Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Crisis Time -- What to Do When Things Go Sideways About this episode A crisis can be an opportunity to change your culture. But you have to get through the crisis first, and that starts with getting to the truth of what happened. a16z's Margit Wennmachers, who co-founded The Outcast Agency, and Judy Smith, the founder of a crisis management firm but also "the real life Olivia Pope" (the inspiration behind the ABC show Scandal) draw on their long experience managing all types of crises to walk us through what steps to take when things go bad.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 2 Welcome to the A16Z Podcast. I'm Michael Copeland, and this is our crisis segment. I am not in crisis, but we have two people here who know everything about crisis. Judy Smith, founder of Crisis Management Firm Smith and Company. She's an author and the real life Olivia Pope. So if you uh haven't caught up on your episodes of scandal, go online and catch up right now. Also with us today is Margaret Venma's, a partner here at Andrewson Horwitz, the co-founder of TechCom's firm Outcast and the person in Silicon Valley who everyone turns to in a crisis. So Judy Margett.
0:38 Speaker 1 I know, right?
0:40 Speaker 2 So this is all crisis all the time right now. And so let's get into crisis mode. Let's start with the basics. And Judy, let's just define crisis. When do I know that things are really not headed in the right direction?
0:54 Speaker 1 Anytime I don't get any sleep. Which is most of the time, I might add. Look, you know, I think uh uh a crisis uh really is anything that um whether it's an individual or corporation really fundamentally believes that it is going to affect their brand and in fact uh affect their reputation as well. I don't know, Mark, what do you think?
1:19 Speaker 0 Yeah, I know I agree. It's sort of like what do people think of you today, and then all of a sudden you find yourself in a situation where if you don't resolve this well, they'll never think of you in the same way ever after, and and they are unlikely to believe you or by your product.
1:34 Speaker 2 So I want to get to unlikely to believe you and or buy your product, but what flavors do crisis crises take? Are they is it sort of a consistent theme of somebody didn't tell the truth, somebody did something wrong, what is it? Aaron Powell
1:48 Speaker 0 They involve any range of things in here in Silicon Valley, it can be as simple as a site outage that is persistent. You know, Twitter back in the way in the day with a failway already, that that ends up being a crisis because your product fundamentally doesn't work and um you can't monetize as a result. It can be personal foibles, it can be management shakeup, it can be hostile takeovers, you name it. I mean, there's um endless flavors of them.
2:12 Speaker 1 And that what I think uh Margaret would agree on this is what makes our job interesting because it's always uh a variety of crisis that can happen, and so you find yourself never never bored with it.
2:28 Speaker 2 Never bored, but always busy, I imagine.
2:30 Speaker 1 Yes.
2:30 Speaker 2 Um let's let's pretend that we are moving right along as an individual or a company, everything's going great. No crises on the high on the horizon. But what do you do to prepare? When everything's going extremely well, uh is it fair to say that it's not a matter of if it's when a crisis hits, but what can I do before it hits?
2:50 Speaker 1 Uh I I agree with you. I think it is that a crisis is going to come is just a question of when. Um I think part of what you can try to do to prepare is to have sort of in your top uh desk drawer a plan if something does happen. The kind of research that we do shows that anywhere between 75 and 80 percent of the companies that do have plans that their likelihood of recovery is higher. It doesn't even matter if the plan is on point, you know, just the basics, like if a crisis breaks, who's our core crisis team, right? Who's going to who's going to handle it? Is that person know how to speak to the media, the financial person on touch?
3:36 Speaker 1 All of those kinds of things. Right. That's exactly right. I think
3:41 Speaker 0 that would say there is the plan, which um I would encourage everyone to create one, even if it goes out the window the minute something happens. But there's also the cultural uh component. Because often in a crisis, there's a lot of hiding under the desk and defensive crouching and whatnot. And if you set a culture of transparency and owning a crisis before anything happens, I think you're going to get through it a lot faster.
4:05 Speaker 2 I agree. Trevor Burrus, Jr. And so what does that look like? I mean, is that your interactions with your customers? And I'm talking about the culture. Is that interactions with media? Um what are you trying to build? Trevor Burrus,
4:13 Speaker 0 Jr. I think that is to start with an internal thing. So let's just say, you know, um I remember the IBM systems at the 90s 96 Olympic Games didn't work. So instead of your long jump result, you would get the shoe size of the athlete. That's pretty bad, particularly when you have 15,000 accredited reporters relying on those results to cover the games.
4:34 Speaker 2 And you're the world's largest tech company. So what
4:36 Speaker 0 you need to do is you need to get the engineers to say, like, okay, here are the problems. Let's make a list of the problems. If you haven't set a uh culture of transparency and honesty, and it's okay and in fact encouraged, it's going to take you a lot longer to resolve the issue.
4:51 Speaker 1 That's exactly right. And that to me is the culture is key to success. And it also demonstrates uh leadership. Because in a culture, if you have a culture where people don't feel um confident and feel free to tell the truth and to voice their opinions when a crisis or problem happens, um that is going to make it much worse. Right. And
5:21 Speaker 0 today, you know, we have a lot more scrutiny. Look at the you know, all the hacks that's been happening. Now they're boards and the and CEOs being sued and fired, right? You want to be the engineer who goes like, um I kind of messed up over here. Right. Right. Yes. That's right.
5:40 Speaker 2 So crisis hits. Judy, you show up either literally or figuratively. What happens first? And how how how when you walk in the door, what is your role and how do people sort of know what you what you're there to do?
5:54 Speaker 1 Um shake it up. No, they uh Right. No, that's exactly right. Look, I mean, they certainly know that we are that we are here to to help. I think the first thing that you want to do in any situation is to gather the facts. And um that is not always easy because sometimes um people may not be as forthcoming as we might want them to be with facts, and then they're just some sort of facts that you don't know. You know, you have to deal with it. Yes, yes, absolutely. That's a great way to describe it. Great way to describe it.
6:32 Speaker 2 Well, speaking of truthiness, things are going south, and they're like, well, why don't we just say this? Can't we just say this?
6:40 Speaker 0 I always I like to say a crisis is a terrible thing to waste because the the thing that I like to ask at the uh coming in is do you want to use this as an opportunity to make the company better, or do you just want stuff to go away? And it's a very telling how people react to that. And I think if a good Do you
6:58 Speaker 1 find most people say go away or
7:01 Speaker 0 I think most people say
7:04 Speaker 1 of
7:04 Speaker 0 course we want to make the company better all the time. But they don't mean
7:06 Speaker 1 it.
7:07 Speaker 0 And then what happens what gets said after that because ends up being very telling. Yeah. Um if you want to make the company better as a result, you know, you're going to take your time to really investigate what is the truth. And um, you know, the the size of the companies that Judy deals with probably much, much larger than our companies here in Silicon Valley. But I will tell you, if you're the CEO and you're working you can't name by name everybody's um all of your employees. It's probably uh that's the time where you you you're entering truthiness land. Right. And so that's where you really, really need to make sure that you get your facts straight and you really understand what is going on in the company and what led to the crisis, and then as a result, how to resolve it. Aaron Powell
7:49 Speaker 2 So once you have that truth, and and we can talk about um truth, but you you might not have all the information because maybe nobody does it at you know as things are unfolding. But what do you do next? And and if you don't have the whole picture, how do you talk to people when do you talk to people? Um what happens next?
8:07 Speaker 1 I I think it's important even when you don't have all the facts, and it depends on what kind of steam the crisis is mounting. But I think it's important to communicate with people. Um even if you don't have all the facts, you can clearly indicate it's the facts as you know them to be nail. Because the issue is a lot of times when you are not uh filling that void with information, somebody else is going to plug that hole for you. Yeah,
8:38 Speaker 0 and then you enter land of speculation and someone else tells the story for you. The problem with crises and problem with facts is they weren't built for Twitter. Right. Right. Facts tend to take time. Actually, want to find out what really is going on and who did what or what system failed, or you know, what legal issue, what the complications are, you need to take time. In the meantime, I think the the spokesperson, whoever it may be, needs to be transparent about what a company does know and what it's doing and quote unquote buy some time. And if you don't engage, people just think you're hiding. So people think you're hiding, they tend to think you're lying. Yeah,
9:14 Speaker 2 I mean, as a journalist, I certainly didn't like to hear no comment. But it's time to be silent.
9:20 Speaker 1 Yeah, but but as you know, there are tons of ways to um say something, but not really say anything without saying no comment. Um so yeah, I mean, sure, there are times, there are times for that. Um, but you have to you have to weigh that in particular. Um I think with uh social media, it makes it so much harder to do that because things pick up so so quickly and take on a life of its own.
9:52 Speaker 2 How do you manage that speed? I mean, we we we talk about rapid response teams or uh but or rapid response, but everything. Everything now seems to require rapid response. That's the world we live in. So how do you prioritize? How do you make sure that the sort of response follows the logic and the sort of truth that you want it to? Aaron Powell
10:13 Speaker 0 Well, I think that you need to hear other voices. So if you're in if you're in a situation, you're running a company, and I'm sure we've both been in that situation. It is easy to get defensive. So I think it's very important to get outsiders to go like, okay, so this is this is what's coming across, right? And so you need to manage according to that. I will say not everything is a crisis, right? So there'll be internet trolls, there'll be people who are just doing performance art. You know, they're just you know slamming you for no good reason. And that stuff you have to just develop rhino skin and let it roll off your back. Right. You don't want
10:50 Speaker 1 to over-respond to a crisis. Right. Or overresponding one. Yes, that's right. That's
10:55 Speaker 2 right. Trevor Burrus, Jr.: Then is it just sort of a sense you have that okay, this doesn't warrant a response, this is just trolling. Um is that just gathered over time? If you're a young company,
11:04 Speaker 0 well, it's gathered over time. It's looking at the profiles of the people who are doing the commenting and what credibility they have, what social or other footprint they have, right? You know, it's a 60 minutes calling, or it's just one lonely person, not to make fun of a lonely person, just doing the same thing. Because blogging at home and the jammies, right? Exactly. So I mean, of course, big companies have lots of analytic teams who hopefully have some sense of that, you know, as it happens. And for a smaller company, sometimes you discovered as you go along, right? If you are a company that caters to developers, you know, uh, and um the developers are complaining, that is super, super important. If you're a company that sort of doesn't really cater to developers and yet you have upset developers, you know, you can filter that out. Right.
11:48 Speaker 2 So it's a function of knowing your constituents and who's really most important to you and your company.
11:53 Speaker 0 And checking yourself because what you may think is a completely legitimate response because you have 50 details that the outside world doesn't, you need to check your gut reaction with someone who's on the outside. Aaron Powell
12:04 Speaker 2 I see. Let's get to apologies. Judy, when is it okay to apologize or necessary to apologize? And when do you stop apologizing?
12:13 Speaker 1 After you do it once I look, I I think what's key about uh an apology is that it uh has to be authentic. Sort of the worst thing is to have somebody else, I think, write an apology for you. Because the American public, no matter what it is, I think is very forgiving. But there are a few things that have to happen is one they have to feel that the person is sincere, um, that they meant the apology and that they're truly asking for forgiveness. Um I think if that doesn't come across, we've all seen them uh and heard them when someone apologizes and we'll say, oh God, that person's not really sorry for it.
13:00 Speaker 1 I mean, we've seen that.
13:02 Speaker 0 Yeah, and to put uh bit spicier language on it, if you're gonna eat shit, don't nibble. Yeah, if if the company's made a big mistake or if you've made a personal mistake and you're going to go admit it, don't make that one short little sentence and then walk off the stage. Right. Like make it an actual apology and then you want to own it. You want to own it. And particularly if you're a company and involves your product or involves corporate structure or whatnot, you want to really credibly explain what you're going to do about it to prevent something like that from ever happening again.
13:35 Speaker 2 And who needs to deliver that message? Again, a question of authenticity and belief. If I'm a spokesperson, is that okay? Does it mat does it depend upon how severe the crisis is? Aaron Ross Powell, Jr. I
13:45 Speaker 1 think it depends on how severe the the crisis is. Um I think if it's something that goes in direct relationship to the core of the company, um something like GM, uh you would want to see the CEO out there uh apologizing and and owning that and making sure that that CEO is communicating what they're going to do differently so it doesn't happen again. You can't, a spokesperson can't convey that because they have no authority. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
14:17 Speaker 0 I completely agree. I think I I would quote unquote save the CEO for when you actually know the facts and you know the plan versus have the CEO the day-to-day, like, look, we're still looking into it, you know. That's just a waste of time because that person's also going to be very busy if if the company is going to be better after this. But when the actual moment is, you you as Judy said, you want to do it once, you want to tell it all, and you want to tell yourself, right? Those are sort of the the three rules. And then you have an opportunity to move on. Aaron Powell
14:48 Speaker 2 This gives some uh a question I have about individuals versus companies. You know, you're an individual CEO apologizing on a behalf of a company. But Judy, you work with celebrities and politicians and companies and and Margaret, you work with companies and individuals. Is there a different kind of approach between me, the person and and the organization, the company? Aaron Powell
15:08 Speaker 1 Um I I don't think so. It it certainly depends on um the crisis. But but I will say the the difference certainly is on a company side, you have um you have a lot more issues to consider. You got shareholders uh to consider. That's important. You don't want the market to be affected. I mean, all of those kinds of things are different. But at the core, I think it's certainly about um reputation and brand and uh making sure that however you communicate that it's in a way that is putting that either individual company uh down a path of rehabilitation, I think. Trevor Burrus,
15:51 Speaker 0 Jr. I I would just say that I think there are some nuances in terms of audience shareholders, obviously a very important one that are more complex for companies. I think for an individual, it is a lot harder in a lot of ways because there's no new product cycle. Right. You can't actually ship a new car. Right. Right. So if you're Anthony Wiener and you do the whole New York Times thing and you apologize, and then the same version shows up, there's no new version of you. You're gonna be kind of toast. Right.
16:21 Speaker 1 It's harder to get a second act, so to speak, when it's an individual versus a company because you can make up for it.
16:27 Speaker 0 Right. Right. You know, release a better movie, ship a new car, have a new job on up, like you know, there is a way out with product that people can fall in love with all over again. Well,
16:37 Speaker 2 let's talk about that second chances for companies. And um have you seen it and when and how does it work?
16:45 Speaker 0 We're gonna be talking in generalities all this time because there's very few stuff that we can talk about. I think there's one company that will be okay with me mentioning them, and that's Jawbone. Um their first up uh fitness tracker, just by the way, a gorgeous product, and I'm wearing right now, um had product issues. So there were flaws and there were just too many up bands that didn't work as advertised um out of the box. And um so we did our own like heart-heart and the CEO Hossein did a great job saying, like, okay, I'm gonna make the company better, and here's how I'm going to resolve this. And it spent the associated amount of money, you know, to pull the product from the market, ship a successful new product. And I think there was one headline that was my favorite headline that and it's at jaw bones or Hossein's beautiful failure.
17:31 Speaker 0 And that is sort of the sort of the perfect bookend that you want, right? You have the problems, you've got like the Twitter people on Twitter complaining, some legitimately so, some piling on. You actually gather the facts, you come up with a plan and say, here's what we're going to do, you're going to bite the bullet and spend the money to make that happen. You eat shit, don't nibble on your apology, and then people will go like, all right, I'm moving on, right? You understand the story, you understand what the company did, you believe in the new plan of the company and the new product comes out, and that tends to work. Aaron Powell,
18:06 Speaker 2 I I I remember I was reporting um on job own during this time.
18:09 Speaker 0 Well you tell me that. And well, what happened? You had a job
18:12 Speaker 2 bone that failed and then they took it back and then they gave you another one that worked. And so everyone was willing to give them a second chance. Right. And that's right. And uh And that was their way of an
18:22 Speaker 1 apology.
18:23 Speaker 2 Right. Right. Yes. And it was authentic. Very substantial. Yeah, oh yeah. That was a big apology. So let's talk about style. You know, we invest in young companies, you guys work with both young companies and established companies, but Apple, for example. Apple has this style of you, we will release information when we think it's okay. But they are Apple. Google had a much more open style. But are there different styles and and can I afford as a young company to act like Apple?
18:52 Speaker 0 Aaron Powell I think Apple, it's sort of hard to separate separate Apple and Steve Jobs in this particular instance, I think. And I think the company has actually been a lot more open on a lot of uh different issues, including China, all those kinds of things in in the new era of Apple. And I think it's actually by and large been well received. Back to the core of your question, I think you need to make match the style of your crisis communications with the actual style and culture of the company. So you're going to be having a different style of your virgin and you're quintessentially irreverent. Right. Um than if you're GE and you're quintessentially reliable and stand for for quality, right? So you know, uh crisis is never time to joke, but I I could see Richard Branson getting away with a little bit of some sense of humor in a crisis situation.
19:42 Speaker 0 Whereas a company with the R. Because
19:44 Speaker 1 we expect that from the We expect and it's an
19:47 Speaker 0 established pattern. This this very sort of top-down, you know, one channel out going to the masses that um Steve Jobs embodied things to a large degree. Over because we just have too many channels, too many constituents, and you know, there's Twitter, there's like you know, that is just really, really tough stance to take.
20:08 Speaker 2 This is uh a question that I want to ask, I don't know if you can answer it, Judy, but it's been reported publicly that um you were brought in on the Sony case. What was your observation before you came in on how Sony handled this? And then I want to get to the larger question of in this world of hacks and um personal information on privacy, you know, Target, Home Depot, banks, you name it. How do we respond as a company? What is disclosure? Um are we still working out the details of how and when and who? And are we getting any closer to that?
20:45 Speaker 1 Well, let me just say this. Let's uh use Target as um uh by way of example. I think try Michael. And lost this touch, right? I think one of the things that um Target tried to do early on was to um communicate the amount of um credit card uses that was lost, you know, by individuals. Now that number kept going up. But they try to they try to get that out uh pretty soon. I think overall though, what uh what this has shown with Target and with other companies is that uh it's a new kind of crisis that companies need to prepare for.
21:31 Speaker 1 And uh I think in this an awakening for everybody that you you have to be prepared for that. It's something I think you know, before Target and others that people never never thought about.
21:47 Speaker 0 There was never this magnitude. I mean, you know, we have now two billion people on smartphones. We cite these statistics all the time. These people are doing all kinds of things online. And you know, I've been around Silicon Valley longer than I want to admit, and it in the olden days, no company, no big customer of a security technology company would ever want to say, here's what we're using, blah, blah. And that has not yet really changed. I actually think we're going to come full circle. And I think companies will be out in front and they're going to talk about their security strategy. They're going to admit that there's no such thing as 100% foolproof security. Right. But they are going to make that part of their core messaging platform because you can't just like hide this stuff anymore. Because if you if you are not on record of had as having any strategy, anything, and then something like the target ha hack happens to you.
22:37 Speaker 0 You essentially have no your bank account of credibility is zero. And you're just going straight into the whole.
22:43 Speaker 1 And you know what the other uh thing that's key about when you say it is that people believe anyway, fundamentally that they're that information is not protected anyway. So if you are trying to pretend that, oh, this is rock solid, nobody can penetrate that. I don't think people I I don't feel that people believe that.
23:07 Speaker 2 So are you seeing um attitudes towards disclosure on the part of companies changing? So disclosure to my employees, disclosure to my companies. I know President Obama a couple of weeks ago brought up like we're gonna discuss how, you know, what the regulations ought to be around disclosure for my credit card number being out there. Is there a sort of strategy that you see emerging around this in terms of timeliness and or audience and and how you approach that?
23:35 Speaker 0 So through the lens of the portfolio companies, we have quite a few who sell security products. I have not seen a change in stance from their customer base. I think they're still sort of, you know, we want to keep that stuff secret. And they have, by the way, they have very good reasons, right? Because they don't want to point the hackers into like, you know, here's where they're solid, here are the potential holds and all of that. But there's gotta be a middle ground there because I think you you cannot sell um, you know, forget the American public uh for a second. The countries around the world have very different cultures around security. I mean, I grew up in Germany and like privacy, it's a whole different topic. So if you want to do business around the world, you're going to have to come up with a better communication strategy around security and around vulnerabilities. There's just no two ways about it.
24:20 Speaker 2 The crisis is ended. You guys have done your jobs. Um it's authentic, it's truthful. People have get a second chance. What do you want to walk away from a good crisis with? You know, what in the postmortem, for that matter, how do you conduct a postmortem on a crisis to do a better job next time?
24:38 Speaker 1 Um I think a few things. I think one is you certainly want to assess to your point what went wrong. Um the most important thing is, okay, what are we going to put in place now that we're past it to make sure that that does not uh happen again? Uh I think that's critical. And I also think is as well we spoke about this earlier, um, is that it's no need to waste a crisis because it is always uh I think most of the time an opportunity to do better and to see things from a different perspective, I think. Aaron Powell
25:20 Speaker 0 Yeah, I totally agree. And I think it's also important to actually dissect not just the problem that caused the crisis, but like how the crisis was handled to fine-tune that process. Because I think in many cases, you kind of have a crisis team, but you don't always have all the right people on the team, right? You you you often sometimes you have too many lawyers or too many PR people or too many people who tell you what you want to hear, right? So I think actually it's a big problem. Huge problem. Right.
25:50 Speaker 2 Well, how have you seen that play out then?
25:51 Speaker 0 Well, that's why outsiders get called in, because they leave, so they get to say what they really believe. And they in fact they get paid to do that, but they also, you know, their job doesn't depend on it.
26:02 Speaker 1 Right.
26:03 Speaker 0 That's exactly right. If you're working for someone and your paycheck depends on it, it's just a much harder dynamic to go like, you know what, no one will believe when you say it like that.
26:11 Speaker 1 That's right. That's right. Or you know what, we wouldn't be in this problem or situation if we would have paid attention attention to the internal memo that was circulated six months ago. So it it it's hard to it's hard when you're in the inside to say that. And and to your point, that's why outside voices are are critical, because we get to say what other people won't say or can't say for whatever reason.
26:40 Speaker 2 Yeah, I imagine Enron uh didn't have a lot of outside voices as it hunkered down and tried to
26:44 Speaker 1 do that. No, the whole reality disclosure feeling.
26:47 Speaker 0 Manage what was going on. Well
26:49 Speaker 2 Judy, Margaret. Yes. Uh I feel much better about the crisis I'm about to have. And so thank you guys. Just call
26:55 Speaker 0 us. Right, right. Keep us on speed so much
26:58 Speaker 2 and uh we will continue the discussion.
27:00 Speaker 0 Thank you.
27:01 Speaker 1 Thank you.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated