Pod Insights Behind the Bastards It Could Happen Here Weekly 230 About this episode All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file.
- The Age of Extremophiles
- Libya with Andrew
- Gaddafi with Andrew
- Zohran Mamdani's First 100 Days
- Executive Disorder: White House Correspondents Shooting, Voting Rights Act
You can now listen to all Cool Zone Media shows, 100% ad-free through the Cooler Zone Media subscription, available exclusively on Apple Podcasts. So, open your Apple Podcasts app, search for “Cooler Zone Media” and subscribe today!
http://apple.co/coolerzone
Sources/Links:
Libya with Andrew
Iran retaliation: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cjrqqd8lw2wo
Timeline of Libyan History: https://www.britannica.com/place/Libya/History
Timeline of Libyan revolt: https://www.britannica.com/event/Libya-Revolt-of-2011
Behind the NTC: http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/1062/2/who-drove-the-libyan-uprising
Consequences and Motivations of Libya intervention: https://jacobin.com/2015/02/libya-intervention-nato-imperialism
https://web.archive.org/web/20220517202837/https://merip.org/2011/11/was-the-libya-intervention-necessary/
https://jacobin.com/2021/03/nato-libya-war-uk-us-france-regime-change
https://jacobin.com/2011/09/libya-and-the-left
Rebel abuses: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-14891913
Targeting of Black Libyans and Migrants: https://www.npr.org/2011/10/20/141549384/blacks-and-migrants-targets-of-attack-in-libya
Displacement numbers in 2012: https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/legacy-pdf/4ec23100b.pdf
Consequences of first civil war: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/24/libya-capital-under-islamist-control-tripoli-airport-seized-operation-dawn
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2015/2/16/libya-anniversary-the-situation-is-just-terrible
An attempt at unification: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/dec/17/libyan-politicians-sign-un-peace-deal-unify-rival-governments
El Sharara oilfield situation: https://middle-east-online.com/node/708060
The status quo as of 2020: https://www.politico.eu/article/the-libyan-conflict-explained/
Another attempt at unification: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/3/15/libya-interim-government-sworn-in-replacing-rival-administration
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/9/21/libya-parliament-withdraws-confidence-from-unity-government
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/3/3/un-voices-concern-over-vote-on-new-libyan-prime-minister
Morality police: https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/fears-religious-freedom-libya-proposes-new-morality-police
Slave auction: https://africasacountry.com/2017/11/the-slave-auction-in-libya
Libya’s arms in regional instability: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-libya-arms-un-idUSBRE93814Y20130409/
Natural disaster: https://www.al-monitor.com/originals/2024/09/year-rebuilding-libyas-flood-hit-derna-plagued-politics
https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/libya-floods-derna-turkish-firm-said-repaired-dam-did-it
Gaddafi with Andrew
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Muammar-al-Qaddafi
https://www.britannica.com/place/Libya/
Libya: The History of Gaddafi's Pariah State By John Oakes
Qaddafi and the Libyan revolution By David Blundy, Andrew Lycett
https://africasacountry.com/2017/12/the-return-of-muammar-gaddafi
https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2013/10/03/gaddafis-harem-book
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-16289543
https://newint.org/features/web-exclusive/2016/02/17/what-happened-to-the-other-libyans
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329567625_A_Linguistic_Liberation_of_Gaddafi%27s_Libya_From_Near-Extinction_to_an_Imminent_Revitalization_of_Amazigh
https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/features/2018/10/13/tebu-cultural-awakening-we-may-not-be-arabs-but-we-are-libyan
https://marxist.com/nature-of-gaddafi-regime.htm
https://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/23/business/23views.html
Gaddafi’s relations with the West: https://libcom.org/article/lies-slaughter-capital-2011-nato-intervention-libya-part-two
https://libcom.org/article/libyan-peoples-committees-should-be-foundation-new-life-not-just-interim-measure
https://www.hrw.org/news/2012/09/05/us-torture-and-rendition-gaddafis-libya
https://www.hrw.org/news/2011/09/09/secret-intelligence-documents-discovered-libya
Zohran Mamdani's First 100 Days
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZGdfQ-kPTI
https://www.nyc.gov/content/100days/pages/
https://www.nyc.gov/site/hpd/news/004-26/mamdani-administration-stricter-enforcement-city-s-250-most-distressed-apartment
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/01/mamdani-administration-announces-historic--2-1-million-settlemen
https://www.nyc.gov/content/tenantprotection/pages/pinnacle-tenants
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/01/mayor-mamdani-signs-eo-to-revitalize-mayor-s-office-to-protect-t
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/03/mayor-mamdani-announces-historic--2-1m-court-judgment-against-br
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/02/mayor-mamdani--nycha-announce--38-4-million-investment-to-bring-
https://www.nyc.gov/site/nycha/about/sustainability.page
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/03/mamdani-administration-launches-new-program-to-deliver-affordabl
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/03/mayor-mamdani-advances-new-york-city-s-first-free-child-care-pro
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/03/transcript--mayor-mamdani-announces-major-3-k-expansion--adding-
https://www.thecity.nyc/2026/02/19/mamdani-budget-parks-libraries/
https://www.thecity.nyc/2026/02/10/homeless-deaths-cold-hearing-wasow-park/
https://citylimits.org/the-mayor-promises-a-new-approach-to-encampment-sweeps-homeless-advocates-dont-buy-it/
https://citylimits.org/the-mayor-promises-a-new-approach-to-encampment-sweeps-homeless-advocates-dont-buy-it/
https://gothamist.com/news/can-columbus-ohio-teach-the-nypd-about-crowd-control-mamdani-wants-to-find-out
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/04/09/nyregion/mamdani-nypd-tisch-police.htmlhttps://gothamist.com/news/mayor-mamdani-signals-openness-to-nypd-gang-database-citing-reforms
https://gothamist.com/news/mayor-mamdani-signals-openness-to-nypd-gang-database-citing-reforms
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/03/mayor-mamdani-appoints-renita-francois-as-deputy-mayor-for-commu
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/03/mamdani-administration-secures-nearly--2m-in-restitution-for-800
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/01/mayor-mamdani-announces--5-million-settlement--reinstatement-of-
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/04/mayor-mamdani-announces-la-marqueta-as-first-site-identified-for
https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/04/mayor-mamdani--governor-hochul-announce-state-s-first-pied-a-ter
Executive Disorder: White House Correspondents Shooting, Voting Rights Act
https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/28083136/allen.pdf
https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2026/04/29/congress/section-702-passes-house-00899071
https://www.atf.gov/rules-and-regulations/atf-launches-new-era-reform
https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/federal-grand-jury-indicts-former-fbi-director-james-comey-threats-harm-president-trump
https://www.cnn.com/2026/04/28/media/fcc-kimmel-disney-abc-trump-licenses
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/04/24/business/media/david-ellison-trump-cbs-news.htmlhttps://www.maine.gov/governor/mills/news/governor-mills-announces-decision-ld-307-2026-04-24
https://www.maine.gov/governor/mills/news/governor-mills-announces-decision-ld-307-2026-04-24
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cp846668401o
https://www.ukmto.org/recent-incidents#fae0af84-bd4a-4a4d-86d0-cb7166ef4691
https://www.usgs.gov/news/national-news-release/lithium-eastern-states-could-replace-imports-a-century-or-more
https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/116474434041424846
https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/governor-sinaloa-and-nine-other-current-and-former-mexican-officials-charged-drug
https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/24-109_21o3.pdf
https://www.npr.org/2026/04/30/nx-s1-5805050/supreme-court-voting-rights-congressional-black-caucus
https://www.linkedin.com/in/cole-allen-003804b7/
https://www.fec.gov/data/receipts/individual-contributions/?contributor_name=cole+allen&contributor_zip=90501 https://www.fec.gov/data/receipts/individual-contributions/?contributor_name=cole+allen&contributor_zip=90501
https://x.com/MAGAVoice/status/2048180791356821988?s=20
https://www.timemachine.eu/study-on-quality-in-3d-digitisation-of-tangible-cultural-heritage/
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20150004067
https://x.com/infolibnews/status/2048222643237601457?s=20
https://x.com/aishahhasnie/status/2048274579043336397
https://x.com/TheRealJChubby/status/2048513664286924938?s=20
https://x.com/BonkDaCarnivore/status/2048220342678597688?s=20
https://ww3.ca2.uscourts.gov/decisions/OPN/25-3141_complete_opn.pdf
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/02/17/2026-02994/determination-pursuant-to-section-102-of-the-illegal-immigration-reform-and-immigrant-responsibility
https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/c5d05c7ba737452f85f7b9ee4b2ea99a#data_s=id%3AdataSource_4-59220b9613c647f49771f495924d5772%3A973
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28051570-friends-of-the-ruidosa-church-v-secretary-markwayne-mullin-april-2026/
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 36,007 words · 21 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human.
0:04 Speaker 01 Cash Flow Crunch. OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds, up to $200,000, right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
0:34 Speaker 02 Honestly, honestly. Honestly, no one wants to think about HIV, but there are things that everyone can do to help prevent it. Things like PrEP. PrEP stands for pre-exposure prophylaxis, and it means routinely taking prescription medicine before you're exposed to HIV to help reduce your chances of getting it. PrEP can be about 99% effective when taken as prescribed. It doesn't protect against other STIs, though, so be sure to use condoms and other healthy sex practices. Ask a healthcare provider about all your prevention options and visit findoutaboutprep.com to learn more. Sponsored by Gilead.
1:05 Speaker 03 I turned off news altogether. I hate to say it, but I don't trust much of anything.
1:12 Speaker 04 It's the rage bait.
1:15 Speaker 05 It feels like it's trying to divide people.
1:19 Speaker 04 We got clear facts. Maybe we can calm down a little.
1:24 Speaker 06 NBC News brings you clear reporting. Let's meet at the facts. Let's move forward from there. NBC News, reporting for America.
1:35 Speaker 07 This January, bare-knuckle fighting championship takes over the ocean. The inaugural Brew's Crew sails from Miami to the Bahamas aboard the Norwegian Jewel. Three straight days with pool-deck bare-knuckle fights in the Caribbean. Mess of parties, beach events, DJs, cigars, tequila tastings, and nonstop action. The lineup reveals coming soon. Cabins are disappearing fast, and the prices won't stay this low. Reserve your spot with just $200 down at bkfsea.com.
2:06 Speaker 08 Call Zone Media.
2:08 Robert Evans? Hey, everybody. Robert Evans here, and I wanted to let you know this is a compilation episode. So every episode of the week that just happened is here in one convenient and with somewhat less ads package for you to listen to in a long stretch if you want. If you've been listening to the episodes every day this week, there's going to be nothing new here for you, but you can make your own decisions.
2:33 Robert Evans? Hey, everybody. This is It Could Happen here, and I am Robert Evans. And initially, this was supposed to be a slightly different episode. I have been pondering over the fact recently that I feel weirdly optimistic, particularly in the last couple of weeks, especially compared to a lot of the people that I know and spent time around. And I think it's because I've been interpreting some of the same pieces of news differently than they have, and because I've been coming across some different pieces of information than they have. And I wanted to kind of walk people through why I've been feeling so optimistic. And so I wrote something, and I recorded it around Thursday of last week. And then over the weekend, a gunman attacked the White House Correspondents' Dinner. And actually,
3:16 Robert Evans? this hasn't really changed any of my overall feelings. We'll talk about that this week, probably on ED. But I did make some alterations to the episode as a result of that, although I do think it reinforces my primary point, which is that the political era that we now find ourselves in is one dominated by extremophiles. Extremophiles are organisms with unique cellular and molecular mechanisms that allow them to survive and thrive in extreme habitats. I'm talking about places like volcanic vents at the very bottom of the ocean, or the Dead Sea. If you've ever wondered why it's called the Dead Sea, it's because for a very long time, people thought it was too salty to
3:56 Robert Evans? host any life. Modern research has disabused us of this notion. The Dead Sea hosts life. It's just weird life, because the Dead Sea is a weird place. The term extremophile was coined in 1974 by R. D. McElroy to describe microorganisms scientists were increasingly finding in places that should have been devoid of life. The word is a hybrid term that literally means "love of extremes." And while it is usually used in a scientific context to describe small organisms in very odd locations, some experts have, over the years, pointed out that the label might well apply to humans, too. In the journal article "All About Extremophiles," Johns Hopkins University's James A. Coker wrote that, quote, "Despite common perception, most of Earth is what is often referred to
4:41 Robert Evans? as an extreme environment. Yet to the organisms that call these places home, it is simply that: home. They have adapted to thrive in these environments, and, in the process, have evolved many unique adaptations at the molecular and atomic level." In our human-centric view of the planet Earth, we tend to think of ourselves as being in the Goldilocks zone, not too hot or too cold, protected from radiation, and filled with all the things necessary for life to exist. To some extent, this is true. However, this view keeps us from acknowledging several basic facts, including that the Earth is mostly a cold place, over 90% of its oceans are at or below 5 degrees Celsius, and it has an average temperature of around 15 degrees Celsius. And several conditions we humans consider 'normal,' i.e. 20% oxygen in the air, actually
5:26 Robert Evans? make us extremophiles from the point of view of other species." End quote. Now, I have a bad tendency to want to apply literal knowledge like this metaphorically to my understanding of politics. It's a bit of a sickness, but it also makes more sense sometimes than you'd expect. There's a tendency, among many millennials and even Gen Z and Alpha kids, too young to have known the 90s, to look back on that decade as a sort of cultural Goldilocks zone, as if the brief period post-Cold War and pre-9/11 was some sort of cultural peak for our species, and everything since has been a slow downhill slide. People have different reasons for this, some of them blame 9/11. Some people argue that we were in that sweet spot where the internet existed and could
6:08 Robert Evans? tap you into cool and interesting things, but social media hadn't come along yet and ruined it all. You know, different people come up with different justifications for this. But this view keeps people from acknowledging some very basic facts about the 1990s, which is that it were full of genocides, in Rwanda and Bosnia, just to name two, and repeated US military adventures and misadventures in other parts of the globe, some of which ended disastrously, as in Mogadishu. Our president, for most of the 90s, was a sex pest, and members of the far-right staged a series of bloody terrorist attacks, including the Oklahoma City bombing and Olympic Park bombing. And while all this was happening, a new and more openly extremist Republican Party captured Congress while hapless outmaneuvered Democrats gawked in awe.
6:53 Robert Evans? The reality is that the 90s were a time of extremity, of extreme weirdness and darkness, just like every other period of human existence. And the extremity of the era helped birth a new conservative movement, one radical enough to wrench power from the liberals and bring us ultimately into the slavering jaws of the Bush era. Today, those same neoconservatives seem tame next to their modern descendants, the MAGA movement. But in their own time, they were the craziest bastards out there, and this hits at a fundamental reality in American politics. If survival in extreme times requires extreme adaptations, then it's no wonder that for much of our lives, the extremists are the ones who have primarily thrived electorally.
7:35 Robert Evans? Democrats like to forget this, but Bill Clinton felt like a pretty big swing to folks exiting the era of Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush, just as Barack Obama was seen as the most extreme choice imaginable by roughly half of this country. In fact, he was such an extreme choice that the conservative movement had to birth the Tea Party, and eventually the MAGA movement, in order to unseat the Democratic Party and repeal the changes from the Obama years in power. I like thinking about this stuff because I find it interesting that one common theme from evolutionary biology to modern politics is this: In extreme environments, extreme adaptations are necessary to survive. We Homo sapiens have been in the business of extreme adaptations for as long as we've existed.
8:18 Robert Evans? That's all central heating and air, vaccines, antibiotics, and the AR-15 are: adaptations to extreme environments and situations, many of them, extreme environments and situations that we created for ourselves. The problem is, our adaptations have a nasty tendency to drive even more extreme circumstances, which in turn foster further adaptations, and so on and so forth until we invent the internet and satellite-guided thermonuclear bombs. Extreme adaptations are not always good. But once you've found yourself thrown into an extreme environment, you can't just wish the weather was different. You've got to adapt. That's the bad news about our current political situation. The good news is that the pendulum has started to swing back our way.
9:01 Robert Evans? The extremism of the Trump era is provoking its own equal but opposite reaction, and you can see the first stirrings of that in the popularity of Zohran Mamdani, or the fact that a former pillow of neoconservatism like Bill Kristol is currently advocating for the abolition of ICE. We are in the process of deciding the next extreme that will dominate American politics, which means we have the opportunity to adapt with policies and changes that are every bit as good as the ones the Trump administration has forced through our bad. To do that, we're going to have to be brave, and we're going to have to start getting our shit together now, because this window of opportunity won't last long. The way I see it, the GOP entered office this time around intent on waging the political equivalent of a shock and awe campaign.
9:46 Robert Evans? They burnt up any goodwill or benefit of the doubt they might have had in an orgy of careless and brutal cuts to basic government functions, carried out by the least sympathetic group of groypers imaginable, one of whom was nicknamed "Big Balls." A flurry of state and local legislative pushes and criminal investigations aimed at hurting left-wing activists and queer, particularly trans, people have done tremendous damage, as have relentless ICE raids on mostly non-white Americans. It's been bad, and yet, we're still here. I won't pretend we're in a good situation today, not, at least in terms of what we'd like "good to mean" in the everyday sense of the word. Many of us haven't survived the first 16 months or so of the second Trump presidency. Fewer of us are going to make it to the end.
10:29 Robert Evans? But this regime came to power with the knowledge that their success or failure hinged on speed and violence of action. They had a limited window to make resistance impossible, and they missed it. You can see some evidence of this in our war of choice against Iran. President Trump wanted a quick, brutal triumph that would look good on the evening news, so he told his military to bear down on Iran with all the speed and violence of action they could muster. That plan failed, and the reasons why are weirdly similar to how the Republican Party has overplayed their hand in our ongoing culture war. Back in Trump's first term, the DOD established the Algorithmic Warfare Cross-functional Team, nicknamed "Project Maven." The goal of the project, as per Lieutenant General Jack Shanahan, was to automate the
11:12 Robert Evans? analysis of drone footage and other data humans previously would have gone over by hand, in order to speed up the rate at which targets were identified and struck in wartime. Project Maven from the jump was a product of the worst kind of military thinking. How can we automate as much of our planning of warfare as possible? This is the kind of project you pursue when your finest military minds still believe that victory is as simple as killing or destroying a preset number of bad guys, causing them to give up. The goal was to create a system that could collate and synthesize huge quantities of data in order to allow 1,000 targeting decisions per hour. Kevin Baker, writing for The Guardian, notes that this means, quote, "3.6 seconds per
11:55 Robert Evans? decision," or from the individual targeteers' perspective, "one decision every 72 seconds." Now, we're going to talk about where this kind of thinking has led us in our conflict with Iran, but first, here's some ads.
12:18 Robert Evans? We're back. Now, if you listen to the advocates in this kind of military buildup, the people who are really bullish on AI for military purposes, talk in their podcasts and on their blogs, the reasoning behind why you need to be able to make 1,000 targeting decisions per hour is pretty obvious. They're obsessed with the idea that a future war between the US and a peer or near-peer adversary, most prominently China, right? That's what they're planning on. Now, the Chinese military is also heavily invested in AI. There was a major New York Times article earlier this month, in April of 2026, titled "Mutually Automated Destruction: The Escalating Global AI Arms Race." I'm going to quote from that now. "China and Russia are experimenting with letting AI make battlefield decisions on its
13:02 Robert Evans? own, two US officials said. China is developing systems for dozens of autonomous drones to coordinate attacks without human thought, while Russia is building Lancer drones that can circle the sky and autonomously pick targets," they said. "Even as the specifics of the technologies remain veiled, the intentions are clear. In 2017, Mr. Putin declared that whoever leads in AI will become the ruler of the world. Mr. Z said in 2024 that the technology would be the main battleground of geopolitical competition. In January, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth directed all branches of the US military to adopt AI, saying they needed to accelerate like hell." Now, my interpretation of what I've read from most of these guys is that they see future conflict as a massive but almost instantaneous chess game, right?
13:46 Robert Evans? Whoever has the AI that can most quickly and effectively sort through their intelligence, come up with target packages, and then strike those targets first, wins, right? If we can make a thousand decisions and a thousand strikes in an hour, and they can only make 800, then we'll destroy more of them, and we'll win the war, right? It'll all be decided right at the start. And this may well be how a shooting war between China and the US would proceed, but given that very few people in either country want that war to happen because it would kill us all, I think we might do best focusing on the war our country is currently fighting, where this logic has resulted in a catastrophic failure for at least the second time in my life. In 2003, the United States invaded Iraq after more than a year of buildup and years of intelligence gathering.
14:29 Robert Evans? Our military planners put together a list of 50 high-value targets. The idea was, if we could use our incredible, super-advanced spying equipment and our precision-guided weapons to wipe out the most important figures of resistance in Iraq, we could hobble any response to the invasion. All 50 targets were struck. None of the people targeted were killed. Now, that doesn't mean no one was killed, it just means we missed all the people we thought we were going to hit. To quote from Kevin Baker's great article again, "The targeting cycle had been fast enough to hit 50 buildings and too fast to discover it was hitting the wrong ones." Fast forward to earlier this year. The Trump administration orders the launch of Operation Epic Fury and unleashed a nightmare arsenal of hyper-advanced weaponry on the people and leaders of Iran alongside the
15:13 Robert Evans? Israeli Air Force. In the first two weeks, US forces hit 6,000 targets, picked with the help of Project Maven. One of them was the Manab Girls Elementary School, which was destroyed by a missile, killing 156 and wounding 95.
15:28 Robert Evans? Now, Alex Karp, the CEO of Palantir's hyper-advanced AI and a multi-billion-dollar network of satellites backed up by decades of intelligence gathering by the CIA and the Mossad, wasn't enough to stop us from striking a school that we knew contained none of our targets. We had data that the people we thought were there at one point were no longer there, and it was a school now. But some of the data Maven relied on was old and outdated, and these machines aren't capable of real judgment in the way we think of it. And because people trusted them so much, no one thought to check before ordering the strikes. This is a human error. This is not an AI error. But it illustrates a massive flaw in the fantasy that winning a war could be as easy as building a smarter machine. Now, to be accurate, and it is important to note,
16:14 Robert Evans? a lot of those 6,000 targets were what we thought, and they were accurately struck and killed in the opening salvo of the war. President Trump and his mouthpieces celebrated their successful assassination of Iran's supreme leader alongside many other prominent military and governmental officials. This seemed at first to be way more successful than the opening strikes against Iraq. They didn't get any of those 50 guys. We got a bunch of our initial targets in this first wave of strikes. Maybe we just didn't have the right technology when we invaded Iraq. Maybe now we're doing it right, you know? Finally, we'll be able to win a war this way. However, that quickly proved untrue. All of those strikes put together were not enough to break Iran's will or its capacity to fight and fight back effectively. Now Donald Trump finds himself trapped in an expensive quagmire, one that is already bleeding him
16:59 Robert Evans? advanced munitions and equipment while it crashes the global economy. Most recent AP NORC poll puts Trump's overall approval at 33%, which is down 5% since just back in March. Only 32% of Americans approve of his leadership on Iran, because most of this country can still see a man shooting himself in the dick for what it is. Pete Hegseth is our most lethality-obsessed Secretary of Defense and history, and in him we see the result of a long sickness, first incubated during the Vietnam War, when embarrassed generals needed to spin their failure to make progress as a kind of victory. So they turned to bragging about how many fighters they'd killed, inevitably defining many civilian dead as enemy combatants, and bragging about the tonnage of trucking that they'd destroyed,
17:44 Robert Evans? based on wildly incomplete and inaccurate intelligence. Ever since this calamitous era, informed students of military theory have seen doing body counts as the death knell of a military entity's ability to make intelligent decisions that move their forces closer to victory. But because the entire conservative project in this country is built on the thoughtless worship of military prowess and power, we've seen this kind of thinking trickle down to the Sarekadra of influencers who call themselves right-wing intellectuals today. I'm talking about dudes like Matt Walsh and Chris Ruffo, who've built their reputations on picking targets to drum up mobs against and use as the basis of attack ads. These people have proven legitimately good at stirring up hate and forcing laws all over the country restricting things like drag shows
18:28 Robert Evans? or the use of chosen pronouns in government documents. All these people are, by definition, huge assholes, and so are their followers. And thus, when those people get radicalized to take action in their communities, they make those communities worse. This pisses off their neighbors, which has resulted in significant backlash across the country. As an example, Moms for Liberty was formed in Florida on January 1st, 2021, by Republican activists and former school board members who were outraged about pandemic safety protocols in schools. It became a vehicle for the parental rights movement, a nebulous and deeply toxic force in American political life that sees the parent as a kind of absolute sovereign over the life and mind of their child. Any influence that might lead that child to become a different kind of person than the parent envisions
19:13 Robert Evans? must be pruned away. The group used the then-fresh moral panic over critical race theory as a lever from which to force themselves into American life. In June of 2021, they started filing what would become a long series of criminal complaints against books available in specific school libraries across the nation. Schools started removing books, and Moms for Liberty-inspired candidates began winning school board elections around the country. It looked, for a little while, like a popular wave of hysterical fear might yank America into a Fahrenheit 451-style future, slightly ahead of schedule. But just a couple of years later, a funny thing happened. Moms for Liberty-backed candidates started losing major elections. First, a series of school
19:53 Robert Evans? board races in 2023 in Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Iowa. But even as the Biden administration careened towards a disastrous new election in 2024, one in which the far right seemed to have all the momentum, regular people kept rising up and organizing to protect their schools. One of the first was Karen Sfoboda, a mother of seven in Dutchess County, New York. In 2023, she told NPR reporter Jim Zeroli, "I looked into the local Facebook page of Moms for Liberty and just browsed through some of the social media of some of these individuals, and what I saw was very upsetting. As a mom of kids who are members of that community, it was very concerning to think that these people would be trying to get onto the school board, because what does that mean for my kids?" So she started a group of her own, Defense of Democracy, which organized like-minded parents in her
20:38 Robert Evans? community to warn each other about Moms for Liberty. It defeated an entire slate of Moms for Liberty-backed candidates in 2023, all with the infrastructure of a Facebook page and weekly Zoom calls. And the really remarkable thing is that even while the 2024 election took over the national discourse and the Democratic Party completely shat the bed, people kept connecting and organizing in school districts across the country to fight for their children's educations. In November of 2025, the Houston suburb of Cypress, Texas, saw Democratic candidates sweep three school board seats and take the majority, ending two years of Republican dominance. This trend was repeated elsewhere that same month for a political article by Liz Crampton and Madison Fernandez. In Pennsylvania, Democrats slipped at least two dozen
21:22 Robert Evans? school board seats per an ongoing tally from Progressive Recruitment Group Pipeline Fund. The under-the-radar trend was enabled by voters' increasing weariness with the culture wars that helped the MAGA movement engineer school board takeovers and generate hyper-local interest in politics as the COVID-19 pandemic raged. In addition to Texas, Republicans lost seats in the suburbs of Columbus, Ohio, and the national battleground of Pennsylvania, the result of well-funded campaigns orchestrated by local leaders.
21:47 Robert Evans? Now, one of my favorite details from that piece is a quote from one of the new school board members, Leslie Gilmard, who stated, "Folks just wanted their school boards to be boring again. They wanted normalcy. Once the board was taken over by a super-partisan extremist majority, folks across the political spectrum were dismayed." Now, I continue to be an advocate of the thought that Tim Walz might have made a more effective vice presidential candidate if he'd kept calling the Republicans out for being freaks, because they are. Their obsession with the lives and behavior of their fellow citizens and their naked, slavering need to control their neighbors is upsetting and unnatural. The way I see it, we're in a time of incredible opportunity right now. The devil has played his hand and wound up slipping on a puddle of his own flop sweat along the
22:28 Robert Evans? way. The momentum is with anyone but these fucks, at least right now, which is why a bunch of tertiary Trump supporters like Tucker Carlson have been cutting bait. Donald did the thing fascists often do: he kept reaching until he reached for something that exceeded his grasp. Now, I don't know what's going to happen next in our absolutely unnecessary struggle with Iran. I think there's a non-zero chance Trump tries to extricate our forces, say for some token, so Israel won't say we abandoned them, and tries to take out the Cuban government next. It's also possible he'll escalate the violence against Iran in some massive apocalyptic, hideous way. In either case, the human cost will be nightmarish, but either action would just be the flailing of a busted gambler, putting everything he has on a fantasy that Americans want to see foreign enemies broken while they can't
23:13 Robert Evans? afford to fill their car at home. Every poll of the American people seems to suggest that most of us has a pretty low appetite for unnecessary wars. Outside of Florida, it's hard to find regular people who are scared of the Cuban government. The idea that they represent any kind of threat to folks in Michigan or Kansas is absurd on its face. The further Trump reaches, the angrier people get. Fascist governments rely on the complicity of the masses even more than their enthusiastic support, and many Americans have proven themselves unwilling to be complicit in most of what the Heritage Foundation and their friends want for this country. And that's a nice note to roll to ads on.
24:01 Robert Evans? We're back. If you want a direct example of how weak the cultural conservatives are right now, think back to the stunt President Trump pulled with DoorDash earlier in April. He ordered several bags and had them delivered by a dasher who was there to get photographed praising the president's no tax on tips policy. While they were standing outside the Oval Office, Trump asked the dasher if they thought trans women should be allowed to compete in women's sports. And the dasher in question was 58-year-old Sharon Simmons, who was a, I mean, it's been widely reported, is a Republican activist. She'd previously spoken out in favor of the no tax on tips policy at the House Ways and Means Committee field hearing. And even when she was under the gun next to the president, Simmons wasn't willing to agree with him on the weird anti-trans stuff. She replied, "I don't really have
24:43 Robert Evans? an opinion on that." And I'm not here to call her a hero for that, she's not, but it shows a crack in the rhetorical wall these people have built for themselves. A Republican can't just support low taxes now. They have to endorse a whole raft of psychotic vengeance politics and anti-scientific views that are deeply alienating to anyone who has a chance of being called normal. Any discussion of life after Trump nowadays has to include an acknowledgement of the big lurking question of our age: what if he won't give up power? And that's a bigger question than the "just Trump." A large number of government officials, elected leaders, military officers, and law enforcement officers have implicated themselves in the crimes and what we might call the "ought to be" crimes of this administration. It's not unreasonable to ask, what if they won't leave power without a fight? And I
25:28 Robert Evans? don't have a comprehensive answer for you that I feel comfortable putting in the last couple pages of a podcast script. But I will point out that just in the last month, as I write this, Viktor Orban and his entire political movement faced sweeping defeat at the polls. Orban had been previously referred to as a quasi-dictatorial figure. He was the leader of the Hungarian government, and he had led a massive right-wing crackdown that attacked schools, that attacked the LGBT movement, and that became a major funder for much of our own right-wing movement. It's come out that the Orban government was sending money helping to fund CPAC. They were sending money to specific right-wing influencers like Rod Dreher. And despite the fact that Orban was the guy that people like Tucker Carlson a couple of years ago was saying, "This is the future of American politics.
26:12 Robert Evans? Orbanism is what we want." Despite that fact, when they lost an election, he and his cronies backed down without a fight. Now, ultimately, they did this because they still think they're bulletproof, right? We've got enough people in the government that we can stop Peter Magier, the new guy, from doing any damage to us, right? And thus, temporarily leaving power is an acceptable sacrifice because that lets us avoid a civil war, and the rest of the EU won't look kindly on that. I'm sure that's a lot of their thinking. And obviously, the US is in a very different position geopolitically. But the rapidity with which some former Trump stalwarts like Marjorie Taylor Greene and Alex Jones and Tucker Carlson have abandoned MAGA suggests one thing: they think it's more personally profitable for them to not be seen standing next to the president or
26:57 Robert Evans? the MAGA movement right now. And here's more good news. Remember how basically every social network is now owned by an openly evil right-wing billionaire? Well, Americans have responded to this by discarding social media and ever-growing numbers. This has been about one of the most consequential shifts of the last few years. And just this week, University of Amsterdam professor Peter Thornberg published a study on shifts in US social media use from 2020 to 2024. Quote, "Online platform reach declined, driven by growth in the share of Americans, especially the youngest and oldest cohorts, who report using no social media. Visiting and posting activity on Twitter slash X and Facebook have fallen by nearly 50% since 2020, with the decline on Twitter X driven primarily by reduced participation among Democratic users."
27:42 Robert Evans? And this is broadly speaking, a good thing for the mental health of Americans overall and for the future of our body politic. But the Americans who remain in social media aren't all doing so hot. Over the same time period, traffic on Twitter and Facebook grew markedly more right wing as both sites shrank. In his paper, Thornburg warns, "As casual users disengaged while polarized partisans remain vocal, online discourse becomes narrower and more ideologically extreme." Or, in other words, "As the algorithms that govern what gets seen on these shrinking social media sites reward more extreme content, less extreme users leave, and the ones who succeed and become more widely shared are the most extreme." It's, you know, another extremophile kind of situation.
28:26 Robert Evans? Part of why the people near Trump all believe they're winning is they live in these same internet fever swamps and they've gotten used to the internet mattering a lot more than it does right now. I don't mean to suggest that what happens online isn't important, but that importance has been softened by the sheer deluge of AI slop spam and weird right-wing propaganda that we've been forcibly drowned in for years. Less people are using these things than they used to, which means their reach has declined because people find them off-putting and gross. The data shows that folks particularly over 65 and under 24 are increasingly fed up with not just social media, but the whole state of affairs we've been locked in politically. In the recent Virginia governor's race, Democrat Abigail Spanberger won by a comfortable margin.
29:08 Robert Evans? Republicans devoted a huge amount of their budget against her to anti-trans attack ads, writing high off their inaccurate belief that anti-trans propaganda had won Trump the reelection in 2024. But only 4% of voters in that election listed transgender policies as a top issue. Now, that alone might just point to the overwhelming impulse towards centrism shared by much of the American middle class. People don't like to stand out, particularly as a political radical. But a year after Spanberger's election, a majority of Virginia voters approved a radical redistricting measure. This was entirely framed as a response to the Republican Party fighting for the right to redistrict several states in their favor. The usual chorus of voices piped up to say, "Oh, I don't know, guys. We shouldn't do the same thing they keep doing in order to defend ourselves.
29:53 Robert Evans? That doesn't seem fair." And this time, thank goodness, most people ignored them. The controversial measure outperformed Kamala Harris by eight points. And yes, a federal judge did immediately rule the measure unconstitutional. But you know how these things go. We're off to a series of court battles now. And however those end up, two useful things have been accomplished. The liberal majority of a state has banded together to fight the Republicans on their own terms, and a clear message has been sent to those same people that Republicans benefit from a different set of laws than Democrats. Now, any anarchist or leftist political organizer you've ever known would have told you the right wing always benefits from an interpretation of the law that, gee shucks, seems to deny their opponents the right to do the same things in self-defense.
30:37 Robert Evans? It's bad that things work this way, but good for rank-and-file liberals to be reminded of that reality. If it weren't, the current gatekeepers of our news media wouldn't be rallying so hard against this measure. The same day I wrote all of this, The Washington Post published an opinion column by Theodore Johnson titled "Why Virginia Went Back on Its Word." It opens with a particularly idiotic paragraph. "Partisanship did its best impression of democracy in Virginia on Tuesday. Voters approved a referendum permitting the state's congressional districts to be redrawn to help Democrats win four additional seats. It's retaliation to recent redistricting by Texas to hand Republicans five more seats at the behest of President Donald Trump. It's a red versus blue tit-for-tat over who can gerrymander more efficiently. A necessary evil, the party say, to protect democracy."
31:22 Robert Evans? It's actually not necessarily, I mean, not that it's a necessary evil, the party say, it's that one party was already doing this for years, the Republicans, and you didn't speak up. The Washington Post, you know, this guy didn't write the same column when this shit's been happening in other states. He only does it when Democrats do it in Virginia, right? And I also might point out to Theo that a majority of voters approving a measure is democracy. You know, if your only concern is the overall health of democracy, redistricting that favors Democrats merely corrects a structural imbalance in our political system that favors loosely-populated rural areas with an unfair proportion of political power and marginalizes the greater number of citizens who live in urban areas and tend to vote Democrat. Anyway, there are other good reasons to see
32:05 Robert Evans? hope for a fierce swing in American politics, not merely back to the middle, but far to the left, simply as a matter of practical necessity. The Republicans have spent their time in power gutting the Parks Department, the Post Office, the VA, the FAA, and every other useful part of our state's structure, and this is a big part of what's radicalized people because they very quickly come to notice that things are missing and shit is not working right. For decades, the government has been the enemy to millions of Americans who went out in the world and relied on government services every day of their lives. And yes, that's irritating and unfair, and no, we don't have time to fix that right now. What we can do is use the fact that the Republicans broke all these systems to point out to people, actually, you don't hate it when the government does
32:48 Robert Evans? stuff, you just hate the way Republicans run the government. And the fact that the Democrats have usually been too scared to push for policies as extreme as they need to, right? This is an opportunity to convince a lot of people, oh shit, paying taxes to support a vibrant civil society with extensive and functional infrastructure is a lot better than letting big balls delete half of civil service, right? Like, that's, I think, the opportunity we have right now. And pushing that basic line on as many Americans as possible in the next two years is, I think, one of the most important things we can do at the moment. Along with that, we need to keep building support for enforcement of consequences against the cadre of billionaires and their lackeys who have been robbing our shared heritage blind this whole while.
33:31 Robert Evans? If I had my way about it, I'd point out to people that there are an awful lot of billionaires who we knew colluded to take over the federal government and put something like Elon Musk's doge in place. You can just see that in some of the texts between Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk. These people are enemies of the state with an awful lot of money that we could confiscate to do things like replace the books Moms for Liberty tore out of public libraries. Now, we also need to see consequences for the criminals who have weaponized the organs of the state to fight their war against transgender Americans. This is an issue you can, in fact, get centrist voters to support. The average swing voter may not be particularly woke on gender theory, but they don't like seeing the government bully people who are just trying to get by. The widespread suffering created by the MAGA movement also creates potential
34:16 Robert Evans? for widespread solidarity between its victims.
34:20 Robert Evans? If the midterms go badly for the GOP and the 2028 elections go even worse, the USA's new elected officials and surviving citizens will find themselves in the same situation as the man who just unseated Viktor Orban and his supporters. We all learned how temporary a victory can be after 2024. I've seen more than a few comments online by liberals who decided Orban's defeat was a good time to attack a straw man caricature of a leftist, and these posts were generally laughing at this idea that a lot of people on the left expressed, that electoralism can't defeat fascism. Now, I do share a frustration with the blanket rejection of electoral politics that some people on the left champion, but every online and real-life lefty that I know was thrilled to see Orban get the boot. However, they all did share a fear, and this is one
35:05 Robert Evans? fear that I've seen in common with every analyst and expert on Hungarian politics that I've read, which is, winning the election isn't going to be enough for Magyar. Orban is an extremist, someone who took power because things were extremely shitty in Hungary, and voters got angry enough to vote for a guy who promised to burn things down. They did come to regret that, but things are still extremely bad in Hungary. Joe Biden was a moderate who tried to govern in an environment of raging extremes. His promise was that he would bring things back to the normal of the Obama era. He failed to do that because it's impossible, and his failure opened up the way for Trump 2.0. If we don't want to repeat that cycle, the failures and ultimate collapse of the MAGA
35:47 Robert Evans? movement have to be met with new strategies, new tactics, and new politics as we seek to fill the void that they're going to leave behind. I wrote and recorded the first draft of this piece, as I said earlier, just a few days before a gunman stormed into the Correspondence Dinner. His manifesto has made it clear that he wanted to harm the president and members of his cabinet. Within hours, his social media accounts were archived and his life was put under a microscope, as it always happens with gunmen these days. All of this revealed a liberal man, one who had previously expressed very common centrist opinions, including a dislike of firearms. I've seen this used by people to justify a conspiratorial narrative that immediately followed the attack. This guy is a perfect patsy. Obviously, they cooked this up in a lab as an excuse to crack
36:32 Robert Evans? down on Democrats. I don't believe that, and here is not a place for an argument as to why. Again, we'll talk about that, I'm sure, later this week. What is interesting to me is that before any of this happened, I'd been planning to revise the ending of this episode by commenting on an article that came out in April of 2025. It's published by Axios, and the title was "Democrats Told to Get Shot for the Anti-Trump Resistance." Here's a quote from that article. "At town halls in their districts and in one-on-one meetings with constituents and activists, Democratic members of Congress are facing a growing thrum of demands to break the rules, fight dirty, and not be afraid to get hurt." One of the lawmakers that they talked to for that article related a conversation that he'd had in a meeting with a constituent. Quote, "I actually said in a meeting, 'When they light a fire, my thought is, grab an
37:16 Robert Evans? extinguisher,' and someone at the table said, 'Have you tried gasoline?'" So many regular liberals are embracing extreme rhetoric and measures today because they know on some level that that's the only way you survive in an extreme environment. We see this in the thousands of normies in Minneapolis who have been willing and eager to confront armed federal agents in bathrobes and risk their own life and limb to protect their neighbors from ICE. And we've also seen a very dark reflection of that in the actions of that gunman last weekend. Now, the fact that an educated and informed 31-year-old man decided to buy a firearm that he hated and attack the president represents many failures. One of them is a failure of the Democratic Party and the liberal project to provide him
38:00 Robert Evans? with anything that felt like a useful outlet for his rage and hopelessness. When people start talking and acting like this guy was acting, you can either throw your hands up and back away, or you can try like hell to present them with a counteroffer. In this case, I mean a set of policies, activist campaigns, and organized actions to make this country a less horrific place. The victory and wild popularity of Zohran Mamdani is proof that you can, in fact, do this even in 2026. The widespread support for formerly extreme positions like abolishing ICE, taxing billionaires, radically redistricting states, halting the construction of data centers, and expanding and packing the Supreme Court are more than enough evidence to show that people will
38:42 Robert Evans? get in line to back a candidate and a party who promises radical change. Moreover, everything I've seen lately suggests People are starving for a movement like this, hungry for their own candidate who feels like Mom Donnie, hungry more than anything to feel hopeful again. When Oregon Senator Ron Wyden posted, "See you at Nuremberg 2.0" after Kristi Noem got fired, I watched a coalition of left-wing radicals and centrist Dems who never came together over anything else express wild glee at the very thought. We can do this. We have the tools and we have the opportunity. It's going to take a big, bold step into the unknown, but that's our only option besides waiting until we get another chance to look through the social media archives of a gunman.
39:36 Speaker 00 Cash flow crunch? OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds up to $200,000 right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
40:06 Speaker 07 This January, bare-knuckle fighting championship takes over the ocean. The inaugural Brew's Crew sails from Miami to the Bahamas aboard the Norwegian Jewel. Three straight days with pool-deck bare-knuckle fights in the Caribbean. Massive parties, beach events, DJs, cigars, tequila tastings, and nonstop action. The lineup reveals coming soon. Cabins are disappearing fast, and the prices won't stay this low. Reserve your spot with just $200 down at bkfsea.com.
40:37 Speaker 03 I turned off news altogether.
40:40 Speaker 03 I hate to say it, but I don't trust much of anything.
40:44 Speaker 04 It's the rage bait.
40:46 Speaker 05 It feels like it's trying to divide people.
40:51 Speaker 04 We got clear facts. Maybe we can calm down a little.
40:56 Speaker 06 NBC News brings you clear reporting. Let's meet at the facts. Let's move forward from there. NBC News, reporting for America.
41:10 Speaker 10 So by the time you hear this, the situation may have evolved in any number of directions. I'm speaking in the immediate wake of the United States and Israel's brutal invasion of Iran. Thus far, over a thousand have been killed, including over a hundred schoolchildren and the Supreme Leader of Iran, Ayatollah Ali Khomeini. In response to this American Israeli aggression, Iran has retaliated by targeting both American bases and civilian and energy infrastructure in the neighbouring countries that have facilitated American presence in the region. With the strategically and economically critical Strait of Hormuz in jeopardy, with France, the UK and Germany, aka the usual suspects, indicating
41:54 Speaker 10 potential involvement, and with the potential Russian and Chinese involvement also being floated in some circles, it seems to me that without any formal announcement, the war on the world has escalated potentially to a point of no return. Hello and welcome to It Could Happen Here. I'm Andrew Sage, Andrewism on YouTube, and I'm joined again by
42:17 Speaker 11 It's James. Hi Andrew, how are you doing?
42:20 Speaker 10 As well as I can be.
42:22 Speaker 11 Yeah, that's about the best we can hope for these days, isn't it?
42:25 Speaker 10 Yeah. And in a time like this, I want to take a look back at history, particularly how past US interventions have left devastation in their wake. Today I want to look at the fate of Libya, a country still dealing with its simmering tensions following the end of the post-intervention civil war. So I suppose we should begin in mid-February in 2011, when the Arab Spring was sweeping the Middle East and North Africa. Among the countries caught up in the fervour against the prevailing states was Libya, a North African state ruled for the previous 42 years by the Colonel Muammar al-Gaddafi's government. Masses had taken to the streets across the country, starting in Benghazi. The government
43:10 Speaker 10 had some successes in putting down the revolt, killing hundreds of rebels, demonstrators alike, and some failures, as the masses managed to hold position. The people had many motivations, spanning Islamist, to democratic, to militant, to tribal, to just disaffected, against a government intent on its continued survival.
43:32 Speaker 10 Revolutions, uprisings, protests, revolts, they tend to be messy affairs. I'm sure, James, you're well aware of that.
43:39 Speaker 11 Yeah, yeah. I think it's really easy as like outside observers or when we're looking back at history to be like, oh, this revolution was an Islamist revolution. This was a Marxist-Leninist revolution. This one was an anarchist revolution. But every revolution that I have been at, that I have witnessed happening, is an everything revolution when it starts and it later becomes a something revolution. But especially in the Arab Spring, right, like in that time, it was just like, we've had enough of being under the boot of these regimes. And it was extraordinarily heterodox. And that was quite beautiful in the early days.
44:22 Speaker 10 Exactly, exactly. The heterodox nature of revolutions is really what I want to drill here, because I think it's very easy people to caricaturize and super broad brush and disdetermine, or this is, in the case of Iran, people are saying, oh, it's only monarchists, it's monarchists and Zionists going out in the streets when they were protesting, when the situation on the ground is always more complex than that.
44:48 Speaker 11 Yeah, maybe I'll just take a second to address the annoying campist tendency. I understand every time the United States rains down death on some part of the world, it's terrible, right? It's sad, as you've just said, Andrew. In Iran, we've seen a girls' school bombed not once but twice, it seems, right? Like what they call a double attack. That doesn't mean that your response has to be to support the other people who are killing those same civilians in that same place. It is possible for two things to be bad. And like, in Iran, yeah, there is a monarchist opposition, it sucks. I spoke just this morning
45:29 Speaker 11 to a Kurdish group, which is opposing the regime in Iran, and they had nothing but bad things to say about the monarchists, right? They said, this is the PAK, right, the Kurdistan Freedom Party, I'm quoting here, "They do not have a foothold in society to actually achieve anything. The lies and delusions of a group of people sitting in nightclubs cannot make any real impact." You're free to use that one next time someone tells you all the opposition in Iran is monarchist. It's nonsense.
45:58 Speaker 10 Exactly. I mean, just on its face, it's obviously nonsense. There's this notion that these people are hive minds. It's really racist notion that you see popping up again and again.
46:09 Speaker 11 Yeah, very orientalist.
46:11 Speaker 10 Yeah, anytime people step outside and they have something that they're upset about, they just get labelled with this one broad sweeping ideological moniker with their, just they're subscribed to it or not.
46:24 Speaker 11 Yeah.
46:24 Speaker 10 And even within the ideological monarchies, there's always a lot of nuance in how people understand those ideologies. You know, no two Islamists are necessarily alike, no two monarchists even are necessarily alike. And those are both ideologies that I absolutely abhor. You know?
46:41 Speaker 11 Right. Yeah. I don't understand how you can be a leftist and spend your life like as such. And then also think that in other parts of the world, people don't want the same things. Like, I believe it is inherently human.
46:57 Speaker 10 Yeah.
46:57 Speaker 11 To want dignity and respect and the same for others and to want our communities to govern themselves. And I don't believe that it's any less human if you live in North Africa or the Middle East or South Africa or an island in the Caribbean or an island in the Pacific. Like, I believe it comes from our human nature. And so it strikes me as therefore obvious that there cannot be a country where people's human nature is fundamentally distinct and they're all just like knee jerk monarchists. I wouldn't see the world the way I see it if I was able to believe that.
47:28 Speaker 10 Yeah, yeah. These movements, they're always composed by the choices and actions of sometimes millions of people, each with their own motivations. And it's easy, particularly in retrospect, to pick particular leaders or organisations as representative of them all. That doesn't make it so.
47:47 Speaker 11 Yeah.
47:48 Speaker 10 One of the things that defined the Arab Spring, as you mentioned, was its leaderless nature. You had new liberals, you had monarchists, you had socialists, you had, most of all, I would say, people without any ideological commitments at all. The majority of the human population is not ideologically committed one way or the other. Most people are just trying to live their lives and meet their basic needs.
48:10 Speaker 11 Yeah.
48:10 Speaker 10 And they're submerged in a society that Lends them towards a particular inclination, but that's not set in stone.
48:17 Speaker 12 Mm hmm.
48:17 Speaker 10 Most people in the Arab Spring likely saw just the end of whatever it was that they were suffering under before. And of course, in these kind of incidents, geopolitical actors will choose to back particular factions, lend them credence and prominence according to their geopolitical interests. But don't give them undue credit. You know, during the Cold War, for example, the US would have backed rebellions they believe would benefit them. And vice versa, the USSR backed rebellions they thought would benefit them. And even today, the US is claiming to care about freedom, but has continued to work with the Saudis, who infamously invaded Bahrain to crush the Arab Spring that occurred there.
48:55 Speaker 12 Yeah.
48:56 Speaker 10 And at the time, France's love for democracy didn't exactly match their offer to aid Algeria and Tunisia in putting down their own Arab Springs. Now, as I've been saying quite often, pointing out hypocrisy is kind of a baby's first geopolitical analysis, right? None of these governments have any consistent values beyond their own interests. But I think it's important to make this kind of heterodoxy in movements clear to contextualize what happened next.
49:39 Speaker 10 There's a another notion that US intervention is entering these countries during these conflicts to uphold humanitarian aims, to liberate the women or to liberate minorities in that region. The United States, like all governments, is opportunistic, right? It is taking advantage of often genuine struggles by people to serve its own situation or goals without a care for what happens to those people, either openly intervening or covertly intervening. Most obvious recent example is with the Kurds in Syria. At the time, they were convenient to the United States' interests until they weren't, and they were banned then.
50:21 Speaker 10 And this is especially the case when resources like oil come into the picture. And Libya is extremely oil-rich.
50:30 Speaker 10 So tragically, the West saw this uprising in Libya as an opportunity. Following a timeline in Encyclopedia Britannica, on the 19th of March 2011, Libya was attacked by the combined forces of the United States, the UK and France. These countries now condemned Gaddafi as an oppressor of the civilians they were swooping in to save, though for years before, the UK and France were selling him weapons. They, alongside their Qatari and Saudi allies, took advantage of the protests to assert their military might. This move was authorized by the UN Resolution 1973, and NATO would soon take command of the operation. While claiming to protect civilians under a responsibility-to-protect doctrine, they bombed them.
51:15 Speaker 10 An allegedly humanitarian intervention led to the deaths of tens of thousands of a national population of just over 6 million. Key infrastructure was devastated by the NATO bombing campaign and by the struggles between the government and the now armed rebels of the National Transitional Council, or NTC. A quick note by the way, the NTC appointed themselves as the leaders of the movement. And despite the struggle being kick-started by mostly working and middle-class militants, often of an Islamic orientation, the NTC was composed mainly of regime defectors, businessmen, and exiles who had a broadly pro-Western, conservative and free-market stance.
51:57 Speaker 10 Some of the elements in Gaddafi's government and military had defected to the rebels and equipped those previously unarmed protesters with firepower. And up to now, we only have estimates regarding the civilian death toll, infrastructural devastation, and arbitrary detentions, disappearances, and kidnappings carried out by both pro-Gaddafi and anti-Gaddafi forces. Not to mention the deliberate targeting of black Libyans and Sub-Saharan African migrants by rebel forces that took place during and after the 2011 war, with the claim that they were Gaddafi's hired mercenaries. Many of those Africans' attempts to escape were met with callous disregard by Europe.
52:39 Speaker 11 Yeah, callous disregard is, I mean, there are no words strong enough to to express the way I feel about the uh the way the European Union has treated migrants in Libya. It is absolutely disgusting and continues to be.
52:52 Speaker 10 Despicable.
52:53 Speaker 11 Yeah. Have you read Sally Hayden's book about this?
52:56 Speaker 10 No, I haven't.
52:57 Speaker 11 It's called My Fourth Time We Drowned. Very good book. Difficult read, I would say. It very much is is some of the the type of reporting that I try and do myself on migration and that it talks about people, not numbers, and it centers migrants as individuals with stories. It's a great book, but probably not one to read, you know, right before bed.
53:18 Speaker 10 Hmm, I can imagine. It sounds heavy.
53:21 Speaker 11 Yeah, definitely heavy going.
53:23 Speaker 10 And so, following a steelmate between the pro and Gaddafi camps in late spring of twenty eleven, the rebels, assisted by NATO forces, took Tripoli and toppled Gaddafi's government. And the NTC was recognized internationally almost immediately as the legitimate government of Libya. As Matt Wilgress notes in Jack Ben, quote, "On the day Tripoli fell, the New York Times headline, 'The scramble for access to Libya's oil wealth begins,' was telling. Libya's vast oil reserves, along prized by the West for being the largest in Africa and incredibly close to Europe, were now open to business for foreign investors.
54:02 Speaker 10 As is the case with all imperial interventions, the attempts to get profits flowing for multinational corporations comes long before any ideas of reconstruction, such as essential infrastructure projects or insurance services," end quote. And really up to now, that infrastructure has not been established, and even access to Libya's oil is not yet secured, even though they allegedly managed to loot some of that oil in twenty twelve. Now, Gaddafi himself fled after the fall of Tripoli, but he was found. NATO bombed his convoy and he was captured alive, then executed by NTC forces in October twenty eleven, after which the war was declared over. And the NTC declared Libya an Islamic democracy in their constitutional declaration.
54:47 Speaker 10 The NTC estimated thirty thousand dead, and a UN report from twenty twelve estimated that more than nine hundred thousand people had to leave the country since February of twenty eleven. Many were not Libya nationals, but more than six hundred and sixty thousand Libyans also fled, and an estimated two hundred thousand people had been internally displaced. Continuing with our timeline, in 2012, the NTC handed power over to the General National Congress, or GNC. And despite a formal end to the war, Gaddafi loyalists, local militias and tribes shafed against each other and the GNC. The militias wouldn't disarm, the Gaddafi loyalists continued to fight. And the GNC failed to put forward a new constitution.
55:30 Speaker 10 So in 2014, they were ousted by the newly-elected House of Representatives. And in 2014, a second civil war would begin in Libya. With the nation split, mainly between the House of Representatives, or HOR, with its Libyan National Army, or LNA, based in Tobruk to the east, and their rival, made up of mostly Islamists from the former GNC, with their Libya Dawn militia, based in Tripoli to the west. They didn't win the election, they didn't consider it legitimate because of its low turnout, and they didn't appreciate the amount of former Gaddafi supporters in the new government. So they rose up to fight, claiming to be the National Salvation Government, or NSG. So you have the HOR and you have the NSG.
56:14 Speaker 10 Beyond these two factions, you also had an Al Qaeda-affiliated militia and the Islamic State, both engaged in insurgent struggle around the country, sometimes holding entire cities. Eventually, the two governments came together to sign the LPA, the Libyan political agreement, that formed the interim presidential council and government of national accord, or GNA, in late 2015. But that attempt at cohesion didn't really work out, as the UN-backed GNA, now based in Tripoli, couldn't consolidate power. By the end of 2016, factions affiliated with the NSG still resisted the GNA, and the HOR, still based in Tobruk, refused to endorse the GNA's appointments.
56:56 Speaker 10 So they went from having two competing governments to kinda having three, though the main opposing forces were now the GNA and the HOR. The GNA was backed by Turkey, Qatar and the EU, especially Italy, and the UN. While the HOR was backed by Egypt, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, the United Arab Emirates, and to some extent France, who technically recognized the GNA, but also provided support to the HOR for their struggle against the Islamists. The US was also supposed to be backing the GNA, but Trump jumped out to praise the H O R at one point. So the US's position was exposed as a lot more ambiguous in practice.
57:39 Speaker 11 Yeah.
57:51 Speaker 10 So the GNA and the H O R would keep on struggling against each other for control over the central bank and oil companies and territory over the years. By the end of one particularly significant offensive in 2019, which saw the country's largest oil field brought under H O R control. The situation was such that the H O R's leverage came from their control over the oil fields and the GNA's leverage was that it was internationally recognised and could legally sell the oil. GNA leader Fayez Al-Sarraj and H O R leader Shalif Haftar seemed to be developing cooperative relations. And in March of 2019, they were supposed to have a national unity conference. But then the H O R tried to take Tripoli. Whoopsie.
58:34 Speaker 10 So they kind of had to postpone that conference. The resultant fight then led to the H O R taking Sirti, a major city between Libya's east and west halves. With Turkish support, the GNA successfully repelled the H O R from near Tripoli and situation was stabilised with a battle line just east of Sirti in 2020.
58:54 Speaker 11 Yeah, not just Turkish support. Turkey deployed the Syrian National Army, AKA the T F S A, the Turkish Free Syrian Army. They are widely believed to be rebadged Islamist from previous iterations of various Islamist groups in Syria that Turkey has formed into kind of its own proxy force. I mean, I'm sure if you go to their Wikipedia page, there are like 17 million different war crimes listed, like they are, they are, they are well known for their affinity for war crimes. Yeah.
59:28 Speaker 10 I could imagine. The fact that Turkey, Turkey's backing them tells me everything I need to know, I think.
59:34 Speaker 11 Yeah, right. Yeah. And that they're considered like. A deniable proxy, right? Like, they could be like, Turkey can be like, oh, well, that wasn't us. That was these Syrian guys who we happened to arm and equip and run S4.
59:47 Speaker 10 Yeah. What is their situation now? Now that Turkey is kind of back in the new government in Syria?
59:53 Speaker 11 They have largely been folded into the STG's armed forces. So like Abu Hamza is, I think, a general or brigadier. I can't quite remember his rank, but it's a guy who has been widely condemned is now a military officer within the STG's Ministry of Defence.
1:00:13 Speaker 10 Huh, okay. So a more accurate description then would be that Turkey sent their war criminal proxies to support the GNA in repelling the HOR from near Tripoli.
1:00:26 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:00:27 Speaker 10 And the situation stabilized with a battle line just east of Syria in 2020. And after other attempts to reach an agreement failed, they agreed to share oil revenue, establish a permanent ceasefire and get both Turkish forces and Russian mercenaries out of the country. So the second civil war was officially over in October 2020. According to reporting by Al Jazeera, the UN initiated a new attempt at a unifying government in 2021, which was approved originally by both rival parliaments, leading to the establishment of the interim government of national unity, or GNU, in March 2021, thus replacing the previously UN-backed GNA. So you went from GNA to GNU.
1:01:13 Speaker 10 But then the GNU would be opposed by the HOR, which withdrew from the GNU in September 2021 and established the government of national stability, or GNS, in March 2022. So the GNA was replaced by the GNU and the GNU was now opposed by the GNS. And thus, the country remains split in two up to today, between the UN-backed GNU and the HOR slash Libya National Army-backed GNS. And in all of this chaos, people on the ground have been suffering. They've been suffering human rights abuses, disappearances. Up to recently, the GNU imposed a morality police
1:01:55 Speaker 10 and there have been numerous reports about open slave markets in Libya. Where migrant black Africans are auctioned to the highest bidder.
1:02:03 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:02:04 Speaker 10 This is a result of human trafficking and debt bondage, so not exactly the same as chattel slavery. But the experience and racial undertones are all too familiar. The suffering in Libya has also spread beyond its borders. Following Gaddafi's fall, the weapons of his military stockpiles ended up in the hands of militants across the Sahel region of Africa and even in Syria. You'll remember in my episode on the situation in Nigeria, some of those weapons ended up in the hands of Boko Haram and other Islamic militant groups in the region, Tulani herdsmen and so on. Tragically, because Libya just can't seem to catch a break at all.
1:02:48 Speaker 10 September twenty twenty-three also saw catastrophic floods devastating the country. The hurricane-strong Storm Daniel caused two dams to burst in the coastal city of Derna, which is within GNS territory in eastern Libya. The flooding killed at least four thousand people, though potentially even more, left thousands missing and displaced more than forty thousand others. The nation, still wrought by civil war and still unrecovered from the devastation of the NATO bombing campaign, surely could have mustered a more adequate response to the tragedy if not for those conditions. In fact, it is theorized that the tragedy could have been avoided altogether because, according to reports by the Middle East Eye,
1:03:30 Speaker 10 a Turkish company was supposed to rehabilitate the failed dams, but their works were reportedly interrupted by the twenty-eleven uprising and subsequent civil war.
1:03:41 Speaker 11 Yeah, it's always the cost of war that we don't count, right? Like, if you look at the twenty twenty-three earthquake that killed people in Syria and Turkey, right? Like, undoubtedly, that would have done a lot less damage if it hadn't been for the fact that war had been raging in those places for so long. So, like, everything else got put on hold, right? All the normal infrastructure repair and such that you would expect had to stop.
1:04:05 Speaker 10 Yeah.
1:04:06 Speaker 11 Because of that war, and that made things like the earthquake worse.
1:04:09 Speaker 10 Yeah. I don't think the people who rose up against Gaddafi and fought and died back in February of twenty-eleven had sought this outcome. Unfortunately, in a world dictated by the whims of imperialist powers, this was the end. Of their actions. I don't want people to get it twisted though, because in the time since, as people have observed the devastation wrought by these civil wars, there has been an effort to almost whitewash Gaddafi and to limit our vision of possibilities to a binary of either perpetual Gaddafi rule
1:04:51 Speaker 10 on one end, or perpetual civil war on the other hand. Those are not the only possibilities. So we've discussed the legacy of NATO intervention, which deserves condemnation in this episode. Yeah. And it should be an indication that either Western invasions and wars not going to liberate anyone. Yeah. But aside from that accurate analysis of Libya, since the fall of Gaddafi, I want to bring in some conversation on the man himself in the next episode. Until then, all power to all the people. This has been It Could Happen Here. I've been Andre Seig. Peace.
1:05:40 Speaker 00 Cash flow crunch? OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds up to $200,000 right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
1:06:10 Speaker 07 This January, bare knuckle fighting championship takes over the ocean. The inaugural Brews Cruise sails from Miami to the Bahamas aboard the Norwegian Jewel. Three straight days with pool deck bare knuckle fights in the Caribbean. Mess of parties, beach events, DJs, cigars, tequila tastings and nonstop action. The lineup reveals coming soon. Cabins are disappearing fast and the prices won't stay this low. Reserve your spot with just $200 down at bkfsea.com.
1:06:41 Speaker 03 I turned off news altogether.
1:06:44 Speaker 03 I hate to say it, but I don't trust much of anything.
1:06:48 Speaker 13 It's the rage bait.
1:06:50 Speaker 05 It feels like it's trying to divide people.
1:06:55 Speaker 04 We got clear facts, maybe we can calm down a little.
1:07:00 Speaker 06 NBC News brings you clear reporting. Let's meet at the facts. Let's move forward from there. NBC News, reporting for America.
1:07:14 Speaker 10 Hello and welcome to Ikadapen here. I am Andras Sej, Andrazam on YouTube and joined again by
1:07:21 Speaker 11 It's James again.
1:07:23 Speaker 10 Yes. I've noticed a phenomenon, I'm not sure if you've noticed it too, where anti-imperialist solidarity somehow goes a step beyond opposing imperialist aggression itself and crosses into lionizing or whitewashing the targets of that aggression, or rather, the assensible leaders of the targets of that aggression.
1:07:47 Speaker 11 Yeah, I have noticed this too. It's one of the things that makes me most angry in the world, what's been referred to as the anti-imperialism of idiots.
1:07:55 Speaker 10 Yes.
1:07:56 Speaker 11 Not so relevant now, but I used to like to apply the Assad test to anybody who claimed to be interested in the politics of liberation, right? If you, if you think Bashar al-Assad is a based anti-imperialist people socialist hero, then your politics are shit. I have nothing good to say about that, like you're an idiot.
1:08:17 Speaker 10 Yeah, yeah. It should be a fringe phenomenon, right? But I haven't seen it get an increased traction.
1:08:24 Speaker 11 Yeah, even in like relatively, you know, like I won't start a war with various US leftist publications, but I went to pitch some people this, this last week thinking like there is speculation that the United States will once again ally itself with Kurdish groups, who I'm sure had then planned to once again abandon when that became politically more expedient, but I happen to have some insight into these various Kurdish groups, having spent some time there and having contacts there. And so I went to the websites of these various, you know, big publications which are left or left leaning or even sort of liberal. And I saw these borderline campus takes on what's happening in Iran and it's just so.
1:09:08 Speaker 11 So frustrating to me, like it makes me so angry that people continue to view the world through this binary Marvel movie lens, which sees it as impossible that two things could be bad at the same time. Yeah, it's infuriating to me.
1:09:24 Speaker 10 Yeah. And if I was more inclined to conspiracy, I might say that this binary is intentionally constructed, you know, that it's it's by design that the most vocal anti-imperialist voices also just so happen to align themselves with state power.
1:09:46 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:09:47 Speaker 10 And campism. But I'm not I'm not inclined to conspiracy, so.
1:09:52 Speaker 11 Yeah, yeah. One can make a pretty reasonable argument for that, right?
1:09:55 Speaker 10 One could make that argument.
1:09:57 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:09:57 Speaker 10 I won't, but one could.
1:10:01 Speaker 11 I might.
1:10:03 Speaker 10 I think one of the best examples of this is this sort of odd obsession that some people have with Colonel Muammar al-Gaddafi. Now, last episode, we spoke about the long term consequences of Western intervention in Libya, beginning with the 2011 uprising during the Arab Spring against the 42-year rule of Muammar Gaddafi. What began as a broad, largely leaderless protest movement was quickly shaped by foreign intervention. In March of 2011, the US, the UK and France launched a military campaign through NATO under a UN mandate to protect civilians. The war toppled Gaddafi, but killed tens of thousands and devastated infrastructure. In the aftermath, Libya fractured into rival
1:10:47 Speaker 10 governments, militias and foreign-backed factions, triggering yet another civil war in 2014. And despite a ceasefire in 2020, the country remains divided between competing administrations, while ordinary Libyans face instability, human rights abuses and economic hardship. I think it's fair to say that the NATO intervention was a net negative for the country. But in the same breath, I cannot agree with those who seem to believe that Gaddafi's rule could have continued either, that he was some force for good in the country. And in this episode, I really want to get into the why, to identify and dissect the actions of the man Gaddafi.
1:11:28 Speaker 10 According to his biography in Encyclopedia Britannica, Murma al-Gaddafi was born in 1942, near Sirti, Libya. Sixty-nine years later, he would be captured and killed in Sirti, Libya. After spending his early years in a tent, he graduated from the University of Libya in 1963, and then graduated from a military academy in 1965. In 1969, at the age of 27, Gaddafi pulled off a bloodless coup to seize power from King Idris I of Libya. For the next four decades plus, he would be the de facto ruler of Libya. Gaddafi was both a passionate Arab nationalist and a Muslim.
1:12:11 Speaker 10 In power, he tried to push both of his ideologies. He expelled Western military forces, expelled remaining Italian settlers and Jewish communities in Libya, nationalised the country's oil industry, banned alcohol and gambling, tried to unify with his Arab neighbours, occasionally by attempting coups in their countries, and stood against normalisation with Israel. So a very mixed bag so far.
1:12:37 Speaker 14 Yeah.
1:12:38 Speaker 10 Until 1977, Gaddafi ruled the Libyan Arab Republic. But the culmination of his Cultural Revolution period from 1973 to 1977 would sideline his political and religious opponents, who were beginning to see him as unstable, hubristic and authoritarian. That period would instead cement Gaddafi as the sole ruler of what he would rename the socialist People's Libyan Arab Jamahirya. As recounted in Libya: The History of Gaddafi's Pariah State by John Oakes, Jamahirya was a term he coined in his Green Book, likely inspired by Mao's Little Red Book, published during the Libyan Cultural Revolution period.
1:13:22 Speaker 10 Jamahiria was his idea of a state of the masses governed by people's congresses and popular assemblies. And if it's one thing that makes a political movement, it's empowering, it's slapping the people's unpopular label on everything, regardless of any additional context.
1:13:40 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:13:41 Speaker 10 So they had these democratic local assemblies called basic people's congresses that met three times a year. And those congresses appointed executive people's committees, which did most of the day to day stuff. And above it all was the general people's congress. This period was simultaneously an effort to encourage popular participation through these congresses while suppressing dissent through his control over the secret services. It was clear that Gaddafi was still in charge, even after he stepped down from his former position as secretary general in 1979, and simply and humbly dubbed himself the brotherly leader and guide of the revolution.
1:14:22 Speaker 11 Yeah, some of his like hubristic stuff, like his rhetoric, his outfits, his reference to himself is like, you couldn't parody some of it. It is where like the parodies of dictators in this part of the world come from is Gaddafi's kind of affect, I guess.
1:14:42 Speaker 10 Yeah, he was a character.
1:14:44 Speaker 11 Yes, that he was, yeah.
1:14:46 Speaker 10 He was definitely a character.
1:14:48 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:14:49 Speaker 10 So, I mean, anarchist critiques of democracy are easy to find. And although Gaddafi's Libya was never solely directly democratic, even in his project, you could see some of the flaws and the issues that anarchists have identified in this approach to popular power. As the congresses and the people's congresses were poorly attended and easily manipulated, issues were often raised and rarely resolved. And of course, compounding those flaws was the fact that these people's congresses had no actual power over the things that mattered in Libya. Yeah. The oil industry, the armed forces, the security services and foreign policy. Gaddafi and his compatriots still ruled.
1:15:35 Speaker 10 Gaddafi decided where the oil money went and he directed some of it to a great manmade river project that would extract from the ancient and non-renewable aquifer under the Libyan desert to supply the coast with a more stable water supply. Frustratingly for him, I could assume Gaddafi did not get what he wanted out of the revolutionary people's congresses. So he created revolutionary committees to mobilize the people and safeguard their rule through commandos that answered to Gaddafi directly. These revolutionary committees could arrest counter-revolutionaries, establish revolutionary courts and eliminate enemies of the revolution at home and abroad. The people he called stray dogs.
1:16:21 Speaker 10 All of this for the people, of course, and for the revolution.
1:16:34 Speaker 10 So on people, his system had some degree of people power and people's voice, but in practice, he exercised near total control and suppression of opposition, both within the country and outside the country. The same went for workplaces, of course. He spoke about worker partnership and power in the Green Book, but it was a state-controlled and state-distributed economy in Libya, run by oil money with very few worker-run enterprises. There was also no real freedom of organization or strike in Libya as independent unions were banned and Gaddafi explicitly rejected class struggle despite claiming to be a socialist.
1:17:19 Speaker 10 So in the return of Muammar Gaddafi by Tunisian academic Haytham Gusemi, he highlights the cult of personality that was forged over the years of Gaddafi's rule that has resurfaced up to today. His proponents often point to the good that he did for the country, establishing basic social services, free health gain education, housing and land distribution, accessible loan programs, women's rights and so on.
1:17:46 Speaker 10 And with that welfare state came naturally some base of popular support for people who had little to nothing before.
1:17:53 Speaker 11 Mm hmm.
1:17:54 Speaker 10 Other fans of Gaddafi points to what I like to call hype moments and aura.
1:18:00 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:18:00 Speaker 10 So there was a time when he was in the UN General Assembly and he had what was supposed to be a short time to speak.
1:18:07 Speaker 11 Hmm.
1:18:07 Speaker 10 And he just went on and on and on and on and on and on and he tore up the UN Charter. Hype moments and aura, right?
1:18:16 Speaker 11 And. Yeah.
1:18:18 Speaker 10 That's like something a lot of people point to. He was also at one point in time the chairman of the African Union and he wanted to keep that position permanently. And he was proposing a whole United States of Africa, like he had a whole period of African solidarity, which we'll get to.
1:18:35 Speaker 11 Yeah, okay, good. Yeah, his Pan-Africanist arc is fascinating.
1:18:39 Speaker 10 Yeah, so none of this, however, erases his dark, dark side. For one, for all the women's rights that he put forward in Libya, he was not that great to women. The Green Book presents Gaddafi as someone who cared about women's dignity and rights. But even in that book, you see a very complementarist take on women's place in society. It's like, yeah, they're equal to men, but also their role is in the household. They're supposed to be mothers above everything else.
1:19:12 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:19:13 Speaker 10 He was like, they need to be mothers, but they shouldn't be treated as property or objects.
1:19:17 Speaker 11 Yeah, I think he based a lot of this in like his interpretation of Hadith or the Quran, like his, his idea that like, uh, there was some kind of divine guidance on, on gender roles, right? I've actually seen this in recent days, like you can go and find Hamanay's tweets, right? Like, like Ayatollah Hamanay, not, not his son. And like, you can see his stuff where he's like, you should not mistreat your wife. You can literally find those in his, in his timeline on Twitter, right? He was a big poster and people have somehow attempted to like construe this as like he was a leader of enlightened feminist regime like in Iran, which I don't know, like.
1:19:55 Speaker 10 It's benevolent patriarchy all over again.
1:19:57 Speaker 11 Yeah, I, I like, you, you have to be really on a special fucking truth trajectory to convince yourself that that is the case. Uh, it, it like, like it takes remarkable capacity for self-delusion.
1:20:12 Speaker 11 So rather than listening to women in Iran, women from Iran, many of whom I have spoken to, to look at the evidence of the killing, for example, with, you know, Arminy, right? To be like, I know, but I found this tweet from 2013. So we're good here. This is, uh, this is fine. It's just remarkable, people's tendency to do that.
1:20:32 Speaker 10 Yeah, it's remarkable and stupid.
1:20:35 Speaker 11 Yeah, yes, stupid is a good word.
1:20:37 Speaker 10 Yeah. And going back to Gaddafi, aside from that sort of benevolent patriarchy take on women's equality.
1:20:47 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:20:47 Speaker 10 Investigative reporting by Anna Kajin also gathered testimony since his fall that alleged his procurement, coercion, and sexual abuse of women inside his compound, aided by a network of officials. Unfortunately, many of these women are far too afraid to come forward, even all these years after his death, due to the persistence of pro-Gaddafi sentiment in the country up to today. So not the best for women. What about for Africa? Right? His whole Pan-Africanist arc.
1:21:24 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:21:25 Speaker 10 He styled himself as a Pan-African who would support the struggles of people like Mandela and would fund infrastructure projects around the continent. But he had a history of attempting to overthrow governments in Africa and support oppressive ones, including Idi Amin of Uganda and Charles Taylor of Liberia. So his Pan-Africanism was never concerned with the freedom or well-being of African people. It was, I think, very much according to his own self-aggrandizement.
1:22:00 Speaker 11 Yeah, like, didn't he propose like a African Union, which was more akin to like, like a United States, like a federal Africa?
1:22:08 Speaker 10 Yes, United States of Africa. That was his proposal.
1:22:10 Speaker 11 Fantastic, yeah.
1:22:11 Speaker 10 Yeah.
1:22:12 Speaker 11 Great.
1:22:14 Speaker 10 And as he is proposing this Pan-African vision, within Libya itself, he was pushing for an Arab Libya. Yeah. The Amazigh and other non-Arab Africans in Libya were mistreated. You know, his vision of an Arab Libya led to the suppression of the Tuaregs, the Tabus and the Amazigh. He had policies, as reported in the BBC, in New Internationalist, Al Jazeera and elsewhere. He had policies that included the banning of minority languages, the banning of minority names, the discouraging of cultural expression and sometimes denying citizenship to groups outside the Arab identity. So naturally, many of these minorities took part in the 2011 movement and after Gaddafi's fall,
1:22:59 Speaker 10 there was a revival of language, cultural institutions and publications. However, the NTC and those that followed have continued to ignore the minority plight. Minority groups are still struggling for constitutional recognition, representation and equal rights in a country that is, of course, still divided. And some minorities have chosen to boycott the national political process entirely in favour of pursuing local self-governance. Also, minorities were not the only people being persecuted in Gaddafi's Libya. On the political front, despite calling himself a socialist, Gaddafi was really all over the place ideologically.
1:23:39 Speaker 10 Now internationally, he may have backed the Palestinian struggle, the Irish struggle, the African-American struggle, but he was consistent in suppressing actual leftists in Libya. Marxist.com identified some of these repressive efforts in their article on Gaddafi. Quote, "Gaddafi was very clear in expressing his anti-communism. In 1971, he sent a plane full of Sudanese communists back to Sudan where they were executed by Nsere. In 1973, the regime published an official document to commemorate the fourth anniversary of Gaddafi's rise to power under the title 'Holy War Against Communism', end quote." Quite decent, right? Later on, however, he would get more chummy with the USSR. Yeah.
1:24:23 Speaker 10 But Gaddafi was no Marxist-Leninist. And communists and leftists and workers were not legally capable of organising independently in Libya. Aside from them, you also had the murder and torture of civilians and journalists, the assassinations of rivals in Libya and around the world. It was not... The free speech utopia that Gaddafi tried to paint it as. Instead of emboldening the leftist elements, he emboldened these tribal groups and set the foundation for the Libya that we see today.
1:24:57 Speaker 11 Yeah, his consistent through line is that he he likes strong men and sees himself among them and wants to associate himself with them. At some point in the early 2000s, he was supporting Jörg Heide, a neo fascist in Austria, and telling Europeans they needed to get past their obsession with the Second World War. He had no like consistent politics.
1:25:20 Speaker 10 Well, I mean, that tracks with his expulsion of Jewish communities in Libya.
1:25:25 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:25:25 Speaker 10 He didn't only expel Jewish settlers, he expelled Jewish communities that had arrived prior to Italian colonization, that had existed in Libya for centuries.
1:25:35 Speaker 11 Yeah, that maybe, I guess antisemitism can often be the link that brings terrible people together.
1:25:42 Speaker 10 He had a lot of other notorious incidents of suppression, but one of the most significant was the Abu Salim massacre.
1:25:51 Speaker 10 In short, as recounted by John Oakes, Abu Salim was the site of a prisoner's protest on the 28th of June, 1996. The prisoners escaped their cells and were protesting their mistreatment as guards shot at them from the roof. Two top security officials came and took command, ordering the shooting to stop and promising to address the prisoners' complaints if they returned to their cells and gave up the guards they had hostage. On the following day, shots fired from 11 a.m. to 1:35 p.m., a mass slaughter of approximately 1,200 of the 1,600 to 1,700 prisoners in Abu Salim. The families who suffered that blow were among the first on the streets of Benghazi 2011.
1:26:37 Speaker 10 But those families were not originally told that their loved ones had been killed. Some of them continued to visit the prison for weeks, months, years after, bringing gifts for their relatives who were already long dead.
1:26:52 Speaker 10 In the twists and turns of Gaddafi's ideological development, or lack thereof, following the fall of the USSR, Gaddafi would also pursue economic liberalization. He started opening up to the West ever so slightly. There was slow progress and a brief hiccup. But by 2003, free market advocate Shukri Ganem was appointed prime minister. And before long, 360 state enterprises were privatized. By 2007, Libya was laying off as many as a third of the government workforce, 400,000 public sector workers. According to a New York Times article from 2011, the IMF had actually praised Libya's economic reforms.
1:27:35 Speaker 10 So by 2011, conditions were so unbearable for so many workers, especially young people, there's no wonder that some of them fought with nothing to lose.
1:27:56 Speaker 10 One of the last aspects of Gaddafi's rule that I want to touch on was his complex relationship with Western powers. Earlier in his rule in the 70s and 80s, he did style himself an anti-imperialist revolutionary, and that is the image that our people uphold of him to this day. Libya funded and armed revolutionary and militant movements worldwide, from the African National Congress, or the ANC, to the Palestine Liberation Organization, or PLO, to the Irish Republican Army, or IRA. He aligned himself with the so-called radical camp in the Middle East, including Ba'athist Syria and Iran. And Western governments accused Libya of supporting international terrorism. Libya was considered a rogue state.
1:28:40 Speaker 10 But as noted by Syrian anarchist Massen Kamalmas in an interview with Jose Antonio Guterres, quote, "Even when Gaddafi was declaring himself an anti-imperialist long ago, it was just a lip service while he engaged as an authoritarian in trivial terrorist acts that never meant to support the libertarian objectives of the victims of imperialism." End quote. Still, Reagan called him a mad dog, and the US bombed Libya in 1986 after attacks in a West Berlin nightclub were attributed to Libyan agents. Those bombings narrowly missed Gaddafi himself, but they killed his adopted baby daughter.
1:29:19 Speaker 10 Libya was also blamed for the nineteen eighty eight bombing of Pan Am Flight one oh three over Lockerbie, which led to sanctions by the United Nations and the US, which isolated Libya economically and diplomatically. In the nineties, however, with the fall of the USSR, Libya began slowly shifting toward cooperation. They handed over the suspects in the Lockerbie bombing, and sanctions began to loosen as they attempted to normalize relations. Western intelligence services soon started cooperating with Libyan intelligence against Islamist militant groups, including the Libyan Islamic Fighting Group, which is a thorn in Gaddafi's side. The early two thousands had Libya renounce its weapons of mass destruction program following the invasion of Iraq.
1:30:02 Speaker 10 The US and the UN subsequently lifted sanctions and diplomatic relations were restored, fully with Western countries. Gaddafi hosted Tony Blair of the UK, Nicolas Sarkozy of France, and met with Obama as well. And many of these meetings with Western leaders produced multi-billion dollar energy and business deals.
1:30:22 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:30:23 Speaker 10 BP, Royal Dutch Shell, Exxon Mobil, Chevron, Total Energies, they were all getting pieces of Libya's wealth. As Libya began adopting more neoliberal economic reforms like currency devaluation, trade liberalization, and more openness to foreign investment, Libya was also able to cooperate closely with Western intelligence during the war on terror, including assisting the CIA and MI6 in rendition and torture, as uncovered by Human Rights Watch. So by the mid two thousands, Libya had mostly reintegrated into the Western-led global system. And the West, for their part, simply ignored Gaddafi's continued human rights abuses. The counterterrorism cooperation, the oil and gas contracts, and don't forget the brutal
1:31:07 Speaker 10 African migrant control, were all too valuable for America and Europe.
1:31:13 Speaker 11 Yeah, I remember this, this period quite well. It was when I was, uh, in my undergraduate university and, and Gaddafi was invited to speak, the Oxford Union. I did my undergraduate there, and, uh, and myself and a number of friends who'd-
1:31:25 Speaker 10 So you met Gaddafi?
1:31:26 Speaker 11 Yeah. No, he spoke, he spoke via video conference.
1:31:30 Speaker 10 Okay.
1:31:31 Speaker 11 Which they paused while they they removed us for protesting Gaddafi's like it just seemed like this decades of abuse of his own people have been completely forgotten, right? Because he was now prepared to do abuse of other people that was beneficial to the United Kingdom, the United States. And we felt that that was abhorrent and wrong. So we went to make our feelings known. And the Oxford Union is a very silly institution, right? We do prize itself on free speech and really it just does kind of class reproduction for the most part.
1:32:05 Speaker 10 Right.
1:32:05 Speaker 11 And of course, like, there was not freedom of speech for people who were going to be rude to someone who was in charge of a state, even if they were being rude on behalf of the thousands of people he's he's had murdered and tortured. And yeah, that was my little personal run in with Gaddafi when I was, what, like, eighteen? But yeah, I can't remember if we were like not allowed in, or we were booted out, because I am like, two decades and half a dozen traumatic brain injuries since my teenage years. But yeah, I do remember just being like, people are treating this like it's some kind of fucking novelty. And this person has real blood on his hands. Real people have suffered tremendously and died because of actions he's taken. Like, it's not funny or cute.
1:32:48 Speaker 10 Wow. What year was that?
1:32:50 Speaker 11 It would have been in the early 2000s, the Bush era, because that's when I was in my undergraduate, second Bush term. So like, it would have been born in 2006, somewhere there.
1:33:03 Speaker 10 Yeah, thankfully, I never had any run ins with Gaddafi.
1:33:06 Speaker 11 Yeah. Even at that time, I can remember just being sort of somewhat appalled by the Marxist loneliness tendency to excuse crimes against humanity, as long as they were done by people who who said the right things, who had the right vibes, who condemned the right people. And the liberal tendency to excuse crimes against humanity, so long as they were done in service of capitalism and the state.
1:33:32 Speaker 10 Yeah, yeah, shockingly similar tendencies in some ways.
1:33:36 Speaker 11 Yeah, right, like this fundamentally not rooted in in the idea that people have a right to dignity. Both of them hold people as less valuable than other things, right, be it capital or, I mean, they did much less than this tendency. Honestly, like, it's not even the revolution that they they believe is more valuable than people. It's the revolutionary rhetoric.
1:33:59 Speaker 10 Yeah.
1:33:59 Speaker 11 Like, like with Assad, right, like, you can murder your own people with chemical weapons. So long as you you pretend to give a single shit about Palestinians, even though you've spent decades using your weapons to kill your own people and never once use them to to actually help the people of Palestine, to actually protect people.
1:34:19 Speaker 10 Exactly, exactly. So at this point now, you know, Gaddafi is trying to be all chummy with the US. After he spent some time being chummy with Africa and spent some time being chummy with USSR and with rebel groups around the world. But that was just the thing, right, he had this track record of flip flopping, you know.
1:34:43 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:34:43 Speaker 10 And even though relations had normalized, these Western powers could not trust him. They still saw him as that mad dog. They still saw him as unpredictable and unreliable. In fact, even while he was cutting deals with these multi-billion dollar corporations for the oil contracts and so on. When he wasn't getting what he wanted, he would threaten to nationalize to get what he wanted. And so
1:35:07 Speaker 11 Yeah.
1:35:08 Speaker 10 The West being opportunistic, we're just waiting for an opportunity. They were done with playing his game. And that opportunity came when the people organically rose up against Gaddafi in 2011. Not long after NATO intervened. And the years since Libyans have suffered and died with no end in sight.
1:35:30 Speaker 10 It shouldn't be uncontroversial to say this. Gaddafi was not a true anti-imperialist. I don't think it's possible for a statesman or a government to be truly anti-imperialist. Government is foundationally exploitative internally. And when turned externally, that drive exploitation is what we understand as imperialism. All the markers of imperialism worthy of condemnation, be it economic exploitation, cultural dominance, military violence, et cetera, is carried out under the label of governance when done within its own borders. When done against, for example, the non-Arab minorities in Libya.
1:36:11 Speaker 10 I think what's missing from now popular anti-imperialist narratives is that connection, that analysis. And a gap in the analysis is what's creating this false consciousness that leads people to come to the conclusion that anti-imperialism means that XYZ government is anti-imperialist and good and ABC government is imperialist and bad. That's not how the world works. States are never going to be liberatory, they're not able to produce a liberatory framework. At their best, they function as a welfare state. At their worst, you get mass suppression and cults of personality. Sometimes you get a combination of both, as with Libya under Gaddafi.
1:36:55 Speaker 10 And that's my message for today. Please stop lionizing leaders, stay woke.
1:37:01 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:37:02 Speaker 10 And all power to all the people. I've been Andrew Sage, this is Akhara Panier, peace.
1:37:19 Speaker 00 Cash flow crunch? OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds up to $200,000 right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com OnDeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
1:37:50 Speaker 07 This January, bare-knuckle fighting championship takes over the ocean. The inaugural Brews Cruise sails from Miami to the Bahamas aboard the Norwegian Jewel. Three straight days with pool deck bare-knuckle fights in the Caribbean. Mess of parties, beach events, DJs, cigars, tequila tastings and non-stop action. The lineup reveals coming soon. Cabins are disappearing fast and the prices won't stay this low. Reserve your spot with just $200 down at B K F S E A dot com.
1:38:20 Speaker 03 I turned off news altogether. I hate to say it, but I don't trust much of anything.
1:38:27 Speaker 13 It's the rage bait.
1:38:30 Speaker 05 It feels like it's trying to divide people.
1:38:34 Speaker 04 We got clear facts. Maybe we can calm down a little.
1:38:39 Speaker 06 NBC News brings you clear reporting. Let's meet at the facts. Let's move forward from there. NBC News, reporting for America.
1:38:54 Speaker 15 On Sunday, April 12th, I went to the Basement nightclub in Queens. Like usual, someone scanned my ticket at the big gate off Flushing Avenue. I had to wait in a winding line outside the door, went through security and finally reached the DJ and bar. But instead of the regular collection of twinks, dolls and bisexuals, the room was full of city workers, politicians, journalists and DSA members, a decent number of which probably were bisexual, I suppose. Technically, we were directly above the Basement nightclub in the Knockdown Center event venue, gathered this Sunday afternoon to attend Mayor Zohran Mamdani's 100-day address.
1:39:38 Speaker 15 I'm Garrison Davis. This is It Could Happen Here, a show about things falling apart and sometimes putting stuff back together. This one is one of those rare episodes focused on the ladder. Earlier this April marked Mayor Mamdani's first 100 days in office. This episode, I'll discuss what Zoran has done these first 100 days, some of the challenges he's faced, if he's been able to deliver on the promises of his campaign, and how he's adapted to the power and constraints of running the biggest city in the country. And finally, what all this could mean for the future of working class and left-wing politics in the United States. Let's first return to the 100-day address above the basement
1:40:21 Speaker 15 nightclub. Upon entering the venue, you found yourself in a museum of the administration's first 100 days. This little installation displayed the mayor's snow shovel from the historic blizzard during Zoran's first few weeks in office, a tenant organizing suggestion board from the rental ripoff hearings, and a child-sized mayoral podium used to announce a new free childcare program for two-year-olds. Museum plaques detailed victories for labor and tenants' rights, as well as infrastructure accomplishments like scaffolding reform, and a pothole blitz that filled over 20,000 potholes in just three days. Before the mayor's speech, a Bronx parent, two tenant organizers, and a city worker from the Department of
1:41:04 Speaker 15 Transportation spoke to the crowd about how life is different under the new administration. Mamdani's speech was effectively a State of the Union for New York City. The mayor outlined the campaign promises the administration has fulfilled so far in their short time in office, and connected his style of governing to the sewer socialists of Milwaukee from the first half of the 20th century, who focused on strengthening public services.
1:41:30 Speaker 13 Because for too long, City Hall had not just failed to meet expectations, it had lowered them. After years of broken promises, no one in this city could be blamed for doubting that government held either the ability or the ambition to upend the status quo. Yet, as I said on that freezing January afternoon to more than 8.5 million New Yorkers, we will make no apology for what we believe.
1:42:01 Speaker 13 I was elected as a democratic socialist and I will govern as a democratic socialist.
1:42:09 Speaker 15 This speech was really the first time since the inauguration that the mayor has talked at length about what it means to govern as a democratic socialist and the example that New York City can set for the rest of the country. The address was mostly attended by city workers, who the mayor invited to enter into a ticket lottery. For most of the speech, I was pinned between a group of uniformed Department of Sanitation employees and workers from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. The event in general was focused on uplifting civil servants and celebrating public service, whether that be bus drivers, schoolteachers, or the sanitation workers that kept this city running during the worst snowstorm in years.
1:42:54 Speaker 15 It feels like for the past few decades, the only public sector job that gets regularly celebrated as noble by those in government or in the media and promoted by pop culture is being a police officer. Being a cop is the only public sector job that gets uplifted with propaganda. Zorron's little videos promoting 311 city call center workers is, to quote front of the pod Ben Lorber, "rolling back decades of neoliberal propaganda, reasserting the dignity of public sector work and workers." A common turn of phrase uttered by Mayor Mamdani is, "If you can't solve the smallest task in someone's life, why would they ever trust you to solve the biggest one?"
1:43:36 Speaker 15 So, let's go over some things, big and small, that Mamdani has been able to do in his first 100 days. One of Mamdani's core campaign promises was to freeze the rent. On February 18th, Mayor Mamdani appointed six new members to the nine-member Rent Guidelines Board, which each year is tasked with determining the rent increase percentages for the more than 1 million rent-stabilized apartments in the city. Under Eric Adams, the board approved a 3% rent increase for one-year leases and a 4% 5% increase for two-year leases. In just a few weeks, the new board will hold a preliminary vote to freeze or raise rents before their final vote in June.
1:44:20 Speaker 15 Public testimony on rent adjustments is currently underway. Housing in general is one of the top issues affecting affordability in this city, and the mayor's approach has not been limited to filling vacancies on the rent guidelines board. After Zoran's inauguration speech on January 1st, he went to a neglected apartment building just east of Prospect Park to sign an executive order revitalizing the mayor's office to protect tenants and appointed a tenant organizer to lead the office. This apartment building was owned by a literally bankrupt landlord called The Pinnacle Group, who was responsible for more than 5,000 housing violations and 14,000 complaints.
1:45:02 Speaker 15 The revamped office to protect tenants and the mayor intervened in the bankruptcy proceedings and successfully secured $30 million in repairs and upgrades for tenants, as well as protection from future displacement. Through this office, the administration has continued to crack down on bad landlords who violate New York City law and mistreat tenants. Just a few weeks after the inauguration, Mumdani announced a $2.1 million settlement from A&E Real Estate Properties for tenant harassment and hazardous conditions across 14 buildings in Brooklyn, Manhattan, and Queens. As a part of the settlement, A&E was also required to correct more than 4,000 building condition violations.
1:45:43 Speaker 15 In February, the Department of Housing Preservation and Development released a public list of the 250 buildings with the most severe housing code violations citywide and put them under heightened oversight via the Alternative Enforcement Program, with the city stepping in to make repairs, then billing the landlords if they fail to address violations.
1:46:04 Speaker 13 Since January 1st, we have won more than $34 million in settlements, judgments, and repairs for tenants.
1:46:15 Speaker 13 Delivered improvements to 6,070 apartments so far and issued 195,829 violations.
1:46:26 Speaker 13 New York City will no longer tolerate exploitation as a business model.
1:46:33 Speaker 15 In March, Mayor Mamdani announced a "landmark victory" against famously bad landlord Seth Miller of Aegis Realty. You can say the landlord was egregious at Realty. The city brought a case against Miller for dangerously derelict conditions at 919 Prospect Avenue in the South Bronx. And for the first time ever, courts imposed the maximum penalties under the city's nuisance abatement law, a $1,000 fine per day until housing violations are addressed, and $2.174 million in retroactive penalties. During the first 100 days, the city held five rental ripoff hearings,
1:47:17 Speaker 15 one in each borough, providing New Yorkers a platform to discuss various problems with their landlord from poor conditions to repair delays or junk fees. This was a dedicated public forum for tenants to speak directly to city officials and collectively shape housing policy going forward. A month into office, the mayor announced a $38 million investment to install modern heating and cooling in 712 of New York City's public housing units at the Beach 41st Street Houses in Queens. And technically, this is after the first 100 days, but I think it's worth mentioning that just a few days ago, Zorun announced a $2.5 billion investment in public housing
1:47:59 Speaker 15 to deliver new energy-efficient lighting and faucets to 45,000 homes, heat pumps in 20,000, and 10,000 new induction stoves, all affecting the NYCHA public housing in New York City.
1:48:12 Speaker 15 On Zorin's very first day in office, he also signed two executive orders to accelerate housing construction by building on city-owned properties to increase the supply of affordable housing and cutting red tape to make it faster and more affordable to build. The development approval process for building affordable housing has been reduced by more than two years by the administration's implementation of the new voter-approved expedited land use review procedure, combined with a new program called the Neighborhood Builders Fast Track, which will pre-select qualified developers to shorten the pre-development timeline by eight months for certain projects on city-owned land. Another of Zorin's core campaign promises was universal childcare. On his eighth day in office, Mayor Ramdani announced
1:48:56 Speaker 15 a partnership with Governor Kathy Hochul to provide free childcare for thousands of two-year-olds in New York City with a $1.2 billion increase in state funding. Since then, the mayor has expanded the free 3K program for three-year-olds to more than half of all school districts in the city and announced 2K fall enrollment for school districts 18, 23, 10, 6, and 27, which serve lower-income neighborhoods. 2K applications opened for the first time on June 2, with the program operating on a full-day schedule from 8:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. all year round. As a part of the 3K expansion, seven new early childcare education centers are opening in
1:49:39 Speaker 15 Western Queens, Staten Island, South Brooklyn, and the South Bronx. And on March 30, the mayor announced the city's first pilot program for free onsite childcare for city workers, based at the David Dinkins Municipal Building, with applications opening on April 30. The city also created a new accessible childcare provider map with interactive features to filter by location, age group, and cost. The mayor says that all these steps will lead to free childcare for every three-year-old and two-year-old in the city by the end of his first term. Another key promise was fast and free buses. The administration is making headway on the fast part by building more bus lanes, redesigning streets, as well as adding protected bike lanes
1:50:24 Speaker 15 on McGinnis Boulevard, 31st Street in Astoria, Ashland Place, across Flatbush, East Flatbush, Midwood, and Brooklyn and Kingston Avenues in Central Brooklyn. M'Amdani restarted the stalled Madison Ave bus lane redesign to make buses faster and more reliable for 92,000 daily riders. The city announced a new bus lane for the Bronx Crosstown Bus Service to Yankee Stadium, and restarted the Fordham Road Bus Lane Project to improve the busiest bus corridor in the Bronx, servicing an average of 130,000 daily riders across four routes. Just this week, construction began in Brooklyn for the redesign of Flatbush Avenue, with
1:51:05 Speaker 15 the goal of improving bus speeds by over 40% for 132,000 daily riders. And before the World Cup this summer, Zoran has promised to complete new bike lanes and pedestrian upgrades in Lower Manhattan. As for the free part, that will be a bit harder. M'Amdani maintains that his administration is working with the state government in Albany and the MTA to eventually make New York City buses free, and proposed a five-week free bus pilot program during the World Cup, though it's unclear if that will happen.
1:51:49 Speaker 15 It's not all sunshine and rainbows in New York City. Upon taking office, Mayor M'Amdani discovered the city was facing an unexpected financial crisis in the form of a hidden $12 billion deficit left by former Mayor Eric Adams, stemming from years of fiscal mismanagement and the underbudgeting of essential services like rental and cash assistance, shelters, health insurance, and special ed. As mayor, Eric Adams covered up this massive budget deficit by leaving the gaps grossly understated, gaps that were made worse by divestment in New York City by the state under former Governor Andrew Cuomo. The mayor is actually required by law to have a balanced budget. So rather than sweeping this under the rug by continuing to cook the city's books like
1:52:33 Speaker 15 his predecessor, Zoran chose transparency about the financial crisis he's inherited, and signed an executive order to designate chief savings officers in every city agency to streamline processes and eliminate waste. Some of these savings so far include cancelling $20,000 of Slack subscriptions to saving hundreds of thousands of dollars by foregoing vacant office space. Through his relationship with Governor Kathy Hochul, the mayor secured $1.5 billion in state aid in February. That, combined with higher-than-expected Wall Street revenues and savings measures, shrunk the deficit to $5.4 billion.
1:53:14 Speaker 15 Zoran's preliminary budget released last February sparked criticism for failing short of promises to increase funding to parks and libraries. While campaigning, Zoran advocated for city libraries to receive 0.5% of the city budget, but the preliminary budget only allocated 0.39%, which is actually a $29 million cut from the last Adams budget, down to $456 million. Meanwhile, the park budget remained effectively flat at about 0.5%, rather than boosting it to 1% of the total budget, as Mamdani previously hoped. Though in March, Mayor Mamdani announced new capital investment of $50 million to reconstruct
1:53:59 Speaker 15 10 parks in underserved neighborhoods. This February budget is preliminary and subject to change as Zoran's negotiations with the city council and the state continue. In February, Mamdani reversed a previous policy against the forced removal of homeless encampments after 20 people died in the street during a horrific blizzard and sudden cold snap in late January, despite the efforts of outreach workers visiting known homeless people every two hours to offer warm shelter and check if they needed help. 1,400 people were placed into shelters and warming centers during that first freeze, with 85 people involuntarily moved or hospitalized.
1:54:42 Speaker 15 The new encampment sweep policy will be led by the Department of Homeless Services, rather than the NYPD, as they were under Eric Adams, which Mombani said put homeless New Yorkers in danger and was ineffective in moving people into shelter or housing. Under the new plan, after posting a removal notice, outreach workers will visit encampments every day for a week with the goal of connecting people to shelter and establishing a pipeline to stable housing, while opening new shelters across the city, including New York City's first-ever pet-inclusive transitional housing facility for families. Much of the criticism levied at Zoran revolves around his choice to retain NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch, something he announced before the election.
1:55:25 Speaker 15 Zoran did cancel an Eric Adams plan to add 5,000 more NYPD officers, but, as promised, their budget remained effectively the same, despite the financial deficit. But Tisch specifically has been seen as a rare moderating force in the administration, an outlier that may be preventing police reforms that Zoran campaigned on, like disbanding the SRG, the Strategic Response Group, tasked with responding to both protests and terrorism, as well as getting rid of the NYPD gang database. Critics have noted that Zoran seems to be moving towards "reforms" of the gang database, rather than his previous call to "get rid of it," saying in early April, "I've made
1:56:09 Speaker 15 my critiques of the database clear, and the NYPD has also implemented a number of reforms, as per the recommendation that came through, and the implementation of those reforms and the results of that are part of the active discussion that we are having."
1:56:25 Speaker 15 The gang database in New York has shrunk by 40% in the last two years. As for the SRG, Mayor Maldani still maintains that he remains, quote, "steadfast in my commitment to disband the SRG, to do so in a manner that upholds both First Amendment rights of New Yorkers and keeps New Yorkers safe, and that is the subject of an active conversation that we are having," unquote. Commissioner Tisch has been particularly resistant to the idea of disbanding the SRG, though earlier this month, Mayor Maldani's Chief of Staff, Elbesard Church, said on the news that the administration remains committed to fulfilling the campaign promise of disbanding the SRG, and that a delegation of City Hall and NYPD officials traveled
1:57:08 Speaker 15 to Columbus, Ohio to learn about their protest policing model focused on, quote, "communication" and, quote, "de-escalation" over mass arrests and aggressive force.
1:57:19 Speaker 16 The commitment is to disband the SRG, and I think that the Columbus visit showcases that we are committed to a really disciplined approach here. We want it to work, and we want to do it in collaboration with the NYPD. So the mayor is in regular conversation with his police commissioner, and our teams also meet regularly so that we can design something that is best suited to that commitment being fulfilled and not compromising any of the safety and the protection that New Yorkers deserve.
1:57:48 Speaker 15 In an April interview, Mayor Maldani did express to the New York Times that, when unable to reach an agreement with Tisch, he does have the power to overrule her on police policy if needed, quote, "Ultimately, I hold the final decision no matter which department or agency we're speaking about," unquote. Maldani has not exercised this power with the NYPD as of yet. In March, Zoran took the first step in establishing the Department of Community Safety by opening the Office of Community Safety, led by Deputy Mayor Renita Francois, who directed de Blasio's action plan for neighborhood safety and advised Campaign Zero, which opposes the gang database.
1:58:30 Speaker 15 The new Office of Community Safety will develop strategies and coordinate efforts to combat gun violence, mental health crisis response, hate crimes, and substance abuse issues. At the announcement, François said, “The evidence is clear. Addressing what ails our communities, whether that be crumbling physical infrastructure, social disconnection, or a lack of access to economic opportunity, is how we best ensure that our communities are safe.” It’s too early to judge the impact of the office, but such an office or city department has the potential to challenge the police’s monopoly on public safety. The other common critique of Mamdani is based on his endorsement of liberal Governor Kathy Hochul
1:59:14 Speaker 15 and his decision to focus on governing rather than dedicating resources and political capital towards further uphill primary challenges. Zoran has said, “The success of our movement will be defined by the success of our government.” Through his working partnership with Governor Hochul, the mayor has been able to extract wins from the state, particularly for universal childcare and the $1.5 billion in state aid. In the realm of discourse, some leftists, anarchists, or ultras have jumped on any fault or policy shift as a sign that Zoran has wholly moved to the right or betrayed the movement. Such opinions are rewarded by the social media economy, which tends to encourage whatever is seen
1:59:59 Speaker 15 as the most radical, extreme, or divisive opinion. This tendency has been present even among some of Zoran’s earliest online supporters. Behind this tendency is a willingness, and frankly, hunger, to turn on Zoran, not necessarily for anything he has or has not done, but because of the position he now occupies. Zoran used to be an outsider, challenging the democratic establishment embodied by Andrew Cuomo. But now, he’s one of the most popular Democrats in the country. DNC’s social media accounts are posting Zoran memes and hype videos. This could be viewed as a massive accomplishment, evidence that the Democratic Party can be forced to bend toward left-wing populism
2:00:43 Speaker 15 because of the working-class voters and mass organizing that put Zoron in the position he's currently in. But others view Zoron's acceptance and select promotion within the party as a sign he's been corrupted, co-opted, recuperated, or made palatable. Both of these things can be partially true. The Democratic elite certainly have their own motives for dipping their toes into the Mamdani hot tub, just as Zoron and the New York City DSA have their own aspirations for influencing the direction of the party towards social democracy and democratic socialism. In general, there's a lot of confusion or disagreement on what it means to be a democratic socialist in a position of power.
2:01:28 Speaker 15 As an executive, Zoron is in a unique position that not many other DSA members have ever had. Being in such a position of power informs and shapes the way someone interacts with the systems of party and state in a way that those outside of power cannot fully understand. It filters ideology into material actions. This idea frightens many, but differences in political horizons also affect the way people interact and move with these systems. The question is not, what should Zoron do if there were no constraints on his power? Because then, obviously, he should just implement utopian communism. But his power obviously does have constraints.
2:02:13 Speaker 15 If the goal for the left is to build a working-class movement, to that end, as a function of Zoron's constraints, it may actually be more effective for him to operate down to certain state pathways that allow him to facilitate the building of a working-class movement and avoid other, more extreme pathways that, because of the current constraints on executive power, would either be ineffective at best or self-destructive at worst.
2:02:40 Speaker 15 As the mayor, Zoron's job is to run the biggest city in the country. And as a democratic socialist, that means using government to make life better for the working class. His task is to govern in a way that alleviates economic conditions, to make it easier to organize and build a working class movement. But building that movement is not his job. It's yours. It's the job of the people. And such a movement is the only way of holding elected leaders like Zoron accountable. Zoron is not a revolutionary, nor is he an organizer. He's the mayor of New York City, and as mayor, he has to serve more than 8 million New Yorkers, not just the 14,000 members of New York City DSA.
2:03:25 Speaker 15 The mayor may join the picket line with striking nurses and fight for working-class New Yorkers in City Hall, or even open an office of mass engagement, like Zoron has done. But it is up to those outside City Hall to move in tandem by working to rebuild a labor movement. Assuming that Zoron or some random public official can just do whatever is the most extreme radical thing, mistakenly sees the state as having more power than it actually does. People often see the state as an ahistorical, abstracted seat of power. But no, the state is just the mediator between capital and labor. The power of the state to support labor is exercised by doing things that are in the
2:04:09 Speaker 15 interest of labor and society as a whole, rather than just capital. But this ability is directly linked to the extent that labor is organized. So if labor is largely unorganized, then Zoron is more restrained in what he can do. What he can do, then, is use his position to help build working-class power, which will then enable him further, so on and so on. The state has no power against capital outside of the power that labor gives it.
2:04:40 Speaker 15 Our situation is one where capital is very strong, which means when the state serves capital, it's quite strong. But in its function of serving labor, it's rather weak because the left is built to reckon with the fact that right now, labor is actually quite weak, which means that state actors, even those on the pro-labor left, are very constrained. So the main thing they can do to strengthen labor is providing better conditions for which labor power may be built. And importantly, organizers must utilize those conditions to build the labor movement. Zorin's other task is to demonstrate that left-wing working-class politics can actually govern, not just critique.
2:05:25 Speaker 15 Whether or not he succeeds at governing and delivering for working-class New Yorkers determines the perceived viability of democratic socialist politics nationally going forward. As Mamdani has said, "The worth of an ideology can only be judged by its delivery."
2:05:51 Speaker 15 Mamdani is not the first democratic socialist to be put in such a position. In his 100-day address, Mayor Mamdani spoke about the so-called sewer socialists of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, who 100 years ago, quote, "built the greatest public park system in the nation and weathered the Great Depression better than almost any other American city. Milwaukee purged corruption, built the first municipally-sponsored public housing development in the nation, and transformed the city's sewage disposal system," unquote. Mayor Mamdani is trying to revive this legacy of municipal socialism by acting on his mantra, "There is no problem too big, no task too small."
2:06:31 Speaker 15 On day six of office, Mamdani fixed the infamous Williamsburg Bridge bump that has long plagued cyclists. And in response to the historic winter damage affecting city streets, the administration launched a five-borough pothole blitz, filling 100,000 potholes in less than 100 days.
2:06:52 Speaker 13 This is Pothole Politics. Our 2026 answer to sewer socialism.
2:06:59 Speaker 13 Where government is not too busy, not too self-important, not too mired in paperwork to fix the problems of the city, no matter their size.
2:07:07 Speaker 15 This "pothole" politics has extended to scaffolding reforms, reducing the time that sheds clutter our sidewalks. In January, the mayor announced a new program to expand modular public restrooms. And, starting this summer, the roof of the historic David Dinkins Municipal Building will be open to the public for free viewing and tours. Fighting for workers from within City Hall isn't just an abstract ideal. In the first 100 days, the administration secured $9.3 million in restitution.
2:07:39 Speaker 13 No longer will city government be afraid of its own shadow. If anyone should be afraid, it is those who take advantage of working people.
2:07:48 Speaker 15 On January 15th, the city filed a lawsuit against a predatory delivery app called Motoclick for violating worker laws like minimal pay rate. At the end of January, Zorong announced more than $5 million in worker restitution and penalties due to minimum pay rate violations from three major restaurant delivery apps: Uber Eats, Fanton, and Hungry Panda. This money will be paid to almost 50,000 workers, and as a part of the settlement, Uber also agreed to reinstate 10,000 wrongfully deactivated delivery workers. In March, the administration won almost $2 million for over 800 fast food workers at Taco Bell and retail workers for violations of worker protection laws against unpredictable
2:08:33 Speaker 15 scheduling. The mayor signed executive orders strengthening consumer protections by targeting hidden junk fees and impossible-to-cancel subscriptions, and expanded the protected time-off law to 4.3 million previously unprotected workers, and issued compliance warnings to nearly 60,000 employers. Speaking of sewer socialism, at the end of March, Mayor Mamdani announced a $108 million investment to upgrade and replace more than 6,700 water catch basins to combat flooding. This "pothole" politics lays the groundwork of public trust needed for larger systematic transformations.
2:09:13 Speaker 13 If government can't do the small things, how could you ever trust it to do the big ones? How can we promise to transform our city if we can't pave your street?
2:09:24 Speaker 15 At the end of the 100-day address, Mayor Mamdani made a series of announcements. The administration is restarting trash containerization, and will make buses faster for 1 million New Yorkers by speeding up buses by 20% along 45 priority corridors, and constructing new rapid bus routes for 100,000 New Yorkers who live more than half a mile away from a subway or rail stop. But the big announcement was an update to another of Zoron's core campaign promises. The first of five city-owned grocery stores will open next year, with one store being opened in each borough by the end of Mamdani's first term. The location of the Manhattan Municipal Grocery Store has already been selected:
2:10:09 Speaker 15 La Marchetta in East Harlem, a public market opened by the New Deal-era Mayor Fiero LaGuardia. The city will build a 9,000-square-foot store at the site to offer cheaper groceries than the capitalist competitors.
2:10:24 Speaker 13 I know there are many who use socialist as a dirty word, something to be ashamed of. They can try all they want, but we will not be ashamed of using government to fight for the many, not simply the few.
2:10:43 Speaker 13 We will not be ashamed of adding more heat pumps to NYCHA buildings in the Rockaways or building more supportive housing in Harlem or standing steadfast alongside our trans neighbors.
2:10:59 Speaker 13 We will not be ashamed of investing in youth mental health clinics or working to close Rikers or fighting for immigrants targeted by ICE.
2:11:13 Speaker 13 To any New Yorker, whether you're under attack from the federal government's cruelty or suffocating under the affordability crisis, we will stand beside you.
2:11:26 Speaker 13 Because government is a series of choices. And socialism is the choice to fight for every New Yorker. To extend democracy from the ballot box to the rest of our lives.
2:11:41 Speaker 15 Three days after M'Amdani's 100-day address on Tax Day, April 15, the mayor announced that he and Governor Hochul had agreed to a new Tax the Rich proposal. New York State will have its first-ever P to T tax, a wealth tax on second homes in New York City valued above $5 million, owned by out-of-state elites. This tax on the ultra-wealthy is projected to generate $500 million in annual revenue. And if owners want to avoid the tax by moving into the residence, that's fine, too, because then they'll have to pay New York resident taxes. So you get taxed either way.
2:12:23 Speaker 15 Part of pushing back against the libertarian ethos in America by showing that government can actually make your life better is actually showing people what local government is doing. Since taking office, Zorin has employed the same widely-successful messaging style that helped get him elected to make PSAs and inform New Yorkers about what the administration has been able to accomplish. This is something Democrats have largely failed to do, by either just not doing this sort of outreach while governing, making any outreach inaccessible or hard to understand, or having your outreach come off as cringe or out of touch. Regardless of how much effort is put into outreach, the people have to also see the improvements being talked about
2:13:08 Speaker 15 in their own lives or in their own neighborhoods. A dense population and having a cohesive city culture like New York helps with that. Millions of cyclists cross the Williamsburg Bridge every year. So when the mayor fixes the bump during his first week in office, that's an easy reference point for people. The success of the administration's comms strategy has been by using Zorin's popularity to promote the public sector and public-sector workers while actually showing people how social services help city residents. As the mayor says, "New York belongs to all who live in it." While in office, Zorron has largely declined to explicitly talk about how his administration
2:13:53 Speaker 15 may impact the future of democratic socialism across the country. Instead, keeping his vision laser focused on improving the lives of working New Yorkers and making the city more affordable. To quote the mayor, "We cannot burden ourselves with the question of what this means beyond this city." But before the mayor went onstage at the 100-day address, they played a clip of the progressive New Deal Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia saying that "the greatness of New York City is in the services to its people, where public problems are really the problems of all the people." Quote, "And if we succeed here, surely it can be done elsewhere."
2:14:35 Speaker 15 When former socialist mayor Bernie Sanders made a surprise appearance during Zorron's speech, the senator spoke about how what's happening in New York is influencing those outside the city.
2:14:46 Speaker 17 And I want to tell all of you and the mayor that what you guys are doing here in New York City is important not only to the people here. What you are doing, what the mayor is doing, is providing hope and inspiration not only to people all across our country, but honestly, all across the world.
2:15:12 Speaker 15 As a part of Mamdani's first 100 days press circuit, he was asked on CBS News about the future of the Democratic Party and if his socialist politics are really viable.
2:15:25 Speaker 14 You know, what I find is that New Yorkers ask me less about how I describe my politics and more about whether my politics includes them. And I think what we can see is that a democratic socialist politics is one that should be judged on its delivery, like any ideology. And what we're showing in this city is we can pursue the big things like universal childcare and do the pothole politics at the same time that we're showing, and not just filling in the potholes, changing the catch basins, but also repaving over 1,000 miles of roadway. But Mr. Mayor, presidential and statewide elections are often decided in battleground regions that do not look like New York City. Yeah. I'll be honest with you. Before I was the mayor, I was an Assembly Member of Astoria and Long Island City. At that time, I was told that you could only be a democratic socialist in Northwest Queens. Then I became the mayor.
2:16:10 Speaker 14 Now the next question is the state. Then it'll be, the next question will be the country. I think that this is a politics that can flourish anywhere because frankly, there is only one majority in this country. That's the working class. And it's time we have a politics that puts them at the heart of what it is that we're pursuing and not as part of the appendix.
2:16:26 Speaker 15 Mamdani still has over 1,300 days left in his first term. And there will be more challenges along the way. Challenges with the NYPD, the MTA, state government, federal government, the billionaires, and the blood sucking monsters among the Democratic Party elite. Attempts to hold politicians like Zorron truly accountable to their politics will require more than Twitter Maoists and your small DSA caucus. Navigating all these problems will require not just principal leadership with a commitment to working class politics, but also growing the mass organizing apparatus that helped get Zorron elected and continuing to build power in City Hall, state government, and
2:17:09 Speaker 15 in the workplace. That does it today for It Could Happen Here. See you on the other side.
2:17:26 Speaker 18 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
2:17:54 Speaker 07 This January, bare knuckle fighting championship takes over the ocean. The inaugural Brews Cruise sails from Miami to the Bahamas aboard the Norwegian Jewel. Three straight days with pool deck bare knuckle fights in the Caribbean. Mess of parties, beach events, DJs, cigars, tequila tastings, and nonstop action. The lineup reveals coming soon. Cabins are disappearing fast, and the prices won't stay this low. Reserve your spot with just $200 down at bkfsea.com.
2:18:24 Speaker 03 I turned off news altogether. I hate to say it, but I don't trust much of anything.
2:18:32 Speaker 04 It's the rage bait.
2:18:34 Speaker 05 It feels like it's trying to divide people.
2:18:38 Speaker 04 We got clear facts, maybe we could calm down a little.
2:18:44 Speaker 06 NBC News brings you clear reporting. Let's meet at the facts. Let's move forward from there. NBC News, reporting for America.
2:18:59 Speaker 15 This is It Could Happen Here: Executive Disorder, our weekly newscast covering what's happening in the White House, their crumbling world, and what it means for you. I'm Garrison Davis. Today I'm joined by James Stout and Robert Evans. This episode, we're covering the week of April 22nd to April 30th. Anything, anything interesting happen this week? Very little, not much news. Oh, not much. I mean, Garrison, you've joined the ranks of the vaccine injured, right? Mm hmm. Yeah, yeah. Also joining us are four live vaccines inside Garrison's body. Thank you. Thank you for having me and my four live vaccines, which have obliterated my body and mind this week as I scrambled to finish the M'Adani piece. But news happens, whether or not I feel bad.
2:19:45 Speaker 15 So let's get to it. In fact, I think that happened a lot when we feel that the news sometimes conspires that way. Now, we will talk about the thing, obviously, we'll talk about the thing. But first, some smaller news items to start. Congress has voted to end the 76-day DHS shutdown without funding for ICE or Border Patrol. The bill now goes to Trump today, and if he signs it, the shutdown will be over. The House voted to reauthorize FISA Section 702, the warrant list of surveillance authority. Forty-two House Democrats voted to reauthorize, 22 Republicans voted against. The bill is expected to be stalled in the Senate, at least this version of the bill,
2:20:29 Speaker 15 as it included an amendment about digital currency, which the Senate will fight over. The ATF released a new list of proposed reforms and regulations, repealing the Biden pistol brace rule, as well as requiring "biological sex" be used on ATF forms.
2:20:48 Speaker 15 The State Department is releasing a limited edition passport for the United States 250th anniversary, featuring a portrait of President Trump, superimposed on the Declaration of Independence and an American flag with his golden signature below. Google "Trump golden signature" for more.
2:21:04 Robert Evans? Look, I'm just gonna say, if we have any foreign border control agents listening, you have to detain anybody who see with that passport.
2:21:14 Speaker 11 It is now possible for Nicki Minaj, and only Nicki Minaj, to assemble the most unique collection of United States government documents in history if she becomes a citizen. Because she is apparently the only recipient of the gold card thus far.
2:21:28 Robert Evans? The golden visa, yeah.
2:21:29 Speaker 11 Yeah. She could really, she could really get a unique, you know, Pokemon combination here of, I guess it would, she'd have to advance pretty quickly from.
2:21:38 Speaker 15 She would.
2:21:39 Speaker 11 I'm not clear how one goes from gold card citizenship. And the only way we'll find out is by closely following Nicki Minaj.
2:21:45 Speaker 15 The DOJ indicted former FBI Director James Comey for the second time, this time for posting an Instagram image with the numbers 8647. Once again, Trump's FCC is going after Disney's ABC licenses by directing Disney to file an early renewal order after Jimmy Kimmel made a joke a few days before the White House Correspondents' Dinner about First Lady Melania Trump having the, quote, "glow of an expectant widow." It pains me to say, critical support to Jimmy Kimmel. President Trump, David Allison, Todd Blanch, Stephen Miller, Barry Weiss, Paramount's chief legal officer, and several CBS journalists met in a closed-door dinner in Washington DC last week
2:22:28 Speaker 15 as the Paramount buyout of Warner Brothers and CNN progresses. Nightmare blunt rotation. Maine Governor Janet Mills vetoed the state's 18-month data center moratorium, the first of its kind in the country. Days later, Mills dropped out of the Senate race, paving the way for populist candidate Graham Plathner to receive the Democratic nomination and go up against Susan Collins in the midterms.
2:22:52 Speaker 11 Most of Dems seem to already be behind him. I saw a post from the @democrats account, picture of Graham.
2:22:58 Robert Evans? Yeah, it's going to be interesting to see how the Democratic Party kind of falls in line behind this guy, given the fairly unique degree of controversy over the Nazi tattoo and a couple of other things that have come up. But this has been, in general, the gap between kind of how random progressives and Democrats online talk about Platner and how people in Maine feel about him has been massive from the jump. And I think a lot of it has to do just with the fact that this guy went about campaigning in a very dedicated way. He visited basically every county that like he could. And it goes to show that the consensus that builds online around candidates will never matter as much as like what they're out there actually doing in the world. And it's it's useful to get a reminder of that,
2:23:43 Robert Evans? whether or not you think this is a tremendous disaster, just the degree to which all of the the talk about this guy online had no impact on his ability to actually like win. Now, this is a unique case. There aren't a whole lot of seats that are like the seat that he's going to be taking, right? In terms of like both the weakness of your primary rival and the weakness of the other party, if you should happen to win the primary, like this is not every congressional district, but it's still kind of an interesting case study.
2:24:13 Speaker 11 Maine is also like, it's not California, you know, like Californians, our discourse happens online because we're a vast state and, you know, we have these big cities and such. And Maine is different. Like, he has good ground game and that matters more there, it seems.
2:24:27 Speaker 15 And this signifies like a rejection of democratic establishment politicians, like a hunger for change.
2:24:32 Speaker 11 Yep.
2:24:33 Speaker 15 And the fact that someone with all the controversies that come with Platner was able to beat the democratic establishment, I think, shows how hungry, how hungry people are to upseat these these blood sucking monsters.
2:24:45 Speaker 11 Yeah, we'll keep reporting on that. I'm kind of interested in this race, so.
2:24:50 Speaker 15 Yes, no, absolutely. I mean, Susan Collins plays a unique role in the Senate right now.
2:24:55 Speaker 15 Finally for me, on Saturday, a car bomb exploded at a police station in Dunmire, Northern Ireland, outside Belfast. A group calling itself the "new IRA" claimed responsibility, and a 66-year-old man has been arrested.
2:25:10 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:25:12 Robert Evans? "New IRA, 66-year-old man."
2:25:16 Robert Evans? Well, the "new IRA" is a, it's a, it grows out of the "real IRA," right? Was it the "new IRA" who killed that journalist a few years back in Belfast?
2:25:25 Speaker 11 You know what? I don't know.
2:25:27 Robert Evans? The "new IRA," yep, admitted responsibility, yeah, yeah. That's the "new IRA" as well. Lara McKee is the name of the journalist who was killed.
2:25:35 Speaker 11 Okay.
2:25:36 Robert Evans? I think just out of negligence and incompetence during an action these people were a part of.
2:25:40 Speaker 11 Yeah, this is like, like, just before COVID times, like, yeah.
2:25:44 Speaker 15 Vaguely remember.
2:25:45 Speaker 11 So, two large vessels, including a tanker, have been seized by pirates off Somalia. Another attempted hijacking by pirates was prevented. I'm just going to quote the UK MTO here. Quote, "The master of a cargo vessel was approached by two small fishing vessels with armed persons aboard. One vessel approached within 600 meters. Warning shots were fired and the suspicious craft returned fire. The suspicious boat moved away and made clear of the vessel. All crew are safe and accounted for. Vessels are advised to transit with caution and report any suspicious activities to UK MTO. Authorities are investigating." I saw another incident where a ship had fired a flare at people who were allegedly attempting to board it, right?
2:26:29 Speaker 11 But it seems like there has been an uptick in instance, especially as ships generally are having a hard time right now. The United States has also been boarding a number of vessels to inspect them as part of its blockade on Iran and Iranian goods. Secondly, JNIM, that's Jomat Nusrat al Islam Wal Muslimin, and the Aswad Liberation Front in Mali launched a shock offensive this week that saw them sweep into Mali's capital, assassinate the Defence Minister, and force the military junta and its allied Russian forces to abandon whole cities. They also abandoned a number of bases, right? The JNIM have captured, like, massive amounts of Russian Africa Corps material.
2:27:11 Speaker 11 But this is a pretty ground-shaking offensive, since it's a big change for Mali. The Hunter in Myanmar, I think I'm still keep calling them that. They've rebranded themselves as a civilian government. They're not. No. Min Ahn-haeng has retired as a general and just become president and changed clothes and done the same shit. Like, the Hunter reclaimed Falam this week, which is in Chin State. It's the capital of Chin State. Fighting has been happening there for months. I've been talking to people pretty regularly who are taking part in the, in the battle there. They're obviously, you know, they lost friends in the battle. They are not happy about this, but I think it's fair to say that spirits among the resistance generally
2:27:53 Speaker 11 remain pretty high. And they hope that they'll return to Falam soon enough. Doug Burgum has announced a United States geographic, is it geographical or geological survey?
2:28:04 Robert Evans? USGS geological survey.
2:28:06 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:28:07 Robert Evans? I know that because of the film Evolution starring David Duchovny.
2:28:10 Speaker 11 Not familiar.
2:28:11 Robert Evans? This is an important piece of news for the listeners. There was a brief period of time in between X-Files and Californication where we thought that David Duchovny might have a career as a comedic actor. And no, he did not.
2:28:22 Speaker 11 That he might have a career?
2:28:26 Robert Evans? He's had a great career. He's had a great career, just not as a comedic actor.
2:28:32 Speaker 11 Yeah. Okay, so Doug Burgum has announced that the United States Geological Survey found enough lithium to replace three centuries of imports in Appalachia.
2:28:43 Robert Evans? Enough lithium to do that or make one American small town normal for a weekend?
2:28:50 Speaker 11 Yeah. I want to read from this because it's kind of interesting. Quote, "The southern Appalachians hold an estimated 1.43 million metric tons of lithium oxide, concentrated in the Carolinas, and the northern Appalachians hold an estimated 900,000 metric tons, concentrated in Maine and New Hampshire." According to estimates in a new USGS scientific paper. That is like, I guess, big Appalachia, like going up into Maine there. Leaving that aside, lithium mining is incredibly disruptive to the environment, right? Yeah. Generally, there's two ways you could do it. You can extract it from brine like they do in Chile. And I think other places, I think they're trying to do that in California. Otherwise, it's open pit mining.
2:29:34 Speaker 11 The water use, the energy use, ecological damage will be huge. The potential for disasters is not zero. And the people of Appalachia should be more than familiar with how this tends to go. Right? This is a long history of mining and mining disasters. Moving on, Donald Trump has reposted a tweet about changing the name of ICE to nice.
2:29:58 Speaker 15 Nice agents.
2:30:00 Robert Evans? They should do this. I want them to do this.
2:30:03 Speaker 11 It would be absolutely disastrous for audio journalism.
2:30:07 Robert Evans? It's, it's, it'd be like, look, we understand, you know, it's 1943. People have a lot of issues with the Gestapo. We're going to call them the fun Gestapo now.
2:30:15 Speaker 11 Yeah, the nice Gestapo. Yeah, the great Gestapo.
2:30:19 Robert Evans? SS now stands for super sweet, actually.
2:30:25 Speaker 15 The White House account and the DHS account have posted nice images or hype videos since this as well.
2:30:32 Robert Evans? Yeah, we have to consider, there's like a 40% chance this happens at least.
2:30:36 Speaker 11 Yeah, no, this might happen. This could very much happen. Like, we're laughing, but this could be the future.
2:30:42 Speaker 15 Yeah. What does the N stand for?
2:30:44 Speaker 11 National. National. It's just, it's what they call a backronym. I know Garrison, with these guys, the N could have stood for a couple of things. Yeah, sure. Trump truth, great idea, do it. That is how policy is made these days.
2:31:02 Speaker 15 This is how government policy works now via, via truth.
2:31:05 Robert Evans? Yeah, this has made something clear to me that I was kind of dancing around for all, which is that I am in support in general of any policy that just pulls the wool off of people's eyes. Like, this, this is one of those things where it's now should be clearer to even the really stupid people where we are as a country when we do, when something like this happens.
2:31:22 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:31:22 Robert Evans? And so I'm supportive of it. Like, we can't have any artifice. The more you dress things up, the more people get deranged. So at least this, everyone knows what's happening.
2:31:31 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:31:32 Robert Evans? Really clear.
2:31:33 Speaker 11 I'm also generally in favor of like, they have a budget. It is vast, but it is fixed. And if they want to spend it all rewrapping their vehicles to say nice. Yeah, fine. Also, it's gonna make them feel lame.
2:31:43 Speaker 15 Are they gonna do that by buying N stickers? Or do they have to get the whole new sticker, do you think, right? Slap the end on there?
2:31:49 Speaker 11 I hope they just slap it in.
2:31:52 Speaker 11 I don't know if we want to open the, uh, open the door to them having stickers with N on it. Yeah, who knows, Garrison? They, uh, they had previously spent quite a lot of money wrapping vehicles, so it's not beyond them to get. Maybe they'll go a whole rebrand. Maybe it'll be nice on a picture of someone like holding cake or.
2:32:08 Speaker 15 They gotta find some way to spend the seven bajillion dollars that they have, so.
2:32:13 Robert Evans? Either that, or, you know, when we get someone better in, we could keep the name, but just create like a brand partnership with the city of Nice in France.
2:32:20 Speaker 11 I was gonna say that, yeah.
2:32:21 Robert Evans? It's like, and, and turn them into advertising instead of.
2:32:24 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:32:24 Robert Evans? Pulling people away from their families. They can tell people about all of the new deals on airfare to France that are available right now.
2:32:31 Speaker 15 We don't even need to abolish Nice. We can just reform it.
2:32:33 Speaker 11 Yeah, we could just, we could just reform it to a, a tourism agency for one city in France. There is a type of biscuit in Britain, which I suspect maybe comes from Nice. But it's Germany referred to as a nice biscuit because it has nice stamped on the biscuit.
2:32:47 Robert Evans? Sure.
2:32:47 Speaker 11 So perhaps we could, instead of guns, give them biscuits and they can hand those out.
2:32:52 Robert Evans? Think of how much better it'll be. Some guy shows up for his, like, you know, immigration court meeting and he, he finishes that. And on his way out, there's a delegation of guys from, from Nice, just being like, you wanna go on vacation? One of France's top five or six cities? I assume.
2:33:09 Speaker 11 The Nice sois cops. Yeah, they give you like one of those special salads they make there with, yeah. So many, uh, yeah, it could be great. Hit us up.
2:33:16 Robert Evans? This could be, this could work.
2:33:17 Speaker 11 Yeah, if you're the mayor of Nice, uh, we can, we can introduce you. Yeah. Finally, the United States has indicted the governor of Sinaloa on drug trafficking charges, which is a pretty significant thing.
2:33:31 Speaker 15 Well, that's not as funny.
2:33:32 Speaker 11 Yeah, no, no. No, well, they're not gonna be brand, rebranding it, Sinaloa, clearly, are they, so?
2:33:37 Speaker 15 Speaking of not being funny, let's actually talk about the bad news this week.
2:33:44 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:33:44 Speaker 15 On Wednesday, the Supreme Court struck down a Louisiana voting map as a, quote, unconstitutional racial gerrymander, unquote, that effectively created a black voting district. The ruling was split six, three on ideological lines. Alito wrote the majority opinion, saying that the district violated the equal protection clause of the Constitution.
2:34:10 Speaker 15 The new ruling substantially undermines the 1965 Voting Rights Act, reinterpreting Section 2 provisions against racial discrimination to require evidence of intentional racial discrimination, not just discrimination as the effect. So in the future, proving discriminatory motives may be needed in order to win legal challenges against gerrymandering by citing the Voting Rights Act. This ruling specifically depowers black voters while enabling Republican gerrymandering to continue. Republicans in the South will now be able to redraw House district maps that lean Democrat that have a high number of black voters.
2:34:51 Speaker 15 NPR estimates at least 15 House districts are now at risk of elimination. In the dissent, Justice Alana Kagan wrote, "The court's decision will set back the foundational right Congress granted of racial equality in electoral opportunity." Yeah, this is bad. This is possibly the worst escalation of the continued undermining of the Voting Rights Act.
2:35:16 Robert Evans? Yeah, yeah. Right, yeah. I mean, this is inarguably the most important thing going on this week, even with the shooting that we haven't talked about, like the gutting of the act that people died for. Like, the Voting Rights Act has a body count attached to it.
2:35:30 Speaker 15 Yeah.
2:35:30 Robert Evans? The court has to be packed. The next, like, if there's ever another Democratic or left-of-center administration and they don't pack the court, there's simply no chance of improving or fixing any of the problems this country has. Like, it's a necessary prerequisite.
2:35:45 Speaker 15 It's no coming back from this. D.C. and Puerto Rico also need to become states and have their own congressional representation. Any future opposition administration has to go completely gloves off, like...
2:35:57 Robert Evans? Yeah, and we have to imprison a bunch of the people currently running things, yeah. Like, there's a lot of stuff that has to happen. But one of those is the Supreme Court needs to get packed because, by God, these people are not going to approve of anything that isn't insane.
2:36:09 Speaker 15 It's unclear if this ruling will have immediate impacts on the upcoming midterms, but by 2028, it will certainly have impacts.
2:36:18 Robert Evans? Yeah.
2:36:19 Speaker 11 Yeah, they they had filed for an emergency decision on redistricting, or I guess not redistricting, like like pre-district, I don't know what you would call that, but but uh, to get this in effect before the midterms, basically.
2:36:32 Speaker 15 Yeah. The Supreme Court also sent this to a lower court to work out more details. It's going to obviously be ongoing litigation about it, just as there will be about Florida's redistricting measure that they are trying to finalize before the midterms as well.
2:36:47 Speaker 11 Yeah. And indeed, California, as I think there have been some arguments made, like now that this decision has been made by the Supreme Court, right? Like either states will have to consider this in their redistricting. Shall we take a break?
2:36:59 Speaker 15 We shall, and then we can talk about the dinner.
2:37:02 Speaker 11 Yep.
2:37:13 Speaker 15 Okay, we are back. Let's talk about the dinner. Let's talk about the shooting that happened at the dinner, the thing that everyone else has been talking about for the past five, six days. So yeah, on April 25th, during the White House Correspondents' Dinner, everyone's favorite event.
2:37:30 Robert Evans? It's a shame we weren't there.
2:37:32 Speaker 15 It is unfortunate that we were not there to point our vertical video at our face as the news happens in front of us.
2:37:38 Robert Evans? Oh, I would have been filming just your face, Garrison, and just like really tight in, like to the point where it's it's difficult for you to get up and move. I keep watching. No, Garrison, face to camera, come on. The people need to see this.
2:37:51 Speaker 11 I'd be assuming the warfighter posture.
2:37:54 Speaker 15 You're gonna get up like Hank Seth and storm around.
2:37:59 Robert Evans? I would I would also be shielding myself behind Stephen Miller's wife.
2:38:04 Speaker 15 Hey, that could have been either way. He could have been protecting the wife.
2:38:07 Robert Evans? I know it could have been either way. It's funny though. It's funny.
2:38:11 Speaker 15 At least at least Miller wasn't wasn't getting cucked, unlike the FBI director.
2:38:16 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:38:17 Robert Evans? That is funny that he abandoned his wife.
2:38:20 Speaker 15 Girlfriend, girlfriend.
2:38:21 Speaker 11 Girlfriend, sorry. I guess we should just go, let's recap the events for people who live under a rock.
2:38:28 Speaker 15 So shortly before 8:30 PM, the alleged shooter approached the Secret Service Security Screening Checkpoint located on the terrace level of the hotel. This was the level above the ballroom level. Where the actual dinner was taking place. James, we should probably just read from the court document.
2:38:50 Speaker 11 Yeah, I think I'm just gonna read this straight from the government's DOJ statement in court. Right before the defendant approached the checkpoint, he discarded a long black coat that concealed a 12 gauge pump action shock. The defendant then sprinted through one of the magnetometers at the checkpoint and ran in the direction of the stairs leading to the ballroom where the president and members of his family and cabinet were located. As the defendant did so, he held a shotgun in both hands in a raised position parallel to the ground. A United States Secret Service officer observed the defendant fire the shotgun in the direction of the stairs leading down to the ballroom. The Secret Service officer and others at the checkpoint heard the gunshot. The Secret Service officer drew his service weapon and fired five times at the defendant.
2:39:36 Speaker 11 The defendant fell to the ground and was restrained by law enforcement and was placed under arrest. The defendant suffered a minor injury to his knee, but was not shot. We can in a second talk about whether he shot the Secret Service officer.
2:39:51 Speaker 15 Yeah, because there's an interesting Washington Post review that's out too now.
2:39:56 Speaker 11 Mm hmm. Yeah, and a couple of court documents just filed today.
2:40:00 Speaker 15 Yeah.
2:40:00 Speaker 11 Let's talk a little bit about the circumstances, this, right? This person had purchased, according to court documents, he purchased two weapons from separate firearms dealers in California, buying the shotgun on or about August 17th, 2025, and the pistol on or about October 6th, 2023.
2:40:17 Speaker 15 He had the pistol for a while. The shotgun was more of a recent purchase.
2:40:21 Speaker 11 Yeah, yeah. The pistol is a fascinating choice.
2:40:26 Speaker 15 Amazing choice. 38 Super.
2:40:29 Speaker 11 Yeah, I have never seen a 38 Super handgun outside of the, they're very, they're common in Mexico because they have a certain cachet and cultural value.
2:40:41 Robert Evans? Every 38 Super handgun that I have personally held was embossed in gold and silver.
2:40:45 Speaker 11 Yeah, yeah.
2:40:46 Robert Evans? And usually a Mexican flag, but not exclusively.
2:40:49 Speaker 11 Yeah, or like some sort of heraldry that denotes, uh, that is associated sometimes with organized crime. Like, I'm not, when I say associated with organized crime, a few weeks ago, right? I talked about a material support for terrorism case, which centered on a firearms dealer who was selling grips for 38 Super pistols with images that are associated with cartels. Like, when you buy a 38 Super, someone at the ATF gets an email, I bet. Like, like, these things are very rare and, uh, that they have, they have a certain consumer base.
2:41:23 Robert Evans? Now, obviously, there are normal 38 Super pistols that exist. They're just like, today, most people buy, because it's a weird moon round, too. There's not a, it's not a normal, like, it's not, there's nothing wrong with it, but it's not a round that's commonly carried. It's expensive. It's primarily something that has, like, cachet for drug dealers. But I guess also, my, my interpretation, and I guess we're, I know, maybe this is getting too much into my side of things, but I do have a theory as to why he would have picked this gun and the shotgun that he picked. But we can talk about that later if you want.
2:41:54 Speaker 15 We'll get to that in a sec, yeah.
2:41:56 Speaker 11 He also had a, I believe, two knives and four daggers.
2:42:01 Robert Evans? Yeah.
2:42:02 Speaker 11 Six bladed weapons.
2:42:03 Robert Evans? Really want to see pictures of those bladed weapons.
2:42:06 Speaker 11 They are in the court documents, buddy. Let me, uh, let me, uh, let me just find those for you.
2:42:11 Speaker 15 We have an enhanced image of some of them, too.
2:42:13 Speaker 11 Yeah, so we should talk about this. The government submitted a quote-unquote "enhanced" image in the court case. Mr. Allen took a picture of himself at about 8:03 PM, so about half an hour before he rushed past a magnetometer there. In the picture, we can see he is wearing black suit pants. He is wearing a black shirt. He has a red tie, which inexplicably is tucked into his pants. He has a shoulder holster and a large K-Bah knife in a downwards drawer configuration. He is carrying a pair of pliers and a pair of wire cutters in a holster on his left side.
2:42:56 Speaker 11 On his right side, he is carrying a small leather bag, which allegedly contained more shotgun rounds. And the 1911 is in a crusty or shoulder holster, right? None of this screams "highly trained."
2:43:10 Speaker 15 The quote unquote enhanced image was basically a zoomed in.
2:43:14 Robert Evans? Oh, yeah.
2:43:14 Speaker 15 Copy of this photo that if I were to guess, the word enhanced means that they use some kind of sharpening or AI image sharpening tool.
2:43:24 Robert Evans? Yes.
2:43:25 Speaker 11 Yes.
2:43:26 Robert Evans? None of which are real in terms of like, none of which are actually enhancing or sharpening.
2:43:31 Speaker 15 The details that you are seeing should not be allowed in to be like viewed in court.
2:43:36 Robert Evans? No.
2:43:37 Speaker 11 Yeah, yeah, yeah. The AI is guessing.
2:43:39 Robert Evans? There's not extra data in the photo.
2:43:42 Speaker 15 Right.
2:43:42 Robert Evans? The AI is uncovering like the AI is basically attempting to clean up an image, which is fine if you have like a blurry photo of you and like your wife when you got in your first apartment together that you want cleaned up.
2:43:53 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:43:53 Robert Evans? But that's not, it's not valid.
2:43:55 Speaker 15 It should not be.
2:43:56 Robert Evans? Or should not be.
2:43:57 Speaker 11 Yeah, I'm sure we'll see the defense challenge this and I'll be interested to know like what AI they used and, you know, did they, did they ask for various iterations of the enhancement or did they, you know, like?
2:44:07 Robert Evans? Yeah.
2:44:07 Speaker 11 This will be interesting. I don't think it materially inserted anything. We can see the same Samsung phone. I can see the handle of the knife in both images. I can see the handle of the handgun.
2:44:17 Speaker 15 This is more of like a principle thing.
2:44:19 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:44:19 Speaker 15 Then like, did this specifically affect the photo in this case in any way that would lead to the evidence being more useful?
2:44:27 Speaker 11 Yes, exactly. Yeah, yeah. This is a bad slippery slope. So talking of his phone, he kept it with him as he traveled across the country on a train, taking notes about the landscape as he went.
2:44:38 Speaker 15 Amtrak.
2:44:39 Speaker 11 Yeah, yeah. He, he took Amtrak and like he was enchanted by like the deserts and the, he liked Chicago. He thought the woods on the East Coast were great.
2:44:48 Speaker 15 He kept like a, like a journal where he wrote about the trip.
2:44:51 Speaker 11 Yeah, in the notes app of his phone.
2:44:52 Speaker 15 Yeah.
2:44:53 Speaker 11 And then the day of his attempted shooting, he used open sources to track the president's movements. Should we move on to, did he fire his gun?
2:45:02 Speaker 15 Yeah, that's a big, cause, cause that is a big question right now.
2:45:05 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:45:05 Speaker 15 That's one half of the question. The other half is, did he shoot a secret service agent?
2:45:10 Robert Evans? Which, right. Did he shoot anybody?
2:45:13 Speaker 15 Uh huh. The DOJ is saying he fired a gun.
2:45:16 Robert Evans? The DOJ claims that.
2:45:17 Speaker 15 But is not really affirmatively saying that he shot an agent.
2:45:23 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:45:23 Robert Evans? No, they they've said a couple of different things. They've said that an agent was struck by gunfire. They've said that it was not friendly fire, but they have not said that he was struck by the assailant shotgun, by the gunman's actual weapon. And that's partly because there's not hard evidence yet that the gunman actually fired his shotgun.
2:45:46 Speaker 11 Let me read to you what they filed in court today.
2:45:48 Robert Evans? Yeah.
2:45:49 Speaker 11 The evidence gathered and analyzed to date establishes that your client fired his Mossberg 12 gauge pump action shotgun at least one time as he ran past the magnetometers on the terrace level of the Washington Hilton on April 25, 2026. When the weapon was recovered, it had once spent cartridge case in the chamber, which has been identified as having been fired in the Mossberg shotgun. The government's preliminary ballistics video analysis showed that your client fired his shotgun in the direction of Secret Service Officer VG, which Officer VG observed. Additionally, at least one fragment was recovered from the crime scene that was physically consistent with a single buckshot pellet. That fragment was recovered from a location at the scene, consistent with your client firing his shotgun in the direction of Officer VG.
2:46:31 Speaker 11 The government is aware of no physical evidence, digital video evidence, or witness statements that are inconsistent with the theory that your client fired his shotgun in the direction of Officer VG, or that Officer VG was indeed shot once in the chest while wearing a ballistic vest. They go on then further to say the government also recovered five spent 9mm Luger cartridge cases, each of which was determined to have been fired from Officer VG's service weapon. The government also identified five separate bullet holes in the walls opposite from Officer VG, consistent with the direction that Officer VG fired his service weapon. That's like the most, yeah, that's the most detail that we've seen from them of their case, right?
2:47:14 Speaker 11 His defense had previously suggested that because of some of the public statements Attorney General Blanch had made, the government may have exculpatory evidence, either that he didn't fire his gun, or that he didn't shoot the the Secret Service agent in question.
2:47:28 Speaker 15 Which administration officials have gone on the news to say that the Secret Service agent did not shoot himself, which
2:47:35 Speaker 11 Yes.
2:47:35 Speaker 15 is not saying that another Secret Service agent did not shoot him, though.
2:47:40 Speaker 11 Yeah. Yeah, and it doesn't seem like he shot into like a plasterboard wall, it seems, right? So he didn't maybe get splashed back, which is...
2:47:50 Robert Evans? No, the only holes we've seen look like they came from pistols. And that's something the Washington Post actually did like look into.
2:47:57 Speaker 11 Okay.
2:47:58 Robert Evans? Because there's at least one, there's a couple, I think, of live stream videos that showed like holes from a bullet in the wall. But the Post talked to Rick Vasquez, a firearms consultant and former chief of the firearms technology branch at the ATF, or what was then the ATF, who said that the holes were consistent with handgun rounds. Now, that's not like firearms technology, there's a lot of woo there, but it's also pretty easy to look. I mean, sometimes it can be kind of messy because like the balls in like a double ought buck shot shell are kind of similar in size to nine millimeter, right?
2:48:31 Speaker 11 Somewhere in the 30 caliber range, right?
2:48:33 Robert Evans? But they don't tend to hit with the same kinds of patterns, right? Like it does, there does tend to be a significant difference, especially at that kind of range. The night of the shooting, or within a few hours of it, Trump posted security camera footage. And the Post got a hold of a higher resolution copy of that footage and they went through like a frame by frame analysis of it. Because as you noted, James, they claimed that Cole discharged his shotgun while he was passing through the magnometers, the magnetometers.
2:49:01 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:49:01 Robert Evans? Right? They didn't say it happened elsewhere, they said it like as he was going through that checkpoint, that you could watch him sprint through like he's fucking Naruto running his way into the
2:49:09 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:49:09 Robert Evans? correspondence dinner. And in their frame by frame analysis, the Post only found evidence of four muzzle flashes, all of them from the agent who was allegedly struck by something's weapon, right? So first, I mean, and you can hear in other footage, you can clearly hear more shots than that.
2:49:27 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:49:27 Robert Evans? Like I don't doubt that there were, that he discharged five shots, but the video only shows four. And crucially, it does not show Cole's shotgun firing. And the video follows him until he goes off screen. So maybe whoever wrote that out should have written after passing through the magnetometers, but they seem to pretty clearly be saying it was while he was in that little security area, and there's not evidence. In the footage of him firing, we don't see anything that looks like firing. Like, nobody reacts as if he has fired. Like, there's, there's just no evidence that he shot. And, you know, they're hinging a lot on the fact that there's a spent cartridge in the chamber of his 12 gauge, but number one, that's actually not an uncommon way to store
2:50:10 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:50:11 Robert Evans? that kind of 12 gauge shotgun with a spent shell in the, in the breach, because it makes it easy. If something were to happen, it makes it easier to basically get a fresh round in without needing to have a chambered round at all times, which a lot of people, most people don't like to do.
2:50:26 Speaker 11 Um, yeah, and they're not drop safe either. Like, it's a bad idea to do that.
2:50:30 Robert Evans? You don't want to do that with a shotgun.
2:50:32 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:50:32 Robert Evans? You know, is it possible that he was storing it that way? Is it possible that he loaded one, an empty round in there intentionally? Because he didn't actually, he was hoping to do a suicide by cop and he didn't intend to actually shoot anybody? Is it possible he just fucked up? It's also perfectly possible he fired later, but it's really weird that they wrote it out that way. If that's what they're alleging, because we see him when he's at the, the, the security checkpoint at the magnetometer and he doesn't fire in the footage that we have.
2:51:03 Speaker 11 Yeah. There's been a lot of press statements that are sort of talking around exactly not making the explicit statement, he fired his shotgun and he shot the officer in the chest.
2:51:17 Robert Evans? Right.
2:51:17 Speaker 11 And certainly like, I don't, I'm not sure about the distance we're talking about, like, and then thus the spread that would, would happen with the
2:51:25 Robert Evans? It would be minimal spread, even with a sawed off in a, in a narrow corridor like that.
2:51:30 Speaker 11 Yeah, I mean, you go by an inch per yard, right? Like, that's the amount that it generally spreads. And then if so, if you hit this person once, assuming this person has a chest that's 20 inches wide.
2:51:41 Robert Evans? Yeah.
2:51:41 Speaker 11 That, that doesn't line up, right?
2:51:43 Robert Evans? Yeah.
2:51:43 Speaker 11 Might be different with bug shot.
2:51:44 Speaker 15 I mean, obviously, if, if they had evidence that the secret service agent was shot by Mr. Allen.
2:51:50 Speaker 11 We'd have seen it.
2:51:51 Speaker 15 They would be running with that. The fact that they do not have evidence that, that the agent was shot by Allen is, is, is shown in the way that they're like talking about this.
2:52:00 Speaker 11 Like, he was shot.
2:52:02 Robert Evans? Yeah.
2:52:03 Speaker 11 And the guy discharged a shotgun. Separate statements.
2:52:05 Speaker 15 Exactly. Two, two separate statements.
2:52:07 Speaker 11 Yep.
2:52:08 Speaker 15 They're still affirming that the agent did not shoot himself, which does not mean that he was not shot by another agent.
2:52:14 Speaker 11 Yeah.
2:52:15 Robert Evans? Yeah, and there's a, in that Washington Post article, they talked to Acting Attorney General Todd Blanch and asked him to explain like, why, why are you guys never willing to say like, where the round that hit the officer came from, right? They asked him the question that we've been asking, and Blanch answered, "We want to get that right, we're still looking at that."
2:52:34 Speaker 15 There you go.
2:52:34 Robert Evans? Right? And that is a big change, as the Post notes, a day earlier, he told ABC that officials believed the gunman had shot the officer, so he has pulled back. Which leads me to think, maybe this guy didn't shoot at all, or maybe he fired later, maybe even totally by accident, maybe when he was falling down, he like discharged, but if so, also, you would think there'd be a photo somewhere of where he discharged the shotgun. It's surprisingly easy for bullets to get lost, right? And by that, I mean, just get so destroyed and whatnot by impact, that there's not really much of anything to find, that happens all the time. It's really rare, and I would argue impossible, to discharge a 12-gauge shotgun with any
2:53:14 Robert Evans? kind of shot shell, in a fucking hotel like this, and not have there be some sign of what you hit.
2:53:21 Speaker 15 Yeah, they make holes in things, that's what they're for.
2:53:23 Robert Evans? They make multiple holes. Unless it's a slug, but then they make a really big hole. And Cole had specifically written that he was not intending to use slugs. In his manifesto, suicide note, whatever you want to call it, he specifically stated that he was using a 12-gauge loaded with buckshot, because he wanted to reduce the chances of overpenetration and of injuring or killing someone he did not intend to hit.
2:53:45 Speaker 15 Yeah. Let's talk a little bit about his background, maybe a few other things from that manifesto. I know, Robert, you've done some digging into that.
2:53:54 Robert Evans? I did the normal thing that at least one of us does, generally all of us do in some form, ever after every kind of mass shooting, or like publicly notable terror attack, or whatever, and just found myself looking through a stranger's social media.
2:54:07 Speaker 15 Yeah.
2:54:08 Robert Evans? There's been a couple of good articles out about him now. Most of like, the first things that we knew about this guy, like, the very first fact is when his name came out, there were two different guys who kind of lived in the Torrance area, who were immediately like, there were responses under Cole Thomas Allen, or Cole Allen. And one of them was like some fucking white dude who worked at, I think it was a consulting firm or something, I don't know, it wasn't very, but he just looked like he might have been 30. And the other was Cole Thomas Allen, and it was him winning a Teacher of the Year Award at the, he worked at a company that was basically doing like college test prep tutoring, right? Yeah. So he was a teacher, some people got really angry at the description of him as a teacher because they're being like, he's trying to like badmouth public school teachers,
2:54:51 Robert Evans? he's not a public school teacher, but there are other kinds of teachers. Yeah. He was the Teacher of the Month at the Tutoring Academy that he worked at. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I had found by the time I got there, which was like 20 minutes after the name started spreading, the Facebook page of the school that he worked, or the Tutoring Academy, whatever that he worked at, which I'm not going to name, but it was hundreds of posts already being like, "Good to see this is who's teaching your kids," you know, like, "You hired a terrorist," all this kinda like. Yeah, the usual. Yeah, it's bleak, it's the normal thing that happens, you know, with anything related to this. In this case, right after that, Trump posted a picture of the detained and stripped mostly
2:55:34 Robert Evans? naked gunman that was obviously the Cole Allen who had won the Teacher of the Month, like immediately visible, like you could, it was, a positive ID was very quick. Yeah. From that point on. So, at that point, a couple other things started coming out because, you know, I had looked through from that Facebook page, I had found a couple other posts about Cole Thomas Allen, or different places where he had accounts, which made a couple other details of his background obvious. He was a mechanical engineering student in Caltech, kind of during the first Trump administration. Yep. You know, that was honestly like most of what was like immediately obvious, is that like he'd been an engineering student at Caltech, he'd worked as a teacher, and he'd been a part of, in his LinkedIn, you can see that he'd been a part of Caltech's
2:56:18 Robert Evans? Christian Fellowship, and the Nerf Club, right? Yeah. Now, Ken Klippenstein talked to one of his co-fellow peers during this period of time, who knew that while he was at Nerf Club, Cal had like, kind of led, there was like a conflict within the club over people modifying. And otherwise altering their Nerf guns to make them more resemble real weapons. As Nerf has also come out with more guns that look like real guns over the years.
2:56:43 Speaker 15 Yeah.
2:56:43 Robert Evans? And he was really against this, like he was very against the idea of like Nerf guns that were modified to look like real guns, or just like people playing with things that looked like real guns. Now, fast forward to the actual day of the shooting. His Blue Sky account got found fairly quickly alongside the LinkedIn. Obviously, that got deleted in very short order, but it was archived, thankfully, by a very nice person who realized that it was probably be useful to have actual documentation about what this guy was doing online, rather than rely on a bunch of different articles making claims. So I went through all of that, you know, as soon as it came out. He had about 500 followers, he was following about 114 people.
2:57:25 Robert Evans? He did not post often on his own, but when he did, in like the, the two different occasions I could find of him, like posting on his own in this incomplete archive of his Blue Sky. One of them was him posting in like sympathy and solidarity with Ukraine, which is something that was very consistent. He reposted a ton of different fundraisers from different Ukrainian military units.
2:57:47 Speaker 15 That was in his user bio as well, support for Ukraine.
2:57:51 Robert Evans? Yeah, he was massively supportive of Ukraine.
2:57:53 Speaker 15 Yeah.
2:57:54 Robert Evans? And very angry at the Trump administration's failure to like follow through with US obligations in that regard. And the only other post of his that was like him writing something that I saw, was him basically critiquing an article about using AI in the classroom. And like people who were advocating the use of AI in the classroom, he's very much against that.
2:58:13 Speaker 15 He was a reposter, though.
2:58:15 Robert Evans? He was a reposter, and we'll talk about like some of the things he reposted. His bio read, "Hi, I'm a random Californian guy with posts about American politics, support for Ukraine, and observations of small creatures." And then he includes a quote, "I choose my own battlefields, not through my blood, but with my heart. I stand on the battlefield to protect what I want." So that is, I like typed that quote in, and that is a quote from an anime, the same anime that is, his profile picture was also from this, like, specific anime, which is Kagura.
2:58:45 Robert Evans? I don't know how that's pronounced. I think the character that he had is PFP of was Kugura. It's this like red haired lady with these weird like ball things on either side of her hair. Like, I don't fully know how to describe this lady's hairstyle. It's kind of like vaguely Princess Leia-esque. And that appears to be who he's, his PFP photo is.
2:59:07 Speaker 15 Okay.
2:59:07 Robert Evans? The series is called Gintama. I don't know much about this. I've, I've heard people online being like, oh, he was a fan of like this anime. That means something or other, but like, I don't actually understand enough about the anime to, to give much of an analysis of that. I think it's just people being like, because of the character he likes, it makes sense that he's a guy who would do something very extreme. I don't know enough about the anime to, to say how relevant that is. But the quote kind of does sound relevant to what he actually did.
2:59:37 Speaker 15 Yeah.
2:59:37 Robert Evans? I stand on the battlefield to protect what I want.
2:59:40 Speaker 15 And you can read, you can read stuff like that in his manifesto.
2:59:42 Robert Evans? Yeah. And you can read stuff like that in his manifesto, which we'll talk about. His actual reposts are very normal lib.
2:59:47 Speaker 15 Yeah, he's a liberal.
2:59:49 Robert Evans? Hugely supportive of Ukraine. Nothing about Palestine in there. Nothing about Israel in there. A photo has since come out that appears to be legitimate of him wearing like an IDF shirt some time ago.
2:59:59 Speaker 15 Yeah.
3:00:00 Robert Evans? Um, he doesn't say anything. Again, in the limited, we don't also have, we don't have his whole blue sky in here. In the limited archive we have, I don't see anything of him, like him talking at all about Israel. So like, I don't have enough to say that like, he was strongly supportive, but he certainly, there's a real discrepancy between how he talks about Ukraine and, and him mentioning anything at all about what's happening in Gaza, right?
3:00:22 Speaker 15 Yeah. What is believed to be his Twitter account, which has also been scraped and not as well archived, but there's, there's screenshots of reposts on Twitter reposting Brianna Wu with some criticism of pro Palestine protesters or, or things that are critical of Palestine and in a nominal way supportive of Israel.
3:00:43 Robert Evans? Yeah, and it's kind of hard to tell, was he just more quiet about this online because he wanted to avoid, you know, getting dog piled? Or is this just something that as the genocide got worse and worse, he became less willing to talk about? I don't know, but it's kind of, it's just noteworthy how much, like, how absent that kind of discussion is next to how often he talks about Ukraine.
3:01:04 Speaker 15 Next to the Ukraine stuff, yeah.
3:01:05 Robert Evans? Yeah. He also reposted a bunch of very normal posts. There was one from a user, you know, if you guys remember like a week or so ago, the New York Times published an interview with Hassan Piker, the streamer, and the article was titled "The Rich Don't Play By The Rules, So Why Should I: Why Petty Theft Might Be The New Political Protest." It's where Hassan tried to introduce the term "microlooting" to the discourse, which I don't support at all. But it was like a pro shoplifting kind of, like, are you kind of getting a casual and jokey pro shoplifting argument, right? I don't want to, people are blowing this out of proportion, but it's interesting that he came down against Hassan's side on that. He was basically reposting someone who was like, "Hey, I've been a lot, I've spent a lot of time in countries where graft and grifting are like normal, and it's really bad for that to happen.
3:01:49 Robert Evans? You don't want that to happen to your country." So he's certainly not like, on the far left, like, direct action is good, I love committing crimes anarchist side of things. He is not at all that kind of guy.
3:02:02 Speaker 15 Yeah. He's a liberal. He is a Will Stancilite. He is like-
3:02:06 Robert Evans? A lot of Will Stancil reposts.
3:02:07 Speaker 15 Lot of Will Stancil posts.
3:02:09 Robert Evans? Yeah. He reposted me a couple of times. He posted me like talking about like the Pope, right? Like, because making fun of Trump for calling the Pope, uh, soft on crime. Like, not any of my like spicy takes, right?
3:02:22 Speaker 15 Um, yeah, just like viral posts on Blue Sky.
3:02:25 Robert Evans? He didn't do a lot of spicy takes. Uh, he reposted a lot of like normal viral stuff you'd expect. He was really angry about COVID-19. He hates Elon Musk. He reposted a lot of like, you know, Elon Musk wants poor African children to die, like, kind of content, talking about that after some of the more recent articles about how many people died in, as a result of like the American like aid cuts that Musk was a major part in. He was very angry about that. He reposted Bill Kristol saying abolish- Ice.
3:02:53 Speaker 15 Okay.
3:02:54 Robert Evans? And there's a couple of different posts that he shared about or from people who were criticizing the White House Correspondents Dinner. And particularly like when Jake Tapper fucking made a post about like, here's the napkins that we've got that have like, you know, freedom of the press, you know, the First Amendment stuff on it, that like, is supposed to be like, this is our protest against the president, right? Like, we've got these monogram napkins. And he made fun of that, like a lot of people did. He was generally critical of anyone who would be at the Correspondents Dinner, which was reflected in his manifesto, where he said that like, the journalists and other people at the event who are not in the administration aren't my targets. And, you know, he said he didn't want to hit them.
3:03:37 Robert Evans? But also, he was, quote, "I would still go through most everyone here to get to the targets if it were absolutely necessary on the basis that most people chose to attend a speech by a pedophile, rapist, and traitor, and are thus complicit. But I really hope it doesn't come to that." Right?
3:03:51 Speaker 15 Yeah. Another interesting bit from his manifesto is, quote, "Administration officials, not including Mr. Patel, they are targets prioritized from highest ranking to lowest."
3:04:02 Robert Evans? Yeah.
3:04:03 Speaker 15 Interesting, interesting parenthetical.
3:04:06 Robert Evans? I wonder if that's just because some people were joking after that article came out about how Cash Patel, they had to like, break down his door because he was too drunk to reach. People were joking like, maybe it's best if Cash stays in office because he's so, I wonder if that was the joke he was making?
3:04:21 Speaker 15 Unclear what he meant by that.
3:04:22 Robert Evans? But he doesn't give us any reason to believe.
3:04:24 Speaker 15 It's possible.
3:04:25 Robert Evans? And he doesn't share any jokes like that, right? So that is kind of legitimately baffling.
3:04:29 Speaker 15 No, most of the manifesto is like apologizing to people he knows.
3:04:33 Robert Evans? Yep.
3:04:34 Speaker 15 For how this will be like disruptive.
3:04:36 Robert Evans? Yeah.
3:04:36 Speaker 15 And then talking about his own like, rules of engagement.
3:04:39 Robert Evans? Yes.
3:04:39 Speaker 15 Uh, which he says, quote, "Probably in a terrible format, but I'm not military, so too bad," unquote.
3:04:45 Robert Evans? Yeah. And it's interesting because, you know, he had also shared at least one post on Bluesky that was like, kind of pro-gun control, that was like, talking about how it's bad to have a gun, basically. Like, it increases the danger that you're in, which it did for this guy.
3:04:58 Speaker 15 Yeah.
3:04:59 Robert Evans? But, uh, it is interesting in terms of the firearms he chose. Because this is clearly a guy who supports more gun control. He seems to find it distasteful certainly to like celebrate guns, right? And celebrate like military style weapons. I kind of wonder if he picked the firearms he picked because they did not look like. The pistol didn't look like a Glock or like the standard police guns that he sees people owning. And a shotgun doesn't look like an AR-15.
3:05:25 Speaker 15 Like AR-15.
3:05:26 Robert Evans? Yeah, I kind of wonder, although he says it was to minimize penetration. So maybe that's more likely.
3:05:31 Speaker 15 Other thing I want to mention is because the shotgun was purchased in August. And he does make a few references in the manifesto to.
3:05:37 Robert Evans? Yes.
3:05:37 Speaker 15 Like thinking of having done something like this for quite a while. But this was his first opportunity that he saw that seemed semi-possible.
3:05:46 Robert Evans? Yeah, and I also had the thought that, well, when he bought the shotgun, because he specifically states that he wants to use shotgun to minimize like casualties. Then the date at which he bought the shotgun might be the date at which he decided he was going to do this, right? Or it might be the point at which he started taking actions.
3:06:03 Speaker 15 Yeah.
3:06:03 Robert Evans? It would make sense that maybe that would be around when he had started planning to do this. And you know, there's so much different shit happened around August of 2025. It's kind of impossible to say this is definitely it. I did notice that August 25th, 2025 is when Trump issued his additional measures to address the crime emergency in the District of Columbia executive order.
3:06:26 Speaker 15 Yeah, the military occupation of DC.
3:06:29 Robert Evans? Yeah.
3:06:29 Speaker 15 Okay.
3:06:30 Robert Evans? So and this is when Trump is really in a bunch of, there's a bunch of different news stories around Trump trying to deploy the National Guard in US cities. And I kind of wonder if maybe that's when he, but that's purely theoretical. There was a lot of other bad stuff happening that, you know? So who's to say? He also seems to be angry about our war against Iran. Like the fact like the war of choice that Trump launched against Iran. He didn't get a post a lot about it. But there are some references in the manifesto that kind of make me feel like that that may have also been like a major thing that helped push him to make this decision.
3:07:03 Speaker 15 Yeah.
3:07:04 Robert Evans? Because he specifically stated that I'm a citizen of the United States of America. What my representatives do reflects me, and I am no longer one to permit a pedophile, rapist and traitor to coat my hands with his crimes. Right? Like, there's some reasons to believe that that probably played into it as well.
3:07:19 Speaker 15 Interestingly, he does sign the manifesto with his Blue Sky username.
3:07:25 Robert Evans? He sure does.
3:07:26 Speaker 15 Cold Force.
3:07:27 Robert Evans? Yeah, he thought that was cool.
3:07:28 Speaker 11 Yeah. Perhaps that was a name he used, I don't know, in his nerfing activities, or like, it was something that meant something to him.
3:07:36 Robert Evans? Another thing that's probably worth talking about, because Trump has made the claim several times that this guy was anti-Christian, that hatred of Christianity is what drove him.
3:07:43 Speaker 15 Yep.
3:07:43 Robert Evans? As I said before, in Caltech, he was a member of the Christian group. I'll talk about that in a second. But in his manifesto, he specifically justifies what he's doing as a Christian. There is a segment in there where he's going through, like, some objections he knows people in his life will have, and kind of rebutting them.
3:07:58 Speaker 15 Yeah.
3:07:59 Robert Evans? An objection, one is, as a Christian, you should turn the other cheek. Rebuttal, turning the other cheek is for when you yourself are oppressed. I'm not the person raped in a detention camp. I'm not the fisherman executed without trial. I'm not a school kid blown up, or a child starved, or a teenage girl abused by the many criminals in this administration. Right? So, he specifically is justifying this as a Christian.
3:08:18 Speaker 15 On Christian grounds.
3:08:19 Robert Evans? On Christian grounds. He thanks his church, which seems to have been a major part of his life. So, there's a quote from Ken Klippenstein's article about his time at Caltech. He was pretty prominent at the Caltech Christian Fellowship, pretty Christian and mellow. If I didn't see his face eating carpet, I would have never believed it. And then I found a Christianity Today piece that just came up a few hours ago, and a line from that is, Allen's father, Thomas Allen, was listed as an elder at Grace United Reformed Church and Torrance, and an evangelical congregation that describes itself as preaching a gospel that is Christ-centered, covenantal and confessional. The church's leadership page and social media pages have been pulled down. And, yeah, it's fucked up. They had to have, like, security guards, armed guards, like escort worshippers inside
3:09:02 Robert Evans? and out this weekend, just because of, like, all of the press around this.
3:09:06 Speaker 15 Yeah, I bet.
3:09:07 Robert Evans? Elizabeth Terlinden, who also knew him at the time, told the New York Times, he was definitely a strong believer in evangelical Christianity at the time that I I knew him. She was in the Caltech Christian Fellowship with him. So this guy appears to have been like a very strong evangelical Christian, like a liberal Christian. Yeah. We don't exactly know, was he always, was his Christianity always like progressive and like liberal tended? Or was he kind of, you know, more conservative at a different point in his life? Yeah. We do know that within the last couple of years, he got involved in left wing activism in Los Angeles. His sister told law enforcement that after he got more involved in left wing activism, particularly a group who called themselves the White Awakes, which was referencing an anti-slavery protest in the 1860s. Oh, yeah.
3:09:51 Robert Evans? Right? Like, these were some of the people who, like, backed Lincoln. So he joined some group, an L K S called the White Awakes for some period of time. He starts talking more radically, starts showing up to more protests. And I think he's helping with a couple of different kinds of things with a couple of different groups. But that's when his sister says he starts making like a lot more radical statements and maybe sometimes aggressive statements. And that lines up with when he buys a gun and he starts training after 2023. So this may have just been a thing where he, he didn't have a full plan at that point, but he accepted the possibility that he might need to do violence in order to support, you know, his, his ideals. We don't really know, but that's, that's all we've got in terms of a journey. Yeah.
3:10:32 Speaker 15 In October of 2024, he did make one donation to the Kamala Harris campaign via ActBlue.
3:10:38 Robert Evans? $25. Yeah. But not a lot of, not a long history of donations to the party, not a long history of like volunteering for the Democratic Party specifically. Seems to have been a pretty loyal voter. Yeah. But this is a guy who, I think really during like the, it would be during the Biden years, gets more involved in like left wing protests and organizing. He becomes angrier and then after 2024, he gets really, really angry at Trump. And eventually, probably sometime late last year, decides to take action. And for whatever reason, picks the Correspondence Dinner to do it. It's probably also worth noting that he sends this manifesto thing out right before he carries out the attack. Like, he's staying in the hotel for a couple of days before all this happens.
3:11:21 Speaker 15 He bugs two nights.
3:11:23 Robert Evans? We actually get him to reflect. A little on the security that he's experienced while he's been there. And that's a really interesting part of this. He says, I expected security cameras at every bend, bugged hotel rooms, armed agents every 10 feet, metal detectors out the wazoo. What I got, who knows, maybe they're pranking me, is nothing, no damn security, not in transport, not in the hotel, not in the event. Like, the one thing that I immediately noticed walking into the hotel is the sense of arrogance. I walk in with multiple weapons and not a single person there considers the possibility that I could be a threat. Crazy stuff.
3:11:52 Speaker 15 Most of the security seemed to be isolated around the actual
3:11:55 Robert Evans? Yep.
3:11:56 Speaker 15 ballroom and the levels immediately above and below.
3:11:58 Robert Evans? And again, he doesn't get anywhere close to the president or any other like important person, right? So you could argue the security did its job. He was just in the same hotel. But yeah, crazy stuff. I don't know. I don't have anything else.
3:12:13 Speaker 15 Yeah. Let's go on ad break and then return to briefly discuss some of the conspiracy theories that have spawned after this alleged shooting.
3:12:24 Robert Evans? Love it.
3:12:35 Speaker 15 Okay, we are back. Immediately after the event took place, tons of conspiracy theories started cropping up, obviously piggybacking off of the Butler, Pennsylvania ones. This was not helped by the confusion in early reports because once you get every journalist in DC in one room and then an event happens, that means every journalist has a kind of different version of the event. That gets immediately blasted out online and on the news. So there was not, not a clear sequence of events in the immediate aftermath of the shooting. There was reports that maybe it was just dishes being dropped. Eventually it was clear that no, there was an actual shooting and Wolf Blitzer did lose a shoe in the course of the events.
3:13:18 Robert Evans? He sure did. Poor Wolf.
3:13:20 Speaker 15 Now, also not helping things, Trump was basically live-truthing this investigation on the night of the shooting.
3:13:27 Robert Evans? Uh huh.
3:13:28 Speaker 15 And it was not clear to many people that the shooting did not happen on the ballroom level.
3:13:33 Robert Evans? Yeah.
3:13:33 Speaker 15 And that the shooter did not get close to the targets.
3:13:36 Robert Evans? Well, also, the people, people in the main room were still very scared because like, they had no real context on what was happening and everyone around them just started freaking out.
3:13:47 Speaker 11 Yeah.
3:13:48 Speaker 15 Because there's the military running around, Secret Service running around, they heard gunshots. Yeah, it is a frightening thing. You're seeing J.D. Vance get pulled offstage, Trump stucking down.
3:13:55 Robert Evans? What I do feel is kind of interesting about this is you've got this whole DC class of like press and other important people who are not in power themselves but are close to it. And they're, they do a lot of the things that they do because they like being close to power. And there's this illusion that comes with that, I think, for a lot of these people of importance that gets ripped away when the Secret Service pulls all of the people who are important out of the room and you're just left wondering if you're in danger. Like, that's what it'll be like if there's a nuclear war. All of these people will suddenly have the few folks who have a detail get ripped out of the room and then you'll just hear the sirens start and have no idea what's happening and realize that your whole life in pursuit of being close to power has brought you no security.
3:14:39 Robert Evans? Crazy stuff, wild times. Anyway, Garrison?
3:14:42 Speaker 15 One of the core pieces of quote unquote evidence that was used to assert that the shooting was some kind of false flag or psy-op was a comment made by Press Secretary Carolyn Levitt shortly before the dinner.
3:14:55 Speaker 12 This speech tonight will be classic Donald J. Trump. It'll be funny, it'll be entertaining, there will be some shots fired tonight in the room.
3:15:05 Robert Evans? Great stuff.
3:15:06 Speaker 15 Poor choice of words there on behalf of the press secretary.
3:15:10 Speaker 11 Excellent choice of words. Yeah. Also, though, like, it's not a Dan Brown novel. When people are actually plotting conspiracy, they don't go around leaving little, little Easter eggs for you to find.
3:15:20 Speaker 15 Of course. Yeah, why else would there, why else would the deep state orchestrate like a top, a top level secret, secret psy-op and not, and not decide to leave little clues beforehand?
3:15:32 Robert Evans? Yeah. They got, they have to leave little clues, Garrison. Have you listened to Alex Jones? That's part of the deal they make with the demons is that they have to, they have to leave little clues for the evil that they're doing while they're doing it.
3:15:45 Speaker 15 They call that the Riddler's Law.
3:15:46 Robert Evans? Uh huh, that's right.
3:15:49 Speaker 15 Now, another thing that got amplified in the conspiratorial milieu was a Twitter account with a Pepe profile picture, wearing the same outfit as President Trump, the night of the dinner, who tweeted the alleged shooter's name about two and a half years ago. This post is the account's only visible post. The banner image of the account is a bunch of streaks of color, but if you overlay the image of Trump holding his fist up in the air at Butler, the color streaks and the darkened areas line up with the Trump-Butler photo. What? Now, the alleged shooter also had an undergraduate research fellowship at NASA for the summer of 2014, and the name of this Twitter account matches the name of someone
3:16:33 Speaker 15 at Lockheed Martin who published a NASA paper at the same time that the shooter was at NASA. And the shooter worked for the Jet Propulsion Lab, the same labs that those scientists who have gone missing also have been working out of. Yeah, Garrison, do you want to get out the pen board? When I saw this, I started to feel a little bit scared because I thought I was getting too close. Too close to the truth. I don't know. I was afraid. Too close to needing help. But that's not all, because the Pepe Twitter account was also connected to a time travel study, because the color streak banner photo was traced to a website on how
3:17:15 Speaker 15 to build a time machine, and this photo was used on the webpage for the time machine study. So, what's really going on here? First of all, this quote-unquote "time machine" website is actually a Europe-based project for, quote, "3D digitalization of cultural heritage," scanning artifacts and uploading them online as 3D models. Yeah. That's their quote-unquote "time machine," is preserving cultural heritage. Yeah, it's an archive. And actually, this color streak image has actually been floating around the internet for a long time. I've found versions of it since at least 2018. There are hundreds of people named Cole Allen in the US on data broker sites, right?
3:17:58 Speaker 15 Now, the first archive of this Pepe Twitter account, whose profile picture only matches Trump's because it's a tuxedo, one of the most common outfits for men at events like this.
3:18:10 Robert Evans? Yeah, yes, it is the same outfit that Trump was wearing at the dinner. It's also the same outfit Trump has worn at every dinner because it's what you wear at dinners if you're the president, a tuxedo.
3:18:20 Speaker 15 But the first archive of this post is from after the shooting. So we don't know what this account looked like prior to the shooting. Now, this account could have tweeted tons of random names and then deleted all the other posts to pull a stunt like this. Or people at Twitter, like, you know, X, the everything app, the people who work there, could have backdated the account and the post to boost engagement on the platform. Now, those aren't any more likely than just a simple coincidence, but there are other explanations other than gesturing vaguely towards a pre-planned psy-op. Now, spreading images of this Twitter account isn't necessarily putting forward a specific conspiracy theory.
3:19:02 Speaker 15 It just gets used as a data point, among other unconnected data points, to sow public mistrust and undermine reality, inferring meaning from odd coincidences, right? This is seeing patterns that aren't there, and literally, in the case of seeing the butler photo in a splash of colors. And again, like, why would, quote unquote, "they" drop hints beforehand, right? Is this predictive programming? But predictive programming isn't really necessary to get the public to accept an event like an attempted assassination. In fact, that would only sow suspicion. Dropping these little hints just to sow suspicion for an event like this, it doesn't actually make it more acceptable, right? The whole idea of predictive programming is sowing seeds
3:19:45 Speaker 15 to get the public to accept an otherwise unacceptable thing. And that's not necessary for a presidential assassination. Now, there are some other things that propped up in this conspiratorial shenanigans in the wake of the shooting. A Fox News reporter was calling in to report her experience at the dinner and suddenly cut out when she started talking about something that Carolyn Levitt's husband said to her.
3:20:12 Speaker 19 He kind of leaned over and said, you know, I watched you on TV. You did a great job. You need to be very safe. And he was very serious when he said that to me. And he kind of looked around the room and he said, you know, there are some.
3:20:31 Speaker 11 Sounds like we lost Aisha's phone there.
3:20:34 Speaker 15 Well, well, well.
3:20:36 Speaker 11 What?
3:20:38 Speaker 15 So her audio actually cuts out at different points during this televised call. The anchor said that she was having cell service issues and later on X, this reporter posted that she was about to say that Carolyn Levitt's husband was, quote, "telling me to be careful with my own safety because the world is crazy," unquote. But it does make for a funny moment, a funny moment of television.
3:21:02 Robert Evans? That's a good moment. That's an incredible time for your call to cut out. Like, just awesome stuff.
3:21:07 Speaker 15 Yeah. There's other, other viral posts, spreading video of the military storming past the red carpet, or people in military fatigues storming past the red carpet after the shooting, with one person writing, quote, "Law enforcement doesn't act like this. Neither does the military. This is a staged event with a shitty script and pre-positioned cameras," unquote. The cameras are there because they're there to film the red carpet. They're pre-positioned.
3:21:36 Speaker 11 Yeah, because this is an organization where all the press gathers.
3:21:39 Speaker 15 Because this is a press event. That's why there's pre-positioned cameras.
3:21:43 Robert Evans? Yeah, it's, it's how you do, you know, the White House Correspondents' Dinner.
3:21:47 Speaker 11 Yeah. Also, you're going to see some types of cocks that you have never previously seen when someone tries to assassinate the president. There are a whole lot of people whose job it is to stop that happening. Lots of them aren't necessarily uniformed officers who you see every day in the Secret Service.
3:22:02 Robert Evans? Yeah.
3:22:03 Speaker 15 Other people also thought it was odd that, you know, Trump has skipped every correspondent dinner across his two terms, except for this one. And then all of a sudden, there's a shooter in the lobby. How did the shooter know that Trump would go to this one? Because the shooter planned, planned this since early April. How would the shooter know this? Well, it's actually quite simple. Because Trump announced he was attending this dinner in early March. And according to court documents, Cole Allen started searching for information about this dinner in early April, a month later, before then booking two nights at the Washington Hilton. Trump already announced that he was going to be attending the dinner. The oddest aspect of the conspiracy some post, post this event is that
3:22:49 Speaker 15 Trump needed to stage this not for any national security reasons or to seize more power, but to construct the White House ballroom, which has been the main thing that people on the right have been talking about after the shooting. The people on the right have not been using this shooting to like go after liberal terrorists, but have been talking nonstop about how this security breach demonstrates the need to construct Trump's massive ballroom. And that's the main thing they're talking about.
3:23:17 Robert Evans? It's so funny.
3:23:19 Speaker 15 The idea that they would stage, that the deep state is going to stage a false flag just to push for the ballroom.
3:23:25 Robert Evans? Yeah.
3:23:27 Speaker 15 Is, to me, frankly, very funny.
3:23:29 Robert Evans? Yeah, we don't get an enabling act in our new fascists. We just get a fucking ballroom.
3:23:33 Speaker 15 Yeah, yeah, right.
3:23:35 Robert Evans? Okay. I mean, I guess I prefer this.
3:23:38 Speaker 15 Yeah, the Reichs take fire to construct a nice, a nice dance floor.
3:23:44 Speaker 11 Yeah, yeah, just, yeah, I mean, a lot of this was like centered on the safety and security exemption, which was provided in the injunction against the building of the new ballroom, right? The issue here is that the Trump administration already filed on the 3rd of April, a claim that the entire building was a contiguous whole. They couldn't do the security part without doing the fancy dance floor part, right? And like, Trump has also trussed about this previous to this event. This, this wouldn't have really added anything.
3:24:17 Speaker 15 Yeah.
3:24:17 Speaker 11 They did try and get the National Trust for Historical Preservation to withdraw their court case, which they didn't, like, subsequently to this.
3:24:27 Speaker 11 The events of the White House Correspondents' Dinner.
3:24:29 Speaker 15 So yeah, that's most of what I have on the conspiracy stuff. There's certainly more, but that's.
3:24:34 Speaker 11 Oh, there's more. Yeah, we're gonna leave it there.
3:24:37 Speaker 15 There's always gonna be more, right? Like, that's the way how it is. We don't have good data on like the widespread belief of this theory. There was a poll that circulated that said like, something like forty seven percent of Democrats thought the attempted assassination was staged. But this poll, which is from the Manhattan Institute, so take that with a grain of fascism. This poll is actually polling the Butler shooting, not this recent one. And people did not acknowledge that when they were spreading this poll around. So we don't know how many people actually believe that this shooting was staged. But you can certainly see a lot of people asserting as such on the internet.
3:25:20 Speaker 11 Mm hmm. Shall we move on to a couple of other topics that we need to cover?
3:25:26 Speaker 15 Yes, this will be a super, super sized episode, but it is what it is.
3:25:31 Speaker 11 Yeah, let's go. Talking to people, talking about things on the internet, I think some people got this one. They're a little carried away. A three zero decision of a panel of Second Circuit Court judges has rejected ICE's mandatory detention of people seeking to deport, with a few exceptions. The opinion was written by Judge Bianco, who is a Trump appointee, and stated that, quote, "Petitioner entered the United States unlawfully in 2004 or 2005 and has resided here ever since. He is therefore deemed to be an applicant for admission by Section 1225A, but he is not, quote, "seeking admission because he is not requesting lawful entry into the United States
3:26:13 Speaker 11 after inspection and authorization. The government's attempt to muddy these textually clear waters defies the statute's context, structure, history, and purpose, contradicts a Supreme Court's dicta in Jennings and longstanding executive branch practice, and its interpretation of the statute raises serious constitutional questions that should be avoided even if the statutory language were ambiguous. The statute in question here is the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, and specifically the fact that it has a mandatory detainer for people, quote unquote, "seeking admission to the USA." Now, this ruling puts the Second Circuit in agreement with over 370 judges across the
3:26:58 Speaker 11 nation, but notably at odds with the Fifth and Eighth Circuit, right? Judge Bianco, in a really incredibly New York analogy here for seeking admission, wrote, "If someone sneaks into Yankee Stadium at the start of the game with no ticket for admission and no intention of ever paying, and he is later found by security in a seat in the seventh inning, no one would consider that to be seeking admission to the game." So hopefully that explains to people that the argument that the government is making here is that someone who has been in the country for a long period of time is still seeking admission, right? The Trump administration's placed itself at odds with other administrations, right? This has been law since 1996.
3:27:41 Speaker 11 As Bianco wrote, "For five presidential administrations over nearly three decades, it did consistently release detainees on bond whom the government now argues are covered by Section 1225b2a. Even in President Trump's first term and the first few months of his second, the agency adhered to the decades-old understanding and the relative scopes of Sections 1225 and 1226. Under these circumstances, the fact that no president has ever found such power in the statute is strong evidence that it does not exist." That pretty much explains itself, right? What I have not been able to work out is whether this pertains to people who are detained, as in who are arrested in the Second Circuit, or people who are held in the Second Circuit, or both.
3:28:25 Speaker 11 My guess would be both, because it is the law in the Second Circuit, right? So it applies in the Second Circuit. Certainly, most detention facilities are not in the Second Circuit. A lot of them are in the Fifth, which has come down the opposite way on this. This is why the Supreme Court exists, right? Big disagreement between these several Circuit Courts here. Moving on, let's talk about the border wall. Before leaving office, Secretary Noh messaged several waivers for border wall construction. This was not in the week before she left office, but in this year. One of them waived 28 laws in the Big Bend area of Texas. The waiver included 175 miles of the riverfront of the Rio Grande,
3:29:07 Speaker 11 including parts of the state park, national park and federally protected river. These, some of these areas are very popular for outdoor recreation. These waivers are now being challenged in court by the Center for Biological Diversity. They're out of Tucson. You'll see them in a lot of border legal cases. The Friends of Ruidosa Church and a Tlinga River Guide named Billy Miller. It's an interesting coalition, right, that we don't often see like, like a church group has the sort of approach to this, that it would destroy historical and cultural heritage to build the wall there. Obviously, the River Guide, Billy Miller, Mr. Miller, has the claim that it would be disruptive to a business and, and to people's enjoyment of nature on the river.
3:29:51 Speaker 11 Currently, what they are doing is focusing on Chispa Road. That's, it's near like Valentine, Texas, northwest of Marfa, where they're carrying out road improvements that they did not notify county officials about, which is obviously cause of disruption. I've actually ridden my bike out there a fair bit. Did some work making a film out there a few years ago. It's a really beautiful part of the country. I'm sure a lot of people will be familiar with Marfa, which is nearby.
3:30:15 Robert Evans? Oh, it's a great city.
3:30:16 Speaker 11 Yeah, Marfa's great. Like, I love that area of Texas.
3:30:19 Robert Evans? Yeah, I, I watched it all burn down one beautiful, beautiful afternoon when those horrible fires started. Yeah, it was wild.
3:30:26 Speaker 11 Yeah, I bet. Geez. Luckily, Marfa has, has recovered. Great place to visit. You can go and see the Prada store, which people now think is AI-generated, which is great. Our reality is cool.
3:30:41 Robert Evans? You can go see the Judd Foundations, or the Chinati Foundation, the Donald Judd Museum, you know? A lot of, a lot of good stuff out in Marfa. Pretty good cheese sandwich restaurant.
3:30:51 Speaker 11 Mm-hmm. Pretty, pretty fancy glamping setup there as well. Yep. So I checked out the CBP Smart Wall Interactive Map, which sometimes like they, they don't always have to give notice when they're changing their plans. So sometimes you find out via the Smart Wall Interactive Map. And right now it shows vehicle barriers and patrol road planned inside the national park, right? So this will cause damage far, far beyond the riverfront. Evidently, to build barriers at the riverfront, they have to build roads to get to the riverfront, which will also spread this damage over an area that like, especially in Texas. Texas is not a state which is abundant with public land. No. It is not like those states further west in that regard.
3:31:35 Speaker 11 And I know this is an area which is very special to a great deal of people. I'm really interested in writing more about this. So like especially people in the outdoor industry or folks in that region, I'd love to hear from you. You can do cool zone tips at proton.me if you want to talk about that. Do you want to do the? We reported, we reported the news. All of it. Yeah. Again, calls and tips at proton.me for story tips. For your marketing emails, you can just go ahead and flush those. We reported the news.
3:32:12 Robert Evans? Hey, we'll be back Monday with more episodes every week from now until the heat death of the universe.
3:32:17 Speaker 08 It Could Happen Here is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can now find sources for It Could Happen Here listed directly in episode descriptions. Thanks for listening.
3:32:37 Speaker 00 Cash flow crunch? OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds, up to $200,000, right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
3:33:07 Speaker 07 This January, bare knuckle fighting championship takes over the ocean. The inaugural Brew's Crew sails from Miami to the Bahamas aboard the Norwegian Jewel. Three straight days with pool deck bare knuckle fights in the Caribbean. Mess of parties, beach events, DJs, cigars, tequila tastings and nonstop action. The lineup reveals coming soon. are disappearing fast and the prices won't stay this low. Reserve your spot with just $200 down at B K F S E A dot com.
3:33:37 Speaker 20 This is Danielle Robé from Question Everything. Okay, here's the thing. Life doesn't exactly slow down and neither do I. Between work and travel and podcasting and everything else on my calendar, I need clothes that can keep up. That's why I'm all about cotton. It's natural, breathable, soft, and doesn't shed microplastics when washed. Plant, not plastic. So whether it's a perfectly worn in T-shirt, elevated loungewear, or the cozy cotton PJs that you'd prefer to wear all day long, cotton always delivers. It's comfortable, makes getting dressed easy, and then it somehow always looks good. Cotton, the fabric of our lives.
3:34:12 Speaker 00 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
Previous Part Two: The Naturopathic Doctor Who Bombed a Plane Next Part One: How AI Chatbots Became Cult Leaders Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated