Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | An Open Source Business Model That Works About this episode Open source software has permeated practically every nook of the software world. The biggest companies and largest-scale systems all lean heavily on open source code. Yet, with the exception of Red Hat, no one has built a great business on top of open source software. That’s because what companies should be selling isn’t necessarily the software, or even support, says a16z’s Peter Levine, but a service that leverages open source. One example of such a service is DigitalOcean, which has built a cloud environment tailored to the needs of developers. DigitalOcean CEO and cofcounder Ben Uretsky joins Levine from his New York City HQ for a discussion about open source-as-a-service, how companies of all sizes should think about leveraging open source, and whether we’ll start to see a slew of specialized clouds geared toward different verticals.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 1 Hello, this is Peter from Andrees and Horowitz. And it's my honor to be joined with by uh Ben, who's the CEO of uh DigitalOcean. Ben, how are you doing?
0:14 Speaker 0 Doing doing really well. Thanks, Peter, for having me on.
0:17 Speaker 1 Good. Yeah, great. So one of the things, man, that I've I've spoken quite a bit about recently in sort of the data center of the future and the future of uh enterprise technology is the notion of open source economics finally working and specifically kind of contrasting open source being used, being used as a service, like what DigitalOcean does, versus let's say the Red Hat model of on-prem free software and then charging for you know the most charging for support and maintenance uh as the economic model. And my belief is that there's really a very uh beneficial model by having open source as a service, open and proprietary source as a service, again, as a way to um really drive economic value out of open source.
1:10 Speaker 1 And I'm just sort of curious. I mean, you guys are you've built a company on this, so I'm curious on your thoughts and how you guys think about that.
1:23 Speaker 0 Yeah, definitely. So we we've built our cloud on top of uh KVM's virtualization technology, which in and of itself is an open source project, and we deliver a ton more value than just the uh the virtualization engine. So we've uh created an entire interface and API to interact with uh the infrastructure that we're providing, and we've also put you know thousands of servers into a data center. Now all of this is powered by by KVM, and we've turned it into a infrastructure as a service provider. Um without uh you know the work that was put into the open source project, we'd never be able to to build our company. So I think this is uh a big widespread trend that that we're seeing in uh in the open source community.
2:15 Speaker 0 Uh first of all, the the projects themselves are becoming much more relevant to what people are are doing today. But at the same time, there's also a proliferation of of new projects that are coming out every you know every month and and every year. So database as a service essentially has grown significantly over the last uh decade with a whole bunch of uh NoSQL projects that are that are just you know getting their their start. And what's interesting is as an individual user, um it would take you a very long time to figure out how to leverage that project. You have to learn the ins and outs. There's a ton of best practice that goes along with it.
3:02 Speaker 0 And and one thing that the open source community hasn't really done a great job of just yet is giving you a primer and getting you started uh on best practice implementation from day one. And I think that's where this open source as a service provider really can step in.
3:22 Speaker 1 And
3:22 Speaker 0 hopefully they've taken the time out to perfect the technology on their end, which is based on that open source project, but it's it's pre-packaged for an end user's need. So now, let's say I I do have a need for a clustered scale out, no SQL database, I can just go to one of these open source providers and consume that service without taking all the time to build to build it on my own. So this is definitely a prevailing trend that we're seeing more and more.
3:54 Speaker 1 Yeah, so it's interesting and and you know, maybe to contrast what like it it may not seem obvious to folks that um may it's not even completely obvious to me that open source is out there. I can readily pick up open source pieces, and I can put those pieces in my on-prem installation. So like if I'm thinking about this, why, you know, what's the benefit of as a service versus um you know, just the company themselves, I'll say cobbling together open source components. They're readily available, free to use. Maybe, you know, are there pros and cons to each of those? And how might people think about adopting you know open source as a service versus putting open source on-prem?
4:46 Speaker 0 Yeah, that's a great question. Um a customer that I was just speaking to recently is is taking this new uh philosophy that they're building inside of their business. And what they're looking for is the opportunity to outsource all of these open source projects to a specialized provider. And their basic premise is we don't want to be responsible for the operational challenges that come with scaling and running that technology. So if I consume it as a service, I have a very fixed rate uh under which I operate, and it's going to cost me X cents or dollars per time period or per volume or what whatever the case might be.
5:40 Speaker 0 Um it really is a fundamental uh uh decision that uh that a company needs to make. Do you outsource these pieces to specialized uh providers and hope that they provide a better level of service and you can develop internally, you have
6:00 Speaker 1 actually
6:01 Speaker 0 someone's neck that you can choke, especially because you're paying the money for that service,
6:05 Speaker 1 yeah,
6:06 Speaker 0 or do you build it in how? And with this specific customer, um they've already built a lot of this as a uh uh as a first pass on premise, you know, taking that open source product and deploying it to their own infrastructure, and then realizing that there's so much complexity that goes into managing each one of these uh discrete pieces. And more importantly, um if you just take the open source project, you don't have any commercial support that you can rely on. So when the system breaks, it's up to your operational people to fix it. And uh, you know, that was the decision point that they used to say in our particular case, we would much rather outsource this to someone else.
6:54 Speaker 0 We believe that our total cost of ownership actually winds up being less. And more importantly, if something breaks, we know that we're not on the hook.
7:04 Speaker 1 So
7:05 Speaker 0 I think the example that he used was uh uh in this particular case, leveraging AWS's uh RDS product, which is basically MySQL as a service. And he basically said, look, if the database is broken, there's nothing that we need to do because we know that the service provider will go ahead and fix the problem for us. Once the issue is resolved, our business is back online and operational. Whereas the opposite approach would be he needs to get in touch with his operations people and make sure that they're responsible for fixing the problem. So it's a fundamental shift in responsibility and cost. And does it make sense to outsource it to a specialized provider or deal with the operational challenges of running it in-house?
7:58 Speaker 1 Yeah. It's really interesting. I um in addition to open source being offered as a service. I've also spoken about and written about um this whole notion of data center as a service, where you know you just spoke about these databases being offered as a service. And if you think about it, every part of the old on-prem ecosystem is now being made available as a service, whether it's storage, um, security, infrastructure, right? All databases, to your point, are all now being made as a service. And I'm just curious, like you guys are in this business, and you're you're absolutely you know, driving that trend.
8:45 Speaker 1 Why what is the catalyst that has made this happen now versus at some point in the past, and why are we seeing all these sort of infrastructure components now being offered in the cloud? And you know, what's driving that trend?
9:05 Speaker 0 Yeah, there are a few things that are coming together at the same time. So we have uh virtualization that really came out in the mid-2000s and became uh mainstream. I think that really sparked a lot of change in in the uh the in the data center industry.
9:25 Speaker 1 Okay, virtualization kind of became mainstream. So what? Like what did that do to catalyze this on-prem to off-prem movement? Because I think you're on to something, and I'd love for you to clarify that.
9:38 Speaker 0 Yeah, well, part of the issue became that you have this uh substantially larger infrastructure to manage because now a single physical machine could run a hundred virtual machines. And so organizations or businesses needed to become much better at managing uh all of these. systems that they're deploying. And what happened is the open source community caught up to this need and they built a whole bunch of tools that allow that provisioning process to work a lot smoother. So now you can actually provision these machines on the fly. You can maintain them inside of uh some type of inventory management system and you have full control and visibility over what's happening. So virtualization created the opportunity for more servers to exist than there are physically in the world and then the open source tools came along to allow you to manage that effect effectively and I think those are are pretty big catalysts to drive the beginning for you know this utility type of model where
10:43 Speaker 1 people can
10:43 Speaker 0 come in and because the part of the problem is in the old world essentially you would typically provision one dedicated server per customer and you wouldn't always have a need for the full resources that the machine provides. So there was a mismatch between what the service provider sells and then what the customer needs. And so by virtualizing it and being able to deliver a much smaller slice you've now matched supply and and demand and that allowed people to really consume these you know services on a as needed basis because the tools and the technology enabled provisioning of really thin slices in an automated fashion and everything kind of just you know supported it supported itself.
11:30 Speaker 0 Whereas in the old model you have people that would get a phone call and being told hey we need you to go ahead and brack and stack a server with this many processors, this much memory and these disks that doesn't really allow this automated approach to work.
11:48 Speaker 1 Interesting so this fluidity of sort of the back end system as enabled by virtual machines really created this operational model that that worked very well for multiple customers getting maximum use out of the out of the system in the back end and that's probably that you know that's what you're saying is really the catalyst. That's yeah it's also
12:15 Speaker 0 interesting it's also interesting to note that in this particular case uh both extremes are serviced really well by this model in terms that a really small customer can now get started and enjoy the benefits of a world class enterprise infrastructure you know for for just a few cents an hour and at the same time a large scale enterprise can really scale out their operation without incurring all the CapX requirements that go into building out a a huge data center. And more importantly as business dynamics change and and the workload changes they can quickly adjust you know in a matter of seconds rather than being stuck with hundreds of machines that they no longer have a use for so it created a lot of efficiency from you know from a small customer all the way into the into the enterprise.
13:10 Speaker 1 Yeah. Yeah. Let's maybe shift gears a little bit and um talk about kind of the needs of the developer. I mean your business is really um you know kind of anchored around a large large number of developers using your cloud to you know do their work why wouldn't developers just go to a you know sort of standard public cloud why have a developer oriented cloud what are the differences and um you know what happens over the course of time do the developers continue to use a developer specific cloud or move to something more generic. I'm just sort of curious how you think about different and then can we envision different clouds for different verticals maybe developers what you guys are doing but we have you know a cloud for uh uh rocket scientists right and you know right I don't know you know
14:09 Speaker 0 designers yeah
14:10 Speaker 1 exactly so like how do you think about that and I'm just sort of curious how you see the world evolving and you know kind of the importance of having a developer oriented cloud versus a generic cloud and how um you know how you guys think about that
14:26 Speaker 0 yeah well prior prior to digital ocean we feel that there was just the uh generic cloud and the analogy that we like to use is the you know today's cloud providers are really focused on the uh technology and they present that to their users in the most direct manner possible and what that allows for is kind of what we spoke about previously this really large scale out infrastructure to develop it gives you all the non-obs and control that you would need to take over obviously there's a bunch of operational work that that the customer the user needs to um uh needs to do in order to take advantage of this uh public generic cloud but there's no limit to what they can accomplish the challenge that comes up is it's just as as you build larger and larger scaling systems the complexity increases linearly if not even exponentially uh to deliver that to to the market so what we recognize is that there was an opportunity for us to focus on on people rather than on technology and because at the end of the day everyone is using the same virtualization engines there are two or three popular ones and it's kind of like you know Silicon used to build processors no one has a substantially faster CPU than anyone else uh you know today and the same thing happens in virtualization everyone's virtualization engine is is fairly similar in its capabilities and in its performance and so it boils down to what what are what are the core values that you're focusing on and as I mentioned most cloud providers today are trying to focus on technology and they think by introducing the next feature introducing the next service they can win a substantial part of the market and that is fairly that is a fairly accurate statement.
16:29 Speaker 0 What they don't realize is that there's an opportunity to focus on on the people and who actually uses cloud and and hosted infrastructure well developers right they are one of the fastest growing segments of of users online. There are 20 million developers worldwide today and that grows at a couple million people per year and what we realized is that the actual human experience of trying to wrangle that infrastructure is is very painful. And that's the problem that VigilOcean tries to solve is by presenting a simple intuitive easy to use interface to bring that infrastructure under control. We use the same virtualization engines as the other clouds but where we spend a lot of our time is on designing the interface so that people can go ahead and provision these systems rather than it taking large enterprises and large teams of ops people and and software engineers to figure out well how do I build the auto scaling group and how do I manage these thousands of servers across multiple regions what DigitalOcean is setting out to do is providing the easiest way for people to manage that without having to hire even more people to run to run their operations in the cloud.
17:54 Speaker 1 Against that backdrop could you imagine other vertically oriented public clouds or other you know other folks out there could you imagine something you know beyond developers let's say not for digital ocean but in the industry in general does the clo does the public cloud verticalize around around people as you're saying like you guys have done or is there only one which is developers and then there's everyone else
18:23 Speaker 0 I think there's opportunity for other verticals to exist and depending on how far you want to stretch the cloud analogy you could say that companies such as uh uh Squarespace or or VIX you know these companies that provide uh build your website in the cloud using these tools you know they cater to a specific segment of the market as well but they're certainly not an infrastructure provider they're more of uh of a cloud website if is you know if if I may use that term um and and if we even even if we go back to infrastructure itself I think that there is an opportunity for for another focus to exist but it has to be so fundamental in order for it
19:13 Speaker 1 to
19:14 Speaker 0 create uh a real connection with the users and to stand out right if we say that current cloud pro the generic providers are focused on technology and we all use that um and we focus on people and obviously all customers are people at the end of the day even if it's a large enterprise like like Nike there's still someone that's making that decision um finding another bucket uh that's as fundamental as those two I think is possible but there aren't many of them and you know it takes a lot of thought and a lot of focus and what winds up happening quite often is that these buckets actually exist many times over but they're so small that in the grand scheme of things we We are not aware of these companies.
20:03 Speaker 0 So is there a third large bucket that a infrastructure provider could focus on? I like to think that there's always an opportunity to innovate to figure out the next step. You know, when we were building DigitalOcean in uh 2011, this is the dilemma that we face. How do we uh how do we build a company that stands out in the sea of all the other clouds that already exist? And it took us many months uh to be able to figure out our position around around simplicity and focusing on on users that are developers. So I think if someone else took the time out to uh really digest the market and understand what's happening, there is certainly an opportunity for for a new entrance.
20:50 Speaker 0 The the challenge is that quite often we find companies reacting to existing competition or or to market conditions rather than being able to pierce through that uh you know fog and and and truly create something new.
21:05 Speaker 1 Yeah. Let me um just sort of in rapid fire here some competing things you know we talk about internally. Linux containers or virtual or or uh virtualization. What do you think in the future?
21:20 Speaker 0 In the future. Uh not
21:22 Speaker 1 too distant future.
21:24 Speaker 0 You know, Linux containers started started the whole trend. Uh there's this uh a bunch of talks nowadays about the hypervisor is dead. Uh I don't think we're there just yet. Uh containers have a very poor security model, and that's really what's holding us back, but they're certainly more lightweight. The real uh difference between the two is the container has to take on the properties of its parent hypervisor. So you're very restricted. You can't today run a Windows container inside of a Linux server. Right. And that's what virtualization allows you to do. So it kind of depends on the use case, but for general public cloud computing, um, I think the container is the future. We just need to fix the security model.
22:08 Speaker 1 Okay. Uh flash versus spinning disk.
22:11 Speaker 0 Well, flash, I think that's a no-brainer.
22:14 Speaker 1 Okay, so disk goes away completely.
22:18 Speaker 0 I think disk is great for uh archival and and backup media because of its cheap cost and and fairly good performance and reliability, especially in low I.O. environments. So I'd say, you know, second-tier long long-term storage.
22:37 Speaker 1 So desk becomes the new tape.
22:39 Speaker 0 Yeah.
22:40 Speaker 1 Okay. Intel or ARM?
22:43 Speaker 0 Intel, I wouldn't bet against them.
22:46 Speaker 1 Okay. Fair enough. There you go. Well, good. Um with that, uh, Ben, thanks a lot. Um, we're gonna you know, call it a wrap. And um I'll have you on at some point again. I'll love to uh see how all
23:00 Speaker 0 this materializes in the future. So uh we'll talk with you soon. Thanks.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated