Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | The Year Mobile Began to Truly Dominate Tech About this episode Benedict Evans highlights the past year in mobile. From Apple's ongoing rule of the high-end, to Android's spread farther down the price curve. Without a clear and massive shift on the horizon in mobile tech, Evans outlines the trends in mobile that will matter and that possess opportunity for the right companies and emerging technologies. For a complete rundown of the year's trends check out Evans' 16 Mobile Theses: a16z.com/2015/12/18/16-mobile-theses/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 1 Welcome to the A16Z Podcast. I'm Michael Copeland and I sit here with Benedict Evans. And Benedict has been putting together his year-end package. 16 mobile theses. And it's your two turtle doves and a partridge and a pear tree plus 13 other things, I guess.
0:20 Speaker 0 It's a bit like um there's this old Russian joke that a bunch of guys have been locked in a prison cell for so long that they know all each other of each other's jokes off by heart. And so instead of sending someone telling a joke, they'll just say 15 and everybody laughs. And I kind of thought like there's a whole bunch of issues that have been talked about and talked about and keep coming up. And I've kind of written three or four things about search and a couple of things about this issue and a couple of things about that issue. And I wanted to kind of pull all of those together into one place as opposed to you know having a last post, most recent blog format. Um and I was also thinking so that was kind of a practical point. Like let's just have everything that I the kind of the the the the way all the different ways to think about all the different aspects of mobile and what the issues might be in one post.
1:06 Speaker 1 Right. And so you check out that post on on A16 A16Z.com and and also on Ben Evans.
1:13 Speaker 0 Yeah. And so what I've done is I've basically written a paragraph about each of those, you know, outlining what are the actual issues around this question, and then link the three or four posts I've written. And so that's just kind of a kind of a practical thing that I thought would be useful. Um what was also sort of driving my thinking a bit is that we are kind of at a stage where we're sort of between waves in mobile in that the smartphone wars are now over, or at least the the first smartphone war is over and Apple and Google both won in different ways, and the kind of the first messaging app wars are now mostly over, and Facebook mostly won in sort of various ways. And a few, I mean there's a few other examples of that. And there isn't like a big new trend coming up that like everyone's waiting for you know mm mobile payments or messaging or something. There isn't like a new thing that's just starting to explode in that sense within mobile.
1:59 Speaker 0 Now there's other things like AR and VR and AI and so on, but um not within mobile specifically. And what we have instead is like we have this platform now. And then the question is well, what are the different things that get built on top of that platform, whether it's productivity or search or you know, or different user interaction models or sort of role of ecosystems and so on.
2:17 Speaker 1 So there's plenty on the horizon, it it sounds to me is what you're saying, but there's not this kind of massive shift that we kind of always do. No, it's
2:25 Speaker 0 not like two years ago where you were going, wow, look at WhatsApp, look at Instagram. Right. There's not like a big trend in that sense at the moment.
2:33 Speaker 1 So what what have you been keeping your eye on then this year? And I know we've talked about a lot of this, but you know, what really jumps out and what has meaning and will extend into the future and have impact farther than we've seen thus far.
2:46 Speaker 0 Um well, the metaphor I used a while ago was the the sort of the tech industry is kind of like a solar system and the smartphone is the sun. And everything else orbits around it. And we had this sort of mental model that mobile is this new big thing and it's another new big thing in a tech industry full of big things, and like that's I think that's the wrong way to think about it. It's rather that the mobile is the new central ecosystem in the way that the PC was a central ecosystem for 20 or 30 years. And so then everything else gets built on that. So you rebuild productivity and you rebuild what large screen and small screen devices look like. You rebuild what the route of getting technology into the living room looks like. So you know, for 20 years, people were thinking about games consoles or streaming boxes or something, is like that would be the mass market consumer computing product, and it turns out no, it's not, it's a smartphone, and the screen is a satellite for the smartphone.
3:34 Speaker 0 And then there's cars and there's watches and there's um you know search and discovery, and those are all kind of things that ship sit on top of this new platform of sort of ARM iOS Android doing one and uh over one and a half billion units this year, and probably over three billion of those things in the world today. And so you've got this big platform and you're building the stuff on it.
3:54 Speaker 1 You just mentioned search and discovery, and one of the things that's virtually impossible or very difficult at least, you know, in the mobile paradigm is search and discovery. So what have we seen this year and and what do you think what does that tell us about where it might be headed?
4:09 Speaker 0 Um I think there's a couple of things here. One of them is it becomes ever more apparent that on mobile it's a smartphone OS that's a platform, the OS that's a platform. Whereas on the like the desktop internet, you targeted a web browser. Yes, you could write a Windows application that connects to the internet, and yes, there was Steam and so on. But basically the internet experience was in the browser, and on the smartphone it's on the operating system, and you target you write apps and web pages and other things. And the interesting thing is that it's also not a neutral platform because Apple and Google change stuff and they do stuff that changes how you might acquire users. And in parallel, you've got this kind of search for another runtime, like let's count what else could we build on that platform? So, first of though, the first runtime is the web, the second runtime is native apps, then you have people think, okay, well, what else can we build? So you have WeChat who basically built a messaging app that is a runtime.
4:56 Speaker 0 Um Facebook would obviously like to clone that. There's other people who are trying to do something similar. Um Baidu has done that in maps um in much the same way. And so there you have a development environment and also a discovery environment and a kind of a user acquisition environment that's in a new place and works in different ways and it's different from the web and different from native apps. Um and that's still completely up in the air. Like we left behind this model we had for 20 years of web browser mouse keyboard, but we haven't settled on something new. And you have Apple and Google who can change stuff and do change stuff every summer, and you have Facebook kind of trying to bud in, and there's Amazon and there's WeChat and all sorts of other people kind of looking at this platform in a way that we didn't have on the desktop web because it was just the web browser, and yes, there were browser wars, but that didn't really change what you could do as a developer in the same way.
5:41 Speaker 1 And do do you foresee then runtime wars, as it were?
5:45 Speaker 0 Um well it's interesting. I mean, that the sort of slightly kind of the sort of the joke that I made is that like every spring Facebook says this is a future of interaction on mobile, and like eight weeks later, Apple and Google say, look, sorry, kid, but like it's our platform. Right. And we get to decide how stuff works. Yeah. Um so you we've seen a little bit of that. Um and yeah, it's like it is Apple on Google's platform. Now there is then there is another question, and this is one of the reasons why the control of Android is interesting and why Xiaomi is interesting and and and so on, is that it may not be Google's platform entirely, and it's not there are so there are some ways in which it's not Google's platform now. And therefore, if you can if if Android kind of spins away from Google or if Android becomes something else, then it might be other people that might be trying to make those decisions. Um so we had this whole wave, of course, of Android launches that were all about trying to create new ways of discovering apps, and those almost all seem to have to none of those seem to have worked.
6:39 Speaker 0 Um but that was like another attempt at like how do we create like a new way of finding and discovering things.
6:44 Speaker 1 Within the within the mobile context, let's talk about Apple and Google a little bit more too. But I uh m maybe can you can just say, okay, Apple, what are the strengths, what are the weaknesses in the in the mobile construct, and let's go down the line a little bit.
6:56 Speaker 0 So where are we? So there are um something like seven to eight hundred million live iOS devices in use today. Um in 1995, incidentally, there were about 250 million PCs on Earth, just to give you a sense of kind of ecosystem scale. So Microsoft, Apple has got several multiples of what Windows had had when Windows 995 was a new thing. And that is big enough to be a sustainable ecosystem, particularly because when you come to the US, it's 30 or 40% of the install base and 70, 60, 70, 80% of usage. Um and in San Francisco, it's two-thirds of the install base. And so you have Apple, though the you know, the fact that Apple doesn't have many users in sub-Saharan Africa doesn't really matter to the ecosystem. And that's kind of different from the way the PC ecosystem worked, where it was like the ecosystem walls ecosystem. There's different market shares in different places.
7:42 Speaker 0 And so Apple's got seven or eight hundred million active devices. Um Google Android has got say one and a half billion. They gave a number in the summer of what on this in the autumn of 1.4, so they've got about one and a half billion active Android devices. Um higher proportion of those are phones and tablets. Incidentally, Apple has about 200 million active iPads out there. And then there's probably another six or seven hundred million non-Google Android devices in China. Six, seven, eight hundred million, depending on who you whose estimates you believe. And that gets us to some something over three billion. And these are sort of
8:16 Speaker 1 forked Android. It's handset manufacturers that are
8:20 Speaker 0 for so forked is a kind of a specific term. Um the Kindlefire is forked. That is to say it's built on Android, you would not hold it to pick it up and think this is an Android device. Right. Almost all the devices in China, you would pick it up and think this is exactly the same as the one you bought in America until you look for Google Maps.
8:35 Speaker 1 Ah, and it's not there.
8:37 Speaker 0 So the Google apps and services layer isn't there. Right. But everything else is there.
8:42 Speaker 1 You mentioned so well let's talk about the weaknesses for both Apple and Google. And so the
8:46 Speaker 0 weaknesses, so that was like the the state of the units. The weaknesses are, I think. Um Apple has got this integrated ecosystem of hardware and semiconductors and sensors and software and manufacturing that means it's able to create high-end experiences that are very difficult for anyone to match. And really isn't really no one else in the market who's providing that that experience in that way. And so that particularly when they came out last year with a large screen phone, it turned out that that took away half of the high-end market, the half of the portion of the high-end market that they didn't already have away from Samsung. Um Apple's position at the high end in the mid-to-high end is very secure. Um they are weak in cloud services, they are weak in building internet services. Um they have a tendency to see those as pipes that connect beautiful user interfaces rather than thinking about what is a service first. Um you kind of see that with Apple Music, for example.
9:33 Speaker 0 Um, although I that's actually a bad example, because with Apple Music, the CloudBit is actually quite good as a user interface, it's a mess, which is kind of ironic given it's Apple. Um they have so far not really touched like the mid range of the hand for that market, and this has been an area of endless speculation for like five years, where Apple do a cheaper phone. They could do a $300 phone now that would be a great phone. Right. Um it would you would not feel John. I wouldn't feel ashamed of it. I feel like that's a question of when rather than if. And obviously that poses questions about what happens to secondhand sales and sales of the other iPhones and so on. Of course, they sell the two-year-old one for $200 and so on. So they're not not touching that, but they're still not touching the middle of the market at all. And that puts a kind of a cap on that on the market. And so there are kind of two questions for Apple. One is like, how big is the market for $400, $500, $600 phones?
10:20 Speaker 0 Because it's clearly not the whole market, but we've yet to see is yet really to stop. And so the speculation right now is like, well, now that they came out with a big screen phone last year, okay, is that a step change? How much further can they grow? And then the other question is as cloud becomes important, does it matter that Apple is weak there, or will you just be using all Google's cloud services on your iPhone anyway?
10:41 Speaker 1 And uh And then
10:42 Speaker 0 you flip that to Google. Well,
10:43 Speaker 1 let me ask one question.
10:45 Speaker 0 All the questions are exactly the opposite.
10:46 Speaker 1 Well let me ask just one question, because you mentioned Samsung and the high end of the market. Um what m other manufacturers other than Apple have been really good at is lowering the price of these fancy phones, so like the OnePlus 2, OnePlus One, et cetera. Are we going to see pressure on Apple ever? Or are they just so
11:03 Speaker 0 Well uh it's that's uh I suppose that's one way of putting it. Another way of putting it would be to say that um the Moore's law has taken the price of Android down to 30 or 40 dollars and every point in between. But any m the the the kind of as it might be two thirds to three quarters of people who are willing to spay and spend five, six, seven hundred dollars on a phone and get the one that's beautifully made and has a beautiful finish and has the best camera and the best screen. Two thirds to three quarters of those people currently are choosing to buy iPhones. And that is currently five, six hundred million people on Earth have got one of these things. And so that seems to be working out just fine for Apple. And so there's an argument that says like it will all go to the good enough product the way it did with PCs.
11:49 Speaker 0 There's another argument that says um that's a bit like saying no one would ever buy a Mercedes because you can buy Ford. Yeah. And well, actually no. People are willing to spend a bit more money to get that, and there are enough people who are willing to do that that you can sustain a market for that product. And it turns out that for Apple, that market is over half a billion people, and we don't know how many more it is because it's still growing.
12:14 Speaker 1 Right. Albeit growing slower. Yeah,
12:17 Speaker 0 it's growing slower. But this is always this has been the question for Apple for like the last four years. It's like, well, what is ceiling on the market for high-end phones? Because it's clearly not the two billion the the global handset market is two billion units a year. The market for six hundred dollar phones is not two hundred bit is not two billion units a year. But we don't know what it is because it hasn't stopped growing yet. Right. Right. Interesting. All right, Google. Google well, Google
12:39 Speaker 1 is the opposite of
12:40 Speaker 0 this. So Google builds incredible cloud services and builds um and isn't quite so good at building the user interface for them. And um necessarily except when they're very simple. Um and there are exceptions to both of these. Um Google tends to see the device as the endpoint for the cloud, whereas um Apple tends to see the cloud as like the pipe for the device. So like the ideal company would be like Apple and Google combined, because then you have a great device and a great cloud service. Um the challenge for Google, on one hand, Google is I think completely unchallenged at the moment in the kind of the fundamental business of knowing what everything is in the world and how to find it. Um at least as it relates to a to competition with Apple. I think there's a broader question of discovery where I think Google faces a lot of challenges, but that's kind of a different point. We can come back to that later. Um so they have they so their their kind of core search product is I think completely unchallenged, really.
13:26 Speaker 0 The kind of the position is completely stable. Um the challenge that they have on mobile specifically is that um what they want in everything is reach. They're not in the business of selling Android phones, they're in the business of reach, and the purpose of Android was to get reach. And they don't have the top 500, 600 million people. Yeah, because obviously 800 million devices, but people have got iPads and iPhones. So this is over half a billion people. And it's generally it's the best half billion people, that is to say it's a half billion people who are most willing to spend money, who most value a user experience, who most spend most of them spend most time on the internet, which is why roughly half of all time spent online on mobile appears to be happening on iOS devices, even though um it it's there are way more Android devices out there than iOS devices because it's skews to a certain kind of user. Um and so how much of that is a problem for Google? Like if you're on Android, they know they get a far more data about what you're doing, what you're interested in, where you're going than they do if you're on iPhone and just use Google search and just use Google Maps.
14:20 Speaker 0 And so you have this kind of question of, well, what kind of reach does Google need, and how much does it matter to them that Apple has apparently got a lock on this portion of the market and that you know the new Nexus is not going to change that, and you know, Samsung's not gonna clearly not going to do anything that's gonna change that. It's not clear how if anything will change that at this in this cycle, you know, ten years everything will change. So um, you know, Google Apple has a cloud question, but is secure and hardware. Google is secure in cloud and has a hardware question, and then it's has kind of limited access to some kinds of users.
14:51 Speaker 1 So and then that leaves us with Microsoft, Facebook, Amazon, and and Samsung for that matter, but these other players who who are clearly in the mobile venue and they need to be there, but where are they? Yeah. Um so Microsoft isn't
15:06 Speaker 0 in mobile. Um they sold just over five million units of Windows phone, they've written the unit down. It's the that that I would be I think there's even odds that that product won't exist in a yeah. Um so Microsoft and WhatsApp in Adela did um was say this is the end of Windows everywhere. That is to say the idea that Microsoft strategy is everything will run Windows and we will leverage Windows and Office against each other. That's gone. And so you have Office on iPad and you have Office on Android, and the the basically what what Microsoft is doing now is using the legal the legacy core businesses as cash cas in order to try and create new businesses for the future. Um and so Windows will go free, Office will go into the cloud, but then you have to kind of create new connected tissue for the enterprise and so on. Azure will be like a good number two. And so they have to transition away from being the PC company and the Windows company and the Office Company in a sense.
15:56 Speaker 0 Um because you know, they miss mobile, they miss this new platform, so they have to become something different. Um Amazon failed with a phone, the tablet is doing kind of okay. Um again, it's like everybody has their own secure business but want somebody else's business where they're in fact they're a lot weaker. Microsoft Apple has a secure high-end business but wants cloud and is weak in cloud, Google's the other way around. Amazon is is is kind of this huge e-commerce giant, but wants to move outwards and to kind of create new adjacent products, and it tends to be much weaker in those, except in content. Um I mean, I think there's a kind of an interesting thing in here when you look at Amazon and and Google and Facebook, though, which is that what Amazon, Google, Facebook all do is look at the funnel. That is to say, they look at how is it that you would know that you want to buy this thing.
16:42 Speaker 0 And I sometimes think of Google and Amazon as being a little bit like kind of funnel web spiders in that they basically wait for you to fall in. Um it's kind of an unnecessarily destructive metaphor. Um but the kind of the reason I say this is like as
16:55 Speaker 1 a customer, yeah. Yeah, I don't know if I like to think of it that way.
16:58 Speaker 0 Well, but the the reason I say that is that you know most people buy stuff on Amazon that they previously discovered existed somewhere else. Yes, there's a bit of browsing, but you know, by and large you go to Amazon and already knowing what you want. And you get in a sense you go to Google already knowing what you want. Like, you know, if you want to find a hotel in Carmel, you'll go to Google. But if you want to know like where could well, actually that's a bad example because there isn't anywhere to go from San Francisco. But you know, if you were in, you know, if you're in in London, it's like, okay, where should we go on holiday this weekend? Okay, there's 25 or 30 or 40 night beautiful medieval cities you could go to for $50 or $100. You ask Google where you're not going to get a good answer.
17:36 Speaker 1 Well, not for medieval cities in the Bay Area. Is that what we're gonna do? Well, yeah,
17:40 Speaker 0 apart apart apart from Berkeley, obviously, which is sort of antiqu stuck in in antiquation. That's a dig on my home turf. So what but what I'm was uh I don't kind of go get a rabbit hole. The point I'm making is Google can tell you what you want when you already know you want it. It might get you like a magazine article that says here are 10 things that you want, but it will not, you can't go to Google and say like where should I go on holiday? What handbag should I buy, what lamp should I buy? It doesn't, it's not structured in that sense. It doesn't do qual, it only does quant. Um and I think it's fascinating of the kind of the piece that I have not written and will probably write next is sort of all the people who are trying to unbundle Yelp. Because what they're all doing, all these different companies are doing is giving you not every restaurant in the city but ten restaurants. And you see exactly the same thing in fashion, which is not we will not give you the entire catalogue of the global power industry.
18:31 Speaker 0 Rather, we will give you 75 things or 25 things or 10 codes. Um and the point of that is um you don't want to give people a search box. You want to give people like that's not helpful to you. Right. If you don't know what you want. If you don't know what to type in, and you see the same thing with Apple Music, um, giving people 35 million tracks in a search box is not a great user experience. Giving people 10 billion web pages in a search box, which is what Google does, is a good experience for some things if you know what you want, but if you don't. And I think that question of of of of if you don't know what you want is wide open. Right. If you do know what you want, Google has won. If you don't know what you want, I think that's wide open.
19:08 Speaker 1 And that also could be uh a a sort of a risk, an area of risk for Google then too. If somebody really needs to it is,
19:14 Speaker 0 I mean you could make a kind of a deterministic point, which is you could propose that the state of search and discovery now is a little bit like the state of theoretical physics in like 1880, when you know there were just a few little bits to tidy up and then we're finished. Right. And it turns out that's not how it works at all.
19:32 Speaker 1 Let's spin things forward a little bit. What what are you looking at next year or in the in the near term? Like what what what's interesting and what are we going to start hearing about and talking about?
19:42 Speaker 0 Well, what's it? McMillan said events, dear boy. Um would ask the British Prime Minister in the sixties what was the hard part of being Prime Minister, and he said events, dear boy. Um so that's part of it, certainly. Um you know the Intel and Microsoft merger and you know Yes, yes.
20:00 Speaker 1 That kind of stuff.
20:01 Speaker 0 Um I think uh VR is getting be clearly becoming close to a mainstream consumer product in the course of the year. Um as cardboard and Oculus and Gear VR and potentially MO from Apple and Microsoft Solidance and so on. So VR becomes interesting. Um there's an interesting question here about you know, is this a $1,500 PC? And there's quite a lot of people who've got those PCs, incidentally. There's tens of millions of people who've got the PC that can run Oculus. Um how important is the difference between what you get on the $1,500 PC and what you get on a smartphone strapped to your head? Like there is a difference, but how much how important is that difference? Um like a five-year view, it seems to me that this is all going to be about smartphones, because just Moore's law will drive this and the graphics and the sensors will get there. But like, do we have to wait until that? Like what are the kind of the transitional points that we get there?
20:49 Speaker 0 Um and then also, of course, there's AR floating around here where both Microsoft has a story and also of course we have an investment in Magic Leap, which has a story here, and an astonishing story if you if you have the demo. So the sort of AR VR is interesting, drones are interesting. Um all the stuff that gets um IT, industrial internet, all the stuff that gets built on the smartphone ecosystem is kind of interesting. Um then we get Apple and Google's kind of annual jamboree in the summer, and they like set they've got like a list of ten things that they could do, and they'll do three, and that can kind of pull the industry in different ways. And so you always slightly it's a kind of a Deus Ex machina, as I kind of alluded to earlier, that like if Apple and Google do this, then it will happen. And if they don't do it, then it just won't happen because they control the operating system.
21:34 Speaker 0 Um so there's that question. Um then there's like, you know, as I said, there's not like a it's not like two years ago when I I was, you know, tracking Skype uh tracking WhatsApp every day. There's not like a big thing that's blowing up in quite that way.
21:47 Speaker 1 Yeah, I was gonna ask you, are there companies that are a little bit on the margin more that we should be keeping an eye on that? Are you gonna be able to do that? Well,
21:54 Speaker 0 there's lots of companies that are on the margin that I'm keeping my eye on, and I'm not gonna tell you about them, but that but there's not like the kind of holy crap, haven't you heard about this company? Haven't you seen it? There's not quite that at the moment. Uh I mean obviously there are, but not lot, not like some big mega trend. Um which is you know, it's kind of interesting as a sort of a w a state of where we are in the industry.
22:15 Speaker 1 Well, we will talk to you soon and often again uh and see if where we're headed is where you think we're headed, and when you can tell us about these holy crap companies, you better do it.
22:27 Speaker 0 I'll try. Benedict, thank you. Thank you.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated