Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Bitcoin, Greece, and What’s Next for Cryptocurrency About this episode There are few things as old as financial catastrophe, except maybe finance. But in the latest fiscal meltdown in Greece, people started asking questions about whether newer technology -- bitcoin and the underlying blockchain -- could help. One of those was Wall Street Journal columnist Christopher Mims.
In this episode of the pod, Mims and Coinbase CEO and co-founder Brian Armstrong talk about the current state and future possibility of bitcoin and the bitcoin blockchain. When it comes to Greece -- or the next financial snafu -- Armstrong and Mims think there is potential for bitcoin to help, but some education and UI mainstreaming needs to happen first.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 2 Welcome to the A16Z Podcast. I'm Michael Copeland. There are a few things as old as financial catastrophe. Except for maybe finance. But in the latest fiscal meltdown in Greece, people started asking questions about whether a very new technology, Bitcoin and the underlying blockchain could help. One of those was Wall Street Journal columnist Christopher Mims.
0:25 Speaker 1 So it's just fascinating to me that you can take this underlying the technology that is under Bitcoin and use it to represent literally any exchangeable good. And it can even, in the most extreme case, sort of be used as a mechanism for barter. And so because Greece, a few weeks ago was at this point where people were getting desperate, they're sending people IOUs. I just said, you know, why couldn't you represent that with uh you know the blockchain technology? Obviously, we don't have the ability to do that now. There's a lot of infrastructure that has to be put in place. But could you do it at some point in the future when Bitcoin is more mainstream and people are used to paying this way when you have a generation of people who are used to paying certain things with their phone?
1:04 Speaker 2 Mims is joined by Coinbase CEO and co-founder Brian Armstrong in this segment of the pod for a wide-ranging discussion about the current state and future possibility of Bitcoin and the Bitcoin blockchain. When it comes to Greece, or the next financial snafu, Armstrong thinks there's potential for Bitcoin to help. But there's also some education that needs to happen.
1:28 Speaker 0 When I hear people talking about uh creating all sorts of other currencies and putting it on the blockchain, I'm always I'm a little bit skeptical of that. I think what they're talking about really is like you can digitize any various types of assets and transfer ownership of those in the blockchain. So that could be like shares of a company or some asset like a piece of real estate or concert tickets or something like that. But um, in terms of what currency will actually be used, like if the Greek government is talking about making some kind of their own currency and having on a blockchain, I think they don't really understand what blockchain means when they say that.
2:05 Speaker 2 And you can't have a discussion about Bitcoin without asking about its price and investment potential.
2:11 Speaker 0 You know, you shouldn't invest all your money in Bitcoin or something like that. But should every investor own maybe one Bitcoin? Yes, I think I think they should. And the reason is not so much as an investment, it's to start learning about this technology, which will be a major influence on finance in the future.
2:29 Speaker 2 Bitcoin, Greece, and what's next for cryptocurrency on this segment of the A16Z podcast. Christopher Mims kicks it off.
2:38 Speaker 1 Yeah, Brian, I just wanted to start with you know where your interest in Bitcoin is coming from.
2:42 Speaker 0 My interest is really as a technology entrepreneur. My belief of the world is that technology is this great force to improve the world, and it's probably the most powerful force changing the world right now. And Bitcoin is a great example of that. It's um it's an open standard or protocol for a global payment system. And I think it when I read about it back in uh 2010, I realized it had the potential to have a big impact on the world. So over a period of time got comfortable thinking through all of the end game scenarios of it and eventually decided to start a company around it. Um to give you a little more detail, I was I was actually working as a software engineer at Airbnb, and we were moving money to 190 countries around the world, and I sort of had a front row seat into how inefficient that payment network was all over the world.
3:31 Speaker 0 Usually in each country there's a proprietary system of a couple different payment systems there, each with um each kind of is like a mini oligopoly, and so there's uh not much innovation happening there, usually high fees, delays in how fast money can move, and um a limited geographic reach of each of those. And so when I read about that idea to have that the whole world could have an open payment network, it it immediately captured my attention.
3:59 Speaker 1 It's funny you should say that because that's my introduction of Bitcoin as well. I feel like people talk a lot about uh Bitcoin in kind of a misinformed way. They look at it as you know, an asset like gold, and so everybody pays attention to the fluctuating price. But what caught my attention was I was talking to a uh remittance company in the Philippines, and they were using Bitcoin as a super fast, uh super low cost, low fee way to transfer money between countries in the West and the Philippines. And of course, the reason they can do it is that they can get in and out of any given currency really quickly, and Bitcoin is just the conveyance. And so I don't know what you're feeling is, but when I look at Bitcoin, I feel like the sort of minimum viable product for Bitcoin right now is remittances for or money transfers.
4:45 Speaker 1 So my perspective is right now, it's not so much about Bitcoin itself, it's that the technology simply allows you to transmit money, and then of course you have to have an exchange on both ends. But that's kind of where I see Bitcoin, and I'm curious. You know, do you that what you see as a sort of minimum viable product right now, or do you see other things that people are doing that you think they're actually going concerns right now?
5:10 Speaker 0 Yeah, so I think that's a great example. It's actually one of several. Um so I kind of more broadly think of it as three major categories where Bitcoin could be the most useful. One of them is um what uh an example of what you cited, which is um disrupting traditional financial services products. So in that case, remittance. It might allow it to be faster or cheaper, right? Other examples of traditional financial products it might disrupt would be things like credit card payments, where now those fees are less, or um, instead of going to get a loan at a bank, you might be able to get a peer-to-peer loan through something like BTC Jam, which is a startup out there. So there's that's the first category would be disrupting traditionally what we think of as financial services.
5:56 Speaker 0 The second major category in my mind would be developing world use cases where people actually don't have financial services today. These are the unbanked of the world. And there's something like two to three billion people in the world who have a cell phone but do not have a bank account or credit card. Um they're living essentially with cash, or they're using some kind of um primitive digital currency, like a lot of people actually send cell phone minutes or cell phone credit, and they can SMS it to each other in the developing world. Like this is very popular in the Philippines and India and places like that. Um there's actually some places where you can go in the Philippines and buy dinner with cell phone minutes and things like that, and you text it to the person across the counter.
6:42 Speaker 0 And so those are all early precursors of digital currency, types of digital currency that people are using there. And we think a whole generation of kids and people in the developing world will actually grow up, and their very first quote-unquote bank account will actually be a digital currency wallet on their cell phone. So that's the second major category. Um the third one would be what I call brand new internet applications where that are uniquely enabled by Bitcoin. So by that I mean that it's not uh disrupting the traditional financial services industry or something like that. It's actually creating something that the only way it works is with Bitcoin. So these are very small today, but I think in the future, some of these will end up being many multi-billion dollar companies and systems.
7:29 Speaker 0 Some of these are things like um distributed crowdfunding, uh, which like the Lighthouse project is an example of that. Um there are prediction markets where you can use the wisdom of crowds to predict the outcome of certain events. There are um there's uh a lot of them have to do with microtransactions, actually, which is something Bitcoin uniquely enables. So there are things like um tipping on the on the internet uh with um things like change tip. So these are examples of kind of very new use cases that are uniquely enabled by Bitcoin, which are not big yet, but could actually grow in uh it's more of like a green fields idea.
8:08 Speaker 1 Yeah, so I mean, one of the things you know, there's been a lot uh uh let's say derision about Bitcoin. And the reason that I kept paying attention to was that there felt like this burgeoning developer community, you know, it reminded me of iOS or Android in the early days. And I was wanting to get a sense of how big that is.
8:29 Speaker 0 There is a lot of developer interest. Um you're right. It's especially uh with younger people like currently in college and things like that. We only have a few pieces of data on it. One of them is that we've had 7,000 developers sign up on Coinbase to create apps, and we have one of the more popular developer platforms out there. The other is that we've seen some data around uh the number of GitHub repositories that are being created every month that have something to do with Bitcoin. And there's been about, well, let's see, there's about 6,000 total to date, which is outpacing the number of GitHub repositories for other common payment systems like PayPal. Um so that's a I think that's a really interesting early indicator of um the amount of developer interest. And if you look at traditionally things that have gotten a lot of developer interest, like Linux or Android or whatever, um, it sometimes takes five years or 10 years, but they eventually end up being massive platforms.
9:25 Speaker 0 Like Linux runs the majority of the internet now, and it was all started with a handful of really passionate developers who got excited about it. So in general, that's a really good predictor, I think, of where the future is going. Um, you know, Chris, I I know you wrote a lot about um Greece recently with with Bitcoin and everything like that, and I was I was just curious how did you get um interested enough to go do some investigation into that Greece aspect of it specifically?
9:53 Speaker 1 Yeah, it's funny. There was a lot of chatter. I mean, I forget his name, but the the guy who is rumored to be one of the Inventors of Bitcoin wrote about it on this blog. Also very focused former Greece finance minister who's now I think facing criminal charges for talking about setting up an alternate
10:16 Speaker 0 currency. I didn't know that.
10:19 Speaker 1 More than a year and a half ago. Yeah. So he uh you know he said you could create this thing, I think he called it FT coin, and the it would be based on future tax revenues. And sort of what's impressive about it and what got me excited was the possibility that Bitcoin could truly be this almost blank canvas for money. You know, people talk about this mechanism of side chains, and for anyone listening to this who doesn't know what those are, just think of them as clones of Bitcoin that can be exchanged for Bitcoin to be the simple version of it. I know that's a gross oversimplification. But anyway, this means that you know things that people object to about Bitcoin, like, oh, it's a deflationary currency because there's a cap on how many uh Bitcoins can be created, become irrelevant, right?
11:05 Speaker 1 Because a central bank could say, hey, you know what, we want to place the dollar with uh you know a dollar token that is represented on the Bitcoin blockchain, you can do that. Um, I talked to Michael Casey, who we used to be to Wall Street Journal, now at the MIT Media Lab advising them on cryptocurrencies, and one of the things he talked about was you know, stores are starting to think about what if we uh represented our uh you know, like not coupons, but like store tokens, store credit uh through our own cryptocurrency. Um and they're you know they're totally earnest about this. So it's just fascinating to me that you can take this underlying the technology that is under Bitcoin and use it to represent literally any exchangeable good, and it can even in the most extreme case sort of be used as a mechanism for barter.
11:54 Speaker 1 And so because Greece, a few weeks ago was at this point where people were getting desperate, they're sending people IOUs. I just said, you know, why couldn't you represent that with uh you know the blockchain technology? Obviously, we don't have the ability to do that now. There's a lot of infrastructure that has to be put in place. But could you do it at some point in the future when Bitcoin is more mainstream and people are used to paying this way when you have a generation of people who are used to paying certain things with their phone? It seems entirely possible. So if you have this new ability to tokenize anything in your world, um, you know, it it means that you can create currency just based on barter. Um it means that banks can decide to create currency, companies can decide create currency.
12:41 Speaker 1 I mean, as long as it's legal, right? That's there's always the regulatory dimension to it. So that just seemed just so fascinating to me because you know, nothing is older than currency crises, right? Except for money. So this problem is never gonna go away. So isn't it interesting that we possibly have sort of a way to kind of uh that the end often does you know, route around the damage. But Brian, I I mean, I just wanted to ask you, you know, given um how far-fetched a lot of that discussion is, you know, what have you seen in terms of discussion related to that? And maybe you can bring it back to Earth, you know, what's going on now? What's in the immediate future?
13:22 Speaker 0 So, I mean, there's a there's a few things. One is that when I hear people talking about uh creating all sorts of other currencies and putting it on the blockchain, I'm always a I'm a little bit skeptical of that. I think what they're talking about really is like you can digitize any various types of assets and and transfer ownership of those in the blockchain. So that could be like shares of a company or some asset like um a piece of real estate or concert tickets or or something like that. But um, in terms of what currency will actually be used, like if the Greek government is talking about making some kind of their own currency and having on a blockchain, I think they don't really understand what blockchain means when they say that. I I think Bitcoin will be the currency that that everyone ends up using on the blockchain, and it did they probably don't quite understand what they're saying when they say that.
14:10 Speaker 0 Um but I don't know, just from like a more broad perspective of of what we think is interesting right now. A lot of the focus historically has been on Bitcoin on the price of Bitcoin. And it's because the early adopt the early adopter use case of Bitcoin is all around it being a speculative asset. People are buying it because it's scarce, they think it'll be useful for something in the future, and in that sense, it's kind of like a better version of gold or better version of money. So there's a lot of people buying it and trading it like a like a stock or something like that. Now, about that's 80% of activity, let's call it roughly. 20% of activity is people actually using it now as a payment network on some of these new types of applications like the ones I mentioned or doing peer-to-peer payments or paying their contractors and other countries, things like that.
14:56 Speaker 0 And I think over time what will happen is that those two percentages will shift. Um the 80% will end up becoming the 20% speculative asset, and it'll be 80% um payment network actually happening. Um the reason is that the speculative investment aspect is a bootstrapping mechanism, if you will, for the payment network, which I think is the eventual long-term potential of Bitcoin. And the much more interesting mechanism, or sorry, the much more interesting um metric to focus on other than price is actually number of daily transactions on the Bitcoin network. And that's gone from about 50,000 a day to 100,000 a day in the last 12 months. A lot of people don't realize that. That graph is actually just pretty slowly and steadily marching up, roughly doubling every year, whereas the price is just wildly fluctuating all over the map. Um, where people are trying to extrapolate, you know, what if there'll be a million dollar Bitcoin eventually or something like that.
15:47 Speaker 0 So my hope and belief is that you'll see the number of daily transactions become more of a focal point. That'll continue to double every year, roughly, and you'll see this payment network um emerge where that becomes the primary use case of Bitcoin. And it's and then the speculative investment use case will actually diminish a bit more into the background. It'll end up being something much less volatile. We've seen volatility drop drop every year for the last three years. Um that ends up being a little bit more like a commodity like gold, but does the average person really care about commodities markets or FX trading? Uh probably not. They do care about how they're going to send money and pay for things, and they want to do that cheaply and efficiently.
16:27 Speaker 1 So are you uh I have to add, are you want to be you know Bitcoin to a million dollars folks? I mean, is that where you see it going? Because I mean it seems like inevitably if it becomes more useful, it Bitcoin do become more valuable,
16:42 Speaker 0 right?
16:43 Speaker 1 If you're right that this does become the default mechanism, default use for Bitcoin is a means of exchange.
16:49 Speaker 0 I never want to make uh predictions about the price of Bitcoin because it's a good way to um uh I don't it's not I don't want to be in the business of giving people an investment advice, right? It's just uh easy way to disappoint people. But um personally, yes, I'm I'm long Bitcoin. I I buy Bitcoin. I I'm not too concerned about the price day to day. I tend to um dollar cost average it over a long period of time. And what I do tell everyone is you know, you shouldn't invest all your money in Bitcoin or something like that. But should every investor own maybe one Bitcoin? Yes, I think I think they should. And the reason is not so much as an investment, it's to start learning about this technology, which will be a major influence on finance in the future. It's it's almost like if you went back to the 80s or the 90s and you said, uh, well, do we need a desktop computer in every home?
17:35 Speaker 0 Um maybe maybe not. I mean, there's not really that many things you can do with it yet, right? Like there's no AOL and there's there's no email where my grandmother can't get the family photos or whatever on Facebook or whatever they need to do. But there was a lot of people who went out there and they got a desktop computer because they believed that this was going to be something important in the future, and they wanted to start to learn about it and participate in that revolution. And so that's where I think people are at more, and I encourage everyone to go out there and buy one Bitcoin, not for the price or the investment aspect of it, but just to learn about it and um have a piece in the game.
18:11 Speaker 1 You know, one of the things I talked about in my article for the journal was look, uh, you know, Bitcoin doesn't make uh you know look of difference to to people in Greece right now.
18:21 Speaker 0 Yeah.
18:22 Speaker 1 Um and I think the ongoing challenge for Bitcoin, it reminds me of like, you know, uh let's say encryption technologies for communications. I mean, they've been around
18:32 Speaker 2 a long
18:32 Speaker 1 time, and they're still hard to use. I mean, they're only just sort of becoming uh invisible on the default. Uh but you know, where I the thing I always ask myself is where what's the breakthrough? Like where I really is it's gonna be slow, but how does how do we get Bitcoin into the hands of everyday people? Does it need to be in Google wallets? Does it need to be an Apple wallet? Do I need you know one click access to an exchange? How are we gonna how are we gonna get Bitcoin beyond the realm of people who are reading message boards about you know how to safely store it on a DOM drive in a fireproof box and all that?
19:10 Speaker 0 Well, I mean, certainly our approach has been to try to make it easy to use for the average person. So it wasn't that long ago that pretty much every Bitcoin site out there talked a lot about private encryption keys and all these complicated things. You needed a computer science degree to try to understand it. And um I like to think we were uh helpful in making Bitcoin a bit easier to use for the average non-technical mass market person. Um making it secure also was a big deal. I mean, if people forget their password and all their money's gone, that's kind of a non starter for um a real financial revolution to happen. Um there was also a lot of websites out there being hacked, and um there's a lot of uh security breaches. I mean, that happens in traditional financial services too, but Bitcoin as an industry has really had to mature in the last couple years.
19:59 Speaker 0 And And companies like Coinbase are now storing hundreds of millions of dollars of Bitcoin and doing it securely with lots of checks and balances that are happening in traditional financial services as well, like security audits and financial audits and all sorts of things. So I think those things will all help, but is there going to be some moment where Bitcoin just suddenly is mainstream? No, I don't think so. I think it's going to be a series of lots of small things that happen over time. People will there'll be some game they want to play online. It turns out the only way to play it is with Bitcoin, and so they'll go out and get some. Or it'll somebody they'll be in a foreign country and somebody will remit money to them, like $50, and the fastest and cheapest way for them to get it was in Bitcoin, so now they'll have to go figure out a way to cash that out in their local country, and that that'll be another way, right?
20:52 Speaker 0 So I think you'll see it bit by bit in these in these areas grow in in certain in in different ways. And like we've seen with the number of transactions per day, it's roughly doubled in the last year, but it's been a pretty steady thing. There wasn't there wasn't a moment where suddenly it just doubled in a week or something like that. The one the one counterexample to that I can think of would be uh countries that are going through periods of financial crisis, like Greece, where you know, which you wrote about recently, um, where like for example, when the Greece uh situation happened, we saw roughly 3x or 300% growth of our normal by sell volume across all of Europe, not just in Greece, because of course the Greek bank accounts were frozen, and people, there was people really people in the rest of Europe who wanted to go find out about Bitcoin, the number of Google searches went up dramatically for it.
21:44 Speaker 0 So certainly, I mean, every every year in the world somewhere there's some kind of financial crisis, and um I think those will be periods where people start to look out, look for other options and start to really think about what it means to have their money in a bank account. Is that trusted and
22:00 Speaker 1 things like that?
22:01 Speaker 0 Of course, I'm curious uh what you've seen on the usability challenges around Bitcoin. I mean, I feel like it's uh still very unapproachable topic for some people and that they feel like it's it's complicated or they still don't quite understand Bitcoin. I mean, what what have you seen as ways that the average person out there has gotten their head wrapped around this this new concept or started using it?
22:25 Speaker 1 Yeah, it it feels like the usability challenge for Bitcoin honestly is uh magnified by the fact that we have this usability challenge that's yet to be solved in terms of digital money. Um so I mean David Woolman, this amazing writer who wrote a whole book about the end of cash, and you know, he and I talk about this regularly, and I'm like, you know, I'm like, that's crazy. Cash is not going away because it's so incredibly useful. And I mean, especially in the US, you have this problem of you know, we have Apple Pay coming
22:55 Speaker 2 in,
22:56 Speaker 1 and nobody's quite sure about the adoption figures there. Google wallet has been mostly a failure to date. Um, it's just so easy to pull out a credit card. Yes, there's a fee structure there, but because of the history of that, you know, the cost gets eaten by the merchant. Um, you know, they have deals with Visa and MasterCard, but they're not even allowed to, you know, like give you a discount if you use cash. So we have this pretty good payment system in place. So the usability problem is I mean, this is what people always say about product adoption. If something is painful, if you solve a difficult, painful problem, adoption will be very rapid. If you're merely better than something that's good, adoption is going to be slow and it can even be non-existent.
23:44 Speaker 1 So I mean, I would kind of throw that back to you. I think that the you know, the reason I talked about Greece was you know, people in Greece are in a really painful situation. I heard a radio interview recently with a mechanical engineer in Greece who had literally kind of seen this coming and had withdrawn something like 50,000 euros and had bundles of euros in cash uh stored in the back panel of his refrigerator, and the thieves wouldn't be able to find it. And I thought, wow, you know, here's a guy who could use uh uh a store of value that could be more easily transmitted and is more liquid, you know, even if the price is fluctuating, like Bitcoin, if he'd known about it. Um but you know, outside of these these crises or countries where you people are really unbanked, you know, I I I would ask you, you know, why is it that Bitcoin's gonna give me the average user that is gonna make me say, wow, that's that's really a difficult problem I have.
24:46 Speaker 1 Bitcoin solves it, or this app solves it.
24:48 Speaker 0 Yeah, I I totally agree with that. I think um if you're talking about winning on usability, um the easiest place to go is people who have high pain points around their current options, or another way to put it would be their next best alternative is dramatically worse, not just a little bit worse. So I kind of think of it as a spectrum of how frustrated people are with their current options, right? So if you think of it like a one to ten scale, one being the least frustrated, you have things like people uh swiping their credit card at Starbucks for a copy. It's very painless. Sure, the merchant has to pay two you know two percent plus, which is a bit frustrating for them, but not too bad. And then you go up the ladder a little bit, maybe like a three or four on the scale is online shopping, right?
25:34 Speaker 0 You have to put your credit card in in a website, you it's a little bit scary, you think it might get hacked like Target did, or you have to type 16 characters and a four for the date and five for your zip code and a three-digit security code, it's kind of frustrating, or they expire every every couple of years. Um, but still not the end of the world, right? Now, if you go up the scale a little bit more, you have people who let's say I want to send uh 100 to my family in Mexico and it cost me 12 dollars. Now that's starting to be a little bit more of a pain point, right? Now maybe like a six or a seven on the scale, and I'm starting to feel like the pricing is predatory even or something very inefficient, right? Um if you keep now you can keep going up that scale quite quite a bit further, right?
26:20 Speaker 0 So to your point about the person in Greece withdrawing $50,000 in cash, that's a good example. There's also people who are trying to remit money from the UK to Somalia, for example, and all of the banks have shut down that service. Um so literally people have resorted to flying suitcases of cash to Somalia, and you could argue they have a very high pain point there. Their next their next best alternative is very much dramatically worse. Now, at the top of that scale, you have things like people in the developing world who don't have any financial services whatsoever. Um you have like the whole banking model really doesn't work in those in those demographics with like a checking checkbook and like a bank branch in the corner. You also have things like microtransactions, which just aren't possible in the existing financial ecosystem, right?
27:09 Speaker 0 Or if you want to build a global uh crowdfunding site or uh prediction market or something like that where people all over the world um without having to register can within a couple seconds put money into this thing or see it tip. It's like literally the only way to build it is with Bitcoin. There is no next best alternative. And so you could argue those people have the highest pain point and they're willing to tolerate the biggest usability challenges to get something, anything going. Um you could there's other examples of that too. You like if you're in Nigeria and you want to buy an iPhone, pretty much every website will reject you. Um if you're selling some kind of high-risk service or you know, you're in the adult industry or whatever this is, people find themselves in very difficult situations to uh to accept payments.
27:56 Speaker 0 But um that's how you should that's how I'd like to think about it is there's like a spectrum of options. Now, someday if the world if Bitcoin becomes more and more popular, like we all think it will, um, then yes, even the Starbucks across the street will be accepting Bitcoin because they they still don't want to pay 2%, they'd rather pay a fraction of 1%. Um but that's gonna be the last group to adopt it. And the usability can help us get there faster, but I think it's better to focus on people with the highest pain points. Chris, we talked a little bit, we touched a little bit earlier on side chains. Um I thought it might be interesting to talk about that just for a couple of minutes, because I think it could have a big impact.
28:39 Speaker 1 You know, as I understand it, uh there is this kind of this technical trickery that means that you can create an unlimited number of uh independent blockchains that are still linked to the main Bitcoin blockchain such that any token on these quote unquote side chains can still be exchanged for Bitcoin, I think on a one-to-one basis. And the idea is if you can have these side chains, you can have a lot more experimentation. So you could have something that's just kind of like another Bitcoin, but it has new protocol that um, for example, allow it to be transmitted a lot more quickly, because as I understand it, you know, the more transactions there are, there are challenges in fulfilling this dream of Bitcoin being uh a transaction that instantly resolves.
29:30 Speaker 1 Uh and then you know, there's just people have other ideas, and then like I said earlier, you know, people might want to put other things on the sidechain. I mean, let's not forget, I think it's Ecuador recently banned Bitcoin and said we're gonna create our own cryptocurrency. Uh that's
29:49 Speaker 2 how our entire financial system is gonna work,
29:51 Speaker 1 which to me is wild, but it it feels like you know, as much as Bitcoin is is it's important that you have this very solid. Main means of exchange, you know, my perspective is giving people the ability to experiment is good. The same way that letting people build all of these new protocols on top of the original protocols that enabled the internet is what gave us everything from the web to YouTube. I mean, so my perspective, of course, as an outsider's perspective, is that you're not going to realize the full potential of Bitcoin unless you get something like sidechain. But I'm like, you're somewhat skeptical of that. So I'd love to hear your view on sidechain, how they work and where they might go.
30:32 Speaker 0 No, I'm I'm actually pretty positive on sidechains. I think I think they're great. I am skeptical of uh countries like Ecuador saying they're going to create their own digital currency since if you centralize a digital currency, it seems to miss the whole point in in my book. Um I do think there'll be other countries who try to do that, but I don't think they'll be successful. But but side chains generally, I think are great. I mean, it's essentially a way to um allow experimentation, just like you said, and you can have a one-to-one peg, they call it. So if you have a Bitcoin on the main blockchain, you can transfer it over to this sidechain and experiment with different things. Um the main thing there was a lot of experimentation before sidechains. These were altcoins, people called it.
31:19 Speaker 0 And that worked somewhat, but the the downside of it was that um it was difficult for anyone to get a large amount of traction on any of these site uh alt chains. And so um, because they all needed separate mining uh computers that would that would run each one. The beauty of the sidechain is that they can all use the one Bitcoin blockchain's um hashing power. And if we if there's a sidechain that runs in you know out there in the world for some period of time and it demonstrates that it's viable, there haven't been any bugs found in it, that could actually be elected to be the new main Bitcoin blockchain uh with better properties like these faster confirmation times or whatever it ends up being. And so the the great part about that is that it means Bitcoin can evolve over time.
32:05 Speaker 0 It actually has a mechanism built in to do upgrades, just like your phone gets upgrades downloaded from Apple or Google or whatever. And so if you other protocols that are out there, like TCPIP, which is a foundational protocol of the internet, or SMTP, which is out there for email, they have very slow um they they can't really uh update or change that that often because it requires massive amounts of infrastructure to be upgraded. It's a very high-risk upgrade because um a lot of those things haven't been tested at scale before. And so it's really awesome to see Bitcoin have um a mechanism for upgrades, essentially uh built into it, which gives me a lot more confidence that it'll survive the test of time.
32:48 Speaker 1 Well, Brian, let me uh just take that thing to say thank you for uh your time and your thoughts on this. Uh I'm as a journalist, I'm a little uh sad that this is gonna be public because I feel like they're with uh or two or three columns worth of material of this conversation. Um but I but I hope people listen to it. And um, I just kind of as a closing thought, um, I hope that anybody who listens to this kind of understands that um Bitcoin is something that is easy to uh be derisive about because uh of its fluctuating price and good association with things like gold. But I think we're really at a turning point where even people like me who are fairly non-technical, um, should start paying attention to it because there are some really interesting opportunities cropping up here and there, and I see a lot of early adopters, uh, especially among banks.
33:46 Speaker 1 And that to me is always a sign that um this is going somewhere real because they're not gonna uh spend all their money and analyst time on things that aren't gonna make the money.
33:58 Speaker 0 I I agree. It does feel like Bitcoin is at a bit of a turning point, and a lot of that is due to the excellent coverage that's out there from journalists like yourself who are starting to really dive in uh one level deeper and look beyond um just the basic headlines around what the price is doing this week or something like that. So I really appreciate you taking the time as well, and it's um it's been great to chat. Likewise.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated