Pod Insights a16z Podcast Easing the Housing Crisis by Building Better Tools About this episode In the U. S., homeownership continues to be the foundation of the American dream — not to mention the primary driver of wealth creation. In this session, Divvy Homes Cofounder and CEO Adena Hefets talks to a16z General Partner Katherine Boyle about why she started Divvy, some common misperceptions about the rent-to own model, and how government investment — even regulation — could smooth the path for innovation in the housing market.
Transcript 0:21 Speaker 2 So great to have you here.
0:23 Speaker 1 So you have an incredible life story that I would love for you to share about why you became so inspired to found Divi. So if we can just start with talking about your background, your story, and why this mission matters so much to you.
0:35 Speaker 0 Sure. So first I just want to say thank you to Catherine and David Yulovich for putting this on. There aren't many conferences where we get to celebrate companies that focus on this topic. And so thank you for showcasing us. Also, she's growing a baby on stage while she's hosting. Because it was an obvious. Come on, everyone. The most impressive.
1:02 Speaker 0 So I'll I'll give you a little bit of my background and then we can dive into a little bit more about Divi and what we do. So as Catherine mentioned, my goal at Divi is to make homeownership accessible. And this mission is so meaningful for me because for my family growing up, owning a home was everything. My dad had immigrated from Israel. He, when he came to the US, couldn't speak English, didn't have a FICO score, met my mom, and they got pregnant. It was the 80s, and they were like, okay, now what do we do? And they're like, okay, we have we should find a home. And realized that they couldn't get a mortgage. They were really fortunate that they found a woman who gave them seller financing on the home. 34 Abbey Drive, they they had three additional children in that house, so four total.
1:47 Speaker 0 And every time one of us went to college, they would refinance and cash out. They finally were able to get a mortgage and they would refinance the property and cash out and use that cash to pay for me and my siblings to go to college. And you know, to me, this is the heart of the American dream, which is providing a life for your children, which is better than the one that you had, and doing that by being able to work, invest in property, and grow wealth for your next generation.
2:15 Speaker 1 So I mean, this is something, as you said, that everyone cares about politically, it's such a political issue on both sides. Everyone agrees like homeownership is the path to wealth creation in America. Why is it so hard for people to get a mortgage and for people to access affordable homes?
2:29 Speaker 0 Yeah. So this is a fun fact. So I just did the new calculation today, based off of our 7.15% average 30-year fixed rate mortgage. Um, and then based off of an average home price of 400,000, 400,000, which is the average home price in in the US, um, only 20%, 20% of Americans based off the median income at different levels uh can actually afford a home. So 80% of Americans, people living in your districts, uh in in your in the areas that you represent cannot actually access mortgage. And you might be saying, well, why? So there's a couple of reasons. I would say the biggest thing that it comes back to is that mortgages were created in the 1940s, right? That was kind of the mortgages had been around for a little while, but they were actually first pooled and securitized starting right around in the 1940s when people came back post-World War II.
3:23 Speaker 0 And the underwriting criteria and the way mortgages were structured were determined then and have yet to evolve since that point in time. So the underwriting criteria, the down payment requirements, most of how the industry functions is almost a hundred years old. Uh and the last time we tried to innovate, uh, as as one of my board members who worked at Fannie Mae, uh, she was the COO of Fannie Mae, she said it best, where she said, Adina, the last time we tried to innovate, we caused a global housing lab recession. So we're not gonna do that again, or at least not anytime soon. Um and so the biggest reasons why people can access homeownership today, number one is the down payment. Number two is FICO, number three is income.
4:09 Speaker 0 The way that our population or Americans today make income is more varied than it had been in the past. And in the 1940s, we didn't account for things like 1099 workers, gig economy, uh, people working multiple jobs, being self-employed. So these are all things that make it extremely challenging to get a mortgage. Um, and it's something that we try to address at Divi.
4:33 Speaker 1 Yeah, so I mean, seeing those problems, knowing that those are the core factors why 80% of Americans are are left out of this. How did you decide, okay, this is the business model we need to pursue with Divi, and this is how we're gonna fix the problem.
4:45 Speaker 0 That uh that's a great question. So I I didn't wake up, so I'll give you a quick overview on what Divi does for those of you who don't know. Um Divi creates homeowners, and we do that through a rent-to-own program. Uh the way that the rent-to-own program works is meant to mimic a mortgage. Uh so a customer comes to us, we will underwrite them and we'll say, hey, you're approved for let's call it $350,000 home in Atlanta, Georgia. Go out shopping. They get the budget the same way they would get a pre-approval letter for a mortgage, they go out shopping, they find the house that they want. So they are picking out the home, they bring the home to Divi. Divi buys that property for them, we take care of all the inspection, title checks, everything for them. They don't pay a single penny up until we're about to go to closing, um, at which point they sign a lease with an option to purchase.
5:36 Speaker 0 We ask them to commit one percent that we call in very legal east terms a initial savings contribution, but essentially it's like a down payment. Um so that's their initial equity skin in the game, which is one percent. And then every month when they move in, they make one monthly payment, part rent, part equity, the same way that with your mortgage, you pay uh principal and interest, it's just rent and equity, and they can build up ownership. So their 1% goes to 1.2, 1.4, 1.6 every month, and we let them build up to 10% ownership over three years. And so that was the original product. Uh, at any point in time, they could roll that equity onto mortgage, they can cash out their their equity. Um the funny thing is that I came up with this model because I noticed that it was really hard to get a mortgage, and I thought, okay, there has to be a way to structure this.
6:27 Speaker 0 There has to be a way to structure it such that you're not taking credit risk on the individual. I locked myself uh at that time in my apartment, and um I modeled out every way you can make it easier for someone to buy a home, the way that you could take if they weren't gonna be homeowners, they were gonna be renters, and I thought, let me figure out a structure where this could work. Um I didn't know that the rent-to-own industry existed. I hadn't known its predatory history, um, and I just came up with this idea, and I actually got my first customer, Teresa Peterson. Um I got her by putting an ad up on Craigslist. I said, can anyone not afford a home and want me to help you buy it? And that was the first customer, and now tens of thousands of customers later were now offering this out across 20 different metros and nine different states.
7:16 Speaker 1 That's incredible. And one of the things I loved about your first customers too was that you were based in San Francisco, your team's based in San Francisco, but a lot of the the first customers, the early markets you went into were Middle America. Tell us about how you chose your markets, how you decided that you wanted to work in states that are sometimes ignored by tech.
7:32 Speaker 0 So the the first choice to go in uh to a new market was quite easy. We had um we had raised a three million dollar seed round. And if you do the math and you're buying homes, three million dollars doesn't get you very far in certain geographies. So I looked at a map and I said, where can we buy the cheapest homes in America so I can actually prove out this model uh and see where I can take it? And that took us to Cleveland, Ohio, which was the first market that that we started in. Um and it worked remarkably well, and from there, we started actually getting more disciplined and taking a more quantitative approach to figuring out which markets we thought one, we can serve the most number of individuals, two, where we can produce a really good return for our investors. My view is that you will not be successful in this if you don't produce good returns for your your investors as well and can't build a big business.
8:23 Speaker 0 Um and since that time, we're now our biggest market is in Georgia, Atlanta, Georgia, Florida, and Texas are our three biggest markets.
8:31 Speaker 1 And tell us about some of the the homeowners. I know you have really interesting stories about your your first customers, the the profiles like tell us about who you who you were helping in the early days. Sure.
8:41 Speaker 0 Um so our customers on average uh make a household income right around 100,000. There's usually uh a co-applicant, so it's two applicants, usually on a given house, 100,000 of total household income. 51% of our customers are non-salaried, meaning that they're they're not W-2. They'll be 1099 hourly, um, so gig economy. 25% of our customers work in healthcare. So nurses, X-ray tax, uh, teachers, transportation, warehouse facility retail workers, all of those are kind of our core, our core customer base. Over 50% of our customers are underrepresented minorities. And with our transactions, uh, they're 80% female led. Um and so those are just a little bit of the stats.
9:26 Speaker 0 Um, but we're really proud to make sure that we're serving a population that isn't the coastal elites. We we don't operate in San Francisco and New York. We don't plan to operate in those in those metros. And what we do is we provide a path for people who we think have traditionally been ignored by by uh the financing options out there today.
9:50 Speaker 1 Yeah, and we see this with a lot. I mean, you mentioned rent to own and predatory history, how companies have done things wrong and how you didn't even know about them before you started the company. But it's like, you know, we see this a lot with financial inclusion companies. Companies where technologists will will come up with a model and there will be this sort of predatory history, or there will be this sort of negative connotation of, well, what are you doing to people in the press? Walk us through how you navigated that, how you've innovated on the model so that it's not predatory. Like walk us through what you realize the history of this industry, how you could change it.
10:19 Speaker 0 Sure. So let's maybe back up a little bit, which is the history of rent to own, mostly it took off during the 1980s, and the reason why it was so categorized as predatory was because one, the tenant uh didn't pick out the homes. So generally the homes would not have been kept up as well. Two, the tenant didn't build equity in the property. So they were just paying above market rent, and generally couldn't save up for mortgage to be able to ever buy back the property. And then the third major difference is they used to uh force the customer, which is which is illegal to pay uh maintenance taxes and insurance on the property. So Divi really takes a completely different twist to this, which is you are picking out the home, you're building equity in the property, and we are covering all maintenance, all taxes, all insurance.
11:07 Speaker 0 We are offering you free credit counseling, we're putting you on the right path. I also though take full responsibility that I've chosen to build a company in an industry that has a very tainted reputation, and it is on me to set the the uh the precedent of being able to provide what I think is a really great and fair product. So the the ethos behind Divi and all of our employees is every decision you make for a customer, make the decision that you would be making for your parents for your family. So when you're setting the lease contract terms, when you're figuring out how to handle a situation, treat every customer that way. Um at first this was really difficult. I spent a tremendous amount of time going through every detail of our lease contract, like nonstop worrying over every little thing we've done.
11:55 Speaker 0 And I wish there was guidance. I wish there was more someone to tell me, right? Here's here's what's okay, and then this is how you should think about setting the buyback price that the tenant can buy back the home at. So here's an example I constantly grapple with. Um, you know, the tenant eventually has to buy back the property. We use a third party source because we wanted it to be completely separate from us to predict appreciation, and then on in general, it'll average call of 5% a year. Well, um, in the last two years, as the price of homes started running up, you saw some markets that were appreciating up 15 to 20% a
12:31 Speaker 1 year.
12:32 Speaker 0 And I couldn't look my tenants in the eye and say, hey, your your buyback price is gonna appreciate over three years by 50%. It didn't feel right to me. So instead of using exactly what that third party said, I set a cap and I said we're not gonna charge any more than 6% appreciation annually. And I don't know where to pull that number from, right? I we obviously did a ton of analysis to get at that, but these are rules that you have to set and policies that you have to enforce
13:01 Speaker 2 when
13:01 Speaker 0 you're creating a new industry, right? Is you are setting the level at which you should be operating and what is required for the rest of your team. There's no right or wrong answer in a lot of these areas, in a lot of these industries, which are category creators. Yeah.
13:15 Speaker 1 No, and we've talked a lot about the fact that, especially post-2008 in housing, but this is you know true for many different companies that are trying to innovate on models. You want to engage with a regulator very early, but oftentimes the regulators don't want to engage because there's so much worry that things could go wrong. These are very complicated markets. As you said, we want guidance, but sometimes giving the guidance, they don't want to be cut holding the bag. How does Washington work in some of these, you know, these are the most important industries to Americans? Everyone wants to be able to build home ownership. How do you suggest that regulators work better with with startups like yourself, with founders like you who who want to engage early with regulators, understand what the regulations are, what the requild that build the regulations for new industries together versus doing it alone and then asking for for forgiveness if something goes wrong?
14:00 Speaker 0 Look, I was having a debate with someone yesterday, which who is the onus on, right? Is the onus on government to reach out to us and say, hey, let's have a conversation. And truthfully, I don't think that's the case. I think the onus is on us companies to make sure we are opening up that dialogue, that we're showing up for events like this, that I'm actually reaching out and trying to have the conversation. I can promise you, starting a company is not easy. You wake up, you know, just about, well, first of all, you wake up five times in the middle of the night. But when you finally get up at like about you know six in the morning, you are online and working straight through the day, and to have to take a moment and take a step back and be like, oh, wait, did I do you know the proper amount of government relations or am I flying out to take care of this? It's hard, right? It's hard. I don't, we don't know who to talk to.
14:47 Speaker 0 I don't know who to reach out to. I don't know what the communication style is. And so I think we're trying to make inroads, but I think that using consultant firms or consultancy firms to help us actually make those connections and giving us a platform by which we can openly say, hey, I want to start this dialogue. Here is how here is how you can reach out, reach out to us and use this uh mechanism, and this is the way in which you should get in touch with us and start to do that. I'd love to have that dialogue. And if anyone's in this room who who actually uh works either CFPB or regulators, I I'm openly saying I would love to be able to sanity check a lot of our assumptions against what y'all think. Yeah.
15:23 Speaker 1 No, and I I want to end by by asking, you're you're one of the most thoughtful people on macro on where the housing markets are going. I'm sure a lot of people in this room want to hear your predictions on what's going to happen over the next year, what we're seeing in the housing market. You could walk us through sort of high level what you think is gonna happen, obviously with the caveat that no one ever knows for sure. Uh, but walk us through sort of how you're how you're predicting it. And then, you know, the other thing we've seen too that we'll talk more about later today is, you know, I was just sharing, like I moved to Miami almost two years ago. We're seeing sort of this great migration that's really changing the housing market. So I would love your your thoughts on that as well.
15:55 Speaker 0 Uh yeah, I would say right now, if you look at any institution, whether it's an iBuyer, uh a single family rental platform, Divi, then we're not buying homes right now. Home prices are going to decline, and we're seeing it, and we're seeing home prices decline. Started probably back in the second week of July was when we really started to see the market soften. And as interest rates have gone up, we have seen home prices falling, and it's very geodependent, but in some places upwards of 15% from peak already, which is a tremendous amount to see home prices fall in a very short period of time. So our view is one, obviously inflation should be the core focus uh right now in getting that under control, but in raising interest rate that passes almost directly through to the consumer in terms of what they're going to pay in mortgages.
16:48 Speaker 0 And what we are seeing is that demand is falling off a cliff. Uh so people aren't transact. It's it's quite a bit of stagnation. Now, when you parse down what does that mean? Uh, so transaction volume is a down right now, about 20% year on year. Home prices, if you take an average across America, it's only down 8% year on year. Uh sorry, it's up 8% year on year. And you might be saying, well, how did you say it's down from peak but still up 8% year on year? Well, we've had a lot of appreciation in the last couple of years. So while we're down from peak, you're still up on a year-on-year basis. Uh, our view at Divi is that uh we're gonna start to see heading into Q1 year on year declines in home prices across economist.
17:33 Speaker 0 That is likely to be somewhere around 10 to 15% year on year home price declines. If you look back at 2009 to 2012, so home prices reached their bottom. So the bottom of the stock market was 2009, the bottom of home prices starting the housing crisis, so it's 2012, almost three months, uh, three years later. And when you look at at where they were from peak to trough and how they fell off a cliff, um, it depended very highly by market. Some markets you only saw a 10 to 20% decline, and some you saw something closer to like 40 to 50% decline. Florida was one that actually got hit quite hard. Uh overall, it averaged 30%. If y'all look up at the run-up in home prices, since 2019 to 2022, home prices have gone up by about 50%.
18:19 Speaker 0 Right? So when you look at where we are going to come back down to from that peak, I would imagine kind of what came up is going to come somewhat down. And so I think we might be falling further, at least when we get to the bottom than we had in just from peak to trough in a quicker speed. Um, that's okay, right? Houses need to reset. This is part of inflation. Um, but I think that people have to prepare for what is going to be a tougher 2023.
18:47 Speaker 1 Yeah. And to end on, you know, a positive note, one of the sorry y'all. That's or just or just uh a more optimistic note. Um but we have seen, you know, there has been this narrative of people leaving cities, leaving more expensive places, moving to cities, second-tier cities, or even moving to the countryside exurban environments where we're now seeing seeing home prices increase because people can work from home. Curious if you think that that is going to affect kind of, you know, this great migration. Is it going to stay post-COVID? Are people moving into homes further away so that they can you know have larger, larger yards, larger homes? Like how do you see sort of the long-term effects of how housing is changing in America?
19:22 Speaker 0 Yeah, and like look, I think that while we are gonna see home prices decline, we are in a very different, we are in a very different environment than we were in 09. And I will tell you, there is right now over 50% of homes have 50% or greater equity in the property. That was not something we had during the housing crisis. We've seen migration to new cities that I think is going to actually stick, right? We have a tremendous undersupply of homes that will help boo the economy. So I don't think that we're going to see something as extreme as the last housing crisis. What I do think is that we are going to wipe out some of the gains that were made in the last. Last two to three years, which is what we saw in the stock market and isn't surprising. And ultimately, I think is actually healthy. The market needs a reset.
20:09 Speaker 0 Home prices are running up a ton, and ultimately I think this will be good for the consumer because it means that home prices will become more affordable in
20:18 Speaker 1 the future. Which is definitely what we all want. Adina, it's always so fascinating to have a conversation. Thank you so much for joining us.
20:23 Speaker 0 My pleasure. Thank you for having me.
Previous Healthspan, Lifespan, and the Biology of Aging Next The State of Apps with Olivia Moore Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated