in the Vatican, maybe I can go into Holy Orders.
31:01 Kate Lister? Did he dump her or did he die before?
31:03 Speaker 08 She died.
31:04 Kate Lister? She died?
31:05 Speaker 08 Yeah, she died just before he died. He died young as well, yeah. So I don't know what was going on there. So only she died of having too much sex, but um.
31:12 Kate Lister? No.
31:12 Speaker 08 Yeah.
31:13 Kate Lister? But do we know why she died?
31:14 Speaker 08 No, we don't know very much about that. She's like on a footnote. I mean, it'd be nice to know more about her, actually. And you might be able to find out more about her, but she doesn't come through the Raphael literature.
31:23 Kate Lister? Why does he have his reputation then as this absolute dog with two dicks running around Italy? Can't get enough of it. Because from what you're saying, he sounds reasonably well behaved.
31:35 Speaker 08 Yeah, I think it's just to do with Rome at the time.
31:37 Kate Lister? Okay.
31:38 Speaker 08 They're having these parties at the Vatican. You know, the chestnut game. I don't know if you know about the chestnut game.
31:42 Kate Lister? Well, I think, I think you'd better tell us.
31:44 Speaker 08 Would you like, you would like to know about the chestnut game?
31:46 Kate Lister? I think we would, yes.
31:47 Speaker 08 But this is the second time the word courtesan is used in Rome and it's under the borgia, so it's going to be quite rude. There's a description of it in the papal diaries. So there's a guy called Burkhard who takes the papal diaries. And he describes a game in fifty O one where Duke Valentino, who's the Pope's son, Cesare Borgia, invites fifty prostitutes to the Vatican who dance with the servants and others there, first in their clothes and then naked. And then they put all candles, lampstands with candles around and they put chestnuts on the floor, which the prostitutes, I'm quoting now, naked on their hands and knees, had to pick up.
32:27 Speaker 08 The Pope, the Duke, his son, and his sister, the Pope's daughter, Lucrezia Borgia, were all present and watching all these prostitutes crawling around the floor naked, picking up chestnuts. Finally, prizes were offered, silk and doublets, pairs of shoes, hats and other garments, for those, and I quote, who knew the greatest number of those prostitutes calmly.
32:46 Kate Lister? When I have my friends over, we have pasta.
32:49 Speaker 08 Yeah.
32:49 Kate Lister? That's what happens.
32:50 Speaker 08 Yeah. I mean, we could market this game, sell chestnuts or something, but no, it's.
32:55 Kate Lister? Couldn't we? Mattel, are you interested?
32:58 Speaker 08 It is what the Vatican was like in Rome in the early.
33:02 Kate Lister? Oh, wow. I mean, wow.
33:03 Speaker 08 Yeah. I mean, sexy times. So Pope was watching people have sex with prostitutes and giving prizes.
33:08 Kate Lister? Yep.
33:09 Speaker 08 So he had sex.
33:10 Kate Lister? Yeah.
33:10 Speaker 08 And Raphael's coming into this environment. And the reason why he's really associated is because he does so many beautiful female nudes, a time when Michelangelo is doing female nudes that really were quite butch. For example.
33:20 Kate Lister? Yes.
33:21 Speaker 08 Leonardo was doing a few female nudes, but they're all a little bit creepy. Titian also has a reputation relating to his love of women. And he also does a lot of female nudes. And so it's these guys, Raphael and Titian together, who were associated with just having a lot of sex. But whether it's true or not, it's difficult to say. But you have to say Raphael, the evidence suggests that it possibly is true, but also probably with the same person.
33:45 Kate Lister? What did he die of then, do you think?
33:47 Speaker 08 He died of, I don't know what he died of.
33:52 Kate Lister? No one knows.
33:52 Speaker 08 Not too much sex. But possibly, I mean, venereal disease? I mean, sickness is really rife at this time. There's a lot of kind of different illnesses that you could get. It's less exciting, but smallpox was really common. And people had heart attacks and strokes and things. And obviously people just couldn't diagnose it.
34:10 Kate Lister? And lead paint. Maybe he was licking his paintbrush too much.
34:13 Speaker 08 I mean, yeah, all sorts of terrible. I mean, he could be licking his paintbrush or other people's paintbrushes. But all sorts of stuff that you could get.
34:20 Kate Lister? Remembering what you said earlier about paintbrushes.
34:23 Speaker 08 I mean, who knows what goes on with paintbrushes in Raphael's workshop? All sorts of stuff was going round in Rome in a high de- he could have eaten something awful. No one really knows, but it was a massive loss to Rome and they had a massive, massive funeral and it was very unexpected and very sudden. The only person who was probably pretty happy about it was Michelangelo. Everyone else was gut ticked and they had a massive funeral procession and he was buried in the Pantheon. So you can still see his grave today if you go to Rome in the Pantheon.
34:52 Kate Lister? Jill, well defended, I think. I think we're gonna have to let Raphael off the hook, I do.
34:59 Speaker 08 And can I say Raphael is great, is a really good painter. People that look at him, people think, oh my God, that's so great, Ollie and I did a bunch of you, so interesting. But Raphael is really, he, he's a little bit underappreciated nowadays, I think. So go and see the Vatican Stanzel and just be wowed by him. The Villa Farnazina is amazing. So I am a massive fan, massive, massive Raphael fan, and as everybody should be.
35:24 Kate Lister? I think I probably would have shagged him if I was around at the time.
35:27 Speaker 08 Without a doubt.
35:28 Kate Lister? Without a doubt, yeah.
35:31 Speaker 08 I mean, I'm not talking about you, Kay. He's a nice man, he's talented and he's, yeah, definitely.
35:38 Kate Lister? Okay, all right, Raphael, you are off the hook. Jill, you have been wonderful to talk to you. Thank you so much. If people want to know more about you and your work, where can they find you?
35:47 Speaker 08 Well, I'm sticking around on the University of Edinburgh web, website for the foreseeable future. So you can look me up there. You could read my book, How to Be a Renaissance Woman, which is mainly about cosmetics, but we do talk about women's nudity. We talk about women's relationships in there as well. And I'm about to do a series of get ready with me videos for the Science Museum.
36:09 Kate Lister? Amazing.
36:10 Speaker 08 Yeah, so if you want to know how to make Renaissance makeup and how to dress up like a Renaissance woman.
36:14 Kate Lister? I do.
36:15 Speaker 08 They'll be via Instagram.
36:17 Kate Lister? Will you come back and tell us more about that?
36:19 Speaker 08 Of course.
36:21 Kate Lister? Thank you. You have been wonderful. Thank you so much.
36:24 Speaker 08 Thanks, Kay.
36:29 Kate Lister? Thank you for listening and thank you so much to Jill for joining me. And if you like what you heard, please don't forget to like, review and follow along, whatever it is that you get your podcasts. Coming up, we've got episodes on whether or not Alexander the Great had mummy issues with none other than Tristan Hughes from our sister podcast, The Ancients, and the next instalment of History's Worst Fuckboys with none other than the Roman Emperor Nero. Boo. Or maybe hurrah, I'm not sure yet. But if you wanted us to explore a subject, or maybe if you just wanted to say hello, then you can now email us at betwixt@historyhit.com. This podcast was edited by Tim Arstall and produced by Stuart Beckwith. The senior producer was Charlotte Long.
37:08 Kate Lister? Join me again, Betwixt the Sheets, History of Sex, Scandal and Society, a podcast by History Hit. This podcast contains music from Epidemic Sound.
37:23 Speaker 02 In Our Time is a world-class seminar every week. Why was Jeremy a lonely snail? What were lines doing in York in the third century? I'm Misha Glennie and every week I'm joined by expert guests to explore the ideas that shape our world.
37:38 Speaker 03 It's one of the first times, really, that you consistently see someone painting teeth. I know that sounds bonkers.
37:42 Speaker 04 If I was going to define mathematics, I would say it's the study of structure.
37:46 Speaker 02 In Our Time. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Tea or coffee? Love a cup of tea.
Previous Alexander the Great's Mummy Issues: Olympias Next Queer Georgians Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated