Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Bitcoin's Growing Pains -- and Possibilities About this episode Bitcoin has had more than its share of drama. There is, of course, the mystery surrounding its anonymous founder (or perhaps, founders) Satoshi Nakamoto. More recently, there's been a battle over whether the size of blocks need to grow to account for more capacity -- especially since there isn’t much time left to make changes before blockchain capacity runs out, says core bitcoin developer Mike Hearn.
Hearn joins a16z’s Chris Dixon on this segment of the a16z Podcast to discuss the current state of bitcoin development; Hearn’s own Lighthouse creation, which is a bitcoin-based crowdfunding app; and what it will take to move the bitcoin protocol into the mainstream.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 2 Welcome to the A16Z podcast. I'm Michael Copeland. For an arcane protocol, Bitcoin has more than its share of drama. There is, of course, the mystery surrounding its anonymous founder or founders, Satoshi. More recently, there's the battle over whether the size of Bitcoin blocks need to grow to account for more capacity. Or if it's just fine the way Satoshi left it. The drama creeps in because there isn't much time left to make changes before Bitcoin blockchain capacity runs out.
0:36 Speaker 2 And running out of blockchain capacity could spell disaster, he says.
1:10 Speaker 0 If you're in the West and you have access to credit card payments and so on, it's not always clear why you would want to use Bitcoin. But that's not because there aren't good reasons. It's because we're not doing a good job of like telling people about them.
1:22 Speaker 2 Chris Dixon kicks it off.
1:24 Speaker 1 Mike, thanks for being here.
1:25 Speaker 0 Thanks. It's great to be here.
1:26 Speaker 1 So let's uh let's start off talking about the state of Bitcoin. There's a lot of debate going on right now about the block size issue. I guess could you first kind of explain that and then and then talk about your views on it?
1:35 Speaker 0 Yeah. So a long time ago, uh when Satoshi was still in charge of the Bitcoin project, he added um a quick hack to the code, basically kind of a clutch, which uh limited Bitcoin's capacity to process transactions. And at the time that he put this limit in, um Bitcoin was nowhere near uh even close to this limit. Um he imposed a maximum one megabyte block size, and as there's one block every 10 minutes on average, that's you know, you can calculate a maximum transaction rate from that. And at the time he put it in, we were around you know, less than 10 kilobytes per block, so a long way from that. Um we're now at more like half of that block size. And it, you know, as traffic is growing, it looks like we might start hitting that limit sometime next year.
2:20 Speaker 0 So Gavin has proposed that we
2:22 Speaker 1 Gavin is the uh is the main Bitcoin maintainer.
2:25 Speaker 0 He was, actually. So when Satoshi left, he nominated Gavin um Anderson as the as his successor. Um and Gavin was maintainer of Bitcoin core for a while, and then he delegated that again to uh Vladimir Van Delan. So Gavin has suggested increasing the block size, and I've been suggesting this for some time as well. This is a debate that's been going on for several years and has never triggered any action, but now we're sort of out of time. So it's now uh moved into a new phase of this debate. And that's that's what this sort of current drama is about. It's about whether the the limit should be raised and by how much.
3:03 Speaker 1 Can you can you give like a quick summary of the two sides and then why you support increasing it?
3:08 Speaker 0 Uh well, um Gavin has been writing about this on this blog for some time. Uh the the argument for increasing it is fairly straightforward. It's that if we don't, Bitcoin will run out of capacity and running out of capacity is bad news, right? That's that means at worst things break quite badly. And but even at best, even if things don't break, some users won't be able to use Bitcoin, right? They will be kicked out of the system effectively. There won't be enough capacity to handle them. And that would be bad. And the simplest way to increase capacity is to increase this limit. And then the arguments against are somewhat varied, and I find them to be a little bit vague, but uh they basically boil down to a concern that if Bitcoin grows, then um, you know, if the hardware requirements for running a Bitcoin node go up, then it's sort of in some sense less decentralized.
3:56 Speaker 1 So those people would sort would rather have Bitcoin be decentralized and not work than uh than working and slightly more centralized.
4:05 Speaker 0 I mean, that's that's how I would characterize it. Yes, some of them would characterize it as saying, well, people will invent other ways of moving money around that don't involve making Bitcoin transactions.
4:16 Speaker 1 They they believe they'll be off-chain, as they say, like they'll be done through other services that that don't record every transaction on the blockchain.
4:25 Speaker 0 Yeah, services, other networks, other systems, basically. Some of these, some of the things they propose um would integrate with the blockchain in some sense, but yeah, it would it would mean a sort of different sort of infrastructure um for routing of payments.
4:39 Speaker 2 Okay.
4:39 Speaker 1 And so now switching over to Bitcoin as a um, yeah, just kind of the the broader applications. What's your take on sort of what's going on there? And I know, and uh you're you're the creator of what I think is a very interesting project called Lighthouse, and we could talk about that. But um, I'm just curious, sort of broadly what he what's your take on kind of Bitcoin adoption and applications.
4:58 Speaker 0 Um Bitcoin adoption is getting okay. If you plot the graphs of transaction traffic, it is growing and it's settled into a fairly standard seasonal growth pattern. Uh this is pretty standard for online services. I've seen this sort of pattern many times in the past. So that's quite reassuring that we're seeing this. At the same time, um I would like to see it grow even faster. You know, Bitcoin doesn't have unlimited runway uh in the speech. So um I'm quite interested in finding ideas that could help increase usage and really find some sort of killer app or you know killer reason to be using Bitcoin in people's everyday lives.
5:35 Speaker 1 Yep. And so and so and you created this new application called Lighthouse, which I I think is one of the most interesting Bitcoin apps I've ever seen.
5:41 Speaker 0 Yeah.
5:41 Speaker 1 Um can you can you describe what that is?
5:44 Speaker 0 Yeah, so Lighthouse is a decentralized Bitcoin-based crowdfunding application, um, like Kickstarter, effectively, or Indiegogo or similar sites like this. The idea is you can create a project uh that has a goal, uh target amount of money uh that needs to be raised for the project to go ahead, and then people can pledge Bitcoins towards that goal. And unlike other attempts at this, where you know you actually have to deposit your Bitcoin with a trusted third party. Lighthouse is a completely peer-to-peer and decentralized approach. So you can actually um pledge money to a project uh in such a way that it stays under your control until the moment that the project has raised a full amount, and at that point it moves into the wallet of the project creator. But you don't have to, you know, the the money is never in some kind of strange state where it's controlled by someone else but theoretically still owned by you.
6:34 Speaker 1 And how does that work technologically?
6:36 Speaker 0 It uses features in the Bitcoin protocol that Satoshi put there right from day one. We don't know exactly how he intended them to be used because he didn't talk about them much, but uh they can be used for for crowdfunding. One of the features uh that Lighthouse uses is a way of signing transactions so they can be merged together. So you can actually create a kind of partial Bitcoin payment that won't be accepted by the system until it's merged with other similar payments to create a final valid um contract, is what we call it.
7:05 Speaker 1 I mean, this is one thing people I think uh an overlooked fact of Bitcoin is that there's a scripting language involved or embedded rather inside of the protocol, which you know, which you uh are one of the are one of the experts on.
7:17 Speaker 0 Yeah. Um for a long time, you know, the for a long time it wasn't very well known because uh Satoshi's white paper didn't mention it and he didn't talk about it in you know his mailing list posts either. It's actually quite astonishing that he built such a complex system and then just left it there for people to find. You know, it's it's one of them one of the more staggering cases of missing documentation I've ever enjoyed. So you could
7:37 Speaker 1 only you could only find the scripting language through the code itself.
7:40 Speaker 0 Yeah, yeah. Everything uh that's known about the scripting language was actually reverse engineered out of the code.
7:45 Speaker 1 I mean, there was all this talk about things like Ethereum, which was a Bitcoin with scripting, yet Bitcoin itself had this already, at least at least some version of it, you know, of that. Well, Bitcoin is
7:55 Speaker 0 yeah, Bitcoin has had this since day one. Yeah. Um I think things like Ethereum came out of a desire to have a more powerful scripting language, actually. Although it's a bit strange because we've never really fully used the uh capabilities of even Bitcoin's fairly limited language. Uh yeah, you you would
8:10 Speaker 1 think the step one would be to use the existing language, run into limits and then expand as necessary, with the obvious caveat being that as you expand it, you might run into security issues and things, right? I mean, if you have a if uh Turing complete scripting language, presumably there's a ton of vulnerabilities as well.
8:27 Speaker 0 Right. I mean, I think one reason that the the Bitcoin scripting language hasn't been expanded is that you know we keep finding interesting ways of abusing the existing one. So um, yeah, designing these sorts of things is is something of a new research area. Um the Bitcoin language is simple, but you know, it can still do quite a lot actually if you're creative with it.
8:46 Speaker 1 Now, Lighthouse took you uh uh like you I think you told me like seven months or something to build like it feels like there's infrastructure uh perhaps there's opportunity to build infrastructure uh on top of the Bitcoin scripting language to make other applications like Lighthouse easier to build.
9:01 Speaker 0 Yeah. Um Lighthouse's use of the scripting system is actually pretty basic. So it's the the complexity there wasn't really imposed by script or its limitations. The the complexity was primarily around um, you know, designing the user interface to make it simple. So you don't, even though behind the scenes are these signatures and scripts and transactions flying around, you don't want the user to see that. The complexity was in things like you know, how do you distribute an app uh such that everyone can use it, right, but without blowing your development budget by writing the app multiple times. There were lots of issues that came up there. How do you move the data around through people's firewalls? Not stuff that isn't really specific to cryptocurrency or Bitcoin, but it's just the plumbing needed to make all this stuff happen. And um uh a lot of the code that I wrote with Lighthouse was intended to be reusable, and so you know it will be easier next time, right?
9:53 Speaker 0 If someone wants to build a Lighthouse style app, because they can if they choose to, they can reuse that code.
10:00 Speaker 1 And what's the benefit of uh distributed kind of crowdfunding as opposed to a centralized one in your mind? I mean, because like uh this the cynics, I don't agree with him, but the critics would say, you know, a centralized service works just fine. You you know, only people who you know want to get around regulation or something would want to use this uh decentralized service. Like what what what are the benefits in your mind?
10:21 Speaker 0 Yeah, I think that sort of argument is quite common. Um it's an argument of privilege, right? So these services um like Kickstarter and Digogo, very very often they're restricted to certain countries, for example. Like uh it's very hard for someone in the middle of India, for example, who maybe doesn't even speak English to create a project and successfully run it on one of these platforms. Um the whole thing is credit card-based. The fees can be very high. Um I usually say the fees for using these platforms can be around 10% of the money you raise. That's not quite fair. That includes banking fees as well as the fees levied by these companies. But it's all a part of the same infrastructure. And by using Bitcoin, you can bypass all of that, right? You're left with at most the exchange fees into your local currency if you don't have a supply chain that you can use with Bitcoin.
11:07 Speaker 0 So there's actually not only huge monetary savings that you can make, um, but it's also you know simpler in many ways. Um it's more flexible and it works all over the world.
11:16 Speaker 1 Just to disclose, I'm a personal investor in Kickstarter from back in I don't know when it was 2008 or nine. So I love Kickstarter and I think it's a great service. Yeah. Um that said, I think that there's I my own belief is there's room for both what I would call services and for protocols. And so services are things like Kickstarter, which are great and say server purpose. But the great thing about open protocols is that they um invite developers and entrepreneurs and investors to build on top of them in a way that they know they can do so safely and not sort of get booted off later the way that corporate controlled platforms tend to do. And so if you just compare, for example, like you know, the amount of innovation that's happened on top of SMTP, the email protocol, you know, there have been thousands of great companies created on top of it and services, Gmail and you know, Outlook are the obvious ones, but there's anti-spam services and there's compliance services, and there's you know, whatever services for helping people do more creative kind of emailing, et cetera.
12:09 Speaker 1 All sorts of interesting things have happened on top of SMTP. Um HTT obviously as well as the protocol underlying the internet, which has unlocked an incredible way of innovation. And so, you know, my feeling is what's so great about these protocols, like what happens the cycle of these things whenever you create a protocol is the critics say, oh, that's only for criminals. They said that about SSL, for example. Um there was a big debate in the 90s about encrypting you know web traffic, because the argument was only criminals who wanted to encrypt their traffic. Um they said that about the VCR, the VCR. Why would you want to cut tape a movie? You know, it's only for piracy. Um the reality is it's it's so that you can then take what was what was otherwise be a corporate silo and make it into a protocol, which lets people build on top of it. That's my own bias, and that's why I think this is so exciting.
12:54 Speaker 0 Yeah, and and I agree. And Lighthouse sort of the design explicitly, I think recognizes that dynamic as well. So you know, the Lighthouse app doesn't try and do everything, right? It it's happy to outsource some things to third-party services like uh like Kickstarter and Indiegogo. Um, whereas those services roll together the movements of money and the hosting of projects and the marketing of the projects and reviewing and quality assurance and all these kinds of things. Uh Lighthouse unbundles them. So there's actually a website called Lightlist.io, which is um an online web gallery. And they uh actually they host projects, they provide project discovery, um, they provide commenting, they're doing some uh ID verification of fundraisers and things like that. So they they are going ahead and then building uh services on top of um the lighthouse protocol.
13:41 Speaker 0 Aaron Powell
13:42 Speaker 1 But they're one they're they're one service, but but there can be competition. Someone else could create a competing service. So you get all the all the wonderful things about capitalism, you get you get true competition on top instead of kind of uh you know, socialist controlled corporate silo. That would be my tip. Yeah, right. I think I think protocols
13:59 Speaker 0 preferred actually.
14:00 Speaker 1 I I think contrary to the caricature that people like up like me who and you, I think who support open protocols as being kind of socialist do-gooders or something. I think it's I think it's actually the opposite, which is we we are actually the the ones who want true free enterprise and competition and want to you know create the tools for people to do that.
14:18 Speaker 0 Yeah, I mean having these protocols is like having standardized road signs and things like that, or having standardized measurements for other things. It it just smooths uh it just greases the wheels of trade and helps everyone do better business, I think. Aaron Powell
14:31 Speaker 1 So where where do you see the the current state of um consumer adoption for Bitcoin and what um what will it take to help that uh continue to grow.
14:39 Speaker 0 Um it's pretty good. I've I've sort of surprised every time I encounter people using Bitcoin, it's always a nice surprise, but it happens more and more often these days. Um I think the uh one reason I'm surprised is you know, right now there isn't um if you're in the West and you have access to you know credit card payments and so on, it's not always clear why you would want to use Bitcoin. But that's not because there aren't good reasons, it's because we're not doing a good job of like telling people about them. Um I'm really keen on uh seeing us get like uh driving merchant discounts through the whole ecosystem, for example. So people can save money with Bitcoin and see their saving money. Um and then they can show their friends, hey, look, you know, look what's happened here, look at this money that I've saved. Um tipping has been really great for this as well, because you know, people can receive a tip without even really expecting it, and then suddenly they feel like, hey, I've actually got some money I could go down to a local cafe and buy myself a drink.
15:29 Speaker 0 And it's a nice feeling, you know, um, that you wouldn't get without Bitcoin. So I'm sort of interested in trying to push some of these ideas through things that can touch everyone's lives in a small way, and and hopefully we can you know get more Bitcoin adoption through some of these techniques. Aaron Powell Yeah,
15:43 Speaker 1 so Clay Christensen, who you know who coined the phrase disruption disruptive innovation, um he has he defines two kinds of disruption. The first he calls kind of low-end disruption, which is basically something in coming in and costing less for an existing behavior, and the other one he calls um, I think he calls it non-cons uh competing against non-consumption, and that is uh new technologies that that allow things you to allow for you to do things you couldn't do before. Um so I I personally am much more excited about the latter kind for Bitcoin. In other words, I'm more excited about new ways that you can um use Bitcoin and pay for things that you couldn't before. So for example, micropayments, machine to machine payments versus save whatever the one to three percent credit card fees that you pay, uh, you know, paying for whatever online merchant.
16:33 Speaker 0 Just because uh well, one is the credit card, you know, the credit card system has
16:36 Speaker 1 done a very good job of effectively hiding those fees. So you basically everyone's paying those fees, and the merchant, you know, it's hidden from the consumer. And basically the way it works, right, is Target gets all of their credit cards stolen, everyone has to, you know, socialize the losses. You basically, it's one of these systems where they privatize the gains into the credit card companies, the merchant processors, Visa MasterCard, et cetera, but they socialize the losses. You you pay for it through chargebacks and decline transactions and getting sent a new credit card and having to change everything. Um so they've done a good job kind of obfuscating the fees, I would argue. And so it's a hard thing to compete against. Whereas if we can cut, you know, sort of brand new things that you couldn't do before because we now have a system where you can push a button and pay someone without any kind of prior trusting relationship.
17:24 Speaker 0 Yeah, I think it's it's not uh exclusive, right? So if you look at the the web, you know, things like YouTube and Facebook, for example, were undoable without the web. That was like totally new markets that were created, social networking and so on that couldn't have happened without the internet. But then a lot of people uh today, even now, they use the internet to read newspapers and you know, send the equivalence of you know electronic letters and basically doing the same things they were doing before, just faster and cheaper. So I don't think it's exclusive and and focusing on um you know, I mean, I would love it if there was a sudden killer app that made everyone want to use Bitcoin that was totally new. That would be fantastic. And uh, this is why I'm exploring some of these ideas with Lighthouse. But um, you know, it it I would like to see us pursue both equally vigorously almost, you know, hedging bets, and we'll see what happens.
18:09 Speaker 0 Yeah, so it's especially for more expensive things like flight tickets, the credit card fees are often not hidden these days. Uh whenever I book flight tickets inside Europe, you know, I see that there's an 11, 12 dollar equivalent uh card fee. And if I can avoid that, and in some cases you can avoid that with Bitcoin, then that's you know, a significant saving. Aaron Powell
18:27 Speaker 1 How do you feel about the um the I mean the use cases in the developing world seem like they might be uh more um pronounced than in the developed world? Aaron Powell
18:37 Speaker 0 I agree. Uh I think if if you look at the debate around MPESA, for example, in Kenya, um, it's been hugely successful there. You know, mobile money in Kenya has been massively successful. And a lot of countries and you know, it's it if you've got a financial conferences and so on, if they're not talking about Bitcoin, a lot of them in the past have been talking about MPAs and saying, why is this so successful? How can we replicate that? But that success has been replicated almost nowhere else. And one reason is um that's kind of painful for a lot of Western financial types to admit is that you know MPESA was partly successful because it sort of ignored all of the Western anti-money laundering requirements and so on. Like you can just have a SIM card and start sending money, right, with MPAs in Kenya. You don't need to have a passport and you know, an electricity bill to prove where you live, which is out of reach for many people in these countries.
19:23 Speaker 0 And um so many of these people that say we want the benefits of MPAs for poor people. We want to see these systems become widespread, but they're not actually quite willing to actually build a digital cash system in the vein of MPs or Bitcoin. And so Bitcoin itself, um, you know, can sort of bypass their sort of, you know, they want uh they want everything at once um uh in some of these cases. And Bitcoin can offer the same value proposition that MPESA has to Kenya, but in every country where people want to use it. And I think that's tremendously powerful. Yeah,
19:51 Speaker 1 I mean, the number we think about a lot here is there's now approaching three billion people with smartphones that will probably go to you know five or six billion. I mean. There's now, you know, I just read an article about a $34 Android smartphone in India. Yeah. Um, these things are getting down to to the price points where there'll be, you know, almost every human on earth will have a smartphone. Um, the vast majority do not have bank accounts. Yeah. So those people either need some way to participate in the economy or not. I I you know, I think you and I would both think they should they should participate. And uh and if the banking system's not going to figure out how to do it, you know, we're gonna try.
20:25 Speaker 0 Yeah, absolutely. And it's very difficult for the banking system to serve these people just due to structural reasons. Um, the moment they want to trade across borders, systems like MPESA don't even work either. So there's a real um niche, well, not even a niche, right? There's a real serious need for many people that Bitcoin can meet there.
20:41 Speaker 1 Yeah. Okay, great. I think we're out of time. Thanks, Mike. Thanks. Bye.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated