Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Engineering a Revolution at Work About this episode From file cabinets to typewriters, spreadsheets and word processing the tools we use for work change not only what we do, but the culture of our workplace. Steven Sinofsky, a veteran of building software tools for productivity, discusses the latest revolution in technology-enabled tools with Benedict Evans. Why today’s cloud-based tools change the role of managers, and why the perfect tool will never exist (nor would you want it to).
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 1 Hello, welcome to the A16Z podcast or A16Z if we want to localize this. I'm Benedict Evans. I'm here today talking with Steven Sinowski, one of my new colleagues at Andrews and Howitz. Stephen, hello. Hi there. How's it going? Pretty good. So you've been a long time working on productivity and working out ways that people were going to work and ways that that would change and how that could be taken forward over time. And you wrote a really interesting blog post a day or two ago, looking at how devices and cloud and SaaS kind of bring a sort of generational change into how those kind of tools work. Can you talk a bit about your blog post and how you think about that? Sure.
0:45 Speaker 0 Well, you know, for me, it it really just it all starts back when I started in computing. You know, when I started in computing, I was uh, you know, helping to computerize, that was the word we used back then, my father's own own business. And uh I've seen a lot of productivity stuff over over the years. My first uh actual paying job um in the was uh a summer at a very large large defense contractor. It was the 80s, the cold war, defense contractor jobs where we all we all went and did in the computer world. And you know, I showed up that that first day of work, and you know, they used this email system that we don't think of as email, but it was called profs, and it was IBM mainframe-based email. So those of you that dates you and you knew about Oliver North and the whole Iran Contra scandal, that was how they communicated was with this prof's email.
1:33 Speaker 0 And the way that that managers used email was um they would get mail, but they would have somebody in an assistant print it out, and then they would dictate the reply, and then they would type the reply in and send it. And so it wasn't visible at all that it was happening electronically to management. And next to every administrative person's desk was a selectric typewriter, and the telex was the way that you quickly transmitted information. And and literally that was when I started at Microsoft, that's what the average workplace looked like outside of Microsoft, where we actually used command line uh Xenx-based email as a huge productivity tool. And it was right when people were starting to put office into desktops or or office-like software. In fact, it was mostly DOS and uh things like that. And those tools were used essentially to automate that style of work.
2:21 Speaker 0 And so even like business writing memos and spreadsheets themselves were sort of done in this analog fashion where somebody would have ideas and then give them to another person to execute with some computers and then print them out and distribute them. And what happened through the the years that I ended up was lucky enough to work on productivity software was that whole process became democratized. And everybody participated. I mean, I remember, you know, that when we finally started seeing companies where people in executive and senior management would do their own email. You know, it was this huge turns out that was a huge productivity win because there wasn't these human routers in the middle, you know, basically printing and handing, and those days of showing up in an office with a stack of printouts that were just mail messages ended.
3:09 Speaker 0 And so now we've got this, we got to this world where these tools were democratized. And it it creates it didn't just um make things more efficient, it also defined a work culture. And so the whole idea of getting slides ready for a meeting. You know, the bigger the meeting or the more important the executives were in a meeting, the more time you spent up front preparing and sort of debugging those slides. And the tools got created to support that process. Like sort of a fascinating thing where like if aligning every item on the slide by a pixel perfect thing was a big deal, then all of a sudden features would get created and UI would get surfaced, and that would become part of the task. And we optimized that dramatically. We created new modules of software. We went and built an enterprise scale server so that documents could be shared in the server.
3:56 Speaker 0 And that sort of gets us to where almost everybody is today. Um it's a fascinating place, except for this generational change that's happening right now, where all of a sudden everybody's showing up to the meeting with a phone and a and or a tablet. You know, maybe in addition to their laptop, but those phones and tablets are changing the whole flow of what's going on.
4:18 Speaker 1 Yeah, I think that's right. I mean, my I mean, my say my first experience of business computing communications was scribbling on the back of telex stack, track of paper stacks that my father brought home from his general electric company um plant that making very big pieces of electrical equipment um in the UK. And then I arrived in the workplace in 98 or 99. So that was the heyday of Office and Windows NT4. And my amazing transformative SaaS product was Bloomberg, which is still like the biggest SaaS and social network and um information visualization platform that nobody in the valley has ever seen, which is kind of a fascinating other conversation. The only people who can disrupt Bloomberg are people who've never seen it and have no idea what you use it for. But then there's a kind of, as you say, it's like I think to my time working in big companies, the kind of the PowerPoint Excel paradigm, so much of what's done with it is not what anybody in Excel would have in is not what Dan, the guy who created um Dan Burkle, which um would have thought you do with it.
5:20 Speaker 1 You see Excel used as a desktop publishing program. You see, you see it used as a substitute for an SQL database. You see um PowerPoint used as an internal business reporting tool. Um note-taking tool or note taking tools. Teaching tool, you know, exactly exactly. And so you see these products being bent, which is kind of a tribute to their flexibility, but it also then points to opportunities. I'm coming at what you say from the other end, opportunities to create new kind of products that peel away some of those use cases. So it seems to me that you know, on the one hand, you have a lot of uses, particularly of Excel that should be a SaaS. Or you've used you know the you know, my friends at NBC Universal or Orange or whatever, who you know, part of your weekly or monthly routine is you spend a day making a 15-slide PowerPoint full of business metrics.
6:09 Speaker 1 You think that that kind of shouldn't be what you're using XL and PowerPoint for.
6:14 Speaker 0 Well, it's a fascinating thing. You know, like I mean, the of course the flexibility of the tools was was, you know, the people just that designed them did amazing, amazing work. And I don't take no credit for having designed the the tools. And and it is amazing. I mean, you see Excel and it's used uh one of these eye-opening experiences I had was to find out at one point in the in the 90s that Excel was the preferred word processor in Japan. Because the documents in Japan are all highly structured with grids. If you ever checked into a hotel or bought a ticket or something in Japan, you see the grid. And it turns out that's just the way they prefer to have documents in that market. And as we tried to break into that market with word processing, we found out that Excel was the word processor. And so all of
6:58 Speaker 1 a sudden the word processor has to pick up all of those features. Now I knew people, a whole banking team I worked with did all their presentations in Word. Yeah. Which is exactly the same kind of thing. It's like using it. Well, we're, you know, word is But they're doing slides in Wood rather than the A. Well, of course.
7:12 Speaker 0 It's interesting that bankers would do that, but because generally, you know, a word processor is really just a spreadsheet with one cell. Yeah. And so it's that's a joke. You're there's laughter that you're hearing. We'll put the we'll put that
7:22 Speaker 1 we'll add that in our own. Yeah, we'll put that in. I was just thinking that's an interesting point.
7:25 Speaker 0 Yeah. Um but what's what's also fascinating is a lot of where each of these modules in productivity software, part of the reason that they're they do all of these things. You know, there's you can make a table in every module of every productivity tool. Tools that Microsoft makes, tools that other companies make. And part of that reason is because those tools were all created in an era where actually getting the software into somebody's computer or onto somebody's computer was a challenge. And so it was no surprise, for example, that when the original versions of WordPerfect evolved to sort of build in document management into WordPerfect. Not just because it's like a lot of people who use WordPress, we're also using document management and law firms and government and regulatory environments. But because if you had to go through the trouble of getting WordPerfect onto the computer in a world without networks or slow networks, you might as well just put everything that they might want into it.
8:19 Speaker 0 And so this is sort of this bundling that happened. Originally, interestingly enough, word processors were sold separate from spell checkers and grammar checkers and drawing programs. You uh the old Word star product line, one of the original DOS word processors, there was Spell Star and Correct Star and all of these other modules. And then but the distribution of those became so tricky, they gradually, in the competitive dynamic, gradually caused those to join together. And and then once you were going through the trouble of getting something onto a PC, you really wanted it to have everything. But today's model where everything is sort of a click away, even apps, which everybody can talk about the headaches of getting all the different apps and stuff, but the friction is very, very low. And your ability to put it on the machine, to get it off the machine is very, very easy, not just because of the store, but because things in the modern mobile architectures, like there's no registry to worry about, there's no side effects of one app messing up another app, and all of those things make it so that the try then buy or just the use the front end to the thing you purchase are way easier, which allows the productivity experience itself to sort of be unbundled in a in a way that makes a little bit more sense.
9:29 Speaker 0 So the Excel scenarios, you see lots of word processors, you see lots of tools for making tables, you see lots of tools for interacting with like checklists and to-do lists, or tools that are very rich semantic level, like like organizing events or organizing people or great tools like Asana that are about task lists where you you now can have these specialized tools and they just work for the task at hand a lot better. Yeah,
9:52 Speaker 1 I mean, this is the thing we were chatting about the other day that if you go to file new in any productivity program, you basically see a list of ideas through iPhone apps. You know, it's like the sports tracker, the you know, the homework results thing, you know, the home budget, those are all apps now. Um I mean there's a there's a the thing you would uh again thinking about the bundling isn't one of the dynamics around that that historic bundling that um basically the output was supposed to be a stack of pieces of paper very often. And so you want a stack of pieces of paper with charts and diagrams and pictures and text, and therefore it kind of made sense that you could do well, you could do word inside of you could do text inside a table, or you could do a table inside text, depending on what the kind of the emphasis was going to be. Whereas now, you know, when you look at all of these sort of SaaS products, they're not ever actually intended to be printed out anymore.
10:39 Speaker 0 Well, in fact, that's one of the the most fascinating things about just visiting all of the startups that I spend time with down here is that printer. There are no printers. Like you like, it's far more important to purchase a coffee machine as a startup than it would be to buy a printer. And in printers, just literally you you can't find them. Like, in fact, I tried to print out some notes for this meeting, and our printers, there's like two of them, and they're not even in very convenient places, and and it's because it's just not the metaphor. If you think about the average large kind of company meeting, even today, the vast majority of meetings are start off with somebody showing up and passing out like a printed version of a work product. You you just don't see that in a company of less than you know a thousand people. Like that's just not a metaphor that people really use.
11:26 Speaker 0 And it's not even the interesting thing about it is it's not just that everybody got emailed the attachment for the meeting. It's that people are looking at things like live data. So when you visit a smaller company and they're looking at their current telemetry for their app, their site, their service, they're they're all looking at the actual tools that are used by the marketing team to manage the information or the IT team to manage the information. They're not looking at like a snapshot from even a few hours earlier. So you don't have you you cut out all of this process called, well, those numbers aren't up to date, let me go do them. You don't have those presentations where a picture of the numbers are embedded in the presentation and they're pivoted the wrong way. Like if you want to sort the numbers by a different way, don't don't like have one person do it on their laptop and then say, okay, let me plug my machine in.
12:14 Speaker 0 Yeah
12:15 Speaker 1 just like that always became an action item. It's like what are those numbers right down? Right. And you come out of a meeting where you've got 10 action items for people asking for more numbers, and whereas now it's just well, you press the button and there they are. Right.
12:27 Speaker 0 And I
12:27 Speaker 1 think these are the things to me that are
12:29 Speaker 0 just these huge cultural shifts in how in how you manage an organization. Like what your role as a manager is in a meeting is no longer to be reported to, because frankly, if you want to know, you should just go visit the place that everybody on the team is already using to keep track of their information. And when you get everybody together, it shouldn't be to argue the pros and cons of how the information was gathered, or is it the right number? Is it the number pivoted the right way? It should be we all agree this is the number. Is it good or bad? And what should we do as an organization to change that number? Trevor Burrus, Jr.
13:01 Speaker 1 And to your point, all the stuff about aligning pixels and so on just goes. Except for you know, when you're doing an external things. I mean, there's a there's a point here about devices, I think, because there's a you know, whenever I talk about you know mobile as the future in a sort of generic sense, or generally I pay, I'll post a chart showing sales of smartphones versus sales of PCs when it's full-based smartphones versus little basic PCs. And people come always push back and say, Well, I'd like to see you do that blog post on a tablet, or I'd like to see you produce all of those charts on a tablet. And I think there's kind of two parts to this. One of them is it's a bit like saying, well, you can't get real work. People say you can't get real work done on mobile devices. It's like saying you can't get real work done on a laptop, you need a desktop because you need the biggest screen. And you know, there was a point 20 years ago when that was true, and that line is kind of moved steadily of the stuff that you actually needed a desktop for was shrunk and shrunk and shrunk and shrunk, and now it's really only like hardcore video editing or something you need an enormous screen for.
13:59 Speaker 1 And I think tablets in particular, and to some extent smartphones again, sort of sit in that continuum. Like, what is it that you're actually trying to do? How many of the things that you're doing need a keyboard and a mouse and a vast screen? But that then just to finish the point, that then flows into this question, the analogy I gave earlier of the of the the somebody doing a weekly PowerPoint reporting document. You know, if your job is if you are a BD person or salesperson and once a week you have to send your head of sales a 15 page deck outlining what's going on, then you need a keyboard and a mouse and a big screen. But you don't actually need a keyboard and a mouse and a big screen to be a BD person. Well and so if that's all in those for so in a SaaS or in something else, then that whole um workflow drops out, right? Therefore, the device you need drops out.
14:41 Speaker 0 Well, absolutely I mean that's sort of the key. Like if you're the sales manager, you should just be looking at Salesforce all the time and or whatever tool you're using that that allows you to just see what's really going on in real time. And the process should not be a weekly summary of the past. I mean, that's just a it's not an efficient way to run an organization when the up to the minute information is available, because your salesperson, as they you know, are waiting for for the flight, the car, the plane, or just walking home from the account, they're they're updating it on their mobile device, what everybody, the view of everybody uh they're seeing. But I would I I'm I'm a little hesitant to go down the path of like um how do you do X in Y? Like how do you do this thing on a tablet? How do you do that thing on a phone? How would you ever do that thing on a on a notebook?
15:28 Speaker 0 I mean, how would that salesperson walking down the street fill out the up-to-date information in Salesforce using a browser and a notebook? They they can't. But the logical end of being careful about that is everybody's gonna have five devices, which is also not gonna happen. And so what what or even if you just say, no, it's only gonna be a tablet and a laptop, or it's only gonna be a phone and a laptop because I don't need a tablet, except you kind of do want a bigger screen sometimes, because if you have a bigger screen, more and more tools can take over the productivity work. And and really there's gonna be this whole continuum, but at some point, like uh whatever it is you define as work is also changing. And I think that's the part whenever I get in and on Twitter and and comments on on other people's posts, you get in this this thing where people say I can't do X in on a tablet or on a phone.
16:16 Speaker 0 And the answer to the And there's the
16:18 Speaker 1 answer is X doesn't is your job to do X, or is X just a tool you're doing for some underlying challenge. And but in some cases, yes it is. If you know if you're coding in Eclipse, you kind of want a keyboard and a big deal. Well,
16:29 Speaker 0 and
16:29 Speaker 1 and but most people's job is not actually to produce spreadsheets or to produce presentations, right? It's something else of which it's something else of which the thing that they think they need a keyboard or that they're using a keyboard or mouse for is actually a tool to get them there.
16:45 Speaker 0 I mean, certainly long ago, like you know, I I witnessed salespeople who basically routinely would only do things that they could accomplish on their smartphones, their early generation smartphones. And what you what I watched happen was you know, field-engaged people gradually just stop responding to email and starting to either text or call because they just were no longer able to. They there wasn't ubiquitous wireless WAN for a laptop. And their laptops, they weren't carrying them to meetings. It became a burden. Now, if they had to do demos or they had to do presentations, they were carrying their laptops. And guess what? Those things now are enabled by tablets, whether it's Surface or an iPad or uh uh Android tablet, all of those, the form factor has allowed a different level of of computing. And and at the same time, like what's just so exciting is it this is it is like a revolution almost in every sense because the manager sitting back at the office who has defined that work process is sometimes the least likely to be the person calling for change.
17:43 Speaker 0 And and so I kind of wrote this blog post as a call to action. Like you you have you know, it it's hard. Like if your boss tells you to fill out a weekly report, and the and very specific, I mean, believe me, I have seen every kind of mandated presentation, status report, and spreadsheet that you could imagine. Like I millions of documents we've collected when I was at Microsoft that were all about like you know, I remember seeing I remember seeing you know, a general in the army requiring status reports to all be done on one slide with four quadrants with this format and no bigger than this text, no smaller than that text, no pictures. And you know, like he is a general. Like so he has a lot of stuff at his disposal to compel you to do the format in that way. And you have no tools to just jump up and down and say, I object, general, sir, I'm not gonna do that.
18:29 Speaker 0 And so part of what's going on is there is this this bottom-up change in in work, and it's gonna take time. And there are people who are literally, I would just say I would almost say they're victims of a workflow, and they don't get a vote. But there are also plenty of schools that are changing, and there are plenty of people that are changing where it is gonna happen and all of these things. When you're talking about a universe of people using a tool that's you know a billion plus in any of the tools, people who insist on every like there are organizations that insist on you have to go visit our our desktop browser-based website to fill in and update an expense report. Okay, that's just another work item that got defined by the platform. And believe me, we've seen tons of companies where they're building new ways to fill out that mundane business report, which used which for a long time became the thing you had to stack up and do only at the end of the week.
19:22 Speaker 0 And incidentally, that was a perfect example of of an early kind of work that could never have been computerized. When when I was making the rounds trying to get people to automate expense reporting, they all looked at me and said, that's why we have a select typewriter. Because our expense reports need to be filled out in triplicate on
19:40 Speaker 1 common.
19:40 Speaker 0 And and they have to be the items all have to fit on these lines, and my computer doesn't fit on those lines because nobody wrote tractor fed paper that that worked. And and of course, in my head, that was exactly what I did for my father's small business. But also, right. So there is a place where the the work product can change. And it takes a long time. Like there's somebody in IT and expense reporting that defined it. And then eventually I watched, even in my old job, I watched the Selectric typewriters gradually fade. But believe me, we had them all in in the 90s. Like it took a while before that they went away. And there you still will have business processes that are like that. And then on top of that, there are things that are just like if you're a finance person and you're doing a giant model or your trading system, all those, those don't things don't go away.
20:28 Speaker 0 And that's one of the common things is this is such an emotional debate for people. You know, you cannot take away my laptop. It's defines my job, defines my work. And you know, this is this also a huge amount of this is just also additive. You don't define the new thing as always subsuming all of the old. You know, and and it there are going to be breakthroughs. And I always think about the analogies between movies and the theater. You know, it turns out that movies would have gone away long ago had it you people just define movies as putting one camera in front of actors on a stage. Like it's a very boring way to watch a theater presentation. And but then all of a sudden someone said, Oh, you know, these cameras, they can move around, they can go outside. We could use more than one. And then a whole new form got created.
21:14 Speaker 0 That is actually what's happening in business right now. So it's not that you're gonna look at the 15-page status report and say, how can I do a 15-page status report in this tool? Or look at this giant tracking spreadsheet and say, how do I redo this in a tablet? What's happening is new tools, the tools are now five years old, you know, or at the very least, you know, two or three years old. And all of a sudden we're seeing this explosion in new approaches to the work products themselves. And that's what's particularly exciting right now is that people are now there is enough experience with the form factor to say we don't have to just do it the old way. That the the whole way we think about it can change.
21:53 Speaker 1 So, sort of a final question, I suppose. We've gone from having a network drive with a more or less chaotic or sensible folder structure, and you could put everything in the project folder, and it might be Excel or Photoshop or Illustrator or any other thing or Visio or something. But you could kind of know where everything was. Whereas now you've got 10 cloud services and it could be in any of five of them. So we're kind of going through this phase of massive innovation and massive competition and great new companies being created. Do you think we're gonna kind of narrow in a bit on a smaller set of companies?
22:28 Speaker 0 Um actually, I I would take a different view, and I would I would say it's not as much about a smaller set of companies as every time there's one of these discontinuities in technology, and I I think we are because of mobile and so there you you a bunch of new tools appear, and then it takes a little bit of time to figure out the new problems that these new tools created. And that's fine because that's how innovation works. Like if you know, the the enemy of of the good is the perfect. Yeah, and so if if we all locked ourselves in a room until there was the perfect tool for doing work in a company, it would be out of date, too big, too hard to roll out, all of those things. So the only thing that we know for sure is that things are the processes that are currently in place are are essentially being disrupted by all of these new tools. And the companies that go and and are forward-looking and adopt these are are simply gonna be more modern and more productive, just like the companies that were the first to to do word processing and spreadsheets, were then the first to do GUI, the first to do networking, the first to use laser printers, the first to use color.
23:26 Speaker 0 I mean, these are things that come to define differentiation between organizations. And this it's the speed of thought, it's the speed of decision making, the speed of communication, the speed of working with customers. These tools that are out here are all about solving those problems. They're not problem-free. They're gonna create a new set of problems, which is then itself gonna get rolled into new solutions and new ways of work. And that that's just the fun part about being down here and seeing all of that stuff at play.
23:52 Speaker 1 Right. Steven, thanks a lot.
23:54 Speaker 0 Thank you very much.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated