Pod Insights 5-4 McMahon v. New York About this episode Don't be sad, little Johnny, Trump just took the Department of Education to live on a big farm with so much space to run around and play in, and all the treats the Department of Education could ever dream of. The Department of Education will miss you, too, Johnny, but we promise she's so much happier now.
If you're not a 5-4 Premium member, you're not hearing every episode! To hear this and other Premium-only episodes, access to our Slack community, and more, join at fivefourpod.com/support http://fivefourpod.com/support.]
5-4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Dustin DeSoto. Leon Neyfakh provides editorial support. Our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations. Transcriptions of each episode are available at fivefourpod.com http://fivefourpod.com
Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On BlueSky, find Peter @notalawyer.bsky.social, Michael @fleerultra.bsky.social, and Rhiannon @aywarhiannon.bsky.social.
Our Sponsors:
* Check out Mint Mobile and use my code mintmobile.com/fivefour for a great deal: https://www.mintmobile.com
* Check out Quince and use my code FIVEFOUR for a great deal: https://www.quince.com
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:04 Speaker 00 Hey, everyone. This is Leon from Prolog Projects. On this episode of Five to Four, Peter, Rhiannon, and Michael are talking about McMahon v. New York, a recent case about the separation of powers and the dismantling of the Department of Education. In March, Secretary of Education Linda McMahon announced the firing of 1,300 staff members in what appeared to be the first step towards carrying out an executive order from President Trump in which he called for the closure of the department. Nineteen states, along with several school districts and teachers' unions, sued the federal government, claiming the firings violated federal laws and the Constitution. The lower court ordered the employees to be reinstated.
0:47 Speaker 00 But the Trump administration appealed the case to the Supreme Court, where the conservative justices ruled to uphold the firings.
0:54 Speaker 01 The Supreme Court cleared the way for the Trump administration to carry out its plans for mass firings there. A lower court judge had previously put that plan on hold, warning that the layoffs will, quote, "likely cripple the department."
1:07 Speaker 00 This is Five to Four, a podcast about how much the Supreme Court sucks.
1:13 Peter Shamshiri? Welcome to Five to Four, where we dissect and analyze the Supreme Court cases that have left our nation wandering aimlessly like Donald Trump on the White House roof. I'm Peter. I'm here with Rhiannon. Jump, bitch. And Michael.
1:27 Speaker 03 I was gonna say, you make a joke, but that was...
1:32 Peter Shamshiri? We're always a week behind the news here, but today, as we're recording, a week before this comes out, Donald Trump was interviewed on the White House lawn, and he was just sort of rambling. And then shortly after, he just sort of appeared on the roof of the White House.
1:53 Speaker 03 And they were like yelling up to him like what he was doing and he said he was building nuclear missiles and then like mimed like with his hand like a missile watcher. Just the man unbelievable.
2:08 Peter Shamshiri? Brain fried. And I'll tell you, when I was like 15, I worked at a nursing home.
2:13 Speaker 03 Yeah.
2:13 Peter Shamshiri? And, you know, many of the people there had it fully together and many people did not.
2:18 Speaker 04 Yeah.
2:18 Peter Shamshiri? And there was like a subset of the residents there who you were aware did not have it together.
2:25 Speaker 04 Yes.
2:26 Peter Shamshiri? And every now and then, something like this would happen. Like every now and then you'd be like, what's Esther doing in the courtyard?
2:33 Speaker 03 Yeah.
2:35 Peter Shamshiri? Right? She really looks like she doesn't know what her purpose in the courtyard is. Someone should wrangle her.
2:41 Speaker 04 And if you'd ask her, she would say like, I'm building missiles.
2:43 Peter Shamshiri? She would say she was building missiles.
2:45 Speaker 04 Yeah.
2:46 Peter Shamshiri? Or something along those lines, something that didn't seem tethered to reality.
2:50 Speaker 03 Yeah.
2:52 Peter Shamshiri? Yeah. So anyway, that's what's happening to Donald Trump.
2:56 Speaker 04 Our president.
2:57 Peter Shamshiri? He is Esther in the courtyard.
2:59 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
3:00 Peter Shamshiri? Or to use one that really happened, Hope making a run for it out of the half mile long driveway out to the main road. I once saw Hope in a wheelchair, just hauling ass out to the main road. Just, she made it so far, it would shock you.
3:19 Speaker 04 Free Hope.
3:20 Peter Shamshiri? I was there for two years after. No one ever figured out how Hope got out. Today's case, McMahon v. New York. This is a case from just a few weeks back about Trump's gutting of the Department of Education. Linda McMahon of the McMahon family.
3:40 Speaker 04 Yeah, that one.
3:41 Peter Shamshiri? Who were the longtime owners of the WWE.
3:44 Speaker 04 Yep.
3:45 Peter Shamshiri? Is your secretary of the Department of Education.
3:50 Peter Shamshiri? In March, she fired over half of the department's staff. A few days later, Trump issued an executive order telling Linda to, quote, "take all necessary steps to facilitate the closure of the department." This is all very illegal, folks. The Department of Education was created by Congress and cannot be legally disbanded without congressional approval. But what are laws, right? Are they binding mandates that weigh upon politicians and elected officials? No. We've always told you they weren't real. And people are like, what do you mean?
4:26 Speaker 04 Yeah.
4:27 Peter Shamshiri? What do you mean? This is what we mean. Laws are just the idea that someone should be constrained.
4:34 Speaker 04 Yeah.
4:35 Speaker 03 Yeah.
4:35 Peter Shamshiri? And they are supported by institutional power.
4:39 Speaker 03 Right.
4:40 Peter Shamshiri? Or perhaps they aren't.
4:43 Speaker 03 What is institutional power against the weight and power of a 79-year-old man wandering around on the roof?
4:52 Speaker 04 Yeah. Who's to say?
4:53 Peter Shamshiri? What is more important? The ability of Congress to pass a law and have that law be respected? Or the whims of our roof-wandering president?
5:05 Speaker 03 Yes.
5:06 Speaker 04 That's what this case comes down to. Yeah.
5:08 Peter Shamshiri? So a district court ordered the Department of Education to reinstate the staff members that it has fired and to put a stop to any further shenanigans. But the Supreme Court, in a six-to-three shadow docket decision, lifted that order.
5:24 Speaker 04 How many of our episodes over the years have started in some form in the introduction with Peter going, "This is all very illegal," you know? That's what we're here. It's a legal podcast about all the illegal stuff that the right wing in America does and how the Supreme Court gives it the thumbs up, you know? So let's go through some of Trump's attacks on the Department of Education. Why is this guy doing this, you know? Back when he was campaigning for a second term, he was already talking, of course, we all remember, about dismantling the Department of Education on the premise that education in the United States should be controlled by the states, not the federal government.
6:07 Speaker 04 No mind, doesn't matter that states' school boards already control their own curriculums. By and large, the federal government doesn't do that, but whatever, you know? Get rid of it. Get rid of the Department of Education. At the time, again, when he was campaigning for a second term, Trump's proposed reforms to education, kind of like broadly in the United States, included prayer in public schools, expanding parental rights in education, patriotism as the centerpiece of education, and emphasis on the quote unquote "American way of life" in public schooling, without really defining what that means. But, you know, we can infer. Also proposed, of course, and we see this being rolled out
6:49 Speaker 04 through the Department of Education and through the Trump administration in other various ways, dismantling, of course, diversity initiatives in education and federal funding cuts for schools that feature quote unquote "critical race theory", "gender ideology", or other inappropriate racial, sexual, or political content. You know, we're talking about government censorship here, thought police, and attacks on racial minorities and LGBTQ people, basically like existing in public, right? It's the whole gamut. We've been talking about it for months because the Trump administration has been up to this for months in this second term. But it's also, we should be noting, it's also about Christianization and privatization.
7:33 Speaker 04 You know, legislation at the state level across the country includes stuff that like is in line, running parallel with what the Trump administration is doing. You know, includes school choice and school voucher programs where public schooling funds are diverted to private schooling and homeschooling. Texas just passed a law requiring that the Ten Commandments be put up in every public school classroom. It's a lot of stupid, stupid bullshit. Penn America did a study that found that more than 10,000 books had been removed from library shelves in the 2023-2024 school year. There's a theme here, people, you know? This is what the Trump administration is doing with a big, you know,
8:16 Speaker 04 cherry on top of dismantling, dissolving the Department of Education. One side note, I was looking at like speeches during the Trump campaign. He also, or interviews, and he also said at one point that he was gonna fund a free college called the American Academy, and it would be funded by taxing, fining, and suing private universities. It's good stuff. Anyways.
8:41 Speaker 04 Great plans. He was walking around a roof, you know, when he came up with that one. So you have all this right wing meat and potatoes culture war stuff in terms of like drumming up reactionary populist fervor for these things. But there's also a layer of like this almost like theater, this politics of reducing the size of the federal government. Doge, efficiency, killing big brother, killing the federal government, stealing money, taxpayer money from you. This kind of thing. So in early March, Secretary of Education Linda McMahon initiated what's called a RIF, R I F, a reduction in force, where the Department of Education announced the firing of about 1,300 people.
9:26 Speaker 04 Now, it was 1,300 people being put on administrative leave, firing them, but including also sort of voluntary resignations and buyouts. And the Department of Education pulling funding for what had been like temporary positions. In total, this was reducing the Department of Education's staff by 2,000 people. That is nearly 50% of the Department of Education's workforce. When announcing that riff, Linda McMahon said, quote, "Today's reduction in force reflects the Department of Education's commitment to efficiency, accountability, and ensuring that resources are directed where they matter most, to students, parents, and teachers.
10:07 Speaker 04 I appreciate the work of the dedicated public servants and their contributions to the department. This is a significant step toward restoring the greatness of the United States education system." Getting rid of it, you know?
10:20 Peter Shamshiri? Right. Well, it used to be a lot better. There's actually evidence of this. You'll hear right wingers say it. Did you know that SAT scores have gone down after the creation of the Department of Education? Haters will say that's because more people are taking it now, because more people are going to college. Don't listen to them. All right. Don't listen to them.
10:39 Speaker 04 Don't listen to them. In 1920.
10:43 Speaker 04 School was better for your kids. Yeah. That was the ideal moment in schooling. Yeah. Before the New Deal state. Yeah, exactly. Now, following that riff announced by the Department of Education, on March 20th, just over a week later, Trump signed an executive order titled, "Improving Education Outcomes by Empowering Parents, States, and Communities." It directs the Department of Education, it directs the Secretary of Education, "to take all necessary steps to facilitate the closure of the Department of Education and return education authority to the states." Now, could you read the title of that order again? Improving Education Outcomes by Empowering Parents, States, and Communities. Hmm.
11:27 Speaker 04 Again, explicit in the text here, facilitate the closure of the Department of Education. Wanted to make a note, I think people probably remember if you saw the signing ceremony for this executive order, Trump was like surrounded by like a bunch of like school age children, like little, little kids. Of course, classic, classic move. Just wanted to note at the signing ceremony, bunch of governors there, bunch of governors traveled to that signing ceremony. Ron DeSantis of Florida, Greg Abbott of Texas, Mike Braun of Indiana, Kim Reynolds of Iowa, Jeff Landry of Louisiana, and Mike DeWine of Ohio, just there to watch the signing ceremony for dismantling the Department of Education. On the day that Trump signed that executive order,
12:11 Speaker 04 he speaks during the signing ceremony, he's also doing interviews right after. He says, quote, "Today, we take a historic action that was 45 years in the making. We will begin eliminating the Federal Department of Education." Later on that day, he says, "We're going to eliminate it. Everybody knows it's right. We want to return our students to the states. We're just some of the governors here are so happy about this. They want education to come back to them, to come back to the states, and they're going to do a phenomenal job." Walking around on the roof, you know?
12:43 Peter Shamshiri? Yeah.
12:44 Speaker 04 The next day, on March 21st, he announced that programs for students with special needs and the federal student loan portfolio, these are all things that are administered by the Department of Education, and we'll get more into that in a little bit. He announced that those programs would be transferred from the Department of Education to the Department of Health and Human Services and the Small Business Administration. So, moving things around in stupid ways. So, how do we get this case? Plaintiff, this is a group of 19 states led by New York as well as DC, two public school districts and several teachers' unions. They went to federal court in Massachusetts,
13:26 Speaker 04 and they're arguing that the RIF, that original reduction in force that was implemented by the Department of Education in which, you know, over 1,300 employees were fired, that that violates both the Constitution and federal laws that govern administrative agencies, the power of administrative agencies, the power of Congress to give power to administrative agencies. And so, that first federal court in Massachusetts, that judge did order the reinstatement of those 1,300 employees. You gotta give them their jobs back. This is illegal. Of course, Linda McMahon, the federal government,
14:09 Speaker 04 appealed that, and that's how we get to the Supreme Court.
14:12 Peter Shamshiri? All right, so let's talk about the law here. The most fundamental issue here is that Congress created the Department of Education by statute, the Department of Education Organization Act, back in 1979. The president cannot unilaterally dismantle it because the president cannot simply nullify an existing law on a whim, right? That would violate the law itself. It would also violate the constitutional separation of powers. If you zoom in a little bit, the Department of Education has within it various different entities. Congress has prohibited the Secretary of Education from abolishing organizational entities established in the originating statute
14:55 Peter Shamshiri? from 1979. And then there's also some entities within the Department of Education that the Secretary of Education can get rid of, but only if they follow certain procedures, which McMahon did not do. But again, all of that is just a technical way of saying the Department of Education, created by Congress, only Congress can dismantle it.
15:14 Speaker 04 Yeah.
15:15 Peter Shamshiri? Trump's executive order is therefore flagrantly unconstitutional. Any executive action taken with the intent of dismantling the Department of Education is unconstitutional. And any executive action taken that deprives the Department of the ability to fulfill its statutory obligations is unconstitutional.
15:34 Speaker 04 And there's no question about the intent. Again, he's saying we're dismantling the Department of Education.
15:38 Peter Shamshiri? It's in the order. It's in the order, right? So you have this sort of twofold argument where, one, these actions are designed to fulfill an unconstitutional goal. And, two, they are depriving the Department of the resources it needs to actually function as Congress intended it to function.
15:56 Speaker 04 Yeah.
15:57 Peter Shamshiri? So, like many cases lately, there is no opinion here. This is a shadow docket, procedural order. It dropped after the term technically ended. The court doesn't explain itself. So what do we know here? Well, it's a procedural order. The court is not technically saying that this is all constitutional, but the lower court had halted the termination of the education employees and ordered the reinstatement of anyone who was fired. The Supreme Court is lifting that court order. So this decision is allowing the firings to proceed. So technically, the Supreme Court could, in the future, say, oh, yeah, the executive order is unconstitutional. But the damage has already been done.
16:42 Peter Shamshiri? They've allowed Trump to gut the Department.
16:45 Speaker 04 Right.
16:46 Peter Shamshiri? And we've now seen this basic tactic over and over again, where the court Ignores the constitutional issue and just intervenes to allow the Trump administration to implement the policy.
16:58 Speaker 04 Yeah.
16:58 Peter Shamshiri? We saw it in the birthright citizenship case, for example, basically saying, hey, we're not ruling on whether this policy is constitutional. We're just saying that Trump can implement it while courts figure it out.
17:09 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
17:10 Peter Shamshiri? Right? This allows them to give Trump the win without, you know, technically giving him the win. So again, no opinion here. We don't know exactly why the courts conservatives decided to stay the court order. I should rephrase that. We do know why, but we don't know what their explanation would have been.
17:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, we don't know what they're saying about why, because they don't say anything.
17:34 Peter Shamshiri? Right. So we do have some hints via the briefs submitted to the court by the Trump administration. Those briefs don't really argue for the constitutionality of the action. They don't say, hey, this is all constitutional, probably because that would be kind of a waste of time, I think. What they do is they talk about standing, right? The idea that the people who are suing don't have the right to sue because they're not injured or they're not injured directly enough. They talk about the court's jurisdiction over personnel decisions. This is something that sort of fits into the unitary executive concept, the idea that they believe that courts shouldn't be able to interfere with the president's staffing decisions within the executive branch.
18:16 Peter Shamshiri? They talk about reinstatement not being a proper remedy here. So those are the sorts of arguments we were seeing the Trump administration make. It seems like a decent guess that the court would try to hang their hat on standing here. But I think it's worth looking at a similarly situated case from the Biden administration. Biden attempted a few years back to issue a moderate amount of student loan relief, if you recall. We did an episode on the resulting Supreme Court case, Biden v. Nebraska. Biden's effort was challenged by some states that had very questionable claims to standing, probably more questionable than the plaintiffs in this case. But there, the court prevented the administration
19:00 Peter Shamshiri? from implementing the plan while the case was being decided. So you have two policies being challenged. In both cases, the administration says, hey, the challenging party doesn't have standing. With Biden, the court blocks the policy. With Trump, they let it proceed. Simple enough. I don't think you're going to get much clearer than this.
19:19 Speaker 04 Yeah.
19:20 Peter Shamshiri? And once again, very similar to birthright citizenship, the substantive issue that they're dodging here is an extremely simple one. Everyone knows that Trump cannot unilaterally abolish the Department of Education. So why can't the court just say that? To use the student loan case as an example again, the court struck down Biden's student loan plan because there was no clear authorization from Congress, it said. Now, it couldn't be more obvious that there's no clear authorization from Congress to shut down the Department of Education.
19:56 Speaker 03 They literally put in the law, you can't shut down the Department of Education.
19:59 Peter Shamshiri? It says in the law, you can't do this. So like, what kind of fucking transparent charade is this? Like, who were they trying to fool with this bullshit? It's just exhausting. It's just a waste of time. And I feel a lot of people complain about the lack of an opinion. And they're like, they should be forced to explain themselves. And I think we've talked about this before. But I'm like, who cares? Who cares what kind of fucking bullshit they would have used to justify this?
20:28 Speaker 04 Right.
20:28 Peter Shamshiri? Right? Should they have to work more? Sure. But what's the point? What's the point of reading this? This is like, you have, you have someone in your life who's a serial gaslighter and manipulator, right? Does letting them explain themselves help?
20:42 Speaker 04 It doesn't do anything. Yeah.
20:44 Peter Shamshiri? No.
20:45 Speaker 03 I also just think there are a bunch of annoying legal pedants whose entire mode of operating is to parrot at you what the Supreme Court said. And they have nothing here, right?
20:58 Peter Shamshiri? Yeah.
20:59 Speaker 03 And that's nice. They can't be annoying in my mentions, which is the most important thing.
21:05 Speaker 04 Yeah. And for the, for the libs, for like lib commentators, you know, who are saying that they should have to explain themselves in every case and every shadow docket decision. You know, it's like, for what? So that you can then like, take them in good faith and sort of argue and be like, oh yeah, actually that's kind of reasonable. When it's ridiculous, right? We talked about this in the birthright citizenship context, where a bunch of people turned around from that decision. And we're telling you that, oh yeah, this is actually kind of a good, a good decision about nationwide injunctions, because nationwide injunctions are bad. It's just like, yeah, no, it's kind of, it's kind of on the lack of an explanation here.
21:48 Speaker 04 The lack of an opinion here to justify the ridiculousness, the absurdity actually is sort of mask off in its own way, you know?
21:57 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's more honest about what's going on here than if they wrote something. And it's more illuminating about what's going on here than if they wrote something.
22:05 Speaker 04 Right.
22:06 Speaker 03 So there is a dissent. There's a 19 page dissent, medium length, I'd say, from Sotomayor, joined by the two other liberal justices. It's a mixed bag. I think there's some good stuff in there. There's some stuff missing and there's some bad stuff in there is what I'd say, an archetypal mixed bag. So the good stuff, I think, is she does a very nice job of highlighting, one, like, the specific correspondence between like, offices within the department that are just completely gone, that couldn't be, by statute, were forbidden from being eliminated. She also does a nice job of illustrating the way this has immediate impacts.
22:51 Speaker 03 She notes one college that required.
22:56 Speaker 03 Recertification for financial assistance for federal financial aid. And instead of taking the average seven weeks for that to happen with the reduced staff, it took 18 or 19 weeks. In that time period, their spring enrollment period came and went. And so they weren't able to enroll people on federal financial aid, which was 80% of their incoming class. So all of a sudden, 80% of their students are not there. They're losing tuition as a result. Like, that's devastating. That's absolutely devastating. What's missing, I think, is the flip side of that, which is, what about those kids?
23:40 Speaker 03 She doesn't, she doesn't talk about the kids who are all of a sudden not enrolled in college. You know, like, that's a major fucking problem for them, too. Because she's talking about it in a way of like, this gives us standing. This is a real harm here that should give this school standing. But it's missing, I think, something humanizing and real. She does a good job of also highlighting how lazy the government is being, how they don't rebut any of these, you know, factual findings from the district court. They don't try to argue that it's legal, right?
24:20 Speaker 03 She's sort of like, look, we all, we can all see what's going on here. And she doesn't say this, but implicitly, I think what it highlights is how very different this is from Trump one. I think if you go back and listen to like, our episode on Trump v. Hawaii, for example, we talked a lot about-
24:40 Speaker 04 The Muslim ban case.
24:41 Speaker 03 Yeah, the Muslim ban case. We talked a lot about how the court put them through their paces and made them keep coming back with better versions of arguments and better versions of the order until they were satisfied with something that they felt was like, facially plausible.
24:57 Speaker 04 Yeah.
24:58 Speaker 03 Even though everybody knew it was a Muslim ban, and that was the intention and that was like the desired effect, you know, they could say with a straight face, it's not a Muslim ban. And then here, you know, they're like, whatever, fucking fire half the DOE, that's fine.
25:15 Peter Shamshiri? Right.
25:15 Speaker 04 Yeah.
25:15 Speaker 03 Like go wild.
25:17 Speaker 04 Yeah.
25:17 Speaker 03 What bothers me about this opinion is very early on, she's describing in her introduction, she's describing about the majority. It hands the executive the power to repeal statutes by firing all those necessary to carry them out. The majority is either willfully blind to the implications of its ruling or naive. But either way, the threat to our constitution separation of powers is grave. And I just want to say that's a false dichotomy. There is a third possibility that I think is far more likely than the two she mentions is that they're not willfully ignorant and they're not naive.
25:59 Speaker 03 They know what the implications are and they approve of the implications because they want Donald Trump to close the Department of Education.
26:08 Peter Shamshiri? Right.
26:08 Speaker 03 And they do not care whether he follows procedures. That's it. They're on board. They're on board with this project and they're saying, fuck it, go for it. So do not do their job for them by pretending they're better than that.
26:25 Peter Shamshiri? Right. Like, oh, I don't, I don't think you realize the implications of what you're doing. It's like, of course they do.
26:30 Speaker 03 What the fuck are you talking about?
26:32 Speaker 04 No, no, yeah, they fully know, they fully know.
26:34 Speaker 03 They all read your dissent?
26:36 Speaker 04 Exactly, exactly, exactly.
26:38 Peter Shamshiri? They're making fun of you behind your back, like.
26:41 Speaker 04 And we were talking in prep for this episode about like how, you know, in the five years we've done this podcast, like, you know, the conservatives on the Supreme Court do act a little bit differently, but to me, I was thinking about it, like the liberals really don't, like the liberals on the Supreme Court still have yet to say, you guys are doing policy that you approve of, no matter the procedure or the legal steps to get there. You are doing results oriented wholesale approval and rubber stamping of what the Trump administration wants every step of the way, you know? They've yet to do this.
27:18 Speaker 03 I think Katanji Brown Jackson has done that, but I think Kagan and Sotomayor are like clearly stuck in their ways. Yeah, yeah.
27:28 Speaker 04 Sad.
27:29 Peter Shamshiri? Yeah, that's why it would have been cool for Sotomayor to retire.
27:31 Speaker 03 Hmm.
27:32 Peter Shamshiri? But here we are. I'm gonna tell you this. If she dies during this term, the episode we're gonna put out
27:44 Peter Shamshiri? is gonna be so disrespectful to her as a human being that it will shock you.
27:48 Speaker 03 Yeah.
27:48 Peter Shamshiri? Brace yourselves now.
27:50 Speaker 03 Yeah, and I like Sotomayor.
27:53 Peter Shamshiri? Me too. That's why I feel like we need to say it.
27:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, the way I just disassociated to prevent myself from thinking of how angry I would be, you know, like I just clocked out real, real hard there.
28:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:04 Peter Shamshiri? If she heard the episode, she would hold it together for a few more years. You know what I mean?
28:11 Speaker 03 She'd feel like, I gotta avoid that.
28:12 Peter Shamshiri? She would like bear down and just power through.
28:18 Speaker 03 Maybe now's a good time for a break.
28:21 Speaker 04 Hey, everybody. Do you hate being told to wait for something that you really, really want? Well, with Mint Mobile's holiday deal, there's no waiting. Right now, this second, all their plans are $15 a month. I have a friend who switched to Mint Mobile from like a big cellphone carrier company, and she's really happy with Mint, primarily happy with the fact that it's $15 a month. Can't beat that. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right with premium wireless for $15 a month. All plans come with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. You can even bring your current phone and your phone number that's near and dear to your heart, so special to you.
29:03 Speaker 04 You can keep it. Choose from three, six, or 12-month plans and say goodbye to a monthly bill. It's so easy. Sign up online and get premium wireless service for $15 a month. So what are you waiting for? To get your new wireless plan for $15 a month, go to mintmobile.com/54, all spelled out. That's mintmobile.com/54. Cut your wireless bill to $15 a month at mintmobile.com/54. Here's the disclaimer. Limited time offer. Upfront payment of $45 for three month, $90 for six month, or $180 for 12 month plans. The plan is required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only.
29:47 Speaker 04 Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. Capable device required. Availability, speed and coverage varies. Go to mintmobile.com.
29:57 Peter Shamshiri? All right, we're back.
29:59 Speaker 04 Okay, so it's these 1,300 jobs we're talking about. 1,300 staffers of the Department of Education who have been fired. And that is sort of technically in a really narrow sense, what this case is about, certainly. But I think when we're talking about the broader question of the Trump administration dismantling the Department of Education out in the open, telling us that they're doing it, we should talk about what is important about the Department of Education? What does the Department of Education actually do? So the Department of Education is largely responsible, is the federal agency largely responsible for oversight of public school education
30:40 Speaker 04 and enforcing discrimination laws in schools and distributing aid money for schools that educate low income students and students with disabilities, but also for distributing, like Michael just said, federal student loans, administering aid money to students themselves? So the dismantling of the Department of Education leaves really, really, really big questions about how states will then distribute this federal money that is supposed to be intended to help educate students who are poor, who are disabled, who are still learning English and need extra support. Title I, massive, massive federal.
31:23 Speaker 04 Program Title one is intended to create an equal playing field in public schooling is intended to get money to schools that have weak property tax bases, get money to schools in rural areas where there isn't a lot of population to get property taxes from those kinds of schools depend on this money to pay teachers, to pay for buses, to pay for classroom technology. And what the Department of Education does is not just kind of like hand this money out, but you have to think about it as like federal oversight, accountability, and administration of these massive, massive millions and millions of dollars. So, for
32:05 Speaker 04 example, you know, states like Mississippi and Alaska, they depend on this funding to fund more than 20% of school districts costs in their state. And so without the Department of Education, not just in distributing these funds, but acting in its oversight functions, there's a lot of threat here in terms of how now state leaders, local leaders are going to use this money, could spend the money on anything they want, including vouchers to attend private school, making big moves to really defund in a very serious way, public education across the country. The IDEA program is a massive part of what the Department
32:46 Speaker 04 of Education does. This is the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. That is the administration, again, oversight, distribution of money and support to meet the needs of children with disabilities in public schools. Look, the Department of Education sent more than $18 billion in supplemental funding annually to local school districts to provide this kind of extra academic support to schools with high rates of poverty, to schools with children with disabilities, which is all public schools.
33:20 Peter Shamshiri? Yeah. And, and by the way, I mean, just to make this concrete. Without this funding, many, many public schools that currently provide services for special needs students will no longer be able to.
33:32 Speaker 04 Yes.
33:33 Speaker 03 Just that's it.
33:34 Peter Shamshiri? That is a simple fact about how this will play out. I don't know exactly what percentage, but substantial percentage.
33:40 Speaker 04 Yes. And the Department of Education also has a Department for Civil Rights and its own Office for Civil Rights, which has been hit incredibly hard by these layoffs. Because of these firings, seven of 12 regional offices for the Department of Education's Office of Civil Rights have been completely de-staffed. That's lawyers who work there, administrative staff, everybody. Seven of 12 regional divisions for the Office of Civil Rights for the Federal Department of Education no longer exist, do not have staff. And so what does that mean for students? What does that mean about what the Department of Education used to do?
34:20 Speaker 04 Well, it means that legal protections that hold schools and colleges that receive federal funds accountable, this is legal protections against discrimination from Islamophobia to racism to discrimination against students with disabilities. These offices to enforce that accountability on schools do not exist anymore.
34:45 Peter Shamshiri? Which makes sense because after Mahmoud, a lot of that discrimination is just people's religious right anyway. So why have an office to oversee it?
34:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, it goes hand in hand, to be honest.
34:59 Speaker 04 You know, there's also Title IX, massive, massive, very important federal law, a civil rights law that was enacted back in the early 1970s as part of the Education Amendments, as part of the push to create the Department of Education. And Title IX prohibits sex-based discrimination in any education program or activity that receives federal financial assistance. If you are a woman who played sports in public school growing up or in college, if you are somebody who was able to make a complaint about sexual Harassment or sexual assault at a university and that process laid out according to administrative
35:41 Speaker 04 standards, the Department of Education administers this, you guys, like dismantling it has a massive, massive effect, not on curriculum, actually, not on curriculum, but on the way public schools and universities in this country run, the extent to which they are held accountable to fair standards, the extent to which they fund in a fair way, students of all kinds, receiving the education that they need. It's a massive stab at American democracy.
36:12 Peter Shamshiri? Yeah, that's just like a glance at what the Department of Education actually does.
36:18 Speaker 04 Brief summary.
36:18 Peter Shamshiri? I would like to give you a glance at how the conservative political movement talks about the Department of Education. I'm gonna read a quote from Project 2025 to you. Here goes. "In contrast to DOJ's long history, the Department of Education is a creation of the Jimmy Carter administration. The department is a convenient one-stop shop for the woke education cartel, which, as the COVID era showed, is not particularly concerned with children's education. Schools should be responsive to parents rather than to leftist advocates intent on indoctrination, and the more the federal government is involved in education, the less responsive to parents the public schools
37:02 Peter Shamshiri? will be. This department is an example of federal intrusion into a traditionally state and local realm. For the sake of American children, Congress should shutter it and return control of education to the states. Short of this, the Secretary of Education should insist that the department serve parents and American ideals, not advocates whose message is that children can choose their own sex, that America is systemically racist, that math itself is racist, and that Martin Luther King Jr.'s ideal of a colorblind society should be rejected in favor of reinstating a color-conscious society."
37:38 Speaker 04 My god.
37:39 Peter Shamshiri? So now, a couple of things. Obviously, they are advocating for the abolition of the department, but you can see based on their subsequent caveat, and in fact, the longer chapter on the Department of Education, which I read too. They're not really anticipating that it would be shut down. And so they're like, all right, but here's how we weaken it, even if it's not shut down.
38:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:06 Peter Shamshiri? Right?
38:06 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:06 Peter Shamshiri? Which is interesting in part because I think that this means that Trump is to the right of Project 2025 in some respects. At the very least, he sort of understood that this is something where you could move ahead. And why not? Why not just go for it all? No need to do this incrementalist shit.
38:24 Speaker 04 Yeah, exactly.
38:25 Peter Shamshiri? Let's just try to wind down the Department of Education and see how it goes.
38:30 Speaker 04 Yeah, which should be, you know, we talk about how this is like blatantly illegal, right? And you see kind of in Project 2025, how they're doing the like little piecemeal thing, like you're saying, Peter, like not outright talking about dismantling it explicitly. And then Trump takes it explicitly to the dismantling stage himself. There's also years and years of the conservative attack on the administrative state in general. We know that conservatives over the past 40 years, they don't like the Department of Education. They say it's like a woke Jimmy Carter creation agency, right? And yet, and yet, federal court decisions over years, including by conservative judges,
39:11 Speaker 04 there's a memo that later Supreme Court Justice William Rehnquist wrote when he worked for the federal government. All of these things over the past 40 years, despite their hate for the Department of Education and the administrative state in general, where they're saying like, mm, there's not really a legal argument that the president can completely dismantle a federal agency that Congress created. So what you have here is Trump kind of like pushing, like being a bit of a vanguard. And then the rest of the right wing movement just getting in line and completely supporting it.
39:53 Speaker 03 Yeah, you know, and I do think, I think this is, this is very much a result of the Supreme Court itself, this Trump getting to the right of Project 2025. You know, I saw this described once, the way Trump operates as something like, they called it, I think, active intelligence gathering, which makes him sound very strategic and he's not, but the concept I think is useful. And it's like, imagine if you're like laying siege to an old timey fort or something, right? You want to know where their defenses are strong. You could try to sneak in and look around, or you could try to intercept a message or something.
40:35 Speaker 03 But one thing you can do is just attack it and see where you get a lot of resistance and see where you don't. And then back off and reformulate your strategy based on that information. That's the idea of active intelligence gathering, that you learn about your opponent by just pushing them and seeing how they respond. That's what Trump does. He just pushes, he pushes, he pushes. And if you push back, he might stop, he might even back up a little. But if you give, well, then he takes that space and he pushes more, right? And so, you know, the Supreme Court, they gave him fucking immunity. They gave him more than he asked for in the immunity case.
41:16 Speaker 03 They gave him a polite suggestion to make every effort to get the people back from C coat, but did not order him to do so. They signaled very strongly to him that they were not going to get in his way. So why wouldn't he go further than Project 2025? Why wouldn't he go nuts? He's going to go nuts until somebody tells him, no. This is what's happening with the universities, right? You negotiate with him. There was a quote from a UCLA person saying, within hours of them settling, quote unquote, with Trump, the DOJ was on their back. Like you give ground, he takes it and he goes for more.
41:59 Speaker 03 It's only by standing together and refusing to budge do you have any hope of resisting this guy? And the court isn't interested in resisting him.
42:09 Speaker 04 Exactly.
42:10 Speaker 03 They want to open the gate. They want him to run wild and that's what he's doing.
42:13 Speaker 04 Yeah, tell us where you want to go. We'll give you the ticket. Yeah.
42:17 Peter Shamshiri? You know, I think this also kind of fits in the tradition of a longstanding conservative strategy, where you deprive the government of resources and you thereby make it an unreliable provider of jobs and resources, which lowers people's opinions of the government and also creates. Room for private actors to step in.
42:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
42:42 Peter Shamshiri? So like, there's a longtime conservative policy strategy called starving the beast, which is where you cut taxes repeatedly. And if you cut them enough, the theory goes, you essentially force the government's hand. You force the government to become smaller because it can no longer sustain itself. You could see this is a similar approach where they just gut these agencies. The Supreme Court lets them do it, at least for long enough that it sticks, right? And then even if ultimately the court says, oh, this was unconstitutional, it's too late. Right? They've already starved the beast. They've weakened the government function permanently. Or at least for the foreseeable future.
43:19 Speaker 04 Yeah. Are they just gonna like, start up another agency with 4,000 employees? Like, it's not gonna happen.
43:26 Speaker 03 Yeah. A lot of those people will not come back because of the instability. But even assuming you could get 1,000, 1,300 people back, the hiring process, the screening, the interviews, the training.
43:40 Peter Shamshiri? Incredibly cumbersome. Not to mention, who, forget the Department of Education specifically. Who wants to go get a government job now if every four years, some lunatic is gonna come into office and fire you? Right? Make your department a shell. No one wants that job. So what was previously a really nice, stable career, no longer is. And this is very explicitly part of the strategy, right? This is something that conservatives talk about when they talk about hollowing out the administrative state. They talk about making the position of a civil servant unstable.
44:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, you know, and I think what this really starts to highlight too, is like, you know, Peter just said a minute ago, what are you gonna do even if the court says it's unconstitutional a year later? But that makes me think like, what's a good remedy for this type of harm? And how do you conceptualize the harm is important.
44:41 Speaker 03 One person being unjustly fired, the remedy is something like reinstatement or back pay or both. One remedy for an institution that like this college that lost a bunch of tuition is to reimburse them for their lost tuition. But what do you do when the harm is this large and this diffuse?
45:02 Speaker 04 It's societal, yeah.
45:04 Speaker 03 Because we are all harmed by this. That's the thing. When our representatives are drained of power, when our laws, the laws that were duly passed by our representatives and signed by the president and have been in effect for 50 years are just torn up on the whims of some senile freak, we're all harmed by that. And a court can't order a remedy appropriate to that harm. That's the thing. The only appropriate remedy here is a political one that does involve perhaps courts, but
45:45 Speaker 03 it's something like the next democratic administration sends a lot of people to jail and disempowers a lot of people and drives them from public life. And that includes people like Chief Justice John Roberts and the five Associate Conservative Justices. I think it should include the organizations that were arguing for this, whatever heritage and the Federal Society and all of that. There's no rectifying this without a serious reckoning for the people who are rending the social contract.
46:27 Speaker 03 When you tear up the social contract, the remedy for that is you no longer get to participate in public life and maybe you go to jail. That's it.
46:36 Speaker 04 Yeah, accountability for tearing up the social contract basically looks much bigger than, you know, like some people get their jobs back or something like that, right?
46:46 Speaker 03 Right. Some people get a payout.
46:47 Speaker 04 You're right. The harm is way, way bigger than that.
46:50 Speaker 03 Yeah. Anything short of that is, is just, it's not good enough. It's not good enough.
46:55 Peter Shamshiri? Yeah. One last point I'll make before we wrap up. I want to talk a bit about this unitary executive theory. Now that a Republican is in office, the court is increasingly enamored with this idea, this legal theory that the president has a certain level of unfettered authority within the executive branch, right? This is something that like Clarence Thomas is a big proponent of, and the other conservatives appear to be warming up if you just sort of like read between the lines in cases like this.
47:25 Speaker 04 Yeah, they're not saying the words unitary executive theory, right? But like all of these decisions, immunity included, like all add up to like this is their vision of how they think the executive branch should be operating.
47:36 Peter Shamshiri? And this is an argument that the Trump administration has been making very consistently, right? Not just that Donald Trump has like, I don't know, some statutory power to do this or whatever, but that courts have no constitutional power to intervene.
47:54 Speaker 04 Yeah.
47:54 Peter Shamshiri? This is the sole prerogative of the executive branch. The administration has been, in cases like this, pushing the idea that the president has unilateral discretion to make staffing decisions within federal agencies. But you can see in this case, just how awkward and clumsy that formulation is. Because Congress created those agencies. You cannot fulfill Congress's intent while allowing the president to hollow out whatever agency he wants to, right?
48:29 Speaker 04 Yeah.
48:30 Peter Shamshiri? Those things cannot really actually coexist. So the idea of this like unfettered president who can just sort of suck the life out of these agencies that are in fact created by Congress, it just doesn't make a ton of sense. It's sort of conservatives just sort of wish casting an authoritarian.
48:50 Speaker 04 Yes. Wish casting an authoritarian. Yes.
48:54 Peter Shamshiri? They conjure up a legal theory to bolster it to like, oh, it's no, it's not authoritarianism. It's just like
49:00 Speaker 03 The unitary executive.
49:02 Peter Shamshiri? The unitary executive theory.
49:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
49:05 Peter Shamshiri? But it doesn't really make sense. The system relies upon these like power sharing arrangements. And you can't really get away from it with the whole system collapsing. And I think you see that very clearly in this case.
49:19 Speaker 04 Yeah.
49:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:21 Peter Shamshiri? Anyway, enjoy educating your own kids, everyone. That's how it's gonna be from now on. And look, I, I might have kids, so I'll be just, I guess, mandatory homeschool for them.
49:33 Speaker 04 Oh, my God. Can you imagine Peter homeschooling you?
49:36 Speaker 03 Oh, my God.
49:37 Peter Shamshiri? Prepare to be smart as fuck if you get homeschooled by me. Prepare to be so fucking smart, dude.
49:43 Speaker 04 Can you do math? Okay, Peter?
49:46 Peter Shamshiri? I used to be like a gifted math student until they started throwing letters in there. I was like, what is this? What? It, it's a true story that I was like truly an elite math student. I got like pulled into like a class that just had like three other kids in it. One of them ended up being the High School of Aledictorian. The other one went to Yale. And then there was me. And when calc hit, like algebra, I started to fade a little bit. When calc hit, I was bombing.
50:15 Speaker 04 It wrapped your world.
50:16 Peter Shamshiri? It was the first time I had like I ever was bad at school. It's also a twofold problem. I also went off Ritalin this year, so it was, it was really a perfect storm. But I'm, I'm telling you, no amount of Ritalin would have helped me with that. I was just like, I, all of a sudden I had my friends being like, yeah, this makes a natural sense to me. Like, I understand cosines intuitively. And I was like, what are you talking about? What is going on?
50:42 Speaker 04 We know Michael is good at math.
50:44 Peter Shamshiri? Point being, up until like eighth grade, I'm good. I can, I got these kids. After that, you might as well join the Amish because you're on your own.
50:54 Speaker 03 Well, if it gets there, I was an algebra teacher.
50:57 Speaker 04 Yeah. Michael, Michael will homeschool your kids for math at least.
51:02 Peter Shamshiri? That is all I ask.
51:03 Speaker 04 I'll teach them Marxism, radical Islamic thinking, you know, Sharia law, things like that.
51:11 Peter Shamshiri? Yeah, I'll call you for sure.
51:20 Peter Shamshiri? All right, folks. Next week, we're taking off, but then we are coming back with Medina v. Planned Parenthood, another case from this past term about whether Planned Parenthood can sue when a state excludes them from the Medicaid program. Follow us on social media at 54pod. Subscribe to our Patreon, patreon.com/54pod, all spelled out, for access to premium and ad-free episodes, special events, our Slack, all sorts of shit. We'll see you in a couple of weeks.
51:52 Speaker 04 Bye, y'all.
51:52 Speaker 03 Bye, everybody.
52:07 Speaker 03 Five to Four is presented by Prolog Projects. This episode was produced by Dustin DeSoto. Leon Nefok provides editorial support. Our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Ship's NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations. If you're not a Patreon member, you're not hearing every episode. To get exclusive Patreon-only episodes, discounts on merch, access to our Slack community, and more, join at patreon.com/54pod.
Previous Trump Brings the War Home [UNLOCKED] Next Medina v. Planned Parenthood South Atlantic Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated