Pod Insights Behind the Bastards Part Three: How The Navy SEALs Lost Their Mind About this episode In this episode Robert Chronicles how Richard Marcinko's elite red cell suffered two casualties trying to beat up an unarmed man. Also: the Navy SEALs make a series of questionable decisions overseas.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 13,942 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:05 Robert Evans? It's Behind the Bastards, once again, the podcast where every week we tell you the worst things about the worst people in all of history. And this week, we are doing parts three and four of our series on the founder of SEAL Team Six, Richard Marcinko. And in these two episodes, we will be getting, you know, past just Richard and talking about kind of how the things he set in motion led to the continuing derangement of the Navy SEALs well beyond just Team Six. And back to talk with me about how things got as bad as they are now, Andrew T. Andrew, how are you doing?
0:37 Speaker 01 What's up? How's it going? I'm good.
0:40 Robert Evans? Fine and dandy, Andrew. Fine and dandy.
0:42 Speaker 01 No war crimes this morning, so.
0:43 Robert Evans? That's good. You haven't committed any, right? I can't promise that myself.
0:46 Speaker 01 Yes, I'm so sorry. Yes. The world, possibly even SEAL Team Six. I don't know.
0:51 Robert Evans? It's entirely possible. There's a non-zero chance we're back at war with Iran, if I'm remembering correctly. But that changes every day.
0:58 Speaker 01 The point is, I don't know.
0:59 Robert Evans? The point is, you don't know. And the point is also that you have a podcast.
1:04 Speaker 01 Yes, that is the point. Yes, I've been doing a Star Trek podcast with Tony Newsom, Jesse Gender. It's called Starter Trek. They are, I won't say making me watch Star Trek, because I do enjoy it, but I do not know jack shit about Star Trek, so I'm muddling my way through. And it's really fun. We're on podcast places and YouTube and.
1:26 Robert Evans? Excellent.
1:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's what I'm doing these days. One of the things, I guess.
1:30 Robert Evans? Check that out. And I've got a little plug I want to put in for some friends of the pod. A lot of you listened to the Knowledge Fight Podcast, which is currently on hold or, you know, no longer being produced. But the hosts of that are two great guys, Dan and Jordan, who did wonderful work documenting Alex Jones and actually helping with like the legal fight against him in Infowars. And they both have new projects. So I just wanted to let you know, because a lot of our listeners listen to their stuff. Dan has a new podcast called Show Me State of Mind, and Jordan has started a YouTube series of short video essays called, that's @everyoneiswrongabout. So YouTube @everyoneiswrongabout is Jordan's new thing. Yeah, that's it. And now it's time for some SEALs.
2:13 Robert Evans? Not the ones with like blubber and like that people eat.
2:17 Speaker 02 That's the kind I prefer.
2:19 Robert Evans? I guess our Navy SEALs have some blubber, but they're pretty skinny usually, right? Yeah. I mean, I doubt they'd taste very good. Maybe. I wouldn't try one.
2:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, they might, man.
2:29 Robert Evans? I'll eat any kind of seal. Look, once, you know, I'm not gonna club it, but if it's fed to me, I'll try a Navy SEAL, I'll try a harp seal, you know? That's just where I, that's just where I roll.
2:40 Speaker 01 Yep.
2:43 Speaker 03 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human.
2:47 Robert Evans? Picture this: You're listening to the Sniffy's Cruising Confessions podcast, and suddenly, "Wait, what did they just say?" Well, the questions raised in those show-stopping moments will be answered in the all-new bonus series, Sniffy's Cruising Confessions: Bedside Manor. Hosts Gabe and Chris will dive deep on a specific topic covered in that week's Tuesday episode, from sexual health and HIV prevention to finding the right doctor. Listen to this special bonus series, Sniffy's Cruising Confessions: Bedside Manor, now on the iHeart Radio app or wherever you get podcasts. Sponsored by Healthy Sexual from Gilead Sciences.
3:19 Speaker 04 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
3:52 Robert Evans? Richard Marcinco commanded SEAL Team Six from its inception in August of 1980 to July of 1983. So again, not a long run as the founder and head of SEAL Team Six.
4:04 Speaker 01 Oh my god, we're gonna get, we're not, we're going like more than one episode per year. This is like, yeah.
4:11 Robert Evans? It, it, because we're getting way beyond, there's way more stuff. You wanna talk about the SEALs doing anything bad? You have to get out of Marcinco's era, because they're not doing a lot when he's running Team Six, you know?
4:20 Speaker 01 They're doing bad things, but mostly to their livers, it seems like.
4:24 Robert Evans? Yeah, right, right. During that early 80s period, there's not as much shit for them to go do. As there's going to be, or as there was in Nam. So, given Richard's bloodthirsty nature and his frequently stated love of killing, it's tragic that he missed SEAL Team Six getting its baptism in fire on a little island called Grenada. Now, most of you millennials are too young to have any memory of this, but Grenada was one of a handful of brief little mini-wars that the US ran during Reagan and Bush one years to make us feel better about the fact that we'd lost Vietnam. We needed to get our mojo back, and the only way to do that was to invade some countries that had no chance of fighting back whatsoever. You can look at the Falklands if you want to say sorry. I don't need to talk shit about England right now.
5:05 Speaker 01 We just need a confidence builder. Yeah. Batting practice.
5:09 Robert Evans? Yeah, Grenada and fucking Panama and then Desert Storm were like taking Cialis for like your military industrial complex after it gets like that middle-aged Vietnam, you know, limp syndrome. Yeah.
5:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah. This is the first, this is the first time this has happened.
5:25 Robert Evans? Yeah, yeah. So Reagan took over after Carter during a time when left-wing movements were spreading across Latin America and the Caribbean. There was a coup in Grenada and leftists took over the government, and he used the pretext of some US medical students who might be the next Iranian embassy hostages to deploy overwhelming and sudden US force to the area. Their first task ended in disaster. On the night of October 23rd, prior to the invasion, a mixed team of SEALs and some Air Force Combat Control team members parachuted into the sea to go ashore and plant beacons on an airfield. This is exactly the kind of thing SEALs are supposed to be doing, right? The jump got botched, though, and one of the SEAL teams had way too much gear, up to 400 pounds each, and their life vests couldn't support them.
6:08 Robert Evans? Four Team Six SEALs died in drowning without ever seeing combat. The rest of the mission flopped because a boat broke. So, not a great first run for Team Six, you know?
6:18 Speaker 01 Oh, man. Drowning because of too much gear is like...
6:21 Robert Evans? That sucks. That sucks so bad.
6:24 Speaker 01 That's, but that also.
6:25 Robert Evans? What a shitty way to die.
6:26 Speaker 01 It feels, I guess, that's, that's how it was gonna happen. Jesus.
6:30 Robert Evans? Well, someone, again, it's the, someone probably should have checked the math on that. I don't know.
6:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:35 Robert Evans? There was massive debate as to why Team Six had needed to parachute into the water with all of that gear in the first place. Because there were other ways to have accomplished the mission. And the answer seems to have been because like, well, it was cool as fuck to do it that way. And that's what we trained for, because that's the kind of stuff we're, we're into. And his book, Or notes that SEAL Team Four actually had wanted to do the mission instead of Team Six, and they were gonna use like boats. And they might have, they might have done that, quote, "had SEAL Team Six not been so eager to show off its skills in a real war." That's from Brave Men Dark Waters. And Brave Men Dark Waters is a pretty positive book towards the founding of the SEALs and their early establishment.
7:15 Robert Evans? So the fact that Or is saying that they did this because they kinda wanted to see if they could, and a bunch of guys died, means something, right?
7:22 Speaker 01 I, I, it's, I guess the, the tiny thing that is like, is it heartening to know that, that like, right wing dorks? Have just always been around or, you know, the entire, most of everyone's lifetime?
7:36 Robert Evans? And they're always really bad at estimating risk.
7:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:40 Robert Evans? Estimating how likely things are to work for them.
7:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
7:44 Robert Evans? Unfortunately, they're also try, likely to take certain risks, which is why a lot of people don't, don't fight back. But that's a separate question. So a day and a half after the drowning, during the actual invasion of Grenada, SEAL Team Six was again tasked with a special mission. This time, they were asked to seize the government house and protect the governor general, who was a representative of the British government because Grenada was a Commonwealth. And so the job was like, they would infiltrate and like, get this guy and evacuate him, and he would like, sign a thing declaring the US invasion legal, right? That was kind of why they wanted Team Six there. But the, the mission gets fucked from the jump. And they wind up under heavy fire, getting really badly injured, surrounded in this building by APCs.
8:24 Robert Evans? And they, they don't really get to do much, but they do get the governor general, and he does sign that thing. So like, technically, they accomplish their political goal. But like, it slows the invasion. A bunch of like, regular Marines have to rescue the SEALs because they've, they've gotten themselves in a bad situation.
8:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:40 Robert Evans? Yeah.
8:41 Speaker 01 Then the adults have to come rescue these lunatics as usual.
8:45 Robert Evans? The adults being the Marines.
8:47 Speaker 01 Right, right.
8:48 Robert Evans? Yeah, they took a break from eating crayons to go save the Navy SEALs.
8:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:53 Robert Evans? Two other units from Team Six were sent to accomplish other tasks. One had to set beacons on an airfield and the other had to disable a radio transmitter. After the short conflict was over, there were serious questions asked by war planners. Had everything Team Six had been asked to do been necessary? Did we need to use these guys for this? The failures witnessed in Grenada helped spur the creation of a new Joint Special Operations Command. They're basically reforming JSOC and now it will include all special forces and not just a few specialized units. Now, the SEALs fought this. One way they'd establish their value post-Vietnam was to make themselves an integral part of carrier group operations for the Navy. But ultimately, the SEALs were integrated and it was probably for the best for the SEALs
9:36 Robert Evans? because being integrated to JSOC brings them a lot more money. And by 1990, it's ensured that the SEALs have expanded to more than 2,000 men, which is double the size they'd been in Vietnam. Because as we're kind of nearing, you know, the collapse of the Soviet Union, the post-Cold War era, as that's all in sight, there's this understanding that maybe we don't need to worry about the big wars, but we need elite teams of guys who can do stuff like overthrow a government that we don't like so much. You're like, take out a terrorist, handle a hostage situation.
10:06 Speaker 01 Can I ask a broad question? I guess, which is like something I've, you seem like you definitely would underknow this more than me, which is that like, the JSOC of it, why, besides branding, or is it just branding, why the fuck do we have so many different types of elite guys?
10:22 Robert Evans? It's because they do different things. So, the Navy SEALs are traditionally supposed to be number one, like, water naval operations. They work with carrier groups, like we talked about. They're also supposed to be doing like hostage rescue, hostage operations, assassinations, kidnapping. Whereas a unit like the Green Berets, for example, are like the guys, at the start of Afghanistan, you drop a handful of them into like, a village and their job is to build up a militia of locals and like, train them and teach them how to like, fight as a unit and stuff in order to help them accomplish the US's goals. And that's a very different skillset than the SEALs. The Green Berets are obviously meant, need to be competent fighters, but they're supposed to be really good at like, working with locals and not just killing them. Because that's kind of the point. That's why you won a Green Beret, right?
11:03 Speaker 01 Right, right, right.
11:04 Robert Evans? Delta Force is also, I mean, and these kind of do get muddled, especially today. Like, what is Delta Force used for as opposed to the Team Six is?
11:11 Speaker 01 As opposed to the Rangers, as opposed to...
11:14 Robert Evans? Right. There's a lot of them and they all have specializations ostensibly, right?
11:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. I guess to me it's just the era of like helicopters, drones. It just seems more like G.I. Joe than anything else.
11:27 Robert Evans? Yeah, and there's an argument to be made for that. Again, not one that a lot of these guys will make, but there is an argument to be made that like sometime, especially like today, a lot of these units have like overlapping capabilities and like purposes that it's kinda, yeah, anyway.
11:41 Speaker 01 Right, right. Okay.
11:42 Robert Evans? Yeah, so when we left off with Richard Marcinko, because this is the stuff that's happening. I told you in the last episode, he gets a new job creating the Red Cell who's supposed to break into Navy bases.
11:51 Speaker 01 That's right.
11:52 Robert Evans? So while he is starting that job, that's when like Grenada is going on, right? Because he's out of the, of Team Six by that point. So, let's get back to Richard for a little bit. When we left off, Marcinko had charmed his way into getting a classified unit, Red Cell, which he got to train up and could use to break into any Navy facility he chose. Uh, he was also supposed to use them to kidnap sensitive employees of said facilities to test their security, uh, protocols. This latter remit gave Marcinko a chance to get back at the people he hated and blamed for all of his woes. Lazy officers and civilians with cushy desk jobs, right? He gets to like fuck with these guys for a living now. So he and his men often forced kidnapped victims to carry out intense workouts and would like mock them for their performance.
12:33 Robert Evans? And otherwise, they're not like supposed to beat them up usually, but they are crossing that line or getting right up to it a lot because they're dicks.
12:42 Speaker 01 I, I will just say, if like the Daily Wire or someone like that had any actual chops, you could make like kind of like a right wing version of Dirty Work out of this story.
12:52 Robert Evans? Yeah.
12:52 Speaker 01 That would be, you know, probably funny enough, honestly.
12:55 Robert Evans? Yeah. There's a great script in this tale. Um, I'm surprised it hasn't been made into a movie. Um, so complaints were pretty minimal at first, right? Because they're not really beating people. And so it was easy to dismiss people saying, hey, but they're really dicks to us. It's like kind of sour grapes because you're not good at your security and the C.U. showed you up. But then Marsenko's Red Cell started crossing paths with a man named Ronald Sheridan. Now, Ron was not a soldier, but the civilian head of security for a naval weapons facility. He had criticized the flaws in the red team analysis of his facility when they'd shown up on site and he had denied Marcinco the use of his facilities to plan their operations. He's like, basically, okay, if you want to try to bust in, you can't like use facilities on the base for your planning, right?
13:40 Robert Evans? If you're trying to cosplay as an enemy, you can't like prep inside the base, you know?
13:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
13:46 Robert Evans? Because they won't get to.
13:47 Speaker 01 Get your own Motel 6 asshole.
13:50 Robert Evans? Yeah, get your own, that's literally what he's saying, right? And Marcinco does not love this. So I'm gonna quote again from Code Over Country. "The team instead worked from a local dive called Garfs. There, Marcinco and the team plotted their next operation while drinking, day and night. This included how to terrorize Sheridan. The strict rules of engagement called for all operations to occur at the naval facility being probed and for the operators to only use force to simulate getting control of a target. Sheridan lived in Eagle Rock, a Los Angeles suburb north of Seal Beach. By the time the two operators, Frank Phillips and Arturo Farias, showed up at Sheridan's home, they had already gone too far." So from the jump, they shouldn't be at this guy's house and they are. On March 20th, 1986, the Red Cell moves in to kidnap Ron Sheridan.
14:34 Robert Evans? But here's the thing, Sheridan knows he's got a really sensitive job and he takes it seriously and so does his wife. She takes it really seriously, so when Frank Phillips tries to kidnap Ron Sheridan, his wife is there, his wife Margaret is there with a gun. Every morning, she walks him out to his car with a loaded 45 and she nearly shoots Phillips two times and he has to like explain and show them his badge and Ron agrees to go with him for the good of the exercise, although I think you could agree, they beat the exercise.
15:04 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:05 Robert Evans? This lady got the drop on his elite Navy SEAL and nearly killed him. In his larping job testing security on naval bases, he almost gets a SEAL killed by a housewife.
15:15 Speaker 01 That is so funny.
15:17 Robert Evans? It's so funny.
15:18 Speaker 01 That's so good.
15:19 Robert Evans? It's really good.
15:20 Speaker 01 Good, yeah.
15:21 Robert Evans? Like, like I would say, I guess his security was pretty good.
15:25 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:26 Robert Evans? Like, sounds like Sheridan's got it on lock.
15:30 Robert Evans? But instead, they kidnapped this guy and they take him to a shitty motel. Well, they like sit and watch TV with him for most of the day. And he's like putting up with it for a while. But after a few hours, he's like, I gotta go home, guys. Like, why are we still doing this? And the SEALs are like, no. And he's like, seriously, let me go. And so they call Marcinco. And Marcinco is still at the bar and is very drunk and continuing to drink during the operation. And he's like, if that fucker wants to leave, tear him a new asshole and have the camera team film it. So he orders his guys to beat him up and film it. So two Red Cell operators bust into the hotel room and start beating the shit out of Sheridan. They strip him to his underwear and tie him to a chair while calling him a pussy. They beat him, they waterboard him in a toilet.
16:14 Robert Evans? Now, again, all of these Red Cell guys are SEALs, former SEALs. They're the best of the best, a lot of Team Six guys. And yet, while beating an unarmed tied up man, they still took casualties? One operator fell on Sheridan while torturing him and broke a rib. They lose a man beating up a tied up dude. The best of the best, only the most elite.
16:40 Speaker 01 Only a SEAL could take down a SEAL, clearly. In both these instances, we've talked about today.
16:45 Robert Evans? Well, only a civilian security employee's body can take out a SEAL.
16:50 Speaker 01 Or a SEAL took himself down. Yeah, well, that's true, I guess.
16:54 Robert Evans? Yeah. Rob's wife later said, after her husband was returned, I wish I had shot that guy. And I get it, Margaret, that's a fair way to feel.
17:03 Speaker 01 Yeah. I will say just broadly, we're kind of getting close to this era of like, we're starting to see law enforcement fight other law enforcement at the margins, you know, ICE arresting like local cops and stuff.
17:16 Robert Evans? Little bits, yeah.
17:17 Speaker 01 I have a little, you know, wonder what's gonna happen one day. Cause one of these days, someone's gonna do something, one way or the other, I guess.
17:26 Robert Evans? It probably won't be the fun version of it, but we can hope.
17:29 Speaker 01 It never is, I guess, yeah.
17:30 Robert Evans? Yeah, yeah. So the fact that his guys had beat up the student, filmed it, didn't look good for Marcinko. So he had the tape edited to remove the worst of the beating, but Sheridan reported the abuse and the Navy got access to the full video? Marcinko insisted nothing abnormal happened, but he was fired from Red Cell a month later and given an admiral's mast this time. Now, his clout held up yet again. It ensured him a slap on the wrist punishment, but a month later, the Navy opened an investigation into Marcinko's time as Team Six commander. The motivating incident for this was a report Marcinko had drunkenly pulled a gun during a military exchange trip to New Zealand? And Marcinko's like, this was all political, but also, and maybe it was, but also, why
18:14 Robert Evans? did you drunkenly pull a gun during a military exchange trip? And that's a good reason to fire a guy, I'd say.
18:19 Speaker 01 Why did you bring a gun to New Zealand?
18:22 Robert Evans? I mean, I'm sure, maybe he gets to, like, he's in the military. I'm sure that was normal.
18:27 Speaker 01 Aren't you some kind of badass? You should, I'm gonna say this, I'm so sorry. If you're a SEAL, if you're the king of the SEALs, you should be able to fight New Zealand barehanded. That's all I'm saying.
18:37 Robert Evans? You should be able to fight New Zealand barehanded. I mean, come on. Like, come on.
18:41 Speaker 01 Get the fuck out of here. Get real, bro.
18:43 Robert Evans? Yeah. So the SEALs clammed up and defended Marcinko, and for a while, it seemed like he'd get away with this, too. But after the word got out that Richard was about to be promoted to captain, a bunch of officers inside Navy Special Forces flipped out. And these are not like big Navy guys, these are Special Forces guys, and they realized what a fucking poison Marcinko is to everything they are trying to do. One of these dudes actually writes a seven-page letter to Ronald Reagan, being like, please do not promote this man, but ultimately decides instead to call Naval Investigative Services and report some of what he knew about the fraud Marcinko had enabled and carried out in Team Six. This caused the launch of a probe in the spring of 1986, which turned into a full investigation
19:24 Robert Evans? nicknamed Iron Eagle. Marcinko would later blame all of this on Eggheads and Big Navy, who he defended and lightly tortured while at Red Cell. But the lead investigator was Clifford Sibon, a former Army Ranger who earned a Bronze Star in combat. He was a huge supporter of the mission of the SEALs. He just wasn't willing to let Marcinko get away with corruption. From the book Brave Men: Dark Waters, quote, "At one point, they hired a truck, backed it up to the door of Team Six headquarters and carted away the team records, about 50 boxes of them. It was an extraordinary scene, a government agency raiding, in effect, one of the Navy's most secret and most vital military units." This is like a big deal investigation. Yeah, like that's scandalous.
20:05 Speaker 01 Honestly crazy they kept any records, though, given the small amount I know about them.
20:11 Robert Evans? Yeah. So, at first, the actual evidence against Marcinko seemed thin. He'd done a pretty good job covering his tracks. But eventually investigating agents found out that one of his top SEALs, a man who'd actually fought in Grenada, John Mason, had also taken trophies back from Grenada with him, AK-47s. And that was illegal. Trophy taking is illegal now. Importing automatic weapons is definitely not, you're not supposed to be doing that.
20:37 Speaker 01 Of the trophies, AKs is not the most illegal one.
20:42 Robert Evans? Yeah. And look, would it be tempting? Were I and John Mason's, of course. You can't expect superhuman self-control. That's why you build guide rails into the systems like this. So, they decided to look into Mason, and sure enough, he'd filed a shitload of fake receipts. So many that he'd had them printed at print shops to mimic real receipts. He had like ongoing relationships with print shops to fake receipts that he sent in to the Navy to get reimbursed for stuff.
21:09 Speaker 02 Oh my god.
21:11 Robert Evans? That's pretty funny.
21:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:13 Robert Evans? So, investigators get Mason dead to rights, and they're like, hey, you want to keep that Navy SEAL Wallace silence up? Or do you want to not go to prison? And Mason says, oh, I'll roll on Dick if it's between that and prison. So he gives them a bunch of information about widespread financial improprieties directed by Marcinko. Mason was charged with 37 counts of various kinds of fraud and offered a suspended sentence for flipping on Marcinko. He agreed and he gave the Navy info on the scam Marcinko had just perpetrated. During his red cell days, Dick had cooked up a scheme with Mason after Mason had left the Navy and was a civilian working for a contractor. Marcinko ordered, agreed to order 4,300 experimental grenades for Red Cell with SEAL Team Six sponsoring
21:58 Robert Evans? the contract because it's a, Red Cell's a classified unit. So they're doing purchasing through Red Cell, right? Now, the idea was that these 4,300 experimental grenades were re-pinable. So if you pulled out the pin, you could change your mind later, I guess, and like, put it back in so you could make the grenade safe. And he wanted to test them with his new elite unit. There's debates about this. One source says they were just normal grenades. That was always a lie. In his book, Orrer seems to be convinced that they were experimental grenades. I don't know the truth. The grenades sold for $310,000 and the manufacturer kicked $110,000 back to Ramco, the company that Marcinko and Mason had formed. So he is lying to just get startup money for a new business. Like, that's
22:42 Robert Evans? the purpose here, is like, they're creating a con grenade buy in order to steal money from the Navy that they will then put into a business for their civilian lives, right? So that was the idea. But Mason gets the money first and he blows all of their money on fancy cars and like, a lavish office space for the, I don't even know what the business was supposed to be. So in 1987, Marcinko is tried in federal court with bribery and conspiracy. The first trial ends in a hung jury and the second in January of 1990 sees him found guilty and sentenced to 21 months in a minimum security prison. So, Richard goes away for a while. He's out of the Navy and he is officially persona non grata among the SEALs. And this is the end of his military
23:25 Robert Evans? career, right? Richard Marcinko, we'll hear from him a couple of times still. Old Dickies still out there. Oh, good. But he's, he's not in charge of anything. In 1987, the name of SEAL Team Six was changed to Naval Special Warfare Development Group, or DEVGRU. And this is the official name today. They're no longer called Team Six. People still call them Team Six. Yeah. All the time. Yeah, yeah. People, I mean, a lot of people know they're called DEVGRU too, but like, DEVGRU is the official name, right? And as you might guess, by the fact that everyone does still call it SEAL Team Six, Marcinco's legacy was hard to eradicate, right? You can change the name, but you can't necessarily change the culture that this guy started off in there.
24:05 Speaker 01 It's all branding and culture. It's the real shit, I guess.
24:09 Robert Evans? The branding is we're criminals and no one tells us what to do. And also, we get to murder whoever we want.
24:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
24:14 Robert Evans? Shocking. Shocking that branding caused some problems. You know whose branding has never caused problems, though?
24:21 Speaker 02 I was hoping you wouldn't do that.
24:22 Robert Evans? Pretty good.
24:23 Speaker 01 It's pretty good.
24:24 Robert Evans? Pretty good. Pretty good ad pivot. All right, everybody. Go away. Well, don't go away. Listen to ads.
24:32 Robert Evans? This ad is brought to you by ViiV Healthcare, the makers of Devoto Dolutegravir Lamivudine. If you're living with HIV, do learn about Devoto. Devoto is a complete HIV treatment by prescription only for some people 12 and older. Your doctor will determine if Devoto was right for you. Most HIV pills contain three or four medicines. Devoto is as effective with just two. No other complete HIV pill contains fewer medicines than Devoto.
24:56 Speaker 05 It is unknown if Devoto is safe and effective if you have HIV and hepatitis B. If you have Hep B, don't stop Devoto without talking to your doctor, as it may get worse or harder to treat. Don't take Devoto if you're allergic to its ingredients, or taking Dofetilide due to serious or life-threatening side effects. If you have a rash or allergic reaction symptoms, stop Devoto and get medical help right away. Other serious or life-threatening side effects include severe liver problems and lactic acid buildup. If you're female or obese, you may be more at risk. Tell your doctor about your medicines or supplements, medical conditions, liver or kidney problems, pregnancy, breastfeeding, or planned pregnancy.
25:31 Robert Evans? Do ask your doctor about fewer medicines. Visit devoto.com or call 1-877-844-8872.
25:38 Speaker 04 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
26:12 Robert Evans? We're back. So, it's December of 1989. The good people of the George H.W. Bush administration have decided that the United States still has not gotten enough of its mojo back post-Vietnam. And so, we invade Panama. There are other reasons involving Manuel Noriega and cocaine, but we went over those in our Behind the Bastards episodes on Panama with Chelsea Manning. So, go listen to those if you want to know why Panama happened. Contrasting with Grenada, there was a ton of time to plan before invading Panama. Grenada, they have to throw together really quick, which is part of why shit's so slapdash. Panama shouldn't have been, in part because like while they're planning it, we have bases there. So, we literally have like our guys planning the invasion, just like walking around and
26:55 Robert Evans? like taking notes on the stuff they're gonna be doing for a while. That's really kind of the ideal situation to invade another country.
27:04 Speaker 01 I mean, it's the red team, you know?
27:06 Robert Evans? Yeah.
27:06 Speaker 01 It's the red cell approach. Just live there for a little while.
27:10 Robert Evans? Yeah. However, the fact that we have all this planning time may have actually hurt the SEALs because the people of Panama are generally friendly. They really like Americans. They tend to be nice. They tended to be nice to American soldiers. That was the attitude of the government at the time. And so, the Bush administration doesn't want to have a lot of civilian casualties to explain. It doesn't want damage to a lot of infrastructure, right? They just want Noriega out and to be able to like, you know, do their own stuff, right? So, they tasked the SEALs with taking and capturing the airport that holds Noriega's jet, and they tasked them with doing it only with small arms. So, we're not going to try to take this out with an airstrike, and we're not gonna give you guys heavier equipment. And we're not gonna give you, like, send in a larger unit or a unit backed up with armor.
27:55 Robert Evans? We're going to send in a small group of elite SEALs with small arms to take this hangar, right? So, the guys they send in-
28:02 Speaker 01 This feels like the SEAL's bluff has just been called, basically. It's like, oh, okay.
28:06 Robert Evans? Kind of does.
28:07 Speaker 01 Captain badass, you should be able to do this with like a knife.
28:11 Robert Evans? Yeah. So this is not Team Six, this is SEAL Team Four. But the op is a massive shitshow, so much of one that it becomes historic. Because the SEALs, kind of, as they're approaching this hangar, they have to do so in the open, and they have like night vision. So when they get up to a certain point, they can see who's in the hangar. But that's also the point at which they're like 10 or 15 something yards away. And so they get up close, and the second they see these guys, they realize they're completely in the open. And there's like a dozen or so guys, dudes in there, who are, all have guns trained on them. And immediately open fire, and there is zero cover. And if you watch like movies, the way Navy SEALs are, you've got something like 24, I think, Nate, like around two dozen SEALs, or more. It's like, it was a historically large group of SEALs.
28:54 Robert Evans? There were huge arguments about should multiple platoons? Because we don't, SEALs don't train to fight that way at this time. Should they have sent in like, I think it was two platoons? But they outnumbered the enemy two to one. Again, in the movies, they would have killed these guys in a second. But this is real life. And it doesn't matter how well trained you are in real life. If you are in the open, 15 or 20 meters away from people with a machine gun, you're gonna die. And that's what happens. It's possible that only two men actually fired back into the SEALs. But they immediately kill four and wound like seven or eight more. They take like half the unit out of commission, almost instantly. Now, the SEALs do eventually accomplish the mission, but not because they take, like, the hangar gets abandoned by these guys. They like leave after a while. And it's just, it's a really bad time.
29:39 Robert Evans? Like, the SEALs have a horrible time, a lot of them die or get horribly injured. Noriega never even tries to go for his jet, so their sacrifice is completely meaningless. And their opponents flee rather than being defeated in a satisfying way. It's the worst it could have gone. And again, it's because, this is not a thing any guys should be doing. We know if you just send dudes directly into the maw of a machine gun, they die. It doesn't matter if they're SEALs. There is no reason, conventional infantry should have handled this.
30:09 Speaker 01 Is this the same version as like a Navy SEAL? This is just like, is this the same as just like a stealth bomber being taken out with an IED?
30:18 Robert Evans? If something like that were to happen, that's kind of the idea. Is that like, this incredibly valuable unit that's highly trained was sent in to do something that was, you should not have elite, highly trained operators just running into guns like that. It's stupid. Also, during the same thing, Team Six tried to capture Noriega. They didn't. In the wake of the invasion, the commander of US forces, Lieutenant General Carl Steiner, bragged that everything had gone so well, there were no real lessons to learn, which gives you an idea of why the US military sometimes makes the same mistakes over and over again.
30:51 Speaker 01 Yeah. Cover your ass. Cover your ass. It went great.
30:55 Robert Evans? Okay. So, the Persian Gulf conflict is probably gonna be the high watermark for unproblematic SEAL success at war, because commanding general Norman Schwarzkopf hated special forces. He's very distrusting of special forces. He only wants the West Coast SEALs participating because they're seen as less problematic. I think that's some of Richard's legacy, still. He probably would have been annoyed if he wasn't still in prison in March of 1990. Now, maybe because there weren't guys like Marsekko around at the time, the SEALs get integrated effectively into a broader military apparatus during Desert Storm. At one point, like, one of the things that the SEALs do, are used to do, is a six-man unit is sent in to create a diversion.
31:37 Robert Evans? Like, they're basically swimming by a coast, and they're trying to, like, fake and make it look like an invasion is coming by carrying out acts of, like, subterfuge and sabotage. And they're able to successfully draw two full Iraqi visions away from engaging the US in combat. And that's exactly the kind of shit SEALs are supposed to be doing, right?
31:56 Speaker 01 Right.
31:56 Robert Evans? Like, that's undeniably useful. It does require people who think outside the box. It requires courage and creativity, and it saved a bunch of lives, net. Like, that's a good example of how you could use guys with this sort of training, right? So they can be used effectively, you know? Outside of that, SEALs track and remove sea mines, and they do search and rescue for downed pilots, they capture an oil platform, and none of them die. So Desert Storm goes pretty well for the SEALs.
32:22 Speaker 01 But, but that's like, like, like, most of the time, it's always leadership, right? It's always just like, like, actually being used correctly. It's doable. They are, they are human psychos, but you can put them in the right place.
32:35 Robert Evans? Schwarzkopf, number one, does not buy in to all of the bullshit around the mythology of these units, and number two, he's, he's using them to accomplish a really reasonable thing to use a small unit like that for, right? The tasks there being set.
32:47 Speaker 01 Yeah. My memory of him is he just seemed like a guy that had a turkey sandwich with no condiments on it every day for lunch.
32:54 Robert Evans? Yeah, yeah. Fellow, I read his autobiography as a kid. He was a bland fellow. Weirdly enough, he grew up in Tehran as a child, which is kind of strange. His dad was like an ambassador or something. It's very strange.
33:05 Speaker 02 Andrew, you think he has a like white bread, turkey sandwich, no seasoning with just a piece of lettuce?
33:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, lettuce, turkey bread, nothing.
33:15 Robert Evans? You can imagine.
33:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
33:17 Robert Evans? Stormin' Norman? Absolutely.
33:18 Speaker 02 Hilarious.
33:20 Speaker 01 Half a packet of mayo. Has to be a full packet.
33:22 Robert Evans? Half a packet of mayo. But just next to the sandwich. Like, my grandpa used to just open a bottle of vermouth when he was mixing his martinis. That kind of idea.
33:30 Speaker 01 Just a smell.
33:31 Robert Evans? Towards seasoning. Yeah. Salt is in the house next door. Yes. So by the 1990s, that's like, kind of the mid to late 90s, the SEALs had been in a wide range of conflicts that they could draw experience from when looking and planning for the future. They'd been successfully integrated into the modern warfighting machine of the United States. And this is where the book Brave Men Dark Waters ends. An author, Orr Kelly, notes that a couple of points that he felt like worried him about the organization's future. So this is Orr writing post Desert Storm and before 9/11, right? About what he's afraid is going to happen to the SEALs in the future. "The SEALs have not been very good at learning from their experiences, especially when things go wrong, and applying those lessons to the future. A meeting devoted to SEAL participation
34:16 Robert Evans? in Operation Just Cause was held shortly after the operation, but most of the SEALs present found the briefing unsatisfactory, and a few were so disturbed that they walked out." Right? That's the briefing on like that Panama shit show?
34:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
34:27 Robert Evans? And I don't know if they walked out because they were disturbed at how bad the planning was, or were disturbed that guys didn't want them to do shit. It's a little unclear to me.
34:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
34:34 Robert Evans? But it shows that there's this kind of institutional unwillingness to really critique as much of what they're doing. You know, you could treat critique big Navy. And that's Orr's fear for the SEALs as they go forward. And it's kind of proved to be kind of prescient.
34:47 Speaker 01 It's really like, these tough guys are kind of just soft baby boys at every turn as soon as criticism of any kind.
34:56 Robert Evans? To never be mean to them and always treat them like special angel boys. Yeah. It's weird for as tough as they claim to be. So there's a real debate post-Gulf War about the purpose of Navy SEALs and what it should be in a world where guided missiles had relieved them of many of their previous duties of doing sabotage. Well, we don't need to send like some guys in flippers to sabotage a refinery. We can shoot a missile at it, right? In his book, Orr noted that SEALs had previously focused primarily on their ability to influence events by violence, in contrast with the Army Special Forces, and that they might need to learn more about how influencing hearts and minds should work. He's talking about Army Special Forces or the Green Berets, and he's talking about how the SEALs maybe in the future will need to be more like that, right?
35:37 Robert Evans? And even then, some SEALs resisted this idea. As Orr wrote, "One form of violence that SEALs talk about among themselves is the possibility of capturing or killing terrorist leaders or even foreign heads of state. One of the frustrations of their involvement in Desert Shield and Desert Storm was that Saddam Hussein remained off limits. Attempting to take out Hussein would have been an assignment tailor-made for the specially-trained anti-terrorist experts of SEAL Team Six. In fact, one former member of the team, while at the Naval Postgraduate School, wrote a study of how the team might be used to carry out clandestine assassination attempts. His thesis remains highly classified." Cool. Just thinking about, you know, stuff that's not necessarily the SEALs, but stuff Special Forces guys are doing in the Trump era to heads of state.
36:20 Speaker 01 Do you regret not going to college to write fanfic about fucking like murdering Saddam Hussein?
36:28 Robert Evans? I do, I do. I mean, I would have written fanfic about writing a novel with Saddam Hussein, which remains my chief goal, you know. I'm a fan of him for his other work. I don't forgive him for, you know, for the crimes, but his romance novels, you know.
36:44 Speaker 01 He's an artist. You gotta separate the artist from the art.
36:46 Robert Evans? That's right. That's right. It's very hard to do with Saddam Hussein.
36:52 Robert Evans? So Orr Kelly also related his concern that SEALs in Panama had shown they had issues working in large multi-platoon groups. Furthermore, their extraordinary abilities only really were at their peak when they had rapid air and artillery support, right? The SEALs are only able to be the most effective when they have a lot of guys backing them. And if, you know- That had been a facet of most SEAL Ops since NOM. But that means like if you don't have access to that stuff, are they as capable? Is, are they likely to get into problems, you know?
37:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
37:23 Robert Evans? And the global war on terror.
37:25 Speaker 01 It's awfully, it's awfully stone soup with the SEALs, isn't it?
37:27 Robert Evans? Yeah.
37:28 Speaker 01 It's like, all you need is Navy SEALs and fucking air support and an army behind them. And they'll fucking do whatever you want, bro.
37:38 Robert Evans? They're great. With all the air support they can call in, they're deadly as hell.
37:44 Robert Evans? So, uh, the global war on terror would prove some of these fears prescient and give Mersinko's old unit in particular, a chance to make a name for themselves as the president's assassins. Before all that, we get to the 90s, a glorious decade of peace and prosperity. Well, nothing bad happened if you don't count the Balkans or Rwanda or several other places. Anyway, in 1992, Richard, uh, Mersinko gets out of prison and publishes the book Rogue Warrior, which is the first account of life inside SEAL Team Six, written by a SEAL. Even though Mersinko was disgraced, it timed perfectly with the post Desert Storm hype and millions of copies were sold. So the book is a stupendous hit among civilians who wanted a glimpse inside the rarefied air of special forces. And they'd already thought these guys were basically superheroes.
38:28 Robert Evans? So Mersinko's bold claims didn't seem so wild, like the reader is prepped to believe anything about a SEAL Team Six guy, right? If he says he was doing crazy operations with Team Six while he was leading them, even though they really weren't doing all that much, it must be true because he founded SEAL Team Six, right?
38:45 Speaker 01 Well, we're also in the, we're in the Van Damme era. We're in the Steven Seagal era. Of course, this is what they do. We've seen it.
38:52 Robert Evans? And it says, it says a lot about the veracity of Richard's first book Rogue Warrior, that he follows his autobiography, his nonfiction autobiography with a fiction novel series, also called Rogue Warrior.
39:07 Speaker 01 Hell yeah.
39:09 Robert Evans? He creates a bunch of fiction novels with the same title and branding as his autobiography that's supposed to be nonfiction?
39:15 Speaker 01 Makes sense.
39:17 Robert Evans? I think the idea is these were based on the real classified missions.
39:20 Speaker 01 Of course.
39:20 Robert Evans? And he can't tell you about those, you know, but yeah.
39:23 Speaker 02 I love when you do that voice.
39:25 Robert Evans? It's my first time.
39:26 Speaker 02 You're so good at it.
39:28 Speaker 01 Based on a true story.
39:29 Robert Evans? Based on a true story. That's all we need to put in the Hollywoods.
39:32 Speaker 02 They're like Rogue Warrior.
39:35 Robert Evans? That's right. Great title. Print it. The first of the fictional Rogue Warrior novels was Rogue Warrior: Green Team, which spiraled out into the long series of subsequent novels, ostensibly based on Marcinko's real life, with him as the lead character and also on the cover. Sophie's gonna show you a copy of Rogue Warrior 2: Red Cell. That's actually Richard Marcinko. He's got, he looks like Steven Seagal.
39:58 Speaker 02 Hold on, Andrew, are you ready for this? Are you ready for this, Andrew?
40:02 Speaker 01 I don't think I am, actually.
40:04 Robert Evans? Oh, man.
40:06 Speaker 01 Oh.
40:09 Speaker 01 Bummer.
40:10 Robert Evans? So again, he's got a ponytail and a beard. He looks like Seagal in the 90s. Purposefully, probably. He's wearing all black. He's got like an MP5 submachine gun crossed against, over his heart like it's a fucking, I don't know.
40:22 Speaker 01 What a dweeb.
40:24 Robert Evans? Yeah.
40:26 Speaker 01 It's always dweebs.
40:27 Robert Evans? Oh, man. It's so sad. Okay, Richard. Okay, man. It was through these novels, which make him a rich man, that Marcinko would prove himself forever the smartest member of Team Six. Instead of risking his freedom and money by telling US government secrets like some subsequent Team Six members, he could just lie and pretend to be giving away secrets.
40:50 Speaker 01 Make shit up.
40:51 Robert Evans? Yeah, just make shit up. I need to read you how the book is still sold today. This is from the audible description. When Richard Marcinko wrote his bestselling autobiography Rogue Warrior, he and co-writer John Weisman were bound by government restrictions and could only tell a fraction of his incredible story. Now, the tales he could not tell, the secrets he could not reveal, explode in Rogue Warrior 2: Red Cell, a riveting new novel with Marcinko himself as the hero.
41:21 Speaker 01 Oh my god.
41:22 Robert Evans? Love it, love it. I, I, I love the, the tales he couldn't tell. A riveting new novel with himself as the hero. Yeah. I'm, I'm sure these are real stories, Richard. So this is him, this, I, I picked Red Cell because we know the real Red Cell story. So here's what Richard wants people to believe what he was doing with Red Cell instead of nearly getting his men killed by a dude's wife and having another one of them seriously injure himself torturing a man. Quote, freelance security consultant Dick Marcinco is playing terrorist at Tokyo's Narita Airport. Easily penetrating the facility's defenses, he engages in a deadly firefight with North Korean operatives and discovers that a group of traitorous Americans are smuggling
42:05 Robert Evans? nuclear materials to North Korea and Japan. With nowhere else to turn, the former Secretary of Defense recalls Marcinco to the Navy against his will to command Red Cell, a dirty dozen SEAL team Marcinco created. From infiltrating Washington's Navy Yard offices and secret special nuclear weapons depot in California to raiding a North Korean Navy base in target far out in the Pacific, the rogue warrior and his marauding SEALs fight incredible odds and increasingly dangerous enemies.
42:32 Robert Evans? Yeah, that's real, man. Yeah, I, I love that a group of traitorous Americans are smuggling nukes to North Korea and Japan.
42:37 Speaker 01 Japan.
42:38 Robert Evans? Allies in nuclear warfare, North Korea and Japan shaking hands. What is their plan? Why do North Korea and Japan want nukes together?
42:48 Speaker 01 It's just, you know, to, to... For the vibes. I guess it's Mechagodzilla?
42:53 Robert Evans? Mech, it might be Mechagodzilla. That's actually possible. It's possible.
42:59 Robert Evans? On September 11th, 2001, some unfortunate things went down. And at the end of it, two pretty big buildings were gone. Because the guys behind this had mostly been Saudi terrorists living in Afghanistan, the United States goes to war with Afghanistan. From the beginning, it's pretty clear that this was, you know, not gonna be a normal kind of conflict, in part because it's Afghanistan and wars don't tend to go very well there. Right? Yeah. A lot, a lot of the operational burden in Afghanistan from the beginning we knew was gonna be put on US special forces, right? And actually, at the start, when US troops first enter Afghanistan, they're basically 100% of the war effort in the earliest days. It's not long after the Twin Towers fell that the Navy SEALs,
43:41 Robert Evans? who were still largely the force they'd been in the 1990s at that point, which is, you know, men trained mostly for coastal operations, who specialized in hunting, tracking, and destroying. Afghanistan was new terrain and a new kind of war to them. And when it began, most of them had no combat experience. And there were a lot of lessons that are going to be learned in Afghanistan. And not all of it is going to be, I mean, there are a lot of lessons that are going to be learned in blood in Afghanistan. And it's not just going to be SEAL blood. Them fucking up is going to cost a lot of other people their lives. Some of this is just an unavoidable consequence of war. When you invade a country, especially with an army where most people haven't like done that stuff before, even your special forces guys usually haven't been in combat, there's going to be even more mistakes than there normally is in a war. If you've got like a lot of people who have been in combat before. So like, that stuff's going to happen too.
44:26 Robert Evans? It's just, you're going to have a lot of fuckups in the early stages of special forces involvement. Because in part, they're still learning how to fight.
44:33 Speaker 01 When you drop your water type Pokémon into an earth arena.
44:39 Robert Evans? Into an earth.
44:43 Speaker 01 This is as much as I know about that, but I feel like I'm correct.
44:46 Robert Evans? That's more or less how military strategy works, actually, Andrew. You know who else knows how military strategy works? The sponsors of this podcast, all of whom are actively planning to invade the United States and subject it to an authoritarian rule. But, you know.
45:00 Speaker 01 That part's actually true. This is the closest to truth.
45:10 Robert Evans? This ad is brought to you by ViiV Healthcare, the makers of Devoto Dolutegravir Lamivudine. If you're living with HIV, do learn about Devoto. Devoto is a complete HIV treatment by prescription only for some people 12 and older. Your doctor will determine if Devoto is right for you. Most HIV pills contain three or four medicines. Devoto is as effective with just two. No other complete HIV pill contains fewer medicines than Devoto.
45:34 Speaker 05 It is unknown if Devoto is safe and effective if you have HIV and hepatitis B. If you have Hep B, don't stop Devoto without talking to your doctor, as it may get worse or harder to treat. Don't take Devoto if you're allergic to its ingredients, or taking Defetolide due to serious or life-threatening side effects. If you have a rash or allergic reaction symptoms, stop Devoto and get medical help right away. Other serious or life-threatening side effects include severe liver problems and lactic acid buildup. If you're female or obese, you may be more at risk. Tell your doctor about your medicines or supplements, medical conditions, liver or kidney problems, pregnancy, breastfeeding, or planned pregnancy.
46:09 Robert Evans? Do ask your doctor about fewer medicines. Visit devoto.com or call 1-877-844-8872.
46:17 Speaker 04 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of 5-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
46:50 Robert Evans? And we're back. So, in January of 2002, a SEAL Team 6 officer named Vic Hyder murdered an unarmed Afghan man at the first Team 6 action of the war. Hyder had been leading a team to capture Al Qaeda guys in a compound. After the mission was completed, the SEALs took fire from somewhere. And after that, an old man walked up to them as they were evacing. So, right? They captured some guys in a compound. There's a firefight. After it's completed, they're taking fire, but they can't see who's shooting at them. And then around the same time, an old man is just kind of walking, because they're just out in Afghanistan, and there's just a dude who lives there, and he's walking around. And because it's dark, Hyder starts shouting at the man to stop, but this guy doesn't speak English. He's in his own country. He doesn't know what's being said. And he's elderly.
47:35 Robert Evans? He can't see for shit. And so, he keeps stumbling in their direction. And Hyder, who's got like night vision and is not in direct danger from this man, decides he's close enough that if he has a grenade, he could hurt me. So, I must assume he has a grenade. And he shoots this elderly man to death. Right? The thing that had been in his hand, that Hyder worried was a grenade, turned out to be a cassette from a tape player. Now, again, if we're talking about... It's bad when cops do this all the time. But cops don't have very good... I mean, not... This is part, here's what I'll tell you. This is why the training argument is bullshit for cops, right? Because the argument is, well, cops do this, but it's because we need to fix their training. These guys had all the training in the world. No cop will ever have more training than Vic Hyder is. He shot a man with a fucking cassette in his hand.
48:15 Speaker 01 Right, right, right.
48:16 Robert Evans? It's what you're asking them to do. There's no training that'll stop that. They make decisions themselves past a certain point. And a lot of guys in situations like this will decide, my life matters more than any random dude whose country I just stepped into, right?
48:29 Speaker 01 Well, and you could argue that these guys clearly have been told they are so valuable as humans that their life is worth much more than any random person. You know, the potential that they might be hurt means the other person has to die.
48:42 Robert Evans? Vic says that, and I'm sure he was taught that. What should tell you that that's not universal is a bunch of his men complain, right? He's an officer, a bunch of his enlisted men, the guys that are supposed to be like the real pipe hitters are like, that's fucked up, dude. You just murdered an old guy. And they complain and it gets put down to officer enlisted rivalry. Ah, they just don't like their officer, you know, right?
49:04 Robert Evans? Hyder was not well liked in the unit for stuff like this. One reason, and this is a reason that also causes a lot of fucked up behavior is that some officers don't all go through like the, the really intense selection process necessarily that SEALs, enlisted SEALs do. You don't necessarily go through all of the same shit if you're an officer, because it's a different job and the way you get there is different, right? And that causes some of the conflicts. And some of these officers are insecure about, maybe I don't really deserve to be here. And some of them compensate for that insecurity by becoming ultra violent, right? That is a pattern that occurs among the teams periodically. It's not every officer who does this, but some of these guys, and it comes sometimes from insecurity. I'm sure some of them would do that if they were an enlisted man too, because they're just psychos, right? I'm just trying to provide you some explanation for the motivation here.
49:49 Speaker 01 And it's obvious it could be a little of both.
49:51 Robert Evans? Yes, yes, it's gotta be some of both. But the insecurity here isn't a 0% of the factor, right? Yeah. At the time of combat operations in Afghanistan, Team Six had about 200 operators split into three assault teams, blue, red and gold. Each team got a mascot and proving that Navy SEALs are no different than 15 year olds. This immediately started to get out of hand, right? Because they get way too into their fucking mascots. Now, the biggest problem is that red team has a Native Ameri-, stereotypical Native American warrior as their mascot, right? And they call themselves the Red Men.
50:25 Speaker 01 Yeah.
50:26 Robert Evans? Blue team are the pirates and they fly a jolly Roger into battle. And gold team are the knights or crusaders and they wear Crusaders crosses and lions. And you can imagine how comfortable some of this imagery gets.
50:36 Speaker 01 Jesus Christ, yeah.
50:38 Robert Evans? Perhaps unsurprisingly, the worst would be the red men, the ones with like a racist nickname. In his book, Matthew Cole writes, quote, "Since the 1980s, when red team was first created, there were many operators in the unit who had experienced a metamorphosis of identity and persona into Native American warriors." This is something that officers in the team who are critical of the culture will say. And, and some enlisted guys, that's how they describe it, that it's a metamorphosis. These guys really believe.
51:04 Speaker 01 Right.
51:05 Robert Evans? Again, you don't have to credit these guys as knowing anything about any Native American tribe, knowing anything about history, knowing anything but shit they've seen on bullshit movies, but they think that's cool.
51:13 Speaker 01 Yeah.
51:13 Robert Evans? And they get way into the idea.
51:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
51:16 Robert Evans? Right? That's all I'm saying.
51:18 Speaker 01 Right.
51:18 Robert Evans? Please don't take this as they know what anything. It's a cartoon, right? I have never gotten enough detail about exactly what's meant by metamorphosis. I'd really like to talk to some dudes about that.
51:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
51:29 Robert Evans? But the most demonstrable part of it is unfortunately quite racist, which is that as the war on terror goes on, some of these dudes start taking scalps. Now.
51:38 Speaker 01 Of course.
51:38 Robert Evans? This had not happened at the start of the, when Hyder's and this isn't start immediately, right? But Hyder is one of the guys who kind of starts the ladder of escalation of brutality that helps lead in that direction, right? And he's, he's, among other things, he's a guy who feels like, I need to prove I deserve to be here.
51:54 Speaker 01 Right.
51:54 Robert Evans? By being ultra violent.
51:55 Speaker 01 Right. So the classic small man bully.
51:59 Robert Evans? Right.
51:59 Speaker 01 Like five.
52:00 Robert Evans? Very small man.
52:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:01 Robert Evans? On March 6th, 2002, Lieutenant Commander Hyder led more than 20 SEAL Team Six operators in two Chinooks on a mission to kill or capture bin Laden. As you can guess from the date, it didn't go well. Intel had revealed an Al Qaeda convoy traveling in the area, which was bombed by the US Air Force before the SEALs went in. Some operators protested having the Air Force bomb the convoy. They're like, our job is to like be super discriminating guys who can get really close and we could know if, because they didn't really know, is this convoy bad guys or not? And our job should have been to get in there close and see if we needed to attack this convoy, right? We could have verified that. And it turns out the intel was wrong. The Air Force had just bombed a family caravan and their Chinooks gunners had unloaded into women and children who were being protected by the bodies of their men.
52:45 Robert Evans? And so in the SEALs land, they see these guys were like throwing themselves these piles of corpses where men are trying to shield their children and wives from the gunfire of the ship that these SEALs had just been in. And it fucks some of these guys up, right? It's a pretty awful thing to see and not all of these guys are completely dead inside and fine with that. Despite the fact that it's immediately clear, none of these people were involved in anything. Hyder and several SEALs continued to treat them as combatants. Per Cole's book, quote, "Hyder said that he and a few other SEALs began to bury the casualties near a ravine by piling rocks over them. As he did so, he approached the man Heath had shot. He was partly, partially alive, faced out, his back to me, and he rolled over. I shot him, finished him. He was dying, but he rolled over and I didn't know whether he was armed or not. That was the end of that.
53:29 Robert Evans? Hyder said that his single shot had blasted open the man's head." So there's this guy who isn't dead and this, instead of trying to render aid, he's just like, well, I thought he might have had a weapon, so I shot him.
53:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, mentioning, mentioning this guy who's dying on the ground might have a weapon is like, I guess that's peak cowardice. It's just like fucking.
53:49 Robert Evans? And there's some, some other SEALs who were there at the time who do complain about this, say like, well, they had weapons, but they were family weapons. Like it's Afghanistan, people, it doesn't, like they're not Al Qaeda because they have a gun, you know? That's just life out here. So according to Hyder, the encounter ended there after he shoots this wounded guy. But a retired SEAL who was there on the mission told a different story to Cole. And according to this person, after Hyder shoots this wounded man, who was unarmed, by the way, Hyder proceeded to mutilate his body by stomping in his already damaged skull and like spreading brains out everywhere. And there's a chunk of guys who think this is cool and there's a chunk of guys who are fucking horrified, right? Heath, who had shot the man initially and witnessed Hyder's actions, reports them to his team leader.
54:32 Robert Evans? He's like, look, I shot this guy because I thought I needed to. And then he just mutilates this guy, kills this guy when he doesn't need to and mutilates his corpse. Like, I think that's fucked up and I don't feel good about it, right? When he does this, quote, "Several of the guys turned and walked away," according to the retired SEAL. "They were disgusted," he quoted Heath as saying. "I'm morally flexible, but I can't handle that," right? So the way, at least in this report, a lot of people are grossed out by what Hyder does. And he does start to get iced out from the SEALs at this point, or from like some units. They have this way of, if you're an officer and you're grossed like that, when you rotate out, we don't have to let you back in. And so sometimes stuff like that happens. But what you should take from this isn't just
55:14 Robert Evans? that there are SEALs who are grossed out by this, who report him. There's also SEALs who think it's cool and who don't have a problem with it. Right. And in this instance, maybe Hyder gets, you know, what I'd call a slap on the wrist, and there's a little bit of accountability, just a teeny amount eventually for him, not really much. But in the future, this is going to become like in other units, when this stuff happens, it won't be, people won't complain, right? Right. People will be okay with it. That's going to happen increasingly often after this point, too. And it's going to happen because of something that goes down on March of 2002. A team of Team Six SEALs under Master Chief Britt Slobinski are in a Chinook, looking for a bin Laden soaring over a mountain that they'd been told had no enemy presence when
55:56 Robert Evans? they get hit with an RPG. Petty Officer First Class Neil Roberts falls from the bird, right? He'd been, you know, the chopper has like, I think it's ramped down and he's standing out there and it gets hit and he falls. And he falls and hits so hard that he bends the stock of his rifle on the way down. So he doesn't have the normal armament that he would have even. They think he's, you know, they don't know if he's dead or not, but the pilot can't stop to rescue him. So they have to get back. And when they return to base with that chopper, Slobinski gets in another chopper with the rest of his men, and they head back to rescue Roberts. But in the interim period, Roberts had been found by Al Qaeda fighters, and they had killed him and stripped his body for gear, and one fighter had attempted to saw his head off as a trophy. Now,
56:37 Robert Evans? SEALs do this all the time. As we've talked about, when war hits a certain kind of level, people do this all over the world. There's no way to avoid types of this other than not going to war. You know, that's the real way, if you want to ensure this shit doesn't happen. But again, these SEALs are new to Afghanistan and this really like enrages them. These people, they lose their minds over the fact that their buddy got mutilated, even though some of them had already been mutilating Afghan, that Afghan people, right?
57:07 Speaker 01 That's pretty standard for these guys. Like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Can't do that to us.
57:13 Robert Evans? No, no, you can't do that to us. In Code Over Country, Matthew Cole quotes a former Team Six leader, saying, "When you see your friend killed, recover his body and find that the enemy mutilated him, it's a schoolyard mentality. You guys want to play with those rules? Okay." And although this former SEAL acknowledged that war crimes are bad, he understood how often they happened. Quote, "You asked me to go living with the pigs. I can't go live with the pigs and then not get dirty." And this is, again, this is bad. This is the kind of thing there should be accountability. The military should be cracking down on this shit more, right? Like, this is not the sort of thing that that should be allowed to happen. It's also, if you're going to vote to send guys to war like this, stuff like this is going to happen. He is right about, "If you
57:56 Robert Evans? asked me to go living with the pigs, I can't go live with them." The pigs are anyone you ask to go murder people in the middle of nowhere repeatedly, right? Regardless of what side they're on, they're going to wind up doing ugly things because that's what happens when you wind up in that kind of a fight. And yeah, it's, the issue is that this becomes an excuse that like, well, this is inevitable to some extent, becomes like, so we can't get angry when guys do it. As opposed to, no, that means if you think this war is really necessary, you actually have to punish those guys immediately and incredibly harshly, even though you know it's going to happen to some of them. And that's going to be bad to morale because otherwise, things get much worse and you wind up defeating your own attempts to win hearts and minds and stop people from trying to kill your dudes, which
58:40 Robert Evans? is what happens in Afghanistan. There's a direct correlation in province, a lot of provinces, between war crimes committed by Navy SEALs and excesses by US Special Forces and the number of Taliban fighters in activity and recruitment and whatnot, right? This stuff pisses people off. Just like I mean Abu Ghraib around the same time in Iraq, really pisses people off, right? It pisses a lot of Iraqis off. It generates more resistance because it's horrifying to see Americans doing stuff like this to dudes in your country. And this, you know, this is the thing that frustrates me most in some ways about the SEALs, which is that they understand that their job is to be extraordinary and they're very proud of that, but they think this really only extends, there's too many of them, think that this really only extends to their ability to kill, not their ability to keep their head and their sense of morality in a horrific situation. I would say, if you want to call
59:25 Robert Evans? yourselves truly elite, the best of the best, exquisitely trained, those are the guys that you can trust, would be able to trust, to put into a situation like this for months at a time and then not start massacring civilians. I would say that's an elite unit. When you do this kind of shit, were you just like the Taliban?
59:41 Speaker 01 Right.
59:42 Robert Evans? Right?
59:43 Speaker 01 That part, right.
59:43 Robert Evans? Why do I feel better about you than them?
59:45 Speaker 01 We forgot what the actual elite part is. Yeah, of course.
59:46 Robert Evans? Right, exactly.
59:47 Speaker 01 Just a little bit of fucking self-control.
59:49 Robert Evans? Yeah, yeah. Because honestly, if you're supposed to be elite, your actual stated job is, live with the pigs and don't get dirty.
59:56 Speaker 01 Yeah.
59:57 Robert Evans? Because you're better than them, if you are. But you're not, right?
1:00:01 Speaker 01 I never have.
1:00:01 Robert Evans? And they want to be while acting the same way, right?
1:00:06 Robert Evans? Anyway, and I think part of the reality is that like, Richard Marcinko and a lot of Team Six guys after him just wanted to be really well-funded and supported pigs, you know, unfortunately.
1:00:15 Speaker 01 Right, right, right.
1:00:17 Robert Evans? That attitude is still present among some people in Team Six in 2002, and almost 20 years after Marenko's departure, it's present certainly in chunks of the SEALs across a number of different teams. The brutality in Afghanistan divided the men, who saw themselves as private professionals and hearkened back to the old UDT days, from the men more poured in Marenko's mold. And this would come to a head in early March of 2002, after Hyder's mutilation of the wounded man and after Roberts' ridge, right? So this is all going down in like, the spring of 2002. Roughly 40 SEAL Team Six men meet at Bagram Air Base to discuss what Hyder had done and what had happened to Roberts and be like, so should we just like, start committing war crimes because the Taliban are, what do
1:00:59 Robert Evans? we do? And they talk, and the claim that Cole reports in his book is that 35 of the 40 guys wound up agreeing, we can shoot them and move on, but we don't mutilate them. That's not honorable, right? But five guys are like, I think I should be able to mutilate people. I don't know if that's the actual ratio. It doesn't seem impossible to believe. And I think the ratio would be a lot worse today, to be honest, you know? I can believe that in 2002, maybe that that's much earlier, right?
1:01:23 Speaker 01 Well, it's like the bad apples thing. It's just like the bunch is getting spoiled, guys.
1:01:27 Robert Evans? Exactly. And this this bunch who vote not to mutilate corpses are still responsible for helping to spoil the rest of the apples because even though they agree, we don't do that, that's not honorable. And they don't like Hyder, no one reports his war crime. He's not punished, right? He's pushed out of the teams quietly, right? And they'll deny, they won't let him get posted there again, but that's it, you know? Like, they're not, because you don't do that in the SEALs. You don't punish your own guys, you know?
1:01:55 Speaker 01 Jesus.
1:01:55 Robert Evans? This is Marcinco's favorite way of dealing with SEALs who didn't fit in, right? Um, just, you know, icing them out of the of the of the team. But it also means that the established standard is that guys who commit war crimes get iced out and not punished and often continue their military careers elsewhere. This is well known to the rest of the Navy. Susan Razer, a retired Naval Criminal Investigative Service agent, told Matthew Cole her opinion that, quote, "The SEALs believe that they can handle the discipline themselves. That's equal or greater to what the criminal justice system would give to that person." And reading between the lines, I think that at least some of this refusal to hold their own accountable comes from a fear that a lot of the saner SEALs have of their more piratical peers and colleagues, right?
1:02:40 Robert Evans? You get some of this in an account of that meeting by a retired, that big SEAL meeting about whether we should mutilate corpses. Uh, and this is from a retired non-commissioned SEAL. Fifi, that's Roberts, was mutilated. And then we had to address a very important question. How do you get the guy's head straight to mitigate any retaliation for Fifi? Otherwise, we knew it's going to get out of control. A third of the guys literally think they're Apache warriors. Then you had the Muslim way of moving ahead. I understand the desire. I don't condone it, but there was definite retaliation. Right?
1:03:07 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:03:07 Robert Evans? So again, you've got this guy who's trying to defend his unit, but he's too honest to be like, yeah, but like, these guys are, a lot of these guys are literally insane. And the fact that like some of these Taliban guys are pretty out there too, is just making them crazier. It's feeding into their delusions. You've got two groups of really extreme, heavily armed maniacs hunting each other and it's making them all get hideously more violent. Especially to the civilians.
1:03:28 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:03:28 Robert Evans? That's this guy's argument.
1:03:30 Speaker 01 And we're the good guys.
1:03:31 Robert Evans? And we're the good guys, though. Even though you really can't tell the difference from looking at all the brains splattered on the ground.
1:03:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, God.
1:03:38 Robert Evans? So in this account, Hyder's mutilation gets sort of grandfathered in under the general belief that we have to allow some kind of retaliation from the craziest of the SEALs in order to keep the units functional. Hyder, for his part, denies that he ever desecrated the body of an enemy fighter or a dead enemy civilian to this day. Quote, "This is what Hyder said. Somebody else is making this up. Memories get distorted over 14 years. They're telling you how they remember it. There was a lot of chaos. I'm telling you the absolute truth." I actually don't know who's right. You know, to be honest, it's entirely possible someone besides Hyder did that mutilation should get fucked up. Like, stuff like that happens. People forget, like, it's war fucks with your mind even if you're there. I don't, I don't, I literally don't know. But so many guys talk about this that like, I think, well, I know what the likeliest thing is, right?
1:04:23 Robert Evans? It's more or less the story that most of these SEALs told, Cole. A lot of, or several SEALs told Cole. So Team Six leadership analyzed Hyder's performance after their deployment and concluded that he'd been a dangerous officer for several reasons. Despite being a ground commander, he'd repeatedly killed perceived enemies on his own rather than having his men do it. And again, the officer is supposed to be able to fight. You need to sometimes, but you're there for other reasons. You're the officer. There's a reason. If you're constantly just shooting dudes that you don't like need to.
1:04:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:04:51 Robert Evans? Then that kind of means you're not doing your job as an officer, right?
1:04:53 Speaker 01 Right. It's like one thing if the assistant manager pulls a slurpee himself, but like.
1:04:57 Robert Evans? Yes.
1:04:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:04:58 Robert Evans? Yeah, and does it once, but if you're constantly doing it, like, you're kind of not doing your other job. And one former SEAL called this "a total breakdown of operational tactics." This also gets back to something Marcinko seeded into the unit. Officers and enlisted have very different, but not lesser, job descriptions. That's the way it should work, right? You need both. However, Marcinko's culture totally venerated the enlisted man and demonized officers. So insecure guys like Hyder came to feel that the best way to earn their place as a real pipe hitter is to just start blasting dudes as soon as they see them. And this is not going to be the last time that causes a problem, but this is the end of Part Three.
1:05:33 Speaker 02 We did it.
1:05:35 Speaker 01 Yay. Oh, still grim, still grim as fuck.
1:05:39 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:05:40 Robert Evans? It's gonna get grimmer.
1:05:44 Robert Evans? I don't know why I said it that way.
1:05:45 Speaker 02 Andrew, you wanna do a plug?
1:05:47 Speaker 01 Sure, sure. Um, let's see, I used to do the Yo, is this racist podcast. We're putting that on pause a little bit, but in the same feed, we're doing a podcast called Star Trek. That's me, Tony Newsome, our producer is Jesse Gender. We're also on YouTube. Uh, I'm watching a lot of Star Trek for the first time. They're watching a lot of Star Trek for like the billionth time. So, uh, yeah, it's, it's been fun. It's been nice to not to take a little racism break. Surprise, surprise, still plenty of shit to talk about in Star Trek.
1:06:19 Robert Evans? Well, listeners, why don't you all take a racism break and we'll be back on Thursday.
1:06:24 Speaker 02 Huzzah.
1:06:25 Speaker 01 Peace.
1:06:28 Speaker 02 Behind the Bastards is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Full video episodes of Behind the Bastards are now streaming on Netflix, dropping every Tuesday and Thursday. Hit Remind Me on Netflix so you don't miss an episode. For clips and our older episode catalog, continue to subscribe to our YouTube channel, youtube.com slash at Behind the Bastards. We love about 40% of you, statistically speaking.
1:07:03 Speaker 06 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 make it happen fast. Rated A plus by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star Trust Pilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
1:07:30 Speaker 07 I'm Donald Faison and I'm in a new movie called Christmas at the Kringle's. At first, it looks like a fun Christmas comedy, but then it gets weird, really weird. Imagine moving next door to a family that celebrates Christmas 365 days a year. Then imagine finding out they may not have the best intentions. The movie mixes comedy, action, suspense, and holiday chaos. We've got a great cast, including Ron Livingston, Rachel Bilson, Rob Riggle, Thomas Lennon, and more. If you like holiday movies and a totally unexpected twist, this one's for you. Christmas at the Kringle's opens exclusively in theaters October 30th. Rated R. Grab some friends and go see it on the big screen. Check out the trailer and get your tickets now.
1:08:08 Speaker 04 This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. You know those little promises you make to your future self? Tomorrow, I'll put my phone away earlier, or stop rehearsing arguments in the shower. Tomorrow, I'll stop saying yes to everything, or stop overthinking that conversation. Most of us aren't trying to become completely different people. We're just hoping to feel a little better every day. That's what's great about BetterHelp. With them, better is personal. It's matching with a therapist who gets you and having someone in your corner. Better doesn't have to come from major victories. It can be from the small habits you create and how you honor your needs on a daily basis. So many of us are great at prioritizing even the smallest things for our loved ones. But what about ourselves?
1:08:52 Speaker 04 With thousands of therapists and millions of members in over 100 countries, BetterHelp is making therapy more accessible so more people can keep moving forward, one conversation at a time. Better is personal. Therapy should be too. Visit betterhelp.com to get 10% off your first month. That's betterhelp.com. Having peace of mind for your home, family, and connected life is more important than ever. Introducing Xfinity Shield, a force field for your home and devices with built-in Wi-Fi features that protect from threats at home and online. With the Xfinity Gateway, you can detect movement in your home. No cameras needed. Plus, get always-on protection for all your devices the moment you connect, so you can rest easy and stream more of your favorite podcasts on iHeartRadio.
1:09:36 Speaker 04 Get it now at xfinity.com/shield. Xfinity. Imagine that. Restrictions apply. Not available in all areas. Xfinity Internet and compatible equipment required.
1:09:44 Speaker 03 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
Previous It Could Happen Here Weekly 241 Next Part Four: How The Navy SEALs Lost Their Mind Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated