Skip to content

West Virginia v. B.P.J.

5-4

Hosted by Michael Liroff and Peter Shamshiri

1h 2m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

The hosts dissect the Supreme Court's 6-3 decision in West Virginia v. BPJ, which upheld the state's Save Women's Sports Act banning transgender girls from girls' sports teams. The case centered on a 12-year-old cross-country runner, identified as BPJ, who was barred from trying out for her sixth-grade team even though every other applicant made it. The hosts argue the law was a moral panic: in five years, West Virginia identified only one trans girl wanting to play, and the Idaho law consolidated into the case was passed when the state's attorney general claimed female athletes had become "bystanders in their own sports" despite no non-trans women being affected.

They walk through each opinion in detail. Kavanaugh's majority opinion, they say, relies on a historically false narrative that trans participation in sports is a recent phenomenon, when the IOC allowed trans athletes in 2004 and the NCAA in 2011. The "zero-sum" argument that a trans girl takes a spot from a cis girl is undercut by the fact that BPJ's team had no cuts. Thomas's concurrence is described as "rank bigotry," calling trans people a mental illness. Sotomayor's dissent references VMI to argue the blanket ban fails narrow tailoring, and Jackson's separate opinion pokes at whether "sex" in Title IX can mean only biological sex.

The episode closes by contrasting the public's absurdist perception of what trans athletes want with BPJ's actual narrow ask: she never experienced male puberty, so the purported biological advantages don't apply to her. Michael Liroff notes that fewer than 2% of high school athletes receive college scholarships, making the "stealing spots" panic a statistical nullity.

  • The West Virginia law affected only one 12-year-old girl in five years, making it a moral panic rather than a response to a real problem. 5:32
  • The IOC allowed trans athletes in 2004 and the NCAA in 2011, so the first state ban in 2020 was a reaction to a moral panic, not to a new phenomenon. 17:27
  • BPJ's legal position was narrow: she never experienced male puberty, so the biological advantages the state cited did not apply to her specifically. 15:37
  • Fewer than 2% of high school athletes receive any college scholarship, and with only a handful of trans kids in sports versus 200,000 NCAA scholarships, the competitive harm is a statistical nullity. 56:32
  • West Virginia's previous policy since 2016 used case-by-case assessment with an appeals process, not a blanket ban, undermining the claim that only categorical exclusion would work. 38:08

Highlights

  • 5:32

    One Person in Five Yearsinsight

    Michael compares the case to Masterpiece Bake Shop, noting the West Virginia law has only impacted one person in a five-year period, calling it a "right wing boogeyman" moral panic.

  • 7:41

    No Non-Trans Women Affected in Idahodata

    Peter points out that when Idaho's attorney general claimed female athletes had become "bystanders in their own sports," there were actually no non-trans women playing in Idaho sports.

  • 10:23

    Alito Asks If Opponents Are Bigotsdebate

    During oral arguments, Justice Alito asked whether female athletes opposed to trans participation are "bigots," which the hosts note is not a legal question but culture war commentary.

  • 17:27

    The Actual Timeline of Trans Sportsinsight

    The hosts lay out that the IOC allowed trans athletes in 2004, the NCAA in 2011, and the first state ban did not appear until Idaho in 2020, contradicting Kavanaugh's "recent years" framing.

  • 23:05

    The Gap Between Perception and Realityinsight

    Peter argues the public imagines trans athletes want to "switch genders and participate in 8th grade girls' track," when BPJ's actual ask was simply to run on a team where no one got cut.

  • 30:51

    Thomas's Concurrence Called Rank Bigotrydebate

    Michael reads from Thomas's concurrence, which states "men and boys with gender dysphoria are not women or girls" and calls sex "an immutable biological characteristic" that is "binary."

  • 38:08

    The Previous Case-by-Case Policystrategy

    Sotomayor's dissent notes the ban replaced a 2016 policy allowing case-by-case assessment with an appeals process, undermining the claim that only a blanket ban would work.

  • 56:32

    Scholarship Odds Are Statistical Nullitydata

    Michael notes fewer than 2% of high school athletes get any college scholarship, and with only a handful of trans kids in sports versus 200,000 NCAA scholarships, the competitive harm is statistically meaningless.

About this episode

The Supreme Court backs West Virginia in banning it's only openly trans student athlete from the girls cross country team. If you're not a 5-4 Premium member, you're not hearing every episode! To hear this and other Premium-only episodes, get access to our Slack community, and more, join at fivefourpod.com/support http://fivefourpod.com/support. 5 to 4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Allison Rodgers. Leon Neyfakh provides editorial support. Our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations. Our Sponsors: * Check out Mint Mobile and use my code mintmobile.com/fivefour for a great deal: https://www.mintmobile.com * Check out Quince and use my code FIVEFOUR for a great deal: https://www.quince.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Transcript

0:00
1:02:08

10,410 words · 5 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Trans Rights
  • Supreme Court
  • Equal Protection
  • Title IX
  • Youth Sports
  • Gender Discrimination
  • Constitutional Law
  • Moral Panic

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated