Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Is It Possible to Achieve Equitable Equity for Startup Employees? About this episode There's been a lot of activity lately around trying to improve equity compensation (for example, by removing tax liabilities that handcuff them). Or by making equity more equitable in other ways; as former Groupon CEO Andrew Mason observed, "When startups grow into unicorns, the distribution of employee earnings follows a common pattern: the founders make more money than they could spend in infinite lifetimes, a handful of early folks achieve financial independence, and everyone else gets a nice bonus, but nothing life changing."
It's admittedly a very rarefied problem yet one that plagues a number of startup founders and employees who put in a lot of work to make the startup a success ... but end up with less than others in the same company. And it's a problem that has long plagued Mason, who shared his views on something he calls "progressive equity" to help more startup employees achieve financial independence if and when their companies exit through an IPO, acquisition, or other liquidity event. Can it work? Should it? a16z General Partner and co-founder Ben Horowitz joins Mason on this episode of the a16z Podcast to dissect the idea.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 2 Welcome to the A16Z podcast. I'm Michael Copeland. If you are lucky enough to be a part of a company that goes from zero to a monster with an IPO or some big liquidity event along the way, it's not usually the case that the distribution of the wealth created is equitable. A few people make out like bandits, deserving or not, while others, many of whom put in the work to make the company a success, end up with very little. That was the case with Andrew Mason and this first company Groupon. And frankly, it bugged him. So while building his next company, Mason also designed a system for equity distribution that he thinks is fair. Something Mason calls progressive equity. Ben Horowitz, who has seen plenty of bad ideas to make equity distribution more equitable, he actually loves this one, joins Andrew Mason on this segment of the A16Z podcast to dissect Mason's idea and the admittedly very high quality problem that underlies it.
1:01 Speaker 1 I am Ben Horowitz, and I'm here talking to Andrew Mason, and today we're going to talk about a concept that he invented called progressive equity and megadonx.
1:14 Speaker 0 Thanks for having me. It's good to be here.
1:17 Speaker 1 So this is one of these things where I get uh kind of emails all the time about new kinds of employee incentive plans and so forth, and like how the old ways of incentives people will never work, and and there's a great better way. And and usually they're just shock full of holes and ridiculous. Um but this one I thought was ingenious. So if you wouldn't mind kind of taking us through kind of the problem as you saw it and then the solution that you came up with.
1:48 Speaker 0 Sure. Um well, there are a number of different challenges, I think, in um in coming up with an equitable system for distributing equity among the people that are involved in a company. Um this particular progressive equity thing solves one of those challenges, um, which is um if you're lucky enough to be part of a company that that grows to be quite large and is worth more than a billion dollars. Typically, if you if you look over the last 10 years or so at the or or farther back at the distribution of ownership, take out investors for a minute and just look at the distribution of ownership among the people that actually work at the company, the founders and the employees, you have a couple of people who end up making enough money to um uh to live a million lifetimes.
2:37 Speaker 0 Um and then you have a handful of people that achieve some kind of financial independence, and then there's this long tail of people that do well but they'll and they they get a nice bonus. Maybe they can buy a house, but they they've still got to work. Yeah. Um and this happened to us at Groupon, and it was kind of frustrating because um because I felt like there were all these other people there. I felt like I was frankly ending up with more money than I wanted or knew what to do with, and there were all these other people who had put in enormous effort. And I I looked for ways that I could at that point even give some of my equity to them to kind of fix the distribution, and it ends up being um uh a real challenge.
3:24 Speaker 1 Yes, yes. Um I am familiar with that challenge. Aaron
3:27 Speaker 0 Powell Um So what progressive equity is is a system that's basically like uh like a progressive tax, it's an income redistribution um system within the company that as the company becomes more and more valuable, it redistributes um percent ownership away from the the highest percent owners and towards um and and towards the lower percent owners, so the more valuable the company come becomes um the mechanism by which it works, um you could do it different ways, but we tried to keep it very simple. Um there's some number um which we've determined to be uh a financial independence threshold. Right. Um, which is a number that we say once you've made this amount of money, you have enough that you never need to think about money again.
4:16 Speaker 1 Right.
4:17 Speaker 0 Um maybe this is a good time to pause and just and just uh um point out the absurdity of the fact that we have to think about solving problems like this in this world. Um what to do when you make too much money. Yeah. Um so I don't know how to get around that. There's the 18-year-old version of me sitting in the corner shaking his head, completely ashamed of what he sees in this chair. But I'm gonna just look at power through it. Yeah. Um anyway, so you have this financial independence threshold, and that's some number. Um in the blog post where I read about this, I didn't feel comfortable actually uh everybody has to figure that out on your own. You can talk to your financial advisor or whatever. But um our company came up with a number, I'm gonna use a fake term that I was calling megadonks.
5:07 Speaker 0 Um and I said I think I said 50 megadonks was the financial independence threshold. So once you have enough equity, or once your company is valuable enough that your total ownership is greater than 50 megadonks, all of your value beyond that has is basically taxed at 50 percent. Right. So you get half of it and the other half goes into a pool that's redistributed to the rest of the employees prorata with their ownership. And that's basically how it works. Aaron Powell
5:37 Speaker 1 And when you did that, did you? You know, you made it pro rata with the ownership. Did you think about um making it not prorata with the ownership, i.e., umelling it uh once it became progressive?
5:54 Speaker 0 Well, um I think the idea would be that your ownership percentage, the employee ownership percentage is reflective of the impact that they have on the company, which is a whole other problem, right?
6:10 Speaker 1 And sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. Sometimes it is, and sometimes it
6:12 Speaker 0 isn't. And I'd argue that's even a uh that's probably a more pervasive problem in companies and one that this doesn't do anything to solve at all. But and
6:21 Speaker 1 yeah, you're always, I mean, I uh partly because people get equity when they're hired. Right. Not based on their work. Right. And it's amazing that how weak that correlation is between what people get when they're hired and how well they do, you know, once they get there and how hard they work and how much effort they put in.
6:40 Speaker 0 Yeah. I mean, I'm sure you had a similar experience, but I remember at one point looking at the cap table and seeing how much all the different employees owned, and if you just put it in line by ownership and if you put it, and then if you line it up by impact,
6:53 Speaker 1 I I I had that day. Yeah, well, I was like tears. So it's just the saddest thing in the world.
7:01 Speaker 0 Um so I I guess um that's why I thought to do it pro rata um is that separately you should solve the problem of of figuring out how to properly dis distribute among employees to reflect impact. Um but yeah, yeah.
7:18 Speaker 1 Yeah, interesting. So one of the things um you kind of obfuscated in the in the blog post and and then again here, but is a really kind of important thing is the threshold uh in that if you set it too high, um it actually becomes meaningless on several levels, and that like Facebook didn't actually have this problem because everybody made so much money um because like the company just ended up being so like incredibly valuable. So you know, if you had set it at like a whatever 10 billion dollar level, it doesn't matter like at all, even though like it would have paid out. Um it just wouldn't have made any difference to anybody. Uh and then on the other hand, if you set it too low, then it's going to hurt your executive recruiting, because you know, with Google offering people like a hundred million dollars to stay at Google, uh, you know, if you're offering, if you say, okay, the threshold is 10 million bucks, then are you gonna be able to recruit it executives?
8:19 Speaker 1 So how did you think about that balance and how did you get to the number? And then I imagine every employee um that you have knows the number, or do only the people who would potentially get taxed, or how do you think all the
8:33 Speaker 0 employees know the number? Okay. Um it and so there's two different ways that that I think people tend to think about financial independence. When I say there's you never have to work again, and that's a different threshold, I think. Like if you're careful about how you spend your money um the you never have to work again.
8:51 Speaker 1 Yeah.
8:51 Speaker 0 What I'm talking about is financial independence, which is the point at which you impulsively buy or you you you buy a motorcycle with the same degree of carelessness that you buy a cup of coffee. Um in terms of the downside of um uh executive recruiting. I mean, I just think anybody that feels like, uh, you know, you're capping me out, or you or you're taxing me, I don't know, like that person's an asshole. I don't really want to work with them.
9:21 Speaker 1 Yeah, that's a good test. But how about um you know, there's kind of a philanthropic side. So if you look at okay, Mark Zuckerberg, who probably made as much money as anybody, um, and not that he hasn't bought stuff, but he's also like given away like a colossal amount of money. Did you think about okay, for that case, you know, for redistributing it to employees, are we gonna ultimately kind of if if over a certain amount what actually happens is it all goes to charity, then how did you think about that?
9:53 Speaker 0 Aaron Powell I I thought about that a little bit, and I actually it's it's a really good point. Like it arguably it's better. Better for one benevolent person to end up with all this money instead of just distributing it evenly among all the employees so that they can all buy you know slightly nicer cars and other work you know material materialistic things.
10:16 Speaker 1 Right.
10:17 Speaker 0 Um so I think that's a really good point. It still felt like in principle something that was that was good to do, but I I think that's potent put potentially a really good argument to not do something like this. Aaron Ross Powell
10:29 Speaker 1 So then uh you you kind of have this one time event uh where like the tax is paid and everything is distributed, and then you kind of switch into kind of
10:45 Speaker 0 old world,
10:46 Speaker 1 so to speak. Uh do you worry about like what that does to the culture because like you have you know rolling into whatever an IPO or a gigantic secondary or potentially a sale, I imagine this kind of extra mega group, you know, we're all in this together incentive, and then that's just gone. And so how do you think about that? And then would that like make you want to like defer a big secondary or an IPO because you're gonna lose like what it really is in a way a magical incentive for the company, because like here you've got this thing where you know nobody else is going to give me some of their stock. Like no nobody else who I'm gonna work for is gonna go, okay, here's like half of um my stock and I'm giving it to you.
11:38 Speaker 1 Like that's a that that's really a kind of a special thing. And then you've got that special thing all the way through the company and then it's over.
11:49 Speaker 0 Right. Yeah. I never liked the fact that it and that the way that it's structured is that there's this event and then and then it's over. Um one of the reasons that I published all the legal documents that we that we came up with was partly in hopes that someone would take them and find ways to improve upon them. That was the best thing that we could figure out how to how to come up with that was in line with um with the law and was was um uh not a major, didn't put employees that were under this program at a major tax disadvantage or anything like that. Um so it does have this one-time event. Those are definitely potential issues that that we that we may end up be being lucky in if we're fortunate enough to actually hit the
12:40 Speaker 1 megadong tax, yeah. Yeah,
12:42 Speaker 0 then we may end up dealing with some of those things. But I but I'd love to see if there's a way to have the same effect that that where you're redistributing value, um, but it does it's not all tied up in this one-time um liquidation event. Aaron Ross Powell
12:57 Speaker 1 Yeah, interesting. And then do you worry about people in advance of the event who would be on the getting tax side attempting to game the system by like maybe there's a small secondary sale that we can execute where I can unload as much of my stock as possible because then I won't have to pay the tax or kind of like in real life how progressive tax ends up working. Yeah, yeah. Tax shelters.
13:29 Speaker 0 I want to say that it's that that it's structured in a way that we can we can avoid some of that. Like we can't like um in order to trigger the So I think like one of the restrictions on the RSUs that that um and and the the triggering of the redistribution of the uh of ownership is that the secondary sale needs to be at least 15 percent of the company or 35 million dollars or something like that.
13:59 Speaker 1 Right.
14:00 Speaker 0 Um so you're saying that you're saying that employees might like senior employees might lobby for a uh a secondary smaller than that.
14:09 Speaker 1 Right, exactly. So you know, oftentimes what I say, you'll do a big round, let's say the company does a big uh round of financing at a billion dollar valuation, and oh, you're a unicorn, and then there's all this demand in the secondary market, and people are calling them and saying, hey, can I buy your shares? And now they're thinking, okay, if I sell them now, I get an added benefit if I don't have to pay the tax. Aaron Powell
14:33 Speaker 0 Well, I think I think the way that that it's structured is that all of that, it's accumulated value over time. So it
14:40 Speaker 1 doesn't matter if you sell
14:40 Speaker 0 it. Right. So it shouldn't matter.
14:42 Speaker 1 Oh, okay. And then another thing that you've done, which is kind of interesting in today's environment is you said if you leave at any time before the tax is paid, whether you're vested or not, you lose all your progressive tax winnings.
14:56 Speaker 0 Right. So this redistribution pool that you would benefit from just because it felt like it became very complicated to do it the other way, and this does feel like a benefit for people who are going to there's there's very for most people there's no downside and only upside. Like again, a c a company needs to be extraordinarily valuable for the average employee that's owning a tenth of a percent of the company to reach um the financial independence threshold. So that hasn't been an issue when we've talked to our employees because most people see it as the whole thing is no downside and potential up upside if I stick around long enough for whatever. Aaron Powell
15:40 Speaker 1 Right. It's better than anything else in the market. Um but you know, potentially if people other companies adopted it, then it might become a thing. And how is it? I I guess like have you felt like people get it in the recruiting process and join the company? Is it a big draw for new employees?
16:00 Speaker 0 Um, so far in our company, because we're small and we're we're kind of weird. Yeah. Um,
16:09 Speaker 1 you're running us. Trevor Burrus, Jr. Like we're doing not just because of that.
16:12 Speaker 0 It's like we're we're building this platform for audio tours, which just sounds it's awesome and it's gonna be huge, but it sounds it sounds weird. Um but it tends to people that have been attracted to it have tend to be attracted to it for a passion for the problems that we're solving, and this is a nice bonus. So we haven't gotten into the phase of the company yet where we're attracting people who are like which post-product market fit pre-IPO gravy train can I jump onto that's going to that's going to get me to the point that I never need to work again in a short a period of time as possible. And that's probably where I I start to see this being a major recruiting advantage.
16:54 Speaker 1 And so do you worry about it being a major recruiting advantage in that sense, and that that's one of the um one of the and you know, like you were CEO of Groupon, so you completely understand this dynamic. Um but is that you know, one thing you hate to have in the company is a bunch of people joining for all the wrong reasons because there's no way that they join for the wrong reason and then kind of become part of the right culture. And although like every time I tell CEOs this, they just ignore me and they go, well, we need like boss level engineers, like I don't care if they have the wrong ambition. I'm like, but does that you know because it does tend to take away from what you have, which is like a kind of weird exceptional culture of people who really are on this problem and are there on a mission.
17:48 Speaker 1 Aaron Powell
17:49 Speaker 0 Well, I think I think there's two potential ways that this policy could appeal to a potential recruit. One would be in the purely mercenary, this is a place where I could potentially make more money. Um yeah, that that I mean we have to be realistic about the fact that that's that's a motivation for for people, but I agree it's we wouldn't want people joining for that that being the primary motivation. Um the other way to look at it is oh, this is a company that in principle thinks that the more that values the the input or the the impact of employees and um is putting thought and effort into making sure that employees are rewarded and that and that the spoils don't end up going um being completely lopsided uh and but they're reflective of the um of the impact.
18:46 Speaker 0 And I work I want to work in the kind of company that thinks about their employees that way. Um and I I want to work in the kind of company where I have the opportunity to own more as where I am incented to make the company more valuable because I get to own more of it as it becomes more valuable. Aaron Ross Powell
19:09 Speaker 1 Now, do you worry at all about uh the kind of company policy seeming like a political policy uh where you would because you know once you get into politics you get this like weird kind of religion and it's like, oh, those guys over there are communist or so forth. Um because you know you've called it a progressive equity system and you know progressive taxes. Aaron Powell You have a better name for it. Well, I think it's a great name but because it's very descriptive. Um I you know I tend to agree with it, but I you know, particularly in Silicon Valley today, there's a whole kind of class of uh kind of people with a much sharper libertarian bent who might think, okay, I already live in a progressive tax system.
19:58 Speaker 1 Do I want to live in a progressive Equity company. And I think you've observed the thing that I observed, which is the, you know, what you get paid has to do with a lot of things other than your effort and skill. And like that just is the way life is. And I often come, you know, my mom was a nurse and like she was like a phenomenal nurse. She couldn't in her entire lifetime make what I can make in a year as a venture capitalist, even if I was a crap venture capitalist. And value to the world, you know, like there's one person like saving your life, and there's another person doing like what I'm doing. And I'm like, okay, that doesn't seem like fair. Yeah. But you know, on the other hand, capitalism works a lot better than communism.
20:48 Speaker 1 Um, communism in practice ends up being like a massive concentration of power. Uh, and Joseph Stalin was not a nice guy and and whatnot. So how do you how do you think about kind of, you know, because you don't really want to enter that debate as a CEO. You actually want anybody, you know, be they like a libertarian or a right-wing Republican or a left-wing Democrat, like you'd like them all to feel welcome in the company. You don't want them to feel like, okay, I'm going into a world where they're gonna hate me.
21:23 Speaker 0 I agree. Like I um that was a concern just from a um it it's there it seems like there's no upside in in mentally anchoring this system to a particular political point of view, which it isn't anchored to a particular political point of view. And I called it progressive equity because it was descriptive and I was lazy and didn't think of a better name. Yeah, yeah, that's great. Um but but argue if I was really being if I was really if I was like writing a book about this or like or like actually like going out and trying to market it or something like that, I probably would have taken the time to come up with a more um agnostic title for it.
22:11 Speaker 1 Probably like three musketeers equity, you know, all for one, one for all. So something more like team oriented.
22:18 Speaker 0 Yeah, no, I agree, but I I think for from an employee perspective, um I think once you talk to employees about it, they they get it pretty quickly, and there's nothing about it that's anti-capitalist.
22:30 Speaker 1 So you you know, in a world where you've got incidents like when the secret guys bought Ferraris off the secondary and like all the employees were were very depressed and upset about that, and just you know, kind of a general um you know, less loyal kind of company environment, you know, partly due to all the opportunities and so forth, but it's very difficult to build a great company uh if the people in the company don't love the company and want to stay there a long time. And I would just say in closing that congratulations on like a really creative step to figuring out how to put that together. And um I'm hoping it works. It is a great experiment, but really, really thoughtful.
23:19 Speaker 1 And congratulations and thank you for coming, Andrew.
23:23 Speaker 0 Thanks. My pleasure.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated