Skip to content

The Supreme Court v. The First Step Act

5-4

Hosted by Michael Liroff and Peter Shamshiri

41m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

The episode covers two Supreme Court cases decided the same day: Fernandez v. United States and Rutherford v. United States, both concerning the compassionate release provision of the First Step Act, the bipartisan criminal justice reform law signed in 2018. In Fernandez, the Court held that a prisoner's claim of innocence is not an extraordinary and compelling reason for compassionate release because such claims must be brought through habeas corpus. In Rutherford, the Court held that sentencing disparities created by the First Step Act's reduced mandatory minimums do not qualify as extraordinary and compelling reasons for release. Amy Coney Barrett wrote the majority in both cases. The hosts argue the decisions effectively gut the compassionate release provision by grafting habeas analysis onto a statute designed to operate on different logic, with Justice Kagan's dissent drawing a sharp line: habeas nullifies a conviction as a matter of law, while compassionate release shortens a sentence as a matter of grace.

  • The First Step Act changed compassionate release so prisoners can file their own motions for release rather than relying on the Bureau of Prisons to request it. 7:40
  • Justice Kagan's dissent distinguishes the two mechanisms: habeas nullifies a conviction as a matter of law, while compassionate release shortens a sentence as a matter of grace. 19:58
  • The Sentencing Commission's 2023 guidance specifically stated that sentencing disparities created by changes in the law can be considered for compassionate release, even if rarely. 28:45
  • Rutherford was sentenced to 42 years for armed robberies in which no one was hurt, taking about $1,300 and a watch; under the First Step Act the minimum would have been 14 years. 23:50
  • Trump never publicly criticized the Supreme Court for weakening the First Step Act, unlike his outbursts over the tariff cases, suggesting the law was purely a political gesture. 37:55

Highlights

  • 7:53

    Fernandez's Innocence Claimstory

    Joe Fernandez was convicted in 2013 of murdering two rival gang members based on his co-conspirator's testimony. He has maintained his innocence for 13 years, arguing the co-conspirator framed him to protect his brother.

  • 10:06

    Barrett's Habeas Graftinginsight

    Barrett's majority holds that innocence claims must go through habeas corpus, not compassionate release. The hosts find the logic incoherent: if you can challenge your imprisonment through another law, that does not make your case less compelling.

  • 17:06

    Kagan's Statutory Analysisinsight

    Kagan argues that extraordinary and compelling are measures of degree, not type. Congress only excluded rehabilitation as a category; everything else is a matter of degree. She also distinguishes compassionate release from habeas on multiple grounds including the remedy and the standard of review.

  • 19:39

    Grace Versus Lawinsight

    Kagan's dissent draws the line: habeas nullifies a conviction as a matter of law, while compassionate release shortens a sentence as a matter of grace. The two are not mutually exclusive and should not be conflated.

  • 23:47

    Decades of Unnecessary Imprisonmentdata

    Rutherford was sentenced to 42 years for armed robberies in which no one was hurt, taking about $1,300 and a watch. Under the First Step Act, the minimum would have been 14 years. Carter's sentence would have dropped from 70 to 21 years.

  • 28:06

    Sentencing Commission's 2023 Guidancestrategy

    The Sentencing Commission's 2023 guidance specifically stated that sentencing disparities created by changes in the law can be considered for compassionate release, even if rarely. Sotomayor argues this is the end of the analysis and the Court should not override it.

  • 32:59

    Narrowing Judicial Discretiondebate

    Michael Liroff argues the conservative justices are acting as petty tyrants of the judiciary, systematically narrowing discretion at every level to prevent liberal judges and agencies from making decisions they disagree with, regardless of statutory text.

  • 37:06

    Trump's Political Gestureinsight

    The hosts note the First Step Act was the only woke thing Trump did, spearheaded by Jared Kushner. Trump never criticized the Court for weakening it, unlike his public outbursts over the tariff cases, suggesting it was purely a political gesture.

About this episode

In two cases this term, federal inmates sought their freedom based on compassionate release, an early release process that was expanded under the 2018 First Step Act. The Supreme Court denied both requests. If you're not a 5-4 Premium member, you're not hearing every episode! To hear this and other Premium-only episodes, access to our Slack community, and more, join at fivefourpod.com/support http://fivefourpod.com/support. 5-4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Alli Rodgers. Leon Neyfakh provides editorial support. Our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations. Transcriptions of each episode are available at fivefourpod.com http://fivefourpod.com Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On BlueSky, find Peter @notalawyer.bsky.social, Michael @fleerultra.bsky.social, and Rhiannon @aywarhiannon.bsky.social. Our Sponsors: * Check out Mint Mobile and use my code mintmobile.com/fivefour for a great deal: https://www.mintmobile.com * Check out Quince and use my code FIVEFOUR for a great deal: https://www.quince.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Transcript

0:00
41:13

6,751 words · 4 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Compassionate Release
  • First Step Act
  • Habeas Corpus
  • Criminal Justice Reform
  • Supreme Court
  • Sentencing Guidelines
  • Judicial Discretion

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated