Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | How Hacks Happen (Let’s Just Say Mistakes Have Been Made) About this episode It seems like we hear about corporate (not to mention consumer) hacks in the news every week. Is this something new, or just a continuation of old patterns and we just happen to be hearing about it more now? In this segment of the a16z Podcast, longtime security investigative reporter Kim Zetter of Wired -- who also wrote Countdown to Zero Day, the definitive account of Stuxnet, the first digital virus that wrought physical destruction (on a nuclear facility) -- breaks down how hacks happen.
What's old (like phishing), what's new (like spear-phishing and ransomware)? How are players around the world -- whether for government or economic espionage -- becoming ever more sophisticated, coordinated, and organized? And what can companies do? Zetter shares her observations on how security models have changed -- for example, from defensive to offensive -- to how she susses out the truth when different players communicate about or claim hacks. (Which is one of the reasons that Zetter questions North Korea's role in the Sony hack...)
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 2 Welcome to the A16Z Podcast. I'm Michael Copeland and I am here with my partner in crime, Sonal Chuxi today. And we are lucky to have Kim Zetter, a senior staff writer at Wired who uh covers all things security. Kim, welcome.
0:15 Speaker 1 Thank you very much. So, Kim, you know, we wanted to actually talk to you about what's going on with RSA coming up with what's going on in the security world. And starting with like all these hacks that have been happening lately, is it is it me, is it like a lot more than what's been happening before, or are we just hearing about it more? I mean, I'm talking about big companies from Target to the Sony hack. I mean, there's there's just been so many, like you could probably list more of them than I can.
0:41 Speaker 0 Yeah, I mean, all of this has happened before. It's it's the what is happening here is the government's uh focus on cybersecurity, and by government I mean the Obama administration specifically, um has made cybersecurity uh one of its primary focuses. And that has then trickled down and caused everyone else to um focus on this more because that means money now is going into cybersecurity. So the business world is focusing on it as well. Um in terms of the number of hacks, um, you know, that's sort of um uh uh the result of the media obviously paying more attention and and the public paying more attention. But we've always had these kinds of hacks. Um even you know, the hacks against Target and Home Depot, we had a series of hacks back in 2008 and 2010 against TJX and Barnes and Noble and companies like that.
1:29 Speaker 0 Um so what what changes is um in some of these hacks is that we get a little smarter with security and so uh the hackers have to go back and retool their techniques, but they do come back again. They come back with new techniques and and new methods and new tools um just to uh achieve the same ends.
1:48 Speaker 1 Are there any common denominators to what made all the most recent hacks happen? Like were they all fishing through phishing, were they through the entry point through email? What was the common thread if there was one with all of them?
2:00 Speaker 0 Well, fishing phishing attacks is one of the primary ways that attackers get in. Oddly, it that didn't that wasn't the case with the target um hack. In that case, this was uh this was an interesting case study because this involved a third party company. Uh in this case it was a heating and air conditioning vendor. Um and they had um some kind of connection to Target's network for billing purposes. I don't quite understand the whole reason for that, um why there needs to be some kind of connection there between the two networks. But any time that there is connection, hackers are going to be smart and they are going to um route their way through um those networks and find the systems that they want. So in this case, they went through the access that this third party vendor had into Target's network and used that um as a pivoting point to then uh get themselves to the uh the um the card network uh where the um debit and credit card numbers were being uh processed.
2:55 Speaker 0 So that wasn't that was an interesting case. And that's uh something that I think we will see more of. We s we sort of see uh, you know, victims get hacked, obviously, and their systems are insecure, but uh growing problem um are the issues with third party vendors, contractors, other people that you work with that are going to become a conduit for hackers to get to you. So even though they might not come to you directly, um that is um a vulnerability that not only businesses have, but the government has with its contractors.
3:25 Speaker 2 I I have a question. Uh you know, you say that you don't think the frequency has gone up, but it is there more at stake. So you you describe how there's more third party vendors, for example, who have access to these systems, and systems get bigger and bigger and more complex and more interconnected. Um is there just more to go after and therefore there's more at stake, or is it uh uh have you not seen it change that dramatically?
3:50 Speaker 0 I think that um more obviously um you know, more and more stuff is getting put online. So uh let's take the health records, for example. Huge push from the government to uh digitalize all of our health records. Well, there were always problems in in some cases where you might have records uh um or systems,
4:10 Speaker 1 uh
4:10 Speaker 0 medical systems that were connected to the internet, but now we've just tripled and quadrupled that. And so uh that creates problems. More and more data, more and more systems are um becoming digitized, and then that creates new vulnerabilities and and different kinds of data for hackers to go after. And so that creates uh new opportunities.
4:28 Speaker 1 Right. So with like the recent hacks that have happened, what what else have they shared in common? So we describe phishing as one of the avenues, and you've said that the hackers have just gotten smarter. Um but like how does that happen? Like what I mean I don't mean to say that people are stupid, but why are they why are they not figuring this out?
4:45 Speaker 2 She was looking at me when she said out of Mini C or
4:48 Speaker 0 two. If I if I sent an email to you, you would open it, right?
4:53 Speaker 1 Yeah.
4:54 Speaker 0 I hope so.
4:55 Speaker 1 Yeah, I would, I would. Yeah. We're friends. So
4:57 Speaker 0 hackers have the ability to uh send you an email that in a way that it appears to come from me. Uh it can appear to come from your HR department or your manager um and they're not sending you know spam email about uh Viagra. They're sending they're gonna send you an email with an attachment that appears to be uh the new budget document that you are waiting for or an HR document about benefits.
5:21 Speaker 1 So walk us through the mechanics of that though. How can they actually do that? Like how do they know if they're not in the company to be able to figure that out? Like if they're not inside the company, like let's say okay, between you and me, there might be more points of failure. But if you're inside a company and you have shared language and you kind of know each other's lingo, if I get an email from Michael uh and he sends me a sudden random attachment, I would kind of know it's it's it's weird. Like how do hackers figure out
5:46 Speaker 0 there can be there can be multiple ways of of doing this. And and one is I mean, the most simple way, um, and most email um uh servers will catch this if you've got good filtering on it. The easiest way is to spoof any an email so that it it appears to come, and there are even websites that will spoof an email for you, so that it appears to come from uh one domain. Um if your system is set up to sort of uh you know scour through um the track that email has come through, it will know that it didn't um originate from the email that's purports to you. This happens in your Gmail account where you'll get a message and Gmail will tell you uh this doesn't appear to be coming from the who who appears to be sending it.
6:24 Speaker 1 Um
6:24 Speaker 0 so that's what they're doing in that case. Um so those are the those are the sort of the low low level uh phishing uh attacks. The more sophisticated ones uh can come from someone actually um hacking a system in your network um so that it appears to be coming from the same IP address, but also let's say they hack into Michael's computer and they take over his um address book and they start sending out emails actually through his account um in a way that he doesn't even see it.
6:53 Speaker 1 Right.
6:53 Speaker 0 Um so that's another that's another possible method. Um the phishing attacks though become sophisticated when they when we're um when they do what's called spear phishing. So phishing attack can be sort of um you know a canon effect like spam, where they just send out a lot of uh random emails and hope that someone will open it. Uh spear phishing is something that's they put a little more work into this and uh the Chinese hackers are very good at this. Um and they will and the Russian hackers. Um actually I just want to clarify they both of them are very good at this. Uh depends on who the players are, which how many typos will be in the in the phishing attack.
7:30 Speaker 1 Yeah, we want to hear more about that.
7:32 Speaker 0 What they will do is uh they can study you if you're if you're a really valuable target, if you're a system administrator, for instance, uh if they can get into your systems, they can get into everyone else's systems on your com on your company, for example. So what they might do is target assistant administrator and then we'll do some reconnaissance on him. They'll look at his LinkedIn profile, they'll look at his social networking, they'll see who he's communicating with and they'll see what he's communicating about. And then they'll send him email that is going to be um in particularly targeted to him. Let's say he just came back from a conference that he tweeted about, or he tweets about a presentation that he saw at a conference, and then suddenly he gets a follow-up email that appears to come from the speaker um of that presentation or something else.
8:18 Speaker 0 Um so those are ways that they really uh intensify the sophistication uh to guarantee um you know greater probability that you'll open it. But you don't actually need that much work. You know, you asked if um if people are stupid. Um and they're they're not. Um some cases they are. Um but you know, a report came out this week from uh Verizon uh examining how long it takes and someone to open a phishing email after it's landed in a company's network, and it takes on average about a minute and a half because someone in that company is going to open the email. And I'll and I'll I'll point you to uh something that happened a few years back. This was a security company, one of the top security companies, RSA that's having its conference next week. They got hit in a phishing attack in uh 2010, around the same time that Google got hit. And in that case, they sent only a handful of emails to some specific employees at the company.
9:06 Speaker 0 And the email filtering system actually caught it and sent it to the spam folder. But one of these employees um went through his spam folder and saw the email, thought it was interesting, pulled it back out into his inbox and opened it. Oh my gosh. And that's how the attackers got in.
9:21 Speaker 2 So uh is the kind of upshot of that story just never ever bothered checking your spam filter? Because I do that
9:28 Speaker 0 once every
9:28 Speaker 2 six months like, oh,
9:30 Speaker 0 maybe something.
9:30 Speaker 1 I actually get useful newsletters and shopping emails and things like that. That's what you
9:34 Speaker 2 think so. You you mentioned they, and you talked about the Chinese and the Russians and and in these more sophisticated attacks. Who are they? And what do they look like and and really how sophisticated are they?
9:47 Speaker 1 And and also like Kim and exactly, and also what are they the different players now? Because I feel like this more organized approach seems to be something new and different. Like they seem to be getting ever more sophisticated.
10:00 Speaker 0 They are getting more organized. So, you know, in in the early days, what you were getting were random hackers on the internet. Sometimes they would uh gather in gangs um to do identity theft and and get passwords and go after credit cards and things like that. And there was some organization then. Um but what we really saw the change in was in the uh late 90s, actually sorry, um the mid-2000s where we started to see the cyber espionage uh emerge. And that's where we're seeing nation state attacks like nation like China
10:31 Speaker 1 and
10:31 Speaker 0 Russia.
10:32 Speaker 1 So
10:32 Speaker 0 cyber espionage then uh became uh uh you know a trade tool for you know traditional economic espionage has been supplanted in in some cases. So um now nation states uh like China, China has been accused of this of hacking into companies networks to steal trade secrets and give Chinese companies a competitive advantage. Um that's in addition to already the national security stuff that they're stealing uh, you know, for military weapons and things like that. Those range in sophistication. I mean the Chinese don't necessarily try to hide their their um tactics because they are supported by their government, so they don't really have anything to worry about there. Um in the case of the Russians, uh really really sophisticated uh hackers are in East Europe and why is that by the way?
11:18 Speaker 1 Is it just that they're really code literate and I don't mind? I
11:21 Speaker 0 think the I think the technical training is really superb there. I think that um uh you know, because of the economic conditions, a lot of people have uh uh, you know, uh who weren't able to get a job uh during certain periods after the fall of the Soviet Union um looked to develop these kinds of skills uh you know in the hacking underground. Um and so it really paid off for them. And it is very lucrative. And again, there's a the issue of um being untouchable in Russia. It's uh it's hard to go after Russians, uh little cooperation with the the government, and so uh US authorities have to wait for someone to leave Russia and go, you know, on vacation to Thailand or someplace and have been there. So they're pretty protected there. And in some cases they uh may be supported by the Russian government as well.
12:10 Speaker 0 But uh they're very sophisticated. They're also doing national security stuff, but they're also doing um, you know, economic espionage to sell it. So
12:19 Speaker 1 economic espionage is based as just to so you're saying to sell the product that they're hacking or to extract rents? Because I've been hearing stories about ransomware coming from Russia as well.
12:27 Speaker 0 Yeah, so that's that's a different kind. That that would be more on the criminal ground rather than the espionage ground. But yeah, so it is another interesting uh thing that's growing right now, and that's that started out very not sophisticated. Uh hackers would put malware on your system that could um then it basically encrypts your whole hard drive. And then they send you a message saying give us uh you know this amount of money in order for us to let um let you have access back to your data. And um started out very unsophisticated, they become more sophisticated, they got smarter about their encryption, it's harder to to get around the encryption now. Um and also um, you know, we're seeing different kind of ransom uh such as the case of Sony, where um they did ask for money or they appear to be asking for money in Sony's case, but they weren't looking at um preventing Sony from accessing its data.
13:19 Speaker 0 There the threat was if you don't
13:21 Speaker 1 uh
13:21 Speaker 0 comply with our demands, we'll release the data. And I think that's what we're going to see more uh more of. I think that's uh a new trend that we're going to get.
13:29 Speaker 2 And so you question um in in the case of the Sony hack whether it was North Korea or do we still not have a clear picture on who it might have been.
13:37 Speaker 0 Well, the government is clear. The government has been very adamant that North Korea is behind it and that they claim they have evidence of it, and they implied, although they don't tell us directly, that they know because uh of some kinds of perhaps signals intelligence that the NSA has collected. But they don't say that. Right. Um so we're left to sort of connect dots that we're not sure can be connected. Um my issue with the the attribution is um attribution is always difficult no matter whether it's uh the Sony hack, a really loud hack like that or a quiet hack, um, whether it's a sophisticated hack or an unskilled hack. Um the the way we get hackers, the way we prosecute hackers are usually because they've done something stupid
14:18 Speaker 2 and they've
14:19 Speaker 0 exposed themselves. They've used their real t IP address instead of going through a proxy, or they've bragged about their activity to someone who's an undercover fed online, something like that. Um, attribution in nation state obviously is going to be uh a lot more difficult because they have a lot more resources and skills. So the idea that the government would say definitively this is North Korea already is a little shaky. Um and what they've provided as evidence is an IP address that they say is which they haven't even disclosed the IP address. All they've said is that an IP address was used that um to conduct the Sony hack that North Korea is known to have used, or North Koreans are known to have used. And that's a pretty vague statement because they're not actually saying this is an IP address assigned to North Korea, this is an IP address that North Korea used to hack Sony.
15:10 Speaker 0 They said this is an IP address that North Korea is known to have used, to have used in the past,
15:16 Speaker 1 meaning.
15:16 Speaker 0 Um so that's that's pretty flimsy. And also just if you can trace i if you can trace activity back to an IP address,
15:23 Speaker 1 um,
15:24 Speaker 0 and that's difficult in itself to find the the real originating IP address. You also have to know um whether or not that machine was hacked as well. So just because we traced an attack to your machine, Michael, doesn't mean that you were the one sitting at that computer conducting the attack.
15:40 Speaker 2 Hypothetically, let's be clear about that.
15:42 Speaker 0 Hypothetically hypothetically, uh someone else could have subverted your machine, hijacked it and be conducting an attack through it.
15:49 Speaker 1 Right. So
15:50 Speaker 0 that's another problem with IP addresses. And until the government can provide, you know, some more extensive proof, um, it raises questions. And why does it raise questions? Um because if you look at the communication from the attackers to Sony, the first communication was about extortion. And it wasn't about the um the movie uh that everyone in the end thought it was about. Uh they appeared to be asking in the first communication for payment and they were demanding payment uh and if they didn't get it, they would release emails and other documents from Sony. And subsequently they did start releasing that. But it was only after um media reports started servicing, quoting anonymous government officials about the Sony movie that um everyone then jumped on this band link and and said this was about the movie.
16:37 Speaker 0 But the hackers themselves never mentioned the movie. And by the way, the hackers, you know, they made that threat, that supposed threat, what we would have termed a terrorism threat, that if the movie came out on Christmas Day, they somehow kind of implied that there might be some harm at movie theaters. Um but the and and they also um made some threats that if Sony released the movie, they would release more of Sony's data. But the movie came out and we never heard from the hackers again. No more data.
17:07 Speaker 1 So
17:08 Speaker 0 uh it's also interesting to me that the data that they released um a lot of it pertained to Sony's efforts uh against piracy. And that's um that's an issue that um I can't really see North Korea being all that concerned about. But it is an issue that the hacking community, the underground community of anonymous and groups like that have had an um you know uh a gripe with Sony for years over over the antipiracy efforts. And so it makes much more sense given if you look at the communication from the hackers, if you look at the data that they released, and if you look at the fact that they never bought the movie up, um it really comes across as uh sort of a traditional kind of hack that we've seen before against Sony. So the only difference here is that they took it to another level in destroying data and releasing data, and they used um some of them some malware that have been used in attacks against South Korea.
18:05 Speaker 0 So those are the only things that give every that gave everyone pause. Right. Um
18:11 Speaker 1 actually touching on another interesting theme that I think we should talk about for a brief moment, which is how people are communicating about the hacks. I mean you're interestingly on the other side of this, which is your job is to kind of investigate the communication trails and source from different sources and talk to different, you know, get different facts to put together like what's actually happening, but there is this problem that companies face, which is they're in a world where they actually don't know how to communicate about these things because they're facing them for the first time. Like what are you kind of observing from that perspective?
18:39 Speaker 0 Companies have been forced to be a little more transparent. I mean, so we see you know, Target obviously wasn't uh going to willingly uh disclose the hack. What they what they do in in the case of credit cards, it became it can become a little more obvious because um they're required under breach laws uh to disclose to customers when certain kinds of data uh gets released. So that's some often the way we we first learn about a breach. But the company isn't going to necessarily announce it, or at least they haven't in years past. Now we're actually seeing uh blog posts, things like that where they are coming out and formally announcing the hack and sometimes even before they they notify the customers. Um so that's a a growing trend and and I think that companies are realizing that they have to get out in front of it. Um they don't want it someone else to expose it before they can.
19:26 Speaker 0 Um and also um we see you know the push now from the government for more information sharing from companies.
19:32 Speaker 2 Do you do you get a sense though that in in terms of that disclosure that that it's only like disclosure happens when it kind of gets out there already? Or you know, if if nobody knows that this hack occurred, do we still sort of keep it quiet?
19:46 Speaker 0 Well that's what they would love. I mean, that's been traditionally what what's occurred is that we we never learned about hacks until um either the data started leaking online or um you know credit card numbers were stolen and they were used for fraudulent purposes. So I think that companies also are becoming maybe less um hesitant about discussing because they see that everyone is getting hacked. So you're no longer that individual standing out there alone who's going to get a finger pointed at you for your bad security. Now we know that uh you know pretty much um every level of security it can be subverted by a really uh determined attacker. So I think that there's a little less shame in getting hacked maybe in Sony's case.
20:34 Speaker 0 Maybe not so
20:35 Speaker 1 that's also because of what actually came out but right exactly. So actually Kim one interesting theme here we've been talking on the background here about like what's really changed in the security landscape and you've been saying that a lot of these things have been around for years. But at the same time the players have gotten ever more sophisticated and the hacks have gotten much more complicated. But one thing that's kind of interesting that you and I used to talk about Wired is this trend that sometimes companies are actually it's completely turning around the paradigm where before the model for security would you just defend to protect. So are we seeing people go on the offensive basically
21:09 Speaker 0 so we we are to s to within limits. You know there were there was a lot of talk uh a couple of years ago uh uh a company called CrowdStrike actually when they launched they had uh made this announcement that they were going to be talking about um you know act what they called active defense which was attacking back to a certain extent and then I think they realized that um some of the stuff that they might be advocating was illegal. And there are companies that I think are just now learning that some of the things they're doing
21:38 Speaker 2 could
21:38 Speaker 0 get them into hot water. So um so there are some things in limitation. I mean one of the things that you can do is uh you know you could you can sort of trace back um the the source of the attack and find the IP address and things like that. But you cannot start routing around in the computer at the other end um because that's unauthorized access. You can't pull your back um there's a question about whether or not you could actually pull back your data or delete your data on that server. And I think that that would also be a violation of the computer fraud and abuse act because it would because you don't know if it's performing an unauthorized um action on a computer and you don't know what the consequences of deleting something on a computer might be. And also I want to point out that you know as I said hackers um route their way through other computers to conduct their attacks.
22:30 Speaker 0 So they could be on your computer and if uh your computer is used to attack me and I go into your computer to erase data you weren't the um you weren't the perpetrator and and I could cause damage to your system not to the an original attacker system. So there are a lot of legal and ethical issues around this but one way that um companies are sort of um I guess not attacking back but uh responding in a more active way certainly not defensive is going through the courts um and getting systems taken offline and so we've seen this a couple of times with Microsoft where they've gone to uh they filed a civil action courts in order to get um certain IP addresses or hosting companies uh taken down in order to control um botnets and other malicious activities that's sort of uh congregating in certain IP addresses
23:18 Speaker 1 but what can companies do because the fact is that like you know ten years ago or even as recently as five years ago the security model was to defend and protect like the MacAffee antivirus firewall you know sort of thing but we're talking about very different types of hacks these days that are going through your in various systems internally like we talked about the intimacy of coming from your colleague or your next door neighbor. So what can companies do then to sort of better arm themselves. I mean it seems like this is a whole brave new world of security
23:48 Speaker 0 is uh less from keeping attackers out I mean you know you still need to do that you need to do everything you can to keep them out. But I think that um companies are becoming more realistic and realizing that they need to put a lot more resources into discovering intruders that may already be in the system. And so that means um improving their monitoring and logging capabilities and making sure that e when they have monitoring and logging capabilities that they're actually reading those logs. And they have them configured in such a way that um they can actually distinguish um between something that is concerning and something it's not. But that's a problem as well. Target discovered that Target installed a multimillion dollar security system uh not long before it got hacked and that system was designed to detect anomalous behavior in the network and it did.
24:38 Speaker 0 It sent alerts it sent alerts to um some people who were who were paid to monitor target's networks I forget what they were I think in maybe India or Singapore and they um forwarded those alerts to the system administrators in the US and those administrators ignored them. And they ignored them because you can have a system like that and get so many alerts um that you ha you get this battle fatigue from them and you stop looking or you don't have enough resources to look at everything.
25:07 Speaker 1 Well it also raises the fact that it at the end of the day the whole model of security always comes down to the human error aspect as well at some point.
25:15 Speaker 2 Yeah and speaking of human error you know flip it to to the consumer are you noticing or is there hope for us to to do a better job or there behaviors we can embark upon finally you know two factor authentication for everything. I mean is there anything on the horizon there that seems to help
25:32 Speaker 0 yes I think I think the move towards two factor authentication um obviously was long overdue and I guess we have to think we have Edward Snowden to thank for that. And encryption but if an attacker is already on your system uh encryption won't necessarily help you um because they're going to see your data before it gets encrypted. If you're um you know changing passwords, uh strong passwords, things like that, you know, we're we s we see a movement toward people demanding that passwords be eliminated and that we come up with new systems or biometric systems, things like that. I mean there obviously are a lot of uh people trying to look at this issue now and figure out new ways. But I mean for the consumer now you know two factor authentication for any site that offers it um that's the way to go.
26:19 Speaker 2 Kim you talked to us about what we can do in two factor authentication sounds like a path that we all need to go down quickly. And even
26:27 Speaker 1 three factor authentication if you think about adding the biometric component.
26:30 Speaker 2 Yeah and but are there so what are some other things that you know maybe companies should think about and and also do do you have a any sense of like kind of who's winning or is that not even a question that can be asked.
26:42 Speaker 0 But hackers are winning. Okay. Well that's a sad
26:45 Speaker 1 reality right so that's exactly the world we're in. Do you have advice then Kim for companies that are and bit and consumers that are in this world like what do we do then? I mean if you put your data on the cloud which it could be a lot more secure because you have a you know people a lot more administrators who are dedicated to watching that. What would
27:00 Speaker 0 I don't do my I don't do online banking. Okay. So um I don't have a lot of trust in um in those kinds of systems. I don't have a lot of uh I I do very little I don't put my health records online that kind of thing. So I keep it as as you know as much to the minimum as I can. And I know that um people don't like that because they like uh efficiency and they like convenience but they have to understand that there is that trade-off and you are making a security trade off every time you do that. So
27:30 Speaker 1 if you do make that trade-off then what would your parting words of advice be for people like to be able to audit like the companies they're working with whether they're a person or a company.
27:39 Speaker 0 I don't know that the average person can do that because the average person isn't going to know even if if um you know if you want to put your data in the cloud um do you know uh you know how adequate that audit was um so it's you know it's kind of this circular problem but I think minimally um if you are a company that's considering putting you know using a cloud company um cloud storage that there are some things that you can do you can you can see you can find out if the company has been independently audited and that the security is um to a uh a level that you're feeling comfortable with and another thing that you might do is seed some of your data so that if it's stolen seeding is sort of planting uh little flags like a water margin sort of water margin
28:23 Speaker 2 yeah
28:24 Speaker 0 yeah so that if the data is stolen you can see uh that that it the source of and then you can come back to the cloud company and you know you may be able to tell them hey you've been hacked um but that's some way one way that you're not just completely ceding your control to someone else then.
28:41 Speaker 2 That's great. Well Kim on that somewhat somber note I promise if you get an email from me with an attachment don't open it. Don't
28:49 Speaker 1 actually open any email from him in general. Yeah don't I thank you so much.
28:53 Speaker 2 Scared me to death thanks a lot. Okay.
28:56 Speaker 1 Bye
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated