Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | How Innovation Ecosystems Grow Around the Globe About this episode Why do so many-government led efforts to build the next "Silicon Valley" in one geography or another fail? Is it misguided to even try? But then what does make such innovation clusters work?
In this segment of the pod a trio of expert guests -- AnnaLee Saxenian, Dean of the UC Berkeley School of Information and a longtime researcher/observer of regional competitive advantage; VC Brad Feld and writer on startup communities; and entrepreneur and investor Christopher Schroeder, who covers startups rising in the Middle East and most recently wrote about the tech phenomenon in Iran -- tackle the question of how innovation ecosystems grow. The discussion delves into how innovation is being spurred differently (or stifled) in places like China and Iran; whether there are cultural differences in attitudes for failure or about entrepreneurship; and if regulatory arbitrage is one way for regions to get ahead.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 3 Hi everyone, welcome to the A6 and Z podcast. Today we're talking about startup and innovation ecosystems. I know those are pretty loaded set of buzzwords. In this case, though, it actually really is an ecosystem because we're talking about cities, communities of entrepreneurs, governments, universities, companies, and others. And we want to talk about what makes these innovation ecosystems around the world work or not. Especially since the question we hear often, for better or worse, is how to create the next Silicon Valley.
0:28 Speaker 0 The notion of trying to create the next Silicon Valley is completely the wrong question. And it's wrong question for lots of reasons.
0:35 Speaker 3 So that's why we have three special guests on the pod today who are experts in different aspects of this topic. Anna Lee Saxinian, who's the dean of the UC Berkeley School of Information and a longtime researcher who has studied competitive advantage around the world. Brad Feld, DC at Foundry Group in Colorado, and the author of the book Startup Communities, and who has written a lot about the power of networks over hierarchies. And Chris Schroeder, who's a serial entrepreneur and investor, and who also once served in the staff of former secretaries of state. He wrote the book Startup Rising last year, which is one of the first books to document the phenomenon of startups in the Middle East. And more recently, he's written about the impact of software eating the world and how that's been playing out in Iran. So let's start by having you guys talk about what makes a successful innovation cluster like Silicon Valley.
1:22 Speaker 3 I'm not even sure if that's the right assumption for us to begin from, um, given the question and given how many of those government-led experiments have failed. But since the three of you have different perspectives on this topic, I think it'd be great for us to begin there.
1:36 Speaker 2 I think the the fact is that most places that have tried to create the next Silicon Valley have not succeeded largely because they focus on um specific institutions in isolation without understanding that one of the most important dynamics is the opening of boundaries between firms, between firms and finance, between industries and government, that really allowing we we talk a lot about how information has opened up global access and that allowed new parts of the globe to compete. But opening up flows of information locally, I mean, at the local level between between people, you know, really from the bottom up, I think has been critical in to to making places like Silicon Valley dynamic because ideas get move much more quickly than they do within vertical corporations where they they tend to get trapped, and people can act, they can use center capital, they can invest, they can reform, they can recruit teams much more quickly when information flows openly between them.
2:41 Speaker 2 And so a lot of the things that we look at, whether it's a university or uh a venture capital, you know, sector or whatever, those work especially if they are open to the rest of the ecosystem so that people can learn across boundaries much more quickly.
2:58 Speaker 1 I think that people are learning across boundaries much more quickly, exactly as Anna said. I think there's something that's very different from any time before as these ecosystems have uh risen, and that is a very auto-didact nature of young people with mobile devices to learn not only from each other and to share and innovate and collaborate on things that might be relevant within their markets, but they are instantly seeing the best practices and the best writings of people like Anna and people like Brad and people like Ben Harlowitz, and and they have an ability to access and engage and ask questions and uh improvise on what are best practices elsewhere uh in ways that we simply couldn't have talked about, I think, even five years ago. I had uh a conversation the other day with a bunch of uh young people in Iraq who were drilling me about different valuations of startups now and drilling me about different kinds of ways social networks are functioning in the United States and making their own analogies of what are relevant in Iraq, which of course was completely unprecedented.
3:56 Speaker 1 And when I was in Iran a month ago, all the young people wanted to show me on their smart devices, not only how they were all on our social networks, which allows them to see each other as well as to see other parts of the world, all of them had access to Coursera, all of them were on Khan Academy, all of them were looking at uh Quora, all of them were looking at what other people are doing, and building something bottom up, which is not a replacement for some of the challenges that are still essential in a traditional Silicon Valley story, uh, but actually open up an opportunity and something that's happening in parallel that again we could not have talked about a few years ago.
4:34 Speaker 0 Yeah, I I think the uh the these two constructs uh uh profound and collide nicely this notion of of uh making you know opening up boundaries, making them more porous, which Anna talks about or
4:47 Speaker 3 and and
4:48 Speaker 0 has very articulately for a long time in a lot of the uh the the writing I've done about networks, especially networks versus hierarchies is built on that. Uh and you know what Chris just said about um the technology enablement, which we've been talking about for 20 or 30 years, but it's actually now uh reality uh in terms of how information flows across geographic boundaries. And what I think it it uh results in is that the notion of trying to create the next Silicon Valley is is completely the wrong question. Um it's wrong question for lots of reasons, um, but most importantly, each different geographic region, any city in the world has different uh natural resources. And you know, when I say natural resources, it's only just physical natural resources, but structural dynamics about how the city works, about what in that geography or region is powerful or unique, um, and then you have this layer of knowledge that's pervasive that transcends geography.
5:44 Speaker 0 And over a period of time, not a short period of time, 20 years, 30 years, 40 years, you can have really amazing things happen in different startup communities if you take that very long arc with this notion of the permeability of this information across all kinds of boundaries, not just geographically, but within whatever that region is. Right.
6:05 Speaker 3 What are some of those assets when you Brad, when you talk about, you know, these are assets that aren't necessarily natural assets. I mean, we're now talking about information economy. So the assets can be in the form of human capital. What are your thoughts about how that varies across regions and what it takes to sort of make those communities thrive?
6:24 Speaker 0 Yeah, so i i uh it's important to level set and realize that every single city on the planet was once a startup. Right?
6:32 Speaker 1 We have this phenomenon where people decided to create a city somewhere for some reason, and it might have been,
6:38 Speaker 0 you know, a hundred years
6:38 Speaker 1 ago,
6:39 Speaker 0 it might have been five thousand years ago. And so there are unique characteristics all over the globe about culture, uh about how the economy works, about how information flows, about what people care about, about the types of people that collect and grow uh over a period of time, independent of the uh academic institutions, the business institutions that get built in those those geographies, and all of that is then wrapped around by how people interact with other people in that geography. So the thing that comes from that that's so powerful is if you have uh founders or entrepreneurs who are leading the effort of trying to do things in their geography, again, over a long period of time, um learning and taking from other places, you get this self-referential phenomenon, and if you look at Silicon Valley, it's a great example of it.
7:30 Speaker 0 It's not a phenomenon that happened in the last 10 years, the last 20 years. I have a book on my desk uh that's uh that's called A hundred Years of Silicon Valley, and it was written in 1994. It's it's just a very, very long-term arc. And I think that you know what happens with a lot of people who want to create the next Silicon Valley in my geography, is they're taking a very narrow short-term view versus saying, what is it about the city we're in that's so special and why people are here, and what can we do over a long period of time to build on that?
8:04 Speaker 2 I think I agree with everything that's been said. I think that we often have two short-term view, and that also each region is distinctive and needs to identify its distinctive capabilities. I I do believe that different places have, just for historic reasons, have different skills and it's those skills, as well as their institutions and the social structure that can be built on. And so the first thing is to really think about what what your sort of advantage is. Um, for example, in Israel, they've been able to tap a lot of the military technology that has been funded for decades. Um, you know, in India um entrepreneurs have have been able to sort of bootstrap from low-end body shopping sort of software programming into larger scale software development.
8:51 Speaker 2 So it really is uh the opportunity for entrepreneurs to identify capabilities within a region and then build on them over time so that they um become more valuable uh not only locally but to an export market as well.
9:05 Speaker 3 How does history and timing play a role here? In the case the case of Iran is actually particularly interesting given the recent news about sanctions and the existing groundswell of entrepreneurial and tech activity that's already there.
9:18 Speaker 1 I think there's no question that the arc of time is something that people really do wrestle, and the idea that you can build these things overnight is as they point out a mistake. I think interestingly though, in a lot of these emerging markets, um time isn't also their friend. And what I mean by that is you've got a lot of countries in Iran is a perfect example of this, where 30 to 40% of the population uh is under 30 and doesn't have jobs, and so people are kind of looking at each other and saying, can technology help us to leapfrog? Can technology help us to light maybe some of our natural advantages so that we can not only do things within our markets or within our regions, uh, but possibly and and more controversially uh enter into uh markets more broadly. In the case of Iran. Of course, it's been so locked down because of the sanctions. There's been a two-edged sword to it for them.
10:04 Speaker 1 At one edge, uh they've been locked out of some of the best practices, except as I pointed out, even with the crackdown on um, you know, access to the internet, everyone I've met there of all ages have access to VPN. Uh every mobile phone I looked at had access to all the same things that we have access to. Uh they know a lot about what's been going on, so they've always been able to end run that I think at one level. Uh but the other edge of the sword has been that with other companies not being there, they've been compelled in force, and particularly the new generation to build a lot of interesting technology to effectively replace things. So for example, I saw uh startup Google, uh, you used to be able to uh get almost any app from the app stores from Google, and if you end-run it a little bit from iPhone, but it became very hard, and obviously you couldn't get anything that you would have to pay for because of the sanctions.
10:51 Speaker 1 So what happened, a bunch of startups came up to fill that gap and create apps so people could use them for a period of time. And so there was this interest in both creativity uh and and fire to make something happen, but at the same time it was out of necessity because the options were limited of what they can do. And the good news is they're now uh very talented, very capable, very tenacious, as good as almost any emerging growth market I've seen in early days. At the other hand, they're about to enter now a very, very competitive place, and I think it's gonna be interesting to see how that plays out.
11:22 Speaker 2 I do want to add that Iran has an incredibly highly educated population. Of course, it has been cut off in all sorts of ways. And there's also a huge, very successful at Ranian diaspora, which I suspect will uh I I I know in Silicon Valley they've been dying to contribute back. So Iran is very nicely positioned um in in some important structural ways uh to continue um contributing and to to build on this innovative and entrepreneurial um story that we're seeing already.
11:53 Speaker 3 I know what does the research show about um when I agree completely with Brad that starting with the question of trying to emulate Silicon Valley is exactly the wrong question. Yet whether people are emulating Silicon Valley or not, there is a tendency to sometimes start innovation by imitating and and as Christopher calls it improvising. What are what is your research show um about that?
12:15 Speaker 2 Innovation grows out of imitation and improvisation. So people learn by improvising, by trying things by first imitating and then improvising because often you can't you know you think you're building the same thing, but actually you're building something different that's adapted to local conditions, it takes advantage of local capabilities that don't exist elsewhere. So I think we need to be really aware that that innovation i you know builds on and and imitation. We have a uh sort of a sense often that you know it's it's stealing intellectual property, but uh every you know, every industrial region, every sort of innovative cluster that we've seen has started, you know, from imitation and improvisation.
12:55 Speaker 1 I I had the the the man who was the founder effectively of the Yahoo of the Middle East was a company called Maktube, which Yahoo in fact bought for 160 or 1707 million dollars about five years ago. And he said to me, you know, Chris, you just don't understand how these things stage. There's a lot of risk in startups under the best practices, but we're dealing with cultures often that have zero experience in this. There are plenty of money in a lot of emerging growth markets, but people are used to deploying into real estate, they're used to deploying them to something that's hard and a construct. The idea that 80, 60, whatever it is percent of your portfolio could go to zero is is just not yet part of the culture in many of these instances. So if all of a sudden, as he said, some kid five years ago would come home and tell his parents in uh Egypt that I'm dropping out of college because I've got this great idea for something I'm gonna call Facebook, and trust me, 650 million people are going to be on it and I'm gonna make billions of dollars, you know, his his friends would have laughed at him, his teachers would have laughed at him, his parents might have kicked him out of the house.
13:55 Speaker 1 But if all of a sudden you come home and say, You see this thing called Yahoo? Well, are there a lot of people speak Arabic? Yes. Are there people who'd like to have email? Yes. Are there a lot of people in fact might even want to sell things? Yes. And all of a sudden you say, Well, if that worked there, maybe a smaller version that can become a bigger version works there, and then you get the flywheel starting. Because what ended up happening in the case of Maktub is it is literally kicked out 25 other companies, one of which is soup.com, which is the largest e-commerce player in the Middle East, which just got valued at over a billion dollars. And I can assure you, out of that will be you know another 50 entrepreneurs who will come out and kick out money and the flywheel will continue. And so I just think that this improvisation stage is an absolutely natural early stage for that people will build upon.
14:42 Speaker 3 Can this all really happen at a bottom-up level though? Is there a role for top-down government in creating these innovation clusters, especially when it comes to things like rule of law?
14:51 Speaker 0 Yeah, I I I challenge the assumption that you you need top-down. I think I think that a lot of people approach the top-down as uh necessary, um, but it's it's effectively not sufficient. And so when you have top-down in the absence of uh bottom-up entrepreneur, you know, entrepreneur-led phenomena, grassroots, whatever phrase you want to use, nothing really happens. You get this this stagnation. If you have uh bottom-up phenomena where all of a sudden the startup community starts to develop and grow because you've got entrepreneurs and Christopher's last point, if they're successful, they reinvest uh back in in the community. Often, and especially you know, in different parts of the economic cycle, you have top-down focus, and you have government start to try to organize what's going on in the startup community, or you have academia or university in the city try to become the central point of what's going on.
15:53 Speaker 0 And that is not going to be a successful path.
15:56 Speaker 1 What is a
15:57 Speaker 0 successful path is when those institutions figure out how to attach to the chaotic network that's being built and participate in the network rather than try to control it. And that's that's where the conversation about top-down starts to get complicated because it's not that those organizations and institutions um don't have a role or shouldn't be involved or can't be involved. Quite the opposite. They're very beneficial. However, when they start trying to organize and control the activity or legislate the activity, uh it tends to generate a lot of second-order effects that are sifling, and in some cases, uh actually constrict the growth and development of what's going on in terms of the startup community.
16:41 Speaker 2 Yeah, I couldn't agree more with that. I think, you know, we have this model of government leading, and that just can't be the model. This has to be it um uh you could have a public sector or or uh other agencies um be I mean, at a minimum they should be permissive. I mean, I think we have a lot of places where you'll go and find governments that are are not even permissive that control flows of information or control capital markets in ways that don't work. But uh just because they get in the way doesn't mean that they can uh also be they need to be in conversation with entrepreneurs, with innovators about what will facilitate. Um what what are the you know I I I think that the ideal role for a public sector or even for a university or other institution in a region that's trying to be innovative is to talk to the people who are innovating and say, what's what are the obstacles and what can we do to help support you?
17:33 Speaker 2 You know, do you need more skill? Is there something that we can do to help generate more skill? Are there certain kinds of policy change that would help? These are all valuable things, but they cannot, they they can't be top down, they can't be they cannot have the sense that they will either plan in the traditional top-down sense or or lead this. They have to be contributors, um, really almost co-equals with the entrepreneurs and the innovators.
17:58 Speaker 0 That makes a lot of sense, actually, but I do think that
18:01 Speaker 3 I I don't want to assume that we're being naive about it, but I do think that there is a certain purity to how we view government sometimes. Because when I think about travels in third world countries, I mean it's I'm sorry, not the appropriate phase. Certain developing world countries. I think of corruption, bribery, you know, the fact that some governments can just seize your assets without um notice. And these are not things that are familiar to uh us because we for any complaints that we have about different governments, we are still used to living in a in a society that's actually very well run and organized. And I want to hear your guys' thoughts on how to deal with that when it comes to an entrepreneurial ecosystem.
18:37 Speaker 0 I'll I'll revel in my naivete. Um but but more importantly, I I actually don't think uh that uh, for example, an American democracy is a particularly well-organized or well-structured phenomenon. I think part of the reason it's so resilient is that it's not.
18:58 Speaker 1 And
18:58 Speaker 0 the the different the difference is we have a framework of rules, which by the way, have a very, very hard time keeping up with innovation. Um and and that framework of rules has been a way they're enforced. And that's the challenge. When you go into uh a country where there either isn't a framework of rules or there's not a way in which they're enforced consistently, then you have uh lots of erratic phenomena where you know the the thing you're trying to do uh can be you know stolen out from under you. I mean, I've been on the receiving end, for example, of uh, you know, deals that I I I did in the late 90s, you know, I'm thinking of one in particular with the Chinese company, where you know the merger agreement came back entirely in Chinese.
19:45 Speaker 0 Uh we really had no choice but to sign it, and you know, when it was translated, the signature, you know, the the document basically said you're giving us our the your company and we are giving you nothing, and you will be happy, right? And and At least they sent us the document. Right?
20:03 Speaker 2 So,
20:04 Speaker 0 you know, I I I just sort of start with that. I don't think that that it's it's structured correctly, that there is a framework that has some consistency. And the warning there, and we see it all the time. We see it with you know the phenomena of uh innovator versus incumbent, of course, Uber is is the one that everybody points at, but there's many, many companies that are struggling with this in lots of places in the US right now because the laws don't keep up with innovation.
20:29 Speaker 3 So let's talk a little bit more about that as applied to some of the cultural aspects beyond the institutions that happen sort of tacit implied, you know, for example, attitudes towards failure. You know, Christopher, you've talked about how um on one of the podcasts with some of the students in Iran who are building startups that you know the thought of doing a startup would be so taboo before. Um and now it's something that they're still not something that their families understand. And Brad, you talk a lot about the psychology of entrepreneurs and everything from depression to the mindset of how to deal with failure and the reality of the hard slog of building a company. How do those attitudes play out internationally? And I know does any of your research show um how that plays out? I'm curious to hear from all three of you about about this.
21:14 Speaker 2 You know, I wrote a book, my my husband and I joke that um I wrote a book that glorifies entrepreneurs when I wrote about Silicon Valley, and then I had to live with one. And you know, it it's being an entrepreneur is really hard. I mean, it's easy to glorify it in it, but the ups and downs, but you know, the unanticipated changes, nobody would in their right mind would do it, and yet, you know, we have just growing numbers of people who are doing it all the time, and and um very successfully as well.
21:41 Speaker 0 I think I think there's a uh uh a long arc on this, which is uh I've heard for many, many years uh when I when I talk about uh startups, how you have cultural norms and different, mostly country specific cultural norms around things like failure and you know how the the U.S. has this structural advantage because of uh our cultural norms. And then I end up in uh Iowa at Startup Iowa and you know, having pizza till you know midnight with 20 uh founders of different companies, and they start off sentences by saying things like in the Midwest we're more conservative. And I remember that that night so visibly because at some point I said, Well, you just get over it.
22:26 Speaker 0 Like it's not about being conservative. Like you're all here doing this crazy thing where you're starting companies, you're not being conservative. And oh, by the way, you know, uh three or four generations uh earlier, you're you know, five generations earlier, whoever whoever settled in Des Moines, those people were not conservative. Like they drove in wagons across that broke all the time across the United States and you know, had to deal with you know starvation and disease and you know uh uh you know, just the the chaos of trying to get to where they're going. That's not conservative. So, you know, let go of those things. And it's interesting because that construct then collides with something that Christopher said at the very beginning, which is so powerful, which is that the information about this is ubiquitous.
23:22 Speaker 0 You you can get information about the notion and philosophy uh of how to be successful, how to think about failure, not to revel in it, but to understand that it's part of the process.
23:34 Speaker 2 You know,
23:35 Speaker 0 some of my my own writings and others' writings on depression in the context of entrepreneurship have started to designatize the fact that leaders actually have emotions. And you know, that as human beings, you know, we're just big bags of chemicals. And it's not just that sometimes we have a lousy day, but sometimes we're in a place where you know, in terms of how we relate to what's going on around us, we might be functional, but it's really, really hard. That then is not geographically constrained because of lack of information flow. Uh you know, the the kids in Iran are reading that stuff. And they're there they might be able to relate to it directly, they might not, but it's at least permeating and influencing the way they think about what they're doing in the context of the next business they create.
24:26 Speaker 0 And uh I've seen this very powerfully uh through through some of the work uh that I've done uh through Techstars, which now owns uh Up Global, which runs Startup Weekend, uh, which is around the world, and it's amazing to encounter uh entrepreneurs from everywhere that have the same language. And an example would be I was in uh Rio at uh uh the Startup Weekend Global Summit a couple of years ago, and you know, a kid that looked like any other kid, I said kid in his 20s, looked like anybody else in their 20s, came up to me, handed me a startup Taran Tehran hat, and gave me a giant hug, and just in the middle of the room and said, Thank thank you so much for teaching us how to think about when things don't work.
25:12 Speaker 1 My son Jack, who's a teenager just came back from seven weeks in Taiwan working for a startup there, and so we went out for Chinese food and spent hours just getting caught up about what he saw, and I found myself pressing on, you know, because he's worked for startups in New York and others for A16Z, and you know, what's the difference? So, what was it like in Taiwan? How is it different? And he would come up with a couple of quick things, and at one point he just sort of looked off in the distance and he turned to me and said, Dad, I gotta tell you, the biggest surprise I had is how the same everything was. And I said, What do you mean? He said people they come at problems the same way, they're undaunted in the same way, they're constantly looking for the next new idea in the same way, uh, they support each other in the same way, they think about culture in very similar ways. Uh it really is a lingua franca now, I think of this era that also will not go back.
25:58 Speaker 3 That's great. So, one thing we haven't talked about is what happens when these local innovation clusters are exposed to global competition. For example, in the case of Iran. As sanctions lift, what happens when the eBay when the local eBay like competitor is exposed to the actual eBay? Or in India, when Amazon competes more directly with the like of Flipkart and other competitors. Is it really I mean, is local really an advantage when they're exposed to these companies that have this unprecedented scale and operational efficiency?
26:28 Speaker 2 One of the things we're seeing is that while Amazon may be able to go anywhere, it certainly they have the resources to hire the people. Often what you see, and you see this in China and other places is that the local imitators who get a first start actually innovate in directions that are more appropriate for the local
26:47 Speaker 0 constituency. Absolutely. So
26:49 Speaker 2 yeah, so that I do in China was it was a knockoff of Google, but it figured out what Chinese people want much more quickly, you know. So I I think again, you really um the local has an advantage. They understand their community and what the needs are, and they they markets really are not completely homogeneous globally at the moment.
27:08 Speaker 1 So I'm curious what you guys think about the distinction between what makes for that local advantage versus what in the end is uh uh really the the best software engineer wins, which obviously at least for the time being put some emphasis on to Silicon Valley. So take a place like India. I mean the LinkedIn of India is linked in. The Facebook of India is fundamentally face in, the Twitter or Facebook of India is fundamentally uh linked in. This is not true in e-commerce. In the Middle East, I can tell you that the American great social networks are dominant forces there, uh, but there's a reason why SUP.com is worth what it's worth. And so there is something about understanding the market, understanding unique payment issues. So, for example, in the Middle East, uh, credit cards is not a usual thing, so you have to navigate COD in very different ways.
27:54 Speaker 1 Logistic companies have gotten incredibly sophisticated on the ground there about how to even deliver products in great efficiency and that kind of thing. And I'm wondering if you guys just think about certain kind of general criteria by which you say there are things that at the end of the day, they'll move very, very quickly, and maybe they'll come from Silicon Valley, maybe someday they'll come from Beijing, maybe someday they'll come from Tehran. But once they take off, they tend to be easily dominant versus these enterprises or industries that naturally lend themselves to such local need and execution and assets that they'll you will constantly be seeing that type of innovation. I remember a friend of mine out in Silicon Valley who's talking to me about some of these emerging markets said to me something very interesting. He said, you know, you look at uh a couple of great ideas.
28:41 Speaker 1 So this is these are mobile first societies, these are folks who've never known landlines. We ought to be able to think that some interesting innovation will come from such places. And he said, but you've always got to ask yourself, you know, once that idea starts to move, is it going to be something that a Silicon Valley entrepreneur is going to take global faster than they can. And PESA was a very tactical specific uh need at a specific time that allowed it to become the largest payment mechanism in texting, specifically in Kenya and not around the world. And so I'm sort of curious how how you guys wrestle the idea of what makes for a global software for which perhaps even Silicon Valley will continue to have great advantage and what in local, you know, two or three things or whatever really stick out that gives that kind of advantage for these emerging markets.
29:26 Speaker 1 So Christopher,
29:27 Speaker 0 the the example that you gave uh uh lay uh uh right across how I tend to think about it, which is uh the more complex uh the I mean I I would say value chain. I was gonna say supply chain, but it's really value chain. Um, you know, you going back to you know Michael Porter's value chain framework. Um the more complex the value chain is between the end customer and the supplier uh of the product or the manufacturer. facture the product. And the more complex that is, the bigger the local advantage. And I think you can probably dissect it across, you know, I'm not being precise in my language when I say manufacture and I'm saying value chain. But I think you could you probably take, you know, even poor's framework and look at the different steps of it and say, is there a local advantage to this stage in you know whatever you're looking at?
30:21 Speaker 0 And if the answer is no, uh then, you know, that's that's going to have uh the the uh less defensibility against a global comment. And I think that's why e-commerce is such a good one. There's no getting the product like your example earlier of the best way to ship something from somebody in one country in the Middle East to another country in the Middle East is through New York. Okay that's not going to work for you know the model that Amazon's executing on the the last comment I make on this I can't remember who I can't remember Fadi was his first name. I was in Dubai and I met with uh uh Fadi and Fazel and Father Sun and they were describing soup to me they had a relationship to it through their investment um uh in in their company and they were describing the logistics and how the logistics dynamics of companies that were physical logistics companies they had such an insight into the way that goods and services move throughout the region that really nobody that was outside the region was going to have a chance uh of getting that implemented anytime soon and so in some ways it almost wasn't worth it to somebody else to try to do that um I don't think that the that that's you know limited to e-commerce I think it's limited to anything that has a lot of complexity in that value chain.
31:46 Speaker 2 The only thing I would add to that is that the example uh you gave us uh was India and and software and the the language differences do matter so a lot of our social media transports very easily to India because of the English language there where it's probably not as successful in Brazil but but uh I agree about the complexity of these supply chains being a key variable.
32:07 Speaker 3 Okay well given the topic that we're on about local and regional advantage I am curious about what you guys think about an argument that Mark makes and that he actually made in an op-ed in political last year about entrepreneurs and regions being able to use a sort of regulatory arbitrage to their advantage to help attract innovation and become leaders in like a particular technical area. So for example like with the UK embracing Bitcoin and being more thoughtful about FinTech is it you know as a way for them to be more likely to get an early advantage there or Canada moving um faster on drones regulation and and so on.
32:43 Speaker 1 Not only do I agree with him I think there's actually a physical manifestation also which is that this is the most mobile generation in history and when I say mobile in this case I don't mean uh phones or smart devices I mean they will move to where talent is and this in a way brings us back to the conversation of whether Silicon Valley or whatever I think one of the things that we didn't quite touch on about Silicon Valley here and it's odd to me that people often don't focus about it which is just simply the network effect of talent that's there that the more better the more the excellent people are there the more excellent people want to be there. And so what I'm finding for example and this is going to be very interesting to watch in the Middle East is that if you go to Dubai now as compared to three years ago I see Egyptians everywhere I see Lebanese everywhere I see Jordanians everywhere because as things have been a little bit rougher in other parts of the country and because in fact the environment has opened up the rule of law some of the top down stuff has opened up people are saying this is a place where I want to be and so not only will they be attracted by the opportunity to do things like Bitcoin or cryptocurrencies blockchain things but they'll also want to go to a place which simply they can succeed physically as entrepreneurs and I think that's a very interesting thesis to look at it as an arbitrage as you suggested
33:58 Speaker 2 the mobility is real. It's staggering I have a 22 year old who has lived both in China and India. I mean I grew up in a time when you know I lived in Hong Kong for two years and I never called home because it was so expensive. So we are mobile not just mobile devices but we move everywhere everything can move now.
34:18 Speaker 3 Okay well that's all we have time for I wish we could keep the conversation going but thank you very much Anno, Brad and Christopher really appreciate your time and thanks for joining the A6NZ podcast.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated