Pod Insights Bankless ROLLUP: Silvergate Trouble | MetaMask & Unity | Robinhood Mobile Wallet | ETHDenver 2023 | Bankless Ventures About this episode Bankless Weekly Rollup
2nd Week of March 2023
------
📣 RhinoFi | Makes DeFi Frictionless
https://bankless.cc/rhino
------
🚀 JOIN BANKLESS PREMIUM:
https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/subscribe
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE
https://bankless.cc/kraken
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE
https://bankless.cc/metamaskpod
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM
https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🚁 EARNIFI | CLAIM YOUR UNCLAIMED AIRDROPS
https://bankless.cc/earnifi
👻 PHANTOM | CROSS-CHAIN WALLET
https://bankless.cc/phantom
------
Topics Covered
0:00 Intro
7:10 Markets
8:20 Total Crypto Market Cap
9:30 Ethereum
https://twitter.com/tomuky/status/1630417197125255169
10:55 NFT Royalty Truth
https://twitter.com/hildobby_/status/1630231567061733376
14:42 Crypto vs Gary
https://twitter.com/AlexanderGrieve/status/1629816811360337920
15:55 Unregistered Securities
https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ/status/1631106283163074560
19:00 Jake Chervinsky’s Take
https://twitter.com/jchervinsky/status/1629871537217044481
19:50 Logan Bolinger’s Take
https://twitter.com/TheWhyOfFI/status/1629649343627116545
20:55 Emojis are Financial Advice
https://twitter.com/LisaBraganca/status/1628868429540126720
23:41 Robinhood Received Crypto-Related Subpoena Request From SEC
https://www.coindesk.com/business/2023/02/27/robinhood-received-crypto-related-subpoena-request-from-sec-10k/
25:00 1st-Ever Hearing on Regulatory ‘Attack’ on Crypto
https://www.dlnews.com/articles/regulation/new-congress-body-to-hold-first-ever-hearing-on-regulatory-attack-on-crypto/
27:40 Brian Armstrong CNBC Op-Ed
https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1630997178683457536
29:45 Silvergate Distressed
https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2023/03/02/silvergate-stock-tumbles-45-after-going-concern-filing/
https://www.reuters.com/technology/silvergate-slumps-28-after-delaying-annual-report-warning-about-viability-2023-03-02/
https://twitter.com/nlw/status/1631281983836901376
32:24 MetaMask in Unity Store!
https://metaversal.banklesshq.com/p/game-on-metamask-x-unity
https://program-ace.com/blog/unity-vs-unreal/
https://assetstore.unity.com/decentralization
37:50 Robinhood Wallet
https://techcrunch.com/2023/03/01/robinhoods-wallet-app-is-now-available-to-all-ios-users/
https://twitter.com/0xproject/status/1630916008381927424
40:40 Scroll Deploys on Goerli
https://twitter.com/scroll_zkp/status/1630258973856395264
42:00 ERC4337 Deployed to Ethereum on Smart Contract
https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2023/03/01/ethereum-activates-account-abstraction-touted-by-founder-buterin-as-key-advance/
45:30 New Yuga Labs' Collection will be on Bitcoin
https://www.coindesk.com/web3/2023/02/27/yuga-labs-announces-generative-ordinals-nft-collection-on-bitcoin-blockchain/
46:46 Jump Crypto and Oasis.app ‘Counter Exploits’ Wormhole Hacker
https://www.coindesk.com/business/2023/02/24/oasis-exploits-its-own-wallet-software-to-seize-cry pto-stolen-in-wormhole-hack/
51:35 Coinbase Scheduled Downtime
https://status.coinbase.com/
Solana Unscheduled Downtime
https://decrypt.co/122284/solana-weekend-outage
54:38 FTX Ex-Engineering Pleads Guilty to Criminal Charges
https://www.cnbc.com/2023/02/28/ftx-ex-engineering-head-nishad-singh-pleads-guilty-to-criminal-charges.html
56:50 Bankless Ventures
Bankless Podcast Raising $35M Crypto Venture Fund
https://www.coindesk.com/business/2023/03/02/hosts-of-bankless-podcast-raising-35m-crypto-venture-fund-sources
Disclosures
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16XcKXcH5e4CDc-Qek4WN4FUBPpnViAhLGgvtXat7NBg/edit#gid=0
1:00:13 Jobs
https://pallet.xyz/list/bankless/jobs
1:02:36 Questions from the Nation
1:10:16 2016 Etherum on Coinbase, 2023 Coinbase on Ethereum
https://twitter.com/anajolsson/status/1629101335001067521
1:11:40 The Secret to Success in Any Bear Market
https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1631316358712508418
1:15:35 What David’s Bullish On
https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ/status/1631119466284343296
1:18:50 What Ryan’s Bullish On
1:21:02 MEME of the Week
https://twitter.com/MatterTurbulent/status/1631150786154463233
1:22:50 Risks & Disclaimers
----
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
Transcript 16,193 words · 3 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Ryan Sean Adams? Hosts of Bankless Podcast, raising $35 million crypto venture fund. Hey, that's us, I think. What's this about?
0:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, so Ryan, you and I and our friend Ben Lakoff are starting Bankless Ventures.
0:14 Ryan Sean Adams? Bankless Nation, it is the first Friday of March. David, what time is it?
0:19 Speaker 01 Oh, Ryan, it's the ETH Denver version of the Bankless Friday Weekly Rollup, where we cover the entirely weekly news in crypto. And so much of that news is happening at ETH Denver. So much of the announcements that we're going to talk about are being announced at ETH Denver. So if you don't have coffee, grab it because you're going to need it to get through this weekly rollup. I definitely am.
0:37 Ryan Sean Adams? Okay, so you're in Denver right now. I am not, but the conference, per usual, as is tradition, the conference hasn't officially started though, yet, has it?
0:47 Speaker 01 So it's different this year. The previous years at ETH Denver has been held in this venue called the Sports Castle, but we outgrew the Sports Castle by a wide margin last year. So we had to go to the Ethereum, excuse me, the Denver Convention Center. So the official canonical ETH Denver event does start today, but so much has already happened already. There are so many side events. There was this interoperability conference that was Monday and Tuesday. There was WalletCon yesterday. So to say that ETH Denver hasn't started yet is missing like the forest for the trees, because so much of other events have already happened and have been ongoing all week. So ETH Denver Week has definitely been a very big thing. Plus, the Hackathon has already been going on. So the canonical ETH Denver
1:30 Speaker 01 event starts today, but so much is already underway as well.
1:34 Ryan Sean Adams? That's because when people talk about ETH Denver, it's really a shelling point for getting a whole bunch of crypto people together.
1:39 Speaker 01 It is now, yeah.
1:40 Ryan Sean Adams? What's the vibe? Like, on the ground, what's the vibe? How are people? And by the way, by the way, we're recording this Thursday morning, but this goes out Friday. So the official ETH Denver event will have started by the time you guys are listening to this. But yeah, what are the vibes? Like, what's kind of, how are people feeling?
1:55 Speaker 01 So the It's very much more diverse in in subject matter. Last year, ETH Denver, I think there was like 13,000 to 14,000 people that came and the venue only held 7,000. So that was an issue.
2:07 Ryan Sean Adams? And last year was in February when the market was like just riding all time highs.
2:12 Speaker 01 It was very, very close to highs. Yes.
2:14 Ryan Sean Adams? Okay.
2:14 Speaker 01 I haven't, we haven't gotten official headcounts yet because it's really hard to get an official headcount because there is no official head counter. But people have been giving me estimates of 15,000 to 20,000 people.
2:24 Ryan Sean Adams? Are you serious?
2:25 Speaker 01 Dude, I was at, what was it? The ZK Day? And it was, it was all about zero knowledge. The room was absolutely packed. The ZK Day, the one day event about all about zero knowledge was more than ETH Denver 2020 as a whole.
2:40 Ryan Sean Adams? This is a bear market.
2:41 Speaker 01 If you told me back in 2019 that there would be a single one day conference specifically about zero knowledge stuff happening in 2023, I'd be like, well, I mean, I guess I would, why, why I'm here in this industry? I expect that to grow, but like, it's crazy, man. Yeah. So like, it's so large that people are subdividing into different streams, different talks, different tracks. The energy is very, very large and it's hard to keep track of everything. It is literally impossible to go to everything. You cannot, you have to pick and choose what you want to do.
3:10 Ryan Sean Adams? Guys, as far as content goes, I know David is going to bring us back a ton of content. We've got a bankless, full bankless media team on the ground at ETH Denver. And we're calling this like a virtual conference pass, which is basically what we're providing. And I think, I like to think, David, you're doing this partially, you know, in service to people like me who don't go to these events. And you go and you record, you get some of the highlights, you talk about the takeaways and we publish all of this on the Bankless newsletter. And of course, on our YouTube channel and for premium subscribers, we package this all up into some RSS episodes that you can capture as well. So I bet you're coming home with a lot of content.
3:48 Speaker 01 That's exactly right. I go to the content, Ryan, so you don't have to. At the Interoperability Summit, I recorded, I think, eight interviews with Sriram from Eigenlayer, with Sunny from Cosmos, people from the Axelar Layer One, which has piqued my interest in. Interestingly, so many different people in specifically outside of the EVM Ethereum ecosystem, the rest of the non Ethereum world, all about the interoperability summit. Also Ledger from Up Only, he was there as well. So I got to meet him for the first time. And so that was eight interviews at that event. Luke and the rest of the Bankless Media team and I are gonna go to the actual canonical Ether event today and tomorrow, and probably do that again. So Ryan, I might have like 16 interviews for you.
4:32 Ryan Sean Adams? Rest that voice, rest that voice.
4:34 Speaker 01 Do you hear it?
4:35 Ryan Sean Adams? A little bit, and I'm worried about you. Like, so I've been told that what you have to do in these, look at me, armchair quarterback, I don't even go to these things, but what you have to do is like you speak with a lower, like a lower voice. So it comes more from your throat and that tends to, yeah. So, yeah, exactly. It's totally normal. It's totally normal, David, in person. He sounds like an octave deeper too. Anyway, we got a lot of things to cover too, and we got a short amount of time to do it. So topics of the week, Gary coming out swinging against crypto, Gary Gensler, of course, he thinks everything is a security, but not everyone in the rest of government agrees with him. Neither do we. What else we got, David?
5:13 Speaker 01 Things not looking great at Silvergate, the main bank of crypto, looking pretty distressed. So we have to talk about that. And then the big news, which got announced yesterday, Metamask, everyone's favorite wallet, has released an SDK to go with the Unity game engine, planting a very firm flag that gaming is going to be the next big wave of adoption, servicing 2.7 billion people. Robinhood released a mobile wallet, and I was actually able to try that out. So we got the details as well. But then there's already so many other announcements as well. DevCon gets announced in 2024. Account abstraction is live on the Ethereum Layer 1, but I thought you needed a hard fork for that. We'll talk about that. Yuga Labs is doing ordinals. There's a lot to talk about.
5:56 Speaker 01 And Ryan, I have to go in literally under 90 minutes because I have a talk at Shelling Point. So we are going to race through this weekly roll up.
6:03 Ryan Sean Adams? All right, let's burn through it. And before we do, we want to tell you about our friends and sponsors at RhinoFi. Respect the Rhino is what I say. This is a really cool interface on top of DeFi. There's all sorts of what David and I call money verbs that you can do here. You can trade, you can swap, you can invest pools. Tell us a little bit about RhinoFi, David.
6:22 Speaker 01 RhinoFi is a multi-chain aggregator. So all of your different layer two opportunities are being put into the same interface. So whether you want to trade, whether you want to stay or pool or invest or access some vaults or whatnot, you can do this all on app.rino.fi. This is built on StarkX technology. And so if you want to just have all of your cool DeFi layer two stuff all in one place, check it out. There's a link in the show notes again, app.rino.fi.
6:52 Ryan Sean Adams? Guys, now is the time to go explore things while we're in the bear market and the build market, of course. So go check this out.
6:58 Speaker 01 This is just like banking interface 2.0. Like, go like, go look at your dumb old Wells Fargo.
7:04 Ryan Sean Adams? You want me to?
7:04 Speaker 01 And then go look at this and tell me which one looks more fun.
7:07 Ryan Sean Adams? This looks way more fun. I hate my banking user interface. It hasn't changed in the past like 15 years. All right, let's get to markets.
7:15 Speaker 01 Speaking of new, cool interfaces, again, all crypto interfaces are way better than all previous financial interfaces. What we're looking at, of course, is the Kraken charts, where we're going to look at the Bitcoin price, starting the week at $23,300, exactly flat on the week.
7:30 Ryan Sean Adams? Are you serious?
7:31 Speaker 01 0% up, 0% down.
7:32 Ryan Sean Adams? Exactly flat?
7:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly flat.
7:33 Ryan Sean Adams? Are you just doing that because you didn't want to look up the numbers, David? You're just, ah, it's flat.
7:37 Speaker 01 No, it's literally flat, Ryan.
7:39 Ryan Sean Adams? That's hilarious, man. Okay, how about ETH? Flat too?
7:42 Speaker 01 Flat-ish, starting the week at 1,600, ending the week at 1,625, up 1.5% on the week. I call 1.5% pretty flat. That's nice.
7:51 Ryan Sean Adams? That's a bull run for ants. We're just going, who cares about this? How about the ratio?
7:57 Speaker 01 Ratio? Well, I think you can do the math on that one. Even I can. We are up 1.5% at .0697.
8:04 Ryan Sean Adams? Well, thanks for making it clear. And thanks to Kraken for these fantastic charts that you can find at pro.kraken.com. Because I'm a pro. I'm a trading pro, David. I don't know about you, but these charts make me feel like it.
8:15 Speaker 01 When I think Ryan Sean Adams, I think trading pro.
8:18 Ryan Sean Adams? I know you do. That's a meme that's, you know, real life too. Okay. Global crypto market cap. Are we above a trillion?
8:25 Speaker 01 Above a trillion, $1.11 trillion in total crypto market cap. Down 2% in the last week or so.
8:32 Ryan Sean Adams? You know, uh, let's talk about a few stats going on in the crypto markets. I, I kind of skipped the, the Fed this week, David, because like, nothing's really going on in macro. At least this, this is what I feel like the state of macro is. There's a lot of doom and gloom types of, of things, like a lot of doomers out there and
8:50 Speaker 01 Doomism is in right now.
8:52 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, there are a few people who are predicting a glorious recovery, right? But like, I don't think anyone really knows. It could go one way or it could go the other. So it's really impossible to talk about this week, but I do know this.
9:03 Speaker 01 The bulls and the bears are in perfect balance right now.
9:06 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, that's why we're flat on the like, the last couple of weeks, it's been flat. Um, all I know is I zoom out whenever I don't know the answers in the short run and look at the long run. And the government is going to continue to print money. Crypto is going to continue to eat the banks. And, uh, this is a decade long, long bet. So who cares about the short run, uh, noise? Who cares about the week to week prices that we bring you every single week on the roll up? It's all noise. It doesn't matter, but let's talk about crypto, David. Let's talk Ethereum. It just had its highest month of earnings ever.
9:36 Speaker 01 Ever.
9:37 Ryan Sean Adams? We love talking about Ethereum. We love talking about its earnings, but I, I thought that this chart was really cool. Um, just seeing it depicted all the way from back in October 2016. This is the monthly Ethereum earnings and you'll notice here, David, it's been negative.
9:52 Speaker 01 Right.
9:52 Ryan Sean Adams? Ethereum has been unprofitable from October 2016 all the way
9:57 Speaker 01 Massively.
9:58 Ryan Sean Adams? Until when? Uh, the merge.
9:59 Ryan Sean Adams? When did that turnaround happen?
10:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, the merge. Yeah. Proof of stake makes blockchains profitable. So really, when I see this chart, I just see proof of work versus proof of stake. Uh, and so if you want to have a expenditure positive blockchain, you need to have proof of stake. Uh, and that is what we are seeing. And so this is another way of saying the burn. So instead of talking about, uh, instead of being on the website of ultrasound dot money, instead we are at this one.
10:23 Ryan Sean Adams? We tricked you.
10:24 Speaker 01 Well, it's a different way of looking at this thing, right? And so burn is at all time high. Monthly Ethereum earnings is at all time highs as well. Uh, but this chart is just really putting it into perspective as to what that means in, in comparison to Ethereum's history.
10:37 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, what's also in stark contrast is a lot of earnings reports are coming out for equities and securities and they're all kind of down, like profits are down. This is funny because Ethereum profits are up. When you look at issuance as kind of the cost and you look at transaction fees as their reward, Ethereum's profitable right now, even in a bear market. David, this was a really interesting take from Hill Dobby about NFT royalties that we've been talking about for a while. And this is somebody who dives into the data. There are a few discoveries here that I think bankless folks should know about. What is Hill Dobby saying here?
11:07 Speaker 01 So Hill Dobby is walking us through the royalties stats on Dune Analytics boards. By the way, shout out to Hill Dobby and all of their amazing Dune Analytics boards. A lot of the time when I go to Dune and I find a board and I find a good one, I go look at who made it, it's always Hill Dobby. Not always, data always also comes to mind. So a quick shout out there. So Hill Dobby is walking us through some data analytics about creator royalties. And the big theme lately has been the royalty wars and how royalty percentages are going to zero as a result of this fight between Blur and OpenSea. And so while, what's interesting here is while percentage of royalty pay is going to zero, so like the percentage of what is paid on a NFT transfer is going lower and lower
11:48 Speaker 01 and lower because margins are getting compressed, total aggregate royalty payments are actually at all time highs.
11:55 Ryan Sean Adams? Surprising, right?
11:56 Speaker 01 How does this, how do you square this? Well, it's because even though percentage on a per transaction basis is getting compressed, total volume is going up. So while royalties are getting compressed, total actual royalty payments are at all time highs. And that is a result of competition between these two major NFT trading platforms. So an interesting alternative look at the royalty wars.
12:18 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, it's great news for creators. Royalty revenue is actually going up, which is cool to see. David, we've got a lot more coming up. What's on tap?
12:27 Speaker 01 Gary, the destroyer is absolutely unhinged. We had the bankless meetup yesterday and Mike Selig is there. No, Mike Selig, our nice securities lawyer, who we've been on a couple of times with there, he dropped some comments into my ear, so I will share them after we talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
12:47 David Hoffman? A leader in the crypto industry for the last 12 years. Dedicated to accelerating the global adoption of crypto. Kraken puts an emphasis on security, transparency, and client support, which is why over 9 million clients have come to love Kraken's products. Whether you're a beginner or a pro, the Kraken UX is simple, intuitive, and frictionless, making the Kraken app a great place for all to get involved and learn about crypto. For those with experience, the redesigned Kraken Pro app and web experience is completely customizable to your trading needs, integrating key trading features into one seamless interface. Kraken has a 24/7 365 client support team that is globally recognized. Kraken support is available wherever, whenever you need them, by phone, chat, or email. And for all of you NFT-ers out there,
13:31 David Hoffman? the brand-new Kraken NFT beta platform gives you the best NFT trading experience possible: rarity rankings, no gas fees, and the ability to buy an NFT straight with cash. Does your crypto exchange prioritize its customers the way that Kraken does? And if not, sign up with Kraken at kraken.com/bankless. Learning about crypto is hard, until now. Introducing Metamask Learn, an open educational platform about crypto, Web3, self-custody, wallet management, and all the other topics needed to onboard people into this crazy world of crypto. Metamask Learn is an interactive platform, with each lesson offering a simulation for the task at hand, giving you actual, practical experience for navigating Web3. The purpose of Metamask Learn is to teach people the basics of self-custody and wallet security in a safe environment.
14:16 David Hoffman? And while Metamask Learn always takes the time to define Web3-specific vocabulary, it is still a jargon-free experience for the crypto-curious user. Friendly, not scary. Metamask Learn is available in 10 languages with more to be added soon, and it's meant to cater to a global Web3 audience. So, are you tired of having to explain crypto concepts to your friends? Go to learn.metamask.io and add Metamask Learn to your guides to get onboarded into the world of Web3.
14:43 Ryan Sean Adams? Gary the Destroyer, he's on the attack. It seems like he's on a mission to destroy crypto. I don't know what's up with Gary, but what's he doing this week, David?
14:50 Speaker 01 Declaring everything a security. So in the New York Magazine, he's made some statements which basically summarized as, "Everything is a security except Bitcoin. Every company in crypto out there is in violation. Crypto is pointless, but blockchain is kind of neat." And this is a summary from Alexander Grief, who finished it up, "Hard to argue you're acting in good faith if you're admittedly trying to stamp out an entire industry." I saw another tweet, I can't remember who tweeted it, but it was basically like the meme of, "The Wright Brothers discovered planes and flights, and every other plane after the Wright Brothers is illegitimate." As in, like Bitcoin is decentralized, but every single other chain after Bitcoin is not legitimate. Which is a big Bitcoin maxi take.
15:34 Ryan Sean Adams? But it's like, is Gary a Bitcoin maxi? Or what's he doing?
15:37 Speaker 01 He's acting like it. He's acting like a Bitcoin maxi regulator. And I'm not saying this to like, to say that this is what Bitcoin maxis believe, but like, if you were someone who only wanted to like fence and protect Bitcoin and attack everything else, if that was your agenda, that would be Gary Gensler's agenda.
15:54 Ryan Sean Adams? I don't understand. So I was bored yesterday while you guys were at the party. So I went on a tear of the, did you see this tweet thread from the bank this guy?
16:01 Speaker 01 We had the team dinner last night, and we were all like, guys, let's ride up to it.
16:06 Ryan Sean Adams? Who's doing this?
16:08 Ryan Sean Adams? So I was just in a parking lot somewhere. I was waiting for one of my kids to get done with something. And so I was just like going through all of the potential things that Gary might consider in the real world, unregistered securities. Here's a Chili's gift card for $25 that you can buy in any local gas station. David, if the Paxos BUSD stablecoin is a security, I ask you, my friend, is a Chili's gift card also a security?
16:35 Ryan Sean Adams? That's a question I would post to Gary Gensler.
16:37 Speaker 01 If I'm Gary, I'm gonna say, yes, yes.
16:38 Ryan Sean Adams? Okay, we got a security. Here's another example. Pokemon cards. Are they securities?
16:42 Speaker 01 100% a security.
16:43 Ryan Sean Adams? Wow, profit?
16:44 Speaker 01 Profitable upside, yeah, yeah.
16:47 Ryan Sean Adams? Efforts of others?
16:48 Speaker 01 Big time.
16:49 Ryan Sean Adams? Howie test?
16:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:51 Ryan Sean Adams? Pokemon cards must be a security. Here is a sword. I think this is a Diablo sword.
16:55 Speaker 01 That looks pretty Diablo-y to me, yeah.
16:57 Ryan Sean Adams? Uh, king sword, noble sword. You know, an item drop in your favorite video game's gotta be a security, right?
17:02 Speaker 01 Yeah. Oh, god, yeah.
17:03 Ryan Sean Adams? Do you have Chuck E. Cheese? Did you go to Chuck E. Cheese when you were a kid? These tokens!
17:07 Speaker 01 Not exactly.
17:08 Ryan Sean Adams? This looks like an ERC20 token to me.
17:10 Speaker 01 Why do you think we call them tokens?
17:12 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah. They stole it from Chuck E. And those are also securities. Classic cars.
17:16 Speaker 01 Classic cars that appreciate in value. Well, is that the effort of others? Well, somebody else built it.
17:21 Ryan Sean Adams? Well, Taylor Swift, she's got kind of a, you know, a songwriting artist, a signed autograph. That's worth something.
17:27 Speaker 01 Reputation of others, yep, yep.
17:29 Ryan Sean Adams? How about hotel points? Unregistered security or no?
17:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, I mean, the value of a hotel point has to be determined by how much that hotel wants to make those things valuable.
17:38 Ryan Sean Adams? And they can inflate that at any time?
17:39 Speaker 01 They can inflate those away.
17:40 Ryan Sean Adams? They can change the value of it. What's the supply schedule of a hotel point?
17:45 Speaker 01 Well, it's not deflationary, let me tell you that.
17:47 Ryan Sean Adams? Uh, how about a human organ? Got a little carried away here. Fortnite V-bucks, definitely, right? A puppy. I don't know, like, you can buy a puppy. There's a market for, like, puppies?
18:00 Speaker 01 Well, you can breed cattle, and cattle can produce dividends. And that's an effort of that cattle.
18:07 Ryan Sean Adams? Milk? The milk is the ERC20 that comes out of the cow? It's fungible.
18:11 Speaker 01 It's a profitable enterprise.
18:12 Ryan Sean Adams? I get it, yeah. Kohl's cash. Look, man, this is my Canadian upbringing. Canadian tire dollars? The Canadian watchers will know what these are.
18:20 Speaker 01 I do not want to know what these are.
18:21 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, it's a Canadian thing. Anyway, all of these could be securities. That's what's so ludicrous about this whole thing. There's no rhyme or reason other than, does Gary hate it? If yes, it's a security. That's the way it seems to me.
18:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, and the point that we're making, like, rather than talking about specifically what Gary has said is that this is the implication of like,
18:37 Ryan Sean Adams? Yes.
18:38 Speaker 01 Everything other than Bitcoin and the Bitcoin blockchain is not decentralized and is totally a security. All crypto exchanges are complicit. Probably Bankless is complicit because we talk about these things so tight. And really, that's the news of this week is that this is the stance that Gary is taking publicly.
18:57 Ryan Sean Adams? It's a really hardline stance, and I don't understand it. This is a take from crypto lawyer Jake Trivinsky. What's he say here?
19:04 Speaker 01 Jake says, Chair Gensler may have prejudged that every digital asset aside from Bitcoin is a security, but his opinion is not the law. The SEC lacks the authority to regulate any of them until and unless it proves its case in court. For each asset, every single one, individually, at one time. Which is why we titled this section Gary the Destroyer, right? Because he's coming in, he's doing the whole like chilling effect thing, which is unconstitutional. And trying to scare everyone and just being a megalomaniac, dude. He's just doing the power grab thing. Like, it's becoming clear and clearer and clear that Gary does not care about his job or his role, but is simply trying to grab the power.
19:46 Ryan Sean Adams? Yep. Well, Mad King Gary. That's...
19:48 Speaker 01 Mad King Gary, yeah.
19:49 Ryan Sean Adams? This is Logan Bolinger. What's he say?
19:52 Speaker 01 Logan says, friendly reminder that Gary Gensler's opinions on what is or isn't a security are not legally dispositive.
19:59 Ryan Sean Adams? Good. We don't have kings here, right? This is America.
20:01 Speaker 01 That's right. In this country, judges, not SEC chairs, ultimately determine what the law means and how it applies. Doesn't mean his thoughts are irrelevant. They are just not dispositive. That's a new word for me. Dispositive?
20:11 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah. They're just not dispositive.
20:15 Speaker 01 Cool.
20:16 Ryan Sean Adams? Okay.
20:19 Ryan Sean Adams? Gabe Shapiro, what's he say?
20:20 Speaker 01 Gabe Shapiro, one of a very well-respected lawyer in the crypto space, now says that now that Gary Gensler has made clear he regards every single token, including stablecoins other than Bitcoin as securities under US law, can we start asking, what's the plan here?
20:33 Ryan Sean Adams? That's a really good question.
20:35 Speaker 01 I'm sure his plan is like, well, come in and talk to us. So I can put handcuffs on you.
20:41 Ryan Sean Adams? This has got to be part of Operation Choke Point. And so, David, I guess the good news is this goes to the court system. But I'm not so sure this is good news. Like, it depends on whether we have reasonable judges in the court system. This was a take I saw last week. So a federal court just ruled that these emojis, this is the rocket emoji, the graph going up, and the bag full of money, the chart, yeah, the chart emoji and the bag full of money, objectively mean one thing: a financial return on investment. I believe this is from the NBA Top Shots legislation. The judge says this in their ruling, pointing at an exhibit of NBA Top Shots tweets.
21:22 Ryan Sean Adams? Each tweet promotes a recent sale or statistics of recent sale of moments on the marketplace. And although the literal word profit is not included in any of the tweets, the rocket ship emoji, in quotes, stock chart emoji, and money bags emoji objectively mean one thing: a financial return on investment. If you are doing the rocket emoji or the money bag emoji, David, you are giving financial advice on Twitter, whether you know it or not, according to this judge. Absolutely ludicrous takes, David. And I, like, I don't even understand if these people don't understand how the internet works. Like, you can't just say an emoji is financial advice, can you?
22:08 Speaker 01 I mean, they're not wrong. That's why they're putting the emoji in there, though. The problem is that this is the official NBA Top Shot account. I think if it was a random user of NBA Top Shots, that would be, that would be ridiculous. I think, I do kind of think like, yeah, well, if you're putting the upwards chart and rocket ship and money bags emojis into your platform and you are that platform, like, yeah, we kind of, I kind of get it.
22:31 Ryan Sean Adams? It's in bad form, but what are you, what are you gonna do? You gonna ban certain emojis? This is the stupid thing. If I do a Pokemon card rocket emoji, what am I, like, and I'm the issuer of Pokemon? I guess that's an illegal tweet?
22:46 Speaker 01 Right.
22:46 Ryan Sean Adams? Like, what is that? I don't understand what's going on here, is kind of the bottom line take. And I just, I don't know that the courts are going to interpret things in a reasonable way. Maybe this, uh...
22:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think you...
23:01 Speaker 01 It's hard. It's hard because like you're, there are like promoters laws, right?
23:05 Ryan Sean Adams? If you don't want to buy a freaking movie of an NBA top shot, don't buy it. Like I, I, I think people have to have a bit of responsibility when it comes to-
23:16 Speaker 01 Yes, I think, I think that's really like, there is confusion and gray area. And so what do we do in this environment? We push power and control and responsibility back to the individual rather than by doing this to the issuer.
23:26 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, you're not going to-
23:27 Speaker 01 Taylor Swift tickets, rocket emoji. Like that's going to be a thing too. It is a thing.
23:31 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, it is a thing. You, you're not going to like filter kind of the internet from these sorts of things. And I think doing so is a, is a dead end. But there is a chilling effect that's going into place.
23:43 Speaker 01 Big chilling effect, yeah.
23:44 Ryan Sean Adams? Robinhood received a crypto-related subpoena request from the SEC. And it's basically just saying, the SEC is saying to Robinhood, hey, there might be securities on Robinhood. The subpoena concern, among other things, lists Robinhood's cryptocurrency listings and custody of cryptocurrencies and platform operations. So Robinhood clearly doesn't have clarity from the SEC. Coinbase is suspending Binance USD stablecoin. So that's been delisted on the back of the SEC. And I believe financial regulator in New York, New York, doing this. Mastercard is holding up their crypto plans. They put that on hold. There's a report out that Visa was going to do that as well.
24:27 Ryan Sean Adams? But then Visa put out a statement, I think from Kai Sheffield, who's been on the podcast, saying the story is inaccurate as it pertains to Visa. Here's the reality. And he talks about how Visa is continuing to partner with crypto companies. Anyway, there was this like chilling effect on the industry and that's a result of Mad Gary's actions here.
24:47 Speaker 01 Yep. Nope. That's all come out. And so this is, this is Gary, once upon a time, being like a crypto hardliner. And now this is why we're calling it Gary the Destroyer. Gary, Gary the Megalomaniac. Like, and, and so like this is going so far. That this is actually starting to get pushed back from people outside of the crypto industry. And so this is news saying a new Congress body to come to hold a hearing on the regulatory attack on crypto. So they're starting finally to get pushback from Congress.
25:16 Ryan Sean Adams? Congress, yeah.
25:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, so walk us through this news, Ryan, if you will.
25:19 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, Congress, David, is holding a digital asset subcommittee within the House Financial Services. They're scheduled to hold their first ever meeting on March 9th. And the hearing is titled this, "Coincidence or Coordinated: The Administration's Attack on the Digital Asset Ecosystem." I think we would say this is certainly coordinated activity, but it's really Congress's job to rein regulators in when they go after power vacuums and are seem intent on killing an entire industry. It's good as well that a lot of the blame is being pushed back on those that are responsible for it, namely the SEC and Gary Gensler's leadership over there. Senator Tim Scott called this "the elephant in the room" and said, and Warren Davidson
26:02 Ryan Sean Adams? called Gary Gensler's "selective enforcement" on the crypto industry, I think referring to that as troubling. So that's specifically what this meeting in Congress is going to be about.
26:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, and this is how this has to end. Gary has gone from being a hard ass to being absolutely unhinged. So this, we're gonna, this is going to be a fight. And now we have to fight him. And Congress is picking up wind that like Congress doesn't like Gary necessarily, like Congress has no interest in supporting Gary. He is a rogue actor in a rogue agency.
26:35 Ryan Sean Adams? I hope, I certainly hope that's the case. Yeah. Brian Armstrong put a fantastic op ed out in CNBC, and this is, let me just read a quote from it. This is part of the pushback and fight back. "Yet while other jurisdictions progress," he's talking about outside of the US, "the US seems more focused on turf battles between regulators. No other country in the world has spent as much time and energy trying to convince its citizens that crypto assets are securities." Let's remember this whole securities thing, it's not even a topic of conversation in Europe.
27:08 Speaker 01 No. They're laughing, Europe is laughing at us, dude.
27:11 Ryan Sean Adams? We were just talking about media legislation, which is like, you know. Decently, like, folks we talked to give it like maybe a B minus. It's reasonable. It doesn't, it is completely sensible on its interpretation of what a security is and what it's not. This is a rogue agency in the US. I'm not sure why Gary and others are making this such a big deal. It's absolutely stupid. And I think in general, the context for me is this, this US anti crypto posture is, is crazy. It's a complete self own. I mean, you've seen it like the US has the talent. We have the entrepreneurs. We have the capital to lead in crypto.
27:51 Speaker 01 We have the demand.
27:52 Ryan Sean Adams? Oh, yeah. And yet our regulators are saying to the builders, yeah, go build somewhere else. We don't want this here. I think America is, America is forgetting that has to compete.
28:02 Speaker 01 Right.
28:02 Ryan Sean Adams? On like, it has to outbuild the rest of the world if it's going to stay competitive. And those in government just don't understand it.
28:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, this is like my worst favorite thing about humanity, about how like one bad person can fuck it up for like billions of people.
28:19 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah.
28:20 Speaker 01 Thanks, Gary.
28:21 Ryan Sean Adams? Certainly some of the, the class of 2022 scammers certainly gave him more fuel to be able to wage this war.
28:28 Speaker 01 You know who doesn't care about Gary or anything that he has to say? All of the scammers of 2021 and 2022. Like they just don't give, they don't care about this at all.
28:37 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, yeah, I know. It's frustrating. It's frustrating. Some other news too, that is somewhat related, Silvergate Bank. What's this, David?
28:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, so Silvergate Bank, as of this morning, stock tumbles 45% after a growing concern about the solvency of Silvergate. And so Silvergate reported a $1 billion loss in the fourth quarter. And this has caused a sort of run on the bank. There has not, there's not been any actual symptoms of insolvency yet. There have been concerning murmurings from actually Silvergate itself, as well as other indications as well. Coinbase has no longer accepted or initiates, initiated payments to or from Silvergate.
29:17 Speaker 01 And has rerouted customer deposits to a different bank.
29:20 Ryan Sean Adams? They were using Silvergate, Coinbase was.
29:22 Speaker 01 Yes, they have, they have other banks, but they have started to route payments to a different bank, just that they stated as an abundance of caution. And so it was stated that Silvergate sold additional debt securities to repay debts this year, and they have said that further losses would mean that the bank would be less than well capitalized, is what they said. So this is, one, one part of this is like, okay, banks take risk, that's what they do, that's the part of their business model. Crypto is risky, there's not that many banks in the crypto industry, therefore, the few banks that do serve crypto bear the general risk of kind of the entire industry. We all know what happened with the insolvencies of 2022.
30:06 Speaker 01 And so that has impacted a large amount of Silvergate's clients, which makes them unable to pay back their, their loans to Silvergate, which means Silvergate has to eat some losses. And then in addition to that, Operation Choke Point has really reduced the interest in investing in Silvergate or making Silvergate like a credit worthy bank. And so all of this has like led up to this moment right now, where like Silvergate's stock tumbles 45%, Coinbase doesn't want to use Silvergate out of an abundance of caution. And so this is one part, like kind of a cell phone out of the crypto industry. Then like magnet, like blown up because of Operation Choke Point because of, thanks, Gary.
30:46 Ryan Sean Adams? They can't get, they can't get banked anywhere else, basically. And it's, it's Gary, it's the entire administration that seems to be involved in Operation Choke Point, and the stock is certainly taking a tumble, as you mentioned, Silvergate's stock has a result.
30:59 Speaker 01 Not great.
30:59 Ryan Sean Adams? The question is, where are crypto exchanges going to actually bank in the US? There's Operation Choke Point.
31:04 Speaker 01 This is not the banklessness that we want. This is the bad banklessness.
31:08 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, this does not help liquidity inflows into, into crypto, and it cuts off a way for people to become more bankless. That's the bad news this week. The good news, though, David, is.
31:18 Speaker 01 Good news from here on out.
31:20 Ryan Sean Adams? Good news from here on out, all right? We got through the worst of it. MetaMask is now in the Unity store. David, do you know much about Unity, the gaming platform?
31:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a very well adopted, very high profile game engine that many of your favorite games, if you are a gamer, is built off of. MetaMask has released an SDK for incorporating MetaMask into Unity. What does that mean? Web3 games, asset-powered games, sign in with Ethereum in your Unity game, anything that you can think of that has to do with your private key on Ethereum into a Unity game engine. So like the topic of what that means is massive, but simply think of a more seamless injection of private keys into Unity games and all of the positive second-order effects that come with that.
32:05 Ryan Sean Adams? Did you know, David, there's 2.7 billion users and developers that use Unity for a game or a set of games?
32:13 Speaker 01 Do you think 2.7 billion users who are playing with securities inside of their games run?
32:18 Ryan Sean Adams? Oh, God, I hope not. Don't tell Gary.
32:20 Speaker 01 Well, we'll just DDoS Gary, you know?
32:23 Ryan Sean Adams? 2.7 billion of us?
32:25 Speaker 01 With all of the gamers. Gary's like, "Everything's a security." It's like, "Well, all of the gamers are playing with unregistered securities, Gary. Go get them."
32:32 Ryan Sean Adams? A court case for every airdrop. I can't wait. Take all the 12-year-olds on, one by one. Enjoy that. This is the Unity Asset Store, David. They have a whole section called Decentralization here. That's where you see this. So if you scroll down, you can see-
32:46 Speaker 01 Asset Store. That doesn't mean crypto assets. That means like gaming assets, right?
32:51 Ryan Sean Adams? It's not a crypto asset, Gary. Don't worry. Don't worry.
32:54 Speaker 01 Or is it? Sorry. No.
32:56 Ryan Sean Adams? There are assets in the store.
32:57 Speaker 01 Like gaming assets, like download this package or whatever. Right. Yes, yes, yes.
33:01 Ryan Sean Adams? Because Unity is a-
33:02 Speaker 01 But I don't know, maybe Gary's like, "Ooh, I can regulate that."
33:05 Ryan Sean Adams? Did you say asset?
33:09 Ryan Sean Adams? Oh, pops Gary. No, this is a different type of asset, all right? It's a software asset. Anyway, Unity is a technology platform for gamers. I didn't realize how big it was. Holds about a 50% market share. The only other, like, next biggest gaming engine is the Unreal Engine, which, you know, and oh, Pokemon Go, by the way. That is built with Unity. So can you imagine, like, oh, Metamask wallet inside of Pokemon Go to collect your Pokemon? Can you imagine that?
33:36 Speaker 01 I can imagine that, yeah.
33:37 Ryan Sean Adams? I know. You're a Pokemon Go player, aren't you?
33:39 Speaker 01 I haven't played in a while, but yes.
33:42 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah. I mean, anyway, watch out for those Pokemon securities, but it's pretty cool. I think this is going to be huge. This is going to help bring crypto mainstream. And I think crypto has some work to do with the gaming community. Can we just say that? Like, they don't like NFTs right now.
33:57 Speaker 01 This is that.
33:58 Ryan Sean Adams? They're digital collectibles. They're not NFTs, though. It's a totally different thing. All right, what do we have coming up next?
34:04 Speaker 01 Coming up next, oh my gosh, so much. Robin Hood wallet is out. We got the Deets. Scroll ZK EVM soon TM. Oasis, you like that one, right? Oasis clawbacks money from a hacker to give back to its rightful owner, but was it the right thing to do? And DevCon is heading to Southeast Asia in 2024, which I don't, they didn't announce the specific city, so I don't have my flight yet, but you know I will soon. All of that and more, but first a moment to talk about these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible.
34:33 David Hoffman? The Phantom wallet is coming to Ethereum. The number one wallet on Solana is bringing its millions of users and beloved UX to Ethereum and Polygon. If you haven't used Phantom before, you've been missing out. Phantom was one of the first wallets to pioneer Solana staking inside the wallet and will be offering similar staking features for Ethereum and Polygon. But that's just staking. Phantom is also the best home for your NFTs. Phantom has a complete set of features to optimize your NFT experience. Pin your favorites, hide your uglies, burn the spam, and also manage your NFT sale listings from inside the wallet. Phantom is of course a multi-chain wallet, but it makes chain management easy, displaying your transactions in a human readable format with automatic warnings for malicious transactions or phishing websites. Phantom has already saved over 20,000 users from getting scammed or hacked.
35:18 David Hoffman? So get on the Phantom waitlist and be one of the first to access the multi-chain beta. There's a link in the show notes, or you can go to phantom.app/waitlist to get access in late February. Hey, Bankless Nation. If you're listening to this, it's because you're on the free Bankless RSS feed. Did you know that there's an ad-free version of Bankless that comes with the Bankless Premium subscription? No ads, just straight to the content. But that's just one of many things that a premium subscription gets you. There's also the Token Report, a monthly bullish, bearish, neutral report on the hottest tokens of the month. And the regular updates from the Token Report go into the Token Bible, your first stop shop for every token worth investigating in crypto. Bankless Premium also gets you a 30% discount to the Permissionless Conference, which means it basically just pays for itself.
36:02 David Hoffman? There's also the Airdrop Guide to make sure you don't miss a drop in 2023, but really, the best. Best part about Bankless Premium is hanging out with me, Ryan, and the rest of the Bankless team in the Inner Circle Discord only for Premium members. Want the alpha? Check out Ben the Analyst's DGEN pit, where you can ask him questions about the token report. Got a question? I've got my own Q and A room for any questions that you might have. At Bankless, we have huge things planned for 2023, including a new website with login with your Ethereum address capabilities, and we're super excited to ship what we are calling Bankless 2.0 soon TM. So if you want extra help exploring the frontier, subscribe to Bankless Premium. It's under 50 cents a day and provides a wealth of knowledge and support on your journey west. I'll see you in the Discord.
36:46 Ryan Sean Adams? Robinhood has a non-custodial crypto wallet now. They said that we're going to do it last summer. Now here it is. It's available on the iOS App Store. David, did you have a chance to download this and check it out? Can you give us the details?
36:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, amazingly, in the middle of ETH, I'm ready to have a chance to actually download this. Okay, so here's the deal. It's an Ethereum-only wallet at the moment and Polygon. You can deposit and outbound and send tokens on the Ethereum Layer 1. You cannot trade tokens on the Ethereum Layer 1. You can only send in and out. If you send into the Polygon network on the Robinhood wallet, you can trade and the trades that you make on the Polygon side of Robinhood wallet are gasless. That's the full extent of the wallet.
37:30 Ryan Sean Adams? It's just like when you say trade, you're doing it on a decentralized Polygon protocol. Is that right? With some liquidity pool or something?
37:37 Speaker 01 This is a collaboration between Robinhood, Polygon, and ZeroX. And so ZeroX has this relayer API that's used to swap. And so the Robinhood wallet calls the ZeroX relayer API, swaps the tokens, and that's all gasless and automatic and basically synonymous with the UX that Robinhood users are used to in their normal wallet. No other blockchains are supported. No Solana, no Avalanche. I mean, I'm sure they probably have plans to incorporate them at some time. But like right now, it's a pretty constrained.
38:07 Ryan Sean Adams? Limited functionality now.
38:09 Speaker 01 Limited functionality. I'm sure they are going to add more. But right now, it's just like on the Ethereum Layer 1, it's inbound and outbound transfers. And then on the Polygon Layer 2, it's inbound and outbound transfers and swaps via ZeroX.
38:21 Ryan Sean Adams? How was that haptic response, though? Remember their CEO telling us about that?
38:26 Speaker 01 I did not notice any haptic response.
38:28 Ryan Sean Adams? It's supposed to like, like when you hit a trade, it's like vibrates in your hand. You feel good?
38:32 Speaker 01 Yeah. Well, I haven't been able to trade because I sent in 25 USCC to the Ethereum layer one. And I was like, okay, swap for ETH and I couldn't.
38:41 Ryan Sean Adams? Okay.
38:41 Speaker 01 But I'm sure they are going there. I'm sure this is just the first debut. I'm sure they've got.
38:45 Ryan Sean Adams? I love that they're doing this.
38:46 Speaker 01 The UX is great. If you are used to the Robinhood app, it is almost the same kind of UX and UI layer. So it's great.
38:53 Ryan Sean Adams? And why do we care so much about this is because it's bankless, non-custodial wallet. It's super cool to see Robinhood developing this and building this out, using their resources to do that.
39:04 Speaker 01 In just expediency, I did save my private keys to the cloud, which was a native feature in there. And I'm like, ooh, I hope, I hope they got that one right. You can also save your own private keys to yourself the normal way. You can also trust Robinhood to save it to the cloud.
39:18 Ryan Sean Adams? I think that's fine. As long as people know what they're like getting into, right? For $25, how much do you care?
39:23 Speaker 01 Well, I did $25. Other people would.
39:27 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. In the future. I know. You, as long as they have the option, I'm content with it. It's a great first strike.
39:33 Speaker 01 They do have the option.
39:34 Ryan Sean Adams? What's going on with Scroll? Another, first of all, what is Scroll?
39:38 Speaker 01 Scroll is a ZK EVM that is trying to be EVM equivalent, which is an ambitious endeavor, to use my words at the start of every weekly rollup. But they are going all the way down into the bytecode, making circuit things to make the EVM a ZK EVM. But also Ethereum equivalent. Very ambitious, very bullish if they can get it done. They are getting it done. The last I checked with them, they had, they had like a 600 gigabyte RAM requirement in order to run their prover. And then they dropped that down to 200, which is a huge order of magnitude of improvement, but still have a long way to go to make that accessible to more and more and more. Anyways, they have announced that their ZK EVM is live on a gorley testnet, 100% permissionless.
40:22 Speaker 01 And so this is the last major step that they need in order to go to the Scroll mainnet.
40:27 Ryan Sean Adams? Do you know what? This is way faster than I thought it would be, David.
40:30 Speaker 01 All the ZK EVM stuff is happening very, very fast. So it's 100% open sourced. Scroll has even frozen some of its codebase to pass to auditors for review. So like the Scroll, the Scroll ZK EVM mainnet, you can see it on the horizon. It is not that far off. So congrats to the Scroll team. Ryan and I are angel investors in Scroll.
40:52 Ryan Sean Adams? Yes, true. You find that on our disclosures page.
40:55 Speaker 01 Always.
40:55 Ryan Sean Adams? This CoinDesk headline Ethereum says ERC 4337 deployed, tested in the beginning of the era of smart accounts. David, what is this ERC? What does it do? I can tell you're bullish about it.
41:11 Speaker 01 I'm so glad you asked. Yeah, ERC 4337. What's the difference between EIP and ERC? Well, an EIP is something that gets hard forked in. An ERC is a smart contract standard. That's not technically the difference, but it's good for these purposes.
41:26 Ryan Sean Adams? Like an ERC 20 is just a standard that everyone agrees to. It's not something that needs to be forked into the code of Ethereum.
41:33 Speaker 01 That's exactly right. Yes. So ERC 4337 was deployed to the Ethereum Layer 1. What does that mean? Somebody just wrote a smart contract. There is ERC 4337, which is the account abstracting standard that has been worked on by Yoav Weiss, who is the man that we are looking at in this picture here, and many, many others. It is account abstraction inside of a smart contract. So typically, the way that people have thought about account abstraction is needing to enable it at the protocol layer.
41:59 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, that's honestly, going into this, that's how I thought it was going to happen. It needed to be forked in.
42:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, so that is still the long-term conclusion. But in the meantime, we have ERC 4337 as a smart contract to enable account abstraction as a smart contract. And so you can start to do smart contract wallet level stuff, account abstraction level stuff on the Ethereum Layer 1, starting today. Instead of at the protocol native level, it's just a smart contract that you can use. But this has now been deployed. This caught a lot of people by surprise because I think you, like you, Ryan and me, was like, oh, you can do this through a smart contract? That's pretty cool.
42:32 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah.
42:32 Speaker 01 And so smart contract wallet capabilities is now on the Ethereum Layer 1. And this really is just like a middle step between native support at the protocol level. And but it can also hasten that because we can have more iteration, more development, more experimentation and more innovation on the actual protocol standard that will eventually get incorporated into the Ethereum layer one at some future date and time.
42:56 Ryan Sean Adams? And the reason, by the way, guys, we're so excited about account abstraction is it enables a new era of smart contract wallets, which is basically like if you think about the, you know, the user experience of fintech, a mobile app like Venmo, for example, or Revolut in the UK and in Europe, this enables that, right? Like many of our wallets right now, they do not have seamless user experience, right? You're signing transactions, you have no, you have no idea what you're signing. Smart contract wallets will smooth all of that out, make it incredibly easy to use. This is a big UX upgrade in the future. And this is the infrastructure for that UX upgrade.
43:34 Speaker 01 The metaphor that I've used to explain this is that all of your wallets, your MetaMask, your Ledger, anything with an, it's called like an externally owned account, anything with a private key, that is a Bitcoin of a wallet, a Bitcoin version of a wallet. It's, it's done and simple and not programmable. Account abstraction, smart contract wallets, like kind of a hard word to understand. It's the Ethereum of wallets. It's a wallet with a chip in it. It can, you can program your wallet to do anything. And that is how we get over a lot of UX and UI hurdles.
44:04 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, it's like people have coffee mugs, but there's an amber mug which has a chip in it, which you can heat at any time. That is the equivalent, has a chip in it.
44:14 Speaker 01 I don't know about that metaphor.
44:18 Ryan Sean Adams? I'm enjoying my amber mug.
44:20 Speaker 01 I think my metaphor is a little bit better.
44:22 Ryan Sean Adams? Not to sponsor the podcast, I'm a fan. Board Apes, they are doing things on the Bitcoin blockchain. What are they up to?
44:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, Yuga Labs, so not Board Apes, Board Apes parent Yuga Labs, people know the Board Apes, but Yuga Labs is the software company behind Board Apes, said Monday, it's planning to release an NFT collection minted on the Ordinals Protocol. The 12-fold collection will feature 300 generative art NFTs created by Yuga Labs and placed on a 12 by 12 grid, which serves as a visual allegory for the cartography of data on the Bitcoin blockchain. It will include 3D elements as well as hand drawn features. Interesting, kind of divergent from what Yuga Labs typically does. This new collection does not come with any extended utility or has any affiliation with the current Ethereum based collections out of Yuga Labs. Cool.
45:11 Speaker 01 I mean, this is what we're looking for out of ordinals is adoption by players who are here for the long term.
45:17 Ryan Sean Adams? And this is what Bitcoin needs.
45:19 Speaker 01 Ryan, is, is, we talked about ordinals usage being up for a month straight. Ordinals demand is down for two weeks straight. But, I mean, there was a hype mania. It's, it hit a peak. It could hit a trough and go back up, but we are down two weeks in a row on, on ordinal usage.
45:34 Ryan Sean Adams? Yep, this is good for Bitcoin, whether Bitcoin maximalists know it or not, they need block space demand in the future and this helps with that. David, there was a bit of a controversy in DeFi circles last week as well. Oasis exploited its own wallet software to seize crypto stolen in the wormhole hack. That is the title of this article. Can you tell us what happened?
45:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, so oasis.app, it's a DeFi app. It seized assets, it clawed back, it clawed back assets related to the $140 million exploit of the wormhole bridge, if you remember that one last year, and then returned them to the authorized third party, Ryan, after being ordered by a court to do so. So, a DeFi app was ordered by a court to seize assets that were stolen to return them to the rightful owner. Who was that rightful owner, by the way? That was Jump Capital, so the money got sent back. Our favorite people got sent back. Sorry to all the good people at Jump, but you guys have done some, not some great things. And like, I'm not afraid to admit that, and neither should you.
46:37 Speaker 01 Anyways, so, so oasis.app clawed back assets that were stolen from the wormhole bridge that were Jump's assets, gave them back to Jump after being ordered by a court. So like, the instance is like, cool, we gave, we stole money back from a hacker and gave it back to the rightful owner. But what precedent does this set? What are your thoughts on this, Ryan?
46:59 Ryan Sean Adams? Well, first of all, it's a surprise. Shouldn't Oasis not be able to do that? I think that's the first thing. If it's truly decentralized, then the makers of the protocol or the application shouldn't have the ability to go claw back funds, go reach into a multi-sager, into a smart contract, and take those funds out. So, can you talk about that side of the story? Because what we always say is, it's not, don't be evil, it's can't be evil. Like, there is no ability to change an immutable code, but what happened in this case?
47:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, so the contracts for Oasis were upgradable, which meant there was a hole for Oasis to upgrade their contracts to get that money back. This goes back to my philosophy of if you can be regulated, then you ought to be regulated. And if you can't be regulated, then you won't be regulated. And I think this is the case of an example of an app that could be regulated because clearly a court was able to order someone to do something to get the money back. And that puts Oasis in the category of can be regulated. Now, if they want to not be regulated, they shouldn't have upgradable smart contracts. I feel like that's a pretty safe claim to make. However, I do understand the utility of having upgradable smart contracts because you can,
48:12 Speaker 01 you know, prevent from exploits. You can, you can protect your software, you can protect your users. Plenty of reasons to have upgradable smart contracts. But this is the tug of war, the push and pull between decentralization and centralization. What does decentralization get us? Immutable money, which is great, also comes with the costs. And so this is just an example of where those two ends meet.
48:34 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, I think it's a reminder that there are many DeFi protocols and even layer twos and other things that you think are maximally decentralized and immutable that still have these upgrade hatches. And so we should be conscious of that. Now, for many of these protocols, they are temporary, but that temporary period of time could be months, it could also be years. So people should be conscious of that. It's also like people are pretty upset with Oasis Labs developers saying that it sets a bad precedent. One thing I'd say, though, is put yourself in the shoes of an Oasis developer. You have, you know, you have this escape hatch. And by the way, this wasn't, here's an important point. This wasn't, as I understand it, David, an intentional escape hatch.
49:15 Ryan Sean Adams? It was actually a bug, a flaw in the way that the code was written that the Oasis Labs devs happened to know about. Anyway, they received this court order and it's just like, well, you have the ability to withdraw the funds. And if you don't do it, you're going to get in trouble with the authorities. Authorities, metaphorically, go to jail if you don't do this, right?
49:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
49:35 Ryan Sean Adams? It would be so much simpler if you could just be like, we can't do it. There's no ability. There is no access point for us to withdraw this and that is maximally decentralized. So you're not put in the place where you have to make that decision. But as far as like morally, ethically, should they have resisted and gone off to prison? And I mean, the money was stolen, right? So I'm not very upset at the Oasis devs for this. We just don't know what happened behind the scenes.
50:05 Speaker 01 The calculus is simple. Hey, your app has stolen money in it. Give it back or go to jail. I'm like, well, personally, I'm like, okay, I'll.
50:16 Ryan Sean Adams? Live to fight another day.
50:17 Speaker 01 Exactly. I'll give the money to the right person and I won't go to jail. That's a win-win. And then maybe burn the private keys later, right?
50:24 Ryan Sean Adams? Yep. I, you know, that's just where we are as an industry and I think we should, we should admit that's the case. David, Coinbase had some scheduled downtime this week, but I don't know if that's the story you wanted to get to.
50:36 Speaker 01 No, this is, this is really just the lead into the next story. Coinbase has upcoming planned scheduled downtime. So this will be on Saturday for eight hours. Upcoming, yeah. I don't know how frequent this is. I think this is perhaps like a longer than normal, but this is totally like a normal thing for Coinbase to do. What's not a normal thing to do is have unscheduled downtime for a layer one blockchain. Solana had 19 hours and 20 minutes of downtime. The Solana Foundation said is still investigating why the network went down during the outage. The network, the users could not process transactions, including NFT and DeFi trading. And so I was asking some of the analysts who pay attention to Solana DeFi on the Bankless team.
51:17 Speaker 01 By the way, the analysts on the Bankless team play attention to much more things beyond the Ethereum centric nature of you and me, Ryan. And so I was asking, okay, so did this like impact any like DeFi apps? Did anyone get liquidated when they shouldn't have like what happened? And they were like, well, there's not much TVL left in Solana DeFi.
51:34 Ryan Sean Adams? Really?
51:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
51:36 Ryan Sean Adams? I guess, I guess now it's more. It's NFT. It's kind of cultural. I guess it's more, it's become more of that and less DeFi.
51:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, and it's like, we said this, Ryan, the last time Solana went down, it was a good while ago. It was, I don't know, six, nine months ago, the last time Solana went down. But like, man, you really not need to start building up Lindy. And you have to reset the Lindy clock now. Your chain went down for 19 hours. Imagine if the world of finance was built on this. Like, the whole point of crypto is to have 24/7, 365 immutable smart contracts and DeFi services. If your Layer 1 chain goes down, you get to, that puts, that gives certain people power. And other people not have power, because some people can process transactions when other people can't. And they will be able to have God mode over DeFi, over all DeFi on Solana in that one moment of time,
52:28 Speaker 01 while that network is down. And that, you can't do that. And so, we have to set the Lindy clock back on Solana once again. And so, like, it's...
52:37 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, I know, but it's gonna sound like we're kind of over, like, Solana bashing, but like, I just, I just...
52:43 Speaker 01 This is so important!
52:44 Ryan Sean Adams? I totally believe that certain things disqualify you from the race of Layer 1. Right? And you frequent downtime, long periods of downtime, or you have to do an offline coordination to kind of restore. It's one of those things. So, I know Solana, the, the community is, is working hard on this and building, and we wish them the best for this. But this has to be fixed during this bear market.
53:08 Speaker 01 You need to start building Lindy. Every time you reset it, you go back so far.
53:14 Ryan Sean Adams? Yes.
53:14 Speaker 01 Like, the Lindy is at zero. Like, other, even non-Ethereum chains have better Lindy than Solana.
53:21 Ryan Sean Adams? Not to harp on Solana too much, but apparently the Solana stores in New York City and Miami are also closing as well. So, sign of, sign of these bearish times, I suppose. David, the FTX ex-engineering chief, Nishad Singh, pled guilty to criminal charges. So, I believe he joins Gary Wang and Caroline, and some of the other FTX criminals. Still outstanding is Sam Bankman-Fried, but with all of his executives pleading guilty, he can't be too far behind. Is there anything else you want to add to this? Story.
53:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, Sam Bankman Fried. It's not that he had many friends left, if any, but another definitely one off of the list of potential Sam Bankman Fried friends. This guy, I'm assuming, is going to work with the authorities to settle his case in a favorable as way possible, which is not going to help Sam Bankman Fried. Meanwhile, Sam Bankman Fried, this like 29 year old, youngest dude, just living at home with mom and dad.
54:17 Ryan Sean Adams? Just watching football.
54:18 Speaker 01 Watching football on a VPN.
54:20 Ryan Sean Adams? After stealing $15 billion.
54:22 Speaker 01 Yep.
54:24 Ryan Sean Adams? Strange. David, this is the DevCon news. Tell us about it.
54:27 Speaker 01 DevCon 7 has been announced coming to Southeast Asia in 2024. No specific time, no specific place, other than Southeast Asia, very large place. But keep your calendars open for 2024.
54:40 Ryan Sean Adams? For 2024?
54:41 Speaker 01 To go to Southeast Asia if you're interested in DevCon.
54:45 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah. Are they doing these every two years now? Or is it every 18 months? Because the last one was in 2022, right? In Bogota?
54:51 Speaker 01 Uh, yes, that was 2022 in Bogota in October. So I've talked to Joseph Schweitzer about this. There's no hard and fast rule for what they're doing. DevConnect is the smaller sister event to DevCon. And they are, the F has committed to doing DevConnect every single, not every single year, on a reoccurring basis. And so I think the vibe here is that DevConnect and DevCon are like this binary star system that rotate around each other, to use a metaphor, with one star being bigger than the other, DevCon being the big star, DevConnect being the small star. This is just how my brain works.
55:24 Ryan Sean Adams? And one of them has a faster orbit, right? Which is Dev.
55:26 Speaker 01 No, no, I think every nine months is like one, one, every nine months, you get the DevConnect, which is the smaller one. And then nine months later, you get the DevCon, which is the big one.
55:35 Ryan Sean Adams? Hey, that's cool. Southeast Asia, always interesting places that they host.
55:39 Speaker 01 I haven't gone, I haven't gone to Asia yet, Ryan. This is gonna be my first trip to Asia.
55:42 Ryan Sean Adams? There you go. Get ready. Book 2024, so you're available. David, this is some bankless news, and this is under our raises section. I'll read the headline. Hosts of bankless podcast raising $35 million crypto venture fund. Hey, that's us, I think. What's this about?
55:59 Speaker 01 Yeah. So Ryan, you and I and our friend Ben Lakoff are starting Bankless Ventures. We are still pretty early in this process, but we are starting up a venture capital firm. Why are we doing this? Well, as people who listen to the Bankless podcast know, Ryan and I do a bunch of angel investing. We also do a bunch of advisory work and we enjoy supporting founders who are helping explore the frontier of crypto and the frontier of what it means to go bankless. And so all we're really doing is now we are putting all of that effort that we're already doing into a structure that we are now calling Bankless Ventures. And so I think this really, this conversation really got started, Ryan. We were like, hey, man, we're doing a lot of angel investing. Like, we should hire an analyst. We should like help like, like make this process easier for us. It's a lot of work.
56:43 Speaker 01 And so then when the conversation continues, like, well, that just starts to look like a VC firm. So really important point of emphasis, we're already doing all basically everything that it takes to do a VC firm, private market investing, angel, angel investing, advisory work. And now we are putting that inside of a structure. The only thing that's really new here is now we're doing that with outside capital for LPs. And so that is kind of, that's the, really the thought process behind this.
57:11 Ryan Sean Adams? Nothing changes with respect to our schedule, still coming at you with all the content that, that we always have. And of course, our disclosures are always updated. So if you want to get a feel for the types of angel investments we have been doing, the types of things that we'll be doing in the, in the fund itself, you can head on over to bankless.com/disclosures, click the link there and you'll see all of these things. And the reason why they honestly need to be organized in some sort of a different structure. But David, I don't know if I'd trust a guy in this kind of a jacket here, and it looks kind of like a crypto rebel here. If I give this guy my money. Was this taken last night?
57:48 Speaker 01 That was, that was at the Bankless meetup. Yeah. And the first question that everyone probably like asks is like, all right, how does Bankless Ventures affect the media side of things? And the very big and easy answer is that it just doesn't change anything at all, and intentionally so. When we first thought about doing Bankless Ventures, our first exploration was a long conversation with lawyers. It was like, what would we have to change on the media side of things to do Bankless Ventures? Because we don't want to change anything on the media side of things. We want to preserve media to the maximum degree. And so after that conversation with lawyers, like because we have literally the industry's best disclosures, we also never do any paid content ever on principle. And we already have an editorial policy that makes all of our personal angel investments not impact our content decisions.
58:33 Speaker 01 Like, we just learned that everything that we are already doing on the media side of things doesn't impact Ventures, and Ventures doesn't impact media. And so when we have been chatting with potential LPs, at the very beginning of these chats, we make a very firm statement that at the very beginning of our call, that Bankless Media in no way will support Bankless Ventures. If any portfolio company wants to come on the podcast, and we've gotten plenty of questions or like requests from our portfolio companies to come on the podcast before, they will always have to do it the old fashioned way, which is by building something worthy of covering and sufficiently interesting to the Bankless audience.
59:08 Ryan Sean Adams? And with the investment funds that's flowing into crypto all over the place, of course crypto is always hiring. You can check out the latest jobs on the Bankless Jobs Board. That's bankless.pallet.com/jobs. Uniswap Labs needs a senior software engineer. Bankless is hiring some writers, analysts, social growth leads. Consensus wants a director of engineering. There's still that Adidas role. A global head of Web3 strategy and planning, a whole bunch more. Go over to the Jobs Board and check that out. That's bankless.pallet.com/jobs. David, what do we got coming up next?
59:39 Speaker 01 Coming up next, we got the questions from the nation. We've got some good ones, as well as what Ryan and I are excited about, as well as the takes of the week. So don't go anywhere. We're going to get to all of that and more, right after we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
59:51 David Hoffman? Arbitrum One is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed. On Arbitrum 1, producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With the recent addition of Arbitrum Nova, gaming and social dApps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitrum home. Both Arbitrum 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. On Arbitrum, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees. With Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit arbitrum.io, where you can join the community,
1:00:34 David Hoffman? dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app. With Arbitrum, experience Web3 development the way it was meant to be: secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. How many total airdrops have you gotten? This last bull market had a ton of them. Did you get them all? Maybe you missed one. So here's what you should do. Go to Earnify and plug in your Ethereum wallet, and Earnify will tell you if you have any unclaimed airdrops that you can get. And it also does PoApps and mintable NFTs. Any kind of money that your wallet can claim, Earnify will tell you about it. And you should probably do it now, because some airdrops expire. And if you sign up for Earnify, they'll email you anytime one of your wallets has a new airdrop for it, to make sure that you never lose an airdrop ever again. You can also upgrade to Earnify Premium to unlock access to airdrops that are beyond the basics
1:01:17 David Hoffman? and are able to set reminders for more wallets. And for just under $21 a month, it probably pays for itself with just one airdrop. So plug in your wallets at Earnify and see what you get. That's E-A-R-N-I dot F-I. And make sure you never lose another airdrop.
1:01:32 Ryan Sean Adams? Got some questions of the week for you. The first from the Bankless Nation Discord. Simon Bruce1974 here, saying, "Using Base as an example, if a chain is built on the OP stack, that's the optimism stack, does it still require a bridge to move assets to another chain built on the optimism stack or optimism? Or is it as simple as sending the asset as a normal transaction?" That's the question. What say you, David?
1:01:58 Speaker 01 The answer is yes and no. Right now, the answer is yes. The idea about the OP stack is in the future that answer will be no. And the answer won't be ever perfectly no, but the answer trends towards no. Why is that such a confusing answer? So the idea that... Well, the idea is that base and optimism are both on the OP stack. Because of that common denominator, the bridge between these two chains has less risk and less dependencies and more standardization. And so the bridge between base and the OP stack is less bridgy than it would be had it been to like, I don't know, base to Arbitrum or base to Polygon or something.
1:02:40 Speaker 01 Because of the common denominator of the OP stack, a lot of complexity is removed. And as further innovations, more innovations come to the scene, a lot of that complexity becomes abstracted and obfuscated away. And so, yes, there will always be a bridge. Right now, that bridge is pretty bridgy, to use a very technical term. And then in the future, it will become less bridgy. And that is also true for all OP stack chains. And so the bridginess trends towards zero. However, it will never hit zero. But the idea is that with additional technologies, you can obfuscate and abstract a lot of the bridginess. I made an OP stack video. If you go to YouTube and type in "bankless OP stack", there's my face next to a thumbnail that's titled OP stack.
1:03:24 Speaker 01 If you want to learn more, click that video.
1:03:26 Ryan Sean Adams? It's all part of the same kind of, I guess, nation, security apparatus, if you will. It'll be more like traveling from New York to New Jersey than like New York to cross the border to Canada or something like this.
1:03:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, so imagine it's like, okay, we're in the United States in the 1700s. You can get from New York to Washington state pretty easily. Well, not pretty easily. You can do it without crossing a passport control, but you still got to walk. And then you fast forward 300 years and then you can just fly really, really fast. The bridginess gets less bridgy.
1:03:57 Ryan Sean Adams? No high-speed rail though, yet, which makes me bitter every time I think about that.
1:04:01 Speaker 01 Not yet, yes.
1:04:01 Ryan Sean Adams? Come on, American. Okay, here's a question from Captain Randall Wall. I think I said that right. Sorry, Captain. Apologies if that has already been covered, but what are your thoughts on the Eigenlayer and the potential impact of ETH staking and price? Do you see this as helpful to alts in terms of securing validation? That first question of what is Eigenlayer first? Maybe you have to define that. And what's the potential impact on ETH staking and ETH price?
1:04:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, so Eigenlayer has just absolutely swept the world of crypto by storm just because of what it is. And if you are curious about this answer to this question, it would behoove you, I think, to listen to the interview I did with Sriram at the Interoperability Summit that I went to a couple of days ago, where we talked about this subject in particular. What is Eigenlayer? Eigenlayer is taking normal Ethereum staking and adding on additional, like additional, what I'm calling like mods, if you will. And so like, not only are you staking your ETH to Ethereum for all the normal reasons, but you can also use that Ether stake that you've already staked to also secure something else. So rather than having to have like-
1:05:04 Ryan Sean Adams? And when you say "secure," the idea is like a bond, right? It's like economic security.
1:05:08 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:05:09 Ryan Sean Adams? So that's what you mean by modding. You're like, "I'm going to secure this Ethereum mainchain thing, but then for some additional risk and reward, I'll also do this other thing."
1:05:17 Speaker 01 Right, so imagine like Chainlink, you stake the link token to do the oracle network. With Eigenlayer, you can stake your ETH to Ethereum, again, for normal staking reasons, and then also have that same stake also secure an oracle network, or a data availability network, or generally anything that needs economic security. And so the idea is that this produces additional yields for ETH stakers because they can secure more things, but with additional slashing penalties if you lie or do something wrong for whatever additional thing that you're doing. So the question is, what is the potential impact on ETH staking and price? For all of the, there was a tweet that we talked about forever ago. "Eigenlayer will enable whole all alt-layer ones for ETH maxis."
1:06:01 Ryan Sean Adams? Sure.
1:06:02 Speaker 01 Which also deserves unpacking, so I'll do my best. The idea is that like, all of these alt-layer ones, like Celestia, Subnets on Avalanche, like all of these reasons to produce different alt-layer ones that would trigger the decentralization maxis. Now you can just use Ethereum staking, normal Ethereum staking, to do all of that same kind of services without having to have additional tokens or additional like chains or all that kind of stuff. And so it produces additional yields for your ETH, and it really imbues a lot of the reasons to make additional alt-layer ones and imbues that value into Ether and Ether staking. So in the pendulum, I talked about this with Sriram, there's like a pendulum between Polychainism, mesh network of many, many, many chains and bridges.
1:06:47 Speaker 01 That's one end of the spectrum. And then the other end of the spectrum is like, single one dominant layer one chain. There's always a spectrum of like where we are in the pendulum. And Eigenlayer really pushes this towards there's really only needs to be one dominant chain and everything else is is less necessary. There's going to be a tug of war between these two things, but Eigenlayer is definitely pushing towards like, all you really need to do is stake Ether and then sign up for additional yield opportunities if you want.
1:07:15 Ryan Sean Adams? I think to the question the captain is asking about impact on price.
1:07:19 Speaker 01 Oh, it's bullish.
1:07:20 Ryan Sean Adams? This is incredibly freaking bullish. Do you remember the idea that we'd come out with a couple of years ago about Ether, the internet bond, which is the idea that Ether is an internet bond for the Ethereum ecosystem. That's what happens when you're staking, you're actually bonding it and it accrues monetary premium in the way that a bond might. This is now Ethereum being able to export Ether, the asset as a bond to other foreign chains or foreign protocols. And that is incredibly powerful because these kinds of monetary premium games, like bonding type games, are all power law games, right?
1:08:02 Ryan Sean Adams? So why would you bond with some other chain's native asset when that is far less liquid and far more volatile than Ether, the internet bond? So this is like if Eigenlayer really picks up, and that's still an if, right? We don't know for sure. But if it picks up, it is incredibly bullish for Ether, the asset as that the meme that we predicted a couple of years ago, as the internet bond. Ether, the asset really becomes a bond for securing things economically on the internet. And wow, that is a powerful place to be. So that is why this technology is not just bullish for more chains, more experiments, more scalability, more expansion, but it's also incredibly bullish for Ether, the asset. And I don't even think we've come up with a model for that yet.
1:08:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, the most bullish way to articulate this is that go to CoinGecko, filter out all tokens and only do layer one chains. And as you go down the market cap stack, think of like all of those things, those special purposes, things that those chains do, and Eigenlayer allows Ethereum to eat all of them. That's like the most bullish articulation about what Eigenlayer does.
1:09:07 Ryan Sean Adams? Yep. It's definitely possible. Crazy, right?
1:09:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:09:11 Ryan Sean Adams? All right, some takes this week, this one from Anne Olson, that's A N E dot E. May 2016, Ethereum launches on Coinbase. May 2023, Coinbase launches on Ethereum. My, how things change. This to me is a perfect-
1:09:28 Speaker 01 That deserves so much more likes.
1:09:29 Ryan Sean Adams? This is a part, well, I, look at me, I didn't even give it a like. There you go. This is the perfect articulation of the Protocol Sync thesis, I think, which is-
1:09:37 Speaker 01 Yes, it does, yes.
1:09:39 Ryan Sean Adams? Yes. The most credible neutral technologies sync to the bottom of the stack and become the basis and the foundation for everything else. Coinbase was started before Ethereum, and yet now it's building on top of Ethereum? That's incredible to me. And yeah, it, perfect articulation of what we've been talking about.
1:09:59 Speaker 01 When did we develop the Protocol Sync thesis? That was like 2019, I think, so four years ahead of it. I'm pretty sure this was one of the main articulations, he says, like, eventually Coinbase will build its own chain.
1:10:11 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah.
1:10:11 Speaker 01 And it will use its own chain to produce its products and services. That was a prediction that you and I made in 2019.
1:10:16 Ryan Sean Adams? At the time, we had no idea it would be on a layer two. The concept of layer two wasn't really-
1:10:20 Speaker 01 Didn't even matter. That is an aside detail, the idea is that protocols slip under banks. And that was the, always the articulation. And so like, this is what, this is what it means to be a thesis-driven media company. Man, yeah, sometimes, sometimes we get things right, Ryan.
1:10:36 Ryan Sean Adams? Sometimes we do. Here's something else I think we'll get right, David. This is my tweet, why don't you read it?
1:10:42 Speaker 01 Ryan Sean Adams says, "The secret to success in any bear market. One, learn. Two, build. Three, accumulate." That's it. Walk us through this, Ryan.
1:10:52 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, I think that's really your job in the bear market. You're listening, so this is a bear market for you. And you gotta do those three things. Learn, build, and accumulate. Number one, like, learn. Find people that are smarter than you in this space. Tune into informational resources that are trusted, that are long-term oriented, that have ideas and theses, and back those things up with research rather than kind of the pump and dumps. Use as many DeFi protocols as you can. Travel in a pack, in a community, rather than alone. You'll learn faster that way. Join chats, join discords. Follow people on crypto that you respect and want to learn from. That is what learn means, and you have tons of time to do that during the bear market.
1:11:34 Ryan Sean Adams? Secondly, build. This is applying your talents, your skills, whether you're a podcaster, maybe start a podcast, or come on a podcast. If you're a writer, write something. If you're an artist, create art. If you're a musician, do music. Experiment with NFTs. If you're an engineer, my god, there's so much you can do with that skill set. If you're a front-end designer, if you're an organizer, you can organize things, you can govern things. There's so much that you can do by applying your talents in this crypto space. I know, David, that's very much what you did when you kind of entered in that 2017, 2018 era. It's like, you're really good at communication, and you like talking about narratives. And so you did these things. And that progressed from kind of like, you know, part-time type work to it became your full-time gig.
1:12:20 Ryan Sean Adams? There's a massive opportunity to build. So much needs building, and so much is getting created right now, and you have the opportunity to be on the ground floor. And then third, don't forget to accumulate. Don't forget to buy. This is important. Don't forget to buy the assets that are going to appreciate if your ideas around learning and kind of the building phase are successful. You have an opportunity to get a piece of, I'll call this equity, not the Gary Gensler security equity line of thinking, but more like in the upside of this entire industry. Sometimes, David, I see people that they've been in crypto, they've done incredible things, they know all sorts of things about it, and they've built it. But they've made the mistake of not accumulating along the way, right?
1:13:04 Ryan Sean Adams? So they don't get to share with the rest of the community in that upside. Make sure you don't become one of those people. So whether that means dollar cost averaging in, again, don't risk more than you can afford to lose, but the percentage will vary depending on like who you are, your stage of life, your risk tolerance, all of these things, or lump sum. I mean, now is the time, it's still a bear market. Now's the time to accumulate. You don't want to accumulate during the top of the next Pico bowl run. You want to accumulate now. So that's it. Like anybody else who's selling you other things of like 10 secrets to getting rich on crypto in like 90 days, it's that's all garbage. Only three things you need to do. This is proven, this is tested. Everybody who's doing well in crypto that we know, David, has done these three things. Learn, build and accumulate.
1:13:48 Ryan Sean Adams? And the last thing I'll say is these things are all on you. It's stuff you have to go, you're not going to get spoon fed this stuff. You have to go pick up, take some responsibility in yourself and do it your own. There you go. This turned into, you know, RSA dad talk, but I love it. It's so important. It's so important and you have time right now. You're listening, you're here, you can go do these things, don't wait.
1:14:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'll just add, this isn't necessarily easy to do these things, but it's also not necessarily hard either. And it is fun and it is fun to do it along the way. And so like, it's just a very simple roadmap. Don't overthink it and make sure you have fun along the way.
1:14:29 Ryan Sean Adams? There you go. That's what David always reminds me of, to have fun along the way. This looks fun. I'm sorry I missed it. What are we looking at, David?
1:14:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, so we had the first ever Bankless Nation meetup. The Bankless Nation manifested in real life. Sometimes network states of what this is certainly becoming, Ryan, had manifested in real life at a brewery. Man, it was awesome, Brian. It was also packed. Look how many people there are. There was like over 150 people there. Yeah, it was, it was the
1:14:58 Ryan Sean Adams? So what's the vibe? How's the, how's the Bankless community doing? How's everyone doing?
1:15:01 Speaker 01 It was so many different people from so many different walks of life that all had like different reasons for like what, why they like Bankless and why they listen. And so like there were people from, from Asia talking about like, people from Korea talking about, hey, like I do a lot of translations of Bankless content into other podcasts and other newsletters. The Bankless Brazil guys were there. They're always, they're, Bankless Brazil is a more event than you are, dude.
1:15:24 David Hoffman? Oh, man. That's amazing. I love this guy.
1:15:27 Speaker 01 Anthony Susano was there. Yeah, we had a ton of previous guests. We had the Alfalfa Boys, my friends from, from San Diego. It was just a really cool time. I, I realized like halfway through, I was like, oh yeah, there's a microphone in the stage. I'm not used to going on a microphone alone, but like, I gotta say something. So I hopped on stage and just
1:15:46 Ryan Sean Adams? So what'd you say? You say, thanks everyone for coming?
1:15:48 Speaker 01 I said, yeah, thanks to everyone for coming. And then I kind of told the story of like, yeah, Ryan and I just started the podcast and newsletter with the intention of making content. But then we hired a few people and then, then we hired a few more. And, and then I said like, hey, if you're from HQ, everyone raise your hand. And then introduced the HQ one by one by one. And I just was able to make a big thanks to all the team that was able to support this. Cause like we, I would not, we would not be able to do organize a meetup without the actual team behind us.
1:16:15 Ryan Sean Adams? Totally.
1:16:16 Speaker 01 And so this particular East Denver is the, the event where the Bankless HQ team has showed up the most. I'm currently in an Airbnb that we're calling the Bankless Dorm. We have six or seven other people here. So we got Luke and Dave helping me record content, which is why the in real life conference interviews are going to be the highest quality, high production interviews that we've ever done at a conference.
1:16:39 Ryan Sean Adams? And even though they're there, they're still going to get you this roll up out too.
1:16:42 Speaker 01 Yes, yes. Dave's sitting right here. I'm looking at him right now.
1:16:45 Ryan Sean Adams? God bless you, Dave.
1:16:46 Speaker 01 He's looking over at me, giving me a wave. And then there's Chrissy who is handing out all the POAPS and like talking to everyone in the Bankless Nation. So this is, I think the choice, Ryan, to move beyond just a Fun little lifestyle business and grow this into what is becoming a network state of sorts. I think was a good move.
1:17:04 Ryan Sean Adams? That's really cool. I know, like, so I haven't met as many of you guys, Bankless Nation, in real life as I'd like to. But the times that I have, it's always felt like just like instant connection, like kindred spirit, like different place in the world, maybe different language, all sorts of differences, and yet we're all kind of like one group that is going west together.
1:17:26 Speaker 01 Yes, it's the most diverse group of people from all around the world, from all these various like different interests and like meaning and purpose for being here. Yet everyone just like gets along so well. It's really, really cool.
1:17:39 Ryan Sean Adams? I love it. Really cool. All right. Well,
1:17:42 Speaker 01 That's what I'm excited about.
1:17:43 Ryan Sean Adams? Is that what you're excited about? That was your, what's excited about? Okay, cool. Well, I guess, David, I'm excited about how this this bear market is shaping up. Like, I don't care what anyone says. This is my favorite bear market ever, maybe the best ever. And that's because the tourists are gone, the settlers are here, they know why they're here, we have product market fit. We're not going to run out of money this time. I think we're like fairly well capitalized. This was not the case in 2018 and 2019. The riffraff and the scammers are quiet. They're either going to jail or they fled to, you know, places where they can't get caught. And the builders are building. And I think that's what you're seeing at ETH Denver is just a whole bunch of builders getting together more than ever.
1:18:26 Ryan Sean Adams? During this bear market, they're not dismayed by what's going on. They're not put out by the regulators. They're just heads down building. And so that's why this is one of the most exciting times. Honestly, I've been in crypto and I can say that, like, I don't know. I mean, 2017 was exciting. It's kind of like discovery. 2018 and 2019 were kind of a grind of figuring this out and finding product market fit. 2020 was exciting because it felt like some of the thesis was coming true. 2021, ah, things were starting to go off the rails.
1:19:00 Speaker 01 First half of 2021 was great. Second half of 2021 was a slog.
1:19:03 Ryan Sean Adams? Totally. And then 2022, I was just like, it sucked. I was very disappointed with 2022 and all the shenanigans that went on. 2023, it's feeling like it's shaping up to be my favorite year in crypto yet because we got the settlers. We got the product market fit. We got a little bit of money. We got funded. And so now we can head west and build out this movement and be ready for the next wave of adoption. So that's what I'm excited about this week.
1:19:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, the only thing bad about 2023 is Gary Gensler, but there are so many ways to turn that evilness that Gary Gensler is bringing to us into something like really, really good. Like we're banding together. We're learning to fight in Capitol Hill. And I think there's a way to make lemons out of lemonade.
1:19:48 Ryan Sean Adams? He's gonna level us up, man. It's one boss. It's not the final boss still, but it's a boss fight. And so, okay, bring it. Let's do it.
1:19:55 Speaker 01 And like everything else in crypto is coming together. Yeah.
1:19:57 Ryan Sean Adams? Yep. David, meme of the week. I haven't seen this yet, but I did see the parent tweet. So this was you and Anthony Sisano. It says, caption this. That's David in his jacket and Anthony, you guys together at ETH Denver. So I think we're about to look at a caption. Yeah?
1:20:12 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yeah. So this is the third time I've met Anthony Sisano in real life. Like I first saw him at ZK Day and gave him a big hug, but then had to run off. I was like, oh, that's one of my best friends I haven't seen in so long, but I gotta go talk to this person. But then I gotta come back to him. But it's just like so fun, like how casual it is like, oh, Anthony in real life now. But it's always so good to see him. So we took a photo and I put out this caption, this header on the photo. And we're about to look at the winner.
1:20:38 Ryan Sean Adams? This is the winner. Okay, let me look at this.
1:20:42 Ryan Sean Adams? This is Gimli, of course, Lord of the Rings. Thank you. You told me I'd like this. Never thought I'd die fighting side by side with an elf. That is Gimli saying this.
1:20:51 Speaker 01 And of course Gimli is of course Anthony because of, you know, the beard, the big, big beard.
1:20:57 Ryan Sean Adams? I get it. Well, you guys are not opposing tribes. You guys are same tribes. So you're both dwarves.
1:21:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, but we're just super snarky with each other. Yeah, we're like brothers who fight all the time.
1:21:06 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah. All right. Gimli and his brothers. He has a lot of big dwarf family.
1:21:10 Speaker 01 I'm like a loss and he's Gimli.
1:21:12 Ryan Sean Adams? That's awesome.
1:21:13 Speaker 01 I'm an elf, apparently.
1:21:14 Ryan Sean Adams? Of course you'd want to be Legolas. I understand that. Sorry for that, Anthony. David loves you though.
1:21:20 Speaker 01 Well, Anthony was a big fan of this response as well.
1:21:24 Ryan Sean Adams? That's good. All right, guys, that's been it. The ETH Denver edition. I guess next week we'll be talking a little bit about ETH Denver too, but David's getting ready.
1:21:32 Speaker 01 The conference is actually starting right now. I am literally about to run off to Shelling Point to give my talk and then ETH Denver conference for the rest of the day. So you boys gotta leave.
1:21:42 Ryan Sean Adams? Yeah, we'll get some content to you guys though, pretty soon. So you'll feel like you're there. Risks and disclaimers, gotta let you know, none of this has been financial advice. It never is. It's not legal advice either. Who knows what a security is? I don't even think Gary Gensler knows.
1:21:54 Speaker 01 I have no idea.
1:21:55 Ryan Sean Adams? Crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the Bankless journey. Thanks a lot.
1:22:04 David Hoffman? Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to Bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast and community as a Bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks and exclusive content, and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless premium subscriber today.
1:22:41 David Hoffman? Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, Ask Me Anythings and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the Bankless nation.
Previous Ledger CTO on How NOT to Lose Your Crypto Next 160 - The Smart Money is Here with Eric Peters Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated