Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Which Bitcoin Players Matter? About this episode Users, entrepreneurs, and investors are harnessing bitcoin’s "workaday utility" in Argentina, a place where bitcoin is arguably more widespread among everyday people than anywhere else. What conditions led to this? Is it indicative of what may happen someplace else? Or is it just an isolated case or even a stopgap?
In this episode of the a16z Podcast, NYT journalist Nathaniel Popper, author of the new book Digital Gold on the "inside story of the misfits and millionaires trying to reinvent money", shares his insights on the phenomenon taking place in Argentina; what lessons other countries should (or shouldn't) take away from it; and why email is the best analogy for email. And why the people behind bitcoin really do matter ... especially because -- not in spite of! -- bitcoin being a blank slate to build on top of.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 1 Hi everyone, welcome to the A6 and Z podcast. This is Sonal, and I'm here today with Nathaniel Popper, New York Times journalist and the author of the book just out today, Digital Gold, Bitcoin and the inside story of the misfits and millionaires trying to reinvent money. Welcome, Nathaniel.
0:17 Speaker 0 Thank you for having me.
0:18 Speaker 1 So I just wanted to kick off with an article you wrote in the New York Times recently about what you describe as an experiment with Bitcoin happening playing out in Argentina where people are trading pesos for Bitcoin and vice versa instead of actually into other currencies. Could you talk a little bit about why you think that phenomenon is happening? Um I mean one of the things you comment on is that it's the only place where ordinary people that you you think it's the only place where ordinary people are using Bitcoin for real commercial transactions.
0:48 Speaker 0 Yeah, I mean I I in the course of writing this book I traveled to most of the places where Bitcoin has caught on in any significant way. And I was always on the lookout for people actually using Bitcoin, you know, people who weren't just speculating on the price of Bitcoin or uh working on it for sort of uh political or technological reasons. I wanted to see people using it in some ordinary way. And in Argentina, as I mentioned, as you mentioned, is really the one place where I saw that happening, where I saw ordinary people who didn't have any political motivations, didn't really understand the technology using Bitcoin because it allowed them to do something they they couldn't do with their ordinary currency, they couldn't do in the ordinary financial system.
1:45 Speaker 0 And so to me it was really the m the most interesting experiment for Bitcoin and the most interesting place to look at to understand how it might be used if this did catch on more. And um I think the the Argentinian experience is clearly a little unusual, and so it would be easy to say that you know Bitcoin is catching on there because it's just a totally screwed up, it has a totally screwed up currency, it is a you know, uh largely a totally screwed up country, uh, you know, it's had hyperinflation, you know, multiple incidents of hyperinflation, they've defaulted on their debt, all of this. And so that that is certainly why it's being used there, but I think that despite all the unusual elements of what's going on in Argentina, when you look at it, there are a lot of lessons to be drawn for how it might be used elsewhere once once the the technology, once the protocol, once the code, once the infrastructure is improved, it will it it it will be able to compete in other places in similar ways.
3:00 Speaker 0 And so Argentina was just fascinating, and the the center of that story for me in Argentina were the sort of working class Bitcoin money changers
3:11 Speaker 1 who
3:12 Speaker 0 make the whole thing work down there. I mean, a lot of people use Bitcoin to get money in and out of the country, but when they need to get their money into pesos so they can buy something and they can go to the grocery store, they rely on on this this this money changer who frequently will come to their house to their work and uh give them pesos or give them dollars and it's just fascinating characters, and they they sort of they they give a window on the most basic level into how Bitcoin works, and that was that was at the bottom of it, that's what I was interested in this book and why I was interested in Argentina.
3:50 Speaker 1 So um Nathano, speaking of Argentina though, there are plenty of places in the world that have hyperinflation. Um what about the environment there made Bitcoin take off? I mean, there could have been other alternatives. I mean, it's not like it's the only option.
4:04 Speaker 0 It's not the only option, and and in fact, people have lots of other ways of of getting around the local currency and getting around the local financial system, and frankly, the the most popular way to to get around the peso is the dollar. So there are already uh there's already a whole infrastructure and world of money changers in Argentina who are changing between dollars and pesos. Um that's that is something that sort of set the stage for Bitcoin. I think that what Argentina has that a lot of other places don't have with dysfunctional economies is a very well educated, literate uh tech savvy population that that knew how to um embrace this technology and that had the skills to do that and and uh and a comfort with the idea of a digital currency.
5:01 Speaker 0 I don't know that that's the same conditions exist in a place like Venezuela or Zimbabwe. So Argentina is somewhat unusual in that respect.
5:12 Speaker 1 Right. Well, interestingly enough, Wences Cazares, who you talk about in the book and then the article, um is from Argentina, and I know that inspired his interest in Bitcoin. But he wrote an interesting post recently on LinkedIn about why Greece should not switch to Bitcoin. And he actually it was really funny, he actually said, but if the euro is a problem, switching to Bitcoin would be like trying to cure a headache with a bullet to the brain, which I thought is really funny turn of phrase, but why why would he make that argument um at the same time? So on one hand, you see this phenomenon in Argentina, and on the other hand, you're hearing, you know, folks say that but countries should not think of it as you know as a replacement for their currency or uh to augment their currency.
5:52 Speaker 0 I mean, I think I think it's similar to the argument that the internet in 1995 was not equipped to handle Facebook or Netflix. You just you just didn't have the bandwidth at that point. I mean, the basics of the of the technology of the internet w existed in 1995, but you need a lot of stuff to go into it and to uh to to sort of create a foundation for it to allow to allow more significant things to be built on top of it. And I think it's pretty clear that at this point Bitcoin is not ready for prime time in that way. Uh there are there are sort of basic problems with the with the protocol with the number of transactions that can go through the system and significant improvements that need to be made before it can become that sort of work-a-day thing for larger economies.
6:50 Speaker 0 And I think that Wencis uh it's interesting to to hear him say that. Um, but I think it's it's widely understood among a lot of the people working on this that this there's still a lot of work that needs to be done. And sometimes there's a desire to see a technology like this, you know, embraced immediately. People want this to become the global reserve currency next year. And I think the people who are kind of really in the trenches working on this recognize that this sort of thing takes five, ten years. And and you know, Wences often would say that to me when I was talking to him in the course of reporting on this book that, you know, if it takes ten years, if it takes twenty years, that's that doesn't matter to me.
7:43 Speaker 0 I just, you know, the the important thing is that this eventually catches on. And so sometimes people do become a little too focused on the very near term.
7:55 Speaker 1 Right. Well, I mean, I think another theme there too, is you mentioned the analogy to the internet in the early days. Um there's a similarity in the sense that the internet belonged to everybody and it was borderless and not tied to any one country. Um in that vein, one interesting theme that comes up in the Argentina story that you tell too is this tension between decentralized and centralized players and how a lot of people don't trust centralized players like banks. Um but yet so many aspects of the Bitcoin ecosystem are in fact centralized. I mean, there are some choke points in there for better or worse. Do you have any thoughts on how that plays out?
8:28 Speaker 0 Well, I think it's it's certainly one of the the the constant tensions in my book as I sort of tell the the history of Bitcoin. Um and and because in reality, many of the crises that have hit Bitcoin have been as a result of people trusting their Bitcoins with some central institution that was essentially allowed to hold their money in the same way that a bank does, but without any insurance. And I think obviously the most notable case of this was Mount Gox, which essentially held everyone's bitcoins and uh eventually lost or stole all of those bitcoins. I the jury's still out on exactly what happened there.
9:15 Speaker 0 But um that that has been an issue that people don't actually seem to trust themselves to use truly decentralized technology, or or perhaps they don't have the abilities to do so. And so, you know, I think a lot of the focus in the in the developer community now is on building programs that can allow people to get the advantages of the decentralized technology without having to deal with all the complications of it. But I I think that's a real issue, and um, I mean, I think it's always at the at the center of these debates about um the internet and obviously we now have this with Google and Yahoo we have a decentralized internet yes but you do have these companies that are essentially serving as the middlemen and that have the ability to track all your emails to give emails up and when they're subpoenaed and you know to a to a degree that does seem to defeat some of the original idealism of the project but you obviously have managed to maintain a lot of the benefits.
10:31 Speaker 1 Well I think it's interesting because one analogy that I've seen you use and I'm I feel like I'm a collector of Bitcoin analogies. I've heard settlement network uh lots of different analogies and I think it's probably a better analogy than most is the financial version of email. So I think in that sense I think that's probably one of the better analogies I've heard used and that you came up with so maybe email is a better way of maybe email is a better way of thinking of it than even saying internet because everyone uses email it bypasses you know there are central services but it bypasses sort of a single central player. I don't know what else about email why would you say what else would you say makes it the financial version of email.
11:07 Speaker 0 Well it's just it's it's a way to send things that you have control over. Often oftentimes people get get focused on the idea of Bitcoin as a currency because that's the easiest thing to grasp. Everybody understands money everybody understands gold and that that's true even in the title of my book Digital Gold but it's it's more than just a thing it's more than just a token it's a way to move things and so I think
11:38 Speaker 1 email
11:39 Speaker 0 conveys that that you're moving something but the email itself is a thing that's valuable as well and so that to me is why that metaphor makes sense and obviously it's something that everybody understands and can use it is just a way to move money as quickly as email moves information. And of course both of them are built on top of the internet and rely on that foundation but do something new on top of that.
12:13 Speaker 1 I I think I totally agree with that. And it's frictionless and cheap. I mean the one of the analogies anecdotes that really stuck out in your article in the New York Times recently was about um an artist who if he had used if he had someone had sent him euros to Argentina he would have lost 30% of his profits. Which is just insane. And and he ended up using Bitcoin for that reason which I think is another example of the cost of that because the fact that it's so expensive to move things is is huge.
12:43 Speaker 0 Yeah and the and the costs are much greater in Argentina at 30 to 40% cost. In the US it's it's pretty expensive as well but uh it's not necessarily quite at the place where Bitcoin can easily compete or or or you know
13:00 Speaker 1 clearly
13:01 Speaker 0 beat the alternative but in in Argentina right now it can I think you know part of what's interesting about Argentina is that the what the work going on there it seems like it may end up improving the Bitcoin protocol, Bitcoin software to the point where it can compete in places where you know the the the margin is smaller.
13:22 Speaker 1 Do you think though the situation in Argentina is a stopgap or do you was your sense from you know your observations there that it's actually going to be people are converted and they're going to continue doing this, especially as the protocol and the technology evolves.
13:35 Speaker 0 I mean I think I think the specific situation in Argentina is going to depend a lot actually on what the local government does. The the the the real problem with with transferring money internationally there is this artificial exchange rate that the government creates and that's where you lose most of your money when you bring when you bring currency into the country is is the artificial exchange rate between dollars and pesos. And so if the government does away with that if the government begins to deal with inflation then the advantages of Bitcoin are beginning going to become a lot less significant. Now I I think part of what's interesting that you're seeing in Argentina is that people are starting to use it for more than just the just the international transfers.
14:26 Speaker 0 I mean that was the first big sort of use case but um as people are becoming familiar with it and more programmers are becoming aware of it they're seeing the other ways in which it might be used and one of the really interesting projects that going that's going on right now is actually being led by Wences's company Zappo. They have teamed up with the local social network called Taringa which is you know the this this local sort of Reddit Facebook site and there they're using Bitcoin not as a way of transferring large amounts of money but actually as a way of allowing for really small payments on the social network. And so you know micropayments is something you hear a lot about with with Bitcoin that it might make it easier to make micro payments than is possible with credit card networks.
15:19 Speaker 0 And so the the the possibility for micropayments to take off perhaps you know if the government's policies change on exchange rates and nobody is using it any longer to bring money into the country you know the the usership on Taringa will take off. So I think um you know once people start thinking about Bitcoin they start thinking about the different ways in which it might be used. And and frankly yeah I I'm not at all I I wouldn't argue that Argentina is the future of Bitcoin or Argentina is paving the way for for Bitcoin you know broader adoption by ordinary people. I just think it's a great experiment to watch because it's the place where people are trying that right now and and maybe in two three years if the policies change there that those sorts of experiments will move somewhere else.
16:11 Speaker 1 I agree. And I think it's interesting because the entire theme of what you've been talking about and in your book as well is about the role of people and the players behind this ecosystem. And one debate that I've seen play out and that I myself have strong opinions about on both sides is whether the people really matter actually because in the case of trying to figure out who Satoshi Nakamoto is for example do we really need to know in terms of what use we're actually getting out of it but yet in your book you paint a picture of a lot of different characters and interesting people involved with the evolution of Bitcoin. Clearly you would make the argument that people do matter in that context and so I'm kind of curious to hear why you you think that's the case
16:51 Speaker 0 well I I think you know at the simplest level Bitcoin is not a thing that exists unto itself. Bitcoin and one of the most fascinating elements of Bitcoin the Bitcoin protocol is that it's a kind of blank slate that people can write their needs onto and their interests onto and that's that's really what I saw in the course of reporting out this book is that everywhere it went Bitcoin was used in a slightly different way. And so what Satoshi had in mind for Bitcoin you know he talked about something that could a kind of money that could exist without central banks.
17:37 Speaker 0 That's that's frankly not the way it's being used right now.
17:43 Speaker 1 It's
17:43 Speaker 0 being used in all these other ways. I mean he did talk about uh micropayment so there that there that was there at the beginning but but to understand the technology you have to understand the way that people are using it. To understand it in the abstract is is somewhat useless. If you just described Bitcoin this is what happened for the first two years. Somebody described it and everybody thought it was idiotic. Every nobody you know there was there was maybe a hundred two hundred people using it and everybody thought they were crazy. So it wasn't i i it it didn't exist unto itself it needed to get those people who were using it and those people who began using it weren't all using it in the same way.
18:32 Speaker 0 Each person sort of used it according to their ideas about and their needs and you know initially the the the ability to buy drugs online the the the the kind of political promise of Bitcoin was really important and that was driving the use of it and that drove the the way in which the software evolved because this is open source software and it and it has become something different than what it was when it began and so you know all of this together it just tells you that that the technology is I mean the the the code in itself
19:09 Speaker 1 it
19:09 Speaker 0 could could have just disappeared. It was the people using it that that made it happen and that made it evolve in the different ways that it has evolved. The people are what made this matter the people are what turned this into something that might influence the world the the code in itself would have died a quiet death if it were not for all of the people
19:38 Speaker 1 in
19:38 Speaker 0 this book. And that's something that's very useful for the people to think about who are who are using this technology and trying to improve it because you you have to think about where people are and what their needs are and and almost everybody who influenced the course of Bitcoin was somebody who looked a little bit more dispassionately at what the technology was and why people were interested in it and how they might use the technology to provide another service. Um and you know Charlie Schrem is an was was one interesting case of that. He was a very you know for all of his failings and foibles, he was a very practical guy who saw that it was really hard to buy Bitcoins at that point
20:32 Speaker 1 and
20:32 Speaker 0 he made that possible. Wensis is a a later version of that. And Wensis as an entrepreneur is fascinating because he is so good at telling stories. And I think that's a big part of the reason he has managed to influence Bitcoin the way that he has and the way and that he has managed to build the companies that he has because he can build stories and tell those stories and convince people that those stories matter. And in doing that he's been one of the most successful evangelists for Bitcoin. But in doing that he's also himself influenced the story of Bitcoin.
21:09 Speaker 1 That's great. Well thank you Nathaniel and um that's Nathaniel Popper from the New York Times and the author of Digital Gold. Thank you again Nathaniel.
21:18 Speaker 0 It was great talking with you.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated