Pod Insights Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard Steven Pinker Returns (on common knowledge) About this episode Steven Pinker (When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life) is a cognitive psychologist, psycholinguist, and author. Steven returns to the Armchair Expert to discuss how in general things have gotten better, that tracking the data can make one more optimistic than reading headlines, and the differences between private knowledge and common knowledge. Steven and Dax talk about how evolved language generates common knowledge, the role of conventions and ritual in human coordination, and the power of Super Bowl advertisements. Steven explains the counterintuitive fact that announcing one’s philanthropy actually does more good, why we have to expose ourselves to a universe of ideas to find out which ones are good, and why he’s not afraid of AI.
Follow Armchair Expert on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. Watch new content on YouTube or listen to Armchair Expert early and ad-free by joining Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting wondery.com/links/armchair-expert-with-dax-shepard/ http://www.wondery.com/links/armchair-expert-with-dax-shepard/ now.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 24,827 words · 6 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Dax Shepard? Welcome, welcome, welcome to Armchair Expert Experts on Expert. I'm Dan Shepard and I'm joined by Lily Padman.
0:05 Speaker 01 Hi.
0:06 Dax Shepard? We have one of the world's great thinkers among us today.
0:09 Speaker 01 We do.
0:09 Dax Shepard? He really is one of my favorite. He's like, you know, he's regarded, of course, as being one of the smarter people on the planet. He's a Harvard professor. Uh, but he's, he's so optimistic. I rely on him to like, reset my pessimism.
0:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, but he, as he says in here, he doesn't phrase it that way.
0:26 Dax Shepard? He doesn't.
0:27 Speaker 01 But I agree with you. It sparks hope.
0:29 Dax Shepard? Steven Pinker, he's an award-winning experimental cognitive psychologist, bestselling author, and Harvard professor. His books are Rationality, Enlightenment Now, that's a great one, The Blank Slate, The Sense of Style, and his new book, When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. This was a brain twister.
0:52 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. Also, um, this has sort of reshaped a little bit of the way I think about some things. And I think it might for other people, too.
1:01 Dax Shepard? Yeah, yeah.
1:01 Speaker 01 It's really interesting.
1:02 Dax Shepard? It is. Please enjoy Steven Pinker. We get support from Quince.
1:08 Speaker 01 Okay, can we talk about the fact that the holidays are already here? It's crazy. I feel like I blinked and now we're in gifting season, which I'm not really mad about because I do love giving gifts. And Quince is making it so easy to find something great for everyone on my list, including myself, because let's be honest, self-gifting is a love language.
1:27 Dax Shepard? Quince is seriously the gift that keeps on giving. Their high-quality staples are made with premium materials like 100% Mongolian cashmere, 14-karat gold, and Italian leather. Full-on luxury quality at prices that won't wreck your holiday budget.
1:43 Speaker 01 It's the dream. The cashmere sweater, starting at $60, down jackets, wool outerwear, cashmere accessories, you and everyone on your list are staying cozy and looking incredible all season long.
1:54 Dax Shepard? Well, I'm gonna tell you this, it just got chilly for the first time this year in California, and I'm so excited, and I'm wearing my Quince cashmere right now.
2:01 Speaker 01 It's great.
2:02 Dax Shepard? Yeah, and I am going to gift this to some of my friends. I hope they're not listening.
2:06 Speaker 01 Quince is also more than clothing. They've got fine jewelry for your significant other, leather bags for your bestie, hotel-quality bedding to set up your guest rooms, chef-grade cookware. That's an amazing thing they offer here. And it's such a good gift because people don't like buying cookware for themselves, but it's very important. And they also have five-star luggage, another good gift that people don't like buying for themselves.
2:29 Dax Shepard? Give the gift of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK, too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was Armchair Expert. It's the best way to support the show. This episode is supported by Helix.
2:54 Speaker 01 Okay, can we talk about how November is basically survival mode? Between the holidays, the travel, the hosting, the cooking, the everything. Sleep is the one thing keeping me from completely unraveling.
3:04 Dax Shepard? It really is the foundation. And I think people underestimate how much a bad mattress is quietly ruining their day. You wake up stiff, your back's angry, you're already behind before your feet hit the floor.
3:15 Speaker 01 That was me before Helix. I took their sleep quiz, which is so fast. It took me like two minutes. And they matched me to a mattress that actually fits how I sleep. Not a guess, not a firm or soft coin flip. It's a real match. I have a midnight mattress and I really like it. I was noticing it because I actually had to sleep in one of my other beds.
3:33 Dax Shepard? Okay.
3:33 Speaker 01 Recently.
3:33 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
3:34 Speaker 01 That doesn't have a Helix mattress on it. And I really could tell a big difference in my sleep.
3:38 Dax Shepard? Temperature was all over the map.
3:39 Speaker 01 It was a mess.
3:40 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
3:40 Speaker 01 I need a new one.
3:41 Dax Shepard? Look, they've got over 20 mattress models. So whether you sleep hot, need extra back support, or you've got a partner who moves around all night, there's one built for you. Plus, free shipping and a 365-night Happy with Helix guarantee. That's a full year to decide.
3:56 Speaker 01 Helix has been named the most awarded mattress by Forbes, Wired, and more. So it's not just us being enthusiastic. The experts agree.
4:02 Dax Shepard? Right now, Helix is running their Black Friday sale with up to 30% off. Go to helixsleep.com/armchair for up to 30% off your Helix mattress. That's helixsleep.com/armchair for up to 30% off your Helix mattress. Helixsleep.com/armchair.
4:38 Speaker 02 Hello. Sir. Nice to see you in person this time. Yes, great to see you. Thank you so much for having me.
4:43 Speaker 01 Hey, so happy to have you back.
4:44 Speaker 02 Thank you. Well, then this time you really are having me back.
4:46 Speaker 01 I know. It's much better in person.
4:49 Speaker 02 But last time, I think it was Delta or Omicron, that COVID was still happening.
4:52 Speaker 01 Yeah.
4:53 Speaker 02 And you were gracious enough to allow me to do it remotely. Yes. Here we are, happy to be here.
4:58 Speaker 01 The real thing.
4:59 Dax Shepard? In general, do you like going on the road?
5:01 Speaker 02 Almost every author bitches about book tours, but I figure, you know, I spent all this time writing a book, people want to hear about it. How can I complain about that? I like the fact that people are actually interested in all the work that I did.
5:12 Dax Shepard? How long did you end up in Berkeley? Because the last time we talked to you, you were on sabbatical in Berkeley.
5:15 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, I was there for a year.
5:16 Dax Shepard? Had you spent that much time there ever before?
5:19 Speaker 02 Not in Berkeley. I'd lived in Palo Alto for a year. I was a professor at Stanford early in my career, and I spent a sabbatical in Santa Barbara. So I spent more than three years in California.
5:28 Dax Shepard? I had a sabbatical in Santa Barbara, too.
5:29 Speaker 02 Okay.
5:30 Dax Shepard? I was going to Santa Barbara City College.
5:32 Speaker 02 I didn't know that. Okay.
5:33 Dax Shepard? Yes, went there for a year and then came to LA. So I was just in Nashville for the better part of the last three months.
5:41 Speaker 02 Building or?
5:41 Dax Shepard? No, we built a house there and hoped to retire there and be on the lake. I was already suspicious of this, but I was also delighted to experience it so palpably, which is just three months there was very helpful in me looking at LA from the outside, kind of understanding where people are coming from with their different political things. Like to step out of your culture bubble is pretty profound. I mean, you're going from Harvard to Berkeley, so it's not like...
6:08 Speaker 02 It's the same thing.
6:09 Dax Shepard? There's no Mason Dixon line being crossed. But did you feel like you got understanding of anything in that year there? You're like, I see where this is coming from.
6:18 Speaker 02 Well, partly was exposure to the Berkeley granola culture. As one friend put it, everyone looks like they've just come back from gardening.
6:25 Dax Shepard? Yes, yes, yes.
6:26 Speaker 02 But also there's the rationality community, which Berkeley is kind of the epicenter. And I wrote a book called Rationality.
6:33 Dax Shepard? That's right.
6:33 Speaker 02 But also being exposed to some of the Silicon Valley people, they've acquired a pretty bad reputation, especially in the last eight months.
6:40 Dax Shepard? Yes.
6:40 Speaker 02 There actually was something refreshing about the old can-do spirit. I talked to them about carbon capture or planes that would run on synthetic fuels or even on solar power and... Kind of a dreamy, far-off look would go in their eyes and they try to imagine how to make it happen.
6:55 Dax Shepard? Yes.
6:56 Speaker 02 Instead of complaining about how we're doomed and how everything is corrupt, they're, at least some of them, trying to solve problems. That was refreshing.
7:03 Dax Shepard? It's still fertile ground for optimism.
7:05 Speaker 02 It is, yeah.
7:06 Dax Shepard? People do feel very empowered to fix things. Did you get any perspective looking back towards Boston?
7:12 Speaker 02 The mindset that problems are solvable, that you don't just moan about what's going wrong, but you try to fix them using human engineering. Now, there's a lot of that at Harvard, especially at MIT, my previous academic home. But in the general intellectual culture, it's much more, let's bemoan everything that is going to hell. There was some refreshment there. Although, when I was there, there was already a concern about the reactionary turn that a lot of Silicon Valley people were taking. The neo-reactionary movement.
7:41 Dax Shepard? What's that?
7:42 Speaker 02 Traditionally, people in Silicon Valley were centrist, mildly libertarian. There has been a kind of lurch toward, this is gonna sound weird to say it, toward monarchy and religion.
7:53 Dax Shepard? Kind of totalitarian.
7:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, as opposed to the liberal democracy, which is not sexy, it's not revolutionary, it's not exciting.
8:01 Dax Shepard? Right, it's not disruptive enough.
8:03 Speaker 02 Disruption can be a good thing if you're improving stuff, but if you're thinking about how to make us lurch back to the Middle Ages, not so much. And I think part of it is there is such a reaction to wokeness, such a recoil.
8:14 Dax Shepard? Yes.
8:15 Speaker 02 That people are kind of springing away from what they see as the excesses of the left, but ricocheting all the way to the right. If the left likes it, then it must be awful. Partly exaggerated by the fact that a lot of the cultural mainstream went really anti-tech. Tech became the villain.
8:32 Dax Shepard? Kind of replaced bankers.
8:34 Speaker 02 Yes, exactly.
8:34 Dax Shepard? Yeah, we used to hate people in finance.
8:36 Speaker 01 You think that's just on the left, or do you think everyone had to sort of anti-tech?
8:41 Speaker 02 Well, you're right. There's also a tech lash from the right as well.
8:45 Dax Shepard? They fit perfectly two archetypes. Like, if you're on the right, they represent the swamp and the conspiracy of who's running everything. They're actually really running everything. And then, if you're on the left, you don't trust any corporation intrinsically, and if they have a lot of power, then, you know, they can fill a lot of buckets.
9:04 Speaker 02 I met with some people like Mike Brock, who is one of the tech entrepreneur and former CEO, who basically left to blog full time about what he early on spotted as a threat to ideals of liberal democracy, coming from a neo-reactionary in Silicon Valley. He was ahead of his time because we've now seen, particularly with Elon Musk, at the time it was Peter Thiel, a lurch from people who used to be pretty centrist, eclectic, to highly ideological.
9:32 Dax Shepard? Yes. Now, what do you think's driving that particular niches, perhaps belief? I mean, I guess it seems very intuitive that perhaps they don't think the masses should be trusted with decisions because they're not quite as smart as they are.
9:48 Speaker 02 Yes.
9:49 Dax Shepard? Do you think that's the underpinning of that?
9:51 Speaker 02 There's some of that.
9:51 Dax Shepard? Like, I try to wrap my head around how someone would go like, you know, the best move is one single person making all the decisions that can't be challenged. That seems so antithetical to reason.
10:00 Speaker 02 This entire country was founded on refuting that idea?
10:03 Dax Shepard? Yes.
10:04 Speaker 02 Because we tried it, it was called monarchy, it didn't work out so well. You know, democracy, as they say, the worst form of government, except for all the other ones that have been tried.
10:12 Dax Shepard? Right, right, that's fair. Well, what I always appreciate about you, and while I'll always need a dose of you if ever you want to come, is I am drawn to the optimists. I'm a bit cynical and skeptical, and so I really need you. There's a handful of you. I think you're very much an optimist. The ideals of the Enlightenment that you explored, and if we look at them from the long arc, they're kind of coming true. I like that message. I think Yuval's also a really good person in the intellectual space that's kind of optimistic. And then Bill Gates of all people.
10:43 Speaker 02 Absolutely, Bill Gates. There's a website, Our World in Data. Proprietary is Max Roser, that I rely on. And with me and with Our World in Data, I'd say it's not so much optimism in the sense of putting on a happy face, rose-tinted glasses, seeing the glass is half-full. I think there's a role for that, because it gives you the gumption to actually try to solve things with some confidence that you might succeed.
11:04 Dax Shepard? Yeah, the right amount of delusion could be helpful.
11:06 Speaker 02 Or even when you have uncertainty, you should know that within the realm of reasonable possibility is success. That's what makes it worthwhile. And how do you know? Well, our ancestors were faced with pretty big problems and they solved a lot of those. So why will we be the first generation not to solve any of the problems facing us? But you know, it's not really optimism. It's really more just attention to facts, to data that you don't get from the news. Cause the news concentrates on what happened yesterday. And anything that happens suddenly is almost certain to be bad, or at least way more likely to be bad than good. Cause things can go to hell very quickly.
11:40 Dax Shepard? Yeah, rainbows are rare. You don't get the sudden really great thing.
11:44 Speaker 02 But you know, good things tend to build up a few percentage points at a time and they can compound and transform the world. Or there are things that don't happen. You don't see a headline about a region of the world that isn't having a war. You know, like Vietnam, for example. For those of us who grew up during the Vietnam War, that would have been huge news. No war in Vietnam for decades. Nah, you're a dreamer, you're a utopian. But of course, no war in Vietnam isn't a headline. No war in South America, et cetera. So what Rosling does, what Our World in Data does, what I try to do is show you the things you can't get from the headlines, like plotting deaths in war over time, plotting how long people live, how many mothers die in childbirth, how many kids die, how many kids go to school. And you see, there was never a Thursday in October in which it generated a headline.
12:28 Speaker 02 But if you look at the trends, it shows that we really are better off than people before us.
12:32 Speaker 01 And still, right? Still since the last.
12:35 Speaker 02 So I try to update it with swallowing hard, gritting my teeth. Because you know, I read the headlines too. There's a lot of bad stuff happening. Not everything gets better all the time. It couldn't, that would be a miracle. So war deaths have shaved off a couple of decades of progress in year 2024, last full year for which we have data. It kind of sent us back to the nineties. Things definitely got worse. People think, oh, that must be because of Gaza. It's actually much more Sudan, also Ukraine, and a bunch of other conflicts. Syria? Syria in its time was one of the worst. So if you look at the curve, World War II, it was just literally off the charts. Let's even start the clock in 1946. So even then it goes down. In the last few years, it's crept up a bit. Still not like it was even in the eighties. The seventies, the sixties, the fifties.
13:18 Speaker 02 So there has been progress, but not a miracle. It's not inexorable. It doesn't happen by itself. It happens because people rack their brains to try to solve problems. They don't always succeed, but sometimes they do succeed. So just the mindset of let's look at the data. Sometimes we'll find things are getting worse because sometimes things do get worse. Sometimes they get better. And by and large, in general, almost everything has gotten better.
13:40 Dax Shepard? They tend thus far to be blips rather than patterns, right?
13:44 Speaker 02 When you're in the middle of one, you never know.
13:45 Dax Shepard? Right, but I look at the homicide rate during COVID. It spiked and it got a little scary, maybe even doubled in some places. And in a sense now fallen and rejoined the initial curve.
13:55 Speaker 02 That's exactly what happened. And so one of the graphs that I plot is American homicide rates. In the nineties, there was the Great American Crime Decline, where violent crime fell in half in some places like New York by three quarters. And then it fell again in the two thousands. And then it shot up in 2020.
14:12 Dax Shepard? And it left everyone scrambling for the explanation and everyone claimed it. Whether it was the broken windows theory or it was the stop and frisk theory. Or Dubner, was it abortion being legalized?
14:24 Speaker 02 I look at all those hypotheses and we don't know for sure. I think some are more plausible than others. But what you're saying is right. In that case, it was a blip in that I was getting really nervous like, damn it. What are the trends that I was really happy about?
14:35 Dax Shepard? Throw this book away.
14:36 Speaker 02 That a U turn. Yeah. But you turned at a U turn. So we don't know whether it's a blip or a new normal of war deaths. Again, back to the nineties, not back to the eighties, seventies, sixties, fifties. There's a huge war that everyone forgets about between Iran and Iraq, sometimes called the idiot war, where probably 800,000 people were killed, maybe close to a million in the eighties. People forget about that. Anyway, going back to the theme, some things have gotten somewhat worse. Another thing is democracy. The world got more and more and more democratic. Then about 10, 15 years ago, it kind of leveled off and went down a bit. Better than it was in the eighties, seventies, sixties, but not going in the right direction. Is this a blip? Will the momentum reverse? We just don't know. But some things do reverse. So updating my graphs, COVID screwed up a lot of them.
15:21 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
15:21 Speaker 02 Not surprisingly, but since the vaccines ended COVID and the immunity, the world has. Gone back on track on all the positive trends. And so we're actually at global records for GDP per capita. That recovered longevity that recovered after taking a dip. Extreme poverty and those are like really important. They affect billions of people.
15:40 Dax Shepard? Yes.
15:41 Speaker 02 We are, even after the COVID hit, better off than we ever were in history of the world. I like thinking, I think, is not so much optimism, but just tracking the data. And that makes you more optimistic than if you're reading the headlines, especially. And I'll bring in a little cognitive psychology here because it's my field. But there's a bias called availability, namely if there's an image, if there's a narrative that is available in memory that you can retrieve on demand easily. Because it's so vivid, it's so salient, it's so gory, so recent. That tends to distort your subjective feeling of risk or estimates of danger.
16:15 Dax Shepard? Right, like if you were mugged last night, you have a different perspective on the crime rate.
16:19 Speaker 02 Especially who's you, but even if you read about someone who was mugged or you read about a guy eaten by a shark on Cape Cod, then everyone stays away from the beach, even though there's, you know, one death in a century. Every year, people get killed in car accidents on their way to the beach.
16:35 Dax Shepard? Yeah, by the dozen.
16:37 Speaker 02 So that's a distorter. That's in general, the story that I like to tell, let's try to follow the data, not the headlines.
16:45 Speaker 03 Yeah.
16:45 Dax Shepard? OK, so this current book, it's immediately confusing, which you immediately start to unwind. But what we would call common knowledge is not what you would refer to as common knowledge.
16:56 Speaker 02 Yeah, sometimes the professors, the mathematicians, the scientists will glom onto a word. It's a little bit misleading, but that's the thing about words. Once they stick, they stick, they get grandfathered in, there's nothing you can do about it. That's just what they're called.
17:09 Dax Shepard? That's right. Awful is your example in the book.
17:12 Speaker 02 So, yeah, awful does not mean filled with awe. It used to.
17:14 Speaker 03 Right.
17:15 Speaker 02 Yes. Terrific doesn't mean worthy of terror or causing terror.
17:19 Dax Shepard? And tough shit. We're here now and that's what it is.
17:22 Speaker 01 Incredible, I guess, same thing.
17:23 Speaker 02 That's another one, yeah.
17:24 Dax Shepard? Uh huh.
17:25 Speaker 02 Common knowledge in the technical sense is, I know something, you know it, I know that you know it, you know that I know it, I know that you know that I know that you know it, having an item. So that's common knowledge.
17:35 Dax Shepard? But that takes a minute to really, like, you can say it, I read it, but you really need the diagrams and you really need to think about all the implications of that. So knowing that Stephen and I both know there are lights in here.
17:48 Speaker 02 Yes.
17:49 Dax Shepard? Give us some examples of this difference between private knowledge and common knowledge, because it's kind of fascinating.
17:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, so private knowledge is when everyone knows something, but no one knows that anyone else knows it.
17:58 Speaker 01 Oh.
17:58 Speaker 02 Common knowledge is when everyone knows something and you know that everyone knows it, and you know that.
18:03 Speaker 01 Right.
18:04 Speaker 02 Now, it sounds mind boggling, like, how could I know that you know that? I mean, you start to get confused. It's even used as a source of humor in some cartoons and sitcoms.
18:12 Dax Shepard? Well, give her Seinfeld, because.
18:13 Speaker 01 Well, friends, I know it.
18:15 Speaker 02 Everyone has told me about that episode. They don't know we know they know we know.
18:19 Speaker 01 That's right.
18:20 Speaker 02 And then Rachel says, Joe, you can't say anything. And he says, I couldn't even if I wanted to.
18:26 Speaker 01 Oh, what a show.
18:27 Speaker 02 That captures the idea. So that has four levels of thoughts within thoughts.
18:30 Speaker 01 Right.
18:30 Speaker 02 When it gets to three, it starts to get hard. When it gets to four, it's almost impossible. So what am I talking about?
18:37 Dax Shepard? I think another great example of it is rock, paper, scissors. When you're playing rock, paper, scissors, and this is terrible, I'm assessing how clever I think my opponent is right away. And I think if they're just baseline clever, there is something that feels sturdy about rock. It feels powerful. If you're someone who doesn't do any thinking, you're really prone to throw rock. It just feels stable. I know you're smart, and so you've probably assessed that I'm gonna go for that, and so you're gonna go for paper. So if I think you're smart, I'm gonna go paper. So I generally, if I'm with someone who's smart, will start with scissors. We've gotten to three steps, and four, I think, is a lot for someone.
19:17 Speaker 02 There you go. So that's a great example of. Thinking about other people thinking, the fancy schmancy term is recursive mentalizing. Mentalizing means mind reading, getting inside someone else's head. recursive means you try to get inside the head of someone who's trying to get inside someone's head.
19:33 Speaker 01 Mmm, my god.
19:34 Speaker 02 That's a great example, rock, paper, scissors.
19:36 Dax Shepard? Yeah, also the great scene in Princess Bride about drinking the poison. Do you remember that whole thing?
19:41 Speaker 02 Yes, yes.
19:42 Dax Shepard? But you would have known I would have put the poison. He's giving himself an immunity to the poison. They were both poisoned.
19:47 Speaker 01 So are you saying it's what you just did is private knowledge?
19:51 Speaker 02 Yes.
19:51 Speaker 01 Right, that would be private knowledge.
19:53 Speaker 02 So, common knowledge is, if you were to say, "I'm gonna play rock," that would kind of defeat the purpose of that game. It is a kind of recursive mentalizing, get inside one another. The optimal strategy when you're playing it is to be totally random. Just have a perfect random number generator in your head, unless you can capitalize on some tell or some habit in the other person. It's called an outguessing standoff. There are other examples, like in hockey. Say at a penalty shot, the stick handler tries to guess where the goalie's gonna be. The goalie guesses where the shooter's gonna shoot, looking for a little tell in the other. And actually, it's one of these cases where randomness is rational. If you're predictable, then you're a sitting duck. Right. What would be then common knowledge, though, is you blurt something out.
20:37 Speaker 02 So if something is public, if it's out there, if it's visible, that generates common knowledge without you having to think through all the layers. You just intuitively know it. And I think that's what makes common knowledge so potent in human life. It's not so much that we can do the rock, paper, scissors, or they don't know that we know that they know that we know. We do do that, up to a certain point. But when something is just conspicuous, self-evident, public, out there, that's what generates common knowledge. So that's why certain public things make such a difference, even if everyone knew it the whole time. Conversely, it's why sometimes we try to keep things out of common knowledge, even if everyone knows it. There's a big difference between everyone knowing it
21:21 Speaker 02 and everyone knowing that everyone's knowing it. And that's why we ignore the elephant in the room. We use euphemism, we pretend not to know, we look the other way. And that's a big effect in human life and in politics.
21:32 Dax Shepard? The emperor has no clothes is great. We all know that colloquially, but just walk through the basic steps of it.
21:39 Speaker 02 So the thing about the story of the emperor's new clothes, it is a story about common knowledge. Probably the most famous, because when the little boy said the emperor was naked, he actually wasn't telling anyone anything they didn't already know. They could see the emperor was naked, but he's changed their knowledge nonetheless. He actually was adding to their knowledge.
21:58 Dax Shepard? But the steps are important. So people are noticing the emperor has no clothes on. And they are presumably too nervous to say anything.
22:03 Speaker 02 And they've been told, anyone who can't see the splendid garments in different versions of the story has been cuckolded, is a heretic, is not very smart. So they've been intimidated. If you accept the story, they did doubt it, they could see it with their own eyes. They wondered, you know, are they crazy or am I crazy? When the boy blurted it out and everyone could hear him, that gave them common knowledge. And crucially, here's the other part of the story that is why I began the book with it. That common knowledge changed their relationship. And the reason that I think common knowledge is so important in just everyday social life is that our relationships depend on common knowledge. In the case of the story, it is instead of obsequious deference to the emperor, now it was ridicule and scorn.
22:48 Dax Shepard? His days are likely numbered once everyone recognizes we've been asked to participate in this lie.
22:53 Speaker 02 There you go. So the reason that common knowledge was of interest to so many academic fields, logic, economics, philosophy, political science, is that a lot of large-scale social phenomena that depended on it. Like money, what makes a greenback valuable? It's just a piece of paper. It's you know that other people will accept it. Why do they accept it? Because they know that still other people will accept. Everyone knows that everyone knows it has value. That's what gives it value. Conversely, when that common knowledge disappears, which it can, you get hyperinflation and it really can become worthless. And there are other examples, political protests, crashes, bubbles.
23:30 Dax Shepard? You say this is why autocrats hate any public demonstration. Because what it's letting everyone else know is you're not alone in this assessment of our leader.
23:38 Speaker 02 Not only are you not alone. But in addition, everyone knows you're not alone.
23:44 Dax Shepard? So now it buffets your confidence to also speak up.
23:47 Speaker 02 Exactly. Now you have safety in numbers, you coordinate. And the coordination is kind of the magic word in the book. Because what common knowledge is necessary for is coordination. People doing things on the same page that benefit them both. Without common knowledge, you might know and she might know. But if you don't know, she knows you know, then you still might miscoordinate. So for example, just even something like a rendezvous, ending up at the same place at the same time. Let's say you both want to get together for a coffee. Your cellphone goes dead. Well, you can't just guess she likes to go to Starbucks. Because she might think, well, he likes to go to Pete's. And you say, OK, well, she knows I want to go to Pete's. So she's going to go to Pete's. But then you think, no, no, no. She knows that I know that she likes to go to Starbucks. So she's going to go Starbucks after all. And it's just going to be 50/50.
24:32 Speaker 02 The reason we evolved language is that it generates common knowledge. And as soon as you say, hey, let's meet at Starbucks, that puts it into it. You don't have to go through the layers. Right. You know, there are lots of cases like that. So going back to the public protest. Why do autocrats fear public protest? Why is freedom of assembly one of the fundamental rights? No dictatorship can control an entire population if the population stands up and opposes them altogether. I quote the scene from the movie Gandhi, where the character, maybe in real life, he told a British officer, eventually you'll leave because 100,000 Englishmen cannot control 350 million Indians if the Indians refuse to cooperate. That was Gandhi's big insight. But what it depends on, what will make 350 million Indians refuse to cooperate?
25:16 Speaker 02 Well, one of them can't just refuse to cooperate. Because if everyone else is, you'll be a voice in the wilderness. A public protest where you see everyone, and you see everyone seeing everyone, you realize the moment is now. Or if it's a public article that goes viral that everyone's read. I recount the joke from the Soviet era. A lot of great jokes from the Soviet era. Because it was one of the ways in which they generated common knowledge amongst themselves beneath the notice of the government of the Communist Party. But a man's handing out leaflets in Red Square. And of course, the KGB arrest him, take him back to headquarters, only to discover that the leaflets are blank sheets of paper. They confront him, what is the meaning of this? And he says, what's there to say? It's so obvious. It's a joke about common knowledge, namely by handing out the blank leaflets.
26:00 Speaker 02 He was like the little boy in the emperor's new clothes. He was conveying the information of people who accepted it.
26:06 Dax Shepard? That we're not allowed to speak freely.
26:08 Speaker 02 And that we all know that there is something to protest, that there's a basis for our grievances. In a case of life imitating a joke, Putin's forces have arrested people for carrying blank signs.
26:20 Speaker 03 Wow.
26:21 Dax Shepard? You put a passage in your book from Sapiens, from Yuval's book. And I was so glad to see that because I was already starting to think in terms of that book in that that book's kind of proprietary offering, at least on a really pop level, was we have been able to congregate peacefully because we believe in stories. And I think that's an incredibly salient argument. And I would argue your book actually then breaks down the mechanisms by which story does travel or how we buy into story. But you do make some distinctions between common knowledge and say, story just broadly.
27:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, I name check Yuval Noah Harari. The way he puts it is that human life depends on fictions, fictions like the government, the church, corporations.
27:10 Dax Shepard? They're not real.
27:11 Speaker 02 I think it's a really important insight, so I don't disagree with him. What I say is that I would put it differently. They're not exactly fictions. There really is such a thing as Microsoft.
27:19 Speaker 03 Yeah.
27:20 Speaker 02 Now, it's not stuff. It's not a particular building. Likewise, the US government or Harvard University. But they're real, even though they're not stuff. But what they are is they depend on common knowledge. What makes a leader a leader? Well, I mean, he's got the guns, but you know, as we said, no government can control all of its subjects. What gives someone power is everyone recognizes that he has power. What makes currency useful is that everyone treats it as if it's useful and knows that everyone else treats it as useful.
27:47 Dax Shepard? Right.
27:47 Speaker 02 What makes a corporation is there is a public document, a charter. There can be headquarters, but not necessarily. But everyone acts as if the company exists and that makes the company exist. So it's common knowledge. Is the way I would put it, rather than a fiction. Or conventions. A convention is a way of doing things that makes everyone better off and that exists thanks to common knowledge. A convention like driving on the right.
28:14 Dax Shepard? We were there with the coffee analogy, so let's do it there, which is you and I want to meet for coffee. We both know we have different spots. We think through who's more probable to concede to that spot. But then we might have a pre-existing convention, which might be ladies first.
28:30 Speaker 02 Yes.
28:30 Dax Shepard? Right? Like, I believe in ladies first. Or we have a convention that we go every other time.
28:36 Speaker 01 Right, right, right.
28:37 Dax Shepard? Right? So in place of saying something out loud and making explicitly common knowledge, we could have a covenant that would function as that.
28:44 Speaker 01 Some sort of ritual.
28:45 Speaker 02 Exactly. And conventions basically solve coordination problems. So, for example, what day do you stay home and read the paper instead of going to work? Sunday. Why Sunday? Well, it doesn't have to be Sunday, but as long as everyone agrees it's the same day, then it can work. Because you don't want half the people showing up to work, but then the other half staying home, and then on Thursday, it's the other way around. It wouldn't work very well if everyone picked their own day.
29:09 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
29:09 Speaker 02 If everyone picks the same day.
29:10 Dax Shepard? Productivity's only going down by one seventh.
29:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, right. And different cultures have different conventions. So in Judaism, it's Saturday, which is the Sabbath. In Christianity, it was Sunday. Now, of course, both days, we call it the weekend. It doesn't matter which days they are.
29:24 Dax Shepard? Let's hope the Muslims can get Friday, so we can have a full three-day.
29:27 Speaker 01 Three-day weekend.
29:30 Speaker 01 Would be really good.
29:31 Dax Shepard? Someone's gonna claim Friday.
29:32 Speaker 02 A wedding ceremony, when do you stop treating someone as available? A coming-of-age ceremony, like a bar mitzvah?
29:39 Speaker 01 It's true. We all just decide, once these two people stand in front of a whole group, there's an end at that point.
29:45 Speaker 02 Everyone treats them as committed to each other.
29:48 Speaker 01 Yeah.
29:48 Speaker 02 And crucially, it's another common knowledge generator. Like a public protest, like blurring something out, namely. They're up there, everyone's watching, and everyone is watching everyone watching. And it's also ratified by a ring that everyone can see. So a lot of things from your Anthro 101 curriculum, why do these cultures do these weird things? Seems to make no sense. Well, it kind of makes no sense that they're doing it that way, but it does make sense that they're doing it some way, and they all agree on what that way is.
30:16 Speaker 03 Uh huh.
30:17 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
30:17 Speaker 02 And so a lot of cultural conventions, starting with language. So why does the word coffee mean coffee? Why does the word desk mean desk? Very few words are automatopiac. It's not like they sound like what they're representing. They're conventions, but that's good enough. As long as everyone knows that the sound coffee means the concept coffee, then I can order a coffee and I can expect to get it. And we do that 50,000 times with every one of the words in the English language. Every one of them is a convention that works because of common knowledge.
30:46 Speaker 03 Stay tuned for more Armchair Expert, if you dare.
30:52 Dax Shepard? We get support from Skims. Okay, I have a confession. I genuinely love matching pajamas. It's the best part of Christmas morning, really. Everyone in the same matching set, looking ridiculously cute in front of the tree.
31:07 Speaker 01 I love matching pajamas. I'm literally going to be in coordinating sets with all my friends this holiday season because I got them, spoiler to my friends who are listening, the same Skims pajama set I've been living in. They are so soft and cozy and they look cute. So you can leave the house and go get a late night hot chocolate, be cozy.
31:27 Dax Shepard? Hmm. It's so great how Skims has sets for everyone, too. Women's, men's, kids, even your pets. So nobody in your life has to be left out this year.
31:37 Speaker 01 I have a bunch of different pajama sets. One of my favorite is the organic cotton sleep long sleeve set.
31:44 Dax Shepard? Okay, tell me more.
31:46 Speaker 01 So comfortable, very chic, too. The top is a button down, but very, very soft, easy to sleep in. But as I said before, you can multi-purpose this and look super cute.
31:57 Dax Shepard? Hot chocolate runs. It's like the pajamas we grew up in, except without the scratchy polyester that made opening presents feel more like a hot yoga class that nobody signed up for.
32:07 Speaker 01 All the nostalgia, none of the discomfort. Shop my favorite loungewear and pajamas at skims.com. After you place your order, be sure to let them know we sent you. Select podcasts in the survey and be sure to select Armchair Expert in the dropdown menu that follows. If you're looking for the perfect gifts for everyone on your list, the Skims Holiday Shop is now open at skims.com.
32:26 Dax Shepard? This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Every family has that one holiday tradition nobody actually enjoys, but everyone keeps doing because stopping it would feel like a federal offense. For me, it was a specific meal situation that I will not name because my family listens. But at some point, you have to ask yourself, am I doing this because I love it or because I'm afraid of what happens if I don't?
32:48 Speaker 01 Yes, and that question applies to so much more than the holidays. I think a lot of us carry these invisible rules about how we're supposed to spend the holidays, who we're supposed to see, what it's supposed to look like. And when you start unpacking that with a therapist, you realize half of your stress is coming from rules you didn't even write.
33:05 Dax Shepard? This is where BetterHelp can be a great resource during the holidays. BetterHelp does the initial matching work for you so you can focus on your therapy goals. A short questionnaire helps identify your needs and preferences, which means they typically get it right the first time. If you aren't happy with your match, switch to a different therapist at any time from their tailored recs.
33:24 Speaker 01 I just love therapy. I've been avoiding it recently, or not avoiding it, but I was like, oh, I'm busy, I'm busy, I'm busy, I haven't canceled, canceled, canceled. But then I-
33:32 Dax Shepard? You start feeling it.
33:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, because then I had it this past weekend and I was like, oh, my God. And just thank God, thank God for her. Yeah.
33:40 Dax Shepard? BetterHelp is now in network with more than 125 health plans with many copays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the US, you can still get 20% off your first month. Sign up and get 20% off at betterhelp.com/dax. That's betterhelp, H E L P, dot com slash DAX. We get support from our sponsor Lilly. For adults with obesity or with excess weight and weight-related medical problems, it's time to find out about Foundo or for Glee Prone. Foundo is a once daily prescription GLP-1 medicine used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity to help adults with obesity or some adults with overweight
34:24 Dax Shepard? who also have weight-related medical problems to lose excess body weight and keep the weight off.
34:29 Speaker 04 Foundo should not be used with other GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if Foundo is safe and effective for use in children. Don't take Foundo if you're allergic to it, or if you or someone in your family had majorary thyroid cancer or multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Stop and call your doctor right away if you have an allergic reaction, a lump or swelling in your neck, or severe stomach pain. Serious side effects may include inflamed pancreas and gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes, if you're nursing, pregnant, plant to be, or taking birth control pills, and before scheduled procedures with anesthesia. Taking Foundo with an insulin or self-euphony luria may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include diarrhea, nausea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and may cause kidney problems.
35:09 Speaker 04 Once Daily Foundo is available by prescription only in 0.8 mg, 2.5 mg, 5.5 mg, 9 mg, 14.5 mg, and 17.2 mg tablets. Learn more at foundo.lilly.com or call 1-800-LILY-RX. Now is perfect to talk to your doctor about Foundo.
35:27 Dax Shepard? This episode is brought to you by ServiceNow. Look, I have my dream job. I get to talk to folks I admire like crazy and ask them virtually any question that I want to. I can't imagine a better way to spend my time. But even dream jobs have some not-so-dreamy parts. The stuff that gets in the way. Of the actual work. Now that's where Service Now's AI specialists come in. They don't just tell you what you should do about your busy work. They actually do it, start to finish, cases closed, requests handled, no extra work for you. So you and your team can focus on what matters most, which for me is, are they obsessed with male bodies on the same level as I am?
36:09 Speaker 01 They never are.
36:10 Dax Shepard? To learn how to put AI to work for people, visit servicenow.com.
36:21 Dax Shepard? Are you a frustrated, non-practicing linguist? All throughout your book, someone might easily think you are a linguist more than a psychologist.
36:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, no, I'm a psychologist by training and by occupation, but I am fascinated by language.
36:33 Dax Shepard? There's so many clues into our psychology, right?
36:36 Speaker 02 Well, exactly. So I wrote an earlier book, which is what spawned this book called The Stuff of Thought, Language as a Window into Human Nature. And that book had a chapter called Games People Play on why we don't just say what we mean. Why is there so much beating around the bush and euphemism and shilly-shallying and weasel words? And that's what eventually led to when everyone knows that everyone knows. Cause the answer that I came up with, I'll just give some examples.
37:00 Dax Shepard? Yeah, I love the Netflix and chill.
37:01 Speaker 02 You want to come up for Netflix and chill? Most people know nowadays that doesn't mean you want to come up to just stream a movie and relax.
37:08 Dax Shepard? Yes. Chill's gonna involve some romance, probably.
37:11 Speaker 02 Romance itself is the euphemism.
37:12 Speaker 01 Right, exactly.
37:15 Dax Shepard? Eventually we'll get down to the F-word, I guess.
37:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, what's happening? Why can't we just say it?
37:19 Speaker 02 It used to be for a century, the cliche was, would you like to come up and see my etchings?
37:24 Speaker 01 Oh, wow, yeah.
37:26 Speaker 02 Sexual come-ons are often veiled. Notice it's not even a case of plausible deniability. If he says, you want to come up for Netflix and chill, you know, she's a grown woman. She knows what he means.
37:36 Speaker 01 Right.
37:36 Speaker 02 Still, that's better than, you want to come up and have sex. Better in the sense that it is more comfortable, more considerate. If she turns it down.
37:44 Speaker 01 It's less painful.
37:45 Speaker 02 Exactly.
37:46 Dax Shepard? What I was reading, which is so fascinating is there's plausibility of misunderstanding built into it, which is she knows, he knows Netflix and chill, but she could not be hip to that term. That's like one safety net we give both people.
38:00 Speaker 02 The real safety net is she could think, he may think that I'm ignorant to that term. And he could think. She might think that I think that she's ignorant to the term. It's not so plausible that either one doubts that the other one knows. I mean, they're grownups. Yeah. In fact, I did a study that when you ask people to witness dialogues and you say, it could be a threat, could be a come on, could be a bribe. Does the hearer know what the speaker is up to? Even with indirect weasel words, hints, the listener knows what the speaker is up to. But the difference is the listener doesn't know that the speaker knows that the listener knows. And the speaker doesn't know that the listener knows that he knows. And so there's no common knowledge. And I think that more plausibly, because grownups know how to interpret language. It doesn't pass the giggle test.
38:45 Speaker 02 And why does it still work? I argue that the reason that it works is it gives you deniability of common knowledge. You don't know that the other person knows that you know, even though you do know. And it's the common knowledge that's the basis for friendships, for sexual relationships, for romance.
39:02 Speaker 01 It feels like anything that has vulnerability attached to it.
39:05 Speaker 02 Yeah, a boss and a supervisor.
39:06 Speaker 01 Yeah.
39:07 Speaker 02 To friends. What makes friends friends? It's not like you sign a contract. Do you think that we're friends? And why do you think you're friends? Because, you know, I think that you think that we're friends.
39:14 Speaker 01 Right.
39:14 Speaker 02 And that's what a social relationship is. And blurting something out changes the common knowledge and therefore changes the relationship. When you want to not change a relationship, but you still have information that you want to slip through, that's when you use politeness, euphemism.
39:33 Dax Shepard? Finishing up Netflix and Chill. What I thought was fascinating was the sentence that was, "They can maintain a platonic relationship in the wake of Netflix and Chill, but I'd like to come upstairs and have sex with you." We cannot participate in this illusion that it's platonic anymore.
39:46 Speaker 02 Exactly. Permanently changes the nature of the relationship. You know, as we sometimes say, some things once said can't be unsaid. And the reason I claim is where they're said, they generate common knowledge. Common knowledge is what determines your relationship.
39:59 Dax Shepard? This just proves that we figure out how to operate in nuance, even though everyone's so opposed to it and you're so drawn to everything that's definitive. We have all these mechanisms, like we want to be able to speak in nuance. Maybe I just advanced on you, but also I can act like it was a joke and it's a silly word I use. We have figured out how to dance in that murky nuance.
40:22 Speaker 02 A lot of our mental life is thinking about what the other person thinks about what we think about what they think. And a lot of fiction, a lot of movies, a lot of novels are driven by the viewer or the reader trying to get into the characters' heads while they're trying to get into other characters' heads. Sometimes also trying to get into the author's head, like a mystery. The whole point of it is like a workout of the mental muscles that you use in recursive mentalizing. That is to say, thinking about other people, thinking about other people, thinking. That's kind of what makes mysteries so engaging.
40:55 Dax Shepard? Yes, we're drawn to that. We know that that's an important thing to understand. Okay, so if direct speech is the quickest way to common knowledge, and then in the absence of that, we can have conventions, ladies first every other time. Talk to us about focal points and how those get brought in to bridge this.
41:15 Speaker 02 Yeah, so a focal point or common salience is when you don't have common knowledge. Let's say you're incommunicado, your cellphone goes dead, you just haven't been able to meet and agree on things. You don't have a convention that is some rule that you can fall back on, then what do you do? So this goes back to probably the first discussion of common knowledge from a brilliant man named Thomas Schelling. He said, imagine a couple gets separated in New York. This was in 1960, so cellphones were yet to be invented. How might they find each other? As we talked about before, they can't try to get into each other's heads about where they're likely to go. But he said a good solution would be they both go to the clock at Grand Central Station at noon. Not because necessarily it was convenient, not where they got separated,
41:57 Speaker 02 but if anything is going to pop into someone's mind, that would be just because it sticks out.
42:02 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
42:02 Speaker 02 You are trying to think of what's going on in other people's heads.
42:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
42:06 Speaker 02 While knowing they're doing the same thing. And pop-out salience, conspicuity is a solution to that problem. Now, the thing is, it's not just in this somewhat contrived case of being separated, but there are lots of cases where focal points solve human problems. So an example is two people are bargaining. Now, when you bargain, you know, let's say you're bickering with a car dealer. There's a range of prices where you can make a profit. There's a range of prices that you're willing to pay the car is worth. And you both want to come to any agreement rather than walking away. Because you really do want the car, you're willing to pay for it. He wants to sell it to you. How do you decide on a price? So what people often do is they split the difference. Or they settle on a round number.
42:46 Speaker 02 As Schelling put it, the salesman who says that his rock bottom price on the car is $37,062 is pleading to be relieved of $7,062. Uh huh, yeah, yeah. So a round number, splitting the difference is a focal point. That makes a difference in international relations. Sometimes wars have been ended when a diplomat or mediator suggests some focal point that they agree on. So for example, the Bosnian war was ended by Richard Holbrook. When he said Bosnia hurts the Govana, we're going to divide it so that it's 51% Bosnians and Croats, 49% Serbs. Where do those numbers come from? Well, if Bosnians felt that a country called Bosnia has got to be majority Bosnia, and
43:29 Speaker 02 there are all those Serbs there, and they're going to fight and kill if they're worried about their interests, the 51-49 was a way of satisfying the idea it's got to be majority Bosnia without too much ethnic cleansing. And there are other focal points like that in international relations that could make a difference, including a really important one, which we're now seeing threatened, is lines on a map. Going back to our discussion of progress from earlier in the conversation, one of the things I wrote about my previous books was the fact that there are fewer wars since World War II than there were in the centuries before. In particular, the great powers didn't go to war with each other. Why? Well, one reason is the world decided to freeze the borders on the map. Even if they were illogical, even if they ran in the middle through territories, they separated ethnic groups. The lines are there.
44:14 Speaker 02 If we accept them, it prevents endless bickering and sometimes invasions and sometimes ethnic cleansings. They may be illogical, but the fact that they're there makes them focal points and it's at least something that we can agree on. You're kind of going on something, anything, instead of the debate would be endless as to where the line should be. Yes. I can see those lines, you can see those lines, I know you can see those lines.
44:37 Dax Shepard? You grew up seeing those lines.
44:38 Speaker 02 You grew up seeing those lines, exactly.
44:39 Dax Shepard? You already accepted these lines for some period.
44:40 Speaker 02 Or sometimes, here's another example. The reason that the 1967 lines won't work is that a lot of the Jewish areas of Jerusalem expanded into what used to be Jordan.
44:51 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
44:52 Speaker 02 And so it wouldn't make sense to lop them off. But then, another focal point is, okay, so for every few percentage points of old Jordan that we allow Israel to keep permanently, there has to be the same number of percentage points carved out of the old Israel that will be in a new Palestinian state. And this is all part of the good old days when people actually talked about a two-state solution and US presidents tried to get the two sides to agree on it. That's the way the agreement would have worked. Again, it doesn't necessarily make any sense. Who's to say that what Israel had in 1949 is the right amount of territory? There's no answer to the question, what's the right amount of territory? There is an answer to the question, can everyone see a certain division of territory and know that the other guy sees it? So again, you've got a focal point, going back to your question.
45:35 Speaker 01 Why is gerrymandering allowed in this country? If it's the antithesis of that, it's like, you can just move the lines anytime you want.
45:42 Speaker 02 That's a good point. I hadn't thought to make the connection. But yeah, one of the reasons that gerrymandering is considered outrageous.
45:48 Speaker 01 Yeah.
45:49 Speaker 02 Is that it is not a focal point, it's done expediently.
45:51 Speaker 01 Right.
45:52 Speaker 02 It is done to maximize the number of representatives that the side doing the gerrymandering can claim.
45:56 Speaker 01 Yeah.
45:57 Dax Shepard? I want to talk about how these concepts apply to a few different categories, and then I want to save a tiny bit of time to throw you into the lion's den of popular issues we deal with that I love watching you navigate. But how do these focal points affect the stock market?
46:11 Speaker 02 A lot of economic phenomena, in particular, ones that aren't just predictable from boring supply and demand and investment. You buy a stock because they're building a factory, they'll make widgets, people will buy the widgets, they'll make a profit, you get a share of the profit. Or they'll plant seeds for a forest, the forest will grow, they cut down the wood, it's wood. They sell the wood, they make a profit. That's kind of the way you think economies should go, but of course, it's not the way the stock market goes.
46:36 Dax Shepard? Yeah, it started that way, but it didn't take long to.
46:38 Speaker 02 No, because the famous economist John Maynard Keynes, he likened it to a beauty contest, but not a standard beauty contest like the old Miss Rheingold ads that ran in American magazines for many years, where there were six faces and you picked the prettiest. Here, he imagined there were six faces, it doesn't matter how many. But the prize goes to the person who picks the face that the most other people pick. Oh, wow. And all of them are picking the face that they think the most other people will pick. So he says to solve that, you can't just look at beauty. You've got to get in the heads of other people. He said speculative investing is kind of like that. You're picking the stock that you think other people are going to pick, increasing demand in the future and driving the price up above and beyond its actual productive value.
47:22 Dax Shepard? Yeah, without almost any acknowledgement of whether the company itself is destined for bigger profits or not. That's not really the goal. You're incentivized to sell your stock for more, even if the company collapses.
47:33 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. As long as you could find, as investment analysts put it, a greater fool.
47:37 Dax Shepard? A greater fool.
47:38 Speaker 02 And so you get phenomena like meme stocks where some influencer who just has a following. There's a guy named Roaring Kitty.
47:46 Dax Shepard? Who's the game stock?
47:47 Speaker 02 So this is a moribund business, bricks and mortar video games.
47:50 Dax Shepard? Failing, losing money.
47:51 Speaker 02 He talks it up on his social media feed. Then everyone buys it because they know that all these people are following this feed and they're going to want to buy it up. And so it goes through the roof. Oh, wow.
48:02 Dax Shepard? So there's such a variety of personal power over shaping common knowledge.
48:08 Speaker 02 If someone is public.
48:09 Dax Shepard? Yes. Like what a disproportionate amount of sway over common knowledge certain people have.
48:16 Speaker 02 And they know that it can be too much power. And that's why you get the chairman of the Fed or other economic czars having to watch their words very carefully. So Alan Greenspan famously said, I've learned to mumble with great incoherence. If you think I've been clear, you've misunderstood what I said. Because he knew that any little hint that he gave of, say, the economy getting better, getting worse, veering toward recession.
48:40 Dax Shepard? Yeah, for the last six years, it's been, is he going to lower the interest rate? So any adjective he uses could send a huge surge in the stock market.
48:49 Speaker 02 So I quote Alfred Kahn, who was Jimmy Carter's inflation zeal. And he said, the president has told me, you know, I've never used the word depression because using the word can actually make it happen. So I agree, I won't use the word depression. But you know, we're in danger of having the worst banana in 50 years.
49:09 Dax Shepard? Okay, now, Super Bowl ads, these are fascinating. It didn't even occur to me that public and private knowledge are at play in what products people advertise. So just talk about the power of the Super Bowl.
49:20 Speaker 02 Well, here I owe a lot to a political scientist named Michael Chua here in Los Angeles at UCLA, who wrote a book, kind of a predecessor to my When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows, called Rational Ritual, where he talked about the Super Bowl phenomenon. The phenomenon is, there are products that can't succeed until lots of people adopt them, but why would people adopt them unless lots of other people adopt them?
49:42 Dax Shepard? Like, they'll only work at scale.
49:43 Speaker 02 Introducing a new credit card, like when the Discover card was introduced. It was a really good credit card. There were cash back bonuses and good terms. The thing is, why would you get a Discover card if you didn't think any vendors were going to accept it? And why would a vendor accept a new card if they didn't think a lot of customers would have it? Yes. Or the best example from Chua is the Apple Macintosh computer. 1984, everyone was using IBM PCs, and I grew up on that kind of computer. They had 24 rows of 80 characters, and you had to memorize commands like runder, colon, dot, foo bar, slash.
50:16 Dax Shepard? Yeah, yeah.
50:16 Speaker 02 And if you get one character wrong, it jokes. You had to remember where you kept all your files. They were pain, and that's why personal computers didn't take off. Well, Steve Jobs supposedly stole an idea from Xerox, which is the WIMP computer, Windows Icons Menu Pointing Device, like a mouse.
50:34 Dax Shepard? What an acronym for that.
50:35 Speaker 02 Yeah. So it's clearly a better way for ordinary people to use a computer. The problem is, who's going to buy a Macintosh until they knew that enough other people were buying Macintosh? Because then you might be an orphan, there may not be tech support, the price is going to stay high.
50:50 Dax Shepard? No software designed for it.
50:51 Speaker 02 No software, no peripherals, no consumables. So Apple, they tried it originally with Lisa, and it flopped. They then had the stroke of genius. What if we advertise it on an ad that everyone will talk about on the Super Bowl? Where the Super Bowl is something that everyone watches and everyone knows that everyone watches. It's almost like a holy day on the calendar.
51:11 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
51:12 Speaker 02 So they hired Ridley Scott of Alien and Blade Runner fame. And he directed the most expensive and probably famous commercial in the history of television, the 1984 ad, where it capitalized on the fact that that year, 1984, was of course the name of Orwell's famous novel. So you had a kind of dystopian scene from 1984 of these sackcloth clad drudges filing in. Everything was black and white and there was a corporate guy issuing drivel. And then intercut, there was a scene of an athletic young woman in a tank top and red shorts, carrying a mallet, running and you go back and forth between the corporate meeting and the lemon. And she bursts into the room, she hammer throws the mallet onto the screen. It explodes in a fireball.
51:54 Speaker 02 And then creeping up on the screen, it's on January 20th, Apple will introduce the Macintosh and you'll see why 1984 won't be like 1984. That was the ad, ran exactly once.
52:06 Dax Shepard? Nothing about the product.
52:07 Speaker 02 Nothing about the product.
52:08 Dax Shepard? Didn't explain Windows, didn't explain the mouse.
52:11 Speaker 02 But what it did is it kind of cut the knot. So now, since everyone knew that the Macintosh was a big thing, they could take a chance at buying one and they wouldn't have to be an early adopter. Likewise with the Discover card. Now, this can also work for other products that depend on these kind of network effects, other people adopting them.
52:29 Dax Shepard? Yeah, that they have cachet or some kind of perceived, the brand has value or prestige.
52:34 Speaker 02 Sneakers are sneakers, but sometimes people think, I wear Nikes as opposed to Adidas. What generates that feeling? Well, if you advertise it in public where other people know what a Nike wearer is like or what a Bud drinker is like, then they're likelier to identify with a product. And so what Schwein showed, so this isn't just a story. Showed that for products that depend on network effects, websites where you go to the website only if enough other people are going to it, tech standards, things with brand loyalty that people consume in public like beer and sneakers.
53:07 Dax Shepard? Cars, Mercedes.
53:08 Speaker 02 Cars, yeah, as opposed to things that people consume in private, like batteries, breakfast cereal, underwear. What he showed was that companies are willing to pay more per viewer and more likely to advertise in the Super Bowl. And advertisers charge more per viewer, not just the size of the audience, but the fact that the Event is common knowledge for the Super Bowl for those products as opposed to the products that don't depend on network effects.
53:33 Speaker 01 Hmm.
53:34 Speaker 02 And more recent example, this is decades after Truett published his book, is the year before last, the Super Bowl is sometimes called the Crypto Bowl because so many of the ads were high concept ads for crypto exchanges.
53:46 Dax Shepard? This is 2022?
53:47 Speaker 02 Yeah, Matt Damon with a backdrop of astronauts and mountain climbers and Larry David playing himself at different points in history, rejecting various innovations like fork, like the toilet, like democracy. And the punchline was, they tell him about FTX crypto exchange. He says, nah, I don't think so. And I'm never wrong. The joke being-
54:07 Dax Shepard? He's always wrong.
54:08 Speaker 02 He's always wrong.
54:09 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
54:09 Speaker 02 I mean, the irony was, he was right, because it was FTX, which is the Sam Benjamin Fried exchange. But the idea was, as with the Macintosh, they were not advertising the benefits of crypto, like the government can't confiscate it, it won't be a victim of hyperinflation, you can buy weapons with it. It was simply, don't be left out. Other people are doing it, therefore, they're going to bid up the price. It'll be worth more in a year than it is now. It's a purely speculative investment. And to gin up, again, going back to the Keynesian beauty contest, guessing what other people are going to guess, other people are going to guess, the Super Bowl could do that.
54:42 Dax Shepard? Yeah, I mean, that's my problem with crypto. There's no there there.
54:44 Speaker 01 Well, they're selling, it feels like being on a team, having a group identity.
54:49 Speaker 02 Then it's like the Nike sneakers.
54:51 Speaker 01 Exactly.
54:52 Speaker 02 In addition to the bidding up the price.
54:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I think that happens in politics, too.
54:58 Speaker 02 Oh, yes. So I talk about that on the American primaries. It's a bizarre custom. It starts off in New Hampshire and Iowa. They're hardly a sample of the United States, but everyone knows they're important because what they do is they generate common knowledge of who has a chance of winning. So let's say there's 10 candidates. Because you can only vote for one, people say, well, I don't want to throw away my vote on who's going to come in, you know, seventh versus eighth.
55:21 Speaker 01 Right.
55:21 Speaker 02 Even if I think that that person would be the best president, I'll be throwing away my vote. I want to vote for someone who's either going to be number one or number two, so my vote counts. How do they determine that? Well, they try to guess who other people are going to vote for.
55:34 Speaker 01 Exactly.
55:34 Speaker 02 And they're doing the same thing, which is why in the primary season, minor gaffes and indiscretions and things that are utterly meaningless can actually determine who gets nominated and who doesn't. In the case of Biden in 2020, no one knew who the nominee was going to be. Then suddenly- Before the South Carolina primary, Jim Clyburn endorsed Biden. I don't even know how many people have heard of Jim Clyburn. But the media played it up like this was big news. And then that gave Biden the momentum that he needed. Conversely, and I say common knowledge giveth and taketh away in 2024. Everyone knew that Biden was declining. Yeah. And did everyone know that everyone else knew? Well, when he had that ill-fated debate with Trump in which he kept stumbling, the difference wasn't so much the number of people who thought he was impaired.
56:18 Speaker 02 That did go up, but only by a little bit. A majority of people already thought he was impaired.
56:23 Dax Shepard? I was saying in January on this show, and I got some heat. I was like, guys, this can't be our candidate. And they were like, shut up, he's doing a great job. And like, I was just too early on the one you can say it out loud.
56:33 Speaker 02 Exactly. But then when it was in that heavily watched debate, then it was common knowledge.
56:39 Dax Shepard? He couldn't deny anymore. Okay, money is fascinating. I like this whole chapter on donating.
56:45 Speaker 02 Oh.
56:46 Dax Shepard? If you could do a loose hierarchy that this famous rabbi came up with.
56:50 Speaker 02 Maimonides.
56:51 Dax Shepard? You then studied it in real time, in present day, and it pretty much holds true.
56:55 Speaker 02 Yeah, so this is kind of my earliest encounter with the idea of thinking about thoughts. Because when I was in Jewish Sunday School as a kid, we were taught Maimonides' ladder of righteousness, or charity, depending on how it's translated, where the righteousness of a gift does not just depend on the cash value of the gift, but also on the circumstances of giving, in particular, the states of knowledge of the donor and the recipient. Now, the highest level, to give him credit, was you teach someone a trade, you give them a starter loan, you go into partnership, so he doesn't even need charity in the future.
57:27 Dax Shepard? You fix them, basically.
57:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, you fix them. I think everyone would agree, teach a man to fish, you feed him for a lifetime. Okay. Then the other rungs were the interesting ones. The next one down was double-blind. The rich person puts money into a community chest, goes away, the poor person comes and retrieves it, donor doesn't know the recipient, or vice versa. Level below that. The donor knows the beneficiary but not vice versa. So a rich person leaves cash on the doorstep of a poor person, goes away in the dead of night. Poor person wakes up the next morning, there's the donation. The donor knows the beneficiary but not vice versa. That's not quite as righteous as neither knows the other.
58:05 Speaker 01 Interesting.
58:06 Speaker 02 Then one level down from that, the other way around. The recipient knows the donor but not vice versa. So imagine that a rich person walks around with a bunch of coins in his backpack and the poor person picks them out. The donor doesn't know the beneficiary, but the beneficiary does know. That's a little worse. Worst of all is rich person puts money into the hand of the poor person. Common knowledge.
58:27 Dax Shepard? Yes. Now, this is incredible because, as you point out, what's the fucking difference? If the impact is that you save right there. But I know, I am obsessed with the 1800s patrician class. I've read all these biographies. I love Rockefeller because he didn't put his name on anything. Like, Chicago University is his, we don't know that. His research foundation, we don't know that. Whereas Carnegie, he put his name on absolutely everything. And I'm like, yeah, he's better.
58:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, we all do that, but why? From the poor person's point of view, you know, who cares?
58:58 Speaker 01 Why is it bad if the poor person knows?
59:01 Speaker 02 Well, you're right. And in our studies, people putting themselves in the shoes of the poor person don't care. They just know, the more cash, the better.
59:08 Speaker 01 Right, if the poor person is picking the money out of the rich person's...
59:10 Dax Shepard? Well, they're just saying the fact that the guy, although he won't know who he helped, he will be observed giving.
59:16 Speaker 02 Here's our explanation as to why. We verified that people more or less followed Maimonides' intuition. They agree that a common knowledge gift is less righteous than a double-blind gift. That is, the person is more generous, is more likely to donate in the future.
59:32 Dax Shepard? You should give the Curb Your Enthusiasm example.
59:34 Speaker 02 Rabbi Larry Ben-David, another great Jewish thinker. And actually, he is a great Jewish thinker. So the episode was Larry donates money for the wing of a conservation nonprofit, and it's named after him. Carved in stone, donated by Larry David. And the other wing says donated by anonymous. Now people are starting to gossip, hey, you know who anonymous is?
59:56 Speaker 01 Oh.
59:57 Speaker 02 It's Ted Danson.
59:58 Speaker 01 Oh.
59:58 Speaker 02 Ted Danson, what a great guy.
1:00:02 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:00:03 Speaker 02 And Larry's really, this is his rivalry, this, I didn't know that you could donate anonymously and people would know about it. I would have taken that option, okay?
1:00:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's fantastic.
1:00:13 Speaker 02 That captures the paradox, that he got the benefits of the reputation for generosity and the reputation for not caring about reputation.
1:00:20 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:00:21 Speaker 02 Even though he did benefit from it.
1:00:22 Dax Shepard? I mean, what we want out of people is hysterical.
1:00:25 Speaker 02 It is.
1:00:25 Dax Shepard? And it all comes from being like a hundred-member troop of people.
1:00:28 Speaker 02 Yes.
1:00:29 Dax Shepard? We want them to be benevolent, but egoless.
1:00:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, but sometimes it bites them. You know, there are people who give a ton of money away who aren't saying it, like billionaires, and then people outwardly and publicly hate them and they don't know. Well, they're also giving away a ton of stuff. They're just not really talking about that.
1:00:48 Dax Shepard? Well, there's also the compelling argument and effective altruism, which is by people seeing other donations, it does encourage them to. It's contagious. So you might be doing more good for the cause by owning it.
1:01:00 Speaker 02 That's exactly right. And ironically, there's another medieval rabbi, Rabbi Shlomo Ben Avraham. Contra Maimonides, he argued exactly that. There's a righteousness in publicizing exactly because it'll incentivize others. So Bill Gates, probably the world's biggest philanthropist, he's not anonymous and for a reason, namely, he can cajole, shame his fellow billionaires.
1:01:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:01:24 Dax Shepard? Also, he's an example of like, look what I did and you will live. You can give away this mass fortune, you'll be just fine.
1:01:30 Speaker 02 And his fellow billionaires would then be keeping up with the bills.
1:01:34 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:01:35 Speaker 02 With the Gateses.
1:01:36 Dax Shepard? No, it's one of the most genius aspects of his already genius foundation.
1:01:39 Speaker 02 Absolutely. I talk in the book about how the opposite was Steve Jobs, who was criticized for not giving anything away. Then, in an incident worthy of Curb Your Enthusiasm, Larry David, Bono outed him posthumously, said, oh, no, no, he really did give a lot, but he just was not the kind who cared about his reputation. And so I'll said, oh, Jobs, what a great guy.
1:01:59 Dax Shepard? Yeah, better than Bill Gates.
1:02:00 Speaker 02 Like Ted Danson, although Jobs gave away one thousandth of what Gates gave away.
1:02:05 Dax Shepard? And had probably one millionth of the impact because he did it in this also
1:02:09 Speaker 01 Secret way.
1:02:10 Dax Shepard? methodology that yields results.
1:02:12 Speaker 02 Right. So anyway, those are some of the paradoxes that I talk about.
1:02:16 Dax Shepard? I want to read the list because in that section, you're quoting somebody.
1:02:19 Speaker 02 Oh, the social paradoxes. David Pinnsoft deserves the credit.
1:02:22 Speaker 01 It's just people of means judging other people, though, as you say. The poor person is not judging any of this. They want the money and that's it.
1:02:32 Speaker 02 That's exactly right. So we show that in our studies.
1:02:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:02:35 Speaker 02 If you take the point of view of the recipient, they don't care. If you take the point of view of a third party observing it, they care.
1:02:43 Dax Shepard? But also you can be poor and hate the rich people.
1:02:46 Speaker 02 Well, that's true also.
1:02:47 Dax Shepard? For not giving enough money. Yeah, if they're not getting something from them. This list of phenomena by David Pinnz is great. We try to gain status by not caring about status. We rebel against conformity in the same way as everyone else does. We show humility to prove we're better than other people. Fuck, that one is so prevalent right now. We don't care what people think and we want them to think this. We make anonymous donations to get credit for not caring about getting credit.
1:03:15 Speaker 02 That's my monies. That's Larry David, I should say.
1:03:18 Dax Shepard? We briefly defy social norms that people will praise us. I'm the most guilty of that one. I'm like, oh my God, I'm repugnant. Aren't those great?
1:03:26 Speaker 01 They're so good.
1:03:27 Dax Shepard? 14 of them, and they were all delicious.
1:03:28 Speaker 01 The hypocrisy.
1:03:30 Dax Shepard? I want to talk about why we cooperate, mutual reciprocity and mutualism.
1:03:36 Speaker 02 Yes, I'm glad you brought that up because this is kind of zooming up to really the big picture. What are we talking about here? This isn't just humans, this is any organism. How can one organism benefit another? Well, there's one possibility is that it incurs a cost. And we call that altruism in the technical biological sense. And Richard Dawkins wrote a book, The Selfish Gene, now 50 years old, almost. Classic book. And it's interesting because it raises a puzzle. You'd think that evolution would only select for selfishness. Why should it ever happen that one organism should be nice to another? Most animals aren't, unless they're related. But you do have things where they take turns grooming each other, they share food. And Dawkins had two explanations. One is if they're related, they share genes.
1:04:19 Speaker 02 So any gene that makes you altruistic is helping a copy of itself inside that relative. Or reciprocity, if you trade favors, then everyone could win in the long run. But a lot of good deeds in the animal kingdom aren't altruistic in this technical sense of you pay a cost when you benefit someone else. But in some cases, each one benefits the other. So an oxpecker bird picks
1:04:42 Speaker 02 Ticks off the back of an ox or a zebra. It's good for the oxpecker because they get a meal, all those yummy bugs. It's good for the ox because he's tormented by fewer pests and so everyone wins.
1:04:53 Dax Shepard? There's no sacrifice made on either end.
1:04:55 Speaker 02 I mean, except for the ticks, but we're not worried about that. That's sometimes called mutualism. There are lots of cases, cleaner fish, symbiosis, where everybody wins. And so there, there isn't the same evolutionary paradox because if everyone wins, then of course they can both evolve. There's a different dilemma. And the dilemma isn't motivational, like, oh, is he going to cheat me, exploit me? Is he going to take but not give when it's his turn? Is there going to be treachery? Is there going to be guilt? All that drama, which I think is very real. But in these cases, it's a different problem and that is getting on the same page. It's more of a cognitive problem. And here we go back to our couple rendezvousing, all these other cases where it's good if everyone is on the same page, but how do they get there if each has to know that the first one knows that the second knows that the first one knows ad infinitum?
1:05:40 Dax Shepard? Function's relying on both cooperation and coordination.
1:05:44 Speaker 02 Coordination, yes.
1:05:45 Dax Shepard? And this is really solving the coordination issue.
1:05:47 Speaker 02 Exactly. The book is about coordination. And as with human focal points, like meeting at Grand Central at noon, some animals have evolved without much cognition, thinking, even a brain, they solve the problem with focal points. So I give the example of the annual Great Barrier Reef Sex Festival, as biologists call it.
1:06:05 Dax Shepard? Tell me more, I want to plan a trip around this.
1:06:07 Speaker 02 Oh yeah, you gotta be there.
1:06:10 Speaker 02 So coral have this problem. They're stuck to the reef. They can't get out and get around. How do they mate? They can release their sperm or eggs into the water and hope for the best. That's really wasteful if you're doing it 24/7. So it'd be best if they could all somehow agree on what day to do it. But it's not enough for one of them to think, hey, January 1st or eclipse or whatever would be a good day. Unless all the others agreed, why would they agree? Now, of course, we're using agree metaphorically here. They don't have brains.
1:06:36 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:06:37 Speaker 02 So there's nothing they can think with. So it's all a question of what evolves that works in practice. What works for them is a fixed number of days after the full moon. Say six days after the full moon, that's when they release the sperm. That's when they release the eggs. And so it's concentrated enough they can find each other.
1:06:54 Speaker 01 Oh my god.
1:06:54 Dax Shepard? Not to get too in the weeds, but are they responding to the gravity or the light?
1:06:58 Speaker 02 Light.
1:06:58 Speaker 01 And how they plan six days?
1:07:01 Dax Shepard? They hit their stopwatch.
1:07:02 Speaker 01 How do they know what days are?
1:07:03 Speaker 02 Well, there are a bunch of molecular clocks.
1:07:04 Dax Shepard? They have a circadian rhythm like ours.
1:07:06 Speaker 02 Exactly, circadian rhythm. And so the full moon is their focal point, their clock at Grand Central, and they solve the coordination problem.
1:07:13 Dax Shepard? Sorry, I'm too distracted by this. But what happens on a cloudy night? Does it fuck up the whole system?
1:07:18 Speaker 02 Good question. I don't know.
1:07:20 Speaker 01 Maybe they have more receptors to that.
1:07:22 Dax Shepard? Are they gonna tell cloud?
1:07:23 Speaker 02 It's off Australia. It's not that much. There's not that much clouds.
1:07:25 Dax Shepard? You have a plus with really clear skies down there.
1:07:28 Speaker 02 Or maybe they don't even need clear sky, but just a difference. And maybe just the difference between the night before, or I don't know the answer.
1:07:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:07:37 Speaker 03 Stay tuned for more Armchair Expert, if you dare.
1:07:44 Dax Shepard? We get support from Superhuman. Look, I love what I do. The conversations, the ideas, the creative stuff. But there's this whole other layer of work that eats my day alive. The inbox that never ends. Docs I need to get through, threads I'm behind on. And by the time I've dealt with all that, the stuff I actually want to focus on gets whatever's left. What I needed was something that just works where I'm already working. Not another tab to open, not another thing to set up. Superhuman Go, from the makers of Grammarly, is different. It's already right there, inside your email, your docs, your browser. You don't go to it. It's already working alongside you. You're deep in a long thread, highlight it, and it pulls the key points. About to send something important? It flags what doesn't add up before it leaves your hands.
1:08:29 Dax Shepard? It knows your style, your workflows, and it just backs you up without getting in the way. A thought partner that's already up to speed, at your service, not after your job. So do yourself a favor and try Superhuman Go. From the makers of Grammarly. Find out more at superhuman.com. We get support from Instagram teen accounts. So we talk a lot on this show about how the world is different now than when we were growing up. And one of the biggest differences is obviously social media. And I think a lot of people wonder, okay, what's actually being done to make it safer for teenagers?
1:09:04 Speaker 01 Which is a fair question.
1:09:05 Dax Shepard? Yeah, so Instagram has got something called teen accounts, and they come with automatic protections built. By default, so anyone between 13 and 17 is automatically placed into this experience. They get age appropriate content settings, contact limits, so that by default, only people they're already connected to can message them. And time management tools, daily time limit reminders, and also sleep mode that mutes notifications from 10:00 PM to 7:00 AM.
1:09:31 Speaker 01 Sleep mode is genius.
1:09:33 Dax Shepard? Right? And here's the thing, for anyone under 16, a parent has to give permission to change any of those settings to be less strict. The guardrails are on, and Instagram keeps building new safety features to create age appropriate experiences for teens.
1:09:48 Speaker 01 I am really glad Instagram's helping to give parents peace of mind with teen accounts.
1:09:52 Dax Shepard? Learn more about teen accounts and Instagram's ongoing work to protect teens online at instagram.com/teenaccounts. We are supported by Walden University. You know that feeling when you've been thinking about making a move, going after the degree, the promotion, the thing you keep telling yourself you'll get to someday? Walden University is built for that moment. For over 50 years, Walden has helped working professionals get the W, the knowledge, the skills, and the confidence to create real change in their careers and communities. Their programs are designed around your life, not the other way around. With Tempo Learning, available in select programs, there are no rigid schedules or set weekly deadlines. You move at your own pace.
1:10:36 Dax Shepard? And Walden's faculty aren't just academics, they're practitioners who bring real world experience into everything they teach. From your first class to career coaching and beyond, Walden is your partner the whole way. Take the first step and learn at a pace that works for you. Visit waldenu.edu. Walden University. Set a course for change. Certified to operate by CHEV. We get support by Peloton. You know that feeling when you're spiraling over a problem and you just can't figure it out? When that happens to me, I need a change of pace. And I've found that running is the best way. It takes my brain out of the driver's seat, and I come back with a fresh perspective. Running can be freeing and cathartic, and Peloton helps you feel.
1:11:21 Dax Shepard? All of that. And now that feeling fits wherever you need it with the new Peloton Tread Flex. It's movable and foldable, designed to fit your life. So next time you feel stuck, you can go for a run literally anywhere, whether that's in your office, living room, or even the attic. Plus, they have classes with expert instructors and programs to meet you at any level and keep you moving. Let yourself run. Explore the new Peloton Tread Flex at onepeloton.com.
1:11:55 Dax Shepard? Okay, now I'm throwing you to the wolves.
1:11:57 Speaker 02 Okay.
1:11:58 Dax Shepard? I heard you talking about COVID, and I don't know why this is a bit of a pet project of mine, but I guess as I feel the tension in this country politically, what scares me the most is what seems to be a complete breakdown or failure for either side to acknowledge that the other one has an occasional good point, or that each side can't admit when they error. And I think that's dramatically reduced kind of the reputation of different parties and both sides. And COVID, I think, is a big black mark for my side. And I heard you speaking about it. So what was happening in COVID, do you think?
1:12:35 Speaker 02 The first thing to keep in mind is that we started out, everyone was ignorant.
1:12:38 Dax Shepard? We're scared and ignorant.
1:12:39 Speaker 01 There's nothing to base anything off.
1:12:40 Speaker 02 It was a new pathogen.
1:12:42 Dax Shepard? We could all be dead in six months.
1:12:44 Speaker 02 We know that pandemics can kill a lot of people, way more than wars. History has been driven by pandemics that we often forget about. Empires can fall. When I was working on Better Angels of Our Nature and plotting trends in violence, I looked at life expectancy over the course of the 20th century. And it goes up, and then there's a big notch in the teens, then it went up again. I said, oh, jeez, that's the tragedy of war, World War I. Wrong. It was the Spanish Flu. Killed way more people than World War I. There's stuff to worry about. No one knew. How was it transmitted? And the problem with, I think, a lot of the public health experts is they overplayed their state of knowledge. They said, first, masks don't matter, then you got to wear a mask. It's spread by droplets,
1:13:26 Speaker 02 so disinfect surfaces, then it's spread by aerosols, plexiglass barriers went up, the social distancing. Now, it's not immoral to suggest those things in a state of knowledge and say, We don't know, but at this point, we're hedging our bets. The downside is so bad.
1:13:43 Dax Shepard? The worst case is this, so let's prepare for this. We're not sure if that's it, but let's prepare for that.
1:13:47 Speaker 02 And that is the scientific method. You're never certain of anything. You have a degree of credence that goes up or down with the evidence, but you're never certain. And if new evidence comes in and you gotta back off, that doesn't refute science, that is science. Yeah.
1:14:00 Dax Shepard? Gets you closer.
1:14:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, no one is infallible and no one is omniscient. That's kind of what science is all about. Yes. And I think the experts did not convey that enough. There was too much confidence, which meant that when they changed their mind, it looked like they were flip flopping, they were arbitrary. Also, what they didn't do, and this is something that scientists themselves can't do, is the cost benefit analysis. At its best, the scientists could say, if we have this policy, there'll be many more cases. But how many extra cases are worth, say, keeping a generation out of school for two years? Or all of the depression and anxiety or hit to the economy?
1:14:41 Dax Shepard? Or how inequitable the distribution of who had to go to work and who didn't. If ever there was kind of an elitist policy accidentally, I think it was, that was like, you're essential, why?
1:14:51 Speaker 02 Because I want to get my UPS packages from Amazon.
1:14:54 Dax Shepard? And I want to eat at that restaurant.
1:14:55 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly.
1:14:56 Dax Shepard? But my thinking job should be at home.
1:14:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, so there are basically two failures there. I devoted a chapter in my previous book, Rationality, to each one of them. One of them is calibrating your degree of confidence in an idea according to the strength of the evidence. Something that's called Bayesian reasoning. And the other is decision making under uncertainty and risk. Namely, given that you're not certain, no one's ever certain, we're not God. Given that there can be mistakes in both directions, there can be false alarms, that can be bad. There can be misses, that can be bad. How do you make the optimal decision, trading off the false alarms and the hits and the misses? And I think the people in charge didn't give enough attention to both of those dilemmas.
1:15:37 Dax Shepard? They're all gonna come with a downside and an upside. It's a trade off, you're trying to do an analysis. But I would add a third category of issue, which was a kind of reckless deplatforming, demonetizing, canceling of anyone who was suggesting otherwise. I don't fault anyone for the approach. Makes total sense to me and I get it. Shutting down opposition.
1:15:59 Speaker 02 You're right. That's another problem. And that's a third problem, which is, given that we are all fallible, given that the only way we've bumbled our way toward any kind of progress is, people say things, other people tell them they're full of crap. If you disable that by saying there's some things you can't say, we might have false beliefs and no way of determining what they are.
1:16:21 Dax Shepard? Somehow, our categorical nature has been most weaponized in that situation where if you were opposed to it, we had a clear distinction for you. You don't believe in science. Lock stop. So this is a fruitless endeavor for me to talk to you about it. That kind of wholesale write-off of people based on some wordage.
1:16:42 Speaker 02 Absolutely. And the irony is, the whole thing about science is, it is a way of dealing with human fallibility, human ignorance.
1:16:50 Dax Shepard? It's gotta be open to criticism.
1:16:51 Speaker 02 It's gotta be open to criticism. That's the way it works.
1:16:54 Dax Shepard? It's a quintessential ingredient in the method.
1:16:56 Speaker 02 Now, of course, it doesn't mean anyone can believe anything they want, as long as the evidence really does lean very strongly in one direction. But part of human nature that makes science so difficult and alien to a lot of people, including sometimes scientists themselves, is ideally, the idea is, facts don't care about your feelings. Everyone's entitled to their own opinion, but not their own facts. These are all vital, but these are not the way people naturally think. We naturally think, when it comes to big cosmic questions, why do bad things happen to good people? Why do wars start and revolutions and epidemics? We like to think, in modern times, well, we can answer those questions. We've got scientists, we've got journalists, we've got data specialists, we've got archives, we've got experiments. It's gonna be hard, but we can actually answer those questions. And so you ought to believe
1:17:41 Speaker 02 only what the evidence points to. For most of human history, thousands of years, none of that existed. You could not find out. Ask, why did a plague happen? We're never gonna know. What's an uplifting myth that brings the people together and inspires us all? And the idea is, no, no, you can't just believe something because it makes you feel good. You believe it only if it's true. And if it's true and it makes you feel bad, you've still gotta believe it. I think that's the right attitude, but it's a deeply weird attitude. We don't naturally think that way.
1:18:09 Dax Shepard? Yeah. So, along those lines, what price do you think academia has paid for being
1:18:17 Dax Shepard? Pretty explicitly left-leaning.
1:18:20 Speaker 02 It's a problem in a number of ways. One of them is just reputation. The confidence that people have in universities has been sinking. As Donald Trump has tried to cripple universities, there's not been enough pushback from the public. I mean, they should be saying, "Hey, these are the guys who are going to be finding cures for Parkinson's disease."
1:18:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
1:18:39 Speaker 02 And treatments for paralysis.
1:18:40 Dax Shepard? Alzheimer's.
1:18:41 Speaker 02 And Alzheimer's.
1:18:42 Dax Shepard? Yeah, "Give us clean energy."
1:18:43 Speaker 02 Prosthesis for people who are paralyzed. Kneecapping the institutions that are going to give us that doesn't make any sense. But I think that some of the opposition has been muted, like, "Well, aren't universities just indoctrination camps for woke-ism?" So that's one problem. The other is universities just going about doing their business are going to be led into some errors if some opinions, you can't say that. Because the things that you can't say, well, they might be right. And even if they're not right, this is an argument that goes back to John Stuart Mill and his famous essay on liberty, which kind of made the classic case for free speech. Said the reason that there should be free speech is threefold. One of them is, the other guy might be right. The other is, the
1:19:24 Speaker 02 truth might be somewhere in between. The third is, even if he's wrong, you'll have better reason to believe what you believe if you can explain why he's wrong. Now, universities have fallen down on those principles. You've got many departments where it's 100% left, and you know, the left isn't right about everything.
1:19:42 Dax Shepard? No, as it turns out, no one is.
1:19:44 Speaker 02 Exactly. And you can point to a number of cases where I think academia kind of dug itself into a hole because it did not have people who were expressing another point of view.
1:19:55 Dax Shepard? Yeah. I am a liberal, and I want all those things to happen. And I want our universities to be funded, and I believe in the fourth estate and all those things. But I also think this criticism of elitism is legitimate. It's a realistic issue that I feel like our side's having a real hard time, or my side, I don't know what your side is, grappling with that.
1:20:15 Speaker 02 Yeah, same side.
1:20:16 Speaker 01 I really struggle with it.
1:20:17 Dax Shepard? Well, just if you're looking from the outside and you go, "These institutions are deeply liberal." We agree on that.
1:20:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's also a talking point. I think the right is really pushing that talking point hard so that there is this, like... Ew, universities are liberal. I think that's part of the propaganda. It is, right? It's being pushed.
1:20:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, I've written about this. I wrote an article called Harvard Derangement Syndrome. How I've been a big critic of Harvard, even though I'm a Harvard professor. They're fine with that.
1:20:47 Speaker 01 Which is great.
1:20:47 Speaker 02 Which is great. I'm not just defending my team. I'll identify what the problems of Harvard are. But some of the attacks have been just out to lunch. Yeah, we've got some jargon-spewing leftists in the Department of Romance Languages. But, you know, we have free speech.
1:21:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, they should be allowed to say what they want to say, too.
1:21:03 Speaker 02 But, you know, what does this have to do with the people who are studying antibiotic resistance or cancer metastasis? Or the mathematicians and cosmologists?
1:21:12 Dax Shepard? Yeah, yeah.
1:21:12 Speaker 02 The image of the farthest out of the far out, people confuse with the entire university system.
1:21:18 Speaker 01 We talked about this before. He's in Nashville for a little bit, so I was there for the summer. And I got in the cab, and the driver is from Nashville, and he was talking about Nashville. And I said, oh, yeah, but I lived in LA for 15 years. And he was like, oh, I'm sorry. And I was like, if we said that in the reverse, you're elitist. I was like, why do you get to say it? I do think there's this, like, bias that we are so elite. And also, growing up in Georgia, I disagree.
1:21:49 Dax Shepard? Though, I guess I mean, we acknowledge those are the elite institutions. They all result in higher income and a higher socioeconomic standing when you go to these elite universities. And if they're all very liberal, and then our policy in COVID is keeping all the rich, educated people in their house while the uneducated people are working and servicing them, you know, this starts to add up to a pretty legitimate point of view against the
1:22:15 Speaker 01 But they're not all very liberal. I went to University of Georgia. It's not very liberal at all.
1:22:20 Dax Shepard? But I think there are irrs towards Harvard and Yale.
1:22:24 Speaker 02 At Harvard, in the People's Republic of Cambridge, to the name of a really good neighborhood bar, by the way. A third of the faculty identify themselves as very liberal. Two-thirds don't. I co-founded the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard to push back against the cancel culture and the political correctness and so on. I did a little poll, how many of you would identify as conservative? And I got 60 professors, just in our group, who called themselves conservative, including some pretty famous ones, like George Mankew, who was George W. Bush's economic adviser. I don't think we have as much diversity as we should have. But it is not a monolith.
1:22:59 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:23:00 Dax Shepard? Okay, I didn't get any action on that one.
1:23:03 Speaker 02 There are some cases where a left-wing position was by and large right, and sometimes a right-wing position is by and large right. Markets really are better than a totally planned socialist communist economy.
1:23:14 Dax Shepard? Right.
1:23:14 Speaker 02 History has told us that.
1:23:15 Dax Shepard? The experiment's been run.
1:23:16 Speaker 02 Also, if you have assistance for the poor, that is not going to drive you into serfdom, into totalitarianism, if you've got social security. So I think the left won that debate.
1:23:28 Dax Shepard? Gay marriage, we've had a lot.
1:23:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, the institution of marriage has not fallen apart as a result of gay marriage. And it has not led to people being able to marry their animals or to polygamy.
1:23:36 Dax Shepard? Having black neighbors didn't kill your neighborhood. We've gotten it right a bunch.
1:23:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, but no one's infallible. Kind of expose ourselves to a universe of ideas and find out which ones are good.
1:23:44 Dax Shepard? Yeah, I think the fear for me is, I think it's dangerous to think you know better.
1:23:49 Speaker 02 Some people know better about some things. The thing is, they've got to prove it. And again, that's the whole thing about science, which people, including scientists themselves, can lose sight of. It's not a priesthood, they're not oracles. They have reasons. Why do you think such and such? Well, I'll show you. These are the experiments and these are the data. When you stop doing that, you're not doing science anymore.
1:24:08 Dax Shepard? All right, last thing, I want to close on this because we're filled with a lot of pessimism surrounding this topic. And you're one of the few voices of very smart people that are saying, don't panic about AI. And the first thing I ever heard you talk about was simply this kind of way we came about, which is a competitive evolutionary framework. Dominance is rewarded, and we outcompeted a lot of things. But we're projecting that onto a machine.
1:24:32 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:24:33 Dax Shepard? So tell me why we shouldn't be as terrified as some people are.
1:24:36 Speaker 02 AI could be abused like any technology could be. Are AI is going to turn us into pets or farm animals or wipe us out either intentionally or by accident? I don't think so. Because humans do those things. We did exterminate a lot of species. We enslaved other people, we conquered. But the thing is, humans are products of natural selection. That is, a process that works by competition. Whichever variant has the most descendants takes over. And so whatever competitive instincts led that to happen are there with us now. In the case of something that is designed by humans, not evolved by natural selection. There's no automatic reason to think that they should want to maximize their power,
1:25:19 Speaker 02 maximize their well-being, they can pull their own plugs, unless you do something really stupid, like program them to make sure that they can't be turned off or that their own power is maximized. That would be a very stupid thing to build into an AI. Don't do that. There's no reason to think it'll just happen by itself.
1:25:36 Dax Shepard? You refute this notion that because it's smarter, it can make itself smarter ad infinitum. We all kind of believe that it'll make itself smarter on its own, that there's some limit to that.
1:25:49 Speaker 02 Superintelligence or foom after the comic book sound effect of something just taking off. And since it'll happen exponentially, as soon as it passes that threshold, we'll be powerless to stop it. I don't think that intelligence is kind of a stuff that you just have more and more and more and more of. It's a gadget that solves certain problems, can be extended to solve other problems. But you've got to actually come up with new mechanisms for it to become smarter still. Granted, there was a big surprise in how much smarter AI got with scaling. That is, the AI awakening of about 10 years ago, when suddenly we got Siri and Google Translate,
1:26:32 Speaker 02 and then the large language models, came largely because our ability to crunch numbers got so much more powerful thanks to GPUs, video game chips. Turns out you could re-purpose a video game chip to train an artificial intelligence neural network. So that was a big thing. And the fact that all of us for 20 years have been generating all this text. We've been writing Reddit posts and Facebook posts. So there's all this data to train these things on.
1:27:00 Dax Shepard? Right.
1:27:00 Speaker 02 So that did lead to a big leap, just the sheer scale. But we've kind of run out of web, and you can even tell from the fact that for all the hoopla of GPT-5, it wasn't that different from GPT-4.5. It's not as if it keeps going up exponentially.
1:27:14 Dax Shepard? I already wasn't using it to its capacity. I'll just say that.
1:27:17 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:27:18 Dax Shepard? Like, there was a better one. I was like, okay, I think I'm really just using it as Google for the most part.
1:27:22 Speaker 02 Right. Well, there's a generational difference. Apparently, older people use it as semantic Google. That is, not just text, but ideas. Younger people, they say, are using it as companion.
1:27:31 Dax Shepard? Yeah, that's troubling. But again, I'm on high alert for moral panics, and I feel like they abound everywhere you turn.
1:27:37 Speaker 02 I agree.
1:27:38 Dax Shepard? I lied to you. There was one other word I wanted you to explore a little bit, which is moralism. I just thought this is a good concept to point out because I feel like this is something everyone should police themselves about. Once your argument or your debate has, what I would say, devolved into your lock, sale, assessment of their character, we've got kind of problems. How does it work?
1:27:58 Speaker 02 Yeah. And the better angels of our nature, when I talk about why do people kill and injure and aggress? One category is just sheer exploitation. You make people slaves because before you had machines, that was a labor-saving device. Why do we eat animals? We don't hate the animals. We just like the taste of their flesh. So some amount of aggression is purely practical instrumental, but an awful lot is moral. As I put it, the world has far too much morality. So if you look at what Hitler did, what Stalin did, what Mao did, if you look at most homicides aren't to steal goods like shooting a clerk at a 7-Eleven. Most of it is revenge and honor. A guy disses you, you come back and you shoot him. And you think you're doing the right thing. Most murderers think they are being moral and that they're doing justice.
1:28:41 Dax Shepard? Right.
1:28:42 Speaker 02 Not all, but that's a big category. So one of the reasons is, what is justice? Justice means you punish someone. That's a kind of aggression. It can give you a license to inflict harm on others, thinking you're doing the right thing. And one of the things, going back to when everyone knows that everyone knows, I talk about how common knowledge of a wrongdoer is a great way to form a coalition. That is, if you want to be on the winning side, you want to be part of a big, powerful group, you all agree that someone did something bad, and so you pile on, you mob. That is one of the surefire ways to join a majority coalition. And so sometimes you get phenomena. People have written about it, like Salem Witch Trials.
1:29:23 Dax Shepard? Amanda Knox, recently.
1:29:25 Speaker 02 Amanda Knox, yeah. Where you pick out a victim that everyone can easily-
1:29:29 Dax Shepard? Sacrificial lamb.
1:29:31 Speaker 02 Is a terrifying phenomenon.
1:29:32 Dax Shepard? Yes, yes, yes. We're all seem to be easily prone to that. Well, Stephen, once again, you've written an incredible book, When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. It's such an honor to get to chat with you occasionally. I hope we get to do it again.
1:29:49 Speaker 02 I sure hope so. Thanks so much for having me. It's great fun to talk to you both.
1:29:55 Speaker 03 Hi there. This is Hermium Permium. If you like that, you're gonna love the fact check with Miss Monica.
1:30:02 Dax Shepard? Can I play the cutest thing?
1:30:03 Speaker 01 Sure.
1:30:04 Dax Shepard? I came in from recording yesterday. We were recording for many hours.
1:30:08 Speaker 01 Yep.
1:30:09 Dax Shepard? And I walk into the house and I, I hear this. This is Delta.
1:30:29 Speaker 03 Good job. Good job. Okay.
1:30:33 Dax Shepard? That's Delta learning the theme song of Mom's Car for her dad.
1:30:37 Speaker 01 I heard you asked and she delivered.
1:30:42 Dax Shepard? That was a big-
1:30:44 Speaker 01 It's very sweet.
1:30:45 Dax Shepard? That was a big eye wellie moment to walk in the house and hear her playing that. Oh, this little fucking girl. What a little lady. What a little lady. We had such a fun day yesterday.
1:30:58 Speaker 01 What'd you guys do?
1:30:59 Dax Shepard? Well, Mom's out of town. Mom was in Utah, I think, on work. And so I made an enormous batch of fresh spaghetti. And we all sat down as a family and ate our spaghetti and shared about our day. And then we watched a little Murders in the, Only Murders in the Building.
1:31:26 Speaker 01 Oh, I'm behind, yeah.
1:31:27 Dax Shepard? Then we watched a little Devil Wears Prada.
1:31:29 Speaker 01 Oh, my favorite of all time.
1:31:32 Dax Shepard? And then we went upstairs and we listened to Immense World and snuggled. And they both went to bed so peacefully.
1:31:38 Speaker 01 That's nice.
1:31:40 Dax Shepard? And, oh, it was just the most lovely night. I really love when it's just the three of us sometimes, because I get all the attention.
1:31:48 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:31:48 Dax Shepard? And then this morning, I got so much attention.
1:31:51 Speaker 01 You brush your hair?
1:31:53 Dax Shepard? Um, luckily, I didn't have to brush their hair.
1:31:56 Speaker 01 No, did they brush your hair?
1:31:58 Dax Shepard? Oh, they did not brush my hair. Um, I don't brush my hair, as you know.
1:32:04 Speaker 01 That's one thing you can trick kids into doing is playing with your hair.
1:32:07 Dax Shepard? I should have done that. They were good at snuggling, uh, for sure.
1:32:11 Speaker 01 That's nice.
1:32:12 Dax Shepard? Yeah, I didn't, because normally, we all lay together and I'll only get one of them, because Kristen has the other one.
1:32:17 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:32:17 Dax Shepard? But I had both of them in my nook, and it was heaven.
1:32:20 Speaker 01 That's very nice.
1:32:21 Dax Shepard? And then they were both as excited as I was this morning, because when we woke up, it was raining. I was initially upset because, of course, I didn't take the leaf blower.
1:32:30 Speaker 01 You didn't? After all that?
1:32:32 Dax Shepard? After all that, I thought we had escaped the rain. I thought it had been predicted for the daytime. And I'm like, oh, I said it on the fact check, like, oh, I got away with it.
1:32:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:32:42 Dax Shepard? Middle of the night, on one of my seven times waking up, I wake up and it's just pouring outside. But then in the morning, I got to open my door and meditate on my bed with the sound of rain. And the girls came in, they were dancing because it was raining, and then we listened to, "I love a rainy night."
1:33:00 Dax Shepard? "I love a rainy night." You don't know that 80s song?
1:33:03 Speaker 01 I don't think so.
1:33:04 Dax Shepard? Uh, it's a good rain song.
1:33:05 Speaker 01 That's nice.
1:33:06 Dax Shepard? Yeah, it was lovely.
1:33:07 Speaker 01 Okay, so I feel like I've had an increase in dandruff.
1:33:12 Dax Shepard? Increase or, or, or arrival? I don't, I don't associate you with having dandruff at all.
1:33:19 Speaker 01 I feel like sometimes I've had it before.
1:33:22 Dax Shepard? Well, you had one of those classic Eric compliments.
1:33:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:33:27 Dax Shepard? Which is, go ahead and roll that out.
1:33:29 Speaker 01 Uh, Amy was braiding my hair, and Eric said, "It's a good thing you don't have dandruff, because you'd really see it on your hair, because it's so dark." And I said, "Yeah, I do have it sometimes." He said, "Well, yeah, I did see one flake, that's why I thought it."
1:33:46 Dax Shepard? That's why I said you don't have any.
1:33:47 Speaker 01 Oh, my God. But I do feel like it's increased. And every now and then, I'll just like, "This is gross, I'm not gonna do it right now." But I'll like, stick my fingers in my scalp.
1:34:00 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:34:00 Speaker 01 My fingernails, and then I'll start just like scratching like crazy.
1:34:04 Dax Shepard? Kind of tearing it all up.
1:34:07 Speaker 01 Skin comes out.
1:34:08 Dax Shepard? But you're rea- that's a little different, I think.
1:34:11 Speaker 01 Are you sure?
1:34:11 Dax Shepard? Dandruff is just like, you're not even touching it and it's just kinda raining. If you get in there with those long fingernails and start gouging and then s- some skin cells come off, that's...
1:34:23 Speaker 01 You think that's regs?
1:34:24 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:34:25 Speaker 01 Huh.
1:34:25 Dax Shepard? Now, you know where I get it, which I can't stand it, and I do have a new approach to this. I'll get it in my beard.
1:34:32 Speaker 01 Oh.
1:34:32 Dax Shepard? And I like to itch my beard, cuz I can't get lotion on the beard.
1:34:36 Speaker 01 Oh.
1:34:37 Dax Shepard? I can't penetrate to the skin. I'll just get a bunch of lotion all over the beard hair.
1:34:41 Speaker 01 Oh, really?
1:34:42 Dax Shepard? But I- what I have been doing is, um, I have a new face oil.
1:34:46 Speaker 01 Great.
1:34:46 Dax Shepard? And I put it on the tips of my fingers and it'll really go up and through there.
1:34:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's a good idea.
1:34:50 Dax Shepard? And I think that's been helping a little bit.
1:34:53 Speaker 01 Okay, um, or a gel, like a gel moisturizer would also probably have that same impact.
1:35:01 Dax Shepard? A penetrative...
1:35:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, and you know, like, for skincare, you should be pressing it in. Press.
1:35:09 Dax Shepard? Okay.
1:35:10 Speaker 01 You don't need to do like a smudgy.
1:35:12 Dax Shepard? Oh, just press.
1:35:13 Speaker 01 You can just press it in.
1:35:14 Dax Shepard? Okay, I do need to- I do think I need to get my fingers between the hairs.
1:35:18 Speaker 01 Yes, just cover your- all your fingers.
1:35:20 Dax Shepard? I'm just gonna have all hair.
1:35:22 Speaker 01 But like, like, look, like, I'm pressing on top of hair, right?
1:35:25 Dax Shepard? Well, first you went through it, though.
1:35:27 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:35:28 Dax Shepard? You didn't just go like this.
1:35:29 Speaker 01 Okay, I'm going like this, okay? And then you go, like, go in and out.
1:35:33 Dax Shepard? Okay.
1:35:34 Speaker 01 And I'm touching skin to- it's touching the hair, but there's- the skin is getting impacted.
1:35:38 Dax Shepard? Yeah, yeah.
1:35:40 Speaker 01 I think you should try that.
1:35:41 Dax Shepard? Okay.
1:35:41 Speaker 01 Anyway, um, if people notice my dandruff, that is...
1:35:46 Dax Shepard? So be it.
1:35:46 Speaker 01 What's happening these days.
1:35:48 Dax Shepard? You don't have any, but, so if they notice some, they're- they're imagining it. Do you kinda want- you do wanna do it, don't you?
1:35:54 Speaker 01 Did you see one came o- a couple came off?
1:35:57 Dax Shepard? But again, none are sticking to your black hair.
1:35:59 Speaker 01 Right now, it's not happening, but normally it happens.
1:36:01 Dax Shepard? Yeah, yeah.
1:36:02 Speaker 01 It's like, this is- this is TV.
1:36:04 Dax Shepard? Yeah, it's like when you have a dog who can do a trick until you ask it to do it with other people.
1:36:08 Speaker 01 Exactly.
1:36:09 Dax Shepard? Um, and then I went on a hike this morning. I was like, oh, it'd be lovely to go on a hike because it's a- it's a overcast.
1:36:19 Speaker 01 Right.
1:36:19 Dax Shepard? And tropical feeling, and I underestimated the humidity.
1:36:25 Dax Shepard? And I do not think I've ever been more drenched on a hike ever. I have my weight vest on and when I got back and took off the weight vest, it was soaked. And then my tank top, I hung up and it actually dripped like I had been in a swimming pool. From where I was hanging.
1:36:41 Speaker 01 Well, this is a ding ding ding because we had a guest on yesterday who was quite sweaty.
1:36:45 Dax Shepard? Oh, yes, who sweat through their shirt onto the couch and then you sat there and then you were quite damp. Afterwards.
1:36:53 Speaker 01 But it was, it was, um, welcome.
1:36:57 Dax Shepard? Yeah, because he was hot.
1:36:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:36:58 Dax Shepard? I thought about how hot he was a few times today.
1:37:00 Speaker 01 Today, you did?
1:37:01 Dax Shepard? Mm hmm. I think that's a real testament to someone's hotness when it's like a day later, you're like.
1:37:05 Speaker 01 You're still thinking about it. Yeah, he was hot.
1:37:08 Dax Shepard? Yeah. Did you think about it at all today?
1:37:10 Speaker 01 Um, not today.
1:37:11 Dax Shepard? Not today.
1:37:12 Speaker 01 Not until right now that he's come up. I'm thinking about it now.
1:37:16 Dax Shepard? Yeah, and he's so hot, right?
1:37:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, he, he has a very cute face. Some people have very, um.
1:37:24 Dax Shepard? He has a boyish face, I'd say.
1:37:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, I guess it's boyish, but there's also something, it's not all that cookie cutter, but it's very handsome.
1:37:35 Dax Shepard? Mm hmm.
1:37:36 Speaker 01 Some people have faces like that, like you just kind of want to look at them for a really, really, really, really long time. That's really lucky.
1:37:43 Dax Shepard? Yeah, that's almost maybe the definition of attractiveness is you want to look at it for a long time.
1:37:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, I guess that's true.
1:37:51 Dax Shepard? The hot person, did you know, was in a Got Milk ad?
1:37:54 Speaker 01 I probably have it.
1:37:55 Dax Shepard? Do you have him?
1:37:55 Speaker 01 I might. I need to go back and look. I, um, somebody DM'd me that it, they're back, like they, he saw, this guy saw a Got Milk ad in Los Angeles on a billboard.
1:38:10 Dax Shepard? Really?
1:38:11 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:38:12 Dax Shepard? With the milk mustache?
1:38:13 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:38:14 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:38:15 Speaker 01 So people are listening.
1:38:17 Dax Shepard? I was just telling the girls last night when we were eating spaghetti, I said, you know, I always ate my spaghetti growing up with a huge glass of cold milk.
1:38:24 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:38:25 Dax Shepard? I don't do it anymore.
1:38:26 Speaker 01 I know. You didn't even drink it in hot one.
1:38:28 Dax Shepard? I have too much chest congestion to drink milk willy nilly. I'll get a little huh.
1:38:35 Speaker 01 Hmm.
1:38:35 Dax Shepard? You know?
1:38:36 Speaker 01 Okay, clogged up.
1:38:37 Dax Shepard? Yeah, I would love it, but they thought that was an anthem. They thought that was crazy.
1:38:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, this is, uh, milk at dinner is a real watershed marker of generations. Uh, uh, my generation had milk with dinner.
1:38:52 Dax Shepard? Constantly.
1:38:53 Speaker 01 Constantly, that was common.
1:38:54 Dax Shepard? That's what kids drank.
1:38:55 Speaker 01 Yes, that's what you drank.
1:38:57 Dax Shepard? No one drank water. That was not a thing when I was growing up. No one ever had a glass of water with anything.
1:39:02 Speaker 01 I know, and this is why I'm confused, why I'm the only one who's like not attracted to water.
1:39:09 Dax Shepard? Yeah, you haven't gotten with the program.
1:39:11 Speaker 01 Well, I try, but it's not in my, it's not how I grew up. And I think you're right. It's not how a lot of people grew up. So how'd they transition?
1:39:18 Dax Shepard? Could you drink more milk? I mean, let's get you more fluids in you. That aren't, you know, wine or, or Moscow Mule.
1:39:28 Speaker 01 I haven't had a Moscow Mule in years. Um, I save my water for right before bed and I drink sixty ounces.
1:39:36 Dax Shepard? You drink sixty ounces right before bed?
1:39:38 Speaker 01 I drink at least, at least fifty. And it's not ideal. It's not ideal timing, but.
1:39:45 Dax Shepard? That sounds like a terrible plan. And you, do you wake up and pee in the middle of the night?
1:39:49 Speaker 01 I do have to pee in the night.
1:39:50 Dax Shepard? And it hurts even?
1:39:52 Speaker 01 Doesn't hurt.
1:39:53 Dax Shepard? Oh, I'm glad we're bringing this up.
1:39:54 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:39:55 Dax Shepard? I've had more thoughts about, remember you brought up on a fact check about the, the length of the penis could reduce the stream, strength?
1:40:01 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:40:02 Dax Shepard? So I was peeing the other day and I was just kind of thinking of the whole thing. And there's so, I mean, the fact that boys think that is so comical. Cause if you really think it all through, all of it, all of it would suggest you're better off with a very quiet stream. Because imagine, if you had a two foot long penis, it would probably be touching the water and you'd hear nothing.
1:40:27 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:40:28 Dax Shepard? Cause it would be falling one inch.
1:40:32 Dax Shepard? The.
1:40:32 Speaker 01 But wouldn't you be holding it up a little bit? Cause like you don't want to touch the water.
1:40:36 Dax Shepard? Sure, you would avoid. This is, I have, I can get in this situation, sitting down sometimes on toilets. And I, and it's always in public. And if I feel the water, I almost die.
1:40:46 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:40:46 Dax Shepard? Um, but if you really think it through, if you had a, a real garden hose on you, you'd be peeing like two inches above the water and that would make the least amount of noise. The most amount of noise would be if you peed from a rooftop.
1:40:59 Speaker 01 Sure.
1:40:59 Dax Shepard? So if you had a very tiny, short penis, it would fall farther. It would go through less penis and slow down less. Like everything about a loud stream really screams smaller.
1:41:12 Speaker 01 Except, okay.
1:41:13 Dax Shepard? But everybody thinks that people are evaluating their peepee size by their stream.
1:41:18 Speaker 01 But also if, if it's a lot of pee, if it's like so much pee.
1:41:23 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:41:24 Speaker 01 That would make a louder sound.
1:41:27 Dax Shepard? More pressure.
1:41:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, cause the pressure.
1:41:29 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:41:29 Speaker 01 So maybe that's like, oh, there's so much pee because the penis is so big, but as we know now, that's wrong.
1:41:36 Dax Shepard? And you're getting into prostate health when you're getting into like how, how fast it can come out.
1:41:42 Speaker 01 I'm just trying to explain how you boys think problematically.
1:41:47 Dax Shepard? Well, I'm saying that it's, it's just a really crazy thing that we deduce that when all signs point to, that would actually mean less penis.
1:41:58 Speaker 01 Right.
1:41:59 Dax Shepard? Yeah. If someone had a three foot hose, you would never hear it because it would be underwater.
1:42:04 Speaker 01 Ew.
1:42:05 Dax Shepard? You would put it in the water and then fill the bowl up.
1:42:09 Speaker 01 That's disgusting.
1:42:10 Speaker 05 Factor hole size though, too, then?
1:42:13 Dax Shepard? Eurythrogirth?
1:42:14 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:42:15 Speaker 01 We discussed that before.
1:42:17 Dax Shepard? Eurythrogirth diameter.
1:42:18 Speaker 01 It's more like how long it has to, I mean, if it's hu, if it's a huge hole.
1:42:23 Speaker 05 It's like a pencil.
1:42:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, if it's a pencil hole and tube.
1:42:28 Dax Shepard? Uh huh.
1:42:28 Speaker 01 And it's, I guess if, then if it's big, it'll still be loud and fast.
1:42:34 Speaker 05 Cause the amount coming out.
1:42:36 Dax Shepard? And maybe short, short though. Cause you would expel it so quickly.
1:42:40 Speaker 05 It could be a long and girthy hole though. I think.
1:42:44 Dax Shepard? Three second pee though. It'd be like loud as hell and then over.
1:42:47 Speaker 01 Bodies are so different. There's, there's so many factors.
1:42:51 Dax Shepard? There are. I just, we, we were really off track with that.
1:42:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, you guys were really off track.
1:43:00 Speaker 03 Stay tuned for more Armchair Expert if you dare.
1:43:06 Dax Shepard? We get support from ZipRecruiter. Oh, get recruiting. So I went down this rabbit hole the other day on real holiday jobs that exist and I couldn't stop. Somebody out there is hiring a ham glazer, a professional ham glazer. Another place is hiring a lead elf, implying a whole hierarchy of elves I had never even considered. Here's the thing, these jobs need real skills. People like that are hard to find. Whether you're hiring for one of these roles or any other role, the best way to find qualified people who are genuinely excited about your role is on ZipRecruiter. And right now you can try it for free at ziprecruiter.com/dax. Plus ZipRecruiter has a new feature that shows you the most interested qualified candidates first,
1:43:51 Dax Shepard? so you meet the right people faster. No wonder ZipRecruiter is the number one rated hiring site based on G2. Let ZipRecruiter find the right people for your roles, seasonal or otherwise. Try it for free today at ziprecruiter.com/dax. That's ziprecruiter.com/dax. Meet your match on ZipRecruiter.
1:44:19 Dax Shepard? You had a couple of items on your list from last time.
1:44:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, I did. But I was about to say something else before we got into penis peeing, maybe.
1:44:27 Dax Shepard? You drinking 50 ounces of water.
1:44:29 Speaker 01 Milk. When we were young, the doctor would tell our parents to make us drink milk for calcium. And then I had to go down to skim milk because of my cholesterol.
1:44:39 Dax Shepard? Right, currently.
1:44:41 Speaker 01 No, when I was little.
1:44:42 Dax Shepard? When you were a child?
1:44:43 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:44:43 Dax Shepard? Wait, you had a high cholesterol?
1:44:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, I've had it my whole life.
1:44:46 Dax Shepard? Check as a kid?
1:44:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's the whole thing.
1:44:48 Dax Shepard? I don't think my cholesterol was ever checked as a child.
1:44:51 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
1:44:51 Dax Shepard? I mean, I almost never went to the doctor unless I was there to get stitches.
1:44:54 Speaker 01 I would do physicals.
1:44:56 Dax Shepard? Oh, yeah, I didn't do those.
1:44:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, I did. And my cholesterol was high.
1:45:02 Dax Shepard? Okay, sky.
1:45:03 Speaker 01 So I had to go to skim milk.
1:45:04 Dax Shepard? Okay.
1:45:07 Dax Shepard? Were you on a stat in fifth grade?
1:45:09 Speaker 01 No, but oh, somebody did ask if I could give an update. Someone DM'd me to ask if I could give an update on my GLP-1 journey.
1:45:18 Dax Shepard? Oh, yeah.
1:45:18 Speaker 01 And my, um, uh, cholesterol. I'm getting, we're getting our blood work done next week.
1:45:25 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:45:26 Speaker 01 So I'll know more after that. And I will report back.
1:45:29 Dax Shepard? Okay, great.
1:45:30 Speaker 01 Oh, wow. This is actually a ding ding ding. Something I wrote down that I wanted to ask you about is your ethics around the handicap stall.
1:45:41 Dax Shepard? Oh, yeah, yeah.
1:45:42 Speaker 01 Okay, let's say you go in.
1:45:44 Dax Shepard? Yeah, I use it all the time.
1:45:45 Speaker 01 You do?
1:45:46 Dax Shepard? Yes, because unless I see a guy in a wheelchair on my way in.
1:45:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:45:49 Dax Shepard? I absolutely use it. There's more space.
1:45:52 Speaker 01 What if they come in when you're in there?
1:45:54 Dax Shepard? I will be out in one second.
1:45:56 Speaker 01 What if you're pooping?
1:45:57 Dax Shepard? I can only tell you this. I, I'm 50. I always use the handicap stall. And I've never in my life exited and there was a guy in a wheelchair waiting.
1:46:06 Speaker 01 Wow.
1:46:07 Dax Shepard? Which has never happened. Now, if that happened and I, I had made them wait a long time, I'd feel bad. If I made them wait the standard time, I don't think being handicapped means you don't have to wait. Like, anyone that uses a bathroom has to wait. You just need a lot of space to operate the wheelchair. I don't think it's a fast pass to go into the bathroom. That doesn't make any sense to me. Like, you don't, you don't have a, it's not a fast pass. It's a, it's a size thing so you can be accommodated.
1:46:39 Speaker 01 But it's just that there's only one.
1:46:40 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:46:41 Speaker 01 And most bathrooms have multiple stalls.
1:46:44 Dax Shepard? Mm-hmm.
1:46:45 Speaker 01 And then one handicap stall. So that's the ethics around it, right?
1:46:48 Dax Shepard? But I would argue, if I walk in and there's a dude in a wheelchair waiting, clearly, I'm not gonna take the handicap stall. He is going to get first up. That's guaranteed.
1:47:00 Speaker 01 Right.
1:47:01 Dax Shepard? And if he has to wait like everybody else has to wait for a stall to open up, I don't think there's any ethical dilemma in that.
1:47:06 Speaker 01 No, there's no, there's no ethical dilemma in him having to wait. There's a line.
1:47:10 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:47:10 Speaker 01 Right?
1:47:11 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:47:11 Speaker 01 But it's if there is no line, you came in and there's nobody there.
1:47:16 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:47:17 Speaker 01 And all the stalls are open.
1:47:18 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:47:19 Speaker 01 If you go in there, you're taking the one opportunity for him when he comes and also nobody's there, but his stall's taken.
1:47:28 Dax Shepard? Yeah, so. I think what happens is people conflate some things. So like the handicap parking spot is closest to the door because obviously they should have to travel the least amount of distance because it's harder.
1:47:43 Speaker 01 Of course.
1:47:44 Dax Shepard? But there's no rationale for someone that's handicapped shouldn't have to wait for a stall.
1:47:49 Speaker 01 No, no, no, it's not, it's not that they don't have to wait.
1:47:54 Dax Shepard? But I do think people think that, like that that thing should stay empty at all times.
1:47:58 Speaker 01 Right.
1:47:59 Dax Shepard? In the event that someone that's handicapped comes in so that they can go immediately in. That's, that's not how bathrooms work.
1:48:05 Speaker 01 Well, it's just that, okay, if it's a one stall thing, I sort of agree with you. But if there's like five stalls.
1:48:11 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:48:12 Speaker 01 There are five stalls specifically so that people don't have to wait that long, right? But if everyone went into the handicap stall, that guy would have to wait for so long.
1:48:22 Dax Shepard? But I, again, if he showed up and four people are standing in line to use just the handicap stall.
1:48:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:48:28 Dax Shepard? Bet my life on the fact everyone's like, oh, go ahead, bro. I'll use the other ones. The most a person would have to wait is for one person to use the bathroom, and I don't think that's a big deal.
1:48:38 Speaker 01 But what if they're pooping and it's so long?
1:48:40 Dax Shepard? If you think you're gonna take a tremendously long dump.
1:48:43 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:48:44 Dax Shepard? Um, probably don't use it.
1:48:46 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:48:46 Dax Shepard? Secondly, glance under. You can see the rest of the bathroom. If you see wheels, pick up the pace, get out of there.
1:48:56 Speaker 01 I don't think anyone's in the middle of their poop and looking under.
1:48:59 Dax Shepard? Oh, I do. Cause I like to be alone in the bathroom. So if like I hear the door and I'm like, I hate, someone's in there and then I look, like, are they still in here?
1:49:08 Speaker 01 Oh, I never look.
1:49:09 Dax Shepard? I could tell you at any moment how many people are in the bathroom when I'm shitting.
1:49:12 Speaker 01 Because when I am in, if I'm in the handicap stall.
1:49:15 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:49:15 Speaker 01 Um, I can't see, like, the door is too far out for me to just like peek. Like, I would have to get up.
1:49:24 Dax Shepard? No, you look under.
1:49:25 Speaker 01 I know what you're saying, but I'm saying the door itself is like here. Like, I'm on the toilet, right? The door is there, leading out.
1:49:34 Dax Shepard? Okay.
1:49:35 Speaker 01 So, and I can't just go like this, like I can't reach, it's the, the bottom is there. Does that make sense?
1:49:41 Dax Shepard? No, cuz it bottoms also next to you. It's not like it goes to the floor and only is open at the door. They're all only coming down.
1:49:49 Speaker 01 Oh, not all, and I'm not thi- I'm thinking of a bathroom, I guess that doesn't do that.
1:49:52 Dax Shepard? Like a Foley with a door you can't see out of?
1:49:55 Speaker 01 You can see under the door.
1:49:57 Dax Shepard? But not the sides.
1:49:58 Speaker 01 But you wouldn't see out the sides, yeah.
1:50:00 Dax Shepard? Okay. A men's bath, I'm thinking of an airport primarily, and it's, it's, it comes down to like the kneecaps.
1:50:06 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:50:07 Dax Shepard? You know, mid, mid cav. And I can see what's happening on the floor of the bathroom. And again, I'm 50, never once have I come out and seen someone in a wheelchair waiting for it. It's just never happened, so it's like, it's very theoretical. Do you use it or what?
1:50:25 Speaker 01 It's just a fun topic.
1:50:27 Dax Shepard? Oh yeah, I'm just telling you why I don't, I have no guilt using it whatsoever.
1:50:30 Speaker 01 Um, I use it some ti- well, I only use it if the stalls are taken.
1:50:38 Dax Shepard? Okay.
1:50:39 Speaker 01 But I often feel bad about it.
1:50:42 Dax Shepard? Oh, wow.
1:50:43 Speaker 01 Like, should I just wait till someone comes out and then I'll use one of those? But then I feel awkward if other people are waiting.
1:50:50 Dax Shepard? Yes.
1:50:50 Speaker 01 I'm like, I can't, I don't know what to do.
1:50:53 Dax Shepard? Yeah, you should just use it.
1:50:55 Speaker 01 I do, I do end up just using it, but I feel like.
1:50:58 Dax Shepard? I use it because I'm a daddy long legs, and if I have my roll-on bag with me and I go into the normal stall.
1:51:04 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:51:05 Dax Shepard? I kind of have to leave my bag on the outside, cuz there's not room between my knees and that. So it's like, of course I'm gonna use the bigger ones, like I have my luggage in there.
1:51:13 Speaker 01 Right.
1:51:14 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:51:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's complicated.
1:51:17 Dax Shepard? It is. Rob, do you shit in the, uh, handicap one?
1:51:20 Speaker 01 Or just pee.
1:51:21 Speaker 05 If, if it's the only stall open, I won't pick that first, though.
1:51:25 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:51:26 Dax Shepard? Those are very ethical.
1:51:27 Speaker 01 Okay, so.
1:51:28 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:51:28 Speaker 05 But I get what you're saying.
1:51:30 Speaker 01 This came to me cuz I was at a restaurant and I was like, oh, what do I do? These are taken.
1:51:38 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:51:38 Speaker 01 Do I go in there? I guess I am gonna, but I hate this.
1:51:41 Dax Shepard? Uh-huh.
1:51:42 Speaker 01 And then I, I wonder.
1:51:44 Dax Shepard? Could you glance around the restaurant, see if there's any?
1:51:47 Speaker 01 Was I gonna come out of the bathroom and go do a big glance?
1:51:50 Dax Shepard? A big sweep, okay.
1:51:52 Speaker 01 That's a little much.
1:51:53 Dax Shepard? Okay. Excuse me, so sorry to interrupt. Is anyone here in a wheelchair?
1:52:01 Speaker 01 And if so, do you have to use the bathroom?
1:52:03 Dax Shepard? Anytime. So when do you think you'll be using the bathroom? Because I was thinking of using the stall.
1:52:09 Speaker 01 It's just, it's the rest are taken. I wouldn't normally.
1:52:12 Dax Shepard? I would never do this, but I am gonna have an accident if I don't.
1:52:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, so, alright, so you have no issues?
1:52:21 Dax Shepard? I don't. I have a very clean consciousness about that.
1:52:24 Speaker 01 Okay, great.
1:52:25 Dax Shepard? But hey, maybe one day it'll bite me in the ass. I'll come out and there'll be a guy. And he'll be like, "Thanks, bro. I just shit my pants."
1:52:32 Speaker 01 Right. I don't know why I wrote this. I must have been watching something. But I wrote, "People change physically through a relationship."
1:52:42 Dax Shepard? They sure do.
1:52:44 Speaker 01 I'm trying to make sense of what I wrote, which I think I'm saying.
1:52:47 Dax Shepard? They can get skinnier, they can get bigger, they can get less muscular, more muscular, they can get balder. They can get more hair.
1:52:53 Speaker 01 Correct. So when it changes, are you allowed to say anything? Actually, we don't need to answer this because we talked about this on Mom's Car. When I was on your episode of Mom's Car.
1:53:08 Dax Shepard? We, oh, we were talking about, one of the callers had a husband who got very into weight training.
1:53:15 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:53:15 Dax Shepard? Uh huh. That's out yesterday.
1:53:17 Speaker 01 Oh, it's out. Oh, my God. Ding ding ding. My episode of Mom, my, when I guessed it on Mom's Car. We answered that very question, so go check that out.
1:53:27 Dax Shepard? Yeah, yeah. And listen to Delta play the theme song.
1:53:30 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. So is it gonna replace?
1:53:32 Dax Shepard? No, no, no.
1:53:33 Speaker 01 Oh.
1:53:34 Dax Shepard? No.
1:53:34 Speaker 01 It should play at the end or something.
1:53:36 Dax Shepard? Yeah, Bob made a video today of everything that's going on. And his version is pretty complex. And so there are other layers that she'll learn.
1:53:48 Speaker 01 Cool.
1:53:49 Dax Shepard? Some of them she won't be able to, as he even said, like, some of them you gotta really span your finger. She just wouldn't have the span. It's gotta be frustrating when you're a little learning piano.
1:53:58 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, I tried, couldn't do it. Well, I could, but I didn't want to.
1:54:03 Dax Shepard? It's I it's no one wants to.
1:54:05 Speaker 01 I know.
1:54:06 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:54:06 Speaker 01 This is the practicing well.
1:54:09 Dax Shepard? You do hear these stories, but those are the phenoms.
1:54:11 Speaker 01 But that's how you become phenomenal.
1:54:14 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:54:14 Speaker 01 I think that is a good lesson. Like if this kid doesn't want to practice, I'm not gonna make them because then I they're never gonna be good at it.
1:54:25 Dax Shepard? I meet those so many people who say I'm so glad my generally mom.
1:54:31 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:54:32 Dax Shepard? Made me take piano. Yeah, forced me to take piano.
1:54:34 Speaker 01 No, I know, but I.
1:54:35 Dax Shepard? Like generally, everyone's grateful that had that experience.
1:54:39 Speaker 01 But this is what this is to me what I think happens. This is my mom. My mom said when I started and I was like, oh, I hate practicing.
1:54:46 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:54:47 Speaker 01 She was like, I regret, you know, it's always it's always the mom saying, I regret that I didn't get pushed into this and that I didn't wasn't forced to practice and you have to practice.
1:54:59 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:54:59 Speaker 01 You'll thank me one day.
1:55:01 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:55:02 Speaker 01 And then what happens is if you aren't self motivated to do it, you don't, you're not good.
1:55:09 Dax Shepard? Unless they withhold things you want. Like if they really can enforce the rules.
1:55:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:55:17 Dax Shepard? Then they would. But your mom wasn't willing to.
1:55:19 Speaker 01 Oh, no, I had to practice every day and I would just sit.
1:55:22 Dax Shepard? Oh, but why can't you play?
1:55:23 Speaker 01 Miserable and I would and I would just tink. I would I would play, but I hated it. It was like I associated with I associated it with such misery.
1:55:34 Dax Shepard? Uh huh.
1:55:34 Speaker 01 That over time I was like, I don't want to do it.
1:55:37 Dax Shepard? Right.
1:55:38 Speaker 01 And at that point, your mom has to be like, Kay, yeah, I guess you've been practicing for two years and you still hate it.
1:55:43 Dax Shepard? Well, they go, you can't watch TV until.
1:55:45 Speaker 01 You like it?
1:55:45 Dax Shepard? Played. No, because you weren't. The goal isn't to make you like it. The goal is to make you do it.
1:55:50 Speaker 01 Well, no, the goal is to make you do it so that.
1:55:54 Dax Shepard? You'll get good.
1:55:55 Speaker 01 It and get good and be self motivated.
1:55:57 Dax Shepard? Probably won't like it until you're good at it. So you can make music and that's very satisfying. It's not gonna be, it's not fun for anybody to suck at something. It's, it's quite unenjoyable to suck at things.
1:56:10 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:56:10 Dax Shepard? So like, the premise can't be, well, they gotta like it to do it. Cause no one's really gonna like it, except for these point zero zero one percent of their like born to be a concert pianist. And they're obsessed with it.
1:56:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I think people who are adults who play piano well, um, started liking it early on their own. And maybe they still had to be forced to practice, but probably when they were practicing, they like liked it and were, it was learning things and, and got excited about it at some point.
1:56:41 Dax Shepard? But could you ever play songs?
1:56:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, I played, I played The Entertainer, I played My Heart Will Go On.
1:56:46 Dax Shepard? Okay.
1:56:46 Speaker 01 I played a lot of songs.
1:56:48 Dax Shepard? And you didn't like it, never liked it. Even when you play those songs?
1:56:53 Speaker 01 I liked, yeah, I did like being able to play them.
1:56:56 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:56:57 Speaker 01 But I guess this is all to my point. I liked having this skill. I did not like getting to the skill and these skills increase and increase and increase. So I was, it was just never gonna happen.
1:57:10 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:57:11 Speaker 01 There are, there are other skills that I did work quite hard at.
1:57:15 Dax Shepard? Mm hmm.
1:57:15 Speaker 01 It also being very hard, but I wanted to be good at it.
1:57:19 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:57:19 Speaker 01 I think wanting to be good at it is sort of the key.
1:57:22 Dax Shepard? Yeah, yeah.
1:57:24 Speaker 01 I think. Um, all right, let's do some facts.
1:57:27 Dax Shepard? Facts.
1:57:28 Speaker 01 So one thing that I didn't say in the episode, but was thinking about, because we talked about like euphemism. And kind of the importance of it and why we do it. And why we sugarcoat or, you know, sidestep or don't say the thing.
1:57:51 Dax Shepard? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:57:52 Speaker 01 Cause once you say the thing, it's common knowledge and it's out there and it can, it can change an entire relationship.
1:57:59 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:58:00 Speaker 01 I was sitting with that after, cause I was like, that's, that's so antithetical to my approach to life. I'm so on it, like I, I'm like, we need to be honest. We need to be saying the things to the people.
1:58:14 Dax Shepard? Right.
1:58:14 Speaker 01 If something's happening, we need to call it out and say it. And I was like, huh.
1:58:23 Speaker 01 Maybe not.
1:58:24 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:58:24 Speaker 01 Maybe that is reckless and can um permanently alter a relationship. So it did make me think, standing on this like, I'm honest and I'm gonna say what's true and it's my job to say what's true and my job to call out bad things or whatever.
1:58:44 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:58:45 Speaker 01 Um, it's worth like, taking a beat.
1:58:47 Dax Shepard? Well, it's, it's not a, a new point I wanna make, but it's, it's crazy to me how many of these longstanding debates are really this kinda quintessential debate between Kantianism and utilitarianism. It's like, that's the Kantian approach. I don't lie cuz I don't lie. The, the, the ends does not justify the means. The means justifies the ends. Like, I do the right thing and the outcome is whatever it is.
1:59:13 Speaker 01 Exactly, yes.
1:59:14 Dax Shepard? And also, no, I, I, I want a certain outcome. So how do I get to the outcome? And it's kinda like, yeah, you could be dead honest and blah, blah, blah and stand on that, but if you start noticing the outcome of that is always bad, whereas I could play with, in this slightly dishonest, nuanced innuendo world.
1:59:34 Speaker 01 Right.
1:59:35 Dax Shepard? And save everyone face and keep relationships going. And it's like, okay, well, I just gotta prioritize, what is my goal in life? To maintain my relationships or, or be correct or what, you know?
1:59:44 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:59:45 Dax Shepard? And it's just, I think it's really interesting how many of our, many, many debates just are really that thing. Does the means justify the ends or does it not?
1:59:54 Speaker 01 Yes, I agree.
1:59:55 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
1:59:56 Speaker 01 Um, so that was really.
1:59:57 Dax Shepard? Can I say one other school thing he said when we were leaving?
2:00:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:00:00 Dax Shepard? I hope he would feel comfortable with this. I think he would. But we were, I walked him out to the curb so he could get out of here. And I don't know how we stumbled upon this, but somehow we were just talking about like, home life and family life. And he said, yeah, you know, I just, uh, I gotta remember my, you know, my opinion's not necessarily needed.
2:00:20 Speaker 01 Oh, he said that?
2:00:21 Dax Shepard? Which is my mantra, as you know. I like try to, um, the best version of myself is when I'm saying, your opinion's not needed here. And I don't know why I found that so comforting, that here's one of the smartest people in the world and he knows his opinion's not always needed.
2:00:35 Speaker 01 Was he talking about at home?
2:00:37 Dax Shepard? Yeah, like your family life, like.
2:00:39 Speaker 01 Interesting.
2:00:40 Dax Shepard? To keep cohesion in your family, you don't always need to say your fucking opinion. But. If this dude can come to that.
2:00:48 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:00:48 Dax Shepard? Who his opinion probably is.
2:00:51 Speaker 01 No.
2:00:51 Dax Shepard? It probably is.
2:00:53 Speaker 01 No.
2:00:53 Dax Shepard? More approaching the correct thing.
2:00:56 Speaker 01 If it's based in fact, that's the fallacy. It's like this smart person's opinion.
2:01:02 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
2:01:02 Speaker 01 Is perhaps better than others. It's still an opinion.
2:01:07 Dax Shepard? It's still an opinion, but I do think if there was somehow to do an opinion shootout with Steven Pinker and someone average off the street.
2:01:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:01:14 Dax Shepard? My hunch is I think his opinion would be correct more often than.
2:01:19 Speaker 01 I, I think that's a, I think that's not.
2:01:22 Dax Shepard? That's a fallacy.
2:01:22 Speaker 01 I think that's a fallacy because depending on what we're talking about.
2:01:26 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
2:01:27 Speaker 01 Yes, I think his opinion on, um, elite institutions, something we discussed in the episode. Is very valid because he has experience there and he's done a lot of research there. So like his opinion is based off of facts.
2:01:44 Dax Shepard? And a tremendous amount of history that he really understands.
2:01:48 Speaker 01 Yes, but his opinion on whether or not chocolate is a tasty treat is not more or less valid than anyone else's. So you just have to, but like we do that though. We as people are like, oh, this high status person's opinion in general is better.
2:02:07 Dax Shepard? This is the tech bro issue is like they are a genius in this little segment of knowledge. But should they be telling you what supplements to eat?
2:02:17 Speaker 01 Right.
2:02:17 Dax Shepard? Probably not.
2:02:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
2:02:19 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
2:02:19 Speaker 01 Yeah. Um, okay, so he mentions the giggle test. I didn't know what that was. Passing the giggle test refers to making an argument, proposal, or statement that is plausible, reasonable, and factually and emotionally sound enough to be presented with a straight face without eliciting laughter or appearing ridiculous.
2:02:38 Dax Shepard? Ah, the giggle test.
2:02:41 Speaker 01 Giggle test.
2:02:42 Dax Shepard? Well, that didn't pass the giggle test.
2:02:45 Speaker 01 Yes.
2:02:45 Dax Shepard? Is that what people say?
2:02:47 Speaker 01 But they would be laughing.
2:02:48 Dax Shepard? First they, that someone say their opinion, they go, and then like I go, well, I didn't pass the giggle test.
2:02:53 Speaker 01 Exact, yeah, you nailed it.
2:02:54 Dax Shepard? Okay, great. Moving on.
2:02:55 Speaker 01 We don't need to, yeah, we don't need to go back, we need to do that again. Did Steve Jobs steal the WIMP computer from Xerox? Um, while Apple leveraged ideas that Steve Jobs and his team saw at Xerox, it is inaccurate to say that Jobs stole WIMP, Windows Icons Menus Pointer, computers from them. The exchange was part of a formal deal, and the Apple team significantly refined and commercialized the technology for a mass audience. Okay, this is fun. So we talk about the Apple ad, the 1984 ad.
2:03:26 Dax Shepard? Oh, yeah, with the mallet.
2:03:28 Speaker 01 The Apple ad being one of the most famous commercials of all time, or, you know.
2:03:31 Dax Shepard? Iconic.
2:03:32 Speaker 01 Best, yeah. And so I have a list.
2:03:35 Dax Shepard? Oh, wonderful.
2:03:37 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:03:38 Dax Shepard? Oh, in the same batch where people were agreeing that, or are saying they also collected the milk ads, a lot of people had the same outrage I did about Thriller, and that was comforting. Yeah.
2:03:47 Speaker 01 I understand.
2:03:48 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
2:03:49 Speaker 01 Um, okay, I'm gonna do top ten.
2:03:53 Dax Shepard? Oh, okay.
2:03:56 Speaker 01 Okay, number one, Apple, 1984.
2:03:58 Dax Shepard? Really? That gets the number, who, who's this, who compiled this list?
2:04:01 Speaker 01 This one is from American Marketing Association.
2:04:04 Dax Shepard? A very trusted organization.
2:04:06 Speaker 01 Dot org.
2:04:07 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
2:04:08 Speaker 01 We should get shares that say dot org.
2:04:12 Dax Shepard? That'd be such a shitty shirt, don't you?
2:04:14 Speaker 01 Why?
2:04:14 Dax Shepard? I mean, with all respect to your feelings, if I saw a guy wearing a shirt that said like, dot com.
2:04:19 Speaker 01 You'd be, no, it's, that, it's, it's a,
2:04:23 Speaker 01 it's specifically not dot com, it's dot org, that's what's cool about it. And then you're like, what is that? And then you ask, and it's like, oh, trusted, it's really trusted.
2:04:31 Dax Shepard? Okay.
2:04:33 Speaker 01 Just aren't your expert.
2:04:33 Dax Shepard? I'm surprised you're not pitching dot edu, I guess. That a little makes sense for a shirt, because then you're like, I'm a student.
2:04:39 Speaker 01 Dot org is our thing.
2:04:41 Dax Shepard? It is our thing, but I, I, I'm not sure that dot org has the reputational excellence that you, I don't know that it really signifies.
2:04:53 Speaker 01 My god.
2:04:54 Dax Shepard? I stand down, I stand down. I just did the thing, I'm proud, I did it, yeah.
2:04:58 Speaker 01 Shared an opinion that was unnecessary.
2:04:59 Dax Shepard? You're right, you're right.
2:04:59 Speaker 01 Okay, Apple, 1984, directed by Ridley Scott.
2:05:05 Dax Shepard? Where's the beef Wendy's?
2:05:07 Speaker 01 Nope. Number two Nike Just Do It 1988. Nike's Just Do It, I guess is the first Just Do It
2:05:15 Dax Shepard? Wow.
2:05:16 Speaker 01 campaign redefined the brand and athletic marketing. The first commercial featured 80 year old marathoner Walt Ironman Stack jogging across the Golden Gate Bridge, paired with the now iconic slogan, "Just do it." Wow, cool.
2:05:32 Dax Shepard? Good stuff.
2:05:33 Speaker 01 Okay, three is Pepsi's Gladiator commercial. That is in 2003.
2:05:41 Speaker 01 Cinematic spectacle that brought pop culture to the Super Bowl stage. Set in a Roman Colosseum, the ad featured Beyonce Pink and Britney Spears as gladiators who defied the oppressive emperor played by Enrique Iglesias. The women overthrew the ruler and reclaimed their power, distributing Pepsi to a roaring crowd, all to the beat of Queens, "We Will Rock You."
2:06:00 Dax Shepard? Ah, I kinda wanna watch that one.
2:06:02 Speaker 01 Me too. For Old Spice. "The Man Your Man Could Smell Like." This is 2010. Okay, Old Spice revitalized its image with this humorous, fast-paced ad starring Isaiah Mustafa in just 30 seconds. Mustafa effortlessly transitioned from a shower to a boat to a horse, delivering witty one-liners about masculinity and confidence, all while promoting Old Spice Body Wash. The ad's absurd humor, sharp writing, and charismatic delivery made it a viral sensation.
2:06:32 Dax Shepard? You remember that one, right?
2:06:34 Speaker 01 I don't.
2:06:35 Dax Shepard? Alright, black guy, you can, I can see him on the boat. He's got a full naval getup at the end. He looks like a fisherman, what's a wharf's fisherman?
2:06:48 Speaker 01 Okay, five Snickers. "You're Not You When You're Hungry." Also, Super Bowl, Betty White. Group of friends plays a rough game of football with one player portrayed by White, performing poorly and getting tackled into the mud. A teammate hands her a Snickers bar and after taking a bite, she transforms into a young man, highlighting the message that hunger can make you act out of character.
2:07:08 Dax Shepard? Make you act like old woman.
2:07:10 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:07:12 Dax Shepard? Gordon's Fish.
2:07:13 Speaker 01 Gordon's Fish. Six Pepsi. Wow Pepsi.
2:07:17 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
2:07:17 Speaker 01 Scary Halloween 2019. Oh Pepsi's Halloween ad delivered a playful jab at its rival Coca-Cola. It featured a Pepsi can dress and a Coca-Cola cape with the tagline, "We wish you a scary Halloween." This tongue-in-cheek visual cleverly framed Coke as the scary choice while reinforcing Pepsi's bold and irreverent brand personality.
2:07:39 Dax Shepard? You know, it's crazy. They had such a good track record and they really shit the bed on that, um, BLM commercial they did. Remember that one?
2:07:46 Speaker 01 I don't remember.
2:07:47 Dax Shepard? It was like cops and protesters fighting and they decided to just have a Pepsi and everyone got along.
2:07:53 Dax Shepard? You don't remember? There's like a huge misfire.
2:07:55 Speaker 01 I don't remember. God.
2:07:57 Dax Shepard? Up there with Bud Light is a real.
2:07:58 Speaker 01 That's not good. Yeah. Okay. Seven Volkswagen Think Small. This is 1960. Okay, I'm not gonna read about that. Oh my God, IKEA. P here.
2:08:13 Dax Shepard? Oh, interesting.
2:08:13 Speaker 01 2017. IKEA's print ad pushed boundaries by inviting women to urinate on it. Yes, you read that right. The ad incorporated a pregnancy test.
2:08:24 Dax Shepard? What?
2:08:24 Speaker 01 If it detected pregnancy, a discount for a baby crib was revealed.
2:08:29 Dax Shepard? Oh my gosh. How could I have never heard that?
2:08:32 Speaker 01 That's great. 2017. Okay, nine US military. I want you. 1917, 19. These aren't commercials though. I don't love that. Okay, KFC. This is 10. Um, FCK. That's what it's called. FCK. This was 2018. When KFC faced a chicken shortage in the UK, the brand turned a crisis into a moment of humor and transparency. Their print ad featured an empty bucket with the letters FCK replacing the KFC logo, a cheeky acknowledgement of their misstep. That's fun.
2:09:04 Dax Shepard? Yeah, I like that.
2:09:05 Speaker 01 Okay, 11 is McDonald's. I'm loving it.
2:09:07 Dax Shepard? Oh, sure.
2:09:09 Speaker 01 Netflix says a joke is 12. Okay, okay.
2:09:13 Speaker 01 Um, oh, coral and their procreation on a full moon. What happens when it's cloudy? Basically, yeah, it, it, it messes it up.
2:09:22 Dax Shepard? Oh, it does mess it up. Okay, that's good to know. Makes you wonder if coral can even exist in places with like very consistent cloud. Like England and Michigan, it's fucking gray for eight months.
2:09:30 Speaker 01 Well, as long as it's consistent, then it would be fine. But it's, if it's, yeah, you can never know.
2:09:37 Dax Shepard? Like, like we, we had stretches in Michigan, right? Where we'd set these records with the, the sun hadn't broke through for 180 days. So you're looking at like six months of no moon cycle. They can't procreate. That would be problematic. But I guess they're always in tropical locations.
2:09:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, you're right. Oh, one more, sorry. Um, he said Bill Gates is, uh, the biggest philanthropist in the world. He's not. Um, he's a big philanthropist, but Indian industrialist.
2:10:09 Speaker 01 Jim, Jamseti, Jamseti Tata holds the title of the world's largest philanthropist of all time, having given a greater amount to charity than.
2:10:20 Dax Shepard? How much has he given?
2:10:21 Speaker 01 In 2025 list, Tata, Tata has donated 102.4 billion compared to Gates's 75.8 billion in lifetime giving.
2:10:31 Dax Shepard? Whoa. Well, he deserves that credit.
2:10:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, good job. Yeah.
2:10:38 Dax Shepard? Yeah.
2:10:40 Speaker 01 All right, that's it. Love you.
Previous Mom's Car: Monica Padman Next Armchair Anonymous: Valet Driver Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated