Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Pulsifer v. United States (2024) asks whether the word "and" in a First Step Act provision means "and" or "or." Mark Pulsifer, convicted of a federal drug offense before the 2018 Act, sought resentencing under its points-based system. The statute exempts defendants from mandatory minimums if they lack more than four criminal history points, a prior three-point offense, and a prior two-point violent offense. Pulsifer had the first two but not the third, so the plain text should exempt him. Justice Kagan's majority opinion read "and" as "or," making him ineligible, relying on a redundancy argument and a quote from The Very Hungry Caterpillar. Justice Gorsuch dissented, red-lining the statute to show how much the majority was rewriting it, and noting that criminal history points expire after 10 or 15 years, so the redundancy argument fails.
The hosts also situate the case within the broader failure of mandatory minimums, which doubled the federal prison population in the 1980s without reducing crime. They note the First Step Act's limited scope—it applies only to federal cases sentenced under mandatory minimum schemes—and that in its first year roughly 3,000 people were released. A federal public defender they reference describes cases where no one was hurt yet defendants face 10 to 15 years. The episode closes with the observation that the rule of lenity, which says ambiguous criminal laws should favor the defendant, is essentially never applied by courts.
- The First Step Act's mandatory minimum exemption requires a defendant to lack all three listed conditions, but the Supreme Court read the connecting "and" as "or," making defendants like Pulsifer ineligible for resentencing. 14:36
- Criminal history points expire after 10 or 15 years, so a defendant can have qualifying offenses but zero criminal history points, undermining the majority's redundancy argument. 26:13
- The rule of lenity, which directs courts to interpret ambiguous criminal statutes in favor of the defendant, is essentially never applied in practice. 22:52
- Mandatory minimums failed to reduce crime but doubled the federal prison population in the years after their introduction in the 1980s, with most new inmates serving nonviolent drug sentences. 40:11
- In the first year after the First Step Act's passage, approximately 3,000 people were released from federal prison, but the Act's applicability remains narrow and the DOJ argued for reincarcerating some of those released. 45:30
Highlights
- 14:36
The And Versus Or Questioninsight
Peter Shamshiri explains the core legal question: the statute says no mandatory minimum unless the defendant has all three conditions, but the government argues "and" secretly means "or."
- 16:08
Kagan Reads And As Orinsight
Peter Shamshiri lays out Justice Kagan's majority reasoning: the statute says "and" but the court will read it as "or" because of a perceived redundancy in the text.
- 20:51
The Very Hungry Caterpillar Citestory
Justice Kagan quotes The Very Hungry Caterpillar to make a textual point about how introductory phrases distribute across list items. Michael Liroff calls it "wildly offensive in this context."
- 25:26
Gorsuch Red-Lines the Statutestrategy
Michael Liroff describes how Gorsuch's dissent takes the statute text, crosses out portions, and inserts bolded replacements to show exactly how much the majority is rewriting the law.
- 26:13
Criminal History Points Expiredata
Michael Liroff explains that criminal history points drop off after 10 or 15 years, so a defendant can have a three-point and two-point offense but zero total points, defeating the redundancy argument.
- 38:26
Terry v. United States Limitsdata
A host describes how in Terry v. United States, a man sentenced to 15 years for crack cocaine possession was denied First Step Act relief because he wasn't sentenced under a mandatory minimum, and Sotomayor called for Congress to expand the Act.
- 40:11
Mandatory Minimums Doubled Prison Populationdata
Michael Liroff notes that in the few years after mandatory minimums were introduced in the 1980s, the federal prison population doubled, with the vast majority of new inmates serving nonviolent drug offenses.
- 45:30
Public Defender on Federal Sentencingstory
A host relays what a federal public defender friend said: in the vast majority of her cases no one was hurt, yet clients face 10 to 15 years, and the DOJ argued for reincarcerating people released under the First Step Act.
About this episode
What does “and” REALLY mean? If you're not a 5-4 Premium member, you're not hearing every episode! To hear this and other Premium-only episodes, access to our Slack community, and more, join at fivefourpod.com/support http://fivefourpod.com/support. 5-4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Alli Rodgers. Leon Neyfakh provides editorial support. Our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations. Transcriptions of each episode are available at fivefourpod.com http://fivefourpod.com Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On BlueSky, find Peter @notalawyer.bsky.social, Michael @fleerultra.bsky.social, and Rhiannon @aywarhiannon.bsky.social. Our Sponsors: * Check out Mint Mobile and use my code mintmobile.com/fivefour for a great deal: https://www.mintmobile.com * Check out Quince and use my code FIVEFOUR for a great deal: https://www.quince.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Transcript
8,262 words · 6 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Mandatory Minimums
- First Step Act
- Textual Interpretation
- Federal Sentencing
- Criminal Justice Reform
- Supreme Court
- Rule of Lenity
- Mass Incarceration
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated