Pod Insights Articles of Interest School Uniforms About this episode How uniforms shaped the American school system. Images and a very special animation at articlesofinterest.substack.com https://articlesofinterest.substack.com/
Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices https://dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Avery Trufelman? When I first met you, when you came up to me after a talk I gave and pitched this story idea, in my mind, and you can correct me if I'm wrong here, you were wearing like fuzzy leg warmers and a little skirt. Does this sound right?
0:16 Speaker 01 That is close because I do remember exactly what I was wearing because I thought about it. I had this fuzzy knit skirt and a trench coat. And I think I was wearing really tall boots.
0:30 Avery Trufelman? Okay, you have a very unique sense of style.
0:33 Speaker 01 Well, thank you.
0:34 Avery Trufelman? Which is all just framing to say I'm kind of surprised you grew up with a uniform.
0:37 Speaker 01 Yes, my name is Grace Tarducci. I am an independent filmmaker and animator and a former Catholic school student. So I went to Catholic school from kindergarten to 12th grade. And my style identity was very closely tied to my personal identity at the time, which was definitely like rebelling. And so I was pretty good at experimenting with what was technically within the bounds of the dress code as was written, but was still pushing it too far.
1:20 Avery Trufelman? You can't have been the only one messing with the, the whole thing is like Catholic schoolgirls roll up their skirts. Like surely everybody was doing this.
1:27 Speaker 01 Yes, obviously. That is a typical thing to do. Everyone pretty much does that. And I would very much over accessorize my uniform, like wearing a lot of jewelry or trying to get away with patterned tights. And I would dye my hair a lot and heavy makeup, you know, peace, love and rock and roll over here. And they really did not know what to do. Like I was getting in trouble so much. They hired a dean of discipline at the school and they said that was partially because of my uniform infractions. And the first thing that he ever had to do formally at the school
2:08 Speaker 01 was take me aside into a room and tell me I had to dye my hair to a natural color.
2:14 Avery Trufelman? What color was it?
2:16 Speaker 01 It was red and it wasn't even that bad. Like I've had purple hair before. It was red and I was very offended and I wrote a speech about it.
2:27 Speaker 01 I said in my essay that I felt like that was patronizing to us, that we wouldn't be able to do our schoolwork because someone had red hair. I remember feeling offended by that language.
2:41 Avery Trufelman? Okay, so the only thing more classic than like being a Catholic schoolgirl and rebelling against the dress code is then participating in the argument about the dress code.
2:51 Speaker 02 I think Grove should dump the uniforms and we have casual dress all year round.
2:54 Avery Trufelman? It's in The Princess Diaries.
2:56 Speaker 01 I feel like I was actually thinking about Princess Diaries because they had a really similar dress code to us in that movie.
3:01 Speaker 03 What's my point again? You like our uniforms. They're equalizers.
3:05 Avery Trufelman? It's just like such a classic debate question.
3:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't know. I mean, perhaps it's a common trope because teenagers in general are rebelling and questioning these pretty arbitrary rules that have been set by adults that we're now realizing are flawed, right?
3:26 Avery Trufelman? I didn't grow up having a uniform. When you said your uniform is like the Princess Diaries uniform, immediately my thought was like, oh, cute. Like, I love it. I was always so jealous of people who wore uniforms. I think that uniforms are fundamentally pretty great, and it's a lot of other stuff that society has put on uniforms that need to be removed. But the clothes themselves are like a wonderful idea.
3:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, totally. But no.
3:53 Avery Trufelman? No. After the break, Grace and I explore the uniform. Sure, the question of whether to have a uniform or not to have a uniform, but really to talk about how the idea of school uniforms came to impact American public education.
4:10 Speaker 04 Hey there, it's Robyn from PRX. If you're a longtime listener of Radiotopia, you may know that we had a podcast that ran from 2016 to 2020 discussing every episode of the show The West Wing. Well, I'm excited to tell you The West Wing Weekly is back. Joshua Molina, who starred on The West Wing as Will Bailey, and Rishikesh Hirway, creator and host of Song Exploder, have reunited to discuss the hit Netflix political thriller The Diplomat. Just as they did in their original run, they're discussing each episode of the series in sequence, joined by special guests from the show and from the real world of diplomacy. Rishi and Josh will be wrapping up the first season with a special live taping at Union Chapel in London on November 14th. Subscribe now to The West Wing Weekly wherever you get your podcasts.
4:56 Speaker 05 I have no issues with the uniforms and everything.
4:58 Avery Trufelman? Really?
4:59 Speaker 05 Like, you know, I've always had issues with being confined to a box.
5:02 Avery Trufelman? So I had the chance of talking to the designer Prabha Gurung.
5:05 Speaker 05 I'm Prabha Gurung. I am a fashion designer.
5:08 Avery Trufelman? Big deal designer, dressed all kinds of amazing celebrities.
5:12 Speaker 05 Oprah, Michelle Obama, Sarah Jessica, Kate Middleton. It's amazing. I'm grateful for that. It was my impossible dream to become a designer.
5:20 Avery Trufelman? He grew up in Nepal.
5:22 Speaker 05 Living back home in Nepal where those dreams about fashion was not only ridiculous, but was impossible. The thing about Nepal is it is a really beautifully mystical, magical place. When you're growing up, if you were someone like me who had this ambition and desire to push myself, it was really like confining.
5:42 Avery Trufelman? He went to a Catholic school in Nepal. What was the uniform you had to wear at Xavier's?
5:47 Speaker 05 Confining, restrictive, boring.
5:50 Avery Trufelman? What?
5:51 Speaker 05 Yawn inducing. I'll just put it this way. So I'll explain. White shirt, navy blue trouser with a navy blue blazer with gold buttons, black shoes. And it was so boring. It really felt like, where am I? Am I ever going to be able to shine? I could see my mother transform herself with the red lipstick and the bindi and the tikka and all of that stuff. And I was like, can I be like that too?
6:16 Avery Trufelman? When Prabha Gurung was growing up, he was teased pretty mercilessly for being gay. But he would watch his mom do her makeup and put on saris. And sometimes she'd say like, do you want to try it on?
6:29 Speaker 05 I would nod my head vigorously. And listen, I think she probably let me because I think she knew I was how troubled I was. So whatever joy I could derive from anything, she allowed me.
6:39 Avery Trufelman? And so he understood how good it felt to wear beautiful clothes, just at home. He couldn't really go out in them.
6:45 Speaker 05 I was simply fascinated by the colors, the ruffles. And I trying on my mom's sari or bangles, which were massive on my tiny hand. But the jangling of the sound.
6:55 Avery Trufelman? He was just like, I love clothes. I love the way this feels. And he even said he would see the Catholic schoolgirls like rolling up their skirts and be like, that looks fun. I want to do that.
7:05 Speaker 05 As they leave their house, it gets rolled up. My was like, if they're allowed to do it, why not me?
7:10 Avery Trufelman? But there really wasn't any culture of pushing back from the boys. And so he quietly had an alternative version of his uniform made.
7:19 Speaker 05 I had it made. I was like over the holiday.
7:22 Avery Trufelman? It was like a similar color of the shirt, but it felt really nice on his skin.
7:28 Speaker 05 It almost was like silk and everyone else was cotton. And I was like, it was notorious. I used to get in trouble all the time. And towards the end of it, I started wearing blue eyeshadows and wearing mascara. I was just like, you know, listen, I'm getting bullied. I'm getting no matter what. I was just like, fuck it, you know, I'm just gonna go full on. I don't even care.
7:45 Avery Trufelman? But I asked him, so it sounds like you weren't that into uniforms. He was like, oh, no.
7:49 Speaker 05 I'm glad I did.
7:50 Avery Trufelman? Really?
7:51 Speaker 05 Yeah, I'm glad I did because it allowed me to really explore the possibility of defining how I present myself to the world. It really taught me the idea of rules, regulations, and how far I can push it and how far I can't. It really defines who I am as a person now. I understand the value of uniform, like I get it. When I think about it, not everyone in that school came from wealth and access. So uniforms, sometimes it is an equalizer, but let's not be fools.
8:22 Avery Trufelman? You can't hide the fact that we live in an unequal society.
8:25 Speaker 05 Even as kids, we know who's rich, who's not. We pretty much know by the shoes that they wear, by the pen that they write with, the food that they bring, the water bottle they carry. So we know who's rich and who's not.
8:37 Avery Trufelman? But I still say, if you can limit the factors that create an unequal society in school, why not? I don't know. I just felt like in school, everything was a competition, like looking at who had what pencil case or who had what pants. And it's like, okay, I'd rather it only be about socks or barrettes or like whatever tiny thing. I know that it's not gonna make the issue go away. It's deeper than that.
9:01 Speaker 01 Sure, yeah, let's limit the factors because kids are horrible anyway, right? So like if we have less things to bully each other about, maybe that's a good thing. But then my question to that would be, why does it look like this then? I'm gonna give you two pictures, okay? And I want you to describe. What the person is wearing in these pictures. So this first picture is from 1971 and is of my Aunt Patty. And we went to the same elementary school, okay?
9:30 Avery Trufelman? See, I'm like, I think she looks so cute. She's wearing a plaid jumper with a white shirt.
9:37 Speaker 01 Okay, now, this one is from 2006 or 2007, and it's me. What uniform am I wearing?
9:46 Avery Trufelman? You are wearing a plaid jumper with a white shirt under it. Okay, it's basically the same.
9:52 Speaker 01 It's like the same exact thing, and it's the same colors. And we're wearing the same undershirt. It's more than 30 years apart. It's the exact same outfit. And I think that is my big why here in general. Like, why is it this like prep school, Eurocentric looking fit? That hasn't changed since the 60s. Why do we have every single kid in a polo?
10:17 Avery Trufelman? Well, it should be said that, Larry, the kids on my block, we should have walked by the school on my block. They do wear like tracksuits. So I think that is increasingly a move to have kids just wear like uniforms that are comfortable to them. But you're right, this other antiquated uniform still persists.
10:34 Speaker 01 I guess we should talk about where it comes from in the history, right? Um, you think? Okay.
10:43 Speaker 06 I was looking at yearbooks and the girls aren't wearing uniforms. And I'm like, wow, this is really weird. Like, maybe they got permission that day and they weren't, they didn't have to wear the uniforms in 1917, 1918. I'm not seeing these uniforms. And then suddenly I see the uniforms and I'm like, oh, what's happened? What's changed?
11:04 Avery Trufelman? Sally Dwyer-McMillian is a professor at Marist University, who we went to speak to.
11:08 Speaker 06 My book is Common Threads: A Cultural History of Clothing in American Catholicism.
11:16 Avery Trufelman? There's this long history in European Catholicism of sisters opening asylums and charities.
11:22 Speaker 06 Where I first saw uniforms in Catholic institutions. It had to do with charitable institutions and it was asylums and children in asylums, where parents could drop their kids off and maybe they couldn't take care of them.
11:37 Avery Trufelman? Often, these quote unquote "uniforms" were just simple dark clothes.
11:42 Speaker 06 I haven't seen many pictures of asylum children, but the descriptions seem to be more like a smock.
11:49 Avery Trufelman? Just to sort of get the kids in something.
11:52 Speaker 06 The church saw that these children need some kind of parenting and care. But they also wanted to identify these children and want to kind of mark these children, because kids ran away from these asylums as well.
12:05 Avery Trufelman? And that tradition continued in Catholic-run charities in the United States.
12:10 Speaker 06 They do open asylums for children. New York City had a really significant asylum.
12:16 Avery Trufelman? But that's not exactly a school uniform as such.
12:20 Speaker 01 The first instance of a school uniform in the United States would be in what were called "federal Indian boarding schools."
12:30 Speaker 06 A segment of sisters or priests or brothers felt as though like, okay, this is our mission. We're going to provide education to Native American kids. But at the same time, also thinking that these kids weren't capable in the same way that white children were.
12:44 Speaker 01 So these schools were implemented for the purpose of taking cultural identity away from Native children in order to Europeanize them.
12:56 Speaker 06 Stripping those Native American kids of their identity and language and customs.
13:02 Speaker 01 Their hair was cut, their traditional outfits were taken, and they were put into these militaristic uniforms that were supposed to make everyone look the same.
13:13 Speaker 06 You know, that kind of homogenizing.
13:15 Speaker 01 That's where we first see a school uniform being implemented in the United States.
13:22 Speaker 06 First, it's in charitable institutions where they're in uniforms. And then I also start to see, and I would call this more a dress code, in elite, select schools.
13:33 Speaker 07 A lot of those asylums and charities were funded from the tuitions that nuns charged to rich families.
13:40 Speaker 06 Sisters have to sustain themselves, unlike Europe, where these convents have been around for centuries. In the United States, it's just like a clean slate here.
13:51 Avery Trufelman? It's like a business.
13:51 Speaker 06 Right, yeah, that sounds like, kind of cold. But, but in a way, they have to figure out how they're gonna survive.
13:58 Avery Trufelman? Something that really defines the American Catholic school movement is this like need to make money.
14:03 Speaker 01 Well, these are proto-Catholic schools, right? Because they're not what we think of as Catholic schools now. So what you're referring to are the convent schools. It was just a very highbrow education for upper-class, privileged girls. They were run by nuns, and they had a dress code.
14:20 Speaker 06 We don't have the technology to really create a uniform, right?
14:25 Avery Trufelman? I mean, this is so like, duh, but we take it for granted. The idea of a uniform relied on mass-produced clothing. That, it was almost impossible for uniforms to actually be uniform in the days before you could just buy something ready-made.
14:40 Speaker 06 Everyone's going to their tailor. But they had specificity, even a swatch of fabric that you would take to the tailor, and they have to adhere to that. So this one, this 1899.
14:52 Avery Trufelman? It's just so not what we would think of as the archetypal Catholic school uniform.
14:57 Speaker 06 So she has a, it's a full, black skirt gathered at the waist, and then she has long sleeves.
15:04 Avery Trufelman? I like a wicked witch of the West Halloween costume.
15:07 Speaker 06 Wicked witch of the West, yes, that's a tongue twister.
15:12 Speaker 01 They were more similar to what you would imagine a nun wearing than what you would imagine like a Catholic school girl wearing now.
15:20 Speaker 06 And they seemed to me to really prioritize, emphasize dark hues so that the students wouldn't display materialism vanity. And the sisters kind of have their eye on someone who might join the religious order.
15:35 Avery Trufelman? What was kind of like preparing girls to like go into that life?
15:39 Speaker 01 There was an element of that. However, it was also a way of these sisters to gain funding for their convent.
15:49 Speaker 06 How will these elite schools, which again are supporting the sisters, going to remain open?
15:55 Speaker 01 And one of the ways they did that was with a very specific uniform. So they're really identifiable as Catholic schoolgirls.
16:03 Speaker 06 And so having this special uniform that sets them apart is a mark of their distinction and class, too, because this isn't crappy fabric. This is very nice clothing.
16:16 Avery Trufelman? But Catholic schools, as we know them now, didn't really proliferate until public schools did. And in America, it took a surprisingly long time for public schools to get started.
16:27 Speaker 07 The early, our founding fathers, whatever that means, but our founding fathers, like Jefferson and Benjamin Rush and even George Washington, they all talked about, like, we need public schools.
16:39 Avery Trufelman? I spoke to this historian and policy expert named Rachel Lissy. She was saying that from the very founding of the American experiment, our founding fathers always wanted to make a public school.
16:54 Speaker 07 But it didn't happen. The reason it didn't happen in the 18th century is because there wasn't like the political will for it. So the earliest schools in America were these sort of local schools that were referred to as district schools and parents would pay.
17:10 Avery Trufelman? You used to have like a one-room schoolhouse, this journeyman teacher who would like go from town to town. He would teach your kids to read. Public education didn't happen, basically, until Catholics started coming to the US.
17:25 Speaker 07 The shift comes in the mid 19th century towards publicly funded schools. It wasn't really about academics. It was much more this idea that there were huge waves of Irish immigrants coming into America. And so we needed to create these public schools in order to Americanize all of these foreign-born, immoral folks coming from outside.
17:48 Avery Trufelman? I think it was also this idea of keeping away the threat of monarchy that came from Catholicism.
17:54 Speaker 07 Public schools could accurately be described as Protestant schools.
17:59 Avery Trufelman? When you think about it, the project of teaching children to read is a Protestant one.
18:05 Speaker 07 So that they can read the Bible is a very Protestant idea because the idea is like, we don't want you listening to the priest or the pope. Each individual student needs to have their own relationship with the Bible and with God that then is going to shape their moral behavior. So we need to not just intervene between these kids and their parents, but between these kids and the pope.
18:26 Speaker 06 Then the bishops decide that they don't want Catholic kids to be reading the King James Bible in the public school. They're concerned about paying taxes that go to these schools.
18:36 Speaker 01 The Catholic hierarchy demanded that Catholic children in the United States must have a Catholic education.
18:44 Speaker 06 There is a requirement. It's passed, it's the Third Plenary Council in 1884, where they determined that they're going to open their own schools.
18:52 Speaker 01 So this is why the parochial schools pop up and they're associated with the parish that you're a part of, which would be your church.
18:59 Avery Trufelman? So it's not like an elite school. It's like, okay, you have to pay a little extra money, but it's still pretty affordable.
19:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, these were largely affordable because the sisters were doing free labor.
19:09 Avery Trufelman? And from the beginning of both the public school system and the Catholic parochial school system, the metric of success was not which system made smarter students.
19:21 Speaker 07 As schools were forming, the debates about how to shape behavior were much more intense than the debates about what kids were actually going to learn. Like, it was like, eh, they'll learn to read, they'll learn numbers. That wasn't the big focus.
19:33 Avery Trufelman? It was about which school system made better Americans.
19:38 Speaker 07 It was also about teaching them the skills they'll need to fit in the economy in the right way. So they'll need to learn how to delay gratification and control their impulses.
19:46 Avery Trufelman? Dr. Lissy told me that the idea of responding to bells is good preparation for future factory workers. That's so nuts, like that we had to run from classroom to classroom at the sound of a bell.
19:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's really funny. And like probably adhering to like really rigid schedules too.
20:01 Avery Trufelman? And meanwhile, on the Catholic side.
20:04 Speaker 06 There's a uniform. There is expectation of behavior and order and discipline.
20:08 Avery Trufelman? According to Professor Dwyer McNulty, there's this idea that Catholic schools have to prove that they can make their kids as well behaved, if not better behaved, than public school students. And so they decided to do what the elite convent schools once did, which is have all the students in uniforms, which promoted their values of modesty and propriety.
20:31 Speaker 06 The bottom line is Catholics in America are the minority and they're the cultural minority, although there's lots of Catholics. So you weren't outfitting the elite Catholics. You were outfitting the daughters of the workaday Catholics. And so you had to make something that was presentable, economical, and that you could manufacture a huge amount.
20:56 Avery Trufelman? So Catholic schools turned to uniform manufacturers like Victor Eisenberg.
21:01 Speaker 06 Victor Eisenberg had also been involved with the military. He had made police uniforms.
21:08 Avery Trufelman? It should be said that Victor Eisenberg is a Jew. Jews ran the schmatta business. I just think it's so funny how much of Guaisha American culture like we made.
21:17 Speaker 01 So this man had a monopoly on development of the Catholic school uniform because there weren't so many places you could get a uniform.
21:26 Avery Trufelman? Shrewd businessman that he was, Victor Eisenberg, would create these multi-year contracts. And it was really smart.
21:33 Speaker 06 That is a contract that just, those uniforms really don't change for years and years.
21:40 Avery Trufelman? Those early mass-produced uniforms were basically like white blouses with simple, solid jumpers. And they were cut like sacks. They were really simple clothes that were easy to churn out. And boy, does Eisenberg churn them out.
21:54 Speaker 06 One of the reasons I think that things take off after World War II is that you get this visual explosion, right? You have the camera and you have pictures in the newspaper and magazines.
22:04 Avery Trufelman? It became this trope of like the gaggle of Catholic schoolgirls like taking the bus to school.
22:08 Speaker 06 And suddenly Catholics are seeing each other and orders are seeing each other and saying, oh, this is what is happening.
22:15 Avery Trufelman? Catholic clothing started to cohere into an identity. And by the 1960s, that identity was plaid.
22:23 Speaker 01 A lot of these parochial schools are Irish Catholic. That could have been a reason for the plaid, but also that it was just a popular trend in US culture at that time was the plaid. But I believe that the plaid becomes more prominent in the 60s because of a man whose name I always butcher because it's kind of weird, but Benninger.
22:46 Avery Trufelman? Benninger, Benninger.
22:47 Speaker 01 I was saying Benninger.
22:49 Speaker 06 George Bendinger. It's a different uniform company and that's a decision to move in the tartan or plaid direction.
22:57 Speaker 01 This guy developed a genius plan of creating an individual tartan for every school. So you could show off what specific parochial school you went to through your uniform.
23:12 Avery Trufelman? And by the end of the 1960s, Catholicism is increasingly something that Americans want to show off.
23:19 Speaker 01 Catholics, specifically like Catholic school kids, were really prominently displayed in the media as a way of fighting communism.
23:27 Speaker 06 If communism is Godless, then uniforms are full of God.
23:31 Speaker 01 And like, obviously communist Russia was secular, right?
23:35 Avery Trufelman? Yeah, it's this idea of like, we have religious freedom. Like, we let these Catholics be here.
23:39 Speaker 06 And so something that happens that historians have identified is that where Catholics had kind of been on the margins of society, they were cultural outsiders, they become cultural insiders in the Cold War period.
23:53 Avery Trufelman? Around this time, Kennedy is about to become president, a Catholic president. It's starting to become clear that maybe Catholicism is not so much of a threat to the American project.
24:03 Speaker 07 There's a sense of like, we'll look to the parochial schools, look how orderly.
24:06 Avery Trufelman? It's kind of like they had won the discipline wars.
24:09 Speaker 07 Right, like, look how disciplined and obedient the kids are in those spaces.
24:13 Avery Trufelman? So then public schools got to thinking, hmm. Uniforms.
24:17 Speaker 07 We should be doing it more like that.
24:19 Avery Trufelman? Especially because increasingly, public schools were starting to be seen as chaotic.
24:25 Speaker 07 And then, as there becomes more and more concern about school disorder, which is a side note, is really often just channeling anxiety about social change. And then the threat becomes much more like non-white, particularly black or brown, children.
24:39 Avery Trufelman? And the school uniform arises to combat this so-called threat. The question is, how legal is it? Is imposing a uniform, or even a dress code, a suppression of free speech? Really? After the break.
24:59 Avery Trufelman? In the early days of the American public school system, there was this big question around discipline. How will we make the children behave?
25:07 Speaker 07 Horace Mann is like, "We're not going to use the crude instruments of corporal punishment, but scientifically, that's not how you shape kids' behavior."
25:16 Avery Trufelman? Dr. Rachel Lissy, once again.
25:18 Speaker 07 It starts even in the earliest public schools. There was a sense of like, the best way to shape behavior is through relationship. And this aligns with the feminizing of teaching, I should also just say. But if we have these female teachers that are like mommies to their classroom, kids will not want to disappoint their mommies. If every classroom has a female teacher who we can pay half as much, so it's very convenient, then kids will want to please them, and that's how we'll create order in the classroom.
25:41 Avery Trufelman? By this logic, no one would think that you could punish a kid by kicking them out of school.
25:47 Speaker 07 Why would you suspend a kid? Because then you're removing them from the supervision of this system.
25:52 Avery Trufelman? Right, you'd be casting your child out.
25:53 Speaker 07 Exactly, exactly, right? So that we have this responsibility, and we should be, if anything, we should be institutionalizing the kid. We should be increasing our control over them, not relinquishing it.
26:03 Avery Trufelman? And then there was this massive shift.
26:05 Speaker 07 In the late 1950s, early 1960s, where we shifted in both our policy and our rhetoric, so I really focus in on a set of incidents that started with this incident in 1957.
26:18 Avery Trufelman? Okay, so this happened in New York, in a public school.
26:23 Speaker 07 Where a kid who was 17 years old, he was actually truant at the time. So he didn't, wasn't enrolled in any school. He had recently returned from a psychiatric facility. But he goes, he's been having some issues with another student outside of class. And he goes into this kid's classroom in his school in Brooklyn and he throws a bottle of lye.
26:41 Avery Trufelman? And he threw it on this other kid's face.
26:45 Speaker 07 It nearly blinds this kid. It splatters on other kids and burns them. Two teachers go to help. They also get injured as well.
26:52 Avery Trufelman? This kid's name was Maurice Kessler and the incident was largely known as the Kessler Lye Incident.
27:00 Speaker 07 It gets picked up by the Southern press. And the Southern press comes out and they say, do you see what's happening in Brooklyn? That's what happens when you try to integrate.
27:08 Avery Trufelman? And the Kessler Lye Incident became this massive blow up because the kid in question, Maurice Kessler, was black.
27:16 Speaker 07 And the kid that he attacked was white.
27:18 Avery Trufelman? And it gets written up in all the papers. The South is like, see, we know how to run our schools just fine. Like, we don't have these accidents. So this is a New York story, but really this is a national story because everybody is really glomming onto what's happening in this liberal hotbed.
27:35 Speaker 07 I think there's something unique about the sort of New York and the national imagination, so to speak. They're not actually concerned about what's happening in the New York City public schools. They want New York to look bad. And so this becomes a way to not only be like, disorder is because of schools, not because we've created this unjust system and there's lack of support in housing and the segregation and it's nothing to do with those things. It's because the school is incompetent and also this is about crime. This isn't just childish misbehavior.
28:00 Avery Trufelman? And so this case gets put before this judge named Samuel Lebowitz.
28:08 Speaker 07 Like, this kid had really bad luck. Judge Samuel Lebowitz was like a real larger-than-life personality.
28:14 Avery Trufelman? Who has been waiting for a case like this, has holding down life. Like, he is a really charismatic guy with a lot of thoughts.
28:20 Speaker 07 Just basically talking about how the city's approach to juvenile delinquency is psychiatric mumbo jumbo and it's like the soft in the head of the approach and it's coddling kids. And what kids really need is like a return to good old fashioned hierarchical discipline. You know, he says like the strap, they need the old strap behind the woodshed.
28:39 Avery Trufelman? This is when we get the policy of widespread.
28:45 Avery Trufelman? Sometimes, causeless suspension.
28:49 Speaker 07 So the suspension policy change that happens following this unwanted kind of national attention, the Board of Ed says, "Principals, you can suspend kids. Just send them home. We'll figure out what to do with them later." At the time, this seemed like totally crazy to people. They were like, "Why would you kick kids out of school?"
29:06 Avery Trufelman? Right. We're trying to get them to school.
29:07 Speaker 07 Right.
29:08 Avery Trufelman? But this is going to be really important to the idea of how schools function.
29:14 Speaker 07 And in the, basically, the beginning of 1958, a year after this terrible incident happens, this suspension policy is made permanent. And the superintendent comes out and he makes this announcement. He says something like, "It's important that a principal have the authority to say to a youngster, 'Young man, you get out of here. We cannot have you disturbing the other youngsters.'" You see this, like, real sense of, like, we're not talking about children. It's these almost adults and this very punitive idea of, like, "Some kids are good, some kids are bad."
29:41 Avery Trufelman? It starts to become more and more normal to just kick kids out of school. It's sort of the origin of, like, "Oh, there are bad apples in these, in these schools."
29:50 Speaker 07 And this shift towards criminalizing is counteracted by a shift towards having a clear codification of students' rights. There's parts of it that sort of kick off in response to Vietnam and also, like, civil rights protests, but it was this idea of, like, "I can wear an anti-war symbol and I have rights to do that." The kind of classic, like, it's like a uniform thing, too, with Tinker and Des Moines.
30:14 Speaker 01 There's this case, Tinker versus Des Moines, wherein a young teenage student wore a armband, a black armband, to school to protest the Vietnam War, to show mourning for the people that had been lost in the Vietnam War on both sides.
30:34 Avery Trufelman? It's a public school?
30:35 Speaker 01 Yes, this is a public school district. Her name was Mary Beth Tinker.
30:41 Avery Trufelman? Yeah, you met Mary Beth?
30:42 Speaker 01 Yes, yes. I was really shy. I was 13 years old. I was nervous and scared the day that I wore a black
30:48 Speaker 04 Black armband at school, but it was part of a group project called Islands for Peace.
30:54 Avery Trufelman? Mary Beth Tinker was one of a number of students in her Des Moines Public School who were going to wear these black armbands to advocate for peace. And it didn't seem like there was anything against their school dress code in that.
31:05 Speaker 04 Because they allowed black armbands in the Des Moines schools if you were sad about the football game.
31:11 Speaker 01 Very importantly, in this case, the armband was not a distracting feature added to her clothing. It didn't have any text on it even. There was nothing disruptive about this form of protest. It was very understated.
31:27 Speaker 04 But then the principals heard about it and then they made a rule against black armbands.
31:32 Speaker 01 All the students that wore the armband to school were suspended.
31:36 Speaker 04 Five kids were suspended, but I learned a lesson. Even if you're shy and scared and even sometimes you might back down, you can still make a difference because here we are still talking about it 55 years later.
31:49 Speaker 01 So this was an infringement on these students' right to free speech, right? So with the help of the ACLU, they sue the school district because of this suspension. And they won.
32:05 Speaker 04 So in the Tinker ruling, the Supreme Court said, yes, you have free speech rights in public school, but you cannot substantially disrupt school.
32:12 Speaker 01 So this both opened the door to set a precedent for what students have the right to do, but then also kind of opened a door for schools to be like, okay, we're going to have overarching rules.
32:28 Speaker 07 We're happy to work with you on laying out these students' rights, but we also want to be able to lay out these responsibilities. And the responsibilities is what becomes elaborated into this discipline code.
32:37 Avery Trufelman? And when I was talking to Rachel Listie, she showed me this code of conduct that applies to a lot of New York public schools. And there are two pages of like students' rights and then 40 pages of things you're not allowed to do.
32:49 Speaker 07 It's like 40 pages of this like very like minutia of discipline code.
32:53 Avery Trufelman? And this represents another deep philosophical change in the way that American public schools are administered. Teachers basically exchanged being in loco parentis for bureaucracy.
33:07 Speaker 07 There's one way of understanding this, which is like students clamored for this. They wanted codes. Parents wanted to be able to say like, "Why are you suspending my kid?" And they wanted more bureaucratic ways of saying, "It's because they violated this thing," rather than a more amorphous, "They misbehaved."
33:21 Avery Trufelman? In some ways, it's easier. Instead of being like, "Well, because I said so." Or like, "I don't like that." You can't be a parent anymore. You have to cite Article 112 in the rulebook.
33:30 Speaker 07 So like, "Hey, don't blame me. I'm not a parent. Just look at the code. And the code, it will tell you what they did."
33:36 Avery Trufelman? Does it say anything about clothes in the code?
33:38 Speaker 07 It sure does. "Wearing apparel that is unsafe or materially disruptive to the educative process."
33:46 Avery Trufelman? Hmm, a little subjective.
33:47 Speaker 07 So that is infraction number eight. And this is 2001. This is a low-level infraction. This is a Level 1 or 2, but one of the things in all of these codes is that multiple Level 1s and 2s can become Level 4s and 5s. So if you repeatedly have the issue, over time, that becomes a thing.
34:09 Speaker 01 Obviously, this creates so many levels of consequences and is one of the reasons that we have the school-to-prison pipeline in the United States. School-to-prison pipeline has become a very popular term, but essentially, it talks about a collection of punitive rules that discipline kids for what is deemed improper behavior, but really just pushes them into a system in which these sort of punitive rules become the norm. I talked to Dr. DeWitt Scott, who is based in Chicago. My name is DeWitt Scott. I am the Director for the Angelina Padrillo Center for Diversity in Indigenous Cultural Affairs at Northeastern Illinois University.
34:51 Speaker 05 In Chicago. So I always felt that mandating uniforms, particularly in public schools, has never really been the answer.
34:59 Speaker 01 We can see this sprouting a lot from the policies created in the 90s.
35:05 Speaker 02 The President of the United States.
35:08 Speaker 01 So in 1996, President Clinton gave an address in which he offered uniforms as a potential solution to violence in public schools.
35:18 Speaker 02 I challenge all our schools to teach character education, to teach good values and good citizenship. And if it means that teenagers will stop killing each other over designer jackets, then our public schools should be able to require their students to wear school uniforms.
35:34 Avery Trufelman? I mean, it is bonkers to dedicate time in the State of the Union to school uniforms.
35:40 Speaker 01 This creates a wave of schools implementing harsher dress codes and eventually, public schools implementing uniforms.
35:48 Speaker 05 Instituting the uniforms just overall didn't achieve what Clinton felt it would achieve. I think it gave schools another reason to penalize students. You have students who would get penalized for not having the right shirt, not having the right belt, not having their shirt tucked in, not having the right shoes, not having the right colored shoes. It created another door for more rules.
36:10 Speaker 01 Even what Bill Clinton said specifically is very racialized. And the places where these uniforms are implemented are largely in black communities.
36:23 Speaker 05 There was a charter school. I'm not going to name the school, but it's a prominent charter school in Chicago. I'll say that much. I don't know if they do this now, but this had to be 10 years ago. If a student was out of a uniform, then they got a financial penalty, a dollar for the wrong shirt, five dollars for no belt, so on and so forth. I had a nephew who was at that school. And at the end of the semester, he had a $600-plus bill. His mom couldn't pay him. This becomes tuition.
36:50 Avery Trufelman? I feel like that also goes back to the other thing Bill Clinton said in that paragraph, which actually, I'd never read the full speech, but he's talking about charter schools.
36:59 Speaker 02 I challenge every state to give all parents the right to choose which public school their children will attend and to let teachers...
37:05 Speaker 01 New schools with a charter they can keep only if they do a good job. Yeah, totally. I think that when you see kids in uniforms, they're usually charter school kids, specifically in New York.
37:17 Speaker 07 In the early 2000s charter school ed reform, one of the ideas was every parent gets to pick the school that's the right fit. And so this is a way of marketing.
37:28 Avery Trufelman? Almost in the same way that Catholic uniforms first came about as like marketing.
37:32 Speaker 07 You know, especially in charter schools where they're not just relying on public funds, but they have to get funders. If you're a funder and you go into a building and you see all these kids in these cute little bow ties, that feels good. It sort of goes back to this American tradition of, it's almost like the Native American boarding schools, making kids all look in a way that makes middle class values feel right and comfortable. You've taken all this chaos and you've turned it into this order. You must be doing good work here.
37:59 Avery Trufelman? And the message became that if you don't want a uniform, parents, maybe your kids just shouldn't go to this school.
38:06 Speaker 07 Because if you really don't want the uniform, this is just not the right fit. And what we want their parents to recognize is they should go back out into the marketplace and shop someplace else. But each school does not have the responsibility to be able to teach every kid that walks in the door. They only have the responsibility to teach the kids that are the right fit. And uniforms becomes one way of filtering. If you're not organized enough to make sure you have the uniforms and you get here on time, then you're probably not the right fit. This is a very classic charter thing is like, we're suspending kids because it's not the right fit.
38:38 Avery Trufelman? So like, when we talk about school uniforms, we're talking about a really broad swath. And they can definitely be wielded as punishment.
38:46 Speaker 07 I think that they are pretty superficial and very racialized and class-based.
38:52 Avery Trufelman? But I also think that, and Rachel Listig said as much, she was like, if the school has a good culture, if it is a place that people are excited to be a part of, they can function like team uniforms.
39:03 Speaker 07 I think if you have a good, strong culture already, and you've done all of that work, uniforms can help in strengthening that identity and that culture.
39:11 Avery Trufelman? Like, people can be really amped on their uniform. There are schools that love... Their uniforms, which is why I also think that like a cute uniform is kind of important, that it's not just like, shut up, sit over there, wear this bland shirt. And it just seems like the common thread throughout all of this is like, no one asked the kids.
39:31 Speaker 01 That's exactly what Mary Beth Tinker said as well.
39:33 Speaker 04 I think it should be up to students, how the dress code is expressed in their school, and that students should have some say. So students, I think, should be on the school boards. They should be voting members. They should be in the administrative committees of their schools.
39:51 Speaker 01 Children should have a voice. They have their own opinions and their own thoughts about what they want to wear. All right, hey, kids, I'm here to talk to you.
40:00 Avery Trufelman? Grace intrepidly went to talk to some real life high schoolers.
40:04 Speaker 03 I like the uniform. It's really easy to decide what I'm going to wear in the morning. I don't mind it. It's, no, it's fine. I wish that we only had one skirt so we didn't have to buy twice as many skirts. That's my main complaint.
40:15 Speaker 02 Would I rather wear sweatpants and a sweatshirt every day? Absolutely, but, you know, it's fine.
40:19 Avery Trufelman? And these high schoolers actually go to Grace's own high school.
40:23 Speaker 01 Wow, this is so nice. Oh, my gosh, this was my Latin room.
40:27 Avery Trufelman? So tell me about going back to Aquinas. What was it like?
40:30 Speaker 01 It was really weird, obviously, because it's my high school.
40:36 Speaker 04 I found it interesting that you were doing a piece on school uniforms because you always had your creative flair.
40:44 Speaker 01 And I'm talking to my principal, who I will never call Leslie.
40:49 Speaker 04 My name is Leslie Mitros, and I was head of school for the last 20 years here at Aquinas Academy in Pittsburgh. And we have learned some things along the way, Grace, that's for sure.
40:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, it sounds like things have changed in a very positive way. The uniform did, in fact, change a lot. Like, I was required to wear a blazer in high school. And now, instead of the blazer, they have a quarter zip.
41:16 Speaker 04 The girls in particular didn't love the blazer. So I said, well, why don't you write me a proposal?
41:22 Speaker 02 For something that's an alternative. And so they did their research and they were actually the ones who proposed that sweater.
41:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, it's so far from what we would have been allowed to wear in high school when I was there. And they're way less strict about the accessories.
41:37 Speaker 02 I can't think of the last time we were splitting hairs over earrings or even the number of piercings. You'll see that when you walk around, there's a lot of individuality there.
41:45 Speaker 01 When I was in school, they had a lot of problems with the way that they were enforcing the uniform. Specifically that the girls felt really uncomfortable. It made you feel like you were being looked at in a way that was inappropriate.
41:58 Speaker 02 The hardest part of it, to be honest with you, Grace, is that none of us are in the business of liking to embarrass kids. But at some point, they need to kind of get that message that it's got to be. It's got to be right. It's a place of work and we want to keep that in the front of their mind, that when they come in the door to go to school, they're here for a reason and it's to do the best they can academically.
42:23 Avery Trufelman? And I guess this is where I come down with it is like, no one should be punished so severely for what they wear. I don't think accessories should be illegal. I don't think hair color should be illegal. I don't think it's about quashing expression. But I do think it's like a laboratory to practice speaking up and to practice having these debates. And like, I know we kind of joked in the beginning that maybe these things exist only to be debated, but I kind of think that all of this comes back to this notion of debate, not only because the uniform is such a classic debate, but that everything should be up for discussion. The uniform should be up for discussion. I think it was Dr. Scott who was like, you don't just fix it and move on. Thinking about school uniforms, thinking about all of these policies, there
43:07 Avery Trufelman? never be a day where it's like, okay, great, that's done. They're addressing these questions. We're bringing new questions, right? You have to continue. You just have to revisit it. I don't know anything of significance in this world where it's just you get to a point and you stop. That's what it is to live in a society and to go to a school.
43:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I will say having to wear a uniform my whole life definitely shaped my style and my identity.
43:35 Avery Trufelman? Especially because like, look, you're wearing a version of a school uniform right now. Did you do that intentionally?
43:40 Speaker 01 Yes, so for as much as I hated my school uniform, I did want to dress as close to it as possible today. As you can see, this is my actual vest from from school. So it has the school emblem on it. Oh, my God. It's so cute. Like, it's stylish, while the vest is, right? So there are all kinds of tips and tricks on how to make your uniform cuter.
44:12 Avery Trufelman? Thank you so much to Grace Tarducci. What a dream to work with. Thank you for embarking on this project with me. Grace, as she mentioned, is an animator. See all of her animation at gracetarducci.com. And she made a little custom animation of all of the different uniforms throughout time. Like, her work is so great. You can see that animation at articlesofinterest.substack.com. Many thanks as well to my fearless script editor, Allison Behringer. Thank you for putting your eyes on this. It's so good to work with you again, buddy. Thank you so much also to Debbie Schaefer Jacobs at the Smithsonian. Your research was invaluable to this project. And thank you also to Prabha Gurung. What a dream to be able to interview this visionary designer.
44:57 Avery Trufelman? His story about Catholic school uniforms is just one of the many incredible tales of his life that you can read in his memoir, Walk Like a Girl by Prabha Gurung. It's out now. I can't recommend it enough. He's had an incredible life. Also, huge thanks to our friends at American Public Media, APM. We worked with them on making a version of this show for kids. If you are a kid or you know a kid who is... Thinking about uniforms or have questions about where uniforms come from. The show is called Forever Ago and it's really fun. It tends to be focused on younger kids, like this kid Hannah, who I'm obsessed with.
45:36 Speaker 03 I think it's helpful to have a uniform. You don't need to decide what to wear. You don't need to be made fun of or asked why you're wearing that.
45:45 Avery Trufelman? I love Hannah. Ugh, so that show is called Forever Ago. Check it out. And I'm gonna make like two more episodes over the summer. And then in the fall, there'll be another proper season. So, thank you for your patience, everyone. All your messages about like, when are you coming back? They're so, I mean, they stress me out, but they're really sweet. So, thank you very much. It's nice to be back making podcasts. So, thank you for listening.
Previous The Memory Palace Next Sunglasses Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated