Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Is Entrepreneurship a Universal Language? About this episode In this special international edition of the a16z Podcast, Mohsen Malayeri, co-founder of Avatech -- one of the more prominent startup accelerators in Iran among many (much like Y Combinator in the U. S.) -- talks to guest interviewer Christopher Schroeder (former entrepreneur, D. C. investor, and author of Startup Rising) about startups in Iran.
What happens when you have a "mobile-first" startup ecosystem? Is this about trying to be yet another Silicon Valley (and if so, are we just substituting a form of technocracy for theocracy)? Silicon Valley isn't a religion, observes Malayeri, but entrepreneurship IS "a common language which has no border".
This is the third installment in a special series on tech startups in Iran, part of a larger theme around global tech and how software -- including mobile -- is eating the world … and creating new opportunities within it.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 2 Hi everyone, welcome to the A6 and Z podcast. I'm Thonal, and I'm here today in another special edition of the A6 and Z podcast. We have two special guests, including one internationally dialing in from Iran, Mosin Mollyari, who is the co-founder of a very prominent startup accelerator in Iran called Avatek. We're here also with Christopher Schroeder, who wrote a really interesting book last year called Startup Rising, and has been documenting and facilitating the phenomenon that's happening right now in the Middle East and particularly in Iran, where there's a lot of interesting startups and a rich ecosystem being built out.
0:34 Speaker 1 Mosan, it's great to be with you. How are you? I'm doing great. Thanks. It's uh it's a pleasure to be on the podcast. I don't think there are lots of Americans who think startup accelerator, incubator, and Tehran in the same sentence. So could you just talk a little bit? Uh really just kind of a cook's tour from your view of what's been happening over the last couple of years in Tehran as startups are beginning to rise in such powerful ways there. There has been a huge
1:01 Speaker 0 change in the past couple of years in Iran, uh, in the startup scene, I should say. Well, we started like two uh two and a half years ago when we uh organized the first startup weekend even in Tehran. The reason we did that was that uh for doing some research, we came to know that lots of startups are failing in Iran. And there isn't much talk about it because most of them they don't uh have a clue of how to build a startup. So that's that's how we we learned that we maybe need to do startup weekend events and start building startup communities around it. We so much used uh the book of uh Bradfeld, uh, which is called the startup communities. Uh we were reading it uh almost using it as a Bible on how to to to build one here in Tehran.
1:50 Speaker 0 And uh suddenly it started to flame over the country. So we started to see a lot of events happening in different cities. For example, only the last 12 months we did like uh 35 startup weekend events in different cities. And it's not just a startup weekend events, it's like the whole events of uh that that encourage the community to get involved and to to grow the community. So on one part, you see the ecosystem is being built up in the country, and at the same time in the past uh couple of years, you see we see the success of stories actually being realized, both at local and international level in Iran.
2:30 Speaker 1 Why did you even decide to do a startup weekend two years ago? And and what was kind of your vision for the ecosystem and how has it played out for you since then?
2:39 Speaker 0 I can go back in time and see that when we started doing these uh I was an entrepreneur myself. Uh we and me and my co-founder, we we had a digital advertising company, uh, which is still exists. Uh and at that time, although we were on entrepreneurs and we were having our own startups, we were so much interested to see how we can leave an impact on our own community. So at that time, before even we started uh running those kind of events around the startups, we were having uh meetups uh regularly trying to engage the community of tech uh tech people, but at that time maybe the focus was not so much on entrepreneurship, I should say. But over time, observing what was happening and seeing a lot of those failure stories by talented engineers who were like really genius, and there were lots of them were already uh draining from the country outside.
3:34 Speaker 0 Uh we we came to know that maybe entrepreneurship is the right solution to it, and we shouldn't uh focus more on the startups. And and I and I could emphasize that at the same time the same was happening in the middle of these uh in the whole region uh perhaps. So we were seeing almost similar stuff in Turkey, in in Arabic countries, and we were, you know, it we were making sure that perhaps we are on the right track.
4:01 Speaker 1 I think that people here underestimate that if you believe as I do, and obviously our friends at A16Z believe that software is eating the world, that means the world. That whenever there's ubiquitous access to technology, as I said from the beginning, people just have the tools to solve problems or create their economic futures. And I am seeing this. I mean, in America, when you think Middle East, all you think of is CNN and ISIS. And I'm seeing literally hundreds of thousands of young people using tools to step up in the same ways that you're talking about. I want to talk a little bit about your first Avatech class, but before that, you you mentioned two or three companies which are doing some amazing things there. Could you give us a little bit about Digicala and the other two that you've talked about and and and how they're doing?
4:46 Speaker 0 Sure. Uh there was this report last year coming out. It was a startup word report, which was conducted in 50 different countries doing a survey on the startup scene. And the report uh result came out with three top valued companies in different countries. And in Iran, uh the top companies were Digikolar, Kaffee Buzzar, and Aparat. So digical is basically uh the big the biggest online retailer in Iran, it's like Amazon of Iran. Uh the second one was Apparat, which is a clone of uh YouTube, uh, because the access is blocked in the country, and also there are some services from Google which are blocked used as sanctions are not being provided to the to the people.
5:31 Speaker 0 So that's a service which is similar to that they're serving millions of users every day. And the third one is uh Android uh Apple store place with more than 15 million users right now. Uh they are basically some something quite similar to Google Google Play, which is a marketplace for uh uh applications. So the Iranian Android users can both download applications and also the developer community and the application builders can can publish their their applications on this platform.
6:05 Speaker 1 And this happened because Google Play effectively pulled out uh because of sanctions or whatever, is that right? They filled a vacuum this company.
6:13 Speaker 0 It's it's very interesting to know that Google Play used to be blocked until last year. Uh there were some changes in Treasury regulations, which made the which later on they opened up the access, but nothing is really changed in terms of access to Google Play because uh by the time that the Google Play service was opened up in the country, although there was there hasn't been a lot of advertising around it, which I don't think Google needs, but uh Koffer Buzzer has already created some domination in the market. So they are still the dominant in terms of like number of users and number of applications being downloaded. But I think in terms of publishing applications, still there are some sanctions, which doesn't let uh Iranian app builders to really publish their applications officially, I should say, on those platforms.
6:58 Speaker 1 And in fact, because there they're like this was stunning to me, but there are you know millions of iPhones there. You can only download iPhone uh free apps, right? You're not able to transact and buy paid apps. Is that true?
7:10 Speaker 0 Well, the reason is that uh because of sanctions, we are not connected to the global credit uh uh let me visa and master card systems, which uh like turn the country to create their own local platform, which is like we we use for online uh online payments. But that's true. I mean, we we people in Iran basically uh unless they they kind of try to bypass somehow, or they buy iTunes gift card, which is not very popular. So most of them are now using the free applications.
7:40 Speaker 1 So it's interesting to me that the companies that you've mentioned have effectively been there's a word I hate. Uh we use in America called copycats. And uh what I like to use in a fact of my book, I call them improvisers because what what great entrepreneurs do is don't merely make quote unquote the Amazon or the of Iran, they are actually thinking about Iranian consumers, they're thinking about very specific needs in the market, and and so they're taking things which have worked elsewhere, but they're making them there. Um and so there are two things. I'm curious your view on that. Um, are most of these startups really first things that have uh worked in the West, and how do you think about that? And then secondly, what are the ramifications if sanctions fall when the actual Western companies come into Iran?
8:28 Speaker 0 Sure. Um I think that the the to answer the first question, which uh asked if if copycats uh I mean, how is the system of copycasts in the country? I think it's like any other emerging market, uh, when we see the penetration of internet increases, the market opportunities that shows up very clearly are the ones which have been proven in in the rest of the world. Um Ali Bomberging
8:53 Speaker 1 I do in China, Yemesapeki, which is the uh seamless of Turkey, Mercado Libre, which is the Amazon of Latin America. This happens everywhere, right?
9:04 Speaker 0 Right. And I I don't think like uh uh I mean, as you as you mentioned, it's really not maybe proper to call them copycats because uh because that's the idea and that's the market opportunity, and an entrepreneur has to tap into the opportunity. So they they ran to it. But the it's seeing if if there are also innovations happening in terms of being very innovative with new ideas, we we have experienced it in our startup accelerator program on sales. We believe that the whole innovation ecosystem is very nascent at this stage, but will improve over time as there will be more access to finance. There will be no more knowledge on how to lead and build those type of innovations and build companies over them. So I'm sure that it will change over time, but maybe at this stage, still we can call it very nascent.
9:53 Speaker 1 I had a wonderful entrepreneur uh who built what was effectively the Yahoo of the Middle East called Mach. Two, which got bought by Yahoo for almost 200 million dollars. We had a conversation like this, and he said to me, Chris, he said, be practical. I mean, this is new to these markets. Uh, these are markets that often don't embrace risk. These are markets that often have people seeking government jobs or big corporate engineering jobs if they can find them at all. If some kid came home and said, Mom, dad, I'm dropping out of college and I'm going to do uh Facebook, you know, they would have been laughed at. Their friends would have said it's crazy, they wouldn't have been able to find investors. But by doing what you've just described, it seems to me, success breeds success. And when investors see success and communities see success, more people want to do it, and then it does exactly as you say, it opens up an entire ecosystem.
10:43 Speaker 1 Am I missing something?
10:45 Speaker 0 No, absolutely. I mean, the we have seen how the interest of the young community has changed once they started to see these successes, local successes stories being realized. So we see them that instead of looking at Mark Zuckerberg and like Steve Jobs and say that, okay, maybe in this country I can't really do it, they see that no, maybe even success stories can exist in the same market. And I mean, hopefully we may we might be even to see that the rate of brain drains would decrease over time as the local ecosystem encourages and empowers the entrepreneurs.
11:21 Speaker 1 Which I think is an amazingly important point because I was struck that honestly, most of some of the best engineering talent that I've seen in emerging growth markets, I've met in Iran. Uh, you guys graduate something like six or seven hundred thousand uh engineers across the spectrum of engineering every year. Half of them, by the way, are women, but a lot of them are trying to leave the country. And do you think that that might change now, both because of entrepreneurship and also because of the potential if the uh if in fact the sanctions get lifted?
11:55 Speaker 0 I'm sure that the the impact would be even higher over time. Uh and the the impact is not only to stop brain drain, and not it's not really stopping, but decreasing this the brain drain. We have started to see uh some of those uh successful diasporas and started to coming back to the country, those who have been working in top tech, you know, engineering companies and top uh startup companies, they they now realize that maybe this emerging market is the right thing to do instead of working, for example, for our
12:25 Speaker 1 Cisco or Twitter, maybe they
12:27 Speaker 0 can leverage that knowledge and come back to this emerging market and start doing in their own country. So that that could be a huge impact over time, I believe.
12:37 Speaker 1 So you set up Avitech as a vehicle to help such people as you've just described, um, meet needs that they have. Like, how do I do this? How do I begin? What do I need? Can you talk a little bit in your vision of Avatech? What problems do you think you're solving for the ecosystem and for the entrepreneurs themselves? And how do you think this will evolve over the next couple of years?
13:00 Speaker 0 Yeah, we we have a very simple vision at Avatech, uh, if I want to put it into one sentence, is is a day where uh no matter which family you are coming from, or if you have a reach dead or a connected family, well, unless you are an innovative person and you can build value, then you do not have to worry about like the access to finance and access to knowledge. So this is the simply the vision that we are trying to create at Awatec. So that's why we have been trying to help the young entrepreneurs uh, you know, coming from different cities, uh having their ideas, being so passionate, and just we we take them to our program, we try to mentor them, train them and get them ready, and by the end of the program, we try to help uh to connect them with the investors.
13:47 Speaker 1 Can you tell us about the program? What's how long are they there? What kind of money do you arrange for them? What services do you think they need most and value most from you?
13:57 Speaker 0 I mean uh we we have been observing what is uh what's happening at the global level. Uh we we haven't really tried to copy the Silicon Valley model, which we believe that doesn't really work in in such an emerging market.
14:12 Speaker 1 Are you talking about like uh Y Combinator and 500 startups or
14:16 Speaker 0 hopefully we have tried to get uh as much as possible and they have been very helpful. I should say that like we have been in touch with top figures in Silicon Valley trying to get on get on Skype call with them, get get their insight into what we should be doing here. Um but we yet, I mean, we haven't tried to copy Tech Stars or Y Combinator competitor here, which we we believe that doesn't work in
14:40 Speaker 1 in such markets. What do you mean when you say that?
14:42 Speaker 0 In terms of the amount of funding you provide, the how long is the program. For example, let's say that mentorship is a culture that has been existed in Silicon Valley for the past
14:54 Speaker 1 uh
14:54 Speaker 0 couple of uh decades. But in in Iran, the whole the whole culture of doing mentorship is is new. So you can't really count so much on such mentors, or the other one is the maturity of the investor community is it's absolutely different. Like you don't have people, a lot of angels trying to, you know, being able to write checks easily without going into too much detiligence and trying to figure out everything uh on the investment memorandum, let's say. So that that's the reason that we believe that we needed to tailor make this program into what we have here. So there are many differences. For example, the the length of the program is not very short, it's not three, four months, it's six months, which consists of pre-acceleration and acceleration.
15:40 Speaker 0 Or the way we do graduation, a demo day, is not that we just get them in front of investors and we say goodbye. We believe that we need to help them step by step to close the deal. But over time, this is gonna be a knowledge that these guys are going to put out and they're going to share their experience. We need to also help them close the deals, get into negotiations with investors, try to empower them in any way. So that's that's how, for example, the program is different at this stage.
16:10 Speaker 1 And so talk a little. I mean, you just announced a class not too long. I don't know, you call it a class, or what do you call the
16:15 Speaker 0 We call them cycle one?
16:16 Speaker 1 Talk about some of these uh gems that you have found uh in cycle one.
16:21 Speaker 0 Well, I I should first of all say that we were uh absolutely uh inspired by what the the entrepreneurs have been able to achieve in such a short period of time, which is six months. Um we I when I go back in time, I remember that like we once we were calling for applications, we were having people showing up as as as one person or or like they were not able to pitch properly to tell us what they really want to do. But I should emphasize that what we did is that we tried to believe in them.
16:56 Speaker 1 And
16:57 Speaker 0 I mean, if if they wanted to get in front of an investor, they would have absolutely get a red card and they would say that no, don't call us anymore, like we don't want to hear it is again. But we instead tried to understand what the ecosystem looks like. And so we tried to believe in those people. We got them into the program. We had like in the first cycle, we had around 100 applicants only, which in the second one increased uh to 250 applicants. But uh, out of those hundred applicants, we we selected 20 of the teams, and we tried to help them during the program with a lot of trainings, a lot of workshops, uh you know, starting from how to pitch to going up to like getting tractions, doing sales and marketing, uh user experience and stuff like that. And at the same time, we started to create a network of mentors, which is not only local mentors who who whom many of them has created those success stories which I just mentioned.
17:52 Speaker 0 We have seen a lot of interest from people, successful entrepreneurs in different countries sending us email, hey guys, we're inspired what we with what you're doing, we want to help, let us know how you do. Uh how we can get engaged. So they they have even been people who are not Iranian and they are based, for example, in Berlin or they're based in uh Washington, and they are now helping uh entrepreneurs in Iran. Uh that you know, they they get on Skype calls, see them, they travel and they just stop by uh by the accelerator and they spend hours with the teams. This has been very effective. I mean, when we see the outcoming results, which is still perhaps is not really comparable with with the graduation from top accelerators around the world. But when we see the progress, it shows that it has been a huge progress.
18:40 Speaker 0 And we believe that if we can't surround the entrepreneurs with the right environment, then they're gonna start glowing in that in that environment.
18:49 Speaker 1 So I'm gonna ask you uh in a minute again about a couple of the specifics in Avatech in the cycle, but you you you're pulling on something very interesting here because I've visited uh accelerator programs around the world and in emerging growth markets. And I mean, a little secret, I think about them even in America, is that maybe with the exception of Y Combinator, maybe 500 startups, a lot of them in the states um have had a mixed batting average and all. And yet I think in a in in nascent ecosystems, they get they're invaluable and just very, very powerful because of the reasons you've just suggested. What do you think are some of the most fundamental structural problems that your entrepreneurs are facing? And I mean this twofold. One is um what do you think that that literally is just a challenge for them to start a business in Iran?
19:37 Speaker 1 But secondly, and I've seen this in other markets where um, you know, they're culturally just learning how to be an entrepreneur, the amount of hard work that has to go into the the talent in Iran is unquestionable. But are there just sort of in these early days challenges that the entrepreneurs have to learn to be great entrepreneurs? Or are they really just ready to go and it's just a matter of them? Going. Well, I mean, there are,
20:03 Speaker 0 of course, different uh the perspective to these questions. But I can emphasize on two different sides. So one side is the entrepreneurs themselves. I think the biggest challenge that they are faced with is leadership, is uh how they are empowered as as entrepreneurs uh in internally to to take over and accept to go to such a you know challenging journey, which is challenging. I mean, uh nobody has doubt that it's it has a lot of ups and downs. And keeping a team and building a concrete team and leading a concrete team around it, I think that's the biggest challenge at this stage. And uh they need to learn how to do it because the rest can be done by trainings, but mentorship, but unless they can't really solve it internally with themselves, getting ready to go to such a journey and having a purpose for it, it would be difficult for them to do it, I think.
20:54 Speaker 0 So we that's why we also emphasize so much on soft skills like leadership, communication, and and things like that, uh especially beginning of the program, we spend so much time with the teams to help them with with such a skills. Um, the other side, I think the the biggest challenge that the entrepreneurs in Iran are are faced with is the the word belief. I think that's the biggest challenge that they're believing. Nobody is believing them. I mean, the government sometimes they don't believe in them, the the investors they don't believe in them. And unless you don't believe in people, like you can't really make a make a huge change. You you have to believe that these guys, because it's all based on projected future.
21:38 Speaker 1 You know, in America, when we think about the government in Iran, we think of it through the lens of you know, frankly, Argo and uh obviously rule of law, corruption. I mean, there are serious issues as there are in many emerging markets. I was quite surprised to see 31 uh government accelerators with some very good technology in it. Um, and I was very surprised to talk to ministers in the information communication technology area who who talk about a hell of a vision to build infrastructure there to encourage uh innovation in very serious ways. Are you feeling that on the ground?
22:16 Speaker 0 We have been feeling it over the past uh couple of years, especially after the election, that the the government is really keen to know how they can lift the barriers. Uh I mean, like anywhere in the world, uh the the government has to focus on infrastructure instead of like getting so much engaged with uh with the startup communities and entrepreneurs. Uh but I think the government has the real intention to help, and they in some parts they've been able to do it. Uh we now have initiatives which are supported by government uh to promote the startup scene. They believe that entrepreneurship is the right uh solution to to most of the challenges, both economic and political and uh all this. So uh we we have seen a huge improvement in the in the the region of the government and in in their approaches uh on how they can help the entrepreneurs.
23:10 Speaker 1 Tell me a little bit about some of your favorite. Well, I don't want to say there are no such things as favorites, but just tell me about a couple of the the recent cycle of Avatech companies uh that are intriguing you.
23:22 Speaker 0 So, for example, in the first cycle, we we did have different startups. We did we did have a startup which was basically uh food delivery platform, uh, an online food delivery platform. The we which was absolutely targeting a local market trying to create a local value. Uh we did have startups which are not clones of successful models. For example, we did have a startup trying to do something in sharing economy uh so people can lend their stuff together to each other. But we did have uh an application trying to help people choose their favorite music in public locations, for example, which was cafetunes, which many of them are like published on the website uh of uh of Avatix.
24:08 Speaker 0 So I can tell that the there were the there were a diverse uh uh set of startups in the first cycle.
24:15 Speaker 1 I just came back after being in town to Istanbul, Turkey, of course, is a remarkable market. Uh the food service uh service there, the seamless of Turkey is a company called Yemesapeki, which just got acquired for over 650 million dollars, and there have been several multi-hundred million dollar exits there. One of the limits on Turkish startups, and I wonder if this has a limit at all with Iran going forward, is that not that many people outside of Turkey speak Turkish. So, you know, do you find that uh Persian is obviously a language of Iran? Uh, but do you find that folks are thinking now with the global economy coming that they're they're trying to think about things in English, or are they thinking about how to reach other emerging growth markets?
25:02 Speaker 1 Uh, is there any limitation on um uh the language as a unique thing for Iran? How do you think about that going forward? Sure.
25:10 Speaker 0 Um language is absolutely a barrier, but I don't find it as the biggest barrier. I think the biggest barrier is the local challenges that building is uh a business has uh in this market from understanding the dynamics of the market, the perspective of the customer, how you want to do the operation, which is absolutely every emerging market has its own uh uh you know dynamics in their own market. So this is, I think is the biggest barrier to understand how the local economy looks like. Going back to a question I think we didn't really talk about it, is that what what would happen in Iran once the sanctions are lifted and then the international companies start moving again?
25:47 Speaker 1 At one level, you've articulated almost a strange benefit that startups have by sanctions, meaning they've been able to build things without a lot of global competition and build some very strong enterprises doing it. If sanctions come down, obviously the uh big global players will be in very, very quickly. I mean, we see Google, Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, all over uh the world right now. So I had someone say something very interesting to me about India, though. They said to me that if you're very locally focused, the big players have had trouble. So, you know, Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, they they tend to be saying a country like India, they tend to be the LinkedIn, Facebook, and Twitters of India. But there's a reason why Flipkar is doing so well there, which is you really need to understand locality to be able to succeed.
26:34 Speaker 1 You can't just jump in overnight. And I'm wondering, uh if the sanctions come down, how do you look at um the uh Western companies and Asian companies coming in? And what do you think are going to be areas that Iranian companies not only will hold very strongly within Iran, but will be able to enter the global market more.
26:53 Speaker 0 Yeah, I I do have my very personal perspective on this. Uh I believe that if a country has specific competitive advantages in specific sectors, the wealth and the value has to be created by the local community. And uh, for example, if Iran doesn't have, for example, it's just an example. If we don't have real competitive advantage in producing cars, for example, Volkswagen entering to the market is an absolutely great opportunity. If there isn't any competitive advantage, but the challenge for entrepreneurs, for local entrepreneurs here, would be creating absolute barrier to entry by by creating domination. So that's that's what happened to PhilipCard, I think, because Flipkart was not only solving the local challenges perfectly, but also over time, before Amazon steps in, they have been able to get some market share.
27:43 Speaker 0 And over time they have been able to change it to market domination. So I think local entrepreneurs, the biggest charity, uh the biggest challenge for them is that until the sanctions are lifted, which uh I should I should even emphasize that not all companies waited until sanctions be lifted completely. Some of them has already started moving in the country. Uh, but they have to work hard, and they have to try to create barriers to entry for them. If they believe that they have the competitive advantage of doing it much better in the local market.
28:18 Speaker 1 So you mentioned something parenthetically that to me was one of the maybe two or three biggest takeaways I had there, which is you know, Americans tend to think like sanctions is about America and America will decide this, and America needs to be there. And frankly, historically, there's been truth to that. To make it in technology globally in the last 20 years has meant to make it in America, if not in the West, right? I mean, even uh hardware providers like Sony or Samsung, you know, you had to make it in America because that was the market for it. But but all of a sudden we're seeing, we saw it with Alibaba, and we're seeing it more and more, that companies and other countries are becoming very aggressive. And you mentioned, and I saw this everywhere when I was in Tehran a couple of weeks ago.
29:03 Speaker 1 The rest of the world is showing up. I saw Chinese everywhere, I saw Germans everywhere, I saw Scandinavians everywhere, I saw Indians everywhere. And and you you touched on that. I mean, talk about the I the what uh other countries are doing and what they're exploring in the the Iranian ecosystem now.
29:21 Speaker 0 There is a well-known company, Rocket Internet, which has already already started operating in the country, a German company which uh is basically cloning the successful models in emerging market where the ecosystem is not really bright that local entrepreneurs be able to create it. But uh they haven't really officially uh talked about it, but they they have been operating here and tried to trying to to build startups, uh some of them which is already existed by by local entrepreneurs, some of them haven't started haven't been started yet. But I mean, for that that's just an example. They have been operating since the uh last couple of months and they are now uh spending a lot of money to to
30:05 Speaker 1 be
30:05 Speaker 0 able to create market you know to to get the market share on those specific uh markets that they have targeted
30:11 Speaker 1 Samsung phones are everywhere HTC phones are everywhere I hear show me is coming in
30:16 Speaker 0 so that's that's in the internet the startups but we see yes we see that Samsung LG Sony all these companies are hugely working here and they're they are having uh huge market shares in the country of 80 million population
30:32 Speaker 1 so I it's uh this cuts across the economy this isn't just about startups most and as you know uh people that I've met with in Toronto both trips that I've done uh and around the country are not shy uh to use uh the word corruption and a lot of the issues that are are true of course in many emerging markets China has been wrestling corruption at a magnitude that's almost hard to conceive of and so that's not that this is unfamiliar territory but I can tell you when Western investors anyhow look at new markets to enter rule of law is essential uh the ability for people to move themselves goods and services is essential the ability to uh repatriate capital is essential the ability not to deal with corruption is very hard and important uh can you just talk a little bit about how uh you think we should be thinking about Iran now and knowing full well that you know the next couple of years could change uh and it could change badly as well as positively how would you have us think a little bit about the the kind of ability of functioning and rule of law there
31:37 Speaker 0 sure uh so there are a few issues uh unfortunately Iran doesn't have a good rank in the doing business uh at this at this moment but as you as you just said uh it's like any other emerging market which doesn't have a top rank but it's uh having a positive progress uh what we have seen here is that uh for example the the law and the regulations has has had a has created a lot of barriers for entrepreneurs uh both in in the in the market perspective and also the the the operation so uh talking about examples uh for for example creating a company is still uh not something that you can do very quickly so that's been one of the challenges we have been uh uh facing with that Awatec for example creating a company has taken up to four to five months sometimes like going back and forth with the documents uh which is not good but government is having uh the specific campaigns and it's also not only government there are lots of NGOs trying to advocate on a specific issues which they believe that are barriers to to private sector and trying to to change that environment into into a better one for for the private sector but uh didn't get your question especially like the is it how how we how we think that this would change over time.
33:01 Speaker 1 Yeah
33:01 Speaker 0 I don't think like I have the real expertise to answer that question but from what what I observed is that uh be being the having the government who is very keen to to solve them uh of course much more agile than the previous government uh I think that the progress would be there and it would get absolutely better to we there is lots of lacks uh still IP is a big issue here uh but uh there there are different initiatives and different advocacy campaigns to address them
33:31 Speaker 1 you know most of one of the great advantages that are built in the United States particularly over the last maybe five or seven years there's just so many platforms where entrepreneurs can build businesses very lightly I mean our access to cloud computing has had an enormous ramification for startups overall sharing economy platforms have been profound as we've alluded to before uh you can make or break a business by accessing APIs and things like Facebook and Twitter that's still pretty nascent there. How do you think about that as a benefit or challenge for the startups in your backyard.
34:02 Speaker 0 I think uh considering those uh existing platforms and as required infrastructure for entrepreneurs I think we are pretty uh at a very low level with this so but but there are the platform there are platforms being made for example going back in time uh if you are an app developer and you want to you know serve an application in local market there wasn't such platform of uh like coffee buzzar which we just talked about it but now there is a platform where 15 million more than 15 million users are already using it and five million people are using it every day like daily uh users so those platforms are being made still access to Twitter to the advertise Facebook to advertise Google to advertise doesn't exist in the country but there are for example a platform of local the display ad network which is serving more than 60 million banners every day but these local platforms are being made on the other side we see that uh the cloud is becoming very important uh the the private sector has serious plan the government is trying to subsidize to create different data centers and cloud services in different even different regions of the country uh so the infrastructure is improving the penetration of the internet has changed uh we are now one of the one of we have one now one of the highest rate of internet penetration and smartphone penetration I've just heard it from uh the CEO of uh a mobile operator here the leading mobile operator that every month there is one million smartphones being added to the network of the country so this is this is a huge growth I mean uh in terms of payment although there are lots of services to be improved that doesn't exist for example the economic of subscription doesn't really exist here but the the there are initiatives to solve those issues and address those issues but comparing it with the rest of the region Iran has uh one of the highest uh online payments rate for example now the the top uh uh websites are now exploring 20% cash on delivery uh and 80% uh online payments which is huge I mean comparing it with Arab countries and even Turkey it's a it's a huge rate yeah so those infrastructures are really changing rapidly in the country and hopefully over time when the sanctions are lifted there will be more existing platforms that we can use in global level and then that's that's uh where the entrepreneurs would get a kick start to to build a startup and create a value.
36:24 Speaker 1 In some respects the biggest surprise I had year over year was that while uh broadband penetration and and mobile connectivity was as high if not higher than any emerging market I went to think things like 3G, 4G were still very, very low. And and folks told me a year ago that they're going to roll out aggressively 3G, 4G, but other business people said nah they'll take their time that's risky I don't think they'll do it. I'm I'm there a year later and there are 20 million plus now subscribers to 3G and 4G out of a country of 80 million and I think they'll get to everyone you know in very short order. I I think with people are walking around with supercomputers in their pockets it changes everything. Can you talk a little bit more about how mobile is changing the dynamics in Iran generally and for the startup ecosystem that's going to be very much a mobile first ecosystem.
37:12 Speaker 1 I'm sure
37:12 Speaker 0 that over time it's going to be mobile first seriously we have seen a huge growth in in mobile adoption I mean Iranian people are very tech savvy they really use uh technology products uh the the reason that it has exploded now is that uh Iranian mobile users uh and the mobile penetration of uh uh in Iran is more than 120% it means that everybody has more than one phone uh there there are people who have more than one phone uh but but the the the access to internet over mobile was kind of limited to some regulations that uh it was only provided to the to a third operator which hasn't really used that privilege very well in expanding the 3G connection in the country but last year we had this uh finished so you can imagine that in a country with 80 million population where you have 120 percent small uh 120% uh mobile penetration suddenly everything changes to a smartphone talking of uh of an example we in first cycle of AWATIC we had a startup which was serving uh females at home uh helping them to and empowering them to create handicrafts seeing a huge massive traffic by what by by females at home by women at home coming from mobile and these that's the reason these guys started building a mobile application instead of rushing into a website because they'll because talking to customers they said that I'm using my tablet and I'm using my mobile and I don't want to use my my sound's desktop for example
38:45 Speaker 1 one of the most frequent questions I've gotten as I've traveled around the world with this is it's uh I think it's actually a silly meme but you hear it all the time people will say you know what's the Silicon Valley of X and while great cities matter and uh network effects of talent the more people who are good the more people who are good want to be there is not irrelevant uh I actually have sort of become convinced it's the wrong question that that when you have a uh mobile empowered uh anywhere that that's an opportunity for innovation that's an opportunity for people to solve problems that's an opportunity for people to take control of their economic futures how how do you think about that question when you look at uh Iran is to is Tehran in fact to be a Silicon Valley or is it a really a broader different kind of approach a new way to think about um economic development economic job creation and innovation and actualization in your country Bradfield was
39:40 Speaker 0 just doing uh blog posts on it if if if what Silicon Valley is he was calling it as a religion as a state of mind as whatever is it it is but I think uh talking of Silicon Valley as as as an uh environment where innovation really boosts and can create wealth in the in in in a In a region, I think over the past and seeing the progress of the past few years, I believe that Silicon Valley is being created in Iran Plata. And we have observed, we have been starting observing it. I'm not saying that it is becoming Silicon Valley. Maybe even the vision is not there. But we see that more innovation is happening. And we see that more businesses are being built, which are to some extent even disruptive to traditional industries.
40:29 Speaker 0 And we are uh we have already started observing it, and it's very interesting to see it. And I think 2015 is is the tipping point for Iranian entrepreneurs.
40:40 Speaker 1 I don't use this word lightly, but as I've gone to meet you and a lot of your colleagues, you know, hundreds of them in my brief trips over there. Um, I think you guys are heroes and the women are heroes. Because I think that you're not only creating a new narrative of uh because you've got access to this technology and and are integrating in the world almost regardless of what governments do and top-down institutions do, but you're unleashing amazing talent bottom up, which if we had this conversation five years ago, 10 years ago, I think would have been near impossible in many parts of the world, not just Iran. And I think that this is a very exciting narrative that most of us in America don't get a chance to see. But when we hear it and understand it, and particularly those of us, you know, who have built startups and we've used technology and we know what can happen with it.
41:25 Speaker 1 I think most people are going to listen to you today and think, of course, of course, why wouldn't it be this way? As opposed to before this conversation, people have this one view of so many parts of the world in Iran in particular. So it's just been a joy to spend more time with you. And I wish you uh the best of luck in all that you're doing. Yeah, thank
41:44 Speaker 0 thank you. It was really a pleasure to talk to you again. And as you emphasized, I believe that entrepreneurship is a common language which has no border, absolutely. And uh we we see a lot of similarities between an entrepreneur based in Silicon Valley and the one based in in Tehran. And we believe that by the way leveraging and you know uh synergizing those those types of uh characteristics, we can we can all get a better world.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated