Pod Insights ABC Rewind 01 | A succulent chinese meal About this episode Who is the man behind Australia's most iconic internet meme, who famously said “What is the charge? Eating a meal, a succulent Chinese meal? Gentlemen, this is democracy manifest"? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjsDMqOdjiQ
Transcript 4,320 words · 21 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:07 Speaker 00 I'm David Marr, host of Late Night Live on Radio National.
0:10 Speaker 01 Very suave, erudite kind of guy.
0:13 Speaker 00 We're here to surprise, delight and maybe enrage you from time to time. We go where our curiosity leads.
0:20 Speaker 02 Let's talk crazy, let's act crazy, let's be crazy because then the enemy doesn't know what you're thinking.
0:26 Speaker 00 Late Night Live, four new shows a week on ABC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:36 Speaker 03 There's this Australian video that went viral. You may have seen it. It's known as "A Succulent Chinese Meal". It's a remarkable, spontaneous performance given by the late Jack Carlson, who died in 2024. Hello, Hilary Harper, bringing you ABC Rewind. And today we're following Lawrence Bull as he meets the man who declared to the police and to the world, "This is Democracy Manifest". And a warning, this episode contains some strong language, adult themes and graphic descriptions, so it's not one for little ears.
1:22 Speaker 04 Gentlemen, this is Democracy Manifest.
1:27 Speaker 05 The first time I came across this video, I had to go back and re-watch it a few times. It's hard to describe what makes it one of the most engaging videos on the internet.
1:36 Speaker 04 Have a look at the headlock here. See that chap over there? Get your hand off my penis!
1:42 Speaker 05 Watching it, I feel like I'm watching an absurd comedy and a great documentary rolled into one. The rarest of mash-ups.
1:50 Speaker 04 This is the bloke who got me on the penis before? Get some cups. Why did you do this? Get some cups. For what reason? What is the charge? Eating a meal? A succulent Chinese meal?
2:02 Speaker 05 If you haven't seen it before, here's what happens. The man being escorted to the police car has a handlebar moustache and looks to be in his late 40s. He immediately reaches out and shuts the car door and turns to wander off. When an officer opens the car door again and reaches for him, he gives an indignant look and slams the door closed again. The whole time, he's trying to put his sunglasses on.
2:26 Speaker 04 Oh, that's some nice headlocks, sir. Oh, ah, yes. I see that you know your judo well.
2:35 Speaker 05 He's outraged that he won't get a chance to address whoever's behind the camera. But then, as he stands steady while six police officers try to force him into a car, all he has to say is nonsense.
2:46 Speaker 04 And you, sir. Are you waiting to receive my limp penis? Now, take your hands off me.
2:53 Speaker 05 Finally, they tip him backwards like a tall piece of furniture and ease him in diagonally. As his head starts to dip out of sight, he says...
3:02 Speaker 04 Tada! And bail him.
3:06 Speaker 05 Surely, no innocent person would act like this. But it makes no sense that a guilty person would act like this either. I had the same questions as hundreds of the comments below the online video.
3:19 Speaker 06 What's the backstory to this?
3:22 Speaker 05 What did this guy do?
3:24 Speaker 06 Where and when did this happen?
3:25 Speaker 05 And why was he behaving like that?
3:26 Speaker 06 What was he even arrested for?
3:28 Speaker 05 Who was this guy?
3:29 Speaker 06 What happened to this legendary man?
3:32 Speaker 05 Some people said it was staged, maybe cut from a TV show.
3:35 Speaker 07 Is this real?
3:36 Speaker 05 Other people said it was a reenactment for a crime show.
3:39 Speaker 07 Who is this guy? Who is this guy?
3:42 Speaker 05 The most popular theory was that the man was an eccentric chess master named Paul Charles Dozer, who was famous for running out of restaurants without paying. He'd bragged that he held the world record for dining and dashing. And that's the theory that took off.
3:57 Speaker 08 Dozer's hilarious delivery and defiant attitude made him something of a folk hero in the eyes of many Australians, who consider him to be a lovable rogue.
4:07 Speaker 05 Newspapers and magazines like Who Weekly, New Idea, and The Daily Mail ran articles on Dozer, stating that he was the man in the video.
4:16 Speaker 09 Yes, this guy wasn't just some crazy old man. He was actually a chess champion.
4:22 Speaker 05 But some commentators weren't convinced.
4:26 Speaker 04 This is not Paul Dozer.
4:27 Speaker 05 Dozer had died in 2003, but people who claimed to know him said he spoke with a thick Hungarian accent.
4:33 Speaker 10 Well, I knew Paul Dozer, and this is not him.
4:36 Speaker 04 We're sure it's not him, not even close.
4:38 Speaker 10 Nothing like him.
4:39 Speaker 04 So who is this legend?
4:41 Speaker 05 This is Dozer explaining his dine and dash behaviour to the ABC a few years after the arrest video was made.
4:47 Speaker 11 The Hungarian Military Strategic Mine Research Organisation controlled my energy figured through ex-Soviet Union satellite. I know it sounds unbelievable.
5:00 Speaker 05 The more I learnt, the more questions I had.
5:05 Speaker 05 But nobody came forward with a better explanation. So, despite millions of views over many years, it seemed like the identity of the man and the reason for his bizarre arrest would remain a mystery.
5:19 Speaker 05 Until late 2019, when another video appeared online.
5:23 Speaker 04 You ready? Yep. What do you want me to say? Democracy Manifest. Gentlemen, this is Democracy Manifest. Get your heads off my penis. And also get your...
5:39 Speaker 05 It's him, the man who was arrested outside the Chinese restaurant. He's indoors, sitting down, eating at a table. He's 30 years older, but it's finally him. But there's no explanation. We're not told who he is, where he is, nothing.
5:57 Speaker 05 Six months later, another video appears on YouTube.
6:00 Speaker 04 Ladies and gentlemen, I am Mr Democracy Manifest, not some Hungarian chess player. It is I.
6:09 Speaker 05 It's him again. This time he's alone, talking directly to the camera. He says his famous arrest outside the restaurant had been a case of mistaken identity, and he'd acted that way because he wanted the police to put him in an asylum where he could easily escape. Then he plays an old news report from the time of his infamous arrest.
6:30 Speaker 12 When Cecil George Edwards was arrested in the Chinatown Mall last Friday, the Valley Police thought they had one of Queensland's most wanted. Instead, he was a petty criminal, working under several aliases, the police allege, a con man with a flair for acting.
6:44 Speaker 04 What is the charge? Eating a meal? A succulent Chinese meal? Oh, that's a nice headlock, sir.
6:53 Speaker 05 I can't make sense of this news story. Heaps of police showed up, media in tow, and arrested this man, thinking he was one of Queensland's Most Wanted. He wasn't the criminal they were looking for, but by amazing coincidence, he was also a wanted criminal. And he just happened to be committing a crime right at the moment they mistakenly caught him. How does that happen? What are the odds? But now, there's a lead. He's selling merchandise plastered with pictures and quotes from his famous video.
7:26 Speaker 13 Get your hand off my penis. Rather go and clasp a bottle of this wonderful Pinot Noir.
7:33 Speaker 05 So after a few emails and a lot of waiting, I get him on the line.
7:40 Speaker 13 Hello, Lawrence. My name's Jack and I have many other aliases.
7:44 Speaker 05 It's good to talk to you.
7:45 Speaker 13 Yeah.
7:47 Speaker 05 Let's go to that time in the 90s when they took you out of the restaurant.
7:51 Speaker 13 Hmm.
7:51 Speaker 05 What were you doing in the restaurant?
7:53 Speaker 13 I had a mate with me. We were having a good feed, which it was a restaurant I used to go to quite often. Next moment, they've ran in. I knew they had the wrong bloke. So I thought, well, why not let them think that I'm a lunatic? So that's why I was uttering all these things. Get your hand off my penis and... Because I remember once, I got into a place. I had me drill going into the safe and they fell on me. The police. Got me back to the police station and I'm giving them cheek and they're bashing me. They used to love bashing you.
8:35 Speaker 13 So I'd pull me dick out and say, keep hitting me again. I love it. Come on, hit me again. And I'd keep trying to masturbate as they're smashing me. And they sent me to the Good and the Lunatic asylum.
8:53 Speaker 13 And I escaped from there quite easily.
8:56 Speaker 14 So that was your plan. So that's where get your hand off my penis came from.
9:00 Speaker 13 Maybe, maybe, maybe, maybe. I were looking for a Hungarian chess player, Doza.
9:10 Speaker 13 Once we got back to the police station, of course, they found out that I wasn't this Hungarian dashin' diner. And they gave me bail.
9:23 Speaker 05 This doesn't make sense. How could the police have possibly mistaken him for Doza? Also, Doza's crime was running out on restaurant bills. There was no way he was one of Queensland's Most Wanted. And you wouldn't send a small army of police officers to arrest him.
9:41 Speaker 14 You were using stolen credit cards at that time, or what was going on?
9:45 Speaker 13 No, no, no. I did nothing wrong in the restaurants. I love a restaurant.
9:51 Speaker 14 Didn't you have to pay bail?
9:52 Speaker 13 Oh, yeah, yeah, of course. That was when they charged me with resisting arrest.
9:58 Speaker 14 They said they also charged you with fraud and receiving stolen property.
10:02 Speaker 13 Did they?
10:02 Speaker 14 That's what they said in the paper.
10:04 Speaker 05 I don't understand why Jack doesn't just acknowledge the fraud charges. But he's not talking, or he genuinely doesn't know. So I leave it for now.
10:13 Speaker 14 And they call you Cecil Jerry Edwards.
10:15 Speaker 13 Oh, you're going back to when I was sixteen years of age. That was my name.
10:22 Speaker 14 Oh, really?
10:22 Speaker 13 Yes.
10:23 Speaker 14 Because this was in ninety-one that I'm talking about.
10:25 Speaker 13 I'm going back to nineteen fifty-eight. You weren't even alive then.
10:32 Speaker 14 Yeah.
10:35 Speaker 13 I was with a couple of blokes and they robbed a place. And I was in the backseat drinking brandy vino. That's all we could get in them days. And they arrested us. So I had a trial. And I thought I'd defend myself.
10:53 Speaker 13 What an idiot thing to do. Imagine me, a seventy-year-old boy. I was actually cross-examining the coppers in courts like some lawyer. The other two older blokes said, "Yeah, we're guilty." "We're guilty." I said, "I know nothing about it. I'm not guilty." So I got five years in jail when I was seventy years old. The blokes who'd done the crime got three years.
11:24 Speaker 05 It's odd to me that Jack would laugh at something so distressing, but he does it so often during our conversation that I stopped noticing. Jack went to Boggo Road Jail, maximum security and notorious for its brutal conditions.
11:43 Speaker 13 And they put me in a cell with two other boys, and the food was disgusting. And I said to them, I said, "Come, mates, we can't eat this one tonight, but we're hungry. We'll have to eat it." And we all had diarrhoea. In those days, cells didn't have toilets or sinks or anything. And the shit tub, it was overflowing. We were vomiting. So I've knocked up on the door and I said, "Screw. Can we have another shit tub, please?" They said, "No. One cell, one shit tub." So then I just threw a bucket of shit over the cheap water. Got this.
12:29 Speaker 13 Well, they come in, they flogged me and and they put me in what they call the Black Peter. Not many people have been in the Black Peter.
12:42 Speaker 13 There's a huge trapdoor. You go down these steps
12:49 Speaker 13 into a dungeon, I think, and it's all dark.
12:55 Speaker 13 You're on a braiding water.
13:00 Speaker 13 That was horrible.
13:05 Speaker 13 Oh, I don't want to think about this.
13:09 Speaker 05 Jack says the Black Peter was the worst thing he'd ever experienced. He'd bang on the doors and fight with the guards just so he could see the light for a few minutes while they bashed him. The man in the cell next to him had been there for months. He finally lost his mind and was hauled off to an asylum.
13:31 Speaker 05 Jack still has nightmares about the Black Peter.
13:35 Speaker 05 He still sleeps with the lights on.
13:38 Speaker 05 After that, he couldn't tolerate being in the cell anymore. Being locked up, he felt he couldn't breathe. He had to get out.
13:52 Speaker 13 I was being escorted from Bogger Road in a train. I was handcuffed to some other bloke. I say to myself, I'm not going to front on this blue.
14:03 Speaker 13 I was pretending to be asleep and the cop opposite me, he's nodding off a bit, so I've just undone the handcuff with the prong of me belt, tippy-tay down the corridor and leapt out of the bloody train.
14:21 Speaker 13 It's a wonder I didn't smash into a bloody signal post or something. But from there, I was careful. I'd just stay in the bush for the day and other night I'd walk. Managed to get a car and I ended up in Sydney anyway.
14:42 Speaker 13 It was so beautiful to breathe that air.
14:47 Speaker 13 I met a beautiful woman. I married her. I had a child to her. All I wanted to do was live a decent life. I didn't want screws hitting me with battens. I didn't want to be in Black Peters. I didn't want to be told what to do and I got out and it was so beautiful.
15:07 Speaker 05 After he tells me about his time in prison, I start to understand Jack's behaviour in the video. He was traumatised in custody and he was prepared to take big risks to avoid going back. I want to keep him talking. He isn't about to own up to any crimes in the restaurant, but I want him to tell me enough about his criminal history so I can figure out what he might have been up to inside the restaurant before his famous diatribe.
15:32 Speaker 13 Eventually, a bloke said to me, "Mate, we can open a safe this way." "We didn't rob the poor, we only robbed the scum that are robbing us, the banks and the other vermin."
15:50 Speaker 05 Jack got four years for safe-cracking. He ended up in French Island Prison Farm in the middle of Westernport Bay, outside Melbourne.
15:58 Speaker 13 The governor called me and he showed me all these photos of prisoners who tried to escape, eaten by sharks or drowned. "You can't get away from here." "Oh, I don't want to get away from here, governor. It looks like a wonderful paradise." "But soon as I got there, there's me mate Pete, working in the vegetable garden." "Two days later, me and Pete, we just took off."
16:29 Speaker 05 Jack and Pete walked overnight, down by the water, so the tide would cover their footprints by morning.
16:37 Speaker 05 After dodging search patrols for a week, they came across a motorboat, circling aimlessly in shallow water.
16:44 Speaker 13 And then all of a sudden we heard it bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum. "What the fuck's that?" Going out, left the board,
16:55 Speaker 13 and there was a bloke asleep. I wake him up, I said, "You must be them prisoners that escaped there,
17:04 Speaker 13 took us across to the mainland."
17:08 Speaker 13 "What a good man, what a good man. A Scotchman, he was a Scotchman."
17:15 Speaker 13 "There's such a beautiful thing when you can escape from tyranny." "God, I felt so good."
17:27 Speaker 13 Tried to steal a couple of cars to get back to Sydney and then we tried to get acquitted. Eventually got pinched.
17:34 Speaker 05 Jack and his mate got caught cruising Parramatta late at night with safe braking tools. So at the courthouse, waiting for his trial to start, Jack put on a performance, a bit like the one outside the restaurant. He pretended to be a cop.
17:52 Speaker 13 It was a big cell with about 20 people in it.
17:56 Speaker 13 And I pretended to walk in and looked like a detective. I was only 25. So I grabbed me mate. I said, "Open this cell door, you know I am Detective Sergeant Rogers. Open this door. I'm taking this man round to the forecourt." All the blokes in the cell were saying, "You copper dog Rogers." Because I geared him up. And I grabbed me mate, he said, "I'm not going." And I've had to give him a couple of punches like coppers normally do. And he opened the door.
18:32 Speaker 13 Away we walked.
18:37 Speaker 13 I've got eight years for that. But that's life, isn't it?
18:45 Speaker 05 Jack spent almost a quarter of a century growing up in jails and boys' homes. Then at age 33, he was finally free.
18:54 Speaker 13 That was beautiful, to have that freedom again.
19:00 Speaker 13 To get parole, you had to have a job. And they got me a job on the TV, doing things like pretending to be a police informer and all the things that I'm not.
19:18 Speaker 13 Division four, cop shop, Matlock Police, homicide. These were things that were on the TV every week.
19:31 Speaker 13 You know how we got sacked?
19:34 Speaker 13 There was a scene in the back of a pub.
19:39 Speaker 05 In the scene, a young Jack and the other actors are drinking around a barrel of beer.
19:44 Speaker 13 And it's a real barrel.
19:47 Speaker 04 You're wrong, mister. Bloody point, I tell you. Reverend Hartley done what he's supposed to do. Got them off their bums out doing a bit of work.
19:54 Speaker 13 They got a take of that ten shots. And the director said, "Just have a sip, pour it out, have a sip, tip it out." And I said to you blokes, "Don't tip it out, don't you dare. Just fucking keep drinking." And we kept drinking and they think that... You know how stilted those shit was, that stuff? But this wasn't stilted, no. A fair dick and drunk.
20:18 Speaker 04 Let me put it this way, T. Yes. If everybody bloody person round here was as hard as some people I know, then we may as well all toss it in.
20:32 Speaker 13 So they sacked me. So I fled to Queensland because I lost my parole.
20:41 Speaker 05 Let's go to that video when they took you out of the restaurant. Why did you say, "This is democracy manifest"? Is that a political statement?
20:50 Speaker 13 At the time, everyone's talking about how wonderful democracy is. Maybe that could have been a political statement.
21:01 Speaker 13 "Gentlemen, this is democracy manifest." As they got me round the throat and putting handcuffs on me.
21:18 Speaker 05 Jack's arrest outside the Chinese restaurant is making more and more sense. He'd been a serial escaper, a fraudster and a performer. I want to ask him more, but I can tell he's getting tired and wants to go.
21:33 Speaker 05 Maybe the cops had been after Jack. They might have sent a lot of police because they were worried he'd try to escape again. Also, he clearly had a criminal history. Who knows what he could have been wanted for? This would explain a lot, except why would the news report call him a petty criminal?
21:53 Speaker 05 I figure someone out there knows something. So I scour thousands of YouTube comments for snippets of information. Eventually, I come across a commenter who said their university lecturer was one of the detectives in the arrest video.
22:09 Speaker 15 The cop in the red tie is my lecturer at Queensland University of Technology in Australia. He's now a professor in law school and showed us this video of his earlier career.
22:20 Speaker 15 I couldn't believe it.
22:23 Speaker 05 I contact the university and after some convincing, I get the former detective on the line. His name's Dean.
22:32 Speaker 05 In the video, Dean's the one trying to order Jack into the car.
22:35 Speaker 16 Sit down inside the car. We're not assuring anything. We're under arrest. Look, I'm under what?
22:41 Speaker 17 My partner and I at the time, we were sitting in the fraud squad on a Friday afternoon and there's not usually that much happening in the fraud squad on a Friday afternoon. There certainly wasn't back in those days. We were probably cleaning which pub we were about to go to. The last thing we wanted to do was be involved in some dramatic incident on the streets.
22:59 Speaker 05 They got a call to go down to Fortitude Valley to help some uniformed officers.
23:04 Speaker 17 And turning the corner there at Chinatown in the valley to where the restaurant was and just been confronted by this wall of people and cameras. It was like they were behind barricades with police sort of manning the barricades. It was almost like a film set or something.
23:20 Speaker 17 So we went into the restaurant and there was heaps of other police. The uniformed inspector or whatever said to us, listen, we don't know what to do with this guy. For us, it was just a matter of working out what we could charge him with.
23:33 Speaker 05 And what was the charge? Eating a meal or sucking a Chinese meal?
23:37 Speaker 17 Yeah, yeah. He had like an American Express card and it was either forged or in the wrong name. So I suspect we charged him with forgery or something like that.
23:50 Speaker 05 On the news, they said, police had been hoping to arrest one of Queensland's Most Wanted. And instead, they got this guy. Who were they talking about, one of Queensland's Most Wanted?
24:01 Speaker 17 I don't know where that would have come from. I mean, he wasn't Dillinger or anything like that, but he also wasn't just some fly-by-night guy. It wasn't they were going, why did we go through all that drama just for a $70 skip check on a meal or something?
24:14 Speaker 05 Yeah. Since then, the narrative now on the internet is that you were hoping to catch Paul Dozer, the dine-and-dasher, and you ended up getting this guy, Jack Carlson.
24:27 Speaker 17 Utter rubbish, utter rubbish.
24:31 Speaker 05 After struggling to get Jack into the car,
24:34 Speaker 05 the police took him to the watchhouse.
24:38 Speaker 05 But when Dean showed up for work the next morning, Jack was long gone.
24:43 Speaker 17 He managed to talk them into thinking that he would be a safe bet to let out. It was a shock to us when we found out the next day that the watchhouse had let him out.
24:53 Speaker 05 Jack ran off and didn't show up to court.
24:55 Speaker 18 Brisbane's credit card con man, picked up at a Valley restaurant a week ago, has gone to ground.
25:01 Speaker 19 Anyone with information is asked to call Crime Stoppers.
25:04 Speaker 17 From that point on, it was sort of a case of trying to track him down again.
25:08 Speaker 05 Dean remembers the alleged credit card fraud being in the tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars. He staked out a Commonwealth bank branch for days, hoping Jack would stop by.
25:19 Speaker 17 I mean, he became a bit of an enigma in a way, the way he sort of disappeared. For someone who was such an accomplished actor like him, it seemed all perfectly set up for him to do his sort of scene in front of the camera.
25:34 Speaker 05 So you're aware of his acting credits?
25:36 Speaker 17 No, I'm not.
25:38 Speaker 17 It sounds like you're going to tell me something here.
25:42 Speaker 05 Did you ever watch any of the old Crawford police shows?
25:46 Speaker 17 Oh, I love Homicide.
25:50 Speaker 17 What are you gonna tell me now? He's did a bit part in that or something?
25:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, he's in Homicide.
25:54 Speaker 17 You're kidding me.
25:56 Speaker 04 I tell you, I went in for two pots, that's all. I come out here, had to go back on me rounds. And me bloody car's gone. Are you sure it was in this street? Course I'm sure. A man spends a fortune paying off his car, what, for some rotten galahad to come along and knock it off? I know, I know it's a free country and democracy and all that, but street, hell the hell.
26:21 Speaker 05 Dean's sure they weren't in the Chinese restaurant to arrest Dozer or any other criminal. They were there to arrest Jack, which makes sense.
26:31 Speaker 05 Jack was using stolen credit cards, and the reason he won't admit it is that he skipped bail and never went to court.
26:40 Speaker 05 But I'm still no closer to understanding why a small army of police turned up, or the media. Dean couldn't explain it either.
26:50 Speaker 05 But most of all, I want to understand why Jack acted like that. He says he was acting insane, but that doesn't make much sense.
26:59 Speaker 05 Is insanity even a defence for eating out on stolen credit cards? Why did he say those bizarre and hilarious lines that have become so beloved? Why was he delivering them like a thespian monologue?
27:12 Speaker 05 In our last interview, Jack mentioned acting on stage and talked about his bit parts on crime dramas. But when I play back the recording, I pick up on something I didn't notice before.
27:24 Speaker 04 To get parole, he had to have a job. And they got me a job with Crawford McNeil got me out.
27:30 Speaker 05 McNeil. The name didn't mean anything to me at the time, but I find out he was a famous playwright who did all of his writing from prison. He was also an alcoholic and a fiercely vocal critic of the justice system.
27:44 Speaker 04 Gentlemen, this is democracy manifest.
27:50 Speaker 05 I book a flight to Queensland to meet Jack in person. It turns out, everything he's told me so far is just the entree to the incredible story behind this succulent Chinese meal.
28:03 Speaker 03 Next time in Rewind, you'll meet the playwright Jim McNeil, who introduced Jack Carlson to acting when they were cellmates in Parramatta Jail. And Laurence solves the mystery of why Jack was arrested outside the Chinese restaurant.
28:16 Speaker 20 He put on a great performance for the media. And I say a great performance because as soon as we got in the car and as soon as we drove away, he stopped and he actually said to us, "That was fun."
28:33 Speaker 03 A succulent Chinese meal was written and produced by Laurence Ball. The sound designer was John Jacobs and the supervising producer was Claudia Taranto. A Rewind production for ABC Radio National.
28:45 Speaker 15 You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC Podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Previous 07| Boycott! | Rugby, Rebels and Reconciliation Next 02 | A succulent chinese meal Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated