Skip to content

Sofia Franklyn on Call Her Daddy and the Decision That Changed Everything

Aspire with Emma Grede

Hosted by Emma Grede

1h 6m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode features a candid discussion about building a podcast empire, navigating high-stakes negotiations, and the painful rupture of a major business and friendship partnership. The guest reflects on leaving the hit podcast Call Her Daddy in 2020 after explosive contract disputes with Barstool Sports, the reality of working without a formal partnership agreement, and releasing a tell-all memoir titled Daddy Issues. The host draws on her own experience going into business with a best friend at age twenty-six, comparing strategies on contracts, equity, and intellectual property while examining how fame and money alter relationships.

  • Always put a formal partnership agreement in place with business partners from the beginning. 18:41
  • Fame and money do not change people fundamentally, but rather amplify who they already are. 23:07
  • Never accept a business clause containing perpetuity without fully evaluating its long-term impact. 33:14
  • Do not rely solely on outside experts or legal advisors when your gut tells you otherwise. 59:50

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Episode Introduction and Sponsorship

    Emma Grede introduces the episode, the guest, and the sponsor, setting the stage for the conversation.

  2. 3:52
    Sophia Franklin’s Early Career and Podcast Genesis

    Sophia discusses her finance background and how she envisioned starting a podcast before meeting Alex.

  3. 6:20
    Business Partnerships and Friendship Dynamics

    Emma shares her experience partnering with a close friend, highlighting the importance of contracts and clear roles.

  4. 11:12
    Negotiating the Barstool Deal and IP Concerns

    Sophia explains the early Barstool contract, the IP implications, and the feelings of being undervalued.

  5. 12:00
    Closing Reflections and Final Thoughts

    Emma wraps up the episode with final reflections, encouraging listeners to consider the complexities of fame and business.

  6. 38:42
    The Breakdown of the Partnership and Betrayal

    Sophia details the deterioration of her friendship with Alex, the betrayal, and the emotional toll of the fallout.

  7. 42:19
    Lessons Learned and Advice for Future Partnerships

    Both hosts reflect on what they would do differently and offer guidance on navigating business with friends.

  8. 54:59
    Choosing Thoughtful Gifts at Macy's

    Emma discusses how to pick personalized gifts for women, emphasizing consideration over size.

  9. 56:25
    Legal Advice Gone Wrong in a Public Scandal

    The conversation shifts to a legal battle where poor counsel led to a damaging public narrative.

  10. 59:44
    The Power of Listening to Your Gut

    Emma and Sophia explore trusting intuition over external legal or publicist advice.

  11. 1:01:11
    Silence Over Litigation: A Strategic Choice

    Sophia reflects on choosing silence instead of suing, leading to her book project.

  12. 1:02:21
    Rebuilding Trust and Self-Confidence

    Discussion on regaining self-trust after public backlash and learning from failure.

Highlights

  • 3:52

    Starting Out in Financestory

    The guest explains how she ended up working a mundane finance job in Utah while dreaming of moving to New York and starting a podcast.

  • 5:08

    Manifesting the Podcastinsight

    After sitting in a cubicle doing mundane paperwork, the guest used manifestation techniques learned from her father to visualize living in New York and hosting a show.

  • 8:48

    Explosive Initial Growthdata

    The podcast scaled rapidly, reaching two million listeners per episode within two months and sparking nationwide college fanatical devotion.

  • 12:06

    The First Contract Termsdata

    The co-hosts signed an initial agreement with Barstool Sports for seventy-five thousand dollars the first year without fully understanding intellectual property rights.

  • 16:10

    Realizing the True Valueinsight

    The co-hosts realized they were vastly underpaid when executives and founders publicly noted that their podcast was funding the entire company's payroll.

  • 29:54

    Staging a Podcast Hiatusstrategy

    To force management back to the negotiating table after being stonewalled, the co-hosts took the bold and aggressive move of stopping production.

  • 34:13

    Leveraging Penn National Purchaseinsight

    The guest recognized immense leverage during negotiations because Penn National Gaming was acquiring Barstool while their show generated top revenue.

  • 37:53

    The Breakdown of Truststory

    Despite believing they were aligned, the guest describes discovering behind-the-scenes betrayals and unreturned calls as the partnership collapsed.

Quotes

  • “I think a good negotiation is when both partners come to like a mutually advantageous place, right?”
    Emma Grede · 14:57
  • “We didn't talk about who is better at what, who's bringing what, how much is that worth?”
    Unnamed speaker · 13:32
  • “The second that Barstool reached out is when I knew we had something. And then right away, I understood that there was money in it at that point.”
    Unnamed speaker · 7:09
  • “We didn't, we, we straight up didn't. Everything was together, you know?”
    Unnamed speaker · 13:23
  • “You have to actually understand what your gut instinct is because it's, it's your collective experience, right?”
    Emma Grede · 1:00:14
  • “I will say, I, looking back, think staying silent was the smartest fucking thing that I did.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:01:11
  • “I found myself in various moments, writing, when I was writing the book, drafting it, wanting to prove people wrong.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:07:40
  • “I don't think someone has to be a winner and a loser.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:02:09
  • “Like, gut isn't like some weird chemical that like bubbles around.”
    Emma Grede · 1:00:20
  • NerdWallet 1:19–1:53
  • Stars and Honey 1:53–2:47
  • ZipRecruiter 35:03–35:46
  • Our Place 36:03–37:00
  • Ladder 53:44–54:59
  • Macy's 55:18–56:20

About this episode

Sofia Franklyn co-created Call Her Daddy in 2018. Two years later, a contract fight with Barstool ended her partnership, and the show kept going without her. Six years on, she's telling her side of the story in her new memoir, Daddy Issues. In this conversation, Emma walks Sofia back through the deal, from a $75,000 first contract to the fight over who owns the IP. They get into what Sofia would do differently, and how she learned to trust herself again after losing control of her own story. Emma also shares how she went into business with her close friend too, and the protections she put into writing from day one. In this episode, you'll learn: Why the one thing to get in writing before going into business with a friend is a partnership agreementHow to weight a partnership by what each person brings, so it holds up when your lives changeWhy "in perpetuity" should stop you cold in any contractWhen to get a second opinion, even from advisors with big namesHow to stop measuring your success against someone else'sDaddy Issues is out now, wherever books are sold.

Transcript

0:00
1:06:56

11,967 words · 7 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Barstool
  • Call Her Daddy
  • Daddy Issues
  • Odyssey
  • New York
  • Sophia with an F
  • Smart Money Podcast
  • Always Pan
  • Utah
  • Capri

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated